Discussion Locked

Telecommute - ALL companies should be required to have a program

0 helpful
28 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Forever in my past, I commuted to work. Sometimes 25mins, sometimes 2 1/2hrs. 3 years ago I went full time (for the most part) telecommute. I could not believe how much more I could get done! It was amazing and perfect. Then, of course, some idiot at corp desides that we need to go back to the 1970's. WHAT A MORON. Oh my god, I HATED IT.
My productivity dropped in half, I was cranky all the time and just plain miserable.
Within a year, I left. I cannot believe that these idiots ever go anywhere in their career. GROW UP - EVERY COMPANY NEEDS A TELECOMMUTE PROGRAM - get the cars off the road, quit giving ****** money to kill us with, increase productivity and worker loyality with one easy command.
If your employer does not have some type (at least part time, start one. If all a worker does is drive, sit in front of a PC, talk on the phone, and drive - get rid of the drive/drive part. What thimbal full of brains does it take to figure that out. I know someone that can't fill that requirement...plain and simple, wasteful IDIOTS.

Message was edited by moderator.

28 replies

by w2ktechman

seems to be the personal relationships that occur during face to face meetings with your peers.
I agree that it would be beneficial for many to be able to work from home, but more and more companies are seeing increased costs due to their work from home employees.
Another problem with giving too uch work from home leeway, is trying to manage and determine how much people are actually working. There are a lot of people that will abuse this privilege if given the opportunity.

Honestly, I think that a rotational work from home schedule would be a benefit, say 2-3 days a week for many people.

by gerberb58

I agree. 2 in and 3 home office...Perfect. TRUST is the key. I goof off more IN the office and waste time. Home office, I am focused, undistracted and don't waste 3 hrs driving and lunching. But to be told I HAVE TO DRIVE everyday is just a bunch of PC and BS. If a manager is that insecure about their employees, either get new employees or get out of the management area.
It's not for everyone, I did not say it was. But some/most of us can handle it just fine. And we and the company and the country are better for it.

by w2ktechman

of knowing a person that worked less than 4 hours a week once they were able to telecommute.
I am not saying that everyone, nor most people will do this, but just a few can cause problems for the many as is the case with many other things.
It really is too bad, but once a manager feels that he/she has been burned like this, they often decide to cut telecommuting out of the picture. I am not condoning this action, merely bringing up another point of view. But I clearly think that you are over-reacting if you think that because of this issue with your company, that others need to be fired. If you are unhappy with the descisions of your superiors, then you should look for a new job!. For most, telecommuting is a luxery, not a must. It is and should be up to the business to decide if it should be implemented, not up to a govt. agency or made into Law.

by beechc23

It's all a question of balance vs. specific situation. In my
case I work for a software subsidiary of a professional
association (we sell software to members), as business
analyst. I was hired for the requirements of a specific part
of the country. My team is located in another part of the
country, but there's an office of another subsidiary about
65 miles from my home. I visit the office of the other
subsidiary about once a week (usually to log onto the
network as my employer doesn't support VPN); and I visit
my team 450 miles away for about a week every 4-6
weeks. Seems to work out well. I too get more done at
home anyway. My previous employer allowed me 2
home/3 office. Then I got a new boss and she insisted on
face time 5 days a week. I quit after less than a year of
that. Commuting 65 miles each way in rush hour was a
major pain. Telecommuting was a must for my next job.

by margarettnt

We don't get hired to make us happy - we're hired for what we can do. Make your management see what you can do when you work from home - and you can find yourself an exception to the rule. This works best when you work with and support an application or environment that runs 24/7 and where there are multiple offices and different time zones. Being able to make life easier for your boss is the name of the game - show how skipping the commute time got a problem solved sooner or over the weekend or when you could turnaround a late evening email and come up with an answer that works before your boss gets his first cup of coffee. You have to be a lot more proactive with your communication when you work from home, learn to balance more phone calls with your boss and send more emails with a short fyi summary. Don't be one of the out of sight out of mind guys - do touch base daily (but don't be a pest). And once in a while, just show up in the office anyway, with a smile. The company policy is only half of the whole - you're the other half that has to make it work.

by wallowamichael

Why should anyone be required to go to the office with all the technology available?

Of course, I live in such a rural area that the only Internet access I have is dial-up, so it's probably better that I actually come into the office to do my work. But, my commute is only about 15 minutes each way, even in traffic (three other cars on the road).

Other than that shortcoming, I could/would work at home, and I already let my worker bees have days at home, if they want them.

Meetings? - WebEx or some other program. You can even have two sided video.

