Discussion Locked

Reliable cheap hardware?

0 helpful
15 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hi! I wanna create a desktop computer that I will put together myself that must be cheap and reliable. This is to be used in an office enviroment, for typical office/e-mail/solitaire =) use, so any CPU speed should be more than enough for today's and tomorrow's needs (I'm thinking AMD but don't know if celeron would be a better choice). RAM should be 256 to be prepared for the future, so any reliable cheap brands would be welcomed.

Maybe the motherboard should have a soundcard, VGA and LAN integrated for simplicity.

HD of 20 GB would be enough but maybe those are not even sold any more.

Monitor, keyboard, mouse, speakers, cases, DVD drive or CD, or maybe CD-RW(depends on the prices)....everything value but everything reliable.Any comments will be appreciated. Thanks in advance.

Sorry if I take a few hours to respond, I'm on a 56 K.

15 replies

by maxwell edison

Reliable and cheap - and enough for tomorrow's needs? You may have some choices to make, and "cheap" is relative.

Processor: You may want to decide between AMD and Intel (You'll get lots of arguments on either side - but I fall on the Intel side.) But if you choose Intel, take a pass on the Celeron and buy a Pentium 4. A Celeron processor has less cache memory, and the P4 runs at a higher clock speed than the Celeron. The fastest Pentium 4 will be 60 percent faster than the fastest Celeron -and that's a significant performance difference.

Motherboard: I prefer an Asus or Intel board. But take a pass on the integrated components such as video and LAN. You can get away with integrated sound (unless you want something really serious),but integrated graphics steals RAM resources and will ultimately bog down the system - you don't want that. You could maybe get away with integrated LAN as well, but as a matter of preference I don't - and LAN cards are really cheap. But I'd recomment buying a good video card with at least 32 MB, maybe 64 MB video RAM, which will cost around $75 to $125. ATI and Nvidia are good choices for a reasonable price.

Hard Drive: Get a 7200 RPM Drive, and a 60GB or 80GB will not be that much more than a 20GB - and easier to find. You'll get better performance and better growth potential with the 60 or 80 as well.

RAM: Go with 512 - maybe 1 GB. 256 won't be enough.

My latest system:

P4 2.4 GHZ
Intel motherboard - D845PEBT2
1 GB DDR RAM(2ea 512s)
ATI RADEON 9000 AGP graphics w/64MB Video RAM
TDK 52x CD RW
Maxtor 80GB 7200 RPM HDD
Antec Sonata case - silencer model. (Quiet and easy to work with - and expansion room.)

There ya' go.

by maxwell edison

By the way, I buy a lot (but not all) of stuff mail order and/or through the Internet, but if you want a good computer "super store" AVOID CompUSA at all costs, and visit a Micro Center. They have a great selection, real good customer relations, andcompetitive prices. (At least that's my opinion.)

by thechas

I've had good luck buying surplus and refurbished hardware from sources such as:

www.compgeeks.com
www.newegg.com
www.pcliquidator.com

Stick with brands you know for major components.

Make sure that you can get drivers

AMD CPUs are fine.
There is very little cost difference between a 1GHz Duron and Athlon.

Be careful with generic RAM.
There are problems with SDRAM DIMM compatibility.
Make sure that you can exchange RAM if it does not work with your motherboard.

Floppy andCD drives can be generic.

Make sure that the power supply is actually rated for the amount of power you need.

Don't cut corners on the CPU fan.

I don't like ANY built-in items on main boards. They have poor performance, and if they fail, the motherboard is toast.

Chas

by djent

Life is a series of compromises and you will trade some of you criteria for others. Prioritize your criteria and accept the compromizes.

by totee

Hey,
I have done business with Multiwave(mwave.com) for a number of years and have not had any discrepencies so far where parts are concerned. They are also very reliable when it comes to timely shipping. Once you get to the site click on product catalog and you can put together the parts you want to order from there. complete specificationsis given on almost all products

totee

by arielstarfire

Intel Celeron at 2.3 Ghz
256 MB 333 Mhz DDR Ram
Intel Pentium 4 Motherboard AOPen AX4gE-N
Intel AGP Video
PCI 5.1 Sound
10/100 Ethernet Card
ATX Case With 300 Watt Power Supply
Labor Included
1 Year Parts & Labor Warranty

www.virgilpc.com

by wlbowers

If you just want help with component avaibility go to http://www.pricewatch.com you can get cheap to reasonable to the outragous.

