Say no to Free "IT Advice"
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
IT Employment
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by anon78
by the admiral
That is a matter of setting rules. Like with my company, if I get a call after working hours and I have to go in, I charge Holiday Rates because it is not a requirement for me to come in unless there is a mess. And If I have to think on my time about work or do work related things, then that is different.
As soon as we start talking shop or start brainstorming, I am on the clock and I charge accordingly.
If I have one of those people asking for one of those "gotta sec for a quickie question," and it winds up being a three hour conversation, then we have a problem. And I tell all of my techs that if it takes more than 15 minutes, table it.
THe note has gone out to call the tech or put a call in on their company computers, and not to bother them on personal stuff, but the fact of the matter is that I can't stop people from asking.
by dmiles
Set your boundaries and hold to them,either you want to help or you donot and its obvious you dont.
Practice in the mirror saying no and learn to live with it no matter what the consequences.
by lazerous200
by macghee
by hollydj
by edenton
I seem to get the worst of both worlds. I am an IT person of a large hospital.
I get calls from people at work asking if I can "come over" and fix a home pc, and I get calls at home from friends asking for medical advice.
My job requires me to have a fairly high level of understanding of medical care, and I am also a EMT. I don't mind fixing my sisters computer or explaining a question from her doctor. I will always give emergency care if needed.
I don't like the calls at 11:30 at night even thou the caller knows I was sleeping. No one calls their mechanic at 3:00am for a "quick question" and it would be unthinkable to call a lawyer at 4:30 in the morning on a Saturday to ask about a small point in a contract. If you do call your lawyer, you are charged accordingly.
Why am I called because your mouse is a little jumpy, or "I opened an email and now I think I have a virus!"? Turn off the #@!$% computer, go to sleep and call me at a normal time. Better yet, don"t call me, call Tech Support for your computer! You paid for a 3 year plan, USE IT!
Even worse are the sick kid calls. When I say to call their doctor, they say they don't want to wake them up. Doctors are on call. I am not.
by tony_moey
by firstaborean
When I was an electronics engineer, I got this sort of thing whenever I started with a new company, and I consistently replied that I had consulting rates, that I never worked for free in my field of work, and I then gave them my rates. I made it clear that I liked to help people, but I always kept my profession at a strictly professional level. Help a friend paint his new garage door? Fine. Help him repair his TV? Hundred bucks an hour.
It doesn't matter what your profession is, just never do it for free, and make that a clear policy, no matter for whom (except possibly for an organized charity). By saying that you have a policy, always applied, you avoid making the asker feel snubbed, especially when you make it clear that, for other, personal help, you're ready to lend a hand, whenever you have the time.
by jor55
by steve
by danitech
Hello,
I have had the same problems in the past... Until recently though i have found it to be a major problem. You can always talk to your boss, and exagurate the amount of time you spend unwillingly helping these people when there are very critical tasks which need to be completed for the company. Tell your boss that you feel there needs to be a limitation on how much time is being utilized with these non-work related issues, and have that "strictly enforced". Then you can tell your co-workers that your boss has noticed you spend considerable amount of time on non-work related things (if your boss is not at the same location as you, one could say they had heard reports of it from "someone") and you need to limit the conversation to 5 min and are very sorry but your boss is watching your every min when someone is talking to you... or something like that. When it comes to the partner though, it's always good to get in their good books, so I would recommend having them bring you to their house to actually repair the problems. That is what we do where I work. Then you get into their good books and magical things happen :)
And if you want to help a co-worker out, or give them "advice" you can always create a how to document outlining the fix for their problems. Just tell them you found something on the internet, not sure if it works, but here you go anyways. Just a thought!
Best of luck!
Dani
by andeanderson
For most of us who have been in the IT industry for more than six months.
But, we must remember there are many new people who are running into the same old problems we have already faced and they are searching for "advice" from those who have already been through it.
There is no easy way to say "no" when someone asks for "free" advice. Each instance is different. If you really feel pressured or uncomfortable when being asked for advice you can excuse yourself because you do not have the time right now to help. Or, if you can take a couple of minutes and offer your advice, not your time and services, then give them your advice.
But, don't just refuse outright. That is a dangerous road. You might need their advice or help in the future. People will always remember who they feel wronged them and sometimes, hopefully, they will remember how you helped them.
Sometimes we in the IT world forget that our tasks are part of a Team Effort and that others have worked just as hard, or harder, to achieve the position they are in as we did in learning the skills needed for the position we fill.
by bill
I've read most of the replies in this chain and I have to agree that it can be a pain having everyone expect free service. The key here is that "advice" is different than "service". One of the best replies put it best, advice is asking a friend or colleague a question with a brief answer. That's fine and in most cases, the right thing to do.
If however this changes to making a house call, taking someone's machine and performing a lengthy "disinfection" this is a totally different story. I know, I get sucked into this all the time. I'm an engineer and design and build systems for a living. The problem is that people think because you do that you would be happy to take care of their problems.
The solution is not complex and doesn't have to make you come off as rude. First, decide if you really want to "just help" or start offering a paying service. If paying service is the way you want to go then be prepared to say "you know, this is going to take me hours to do. I would be happy to do this but my rate is $XXX". I find that people that trust you would rather pay you than the Geek Squad or Dell or some other large organization.
