The "Thunderbird" is the second generation of AMD's Athlon processor line.
The XP processor is the third generation.
The Duron has a similar relationship to the Athlon that the Celeron has to the Pentium II / III.
I would not consider the Celeron or Duron as "crippled" version processors.
They were developed to be price point processors. The main difference is the amount of on chip cache memory.
The average user would not see any performance difference between a same speed Athlon / Duron, or P III / Celeron.
Only with very intense number crunching, will you see a noticable performance difference.
In fact, we are starting to see the processor being less and less a factor in overall system performance. Consider that if you have 2 identical systems with the only difference being processor speed, a 1 GHz cpu will at best be only 25% faster than a 500 MHz cpu.