I have already created an IT support scheme that supports a vast majority of problems from the central office. (VNC, Remote Desktop, IM) This has already saved our department a couple thousand $$ in mileage reimbursements, so why not go the next step and not even have to come to the central office?

I'm in complete agreement.

by absolutely

Just kidding, I feel your pain. Telecommuting would be great, but being able to look over shoulders is considered by many to be an important means of keeping their minions "on task". [Sigh]

Nothing to do for it but become the boss, and make one's own rules.

by protiusx

The company I am working for now did an analysis last year of the financial viability of workers telecommuting and found that we would save about $3 million a year. Managers over look the fact that facilities are a huge cost, and you're right about productivity going up. Our pilot group of users were given quotas that had to be 60% above what they would produce while at work and when the analyzed the results they found the average worker increased productivity by 100%. It was a no brainer really.

by maxwell edison

.....__________ (fill in the blank).

Red flags should be popping up all over the place.

[i][b]Required[/i][/b] by whom? And to what consequence?

Does the word [i]Liberty[/i] mean anything to you?

by jamesrl

And I think it is good for some...then let companies decide for themselves.

My company is mixed. Salespeople, and people who travel doing HW installs, SW installs, and many who do onsite training and consultations, work from home.

People who work in support do not.

I am given the discretion to make the choice for my teams. And I have one person who works from home permanently, and others who work one or two days a week from home.

But it depends on the nature of the job and the organization and even the individual. And that is something that should not be legislated.

James

by tony hopkinson

round trip at the moment, that's 20% of my current net salary.
There are very few decent jobs where I live and a load of decent people who would be happy with my job.

Nobody's job should be just driving a keyboard and a phone, that's means you are either two a penny, or you add no real value whatsoever.

Why should an employer be required to have a telecommuting program. If it would benefit the company, sell the idea to them.

A tip, don't start with they'll get the hours they are paying for out of you. There's another solution to that problem, and you'll have confessed!

by aghai

The last thing one needs is more government regulation. But I believe the spirit of the original message is that working from home can work for this individual as it often can for both employee and employer. There are several "reasons" why an employer may not permit telecommuting e.g. fear that employee will slack off, lack (unaware) of appropriate technology, a just need for team members to be physically co-located. There are equally good "reasons" to permit telecommuting e.g. less distractions, savings on fuel, commute time savings, no reqmt. for dedicated desk space at work, positive feeling that you are trusted etc. etc.
Telecommuting will often make sense but won't be allowed and that is how life goes.

The best companies to work for will be those that recognize trustworthy employees who can telecommute with benefit to both parties.

by tony hopkinson

it will benefit, regulating that it should anyway isn't going to help anything.
Aside from the trust issue, setting up the infra-structure to do it, hardware wise and organisationally isn't trivial.

My portable is sat waiting for some Vista drivers apparently, when that's sorted I can give it a go. It will be strange for me as well, have to discipline myself to put my 'work head' on. Perhaps wearing my tie at home will help. :D

by gerberb58

But, as is the case with me, I am FORCED to drive for hrs a day. Not because it makes perfect sense to telecommute, but because some ego-tistal idiot wants to see me.
I have presented several times the cost savings, the time saving, the productivity gains but to no avail. HE DOESNT GET IT!
And for this type, he is sooooo blind,we need a law. And he needs to be fired.

by willluongo

a lot of governmental interference to have a law that required a telecommute program.

Businesses have and should have the right to make poor decisions, this improves the products through competition, and really, it improves wages, through the same.

Is it unfortunate and questionable in logic for the management to take this stance? Yes.

That doesn't mean they shouldn't be able to.

Besides, you left a year later, so it seems like the problem is out of your hands. I have a friend whose whole department got laid off, and they had a number of outstanding projects for clients. He was stressing about it until he realized that his company just screwed themselves.

by djl4fzw

People are hired to benefit the employer, not the other way around.

If we agree to work FOR an employer, we agree to THEIR terms. It's called negotiation.

Remember, we're always free to go find another employer.

by sjohnson175

http://www.culturerx.com/

RESULTS are what matter. Not hours put in. However, most of the discussion in this thread focus on hours.

Oh and I'll have to agree with those who say bringing the police power of government to bear certainly isn't the answer.

by nicknielsen

Results are good, but too many employers want to see that they are getting the 8 hours they are paying for. For example, I have to document 8 hours of labor every day, regardless of my call load. Preventive maintenance is always a good time-filler.

The military, I think, is one of the first to implement results-oriented concepts. At some of my assignments, we were allowed to leave work if all the work was done. One or two people still stayed to mind the store (24/7/365, y'know), but the majority were often allowed to leave early.