That said, if you want to build a service based business you should be prepared to offer "some" free advice, especially to friends. Think of this as both goodwill and marketing.
by super_it_mom
by jnoonan
I do get asked quite frequently to help others with their PC's. I don't mind helping people especially friends and family. A thank you is sufficient. I don't need to charge them for anything more than supplies, whether it be software or hardware. When they reccomend me to others that I don't know or work with , then I will charge a nominal fee so as to not be taken advantage of. As far as insults go, only individuals that see this as such a major inconvenience in their lives need to lighten up and realize that life is way too short for such trivialities.
Tell me... have you ever asked anyone for advice? Aren't you using Tech Republic for free advice? Have you ever searched Google or Yahoo message boards for answers to your questions? How much did you pay? Did you ever have a friend do repairs to your house, car etc? Next time you do make sure you pay the going rate.
Have a nice day!
--- Joe
by cybergoyle
I also receive many requests for advice and tech support from friends, family, co-workers, acquaintances, and occasionally total strangers that I meet when they learn my occupation. I've met my share of IT workers, and they are many so-called 'freelance' hired guns anywhere you look. Most aren't really that talented at all; they merely possess some basic skills.
That said, getting good advice isn't as easy for the tech-challenged individual. Not only do they have a problem to solve without the first clue how to find an answer (and I've never read any comprehensive manual that could teach me to merely remove and prevent spyware from infesting a PC), they cannot discern good advice from bad.
As a skilled expert, you should feel priviledged that people trust your advice enough to even ask - hasn't everyone dropped a name or called up a buddy to ask for help at some time or another?
Consider the alternative; no one ever asks you for advice or assistance. How would you feel if you offered to help someone and were met with the reply 'thanks, but I already know someone that knows what they are doing....'
by the admiral
I think that is giving too much benefit of the doubt, since most if not all users understand that not all PC's or operating systems are alike being that they come to work using the blessed version and then go home to their preloaded system.
I hae never had someone that did not understand that all PC's are not alike, all notebooks are not alike, all cars are not alike, all homes are not alike.
Lets say that the user asking the question is knuckle dragging stupid as you say. My answer is honest in that the user would not know the difference. If the person is a tinkerer, the answer is still valid, since most if not all companies have a standard setup that differs greatly from every other preload on a home system.
While I have confidence in every technician, I also have confidence that the tech will defer the end user to someone outside of the company, or call the free support numbers for their PC for their answer.
I do not believe that the answer is misleading in that quite simply, it states that the technician is not familiar with their HOME setup versus the corporate setting, and that it is better for a person who is familiar with the HOME setting to work on the system. Nothing more.
I think what I am saying is that in a corporate environment, I want my techs to focus on keeping the business running rather than working on everyones home system, and that free advice for a split second item is fine to give, but for setting up a wireless network with a plethora of other items, that is a different issue whereby stating that "I don't know your situation, so I can't comment" is not misleading or is it avoiding, but respecting them and pointing them in the correct direction.
by dr dij
and those self absorbed doctors who won't diagnose me in the hallway, I hate them.
And those egotistical idiotic auto service co-ordinators at dealers, who tell me to 'bring it in' rather than let me know what's wrong over phone!
It's our fault that we're not teeps and can mystimagically know in the hallway or over the phone what's rong.
The neighborhhods are going to he** because techs want to have their nights and weekends off!
And that person who called my friend over to fix her computer then was not there for two hours is perfectly reasonable, any pc tech whho has a human side should wait for inconsiderate people who use them. After all they exist to fix people's computers.
Now who's missing the human side?
by dr dij
by dr dij
I could say no if they asked me to do something on my own time. If we had a policy not to waste time chit-chatting then I also could say no. And if I was busy, I certainly could say no. Is getting the router working for alot of people at work more important than the directors home PC? Just tell them you've got urgent problem if you don't have time. And since many IT depts are understaffed, this means something is not getting done because they're bothering you.
Carry a notebook, walk fast and look worried, and you'll never be bothered :)
just lose that worried look on the weekend.
by beechbell
by warnerit
I don't know dude, you seem to have kind of a bad attitude. If someone is abusing you, like constantly asking you for business level help and wanting you to come to their business for free, etc. that's one thing. But a little friendly helping out to people you work with or live by is called good PR.
I've been in IT for 12 years and I've seen people with your kind of attitude and they ended up ultimately not getting very far. First people laid off when times got tight, etc.
There's a thing called Quid Pro Quo. You help me and I'll help you. It doesn't always mean money is exchanged. It's more of a barter thing. I happen to live next door to a surgeon and he has many times offered to do things like simple stitches when the kids fall down so we or other neighbors don't have to go to the ER and spend half the day there waiting to get 3 stitches that takes all of 10 minutes. And we in turn help him out with computer stuff or landscaping advice or whatever else our family has expertise in when he needs it. It's not an every day thing. I've also got a guy who owns a custom home building business and also an attorney across the street from me. We all help each other out from time to time with our areas of expertise. No one would expect the attorney to do a divorce or custody battle or something big like that for free, but he certainly doesn't mind giving out 5-10 minutes worth of advice once in a while. I've even gotten referrals for my business from these guys because of helping them out for free in a neighborly way.
