Discussion Locked

server vs standard motherboard

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
A co-worker claims that the architecture of a intel server motherboard is exacly the same as a standard intel motherboard. I belevie that they are engineered differenly. Who's correct?

8 replies

by thechas

It depends on what you mean by architecture.

At a very basic level, all motherboards are the same.
That is, there is a data bus that links the CPU to the RAM the chipset, and the varius I/O busses.

From there, there are differences.
Intel's entry level server board is a soupped up P4 motherboard with a special version of the 845 chipset.
The main difference here is that the IDE controller supports RAID, and there are built-in server busses.

When you get to the higher level server motherboards, you move to a different CPU design and chipset.
At this point, while the "core architecture" is essentially the same as a standard motherboard, everything is optimized for server functions.
You have a built in SCSI controller in place of the IDE controller.
Dual processor support is common, if not standard.
The data buss is specifically designed for server interface to a network.

Now, you can use a standard desktop board as a server if your network is small, or the data transfer requirements are limited.

Chas

by cg it

Somewhere I read a tech writeup [I think it was on overclocker cafe or planethardware] where performance measurments were taken on a "standard" motherboard [one someone would buy to build their own home system]with IDE & RAID and SCSI & RAID with single and a dual processors.They found out was that there wasn't much difference in overall system performance between the two until you got into file servers, email servers, clustered servers, and distributed processing. Then the dual processor server setup outpaced the single processor setup almost 3 to 1. As TheChas said, there isn't much difference in basic board architecture & desgn between the two. The computer industry is rampant with bells and whistles they try to get the general public to buy when they do nothing for overall computer performance. Items like registered memory vs non registered memory Error correction memory vs non error correcting, buffered, unbuffered, memory heatsinks, chipset cooler fans, RAID controllers [i've yet to meet a home user who runs either striped or mirrored drives and knows what RAID really is used for[usually they have a 80 GB HD with no partition] ,the new 8X AGP which really doesn't do much over the 4X AGP [see www.bjorn.com article] so on andso forth. What you will find with server boards is that they lack a built in sound card, built in graphics card, CD audio, Modem & Aux in headers, possibly and AGP slot as AGP is really a gamers thing and really not necessary for corporate workstations or servers [unless the tech sneaks in some games to play at midnight]. Its a nuts and bots board.

by cg it

As I said, the general public knows pratically nothing about computers and computer manufacturers and retailers take advantage of that in the earnest endeavor of making $$. Plus, there is SO much information available about computers, software, operating system, etc it can be intimidating to someone to read and learn who really only wants to just turn the damn thing on and surf the web, watch a movie, send email, or chat with friends, without any problems [like turning on their TV set] which isprobably where the computer industry in general [microsoft in particular] is leading the computer industry towards.

by dcosgrove

It seems that nowadays workstation boards and server boards havge a lot of overlap in technology. I have always comsidered a server board to have onboard SCSI and be multi processor capable. In a very general sense, your coworker could be correct considering the modular aspect of mother boards. You have a series of chips that control processor, memory, ide, video, audio, lan etc. It is the combination of these modules that creates a server board, not any one specific module. Also, as stated in aswer one, there are different degrees of quality in particular "chipsets" I810 and I815 control the same chips, but are not the same in quality. True sever boards should use the most reliable modules for there specific functions, they may also have more a more stable bios capable of more functions than a standard bios.

This discussion is closed to new replies.