Be careful with this. I have 6 computers at home, and the only way I could get everything to work and accomplish this was by persistance.
1) I purchased Nero 5.0 (which does upgrade to 5.5)
2) I purchased Pyro (Cakewalk's software for editing MP3, and recording, etc.)
My computers are:
Intel PII 550MHz - Win98SE
Intel PIV 2 GHz - Win2000 Pro
Intel PII 400MHz - WinNT
AMD K6 350 MHz - Win98SE
Intel P 150MHz - Win98SE
The only sound card that would work with my old record playerwas the Pentium 150 -- the oldest computer in the lot. The other computers would not work with the Sound Cards.
Please understand that the P150 has a Sound Blaster Pro, the other computers have Creative's Sound Blaster Live Value and SB with 16 bit emulation.
Cakewalk's Pryo worked with all the computers, but there was no sound on anything except the Pentium computer. I ended up doing the recording on the Pentium --> and transferring the results to other computers to do the editing andfinal copying to CDR.
----------
I suspect that part of the problem was a resource allocation issue... but since I got everything done satisfactory, I did not pursue it.
But I recommend that you not "overload" your computer with other deviceswhen doing the recording. For instance, my other computers have CD ROM drives (the pentium does not), they all have nics, but the computers that wouldn't record also have CD-ROM, CD-RW, and Scanner, Camera hardware installed.
Basically, I'm saying, if you have a lot of hardware devices, disable some of them before trying the whole route here. I think you should be fine with any Sound Blaster card and any of the software out there to accomplish this task. It's just a matter of getting all the hardware to behave properly when resources are scarce.