Disclaimer: This was never official Air Force policy, but was usually implemented on a shop-by-shop or unit-by-unit basis at the discretion of management.

by nicknielsen

Some companies give their employees a 12-hour window (say 7 to 7) in which to fit their 8 hours. Thus, somebody who may wish to start early and leave early could work from 7 to 3, and somebody who likes to sleep in could work from 11 to 7. This plan provides three to four hours of crossover in the middle, allowing the "hands-on" manager his face time, while allowing employees to choose not to deal with full-up rush-hour traffic.

I know of one tech employer who uses both flex-time and telecommuting to help keep costs down and employees less upset about coming into the office. One or two employees abused the program and, as a result, were placed on standard time with no telecommuting privileges; nobody has abused the program since.

by w2ktechman

Unfortunately, once again the point was brougt up about abusing the privilige. This is probably a semi-common reason that many companies do not adopt telecommuting.

A nice way to treat it though :) :) :)
personally, I am one that would work longer (and do often) rather than appear to be slacking. I often come early and stay late, and everyone knows it.
But, I also spend quite a bit of downtime doing what I want as well. So I guess it evens out somewhere.

by dr dij

I'm sure that will include the military, with eyes only info, credit card companies, security companies, etc. And let them use their OWN PC and don't check it for viruses, trojans, keyloggers, etc.

Better yet, give them wireless routers. No use having their neighbors and people driving by without a net connection.

And to do this all, we can give them laptops, but not the good ones from IBM / Lenovo with a built in encryption chip for the hard drive. And we can give them a gym membership so the laptop will be in plain view in their trunk while they are working out.

And don't bother with biometric ID or strong passwords. If they want to break in, they break in anyway, right? OK, forget giving the employees laptops, they'd just get stolen. We'll just set them outside the door so thieves can pick them up directly.

BUt if we do give them laptops, include a few extra batteries so they can take it on their las vegas trip and the kids can watch DVDs in the back and download animated cursor spyware.

And for the employees convenience, we can download all company proprietary info as spreadsheets, be sure to thro in the employee files, with names, addresses and SSN#s.

Good luck telecomuting! Seems like you have a 'bad words' problem if your post was edited by the moderator? What's with that? Some kind of idiotic rage?

by gerberb58

And yet another that does not get it.
If you cannot be responsible for your PC, you don't qualify. And you don't.
I think you are watching just a little too much network news.

But thats ok, just keep feeding the diaperheads your money and soon none of us will have a telecommute issue......or any other.

by dr dij

what was it that you said in rage that got 'moderated'? So your post was NOT rage and mine was not facetious? Maybe you should take IDIOUTS or ****** out of your post to sound less 'rageful'? (or change it to id10ts :)

sure some companies should setup telecomuting and I'm sorry you can't simply because saves gas and envt. but there are alot of problems. employees not working. security. face time. face it, telecomuting is just not suitable for alot of jobs.

this is your 'moderated' post:
elecommute - ALL companies should be required to have a program
Forever in my past, I commuted to work. Sometimes 25mins, sometimes 2 1/2hrs. 3 years ago I went full time (for the most part) telecommute. I could not believe how much more I could get done! It was amazing and perfect. Then, of course, some idiot at corp desides that we need to go back to the 1970's. WHAT A MORON. Oh my god, I HATED IT.
My productivity dropped in half, I was cranky all the time and just plain miserable.
Within a year, I left. I cannot believe that these idiots ever go anywhere in their career. GROW UP - EVERY COMPANY NEEDS A TELECOMMUTE PROGRAM - get the cars off the road, quit giving ****** money to kill us with, increase productivity and worker loyality with one easy command.
If your employer does not have some type (at least part time, start one. If all a worker does is drive, sit in front of a PC, talk on the phone, and drive - get rid of the drive/drive part. What thimbal full of brains does it take to figure that out. I know someone that can't fill that requirement...plain and simple, wasteful IDIOTS.

Message was edited by moderator.

by djl2

Some governments are fully supporting teleworkers as part of their transportation program. Just think of how many fewer cars would be on the road if people telecommuted a few days a week. Some places even offer tax deductions or even credit for each teleworker.

Connecticut has a great website with lots of info-- http://www.telecommutect.com/homeplate/home.php

I read an article that stated that a full 2/3's of IBM employees work from home at least 1 day a week. I've met a few IBM'rs who never even had a formal office. As far as big companies go, IBM wrote the book on telecommuting starting back in the mid-90's, and it has been a huge success.

Nearly ever study I've read shows the telecommuting increases productivity by about 15%. I worked from home FT nearly 3 years an absolutely loved not having to commute. Most of my team was in other cities and locations, including my manager, so what difference did it make? None.

This discussion is closed to new replies.