The debate is not over - Scientists meet to dispute global warming theory
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Hardware
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
We used to have our bus service operated as a Crown corporation under the name BC Hydro (the forner name of our princial power company, hydro of course because we run on hydro electric power).
A few years back, that was up for public bis and a company name Coast Mountain Translink started to handles bus services and also took over BC Ferries, which run back and forth to Vancouver Island and up through the Queen Charlotte's on the BC coast.
One drawback, they are a privately owned and operated company. However, THEY pushed teh government to impose a gas tax that is then used to help offset funding the new 'private' bus line. A few cents from every litre goes to a private company that has no relationship to the oil companies.
Now THAT is a how a crown corporation handles things, not a private company.
They then started hiking ferry rates bit by bit, now to take just myself and my truck to the Island I am looking at around $80 each way (1hr45min trip each way).
So yeah, they privatized, the province rejoiced. Then they started nickle and diming us with support of the government.
BC Translink is also responsible for all roads, bridges and waterways they use, so whenever a road tax is implemented, guess how gets the money. A bridge needs work and they don't use the road taxes they've collected to fix it, they go to the city again and hold their hands out.
But on a good note, they just got a one year lease ($1/yr) on the world's first double decker hybrid bus in Victoria, the first double deckers in North America were used in Victoria so there's some history behind it too.
They also have several hybrid, single tier buses running around too. So they ARE tryign to look good or do better, but it is still just a dog and pony show until it is widespread enough to make a larger difference.
Private companies running buses? Sure, that happens. :D
by jdclyde
where they offered 200k.....
in a sort of response to his statement "I have read that most of the CO2 gas is held in the Oceans, lakes ect. When the water gets warmer ,I>E less dense, it releases this gas, and the one eyed jump on the warming bandwagon. this process does not happen overnight."
The atmospheric carbon isotope ratio is an absolutely nailed bit of [b]fact[/b] that the increase in atmospheric carbon dioxide is down to Man. Seeing as you asked so nicely, here goes.
Carbon exists in three isotopic forms. Normal carbon is C12 and is by far the most abundant. The second most common is C13. Because this is not identical to C12, being sligtly heavier, carbon dioxide formed from C13 does not behave the same way in photosynthesis and the ratio of C12 to c13 in plant tissue and in fossil fuels derived from plant tissue is not the same as the ratio in the atmosphere. The c13 isotope is more abundant in carbon in the oceans and in volcanic or geothermal emissions.
The relative amount of the c13 isotope in the atmosphere has been declining in a direct inverse relationship with the increase in atmospheric CO2, showing that the added carbon comes from burning fossil fuels and vegetation.
Carbon also has a rare radioactive isotope, C14, which is present in atmospheric CO2 but absent in fossil fuels as it decays. Measurements in the pre-nuclear era showed a steady decrease in the relative amount of C14 again mirrored by the increase in atmospheric CO2 level, demonstrating that fossil fuel carbon was being added to the atmosphere.
Neil :)
When I get involved in a TR GW debate - which is rare these days - I tend to start from here. There are three facts - not conjecture, not theory - fact.
1) CO2 has been rising steadily and quickly over the last hundred years.
2) It's completely our fault that it's rising (see above)
3) CO2 is a greenhouse gas.
I then invite my "opponents" to tell me what those three [b]facts[/b] imply. When they invoke, as they always do, "the freedom of the individual", I generally draw a breath and wait.
Eventually, Al Gore is mentioned and I walk away.
:)
One of the least understood and rarely mentioned issues is that what is happening now is UNIQUE. The only comparable releases of CO2 have been periods of extreme vulcanism and, as this is not pure CO2 and is accompanied by SO2 aerosols, ash and other substances, it's not comparable. By "extreme", I mean the Yellowstone Caldera cutting loose in a major way or the huge Deccan Flows of 70m years ago that covered 500,000 sq km of India with lava.
No one really knows what this CO2 is going to do. All I know is that it is [b]here[/b] and still rising and I can't believe that it isn't going to do something!
That you not urge the caldera to cut loose in order for you to enjoy pretty sunsets where you are.
I'm practically next-door to it, and instruments have registered swarms of late...
by oz_media
Okay, lets drop a flimsy trailer in the middle of tornado alley and whine for handouts when it gets blown down. And then they rebuild another flimsy trailer in tornado alley and so on.
It reminds me of two things, a Monty Pythons scene from The Holy Grail.
[b][u]Swamp castle:[/b][/u]
"Listen, lad. I've built this kingdom up from nothing. When I started here, all there was was swamp. All the kings said I was daft to build a castle in a swamp, but I built it all the same, just to show 'em. It sank into the swamp.So, I built a second one.
That sank into the swamp. So I built a third one. That burned down, fell over, then sank into the swamp. But the fourth one stayed up.
An' that's what your gonna get, lad -- the strongest castle in these islands."
Of course the other story it brings to mind,
"I'll huff and I'll puff and I'll bloooooooooooooow your house down!
Frickin' morons, and to consider the millions of dollars and rescue and relief efforts that are wasted on these idiots.
I'm not sure that I want to be on the end of a piece of vulcanism on that scale, even at several thousand miles range.
