Discussion Locked

sdram ecc

0 helpful
9 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have a Dell pentium II/ 233 with a 64 mb sdram with ecc. I would like to install 256 mb without ecc. Will I have any conflicts if I leave the 64 mb sdram with ecc. in the computer and will this ram be used by the computer ? Do I have to take out the 64 mb with ecc ? I am getting different answers from different people. Thank you very much.
Boris

9 replies

by bigduck

No you should not mix ECC RAM with other types. It will cause major problems. More so if you are useing a Windows based OS. Another point. If this is a machine running Win 95 or 98 you are wasting your money. WIN9x will only use 64 MB of RAM at the OS level. Certain applications will use more i.e. graphics programs, but for the most part any memory over 64 MB in a WIN9x system is just wasted.

by dmiles

Mixing memory will cause errors in some systems and is not recommended,but if you are buying 256m,you can install it and test the system with it a couple of days,it may not be apperent right-off,check your motherboard manual for instructions on adding memory.

by danpiers

First of all, your system only addresses (writes to or reads from) one DIMM at a time. So, as far as your system is concerned, there can be no conflict between the DIMMs because it never sees them both at the same instant. The more important issue can be answered by you motherboard manufacturer. Does it supoport both types of memory. If it can, and the company makes no mention about mixing the two, then the odds are you should have no problems mixing the memory.
As always, there is a possibility that two different brands of memory can be incompatible for other reasons, even if they are the exact same type of memory. I have seen different brands of ecc memory work individually in a system but not together. But, more importantly, I have seen ecc and non-ecc mixed on the same system with no apparent problems.
If, for some reason, the two DIMMs aren't compatible, I would still recommend getting the 256MB DIMM and sell the 64MB. Good luck.

by thedrummer2006

Ive always had bad luck with mixing different types of RAM. You take a chance at decreasing your system performance by doing it. However I dont totally disagree with BigDuck I do disagree partially. Hes right about the 64 meg deal but if you are a gamer the more memory the better because your hard drive can load more of the game into memory which is alot faster and this can also take a load off of your 3d accelerator. Im a big gamer and I went from 64mb to 256mb and noticed a huge difference inmy gaming and Multitasking.

Hope this helped

This discussion is closed to new replies.