Discussion Locked

Power Supply Voltage

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I've been accepting out calls for a school that brought 150 computers from a company. In the last few months, the school has had 9 motherboard replacements. These system has Pentium 4 cpu and 180 watt powersupplies. I believe the 180 watt power supply is the reason for motherboard replacement. Where can I find information to support my claim?

5 replies

by maxwell edison

Pentium 4 systems can sometimes require 300 watts or more. Make sure the power supply is certified for the processor you want to use.

Direct quote from the following:

http://www.infohq.com/Computer/SystemBuyToday.htm

or

http://tinyurl.com/ahrh

----------

Make sure you use a PSU that has enough power for your P4 board. I would not recommend anything less than 275 watts, like this Silencer model. But this would only allow you to minimal P4 system, with these limitations:

No more than 2 hard disks.

No more than 3 cards (audio, video, NIC).

No more than 2 CD-ROM devices (CD-R/W, CD-ROM).

Only one P4 CPU.

CPU cooler required.

Case fans required, both intake (lower front) and exhaust (top rear).

Previous is a quote from the following:

Pentium 4 Power Supply Requirements

http://radified.com/CPU/p4_psu.htm

or

http://tinyurl.com/ahrw

----------

You may have more issues than just the PS, but there ya' go. Good luck

by timwalsh

You might also check the power supply for stable voltages. If these are no-name, low-cost power supplies (as I suspect), flucuating voltages could play havoc with a motherboard.

Check the motherboard manufacturer's website and see if they have any recommendations for a minimum power supply (this is Intel's recommendation as well). BTW, all power supplies tested by Intel for compatibility with their P4 motherboards are at least 250W. That might tell you something.

Other possibilities:
Bad lot of power supplies
Bad lot of motherboards

For what it's worth, my bet is also on underpowered power supplies.

Hope this helps.

by thechas

Yes, 180 watts is light for a P4 system.
However, many OEM systems use power supplies that have just enough power for the system as configured.
Unless the systems have been upgraded with more RAM, drives, video cards, or power hungry USB devices have been added to the PCs, I would suspect that the power supplies have marginally sufficient capacity.

Unless the power supplies are also failing, I would want to know what specifically has failed on the motherboards.

Logic circuits usually just shut down when the voltage gets too low.

The CPU power supply circuit on the motherboard is more of a concern when the system power supply is undersized.

I don't know if any P4 boards were part of this fiasco, but a number of Socket A motherboards were built with a bad batch of electrolytic capacitors.
Look at the large capacitors near the CPU on the motherboard. If the caps are bulged out, or show evidence of a liquid leaking from them, I would suspect the motherboards themselves.The next step, would be to substitute a few 300 Watt or larger supplies in a few systems and see if they run better with more power.
You can also run monitor software on a number of systems to see how stable the power supply voltages are.

Chas

by djent

Apparently was more concerned with price then reliability. Small power supplies are a common tradeoff in bargain systems.

This discussion is closed to new replies.