Discussion Locked

President Obama says chance for healthcare overhaul is slipping away

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

324 replies

by jdclyde

clearly they have done something dishonest to gain this undeserved wealth or they would not have earned the title of being the evil rich, right? they are greedy because they work hard and have been successful, so they need to be punished to reward those that have not put in the same efforts.

There is not a single independent watchdog that is agreeing with the price tag for all the mana from heaven TheObama is promising will rain down on the commoners....

by shellbot

So..the idea of everyone making the same amount disturbs me :)

I'm all for the whole "you get what you work for" type of thing.

Word hard..get pay raise, make more..
Learn new skills, move up, make more..

I could have waited tables all my life, but i wanted something more..

somedays i think it would be nice if i didn't care and got a job where I didn't have to think..or work very hard..but I'd quit in a week..just isn't who I am

by jdclyde

http://news.aol.com/article/obama-health-care-plan/579277?cid=12

To many Democrats have seen they were heading for a cliff and are no longer willing to rubber stamp these programs. Who would have thought it?

The public polls show the general population is against the direction TheObama is going. They disagree with most of his programs, but like him personally. Nothing like having a popular person drive you over a cliff?

by jck

[i]"A new poll suggests public approval of the way President Barack Obama is handling health care reform is slipping.

The Washington Post-ABC News survey says since April, Obama's approval rating on the issue has declined from 57 percent to 49 percent, with disapproval rising from 29 percent to 44 percent.

The president's overall approval rating stands at 59 percent positive and 37 percent negative. It's the first time Obama's approval rating has fallen below 60 percent in Post-ABC polling since he took office."[/i]

-Fox News

According to real poll numbers, about half of America still favors it. So, your "general population" comment is incorrect.

BTW, when did you get a crystal ball? You seem to be able to tell the future and that Obama is going to "drive you over a cliff".

I wish you'd have been telling the future when Bush took office. I'd have stayed in Ireland in 2004 and risked arrest. :^0

by oz_media

It's definitely different than having a very unpopular person send you off to die by yourself for something you don't even believe in. At least Obama is along for the ride.

by tonythetiger

[i]At least Obama is along for the ride.[/i]

Is [b]he[/b] willing to use the health care plan he's trying to set up? Not one Democrat in Congress is! Why do you suppose that is?

In Medieval times, it was common for the king to employ a 'tester' to taste the food before the king ate it... both to make sure it was palatable and that it wasn't poisoned.

Perhaps, since the people are supposedly "king", Congress, the President, and all employees of the public should be required to 'taste' this plan before giving it to us to 'eat'... for the same reasons :)

by delbertpgh

The longer the subject is debated, the more disjointed the Democrats in Congress become, and the less able they become to fight the professional and corporate interests. The program will have more and more giveaways attached to it, will become less effective at controlling costs, and will lose Democrat votes from those who worry about deficits foremost.

Meanwhile, the Republicans will be able to repeat their message longer, and build doubt about the program. The problem with the Republican vision is there is none at all. The Republican view is that no program is better than a bad program, or even better than a good program. They just want to stop it, period, and they will sound reasonable and prudent until it stalls, and then they will say nothing at all.

American medical care is already consuming a sixth of the economy, doesn't cover 20% of the people, and is delivering mediocre results to the other 80%. The longer it goes on, the more expensive it becomes. If we don't hustle, we probably won't get a fix in this time around. If the bill gets worse, it won't be worth passing, but that will leave us in a sorry (and steadily worsening) condition.

by jdclyde

because of the lack of following through on something the party claims to be a lofty goal?

That, and force it through before the details can get out to the public.

by tonythetiger

[i]Are you suggesting public schools are a bad thing and that private schools are the answer?[/i]

... that it's the parents' responsibility to educate their child, not the government's.

If you are going to make society pay for something, you should give them a say in the process. So, for example, if you want society to be responsible for the cost of a child, they should, rightfully, have a say in whether you are allowed to procreate.

[i]Only the rich get educated,[/i]

More money doesn't equate to better education. Evidence the graduation rates and test scores of schools that spend $25,000 per year per pupil vs. those who spend $8,000 per year per pupil.

And in most cities, there are private schools that actually cost LESS than public schools. The problem is the socialist types want those who choose private school to pay for the public ones too!

You see it all comes down to that... getting something they didn't have to work for... thinking they have the right to create burdens for another against his will... They will learn... by the sword if necessary.

by jck

More convoluted thinking from your mind.

I said:

[i]"If someone is able-bodied and won't work, let them starve.

If they have kids and can't feed them because they refuse to work, then take the kids away and give them to people who will care for them and feed them.

Lazy a$$ syndrome is cured REAL F***ING QUICK by starvation.

Nuff said."[/i]

It's a cure for people not working when they are able...not healthcare.

And if my big carcass that likes to stay in bed and watch Jerry Springer and drink rum and cokes can get out of bed and go to a job every day, then so can every other able-bodied person who is living on the dole.

The mentality we need in this country is:
***
Don't wanna flip burgers or stock shelves or sweep floors to make a paycheck?

Okay...go broke, starve, and be homeless...but we won't pity you unless you make the effort to work for what you have.
***

Hard work doesn't kill you. Trust me...I know. When I was younger and I didn't have a job, I mowed the lawn, fixed toilets, trimmed trees, fixed light switches, re-stained furniture, etc. My parents didn't let me be a lazy a$$. I have actually worked pretty much since I was 7 when I mowed yards and what not for money. But, I worked for others starting at age 11 when I started carrying over 100 papers in a town of 14,000 people (the local paper had a circulation of about 5,000, so I distributed about 2 percent of their total print run on a bicycle).

As for people that choose not to buy their own healthcare?

First of all, you don't go shopping for healthcare. You shop for the insurance.

"Pardon me...Columbia Medical? What's your rate for an emergency appendectomy?" :^0

Second, most people don't have the choice of having medical insurance or not. Because of:

A) their employer provides them insurance but won't give them the funds with which they purchase insurance under their group plan

B) their employer doesn't offer insurance.

I am one of the case As. My employer puts up the money for my single coverage medical, dental, and short term disability insurance. If I want to opt out, I can not get that amount given to me. It is non-negotiable as part of my employment. Either I accept free insurance, or I don't.

A lot of people are case Bs though, working either part time or in hourly jobs where they get no insurance. And quite often, those jobs pay so little that they can not afford any type of insurance.

Besides, it's already been proven that corporations can't run the medical or insurance operations right. Medical malpractice is rampant, insurance fraud is rampant, and quality of patient care has gone to the wayside in lieu of maximizing profits.

Trust me on this one. My mom is in the hospital right now. They found that her PCP was dosing her with too much thyroid, and that when they started to take her off it her heart rate dropped.

Then, the (quack that works for the hospital) cardiologist they brought in said he had to do a surgery right away. But, I insisted she get a hold of her own cardiologist. He transferred her to a bigger hospital, and he did tests and said "I think we can treat this all with some medications. There's no need at this time for any invasive procedures."

Go figure. Her first cardio was like my cardiologist: wanted to cut to make more money.

Then, there's the CT scans dilemma. She first went in the ER, they did a CT scan to check for any abnormalities. Saw nothing. Then, I noticed mom was having trouble thinking through things or remembering words. Then, she told me she couldn't tie little ribbons now with her hands. I told the nurse to tell the doctor that she needed a neuro study done. 2 days later, they did another CT scan and...voila...all the sudden there was a tumor on my mom's brain lining.

Wow...a tumor just magically appeared in a week? Lucky of Lucky Charms must have made it just appear with blue moons and yellow diamonds.

Most things now are just done by a playbook in medicine now. People aren't allowed to think (including doctors) about how patients are treated because insurance mandates what is "allowable", unless your doctor wants to get on the phone for an hour or two and argue with some insurance company employee about why it's needed treatment.

And, health insurance is the big driver in that.

It's piss poor at best here in most medical facilities, and I can attribute to that. It took me going through 2 hospitals to get in one that would look at my symptoms and treat me right and get me somewhere so that I didn't end up paralyzed.

Now, I'm watching another cardiologist try and talk my mother into an unnecessary, risky procedure too like mine did me.

I'm watching them misread CT scans.

And I'm seeing them bill Medicare and my parents' supplemental insurance for all this like they did their job right.

So, maybe...just maybe...don't you think that government might be able to do this better and setup a system that is accountable to the people that it serves (that would be me and you), rather than a bunch of shareholders who just want a profit in their portfolio?