Before we owned our own company, spouse and I both gladly helped our co-workers out with home computer questions without charging, and we've gotten some good referrals from them too.
by warnerit
by mgordon
Boss: Certainly you help.
Co-workers: It depends on what is wanted, how long it will take, and what sort of karma you expect.
Family: Generally speaking wise to avoid. The method you use to dodge varies with the person.
Friends: Help.
Here's the reasoning: The instant you touch someone else's computer, YOU become responsible for any failure it experiences for the next unpredictable period of time, but in my experience about 3 months. It is sort of an implied warranty.
Your friends will understand that the computer just died, it's day was up; and not your fault.
Family does not understand. Adjusting the brightness on the monitor just before the hard disk or motherboard dies links you to to the expensive replacement of disk, and motherboard; without compensation and certainly no thanks that five years of documents just vanished.
Co-workers generally also do not understand; if they DID they would have your job. However, there's karma, if you help them *maybe* they will help you. Anyone in the HR department gets mo betta treatment of course :-)
Your boss doesn't need to understand. If the hard disk dies when you touch it, you fix it; but at least you can put it on the company dime.
by schuhmd
I like to think I'm a nice guy. I was the neighborhood IT. Everyone would come to me with their computer problems. And I would help them all. One night the lady next door woke me up to help her fix a printer problem. This was 1:00 am. I helped her as always. A few weeks later my wife was having a hard time breathing. I went over to her house because her hubby is a DR. She told me her Hubby could not be disturbed because he worked late. And I should call 911. This is just one of many responses I have gotten from my neighbors when I needed there help. So now I tell them to call a computer support. And I have become the bad neighbor.
Like someone said no good dead goes unpunished.
....was print up a bunch of business cards with my "home computer consulting" information on it. I then passed them out to everybody who even looked at me twice.
I still get asked for help, but not so much and they always offer to pay me for it.
by sattolico
You should know by now that everyone wants free advice. The funny things is they very often don't use it so ... what do you have to lose? Except a few minutes of your time. You may even build bridges that you may want to use to cross a raging stream later.
Networking is the key and a few well placed help chits will pay back over and over.
If you think you should get paid for the few minutes then tell them to call you at home and what your rate is then step back and watch as word gets around you hard to deal with and a prima-donna.
Have fun.
by thelurch
Y'know you have a friend who absolutly needs your technical support advice for free. He's/She's a professional in another field (of course) and his/her job is dependent on the answers you can give him (or so he/she says)yet, if you were to ask this person for advice, they'd tell you that they can't give out free advice without repercussions. This can be turned around to your advantage.
A friend of mine is a draftsman who decided to go to a flea market and purchase a cheap system to upgrade his own, but his hard drive can't be recognized by the new system. He calls me up via my cell phone and asks me what to do, just as I am in the process of moving to a new place to live, so I tell him I can't talk at that moment.
2 weeks later, he calls me and he still has the problem. Y'think maybe he could have gone to a retail outlet or even the people he purchased the system from? Nope, he expects me to give him free advice. If I were to ask him for free blueprints for a new house, do you think he'd just sit there and draw them up without charging me? I doubt it.
Really, it's because of our experience, technical training, and education that shouldn't give out free advice. That's my stand, and I'm sticking to it.
by wrc it dude
We had an accountant at one stage kept asking for help and expertise with problems that he had caused because the Government is out to get him. I always helped him and all of my colleagues without question.
Then one day when I needed some financial advice, he had the hide to say no problem, should take more that about 2 or 3 hours to sort and the rate is ?100 and hour. I declined.
The next time he had issues with his personal laptop, the only answer possible was shouldn't take more than two hours but the rate is ?150 an hour.
He did get the point immediately but thought the rate was too high, until I explained that I knew exactly how to fix the problem and was he prepared to pay slightly lower rates that will probably twice as due to infamiliarity with his environment?
The point here is that all of my other co-workers I am willing to help, (office machines are an obligation, personal machines good will), as I know they will oblige me with their expertise when I need it.
You will find out soon enough who is taking advantage.
If they are persitant ask them to bring the machine in and leave it sitting for a week or two, if it is that urgent they take it else where because you will obviously be too busy to look at it.
It's funny how most get the point of this as well.
by pccoach
by r&d guy
I found quickly that helping a few causes word of mouth propagation and it quickly escalates to unmanageable proportions.
This required a rule set.
1. Suggest self help. I created some template emails for this purpose.
2. Don't help those who ask for advice/assistance then 'turn brain off' and want hand holding.
3. Enforce the same limits I impose on myself when asking professional friends for advice. Don't allow abuse.
4. In any case enough is enough. I have a full time job and donate assistance of this nature to my church. There are a finite number of hours available. No excuses necessary and if they don't understand this, the problem does not lie in me.
by hodolfo
by mikebytes
by jmiguy
You have absolutely no concept of reality.
