Discussion Locked

saving power vs. wear and tear

0 helpful
13 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Times are tough in the world of Higer Ed. Our Chancellor cites a study at Iowa State University indicating that $115 annually can be saved for each computer and monitor turned off on weekends and evenings, $58 for each laser printer or FAX machine, and $216 for each copy machine.

Conventional wisdom says that the on-off cycle increases the wear on components and in the long run leads to a shorter life for the computer and monitor.

Given the tight budgets we have3 to live with, the likelyhood of keeping computers on a three-year replacement cycle seems nil.

Will we save money, or in the long run will the wear and tear on the computers out weigh any savings in electricity?

13 replies

by ann777

I've always felt that it's best to shut them off. The savings of $'s in parts -- specifically replacement hdds have a mtbf (mean time between failure) and if left on all the time, then their real life is shorter -- and electricity will accumulate.

Another part of the equation should be air conditioning. Are these computers in A/C rooms where the A/C goes off? Do they cook when not in use by leaving them on?

If the computer is planned to last more than three years, then I believe you should shut them off when not in use. If you lease these computers and do not care about long-life or repair-costs (under warranty for the duration of the lease), then leave them on.

Wear 'n Tear of powering off/on the computers are not the same as they were years ago. I think it's pretty much up to individuals -- so go with the flow.

I've worked with public libraries and we've always shutdown the workstations at closing... a clean boot in the morning clears out any trash left on the computer and reimages the computer if anything funky is detected.

by joseph1

I was told by an electronics wiz that every time you turn on your computer you shorten it's life by one day.
But seriously speaking you have to think of why it's not advisable to turn them off and on. The main problem is the first burst of electricity that hits the motherboard and other elctronic circuts is a real heavy one and then the current stablizes. If you have a good UPS, not one that is just a backup battery, but one that stablizes the current youu shouldn't have much of a problem withturning your machines on. The problem is again what is cost effective.
Also if you want to have your systems live linger heat is a killer and dust is an insulator. Keep your electronic equipment vacumed out and well ventilated and fans working and you should get good milage.

by thechas

I would start with a reality check.

Get a hold of the study, and at a minimum, adjust the figures for your local electicity rates.

Keep in mind that the PC itself uses very little power at idle.
Especially if you have enabled power management.
For "office" type PCs, the monitor uses the most power, and generates the most heat.

I suspect that you could acheive 90% of the study savings just be enabling power management and haveing the monitors turn off after say 1 hour of idle time.
Then, set the hard drives to spin down at say a 2 hour idle time.

This way, you get most of the benefits of both options.
The motherboard and CPU are left active, and the monitor and hard drive motors stop producing the heat.
As a side benefit, no-one has to remember (or take the time) to shut the PCs down.

Another thing you can do to reduce the power comsumption, is to avoid the temtation to over-power new PCs.
Keep the CPU speed, amount of RAM, and the video card power to a "realistic"minimum.

Since the Chancellor is concerned about life cycle costs of PCs, now would be a good time to broach the concept of going to LCD monitors for all new PCs.
That way, you get a 24/7 power and heat savings.

Chas

by richard_barsby

Hi the problem is not really in the inrush current during turn on, the main cause of failure due to on off cycles is expansion and contraction of joints in a system be it a solder joint or connectors, solder connections on high power semiconductors which are rigidly fixed to a heatsink tend to suffer most. So still the question leave on or turn off, I have always turned off my PC in the evening and on again the following day the only failures I have had are HDD's and these were both Samsung devices!.

Rich

by bud4wiser

I would suggest that temperature changes and dust are two most debilitating factors to the life of a computer. (or most any solid-state device)

My own preferance is to shut devices off when they are not going to be used for 8 hours are more.

by wlbowers

In the old days when power supplies were are
of the brute force, (large transformers), type
the inrush current did creat quite a shock on
the internal components. But now days
everything is designed with switching power
supplies. These utilize high frequency transfer
and electronic switching to convert the 120vac
to the system's usable lower voltages. this
results in lower inrush and a more stable
system.

The newer system have power managenent.
they can trun off hard drives, even go as far to
slow the processor to almost nothing. But the
system is still on. It is still using energy and
still developing heat in the process. This is the
main killer of systems at this time. Not the on
off cycle.

I have worked on electronics since the tube
days. That is when the "leave it on" Started
because with tubes as you applied voltage
had an inrush current that would cause the
heating elements to flex and move while they
were coming up to temperature.
We are a long way from general tube
operation. The picture tubes and associated
electronics are designed to minimumize this
problem.

All of this boils down to the fact if you don't
have a computer that requires to be on full
time, youaren't waiting for an email, or
something else that requires it .

TURN IT OFF

Lee

This discussion is closed to new replies.