I'm willing to take the risk. I want social medicine. I am willing to pay an extra $2000-3000 a year in taxes to get rid of health insurance and get that $4000 a year in my check that my employer pulls out.

And I don't care if Aetna, BCBS, etc., go broke and bankrupt. They've screwed people for years and made billions in profits, and now it'd be karma for them to get screwed back.

Just understand one thing that you probably wouldn't think:

I think the healthcare reform thing has gone too fast too. I want it done RIGHT. I want the system to hold doctors accountable, hold hospitals accountable, and hold patients (yes...for when they try to defraud the system) accountable.

If we had a system where United Healthcare wasn't making $3-4 billion in profit in a year, and those profits were going back into our government instead of private hands...wouldn't that help pay for other things? Like schools? Roads? Lower taxes?

I want them to do it right, make sure everyone get free, basic care (doctors visits, immunizations, etc.) and treatment.

No free body contouring or liposuction tho. Sorry. :)

by jck

[i]is all your ranting just a copy/paste from what you post to Dawg? Sounds like you are just repeating the same thing over and over, no matter who it is you are trying to show that you are superior to.

Oh yeah, it isn't working either.[/i]

If Oz is saying the same thing over and over, I wouldn't call that bad...I'd call that consistent.

At least he doesn't say "Mission Accomplished" and grin impishly...or do you, Oz???? :^0

by jck

Hey Tammy...want a diet Coke? ;) lol

I sure know how to sweet talk a girl ]:)

by jck

(BTW...I typed this verbatim from his speech.)

[i]"I've always believed that if you're gonna do healthcare, you've gotta do it right. You can't just do it partially.

You can't have a conversation with just trial lawyers and insurance companies. You gotta include patients and doctors. You can't...you can't have a conversation without including the pharmaceutical companies. You can't have a conversation about healthcare without including everyone who is touched by the issue."[/i]

Michael Steele, Republican Party Chairman, at a National Press Club speech, July 20, 2009

That's from the man's own mouth.

Thing is, Bush sat in office 8 years and never tried to do anything to reform healthcare. Why didn't the Republican party light a fire under his arse if they were so opposed to the way it is to get change happening?

Then also, these are the sticking points that Steele says should be dealt with:

[i]He reeled off a list of ?simple, common-sense fixes? backed by the GOP. Most of the reforms address costs, which he called the health-care system?s biggest problem. Among the reforms:

* Requiring doctors and hospitals to post on the Internet the prices of all tests, treatments, procedures and office visits.
* Requiring insurance companies to offer simple, understandable contracts and one-page reimbursement forms.
* Protecting doctors from frivolous, expensive lawsuits.
* Enabling employees to take their health insurance with them when they change jobs.
* Supporting paperless, health-care IT systems
* Emphasizing prevention, wellness and disease management programs.
* Offering tax credits for health-insurance premiums.
* Imposing tougher penalties on companies, physicians and others who abuse the health-care system.
* Enabling small businesses to form cooperatives to offer employee health plans.
[/i]

-From a synopsis of items on the National Press Club website.

My questions are this:

a) why can't most of those, if not all, be worked into the plan Obama is trying to get worked through Congress?

b) tax credits for who? companies? why?

c) why just only help everyone down to the level of "small business"? why not allow everyone to get decent, affordable insurance? including individuals and families?

I like most of what he said, but the tax credit thing just sounds like a way for big companies to get another huge tax break. Give the tax break to the PEOPLE.

But all the bickering is really silly. Stop pandering to Corporate America and getting them tax credits. Stop pandering to insurance corporations and get this thing rolling.

Whether it gets done by August 1 or not, I would like to see a good framework with delineated items of legislation pre-worded and ready for debate and resolution and vote come Jan 2010 for HR 1 and SB 1.

Most importantly, it has to be done right.

by jck

I think I read that the independent auditor at the budget office estimated 1 to 1.5 trillion over the next 10 years.

by delbertpgh

I spend $20,000 a year to put my kid through high school. Never thought I'd try something so foolishly expensive. It works well for him. The school, by the way, can't cover expenses on tuition alone; it depends on gifts. And, they don't take any certified special ed kids, but they bend over backwards to make sure their rich clientele gets its kids educated, even when the kids are far more rich than bright. And, they kick out the troublemakers.

I do it because the public schools suck so awfully.

I've had some experience with kids in Catholic schools. Usually, if you've got a parent spending a few thousand a year on education, the kid has got some parental interest. If parents ignore kids, they come out rotten a lot more often, and make education more difficult.

I don't know for sure, but I doubt the Catholics do special ed... dyslexia, disruptive, mildly retarded, can't speak English, etc. Another big savings. I had my boy in a public magnet school in the third grade. I sat through a day with him to see how he was getting along, and noticed a kid in the back of the room who had a woman sitting next to him. After a couple of classes, I asked her what she was about. She was a paid assistant teacher, and the kid had some kind of explosive, intermittent, disruptive behavior. She sat with him all day, and when he was about to blow his cork she would take him out to the hall to calm him down. I was amazed at the expensive treatment being put out for one kid. Public schools do this kind of thing; private schools don't.

At Central Catholic (where Dan Marino attended,) you can get a pretty good education for around $13,000 per year, subsidized by churches. The admissions director told me it was hard to get in as a freshman, but easier after that. Apparently it's common for parents to get disgusted with spending money on a kid who won't work, so after freshman year they put him in public and save the cash. It leaves Central Catholic with an above-average crowd.

Also, there's governance. Private schools are still sensitive to parental mood, but they don't have to dance to the whims of a vote-seeking school board the way publics do. Private schools can be run by educators who focus on education, and not be captive to whatever extraneous initiative seems to be working its way through the electorate. Like, for example, people who want to protest Al Gore's movie, or the absence of gay topics in the curriculum, or the slightest mention of gay topics.

There are a lot of ways when you pay money for school, you get a better product.

by oz_media

A discussion without opinion is a lesson, sorry but I'm with school. When it comes to a learned skill, yes I want formal instruction such as the years I spent at BCIT studying to be an automotive tech. When it comes to some knob posting a baited and biased opinion of presidential actions, I am going to offer my opinion, just as everyone else has, including yourself.

What else have you offered here if not conclusions and opinions based loosely on available facts? nothing.

by oz_media

A spelling test?

A grammar test? I don't see what 'HOOP you are asking be to jump through.

Way to funny who?

by santeewelding

The method of Position and Opinion does not work -- by definition -- for Everything, capital "E".

It is, rather, blasphemy. But only if you see the above.

You are sweetly innocent.

by oz_media

I have an evil laugh and a cheeky grin, so I am told. 'impish' doesn't really work for me as I have a rounder face and can't pull of the almond shaped eyes and pointy nose bit.

People don't like it when I stick to my guns it seems. I do accept changes and am open to exploring each issue as being unique, which many people here seem to think displays a lack of values.

In fact it is my values that stop me from applying a blanket opinion to all issues, whether related or not, and instead I look at individual cases and issues separately.

by oz_media

At $54.00 month, no matter who the employee is, companies usually don't have issues offering medical, If they don't offer full coverage, they will often offer extended medical coverage and the employee pays the basic. The differences being extended coverage pays you for time you miss work, additional elective surgery costs, such as cosmetic surgery, etc.

Some companies will offer a 50/50 plan where you each pay half, a whopping $27.00 a month, which they will deduct form your check and pay out on your behalf to save you the effort.

We really don't have the horrific system it is made out to be in the USA, it works quite well, though not perfect of course.

Medical is an issue VERY few people worry about or need to discuss here, it comes up when the news is on about provincial medical costs, hospital beds, doctors and nurses wanting more money etc. But it is does not see the same focus on daunting issues the US system does.

It's not a matter of ever being uninsured, because EVERYONE is ALWAYS insured.

We just assume medical, you screw up and get hurt, or someone else screws up and you get hurt, and you go to hospital, closest one and see whoever you want without calling an insurer or anything. I don't worry if I am properly covered, if I don't have a medical card with me and don't know my number it's no problem, they'll see to me and look up the details themselves.

Coverage and costs are just a non-issue really. If you need help, you get help and don't get a bill.

by dwdino

But 100% false.

I did it because I was willing to accept the risk with the understanding that if something catastrophic came up I would either be in debt for ever or dead. I made no assumption on any safety net or assistance.

by oz_media

The initial post is inflamed and baited, it is a post derived from opinion. There are no facts to explore, beyond the facts that shared opinions are based on.