Starting right now, I want you to start sending your entire paychecks directly to me. Since you're so willing to work for free, you won't be needing those silly paychecks for anything.
(As a matter of fact, I have some work I need done around the house, why don't you be here at 7:00 AM to get started. If you do real good, I might even give you a beer.)
IT support people get paid to "resolve computer related issues!" Much of this is done over the phone by offering step by step instructions.
Again, "this is what we get paid for!" This is the same kind of "advice" people are looking for. They are not looking for tips, they are looking for a way to get free tech support.
Anyone who thinks differently has no clue what it's like working in a support position. I've had
one individual so rude, he came up to my desk, dropped his home PC on my desk and "told" me to see if I can figure out why it wont boot up.
He never asked if I would mind taking a look, he just assumed I would do it. (I barely knew him) I had another idiot come and interupt me while on a phone call to ask me if I had a CD burner. When I said yes, he handed me an Allman Brothers CD and told me he needed 2 copies right away. This was at work on company time. He demanded me to burn music CD's for him! (I never even seen this person before)
These are the kinds of arrogant, ignorant people we have to deal with, and quite frankly, I have no desire whatsoever to offer these people anything for free - including my respect.
One more point; I keep reading posts about the "joys of sharing knowledge."
Guess what, sharing requires an "exchange" of some sort.
"Giving" knowledge is what they should be saying.
Peace.
by vltiii
by jmiguy
Butcher's sell meat, plumbers fix pipes, hairdresser's cut hair.
Support techs "advise" users on how to resolve their problems.
by etco
by billeger
Assuming a request is for hardware help, my response is a question, "Where did you buy the machine?"
If they know then you tell them they must get their answers from the seller. And to sweeten the reason, mention that working on the machine by you or them could void their warranty.
As you know, that's generally a true statement. If the machine is old or there is no warranty I will have long ago "forgotten how those work."
Software advice? It's to always use the apps that I most want but -- probably -- can't afford. If they have something of lesser quality, it's hard for me "to understand its interface and navigation."
by vltiii
by the admiral
In your case, I would respond that it would be OK for me to drop everything at 1AM to help you with a printer problem, but it is not OK for me to come over at 1AM for something else.
Turnabout is fair play. If they don't like it, you simply have to explain that there was no reciprocating feelings of loyalty to you when you needed something, but you had to be ready to go when they needed something.
That is the only way you can make it clear that they were using you and you did not appreciate it.
by dvadams
I don't mind giving people advice. This "advice" generally presents itself as a tip on where they can find the information for themselves OR a local PC repair shop in town. This, of course, is said in a polite manner.
Generally I will not fix people's problems unless I consider them to be a close friend or family member. Giving out a little advice or some tips, however does not usually take up much of my time. It's not a bad way to build collegiality with co-workers and you never know when you might need some help from one of them (whether at work or otherwise).
Second option: get a t-shirt: http://www.thinkgeek.com/images/products/zoom/will-not-fix.jpg
by vltiii
by martimus
based on my perception of what you've written you are the one who seemingly thinks that all end users are ignorant of technology. In my opinion there are an awful lot of people who understand just enough about computers to be dangerous.
In my opinion the end users deserve to be given a plausible reason rather than placated with mis-information and hyperbole. If you, as a technology resource, cannot or do not want to involve yourself in troubleshooting their problems tell them so. To me telling them that you're unfamiliar with their configuration and any assistance would be a "shot in the dark" is somewhat inaccurate and misleading.
I, for one, try to have a life outside of work. As such many of my evenings are committed to family, friends, and spending time with my dogs. If someone wants me to look at their computer I tell them that my evenings are booked. I'll be happy to look at their computer for them but it'll be when I have time not when they have time. If my availability is not consistant with them then my recommendation is one of many local computer stores.
by the admiral
When I was going through all of the social and psychology classes through college, there was one factor that came up.
No one likes an arrogant smart butt. When you tell them that it is on your terms not theirs, it shows arrogance, so who in the heck would bother asking you later?
I like spending time with my family as well. When someone tells me that they know every configuration of every Personal Computer on the planet, they are full of crap, plain and simple. There are party quirks of every single system out there and a blanket statement saying that something is inaccurate or misleading is avoiding the facts.
The fact of the matter is that there is a correct way of letting someone down by pointing them in the right direction or looking like a jerk. My comments show that you care about the person, and you give them assitance in pointing them in the proper direction to get the help that they need rather than let them hang there until such time as you have time to deal with them.
However, that is your opinion, and since my answer works 100% of the time, I can take my answer from the opinion rack and put it on the policy rack without a guilt trip.
One other thing. I am glad that you agree with me that all end users are ignorant with technology with your statement: "...awful lot of people who understand just enough about computers to be dangerous."
by gtmullins
If they are paying you by the hour to fix the comuter, the more time you talk the longer it takes to fix, so the bill goes up. If your'e being paid by the job, talk only as long as your are working. It makes the time go faster.
Anyways advice is just that, take it or leave it. It's one person's idea.
by brazen1
This is not a matter of saying NO: It is determining the business needs & implications of every request.
