Discussion Locked

RAID 5 question...

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've got 4 disks in a RAID 5 configuration. None of the disks is labeled (in the controller software) as a "hot backup", so that leads to the question:

What exactly does a 4-disk RAID 5 configuration mean?

More specifically, how many disks could fail without data loss?

(I understand a 3-disk RAID 5 configuration, and that one disk could completely fail without data loss. But I can't find an standard definition of a 4-disk RAID 5 configuration where one of the disks is not specifically labeled as a hot backup.)

I'm not a disk expert, so hopefully someone can elucidate this for me...

The controller is for a Dell PowerEdge: PowerEdge Expandable RAID Controller 3/Di.

5 replies

by redviking

RAID 5 - means that it uses 1 disk for parity and places data on the rest.
In practice this is done with placing data in the first write on disk 1,2,3,4 and parity on 5, next write it's data on 1,2,3,5 and parity on 4 and so on.
I believe that with the hot backup, you mean HOTSPARE. It is a disk in the array that is not in use but will only be used if one of the other disks fails.
eg. you have 4 disks, 1,2,3 it active raid and 4 is hotspare that means you will only have the diskspace of 2 disks to use. 1 is gone as a spare and 1 is parity. With more disks it is exaclty the same. 8 disks means 1-7 is active and 8 is spare. Taking one out for parity leave diskcapacity of 6.
So simply put, with hot spare you can actually loose 2 disks without failing (1 disk from active raid and then 1 hotspare) with out the hot spare you can loose 1 disk without failing.

For more indepth explanation you can mail me.

by paulp

I agree with answer #1, but would add this. The hot spare must be designated as a hot spare when you install the drive. Otherwise the operating system will not use it for that purpose.

Also, you can have any number of disk drives in a RAID 5 configuation. This will be determined by how much disk space you need and how many drives your box and controller can accomodate.

This discussion is closed to new replies.