If you want to research components go to http://www.anandtech.com and brew a pot of java. Your reading will take a while.

Todays market has busted wide open. Components have dropped in price and the manufacturers are causing problems for custom builders.

There is crap out there for sure. But the market for reliable is there just do your homework.

There is a major that is advertising a 2.2gig P4 128meg mem, 30gig, with 17" monitor, second optical drive, speakers, software bundle, 2 year warranty, in home service, and free shipping for $599.00 online rebate.

Won't tell you who but there aren't that many to search.

Deals like this make it hard to compete.

Building your own will get you exactly what you want in the way of graphics, audio, speed, ect.

Just make sure you know your suppliers and their support policy.

Hope this rambling has helped.

Good Luck Lee

by pctech

................. Part two
CDRW drives are not much more expensive than a straight CD drives and is an excellent choice for light back ups. ( Carry the burned disks off site for security. )
DVD is not a good option, unless you are going to watch movies at work. DVD drives are a piece of hardware waiting for an application.
The case should also not be over looked. A mid tower offers more cooling than a desktop or a mini tower. This will also offer you more future expandability. Get at least a400 Watt power supply.
Since you are going to buying online, you should have no problems getting an OEM MS Internet Keyboard/Mouse combination set.
17" monitors are inexpensive. Get one with a low DPI, .25 or lower, and high refresh rates and resolution settings.
Ram is dependant on which CPU you decide to go with. 512 Mgs. of DDR is good for AMD and most Intel boards. RAMBUS is fast fading and too expensive, although it is the fastest, for now.
Speakers are not crucial for a business system, unless you are doing audio related work. A cheap set of amplified speakers should suit your needs just fine.
Shop around, deals can be found. Buy as much as you can from one vendor and you will probably get free or discounted shipping. Check their RMA policy should you need to make a return.

I hope this helps you.

by pctech

Part one.
You need to consider relaibilty over cost savings. You stated that this is to be a business system and reliability becomes key.
I normally suggest AMD over Intel. More "bang for the buck". The Celeron should serve your purpose just as well. Consider the speed/cost of the two.
The motherboard is the heart of the system. DO NOT skimp here. Get one with a 3 year warranty. This usually ensures reliability.
Onboard sound is not a detriment. I would consider it, since this is a businesssystem, and the speakers can be cheap amplified speakers. Again, this is not a gamer machine.
The 60 to 80 Gig. hard drive is a better option than a smaller one. The cost savings for a smaller drive are nearly negligable. 7200 RPM with 8 Mg. of cache would be an excellent choice. Again, the cost savings for less is not really there. DO NOT buy refurbs or OEm drives. The warranty for OEM drives is short, and even shorter for refurbs, if at all.
The case is also important. A mid tower offers you more cooling and expandability over a desk top or mini tower. Get one with at least a 400 Watt power supply. You will need it to expand later.
... I think this is the jest of my first post.

by jim phelps

Sounds like ANY refurbished Dell would meet your needs. You can buy them at dell.com, ready to use, with a warranty, usually getting a very good price.

Either that, or get the cheapest new Dell. It should be more than enough for what you've described.

You need to decide the features you want. Me, I'd go for the DVD RW (to allow for backups) (DVD is a lot higher capacity than CD, and you can use either type of disk in those drives), and I'd get as much as possible integrated on the motherboard. (This frees up the slots for other things.) If an integrated component ever goes out, you can always install a card to replace it.

You said "everything value but everything reliable". I have found that when you try to save a little here and there, you often end up with junk. Go for name brand components.

A few years from now, when some critical component fails, you will want to be able to replace it with the correct part. This is a KEY reason to go with a name brand PC, like Dell, Compaq, or IBM. They will have COMPLETE info on your system on their web site, and they can provide the correct replacement parts. Compaq and IBM, in particular, put a spare part number on EVERYTHING. If you match the spare part number, the part WILL work.

This discussion is closed to new replies.