I agree with you wholly in situations where we are discussing legality and people start offering opinions, which don't fly in law. However this is not one of those cases.

This was an inflammatory personal opinion from the OP, resulting posts are going to be like minded, inflammatory opinions or just conclusions derived from opinion.

Pretend it is what you want, reality is this is a discussion thread and NOBOODY, including the president really has facts to prove anything because it has not been done.

Having lived with a similar system for 40 years, I can attest to it's effectiveness based on my first hand knowledge of our particular system.

To me, that seems far more accurate than speculations by someone with a bone to pick with the president, an unyielding distaste for his every move and no actual knowledge of how effective similar systems are elsewhere, other than the odd snippets of sensationalized 'news' that hits check stand rags.

The OP of the thread has offered such keen insight before, "why does everyone in Canada come to the US for treatment?" "Why did this old man not get elective hip surgery in a hurry?" and other stupid, Enquirer style comments that are obviously related in the USA to generate support for a private medical system. However this doesn't make such stories true or accurate in any way.

It seems some people just can't see through the 'sensational propaganda' and don't believe their nation would do such a thing to begin with. Thus the original OPINION shown here is based on fear and unqualified assertions mixed with a heap of personal bias.

by oz_media

It had NOTHING to do with the government providing education.

JDClyde was talking about his going to private school, as if it afforded him a better education, that's all.

by ontheropes

So sexual innuendo is out but insulting people's Mothers is in. Check.
Just want to be clear.

by jck

Star Trek RULEZ!!! :^0

Mmmmmmm...I'd let 7 of 9 make me a Borg anytime ]:) :^0

by jck

What should liability of a doctor or medical facility be who caused harm to a patient?

10k?
100k?
1M?
2M?

What if the victim is a 25 year old mother of two who was the sole income for family while the husband was in school finishing a degree and now she is in a constant vegatative state like Terri Schaivo?

How much do you give her husband to lose the rest of his normal life with his wife?

How much do you give her kids for taking away the mother who holds them at night?

How much do you give her family to pay for 24/7 medical care and attention she'll need for the next 30-55 years?

It's not so easy to just say:

"Lost an arm? Oh. That's $150,000."

What if the arm that is lost belongs to someone like Eddie Van Halen, Tony Romo, or Heidi Klum?

Yes, I don't think you should be able to sue a doctor for $100M. But if they permanently disable someone to the point that they need medical care most/all of the time, it shouldn't be limited to a fixed amount like $500k. Convalescent care would use that much up within 10 years.

by oz_media

$600.00? Or did you mean $60.00/month?

$600.00 is almost my entire racing and drinking budget for the month,I wouldn't get health insurance at all if that was the case here.

I assume you meant $60 then?

by jck

When I began paying COBRA for my medical plan through BCBS of Florida, I was paying:

$675.00 per MONTH for single medical coverage only

After a few months (beginning of the new fiscal year and new contract) it went to $707.00 per MONTH.

Now you see why I think insurance companies are rip off artists?

by jck

I am gonna home school them.

I'd say 80% of the time (even in college), I was smarter than my teachers.

Like the time a Ph. D. in Mathematics graded my paper at 99% when I didn't miss anything.

I asked "Why did I get 99%."

He said "I don't give perfect grades, because no one is perfect."

So I ask him "What is the percentage of the fraction 10/10?"

He said "Well, that is 100 percent."

I said "Exactly. And, that should be my grade."

He didn't argue and changed it when I mentioned we could take the mathematical dilemma to the department chairman for a decision. :^0

It's not that I don't trust public schools to educate my child.

It's that I don't trust other parents to teach their kids how to behave...and make them behave.

by tonythetiger

the actual, provable losses or damages caused.

I would also like to see PEOPLE held responsible for what PEOPLE do. If a doctor botches your surgery, why is the hospital responsible?

Now there could be cases where a different person could be responsible, or more than one, but we should limit such lawsuits to PEOPLE who caused the loss. Either A PERSON OR PERSONS caused it, or it was an unpredictable accident.

by jck

because they employ the staff, much like if someone embezzles your money at Chase then Chase's insurance has to pay you, not the criminal.

Also if the hospital staff fails to maintain safe conditions for you and you get an hospital-borne illness then it is tortable.

Anyways...I believe in the person being held responsible if it's a situation where they are in use of someone else's facility.

But say a hospitalist doctor who is staff screws up and orders you a shot of stuff your chart says you're allergic to...and you're brain damaged...then the hospital is liable for your actions since you are part of their "team" and not working for just yourself.

by tonythetiger

[i]because they employ the staff, much like if someone embezzles your money at Chase then Chase's insurance has to pay you, not the criminal.[/i]

In Chase's case, they have contracted with me to protect my deposits, and the repayment is simply upholding their contractual obligation. The hospital does not guarantee a certain outcome, and most doctors are independent contractors permitted to use the facilities, not employees.

[i]Anyways...I believe in the person being held responsible if it's a situation where they are in use of someone else's facility.
[/i]

Or equipment. If I rent a car and cause an accident, is the rental company responsible?

[i]But say a hospitalist doctor who is staff screws up and orders you a shot of stuff your chart says you're allergic to...and you're brain damaged...then the hospital is liable for your actions since you are part of their "team" and not working for just yourself.[/i]

Again, it's quite possible for more than one person to be responsible, but penalizing someone who had no control over the process is not reasonable in my opinion. In your example, I assume the pharmacist was supposed to check the prescription against the patient's records for allergies or interactions. He would be responsible too for his failure. "The Hospital" would have expected their employers to act properly, so would not necessarily be logically be responsible. Now, if this pharmacist or doctor had a known history, or if the hospital told the pharmacist not to check the order, just fill it, then they too may share in the responsibility. But most of the time a person knows or should know that something is wrong, and his share of the responsibility does not decrease, even if he is "following orders".

As often as not, a company is targeted simply because they have deep pockets, and the plaintiff's attorney knows that paying a settlement can often be cheaper than defending a suit, especially against a little guy, who they'd have no hope of recovering legal costs from if the company wins the suit.

by jdclyde

They are doing the work FOR the hospital, and as you well know, that makes everything they do while on-the-job relevant.

by tonythetiger

Cobra is essentially a monopoly. When I retire, my wife's coverage jumps to $960 a month if she stays on my plan. We found some half-way decent medical/pharmacy for $199 a month for her that has a yearly "open enrollment" (no refusals for pre-existing), so I'm paying the $960 until next June... or she could just "get a job" :)

Pre-existing clauses are a problem, but I can see their position... Why should they be required to cover someone likely to have a lot of claims for the same price they charge healthy people with few claims. If health insurers were allowed to charge based on risk, like every other kind of insurance does, costs for those who take care of themselves would drop.

by oz_media

I agree all insurance companies, regardless of industry are rip off artists. Insurance companies make money by charging people who are not claiming and using that money to outwiegh those who do, even those who pull insurance scams, your premiums pay for that too.

In that same sense, I feel it is better to have a specific amount of tax dollars allocated by the government at a controlled rate instead. People complain about taxes being used to help those who cant help themselves, however insurance companies are a far bigger rip off that tax allocation.

So a couple of points of your tax dollars goes into a shared medical system, that seems a lot better than an unregulated company charging you more and more to pay for other people's health issues and banking on the fact that you won't get sick, and thus offering you a slightly better rate due to good health.

If people didnt get sick or injured, your premiums would be next to nothing, as people actually make claims, you are therefore paying for their healthcare anyway, why not have it government regulated instead of private and exorbitant?

Is there any possibility that your MONTHLY taxes would increase proportionately to the $707.00 you pay today? i wouldn't think so myself.

I think a lot of people whining abotu taxes and those who earned it are not realizing how much they pay already to care for others who may be careless and harm themselves (costing everyone more money) are not supposed to partake in certain activities but do anyway (injuring and costing everyone else more money) etc.

Yes, insurance is a MASSIVE scam from all angles of perspective.

by tonythetiger

the "evil rich" aren't who you think they are.

No. The super rich are mostly big name Democrats, and are not "evil" at all. They deserve their riches because of their self-proclaimed ability to know what's best for everyone else. The "evil rich" are those who dare try to climb the mountain that the super rich are atop of.

by tonythetiger

is all it costs for all of everybody's health care? Or that that's all you are paying?

Your system isn't cheaper... The real costs are just better hidden.

by jamesrl

In Ontario, the number os much higher, but neither reflect the true cost of providing the services.

