Discussion Locked

Tasers, should the Police have them?

0 helpful
109 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

109 replies

by jdclyde

it would be easy to get half this conversation and see people as advocating the abuse and punishment by cops.

I respect what it is cops do for us, or at least try to do for us. They do a hard job without a lot of pay, and never know if today they won't come home from work.

I have gone over this with my boys, on if they EVER get pulled over.
Get your liscense and registration out before the cop gets up to your car.
Have your dome light off.
Shut your car off.
Keep BOTH hands out in the open, preferably on the steering wheel in a way that is clear your not holding a weapon.
Have your window rolled down.
If you have to reach for something, tell the cop what your doing and then do it slowly and in plain sight.

I believe there are bad cops, but I also believe they are in the minority.

Man, would I have fun with a taser though..... ]:)

by jamesrl

When rolling it out in Toronto (only to superverisors/sargeants/emergency task force BTW), they have an all day training session.

One of the things they do is taser each participant. Its a very effective technique to teach the physical effects of the device.

As Oz has pointed out, its usually not the taser itself that is the problem, its how the tasered person is treated afterwards.

James

by jdclyde

I have seen it too many times, especially with security at smaller venues. It looks like they trolled the local Powerhouse gym or something, just looking for big guys to stand there looking tough.

Many of these guys are walking egos, and I have seen people like that make things worse instead of better. Many of the bar bouncers are the same way.

A few years back there was a guy killed in the region by the bouncers. Got him in a headlock and broke his wind pipe. The thought he "passed out" from the headlock, and lay there dead for about an hour.

Training, retraining, and self-policing to keep each other in check and keep everyone cool. Just like the parenting advice, never spank a child while your mad. It isn't about you and how you feel, or it isn't punishment, it is revenge.

by nentech

They were wrong if the person dies

Same with permeant injuries
Brain injuries
Paralysis
Heart attack

Somewhere you have to draw the line

Unfortunately the taser allows bad cops to torture someone
While leaving them with almost zero visible injuries

Which makes law enforcement attractive employment for sadists

From what I have read in this discussion some people think the cops should be able to do what ever the hell they want to subdue someone
And for any reason they bloody well like
Including having a bad day

After all death is the ultimate form of resistance
Those stiffs will not do as they are told
Better zap em again
Still resisting
Zap em again

And if you still don?t get it jdclyde
Tell me what you think is too much force

Can make it multi choice

Lets start with

a. Death
b. Brain death
c. Paralysis
d. Any others you can add

Col

by ontheropes

http://www.statesman.com/news/mplayer/other/32386

Better have your license, proof of insurance and registration ready to show in a hurry. I timed it as roughly 40 seconds from the cop asking for them until the driver was tasered.

In my mind that cop should have been fired, had his ass kicked and then face criminal charges.

One of the bad parts about watching these types of videos is that there's often no follow-up story. For all I know that cop got a commendation.

by techexec2

.
There must be more to this story. Something is very wrong here. Not having a license plate is odd. Driver not responding a little more quickly is odd. Officer being so ridiculously aggressive, and provocative, and having absolutely no politeness, professionalism, nor patience is very odd.

Personally, I always have both documents at the ready in my wallet. But, I could easily take a few seconds to produce them!

Timeline:

0:00 Officer arrives at car. "Corporal (inaudible) with the Austin Police Department. Let me see your drivers license and proof of insurance. You were going 70 in a 65 mile per hour zone. You've got a license plate on the front of your car, but no license plate on the rear of your car. Let me see your drivers license and proof of insurance!" Driver appears to be fumbling for the documents.

0:12 Officer takes one breath's break in speaking. Then he continues...

0:13 Officer yells loudly at driver: "Let me see your drivers license and proof of insurance!" Driver still fumbling.

0:15 Driver speaks for the first time: "Whoa, whoa, whoa. Let me get it!" Driver appears to be trying to comply.

0:17 Officer: "No! Not, 'whoa, whoa, whoa.' Drivers license and insurance or get out of the vehicle.