BUSINESS ISSUE. Does you company require staff to use home computers for business purposes? If so, is there a company obligation ensure the staffer's computer is compatible/doesn't harm the company's systems? Your management needs to decide the parameters for maintaining offsite, privately owned computers. Some companies do sent IT staff to private homes to help install or troubleshoot connectivity that critical staff have--on billable time. Others let staff to bring in personal 'business' computers for 'tweaking' What's yoor company's policy on using PERSONAL computers for work, and what's their policy for personal computer support?
STAFF TRAINING & MANAGEMENT. I had a staffer who would ramble for hours about how to fix a PC that he'd never set eyes on. That's hours of work on site that he never got done.
a. Have your staff account for their time (maybe even issuing work requests with time in/time out logs) to give them an 'out' when being asked for advice (" I'll be happy to, but I need to log it into the system..." "We need a service request for every computer we work on--can you call XXX and get this request into the queue?" "I can't help you right now, I have XXX service calls to handle." Yes, you become the heavy, but you are, after all, accountable for productivity. Besides, you may be giving your staff just the 'out' they've been dreaming of.
b. More important, ASK YOUR STAFF. I'm guessing you've seen productivity issues, heard gripes about too much work and felt frustration at being sidetracked, or you wouldn't be asking this forum. Once you've established company guidelines, work with your team to collectively establish your departmental guidelines--and the suggestions on this forum are a place to start. This isn't an exercise in navel gazing, its an exercise in working together to solve a problem, develop procedures and refine processes.
3. SELF ANALYSIS. You're a manager; that means you have to manage--yourself, your staff, and the business situation. Sometimes, you'll have to bend the rules, and others you'll have to come down like a sack of wet sand. Sorry, but it goes with the turf.
by nkent
Does anyone remember the original post? That's a lot of replies! This will never be a dead issue!
Part of the original question was a nice way to say no. It doesn't mean they don't want boundaries or don't know where they want them; the requestor wants a gentle way to let the moochers down. One was a partner and some were staff members.
So, I'd go for this:
For the partner, if they are your business partner, I'd give the advice anyway. They're your business partner and you know that it will be reciprocated at some point.
If they aren't your business partner, but rather a partner in the company, then use the same line you could with the staff members. "My time at work is paid for by the company and my work rules do not permit me to work on personal computers on company time. I have very little free time to freelance on computers, but there's a [insert favorite computer store name here] right around the corner and they have the time and expertise to do a good job for you."
It defines your work rules, says you don't have any free time to help them, and still gives them some good advice about where they can get help instead of from you. I've used a similar line several times with good success, even once on a vice president. I'm sure you can tweak it to fit your needs.
Good luck!
by vltiii
by ozziedazza
At work I do not regard this as a problem, as long as it does not take up a lot of time..... The image of IT within the workplace is not served by saying "NO".. Most IT persons are viewed as being rather abrupt and unfriendly and a little bit of helpful advice goes a long way to giving a better image of the IT Dept.
You can always be honest if it is eating into your time and say, "Love to help but I am really busy" or " I am really sorry, but I know nothing or very little about that problem".
However, I always try and help with advice, I do not take on fixing problems from work unless they understand that my time is valuable and as such they have to pay by the hour..(after work hours , in my own home). I used to have the same problem with neighbours until I started telling them that I now charged by the hour (advice and actual hands on).... Genuine problems only now appear at my door with the owners only too willing to pay.
by shelli_2003
I will usually give advice or help out friends and family. The staff members and partner, I would probably say yes but that "I cant right this second, I am so swamped with upgrades (whatever)..etc.. hows next week or the week after?"
Its the new aquaintences that hear you are in IT and start asking questions that I say "Oh is this a PERSONAL computer problem? Windows? Ohhh,Im sorry, if the box doesnt have at least 4 dual-core AMD processors and a Unix based OS Im totally lost..Try Googling the problem"
Works like a charm.
by pka
by smallfred
It seems that this issue is a hot button for a lot of people and the debate ranges from the morality to the differenc between advice and support.
The question is not whether or not they should help or what constitutes advice versus service, but how to say no. Obviously the time and advice being asked for is not something that the original poster is comfortable with.
A few quick thoughts before answering the question, since we are already off topic... Maybe this puts me into the category of the 'not nice' people, but that is not for anyone but me and mine to judge. It is easy to pass judgement and try to stand on moral high ground when you have not been in a position that you felt uncomfortable giving advice in. There are ramifications to taking on the responsibility of giving advice and supporting other peoples things. Regardless of your profession. My husband is a mechanic, he does not take on outside jobs. There is the legal liability if something were to go wrong, not to mention the his time and the tools he has paid unbelievable amounts of money for. When he fixes them in the shop he is covered by the business, then there is the time factor. I want to see him!! We have a deal, I don't take on computer problems outside of work and he does not take on cars (excepting family - of course). And last, his tools, just like the tools a good IT professional collects, are an asset he brings to the table. It is not fair to ask him to use them without compensation. Everyone makes their own deals and lives up to them in there own ways. No one else has a right to pass judgement on those deals. Okay, off my high horse and on to the original post.