But it isn't all taxes either. Our hospitals may be government regulated but they are private and they do fundraise and make money from concessions(Food, flowers, parking, private room fees etc). Teaching hospitals get some funding from med students tuitions. Some of the bigger hospitals make money doing medical research in conjunction with private companies.

James

by oz_media

After commenting with jck, I realized just how badly your current insurance system rips you off, I am sure most if not all of you feel insurance costs are out of control and are ripping you off.

Of course, you understand that the reason your premiums soar uncontrollably is due in part to a lack of regulation (no limit as to what they can charge you, besides competitive pricing)and also the fact the you are paying for other people to get help from yoru own pocketbook.

JCK mentioned paying just over $700 PER MONTH!!! for his insurance premiums, for a single person.

People have continually questioned how I can accept a government taking my money and using it to help others who did not earn it, in my case a whopping $54/month, which is less than 8% of the cost jck pays for private insurance.

I think a lot of people feel that if you pay for insurance, you are not paying for others who did not earn the money, which is only PART of the equation. Insurance companies charging $707.00 month, cannot afford your own health bills paid only by you if you need surgery or extended care, which is when insurance is needed the most.

I am sure everyone else is in a similar situation, insurance companies are private, FOR profit companies, they are in it to take your money and HOPEFULLY you won't get sick and make them pay out for you and instead they can use your money to pay for other people's medical costs and STILL come out with millions for themselves.

so how do they pay for Jane Graham's surgery and hospital bills, totaling over $60,000 when she only pays $700.00/month?

YOU pay for her health care, AND you still pay taxes too AND you pay your own ridiculously high monthly premiums to protect your own arse should you need medical help and are lucky enough to have the right coverage.

However, paying twice at a rate many MANY times what a government subsidized system would charge is a preferred system?

That's sheer lunacy simply because of so called "values" where you don't think the government should be in control.

The problem with unmanageable insurance costs is that they AREN'T regulated and are NOT controlled. However a system that IS cost regulated and controlled is not seen as a more feasible solution?

I simply don't understand how anyone can convince themselves that private insurance is a better deal. The only explanation is an ignorance towards even investigating options and a stubborn attitude towards freedoms and taxation, which results in costing you more, not less.

DISCLAIMER: jck I merely used your figures as an example, not to make fun of what you pay or what your preferences are.

by notsochiguy

Here are some other rate charts that would substantiate the $707 number:

http://www.noao.edu/cas/hr/hr_forms/Rates%202007%20COBRA%20Retiree.pdf

https://hr.depaul.edu/ContributionFolder/Documents/Benefits/2008PremiumsforFull-timeFacultyandStaff09_24_07.pdf

Also, when I switched jobs last year, my former employer sent me the COBRA forms. I could have elected to keep my family covered for the price of about $1200 or so a month (in fairness, that would have covered vision and dental, too...not just health). My understanding is that you are getting the health insurance at the same rates that the former employer did (which underscores how much private companies shell out on this, too). Fortunately, my insurance with my current employer started day 1.

You can elect not to use COBRA. However, if you have any sort of condition, you run the risk of getting rejected for coverage, or paying even higher rates than those under COBRA. So, it is a d@mned if you do (high price, but definitely covered) or d@mned if you don't (may find cheaper coverage, but not be entirely insurable) scenario.

Another bummer about insurance (particularly switching) is that not all doctors accept all insurance providers. I have had to change my primary care physician 6 times since I left my old job due to my former doctor not being covered (some of the new PCPs were no longer covered, either...and a few were just curmudgeons). I'm seeing my new PCP in a couple of weeks for a physical, and just hoping that it goes well (both in terms of my health and rapport).

I could have gone with the PPO option, so I could see any doctor of my choosing, but the price is almost double what I pay for Point of Service (or POS...somewhat ironic acronym), and with a wife about to get laid off, I couldn't justify that extra cost for a pretty healthy family.

by jamesrl

We can see whatever doctor we want. My mom was told by her GP to get a good surgeon, so she asked who was the best in Canada, and called his office and got an appointment in 3 weeks. She was operated on 6 weeks later (non urgent case).

But that also extends to the things not covered by our government funded system, like dental. Today only those on welfare get help with dental, the rest of us often have private insurance, but I've never seen a case where the private insurer could dictate which dentist we see.

James

by oz_media

Too bad I don't have to go through all that, i can't make decisions that may jeopardize my health coverage, I can't choose to pay hundreds more than I do now. Sux really, I want the freedom to waste all my money on insurance too!

I pay $143.00/mo in vehicle insurance and THAT pi$$s me off as I have a choice to find a different policy holder but only save money if I get less coverage or higher deductibles or greater restrictions in what I can and can't do. Kind like your screwy medical system.

These people telling me they pay $700+ for a month, can't think of more important things to do with that same money? the argument is that it is TAKEN from you otherwise?

You have a choice of two thieves:

Thief number one "asks" you for $700.00 and keeps coming back each month for more and will raise that amount if he should so desire.

Thief number two just lets you leave $54.00 for him each month and leaves you alone.

by delbertpgh

The $700 was what his employer pays to put him in a group, and what he would have to pay to continue in that group. Group rates are lower than individual rates. $700 is what it costs to insure an individual who is no more likely than anybody else to get sick. That is, for a certain palette of benefits... the better the benefits, the higher the price, per normal individual.

If you are an individual seeking medical insurance, it's a fair bet that you think you'll really need it. In other words, you are likely to file expensive claims. If you didn't think there was a strong chance you'd get sick and need help with your bills, you probably would just risk going it alone. The insurance company is not in business to lose money by taking the burden off of sick people, and if you are willing to pay for insurance, it's a sign you are risky, so they will price you for risk.

Go look for insurance alone, and you are likely to spend $1000 to $2000 per month, with no coverage allowed for pre-existing conditions. Welcome to America.

by oz_media

Thank god that when I worked there I was still covered by Canadian medical. I could visits a US hospital and they just billed it out to Canada, not me.

I know some people say that isn't fair.

However do they REALLY think that their monthly costs are for them only? If you don't get sick that year you get your money back? If you get sick, the insurer uses other people's money to pay your medical bills too.

Either way, the government takes and redistributes your money, or you choose to let a private company take many times more and do the same.

by tonythetiger

Cobra is the full cost of what the employer WAS paying for when you are no longer working for that employer. In my case I pay $300 a month and my employer pays $700. If I quit I would be entitled to cobra for $300+$700 or $1000 a month. Personally, I would pass on it because once I quit, I could buy as good as what I've got now on the open market for $500 a month.

[i]I simply don't understand how anyone can convince themselves that private insurance is a better deal[/i]

It isn't a better deal, it's just more apparent where the money is coming from. In your case it's included in your income and/or sales tax, and even hidden in the cost of the products you buy because of the taxes employers pay. In our case it's coming more directly from our pockets. Our government is heading in the wrong direction. It plans on hiding the money and putting more middlemen in the loop.

We don't need more paper-pushers who add cost, but no value. We need less!

by oz_media

You have a choice to pay a ridiculous sum of $500.00 a month. If someone else gets sick, your money helps them get better, if you get sicj THEIR money helps you get better.

You're right that is way different than paying a fraction of that cost for the same result.

What's the difference between the government redistributing your wealth or a private company redistributing your wealth but initially taking many times more of your wealth in order to do so?

You seem to not care about costs, but simply who gets to distribute it for you. either way you don't have choice where it is spent.

by delbertpgh

The cost of filling out and submitting the forms, and of processing them, is broadly estimated to take a quarter of our current insurance bill. Imagine... 25 cents of each health dollar goes not to pay for x-ray machines, or for rubber gloves, or even for your urologist's Mercedes... it pays for pencil pushers and the buildings they work in, and of course a reasonable profit margin for the insurors. Let's suppose, $300 billion each year. Seems like fertile ground to cultivate some savings.

Bad news is that if we succeed in getting a national plan with overhead as low as Medicare or Social Security, all kinds of little old ladies in doctors' offices and insurance companies are going to be out of work.

by jdclyde

All I can assume is jck's policy is not through his employer if his monthly bill is that much.

by oz_media

As I just posted at the bottom of the thread, jck pays just over $700.00/month.

Whether he is sick or not, his $700.00 a month goes towards paying other people's medical costs, people who also only pay $700.00 a month and may face $50,000 - $100,000 in medical expenses, which your premiums pay for as they only pay 8,400.00/year themselves.

So now matter how careful and responsible YOU are, your premiums are still based on seeing to others who may blatantly risk injury, people who work when they are not supposed to and further existing injuries etc.

