Discussion Locked

Removeabledrives aren't working for me

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a classroom with 19 workstations. We need to teach Linux and multiple Windows Courses. In each class the students need to install the OS on the computer they use. In a week 8 different classes need to meet in this classroom. 8 sets of hard drives is unmanageable. I need suggestions of other ways of accomodating all of these classes. Thanks

andrew

13 replies

by tbradley

Better Scheduling?

I don't see a perfect solution, except some which will cost $$$$ to implement, and even then you still have some hoops to jump through.

I assume you've explored bootmagic and other similar products. Divide a 20gb hard drive up into however many chunks you need, yet this itself throws extra elements in that you don't need to confuse beginners with.

The only thing I can come up with is a "hard core" workaround, and that is to buy 8 cheap 2gb hard drives for each machine... If this is some serious learning, the $40 cost can be borne by the student perhaps. Get some EXTRA long ribbon cables and power cables, and snake them out the back of the case. That way attachment and removal of drives is done fairly easily.

One other option, and it too is imperfect, is to get one HEALTHY server, with ample HD space, and give each student a mapped drive to act as the "local" hard drive.

I've done this with Windows 3.1 and Windows 95, but 98 and NT have too much baggage to operate "over the wire". Dunno about Linux.

Good luck. I'm gonna subscribe to this one :)

by asd

Cost isn't really an issue since if I continue with removeable hard drives I will need 8 or 9 sets plus drives at close to $300/set. I did think about just mounting the hard drives externally but there is a limit to the length of an IDE cable. Also I neglected to mention that we are using leased Dell towers so I can't cut holes in the case.

thanks

by allan

Only a thought - perhaps someone else could refine the idea but how about boot roms in the network cards and operating systems loaded and controlled and run from server.

by cdobbin

Ya I agree with the first guy, no easy way around this one, the title of your post is "removable drives not working for me" but thats what I would suggest, rather than hang the cables out the back, these removable drive bays are quite cheap and easyto use. Again about the only other solution is to use multiple partitions to load the OS's but that could be a big can of worms itself, especially with novice users.

by asd

The cheap ones that we are using are breaking and I would need like 8 or 9 sets for each computer to completely use the classroom 3 times a day with classes meeting twice a week. It is just becoming unmanageable. We did look at partition magic, boot magic and other software solutions. While they would work there is no way to prevent a student from damaging another student's partition.

thanks

by asd

WE have considered already: additional removeable hard drives but there would be too many of them.

Jaz drives but they don't officially support booting NT or Linux

Orb drives but the don't support linux

Partitioning Software, can't protect partitions from other students

Re"ghosting"(using norton ghost) after each class but someone would have to watch the uploads to make sure it goes well

thanks for the ideas so far and keep em coming please.

by pcjockey2000

I took a class in a room just as you describe. There were multiple classes going on the same days, on the same computers. The solution they had is the one you are resisting: removable hard drives. Because of the continuing nature of most studies, ghosting the drive each night is not only needlessly labor intensive, but detrimental to subsequent classes. I was studying NT and we depended on our drives being the same when we got to class as when we had left them. The removable hard drives were labeled for each group and stacked in a cupboard. Each group had their own set. Perhaps there is a better way, but considering how often beginners blow out their hard drives and mess up programs. I wouldn't want to be the last student to get a multi-user hard drive in a day. I know I didn't give you a solution, but I thought I would throw out a former student's perspective.
Theresa, MCSE

by asd

It is great from a student's standpoint but to properly do this in 1 classroom I would have to have at least 8 sets and as many as 10 sets of drives for one computer. For one lab that could be up to 200 drives to keep track of. I may have to equip3 labs this way

thanks

by ppppp0

Jaz drives don't support Linux officially but I have seen it work as a bootable setup.
My sister attended Colorado Tech Univ and that is what they were doing.... Took them a while to figure it out though...

This discussion is closed to new replies.