There IS a problem with partners asking for advice on their home systems. It could be considered harassment. And is it ethical to spend your time on personal systems while on the company clock? Free was hired to work on the company's systems, not the home systems of the workers, no matter what their rank in the company is.
To make a long story short (too late). The nice way to say no, is just a polite, 'I'm sorry I really don't have the time to discuss your problem and give it the attention it deserves.' If you know of a good tech, recommend them. If not just leave it at that. There is nothing wrong with saying no.
by vltiii
by edeldoug
For me, dealing with free support is easy...
I have been running a part-time home based computer services business on the side since 1996. When co-workers or friends ask me for help, I'm willing to share some free friendly conversation for a couple minutes... If I can give them a quick fix in 2-3 sentences, I'll often do so. But if they want real help; diagnosis, instructions for a fix, suggestions and recommendations; I simply offer them my business card and tell them to give me a call to set up an appointment to look at it!
by knightheart
by knightheart
by knightheart
If you're still fixing his system after he's screwed you out of things he said he'd do for you, you may as well tatoo "sucker" on your forehead and kiss his feet thanking him for giving you the opportunity to suck up to him.
If his wife thinks she knows more, let her fix the problem. If they won't finish the work they agreed to do for you, refuse to fix their problems. If you want to keep being a doormat, go ahead, but don't complain about it.
by gqd2001
Doctor's charges are included with your Canadian citizenship.
But I do agree that we should be compensated for out of office IT support.
by jen
If it takes more than two minutes to "give IT advise" (as in you are talking to them, no action on your part) or whatever you want to call it, then tell them your per hour rate or hand them your rate sheet for your services.
If you have to do any action within that two minutes, then you better get a beer or another reward. If your action goes beyond two minutes, hand them your rate sheet.
The good doctor will not fix a broken arm for free and without special equipment needed to correctly treat the condition (which costs money) when someone asked his advice. However, the doctor appropriately referred them to the ER. If the child's arm was just bruised, then the doctor would have probably recommended a fix that any ordinary person could administer with some ice and such advice could be given in less than two minutes and would let the person inquiring to perform the remedy. Same for IT.
If the person is a close acquaintance, friend or family, sometimes bartering for a similar value task that they can "help" or do for you that you could not do on your own is a good way to trade skills and knowledge. (Trade one hour of tech support for mowing your four acre yard from your college aged nephew, or get your leaking main water line valve fixed from your licensed plumber cousin) Then, you don't feel taken advantage of, you are adding value to their skill-sets as well, and you get something taken care of that would have normally cost you the same amount that you would have received for one hour of your time.
by vltiii
You're making a stretch with your analogy between ITs and Drs. Ultimately, the loss of time or data because of bad IT advice pales in comparison to loss of life and limb because of bad medical advice. Drs. are required to carry malpractice insurance for a reason. I'm not aware of any such requirement to ensure compensation because of a "moron" IT. Protections may be provided for in the contract, but that's a negotiation issue-not required by law.
I would like to think that some of our relationships at work develop beyond the professional. Even when they don't I would think that we would want to at least maintain a professional relationship. My guess is that anyone that ask for advice at work that is not work related does so because they have a certain level of comfort in doing so (rationally speaking). In the end it doesn't really matter. As someone else posted (or maybe it was me), I don't know why this question was even posted. The poster (and any of us) have free will to give the advice or not. As evidenced by the range of responses, all of us have a level that we're comfortable with. Some are more willing to help out their fellow man than others without expecting anything in return. Once the situation gets outside of our level of comfort we can shut it down. If the poster is afraid to do so, then he will have to deal with the constant request without complaint.
Lastly, why do you imply that someone who received their education at National University is less qualified than anyone else? I don't know much about Microskills, but their commercials and the fact that their name implies a connection with Microsoft (in my opinion) does make me somewhat leary.
by vltiii
by matt.werner
Several of my family members are physicians. You are incorrect in stating that malpractice insurance is required. It is not. In fact, for some high risk procedures, the coverages provided are not enough relative to the cost of premiums and doctors either self insure or cease to perform the risky procedure. For example, many OB/GYN's no longer deliver babies due to the high cost of malpractice insurance.
Furthermore, IT and Medicine are indeed similar. Both require complex diagnosis and prescription to solve technical problems. Granted, computer systems mistakes generally do not involve life or limb (although some do, e.g. medical devices). However, IT negligence can cost thousands of dollars (or more) in damages and it is prudent for IT service providers to carry insurance to cover this.
by edeldoug
I received an email from a TechRepublic member who read my previous posting... ASKING for free advice. In this case, I not only gave the advice... I'm going to post it here too. Hope it helps someone.
Q: "I was reading the tech thread about asking for free pc advice. I am a tech as well. Well I am about to ask you for some free 2-3 minute advice.
I live in NY State. I would also like to start my own part time computer business. I am not sure where to start. Would you mind giving me some pointers on how you have made a success of your part time business?"
A: Best advice I can give in a couple bullet points:
1) KNOW your stuff. Be prepared for ANYTHING. Realize that most computer users know nothing more than how to turn it on and move a mouse. Be ready and able to inspire confidence. Don't talk GeekSpeak. It is important to speak fluent 3rd grade English, even if it is as a 2nd language!