You STILL pay for other peoples medical services, insurance companies don't start little savings funds for everyone who pays into it, otherwise your coverage would be limited to $8,400.00 a year, which I am sure you understand is not even covering your most basic medical costs in a private system, should you require medical attention.

So where does the extra money come from, to support Cindy when she breaks a leg ice skating, to support Gord when he almost pokes an eye out while dirt bike riding? YOUR pocket!

Now, in contrast, a system that REGULATES costs is not simply in it to make a profit but break even at best, is a system you scoff at because others who don't pay for it may get your money?

Our overall costs are much lower as they are also regulated and doctors don't get to just randomly make up insane figures for practicing medicine. Your actual costs for medical attention trump our own by miles. Our system is funded in many ways, as Jams has described, as opposed to an insurer the simply raises everyone's rates when the CEO needs a new yacht.

Taxes, my total monthly income tax deductions from my daytime employer are not much higher than your monthly health insurance costs by themselves, which covers ALL of my taxes for ALL services provided, not just medical, so your issue of taxation falls on deaf ears.

No matter how much you THINK i pay in taxes, no matter how little you think i pay in medical premiums, I STILL pay a fraction of what you do each month and I get the whole kit and kaboodle included. No matter who the money is allocated, bottom line is I pay less than you do and I get more for it because it is regulated and controlled, unlike the insurance con artists.

Back to the others you are helping with your premiums; Cindy never covered HER $26,000 in health costs with her private insurance premiums, neither did Gord cover his $52,000.00 when he got into a dirt bike accident, but your insurance company charges you enough that they can help cover the additional costs incurred by Cindy and Greg, they thank you for being responsible and allowing them to play carelessly on your dime.

Overcharging you privately to pay for others seems better does it?

Just the simple premise that ANY insurance agent in ANY industry (as they all are in business to become wealthy at the expense of policy holders) is even comparable to a much lower priced and regulated system, is simply lunacy.

Private insurance is never a better way to spend your money, it is unregulated, overly expensive and is in place simply make the business owner (or investors) rich as hell while helping others, responsible or not, on your dime.

Did Cindy and Doug send you a Christmas card last year thanking you for the help?

by tonythetiger

[i]In that same sense, I feel it is better to have a specific amount of tax dollars allocated by the government at a controlled rate instead. People complain about taxes being used to help those who cant help themselves, however insurance companies are a far bigger rip off that tax allocation.[/i]

I give my money to the insurance guy voluntarily, and he is voluntarily accepting the risk that I won't use as much as I pay in. If I don't think it's worth the price, I can switch to another company. I can choose not to have pregnancy coverage, or choose to have a higher deductible, or choose to pay doctors out of pocket and insure only the big things... I have choices!

With government, I have no choice... pay what they say, when they say, or go to prison. I know you're accustomed to that and think it's great and the way things should be... but I don't! There is no valid ethical principle that beholds me to support another against my will.

by jck

have more soverignty than i do.

i can't decide just to go fishing and not have to call in and ask my boss off.

so who has more freedom? me? or the welfare guy?

and you want me to work harder? yeah right. :^0

by jck

they were the same ones that said "China can never do a better, more cost-efficient job at manufacturing than us." in the 1970s. :p

by jck

It's NOT a monopoly, because you have the OPTION to go and SEEK OTHER INSURANCE.

COBRA is mainly to make sure you can keep insurance if you leave a job and no one else will insure you.

That was the case with me. Because I'm not a beanpole (even tho I can walk 9 miles with the skinniest dude out there), I was "uninsurable".

Otherwise, I would have been without health insurance for 7 months.

Next insurance executive I see trapped under something heavy...is gonna get left to die :^0

by jck

that you'll be moving to Idaho and living in a powerless cabin? lol :^0

BTW...I have no choice either. My employer won't give me the money for my insurance and let me shop. I have to use it or lose it.

Is that wrong as well?

And I'll make one other point again:

No private company is beholden to you in any way to give you quality service.

Your government is, since you control who runs it by vote.

So, you DO have a choice in government-run healthcare by way of your right to vote as an American.

Enough said.

by delbertpgh

I guess if you assume that the federal government collected everything that we currently spend on health, then it would be the case that $2.1 trillion was the federal health care budget.

I googled the following:
"2.1 trillion" health obama

The first hit that came up, believe it or not, was my post in Tech Republic asking you what the 2.1 trillion was about.

by notsochiguy

Develop a rapport with a doctor over a period of 6 years.

Doctor establishes a solid baseline for your health, and can tell when something isn't right without it being mentioned.

Now you have to up and start anew.

Even with transferring the medical records over, a good deal of knowledge about my health is getting flushed down the tubes for no better reason than my doctor and the new insurance not being able to negotiate payment terms.

If the same thing happened with auto financing (sorry, your credit union and Honda couldn't agree to the worth of the car, so you'll have to settle for a GM), people would be lighting torches and carrying pitchforks.

by jamesrl

Is over the creation of a db to store medical records, so doctors/hospitals don't have to ask for paper or electronic records to be sent to them (with patients permission of course). Its cost alot with no results yet.

We've been in the same place 15 years, and I've had a number of jobs (3), been unemployed, but have only had 1 doctor. He came to the delivery of my youngest, not because he was needed, but because he wanted to. He has shepparded my wife to many specialists. When my wife has needed urgent attention from a specialist, he has picked up the phone and made calls on our behalf.

Its too bad you have to lose that.

James

by oz_media

Who's doctor changed after 6 years?

I've seen many GP's that have sent me t o a specialist for further diagnosis, it ensures that people with the most knowledge of a condition work on that condition.

As for changing doctors, I was just told by another American peer that he HAD to change several times because his policy changed and THEY decide where you go based on what you pay.

I can see the same doctor or specialist as a multimillionaire, it doesn't cost me a penny more either. I don't trust GP's for much other than basic issues anyway, I don't need to I as have equal access to the nation's best specialists instead.

by oz_media

I have had friends who owe several thousand in unpaid medical fees. they STILL go to teh hospital or doctor and get help, they DON'T go to jail as you so suggest, their outstanding debt just increases and eventually they'll keep your tax returns to overcome the debt owed. You 'go to jail for not paying medical premiums. As for having a choice or not, I pay in a year what a single American seems to pay in one MONTH!

I am bring forced to save money, how dare they!

You would rather pay more than 10X the amount I pay and have THAT money used to help others, who also pay a mere fraction of their own medical costs, than pay a measly monthly premium (in my case in BC it is a max of $54.00) and have the exact same coverage and the exact same people helped with it? if you can't pay, it is reduced and you still get the full coverage. there's no deciding what you can claim and what you cannot, you are simply covered at a fraction of your current rate.

You prefer to voluntarily pay (as jck noted $700/month) than to be responsible for paying $54.00/mo.

They also don't TAKE the premiums, they are payable by the individual. It's not part of my income tax, though costs are covered at my existing tax levels, it is part of a monthly payment that I make through my bank when I can afford it.

How, is it different in ANY way from what you do? Except the fact that you are bound to an unrealistic policy with outrageous costs that still goes to help others. If someone goes to hospital for a week and some surgery, do you really think that THEIR $8400/yr would cover their costs and it isn't a matter of raising your rates to pay for THEIR needs too?

DO you have a choice who your money goes with your existing system? No, not at all, your only way out is to not hold any coverage yourself, great alternative there!

You can shop around? So one policy charges $700/mo another charges $685/mo? Much better to have such choices, why would anyone choose to pay a mere $54 instead.

You can reduce your coverage to reduce your costs? So you STILL pay 10X what I would pay and I get FULL, unquestionable coverage.

Tony, your argument is absolutely senseless from a financial standpoint, which is what you are trying to make it.

You CHOOSE to pay hundreds of dollars, where I am obligated to pay $54.00. Oh hell me freedoms are being trampled on, I only wish I had a choice to pay a lot more!

You are so set on making your own choices, even when the policy provider essentially chooses how much you pay and where they spend your money, and yet you feel that is smarter than paying a mere fraction of that money and having full care without question.

You sir, make no logical sense at all!

You simply trust a private company with deep pockets to redistribute your funds than your elected government. And somehow that's different/better for you.

What is it? Pride? Morals?

What pride is there in knowing that you choose to pay many times what you could pay?

What morals allow you to feel that being ripped off by an insurance agent (and then being told where you can or can't seek help and what help you are entitled to) is better than paying a mere fraction of that for full, unquestioned coverage?

