Discussion Locked

Router and switch recommendation

0 helpful
19 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'm looking to purchase a router that I can use with either DSL, Cable modem, or frame relay to the Internet and either VPN back to our company network or connect directly via frame relay. I'm also looking for a good 16 to 24 port switch/hub to workwith the router. There are so many products that I need some recommendations to narrow it down.
Thanks.

19 replies

by ryder007

Hi as far as a router for cable or dsl goes, a netgear or linksys router are the best and easiest to configure. I'm not that familiar with frame relay but if you need all three types I would look into a cisco router. Cisco router's are substantiallymore expensive, but they will also maximize your throughput.

Dean

by grbeckmeyer

I would agree with the first post...I have installed both Netgear and Linksys cable/DSL routers and like them both. The one hitch was that the Linksys had some sort of DHCP issue with workstations using Intel chipset NICs, can't remember the chipset number, but a driver update fixed the problem.
As far as a switch/hub, on the low end I would suggest D-link, high end HP. The biggest reason is that they both have lifetime warranties.

by fred king

I would say CISCO. Or ask the company below, their great.

Supplier:
Central Networks and Technologies Ltd
St Chads Court
School Lane
Rochdale
OL16 1QU
Telephone: 01706 712121
Fax: 01706 712222

Hope that helps
Fred

by rgrowcock

Hi,

I agree with the other two posts, in that for DSL or Cable, you can't beat the ease of installation in the Linksys or Netgear. I have also installed both with no problems on either. Frame relay works a little different, and I don't think that either of the mentioned routers can handle it. I could be wrong though.
The other issue is with a VPN. That is a little deeper technology and requires a specialized router. A quick thought for you, who are you thinking of using forCable access? If you use Time Warner's Road Runner, they supply a router. And if in time you want to do VPNs, they just upgrade the router for you. The downside is that you have no configuration controls over this router, if this is an issue for you and your company.
You can also purchase a Cisco router, specifically the 1720, which is capable of handling everything you've mentioned. With the possible exception of Frame Relay, I'm not sure what you would need for that. But whatever supplier you are working with for Frame Relay should be able to tell you what is needed. I wish I had a better answer for you on that.
On the last subject of a switch/hub. I would suggest getting a switch, be it from Cisco, HP, 3com, etc. Depending on your budget, I would opt for a Cisco 2924XL switch. It gives you 24-10/100, auto-sensing ports and works more efficently than a hub. You can get one at www.cdw.com for about $1700, maybe a little less. It's not cheap, but it works very well, with little maintenance requirements. You also may be able to purchase a used or refurbished one too. Hope this helps. Roger

by stillatit

You are going to want to decide whether you want to use DSL or Frame Relay before you pick a router. The reason is that DSL terminates in a modem, which then gives you a tcp/ip connection, while an incoming Frame Relay connection rides on a T1, which needs a CSU/DSU.

The Cisco routers handle the T1/Frame Relay with a plug-in board, but you don't want to buy it unless you need it.

Cisco DSL routers terminate the DSL and give you routing capability, but often your ISP dictates what kind of modem or router hangs on the DSL and will not offer you any options. If you get the option, and the vpn in the Cisco DSL router is compatible with whatever you run at your home office, this is a winner.

If you are looking for a 16 port hub, thisimplies that you will have about that many users. Given this, I would seriously consider getting a Cisco over a cheaper router. Your cost of downtime in the event of a problem argues for getting the best.

For the switch/hub, I like the 3com Superstack series. Again, you can buy a cheaper hub, but what does it cost you in time when there is a problem?

Good luck.

by ann777

I recommend LinkSys routers if you are going to be using DSL or cable. As far as switches/hubs ; Netgear is great, 3com is great too. Stay away from cheapie brands and you'll be fine.

I too say that if you're going to be using Frame Relay, you purchase a Cisco router. And probably 3com Hub/switch.

by tony.colgrove

If you go the DSL, or Cable route and want VPN termination- Watchguard makes a pretty nice product that provides the service of a typical broadband router (like LinkSys and Netgear that everyone else has mentioned), but is a true firewall and supports VPN connections.
http://www.watchguard.com/products/soho.html
Have a look.

As for a good 16 to 24 port switch (skip getting a hub) 3Com is nice.

by mckaytech

One product that comes to mind for the router is the Cisco 2621 - it has two Ethernet ports and a space for a WAN interface that can accept a T1 CSU/DSU card. With this particular piece of equipment, you could support DSL (with external modem to anEthernet port), cable modem (to an Ethernet port) or frame-relay (with integral CSU/DSU). The other Ethernet port would then go to your internal network and this device is also VPN-capable if you choose DSL or Cable modem.

I'm biased because I currently work in a shop that has standardized on Cisco, but you can't beat the Cisco 2900-series switches although the 3Com SuperStack and HP switches are decent and may be somewhat less expensive. In large part, the price will depend on whether youneed a managed switch.

paul

by estebandelatorre

Switch (layer 2)
Consider the 3com 3300 line.
They are:
-Easy to install (and understand).
-Low entry price.
-Can grow up to 4 switches in a stack (96 ports!) at a really low cost.
-Indestructible harware! & good performance.
-They have a cross-cable switch build-in.
www.3com.com

About the DSL Router: Although that 3com have a complete line of dsl routers and VPN boxes, consider first, the one suggested by your ISP provider. They must have some experience in that hardware, so less time for you, and perhaps they may have a lower price. Many times the configuration service is included!

-No Auto-sensing 10/100 speed trouble

This discussion is closed to new replies.