2) Be flexible and available. If you're putting yourself out there as a PC doc, you're on call 24/7/365. You will get panic calls at night, on weekends, on holidays. If you can't immediately respond, you need to be able to settle the customer down until you can get to it.
3) Target your advertising. Don't spend a fortune on a metropolitan radio ad if you only service within 3 zipcodes! Don't buy a tiny ad in a big paper that'll never get seen on page D-11. Go where your customers are. Buy an ad in your own church directory - you'll get calls from people you see every week... who never knew you were a compugeek. Local/regional Journals are a good bet IF they get a high percentage readership. If they simply lay on the lawn till they're tossed in the trash, why spend $ on them.
4) USE word of mouth. When you finish with a customer's call, leave them SEVERAL business cards and ask them to share them with their friends.
5) Your personal vehicle can be a rolling mobile advertisement. Consider a rear-window graphic with your business name & phone #. You never know who might notice it.
(Hey, this is pretty good. I ought to post it!)
Doug Edelman
by emmanemms
by emmanemms
by emmanemms
by moucon
Nobody is asking you to come over and work for free... they're asking for a little help. These are *marketing opportunities* for you - get off the pedestal. I moderate a couple of online communities for "free" as well as jumping in whenever someone in the physical world needs a little advice- but thing is, you get back what you sow. This is the stuff that keeps me in business. Good thing you have a job at a company because you wouldn't make it five minutes if you were out on your own.
PS - EVERYONE with any kind of a professional or trade position has probably gone to school, spent "thousands of dollars" and/or been out there in the school of hard knocks paying their dues. What the heck makes you king ?
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by wmarr
Ok,since you are getting paid for IT services, and your co-workers want "free" services, they had better shop elsewheres.
Here is an example of one of my favourite responses. "Seems you might have a bug AKA virus of some sort. Can't say for sure until I get your computer on my work bench. I usually charge (price per hour) but I can give you a break on that if it is something serious.)Just send your computer to me and I will gladly check it out."
That usually works, and anyone willing to pay for your time will get you to fix it and pay you. The break?? No break, how do they know how long it will take to fix. I usually use my hourly rate as a benchmark, and then tell them what the total bill is once it is fixed. But try to be reasonable, after all they are your co-workers.
by vltiii
by mgelezov
"As an IT Adminstrator I get a lot of staff members asking for advice on their home computers.
What will be a nice way to say "No" to free advice." It was an initial question
My answer (and my opinion) is:
Do some work by yourself first, then come to me and ask me where to find an information. And i will tell where to find it. If you want to get something without any work done by yourself - pay me, and I will do it for you.
I do not see any snobism in here and I do not see any disrespect to my trade. Any work has to be paid.
by vltiii
by vltiii
by unix_guy
Well done, Alacrity!
Yours is the best, most professional approach I have seen.
New problem: how do you address emergencies (I have a virus and need it eliminated now)? Do you explain that there will be a charge, or do you negotiate later?
by mgelezov
At least it is eliminate more than 50% of
requests to fix this or that.
by gary.woodman
I wish I could say that. But everyone knows I do "do" Windows. Thanks Bill, it's been a pretty stable career for 20 years now, following you around tidying up your doo-doos.
I *do* say "I don't have a Windows CD". It's true, too. People who have character weaknesses that cause them to wreck Windows systems really need a Mac, or a PC with Linux (or a typewriter). I give away Linux CDs :-) People I help, in or out of work, get my standard rant about how they're not doing themselves any favours by sticking with Windows, that this will happen again, that there are villains out there on the Net attacking their systems as we speak, that they're fodder for the upgrade mill.
PCs are too complicated. Even the normal care and feeding required to keep Windows functional is rocket science to most people. I'm disinclined to be a self-appointed (and largely unpaid) MS support dude. People who *really* want my help, as distinct from a cut-and-shut repair, will be changing to Linux. I do that for free :-)
Gary
by vltiii
To consider someone asking for advice, free or otherwise as being rude is a matter of personal judgment. I personally think to withhold information that can help another is rude, except in extreme cases. Most of us that consider ourselves decent human beings are more than willing to help another human being. It's that I have all the information and I'm going to keep it to myself mentality that (in my opinion) set so many up for failure, and to the same extent I think it's borne out of some sort of insecurity... If I share this information I won't be needed, or I can be replaced.
It's a sad commentary of where we are as a society when people are only willing to help another if they think there is something (material) to be gained. I don't see how we as individuals can be harmed or damaged by helping another. Of course there are times when helping is just not practical for whatever reason, but to adopt that philosophy as a general rule is truly sad.
by vltiii
If anyone is using awww come, you should question this individuals maturity level and/or what it is about you that makes them feel this approach will work. Pick one.
Yes it demonstrates poor work ethics to bring a personal computer to work assuming that there is not a pre-arrangement with management to do so, but to say that asking a question demonstrates poor ethics is a stretch. Anyone that truly believes this should consider taking courses in organizational behavior. Granted our employers pay us to perform our jobs, but anyone in the work force knows (or should know) that there are some behaviors/actions that "most" employers don't have a problem with in the interest of maintaining a decent quality of life and harmonious work environment. Using your perception, it would be unethical to call your spouse using the company's phone to tell him/her that you'll be working late. It's the employers phone and the employers phone bill, but you'd be hard pressed to find one that had a problem with that.