0:21 Female passenger to driver: "Ok (inaudible). Give him the license".

0:23 Driver to passenger: "No, this guy's sitting here yelling at me for whatever reason...". Driver appears to be just stunned at the officer's behavior and is now a little bit rebellious (and understandably so...).

0:26 Officer decides to arrest the driver. He opens the car door and says: "Step out of the vehicle"

0:28 Driver: "I have no idea why you are acting..."

0:31 Officer interrupts yelling loudly and orders: "Step out of the vehicle! Take your seat belt off, step out of the vehicle and give me your drivers license and proof of insurance!"

0:32 Driver trying to speak to the officer. Again: "I have no idea why you are acting..." but officer is talking over him.

0:37 Driver is out of car and is standing.

0:38 Officer yells orders: "Get to the back of the vehicle, put your hands on the vehicle. Get to the back of the vehicle."

0:40 Driver appears to be just stunned at the officer's behavior and just stands there. Officer continues yelling and pushes him.

0:44 Officer tasers the driver and he falls to the ground.

Happy Thanksgiving! :0

P.S.

1. There has GOT to be more to this story!

2. This is not a taser problem. There is something wrong with this officer. It's lucky he had the taser! He might have used a nightstick or a gun instead. :0

3. I've seen a police officer act completely unreasonable like this before (years ago, before tasers). However, the vast majority are professional and respond like human beings.

by ontheropes

The officer acted like something out of a nightmare. Usually when people are pulled over they're already shook up and need a few seconds to get their ... act together but for crying out loud the officer chose to escalate the situation almost immediately. He acted just like that guy I told you about that used to work with me.

If I had any authority at all over that officer I'd strongly consider going to the DA and pressing charges. Based solely upon what I saw that kind of behavior is unconscionable police brutality. If a cop ever did something like that to me I'd have their videotape in front of a jury suing for everything I could. I expect I'd win too.

I for one am not allowing myself to be "conditoned" to accept that type of police behavior. It's just flat out wrong. It's not how you treat people. Believe me, in theory there are a few people that I'd love to have on the pointy end of a taser but really, I have to think of the kind of person that would make me. I don't want to be someone that would use a taser but for extreme situations. My waiting a few minutes for someone to get their "documents" in order doesn't constitute an extreme situation.

I find that cops behavior totally inexcusable. Totally. He gives all law enforcement officers a "black eye". I hope he lost his shirt and his job in a legal battle.

by techexec2

.
I don't disagree with you at all. I'm with you on this.

Good officers need our full support. Bad officers like that guy should be fired and never have another police job again. But, misuse of the taser is not the reason. That officer is a dangerously bad cop. He is a danger to the public, to himself, and to his fellow officers.

As far as criminal prosecution goes, the problem with taser misuse is there is no statutory law covering tasers. I think this is part of what needs to change.

As far as a civil case goes, unlike an unjustified police shooting or police nightstick beating, there just isn't that much real damage with the taser (except in the rare case where someone dies). A civil lawsuit has to sue for monetary damages. What damages? The only real monetary "pain" a jury could inflict on the city would be punitive damages. If that ever did happen, things would change all across the country. That guy in Utah has filed such a lawsuit.

I think that the only prosecution that might be applicable is a Federal civil rights lawsuit. Maybe.

[b]How this played out[/b]

I found some information about how this played out (1)(2)(3)(4)(5)(6). There is NOT more to this story! It's just a really poor cop who was out of line.

** The driver was charged with "Failing to obey a lawful order". Charges were dropped. Good thing. It was clearly an unjustified arrest and there was strong evidence supporting that on the video tape.

** The officer's immediate supervisor and an Internal Affairs investigation (in March 2007, 4 months later) saw no reason for disciplinary action! :0

** The IAD interview is very disturbing (5). This officer says he thought this should be a simple stop, 5 minutes, citation issued, and they would both be on their way. But, he also claims to have suspected the car was stolen because it did not have plates. And, he claims he suspected the driver had something to hide because he did not produce his license within mere seconds. His story is falling all over itself. The officer was already yelling loudly and strongly at the driver within 13 seconds after arriving at the car! If the officer is lying to protect is ass, this is very disturbing. It's even worse if he actually believes he is telling the truth!

