Discussion Locked

RAM Compatibilty Question

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Was wondering if Dimm EDO RAM is compatible with Dimm SDRAM with a max bus speed of 133 MHz? (In other words, can the Dimm EDO RAM be installed and work in a computer already running with Dimm SDRAM?)

10 replies

by fenaikh

Hi
EXTENDED DATA OUT (EDO)

In 1995, EDO became the next memory innovation. It was similar to FPM, but with a slight modification that allowed consecutive memory accesses to occur much faster. This meant the memory controller could save time by cutting out a few steps in the addressing process. EDO enabled the CPU to access memory 10 to 15% faster than with FPM.

SYNCHRONOUS DRAM (SDRAM)

In late 1996, SDRAM began to appear in systems. Unlike previous technologies, SDRAM is designed to synchronize itself with the timing of the CPU. This enables the memory controller to know the exact clock cycle when the requested data will be ready, so the CPU no longer has to wait between memory accesses. SDRAM chips also take advantage of interleaving and burst mode functions, which make memory retrieval even faster. SDRAM modules come in several different speeds so as to synchronize to the clock speeds of the systems they'll be used in. For example, PC66 SDRAM runs at 66MHz, PC100 SDRAM runs at 100MHz, PC133 SDRAM runs at 133MHz, and so on. Faster SDRAM speeds such as 200MHz and 266MHz are currently in development.

Good luck

Mohamed

by guruofdos

Standard EDO used to come on 72pin SIMM cards. SDRAM comes on 168 pin cards so physically, they are not compatible.

However some manufacturers did use EDO type memory on SDRAM style cards. The two are NOT compatible. EDO uses asynchronous read/write/refresh cycles at a speed of 60nS, SDRAM uses synchronous read/write/refresh cycles at 10-12nS for PC66, 8-10nS for PC100 and <6nS for PC133.

Chances are, the machine won't even boot....at best, you will get memory errors and BSOD's all the time, plus any amount of unpredictable behaviour!!

by guruofdos

TheChas....Just for your information, I have a VXPro motherboard on the bench in front of me that takes 3.3volt EDO DIMMS. I also have 3.3volt EDO DIMMS...

The DIMMS don't work in a TXProII board designed for SDRAM....obviously.

The operating voltage is not the reason. In fact DIMM sockets on older boards using EDO DIMMS often have a jumper to select 5v or 3.3v memory, just in case you need to know that for future reference :-)

by thechas

Sorry, unless you have avery special motherboard, you CANNOT mix EDO and SDRAM DIMMS.

Most EDO DIMMS use 5 volt power whereas the SDRAM DIMMs use 3.3 volt power.

Unless your motherboard is capable of supplying different voltages to different DIMM sockets, and has isolated address and data lines, you cannot mix the 2 styles of DIMMs.

Also, as a general rule, the EDO DIMMS maxxed out at 66MHz. If your bus is 100MHz or 133MHz, you will comprimise system performance with slower speed RAM.
Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.