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by vltiii
by tape monkey
1. Is it plugged in?
2. Do you just install something new?
3. Is the item causing the issue under warranty?
4. Did you contact the mfg help desk or go to their web site?
This will hold them off for at least a day.
Next time you see them ask them if they are still having issues if so then ... tell them: If you have done these things and still don't have a solution to your issue.
Then I will be happy to give you a box of clues so you can troubleshoot it yourself.
It only take 3 minutes to be polite and no feelings are ever hurt. They have usually found or fixed the problem themselves.
by vltiii
You know that's all well and good. Until... the boss gets wind that your doing outside work at HIS EMPLOY, or that co-worker returns a gazillion times because, he/she cannot/refuses to learn the proper techniques of using a computer. Or my very favorite, there is always one individual that FINDS an old a@# computer and wants to re-vamp it, by adding FOUND spare parts or desiring to install old antiquated software. This is the person we ALL dread... the cheapskate, the swindler, the aggrevatingly over zealous self-taught computer tech. When he/she can't figure it out, they warm up to you, siting how great you are, how much you know, that your the "Computer Guru". I tell them, buy a new one, it's cheaper; while there pick up a nice anti-virus and spyware package and keep it up-to-date.
Now on the other hand a 5 minute lesson, or advice is fine, no matter who you are. It's okay to be kind, just don't allow ANYONE to use you.
Do'll do fine, it does get easier to say no.
by vltiii
You said "You know that's all well and good. Until... the boss gets wind that your doing outside work at HIS EMPLOY, or that co-worker returns a gazillion times because, he/she cannot/refuses to learn the proper techniques of using a computer. Or my very favorite, there is always one individual that FINDS an old a@# computer and wants to re-vamp it, by adding FOUND spare parts or desiring to install old antiquated software. This is the person we ALL dread... the cheapskate, the swindler, the aggrevatingly over zealous self-taught computer tech. When he/she can't figure it out, they warm up to you, siting how great you are, how much you know, that your the "Computer Guru". I tell them, buy a new one, it's cheaper; while there pick up a nice anti-virus and spyware package and keep it up-to-date.
Now on the other hand a 5 minute lesson, or advice is fine, no matter who you are. It's okay to be kind, just don't allow ANYONE to use you.
Do'll do fine, it does get easier to say no."
Let's not take this to the level of being absurd. Of course this has to be tempered with professional requirements and what we're actually being paid for. My response was based on the ability and availability to actually accomplish the assistance.
by vltiii
by vltiii
Now you're playing semantics. I think most everyone here knows what is meant/intended by use of the word advice. Giving a literal definition doesn't change that in the least.
As for the people that you choose to call friend, I'm sorry to hear that. Anyone that I would call friend would never put me in such a position, and when they do ask for advice, they (not me) usually qualify it with when you get a chance, can you...???
by trailer
by ramrod
by psicotronica
Hi, fellow IT professionals,
How do I understand your complains.
But, as someone stated, money is not everything. Competence recognition is always welcomed. If people asks you for an advice is because they think or recognize you have competence in the matter. (at least, more than they have?)
I do spend lots of money in training. Despite that, I am always polite with anyone who asks a question or request an advice. Even my competitors!
But an advice is an advice, and giving some clues is sometimes acceptable; solving the problem for free is not! I usually answer ?I do not compete with my own business! It would be a lack of loyalty.?
Comments invited.
fsc
by somebozo
well depends on advice they need.. simple what to buy and what not to buy is ok.. sugessting a solution to some of their touble is ok.. i am considered the centre of technological evolution when it comes to shopping of electronics, wether they are friends, teachers, co-workers, friends of the friends, neighbours, blah blah blah..u name it... i would even support some users or fix other people computers, heck i even support a small business and an internet cafe for free.. it all contributes to my knowledge.. i enjoy the respect and previlliage i get.. what is the most annoying part is when someone nags me to teach them ISA, exchange, or simply anything. what am i .. a friggin teacher.. no.. i spend thousand of bux and hours in keeping myself updated and learning new skills and i am not goin to tranfer my skills for free.. u want to learn something.. go to a book store.. buy a DIY book and learn in.. i hate teaching...
what sucks more as mentiond by some here, is that when people are ungrateful and whine about paying for a part needed to fix their pc.. what the heck im suppose to do.. pay it off my pocket.. NO..i rather burn down ur pc..
But yes u should keep your guideline and who so ever wants the favour from u must be compling to your guideline. Do not call me during my work hours and do not nag me when i tell u i am busy right now and cant talk. Dont ask me the same thing over and over. Finally search the internet (google is your friend) before you ask me little things.
and if u r a chick sitting in star bucks and cant get ur wifi get working to access the internet, i will not come to the site and set it up for u.. even if u send me ur sheaffer and mercedes and offer me $$$...(belive me this happend with me)
by tonez1
Sort by Trending