You don't see that your premiums are increased in order to outweigh costs incurred by others?
What CHOICE is that?

If you don't like them you can go elsewhere? Then you'll still be paying too much and doing so in order to support other people's needs.

I just don't know how one man can be so blind and clueless to reality, just because of strong morals against WHO takes his money from him to help other people.

SIMPLE QUESTION:
If the government offered you a car for $1,000.00 but you had to let them take out 10 monthly installments of 100.00 automatically, would you tell them to get lost because you would rather VOLUNTARILY pay 10 monthly installments of $1,000.00 for the same car at $100,000.00 from a car dealer instead?

If not, that's exactly what you are supporting here.

by jdclyde

If you actually had some values, you would debate someone on the issues discussed instead of stomping up and down like a spoiled child, screaming that everyone is lying, just because you don't agree with them.

I will leave you two to your love fest.

by oz_media

He is along for the ride because he is the president and knows he will be responsible if it fails and it will lose him any hopes of reelection.

I honestly thought you'd see it as opposed to some absurd comment about his choice in policy.

The food taster garbage? Kings aren't elected, I won't even answer such rot, you need to come up with more accurate and reasonable analogies in order for them to hold any weight.

by tonythetiger

the king in the analogy, aren't elected either. It's a perfect analogy!

[i]He is along for the ride because he is the president and knows he will be responsible[/i]

What responsibility? If he messes it up, he won't be re-elected, and will have to suffer with a generous lifetime pension package and perks?

Poor guy!

Let me ask again:

Not one Democrat in Congress is willing to use the plan they're setting up instead of the one they have now. Why do you suppose that is?

I see three possible explanations:

1. They're stupid to turn down such an incredible offer. The problem with that is,if they're that stupid, do we really want them messing around with health care?

2. They KNOW that the plan they're creating isn't as good as what they have, whether coverage-wise or cost-wise. Which begs the question, If it's not good enough for them, why should the people be forced to accept it?

3.They're trying to poison us! :)

Perhaps you could think of a reason I hadn't thought of... care to try?

by oz_media

"Not one Democrat in Congress is willing to use the plan they're setting up instead of the one they have now. Why do you suppose that is?"

You wold be referring to the 'blue dogs' who fear losing their position in their relative electione.

"That, because not only have Blue Dog (conservative) Democrats discovered that his health care plan will push this country deeper into an already massive debt, but if health reform passes, Mr. Obama will have pushed those Blue Dogs out of office in 2010.

The Blue Dogs come from shaky, as opposed to safe Democratic districts, where a wrong step on federal spending or taxes could whisk them out of office easily."

That is not saying there isn't a single democraty on congrss that supports him not in any way, no matter how many times you repeat it, you are still incorrect.

From another news source: "President Barack Obama may rely only on Democrats to push health-care legislation through the U.S. Congress if Republican opposition doesn?t yield soon, two of the president?s top advisers said. "

Hard to rely on them when not a single one of them will support him.

Reuters:"The first of five congressional panels to act, the Senate Health Committee approved on a 13-10 party-line vote legislation that would set up a government-run insurance program to compete with private insurers"

Yeah must have been all, hmmm, not republicans and you say it can't be democrats? Who the hell supported it then?

Face it, there are conservative ddemocrats that don' support it as it will be too expensive and any financial loss will hinder their ability to retain office in a poorer state, and there are even some liberal democrats that think it's not ENOUGH money.

But nowehere, not one single, biased blog on the web, except your own words and I'm sure JD would jump in to spoon with you, is there any mention that "not a single democrat in congress" supports it.

That's just pure buIIshit.

by jdclyde

Is it the place of the school, public or otherwise, to push a pro or con gay agenda? I don't think so. They have real things to teach and if they waste their time on someones social agenda it takes away from the time available to teach real subjects.

As for the AlGoreStory, if there are parts that are known to be factually inaccurate
(wrong), does an instructor that presents this not have an obligation to teach the truth, not a political agenda? Once the teacher knows something is wrong and continues to push it, it goes from being wrong to being an intentional lie. Should teachers teach intentional lies in the classroom?

As for disruptive kids, I do recall people getting suspended and expelled from public school for being so, exactly as it should be.

The problem child you mentioned should have to go to special ed class or summer school, but should not be allowed to WASTE so much of the public funds, not be allowed to be a distraction to the rest of the class. you don't let one loser take the ship down.

by oz_media

You have proven you have nothing more to add to the thread. You are just running around like a spoiled child now, while accusing others of being childish.

So f**k off, get a life and let others participate in a discussion.

by oz_media

It seems that in order to qualify for coverage, or at least affordable coverage (if that's what you call nearly a grand a month) you have to pose no risk of every needing that coverage.

That way they can redistribute your premiums for you so that people who ARE sick can get help, which again raises your premiums. How kind of you all, but how is that any different, other than being a lot more expensive?

From reading this thread it really seems that many American just don't understand the concept of insurance and how it is a cash grab by the provider to line their pockets. Instead they seem to feel it is a valuable industry worth protecting...how lost! insurance of ANY kind on ANY level is a pure rip off, a scam, a sham, a swindle, a con job, a fools game etc.

by tonythetiger

up until about five years ago, yes, if I didn't use above my deductible, I got the the premiums back. That is the reason why I paid my doctor in cash instead of him billing the insurance. Yeah, I paid $45 instead of $10, three or four times a year, but if nothing major happened, I got a check for $800 or so. They still do it, but now it's applied to the whole group as a unit... if nobody has a claim in a month, the entire group gets that month's premium returned. Granted it's a lot tougher but, perhaps amazingly to you, it's happened four times in the last 5 years... and my "group" is almost 45,000 people!

I think there's a psychological thing... some people use something more if they think it's free.

by oz_media

I busted a leg just last week because I knew it would be fixed for free. I think I'll go for loss of sight next month, that'll rack up some free mdeical for me!

" I got a check for $800 or so"

Didn't you just say you pay upwards of $1000.00 a month unless subsidized by teh company?

That's like people who say, 'take mroe tax off my check than you need to, I'll just get it back at the end of teh year. Not realizing that you will only get SOME of it back.

Unless of course you are referring to paying 800 and getting 800 in one month.

by tonythetiger

I was paying about $70 or 75 a month for family plan, my employer was paying nine times that. I was refunded about $800, they about $7,000.

Now it's different. They don't pay for family plan unless you have children you are required to support, and the ratio has changed to 70/30 instead of 90/10. So I'm paying $260 and change plus the difference between single and family ($130) and they're paying $620 or so.

What I was suggesting is them giving me the $620, the $260, and the $130 and I'll get my own coverage for less than $500 (hospital, and inpatient/outpatient testing only) and have over $500 left over to help the economy!

by delbertpgh

It's within the law...

Incidentally, it appears that half the bankruptcies in the country lately are due to medical causes.

by oz_media

Fistly, you make living on welfare sound like a cakewalk, fishing all day, no responsibilities, free money that others work for ? niiiice! Unfortunately that is not reality for most people collecting welfare, just those who scam the system while selling dope or working P/T under the table.

Not too many welfare recipients can afford a car, gas, cold beer, bait, a fishing rod etc.

The working class are the one's in a better position to take a day off as needed, afford to gas up the car, buy a case of beer, a half ounce of dope and drive to a lake to enjoy a day on the water.

If you're unable to take a day off every now and then to relax and enjoy your earnings, you may want to reconsider your position at work.

Having tried to collect welfare between jobs, lawsuits and accidents, and knowing how little they give you, not enough for rent yet alone food and a day out fishing, I can ssure you it is no walk in the park. It sucks, it's embarassing, it's degrading and most people cannot wait to find more to life than collecting welfare, fortunately there is a system in place where they can get job hunting assistance/support, help acquiring a bus pass, work boots and related clothing, enough basic food rations to merely stop from starving to death in teh process and, if lucky, a few packs of smokes if on a real luxury budget.

You are fooling yourself if you think its fun and easy. Just the jumping through hoops to get a check to begin with is more work than I do in a full day now, and you get paid less than the equivalent of a few days work for it.

In fact, I make the equivalent of a welfare check in less than two days. I spend more than a welfare check a day on a weekend.

workign has it's merits, collecting welfare is not living a life at all.

people think taht because yuo are on welfare, yuo have nothign to do all day and all day to enjoy it. Reliy is, the day is usually full of trying to get work, goin gto appointments with case workers, collecting documents and jumping through the welfare hoops, wishing you could afford to do somethign other than sit at home with nothign to do, no money to go anywhere and nobody to hang out with.