** The acting Police Chief reviewed the case and gave the officer a 3-day suspension in May 2007, 6 months later. Bravo! Good for her! He served it and was reinstated. But, two words: Not enough.

** Immediately upon taking the job, a new Police Chief reviewed the video and made every officer view it as an example of unacceptable behavior (4). Now THAT is a dressing down! My guess: There must have been serious civilian pressure on the police department and pressure to remove tasers from the Austin police. Why else would he do this immediately upon taking the job?

** After viewing the video, various officers wanted to make personal apologies to the citizen driver and wanted to meet with him. (Most police officers are the good guys!) No mention of the actual meeting in the article (2)(3). Note date: 10 months later.

** The female passenger ... was the driver's MOTHER! The driver's cousin was in the back seat. They were on their way to Thanksgiving dinner.

** The officer has been suspended three times. He ranks second among all Austin officers in "use of force" reports.

** The officer made a big deal about the license plate. The rear license plate was in the inside the car at the back window. The car was recently purchased.

** This is the first time this officer had ever used a taser on a suspect (his claim to IAD under oath).

** The officer has a medical condition that makes him "edgy" when he doesn't eat regularly (my guess: diabetes). He was overdue for lunch that day because they were short on officers (Thanksgiving). It was after 1:00 pm.

[b]This is similar to the Utah case[/b]

This case had a lot in common with the one in Utah: Poor cop.

** Lack of patience.

** Lack of professionalism.

** Lack of compassion.

** Lack of humanity.

** Lack of complete honesty and candor. Note his inaccurate and disturbing recount of the incident during the IAD investigation (5).

[b]Epilogue[/b]

In the end, the Austin PD officials appear to have done at least some of the right thing in following up on this. However, it is unclear how much there were pushed into doing so. It did take them a long time. I like the new police chief's video admonishing his officers to think about their behavior. But, it reminded me of the video I remember seeing when the L.A. police chief did something similar after the Rodney King beating in Los Angeles. Politically correct, but too little and too late for Rodney.

The Austin PD also appears to have good policies about how officers are supposed to conduct themselves. Are they enforced strongly enough to prevent abuses of honest citizens from happening? Apparently not.

There has been a lot of publicity about alleged taser misuse lately. The FBI is investigating one case I read about last week where a pregnant woman was tased in the neck while lying on her stomach, with a male offier on her back in complete control of her. So, it appears the good guys are working on fixing this problem. I hope so.

------------------------------------

(1) From officer's order to Taser: 45 seconds
http://www.statesman.com/news/content/news/stories/local/09/30/0930video.html?cxntlid=inform

(2) Apologies help boost police credibility
October 2, 2007 - over 10 months later
http://www.statesman.com/blogs/content/shared-gen/blogs/austin/editorial/entries/2007/10/02/apologies_help_boost_police_cr.html

(3) Some officers wish to apologize for use of Taser
http://www.statesman.com/news/content/news/stories/local/10/02/1002video.html?cxntlid=inform

(4) New police chief uses this as a bad example to entire department
http://www.statesman.com/news/mplayer/m/32387

(5) Officer's statements to Internal Affairs
http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/statesman/pdf/09/0930video_affidavit.pdf

(6) Officer's letter to the police chief who suspended him
http://alt.coxnewsweb.com/statesman/pdf/09/0930video_memo.pdf

by ontheropes

What's even worse is that Cpl. O'Conner is number 2 in excessive use of force. Number 1 must be a real prize. Perhaps there's a competition and the Chief's got money down on O'Conner so had to keep him around.

All joking aside I can't say that I'm too surprised at how it turned out. Departments often side with the officer. It's too bad that there wasn't more of an uproar made by the citizens of Austin. It's my opinion that cops like Cpl. O'Conner should be fired but there may be legal repercussions in Texas against doing that.

Thanks for looking all of that up. Great post.

This discussion is closed to new replies.