Discussion Locked

SCSI versus IDE hard drives

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I would like to hear your opinions as to the pros and cons of these two types of HDD.

My understanding was that SCSI drives run faster than IDE drives. However the only Windows computer I have that uses a SCSI HDD runs very slowly. Perhaps this is a software issue, but it seems to respond very slowly to various commands, and especially when downloading web pages.

And no, there are no viruses present.

6 replies

by oz_media

Hi Julian, yes in fact SCSI drives DO transfer data much faster than IDE connections.

Reasons your SCSI drive me be slower include NO SCSI controller, SCSI is not supported by most 'retail' systems and requires SCSI controller cards to be added. If it DOES have SCSI contollers it may not be supported by the BIOS.

SCSI controllers provide the ROM chip/BIOS themselves and don't rely on the mobo. Mobo based SCSI support is generally found in mid to high end desktops.

As for your PC being slow on the Internet and when viewing webpages, this would probably be spyware or a downloader virus hiding somewhere, Temp and Cookie overabundance.

You'd be best off calling Colin for a quick walkthrough the hardware and connection tests first. THen a thorough cleaning, for aware, temp internet files, virus, defrag etc.

This really doesn't sound like a hard drive controller issue though.

Clean up and if you haven't tried Firefox yet, try it out and you can forget IE's problems once and for all.

Good luck
OM

by thechas

Hi Julian,

Your question depends somewhat on what level of SCSI you are comparing to what level of IDE.

Still, generally speaking, a SCSI drive will outperform an IDE drive.

If you compare an older SCSI drive with the newest IDE drives, the speed difference is not much.

The primary disadvantage of SCSI drives are cost and availability.

As far as the slow response of your system, there are many factors to consider.
First is the age and type of SCSI card you have.
Next, is the rest of your hardware.
What CPU, amount of RAM, bus speeds, cache, all impact system speed.

This is your W98 system, correct?

If you have not done so, open system properties and on the performance tab, change your system type to network server. This changes the way that W98 handles file transfers from the hard drive and can speed things up a bit.

Another big issue with Windows 95, 98 and Me is registry bloat.
The longer since Windows was last installed, the slower the PC runs. The more software and updates you install and remove, the faster the registry grows in size.
There seems to be a maximum functional size for the registry on most systems. Once your registry files grow larger than this mystical limit, the system slows down.
It can be amazing how much faster a system will run when you format the hard drive and start over again.

Another issue I have seen with W98 is compatibility issues with the video drivers and IE6 / DirectX8 and 9.
If your video driver does not support DirectX9, I recommend against installing IE 6 or above.

There are a number of good tips posted at www.onecomputerguy.com
While they could be organized better, Bob has a pretty good list of tips for all versions of Windows.

As to web pages, there are a lot of things that effect the time it takes a page to load.
The TR All Questions link is one of the slowest loading web pages I regularly visit.

Chas

by thechas

Got your message.

Yes, installing extra hardware on some cases, and in Windows can be a pain.

Short of a clean installation of Windows, you can get some performance improvement by using a registry cleaner and registry defragmenter.

I prefer Fit-It from V-Com www.v-com.com

Norton Win Doctor also does a decent job.

System Mechanic has gotten good reviews, but I have not used it myself.

There are a few free-ware registry tools available.
However, I have not used any of them either.

Chas

This discussion is closed to new replies.