I don't know if you've ever had the grand privilege of needing government support to simply exist until yuo get yoru feet on the ground, but it certainly isn't something to look forward to and fishing all day is just not in the cards.

by av .

The super rich will just find new creative ways to hide their money. I don't feel sorry for them if they do get taxed.

I do feel sorry for those at the lower end of the rich ladder. Probably most of our small business owners. $250,000 a year is not rich where I live.

You know what I would like to see? Dems and Repubs working together on a more reasonable healthcare bill. I know, silly me. Republicans need to contribute more than just criticism and snipes at Obama. They have better ideas that are more fiscally conservative. They also have friends in the blue dog Democrats. Instead, Republicans would rather wait it out until the 2010 elections and hope that Obama will fail so they get re-elected.

Who gets screwed in the end? The people. Again.

AV

by jdclyde

and you will have noticed, I am having conversations with others.

You were not conversing from the beginning, just attacking, so not worth the effort.

I win.

by dwdino

I have spent the last 10 years digging my way out from under 50K worth of debt. Most my financial analyst friends prodded me to take the bankruptcy route.

I am a man of my word. I signed a contract stating I would pay for X, and I will. Granted, not the easy way, but it is the honest way.

(Before some panic and jump all over the honesty bit, there are limited circumstances where it doesn't apply)

by nicknielsen

[i]The problem child you mentioned should have to go to special ed class or summer school, but should not be allowed to WASTE so much of the public funds, not be allowed to be a distraction to the rest of the class.[/i]

That child is in that classroom because the school district is [u]required by federal law[/u] to accept that child. That teaching assistance is there because that school district is [u]required by federal law[/u] to provide one.

Here are your links, JD. Basically, the Supremes held that "the deprivation of free public education to disabled children constitutes a deprivation of due process."

The applicable laws are Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act of 1974 and the Individuals With Disabilities Education Act of 1990. Since public schools accept federal assistance...

http://maricopa.edu/legal/dp/inbrief/lawsprotdisab.htm

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Individuals_with_Disabilities_Education_Act

by jdclyde

what a crock of .......

yeah, quacks in the alleged mental health "profession" have an ailment and a drug for everything, including making excuses for poor behavior. I bet like many other alleged illnesses there is not a medical test of any kind for this either.

By making it a "condition" it removes guilt from the child for their actions, as well as from the parents.

Definitely a case of too much government in our lives.

by delbertpgh

Fact 1: we're the only rich nation without universal coverage.

Fact 2: we spend about double, per capita, what the other rich nations do on health.

Fact 3: our life expectancy and other measurable outcomes are no better than those of other rich nations; in fact, they are often worse.

Fact 4: bad as our national situation has become, given the system we now have it will get worse. Higher expenses every year are cooked into the system.

I don't think the congress-led bills that are shaping up are very good. However, if we follow the Republican lead and do nothing, we'll just lean into trouble.

by jdclyde

Didn't Obama claim we had to rush through the trillions of "stimulus" to keep from seeing double digit unemployment, that he now says we are going to hit?

I think it is arguable that we are now at the place Obama said we would be if we did nothing, but now we owe trillions will little to show for it.

by oz_media

His credibility ratings have hit an alltime low. He is known as offering "Fact-esque" commentary, Fact-esque was a term originally coined by Cobert, much like Max's factopinguess.

"It's been widely reported and that makes it fact-esque. - Stephen Colbert"

Posting comments from a news reporter with questionable credibilty is not an offering of fact. He is a known flip flopper, which loses all credibility with you in an instant anyway, or at least when you didn't personally support the speaker.

JIM KUHNHENN - Also plays both sides of the fence, which every creates the best story. He attacked the validity of Palin's speech and made Republican's look terrible. But he also had previously attacked Clinton for the same, now he often supports Oama when it is controversial and goes against him when it is also just as controvesial.

So you have two "news reporters", one who isn't crdible and one who is proven to simply run the opposite of the popular simply to stir the pot.

However I am sure both are very factual and righteous in your mind, this week anyway, as they agree with you. Reading some of their past reports I think you'll find you disagree as often as you agree.

nice post.

Slow down, in your haste to find any dirt you can, and dirt is all i is, you simply don't qualify what you present as evidence.

"Fact-esque" If it's reported enough times it becomes fact-esque. That doesn't make it fact though.

by tonythetiger

and sat down and the waitress brought you chicken. If you WANTED steak, wouldn't you pay extra for the ability to choose what you wanted? So you order and eat steak, and you enjoyed it immensely.

Now suppose I criticized you the next day, saying it was stupid to eat steak when chicken was so cheap.

by oz_media

Your analogies are always inapplicable and completely senseless, they don't illustrate the point your are tring to make at all.

Let's use your flawed analogy corrcetly then.

YOU go to a restaurant, steak costs the restaurant $19.99 ro serve and liver costs $4.99. to serve.

So they charge $15.00 for everything on the menu and you can select whatever you want to eat, THAT's where your ability to choose applies.

The difference is, YOU are happy paying $15.00 to choose anything and yet you only eat liver, while others eat steak.

You [i]feel[/i] you are not paying for others but you are and that you have been given a choice.

Therefore YOUR decision to overpay by $10.01 covers others who don't pay the full amount for their steak, but you got to CHOOSE what you ate by paying $15.00, which makes you happy, regardless of who else your $15.00 benefitted and how much your actual meal cost. They didn't take it from you so you justify that it is better to pay more than your expenses.

In contrast the Canadian system charges EVERYONE $4.99 (the price of liver) and yet everyone has the option to order steak too. In our case the butcher only charges $8.00 for steak though, instead of $19.99.

So yes, the additional $3.00 comes from my taxdollars or my $4.99/mo, to overcome the additional burden of peopl eatign steak and not payign teh full cost. I am still paying less than you and getting the same options as you though.

If you have a choice to receive $10.00 less on your paycheck or give away $100.00 you'd make the wise decision to give away the $100.00 instead?

Your system is still makign you pay for those who did not pay for it themselves.

And what if you STOP paying? You aren't covered and all those premiums you've paid to date and not used are simply alocated to others.

That's only marginally elective. You don't have to pay, but if you don't you aren't covered if you have an accident and need help.

if I don't pay, I still get treatment, but if I continue to not pay, they will retain my income tax rebate or at least enough to cover the unpaid monthly premiums, but I still get treatment and no bill for it.

It is a pretty solid system that is not in business to make a profit from policy holders, as is your own.

In your eyes, it's okay if they overcharge and profit from you, it's okay that they help others with your money, but you wont allow them to charge you a mere 10% of the money they do today, if you have to pay it as that is robbery?

Try applying logic next time.

by nicknielsen

My youngest son has Tourette Syndrome, diagnosed not by mental health, but by a pediatric neurologist. He doesn't make the animal noises, shout profanity, or have the gross muscle tics that the movies have popularized, but he does have tics, some of which can be disruptive in the classroom. He can usually suppress the tics for a while when he needs to, but if he suppresses the tics too long, he can have explosive outbursts of temper.

One of the accommodations in his 504 plan was that he was allowed to leave the classroom, go to the nurse's office, and release a few tics when he felt close to an outburst; all he had to do was show the pass to his teacher. The one time he had an episode in the classroom, the teacher refused to let him leave the classroom because she felt it was "an excuse for poor behavior".

There were consequences for my son, of course, but there were also consequences for that teacher.

No matter how much you want it to be otherwise, the world doesn't work in black or white, but in shades of gray.

by tonythetiger

[i]You wold be referring to the 'blue dogs' who fear losing their position in their relative electione. [/i]

'blue dogs' are conservative Democrats. It was Republicans (Senator Coburn) who offered the amendment requiring Congress to use the plan they voted for.

The blue dogs helped Republicans force another amendment... one that requires the elimination or duplicate programs created by the plan, but lost the amendment banning illegal immigrants from using the plan.

[i]"President Barack Obama may rely only on Democrats to push health-care legislation through the U.S. Congress if Republican opposition doesn?t yield soon, two of the president?s top advisers said. "
[/i]

They have the votes even if every Republican voted against it, so it's all a show.

The only way it can possibly fail is if several Democrats vote against it. But if by a Blessed Miracle it does fail, I GUARANTEE that the media will blame Republicans!

by jdclyde

they do have a list of payouts based on the limb you lose in an industrial accident, right?

First thing to consider, what caused the problem and was it avoidable? Also, the burden of proof is often replaced with emotion and junk science. It seems the people with the valid claims get the shaft while the scammers that higher a shady ambulance chaser strike it rich.

You think everyone that ever knew the person should get a payoff? Based on what? Loss of income is one thing, but other than that.....

Obviously ALL medical costs, present and future, as well as all lost income should be taken into consideration. Beyond that is just looking for a payoff, you give me 50 mill and I will not care that you accidentally hurt daddy?

by jdclyde

After you have acted like a trailerpark dweller on the Springer show, you are going to pretend that you were the calm, reasonable one all along? No one sees what a joke you have been making of yourself on a regular basis, really.... your secret is safe......

If you wish to at some point have a reasonable discussion that involves Americans, Politics, or world events, it would be a refreshing change. But as you have repeatedly told everyone here, you just don't care enough to bother.

by oz_media

You said, not a single democrat in congress supports it.

Proof of your assertion woul dbe needed, as I illustrated, that is false it is just asegment of Conservative Democrats in congress that have to fear losing their seat in office. the only reason THEY don't support it is due to personal interests.

by oz_media

You rinsurance rates hav changed from $75/month for a faily plan (which had a total cost/value of around $800.00 to paying nearly $900 (total cost/vale betwee you and employer).

So if I understand you correctly, your incurance rates have risen approx 100.00 a month, $1200.00 a year over the course of 5 years.

Rough math I know but it seems that the total cost has gone up around $100.00 month, I assume for at least similar coverage.

I have been paying $54.00/mo for YEARS and YEARS and YEARS. They had ahike, it was so long ago i forget exactlu when, but it must have been a good 7-10 years ago, and that was VERY minimal, like a few dollars. I am vague on the exact numbers as it is not somethign i offer consideration or pay attention to, it is such a small and insignificant cost, the last things most Canadians worry about is teh cost of premiums, whet coverage they have and what level of care they will receieve.

Full, medical coverage is just a given thing here, everyone has it and it doesn't cost anything isginificant. It certainly doesn't even make the tiniest dimple in my paycheck.

Ontop of that, you guys generally get paid less than we do, even after the exchange conversions etc. I couldn't even begin to imagine coughign up nearly a grand a month for questionable medical coverage. That's one system that would have me moving out of country as fast as my feet could carry me, what a complete and utter sham. TO add all teh other issues you face there, gun voilence, high violent crine rates, the world hating your every move etc. How is America an appealign destination for ANYONE.

If America was designed in one of those civilisation building games, it would be one of those scanerios where messages keep popping up to remind you everyone was unhappy and leaving the country.

HOwever you have a population 10X that of Canada. Seriously, it baffles me as much as Ethiopia being named the most prosperous and desired destination on the planet would.

America had a lot to offer when I was younger, it really was a pretty damn cool place, but that isn't the America I see today. Instead I see a country that has imploded and is trying to blow a little wind back in it's sails to get going again.

by delbertpgh

Just because they charge a lot does not mean they are ripping you off. They have to collect enough in premiums to pay their claims. Many people who have no insurance only buy it because they are sure they will need to collect. It's expensive, after all. If insurors have reason to suspect you are a costly case, then they need to charge you more, or limit risk by prohibiting payment for pre-existing conditions. Like, if your wife was already pregnant when you bought insurance, you get no OB coverage.

It is cheaper in an employer situation because of the group concept. Lots of people get a much cheaper deal because the large group has no more risk of getting sick than any other equal number of typical Americans. Also, almost all of the group participates, because the employer eats most of the cost, leaving the employee side of the bill very affordable, and a relative bargain. I pay about $4800 a year for very good coverage for the whole family, including dental, vision, drug, life insurance, legal insurance, and disability benefits. Probably $3000 is for the medical alone, and it would be half that for single-person coverage.

Group rates go up if too many healthy people take themselves out of the group. Group rates go up if too many sick people get into the group. If the group is just a statistical average, then it can be affordable. Still, the out-of-pocket amounts for Americans probably make a Canadian crap his pants.

I remember in the 1970s there was some state-funded California medical insurance for the poor that went broke. Seems their recruiters had trouble finding poor people willing to sign up, until they began to visit doctors' waiting rooms. They had no trouble signing up folks they found there.

by oz_media

Okay she's hot, if I was in a foreign country and thought she was a little edgy in her ways, I'd drag her in for a floor show too. Not into it? Okay lets go get lunch then.

Either way, what I don't understand is how this "news" would effect a man's abilities in a political role.

It's like judging someone based on personal religious preference or lack of. Bush was a Christian; big deal, it shouldn't have any bearing on his role as a president, beyond helping him retain personal faith and strength. However when he reverted to his religious beliefs as a reason for not supporting same sex marriage, it had gone too far. A specific religion cannot become a basis for governmental decisions. If you cannot separate your personal freedom to choose your religion from your role as president, you should not be in that position. Of course someone's faith will illustrate how they live their life, but to make a political decision based solely on yoru own faith is wrong.

The same goes for the public judging political figures, his sexual exploits, legally and with his wife, are absolutely irrelevant to his ability to perform his political work.

That said;

Why is it that, in America, people are so quick to judge people's moral and religious stance when considering their ability in a a political role?

Why is someone's private life, or sexual adventures with his wife something the public considers before voting?

My only answer is that people let their own personal religious faith intervene with their ability to accept others for who they really are. A religious bias?

If he/she has a political record of costly mistakes, then that is one thing and certainly a question to ask when considering a vote. What a politician, or hopeful politician does when on vacation with his wife illustrtates nothing of political relevance whatsoever.

Character? It has nothing to do with his chracter on a political platform either.

Why is it important?

by oz_media

I am licensed to sell insurance and have done so. I know exactly how insurer's work and how the bean counters think.

When I pay $54.00 a month, plus a portion of my monthly income tax to a medical plan, I know that I pay far less than it would evre cost for my medical bills in a year. Therefore OTHER PEOPLE'S money overcome the additional burden my premiums don't pay for. If it DIDN'T, the government would require higher premiums in order to continue the plan.

The most popular complaint by Americans toward the Canadian system is that they shouldn't have to pay for other people who don't pay their way themselves.

However, that's exactly what you do with private insurance.

Let's assume you are healthy and have a heart attack, it happens to the best of us, do you feel that your monthly premiums cover the entire cost of a triple bypass as well as hospitalization time, administrative costs etc? Obviously not.

So where do ethe extra money come from?

It comes from the other people who pay into the system but don't make a claim for expenses. In essence THEY are paying for your surgery, or at least the portion that your premiums don't cover. When YOU don't visit a doctor and still pay premiums, YOUR premiums outweigh the addiitonal expense of others.

So in essence it is no different than our own, SOMEONE has to pay the costs unless you are payign the full cost out of pocket, which you aren't with insurance.

An insurance company is a FOR profit organization, not a 'break even and perhaps get a little tax money to help with expenses' type of company. In fact, insurance companies are some of the wealthiest around, besides of course pharmaceutical companies, which are often funded and partially owned/financially backed by insurers.

The medical profession in America is an expensive, overpriced and VERY profitable
business. If they find the costs outweigh the income, they raise YOUR rates so they make more profit.

However that is NOT how a subsidized system works.

The Canadian government is not out to profit from medical services, it doesn't make money on drugs, treatments or premiums. In fact it is a low cost simply to overcome SOME of the burden, it is a non-profit/loss based system, the absolute opposite of how the US system is designed to be profitable.

Back to American complaints, if Americans complain abotu Canada's system because they are paying for other people's costs, even though that payment is less than 10% of what you currently pay for your own personal coverage, how do they accept paying 10X more than I do to overcome expenses other insured citizens incur?

If what we do is not morally right, isn't paying 10X more than that an absolute rip off? How can it not be when it is in a unregulated, private, for profit system?

by delbertpgh

We've done health care badly for a long time, and continue to do so. We were alarmed 20 years ago when we spent one dollar in 10 on health; now it's one in six. Time to get off the bus.

An absolute sucker for simplistic partisan Republican rhetoric could say that Obama "promised" we wouldn't hit 10% unemployment (which we haven't done yet, though it's 15% in Michigan), and that therefore we're just as bad off as we would have been had the stimulus not been voted. Of course, I'm not that sucker, and I doubt even you are, JD. In fact, most of the stimulus is yet to be spent.

You've got a job now; it is arguable that you owe it to Big O. Say, "Thank you, O." And make kissy sounds when you do it.