Toba wiped out 60% of the human population some 75,000 years ago and I believe that Yellowstone is of a comparable size if it goes bigtime.
Certainly would put a crimp in Montana and Wyoming property prices...
:(
by oz_media
I thought it might be 50 pages of worthy information but right off the bat it loses a great deal of relevance and credibliity.
First of all it was suggested by the Czech president [i]"it would most help the debate on climate change if the current monopoly and one-sidedness of the scientific debate over climate change by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)
were eliminated."[/i]
That is very true and fair indeed. An independent, UNBIASED private company should analyze the reports. Makes sense to me too
The paper you have linked to seemed a little biased and assumptive at first though, with comments like [i]" The 1990 IPCC Summary completely ignored satellite data, since they showed no warming."[/i]
Is that true? Was it because "they showed no warming" or is that just the 'author's assumption?
Speakign of 'The Author', S. Fred Singer is a well versed and long time scientist, he has a great deal of credibility, as do many scientists on both sides of the fence. But when reading up on him and his ever contested theories and opinions, S.Fred Singer, known to have his own biased agenda is not, for one, unbiased at all.
[i]
"Singer's group, the Science and Environmental Policy Project, completed the organization[42] of the Nongovernmental International Panel on Climate Change (NIPCC)"
Okay so this is not the government but "unbiased?"
This so called third party overseer is actually formed in part by the author of th earticle, who has been shown to have very biased and contested opinions. and he USED to work for the government.
So where's does 'unbiased non-governmental party' come from?
Anyway, I'll read it as it interests me, but as far as unbiased and impartial reporting, this seems to be anything but.
Max, you were always one to check such sources and 'alliances' out, seeking bias or hidden agenda. Why did that stop? I learned this stuff from you!
For some reason, you always assume [i]bias[/i] is a bad thing. To the contrary, it's not. What is bad, however, is when someone tries to conceal their bias. But when one freely admits what it is and is willing to defend it, there's nothing bad about that at all; in fact, it's actually more honest to admit one's bias.
I dismiss the notion that there always has to be an [i]unbiased[/i] middle-ground of some sort. In some cases, you either believe in something or your don't. Where's the [i]unbiased middle ground[/i] on the death penalty question, for example? A person either supports it or doesn't. One's belief defines one's [i]bias[/i].
As far as your [i]hidden agenda[/i] claim about the article or the organization behind it, I don't see anything hidden about it at all. There's an agenda behind their efforts, to be sure, but there's nothing hidden about it - they freely admit what it is.
In the case of this MMGW/CC issue (or whatever you want to call it), there are really only two sides: the advocates and the skeptics. Both have an agenda, and both have a bias. In my opinion, the skeptics are more honest with their real agenda and bias, while the advocates are less so.
I won't say there aren't people who we might call unbiased on that particular issue, but if there are, they probably don't care one way or the other, they haven't researched it at all, and they don't speak up on the issue one way or the other.
I'm not without [i]bias[/i] on the issue, nor is someone like Neil, who is on the opposite side from me - and you certainly aren't without [i]bias[/i] either, although you might try to present yourself as such.
My [i]biases[/i]:
I'm a MMGW/CC skeptic, not a believer.
I'm an individualist, not a collectivist. (Let's see the collectivists among us make such an admission)
People who won't admit their [i]bias[/i], in my opinion, fall into any number of categories, including (but not limited to): they don't really know what it is, and they haven't thought through an issue enough to form an opinion; or those who might try to maintain some lofty appearance of not taking sides, being a [i]moderate[/i], or being [i]open-minded[/i], but in reality they're chameleons who might try to be all things to all people - afraid (for any number of reasons) to really take a stand; and then there are those who are afraid to really admit it for fear of having to defend the indefensible or deny the undeniable - they hide their true agenda because it would be harder to support.
But you throw-around the charge of being [i]bias[/i] all the time, like it's always a bad thing. I couldn't disagree more.
by oz_media
I was only able to get through the introduction, as I have to run out for a while now but Dr. Singer's past illustrates hin as being far from unbiased, his opinions have been openly challenged for ages now. He is also a former government employee, his 'group' also made up the final portion of the unbiased, non-governmental body (NIPCC) that was supposed to provide this unbiased info to begin with, and he's KNOWN for his bias?!?
It seems that they went for a similar report as the PARTIOT Act. Patriot act was a 300 page document, which was completed and distributed the night before it was ot be voted for by congress.
It was full of double speak and wordy terms that would take a good lawyer some time to work through and really understand, however the vote was rushed through the very next morning, with a couple even admitting they didn't have time to read it all before voting on it.
The intro of ths document is rife with assumptions, as I cannot find any other quotes or claims to support their reasons for not including certain data, such as "Singer's group, the Science and Environmental Policy Project, completed the organization of the Nongovernmental International Panel on Climate Change (NIPCC)"
"Since they showed no warming" I'd like to see proof of that assertion or is it just baited speculation as to why it was not included?
Oh well, off for a bit now, maybe I'll get through it later.
.....equally showing the holes in both sides of the issue. Show the holes in the skeptics' arguments AND show the holes in the advocates' arguments. Otherwise, pick a side and admit your bias.
From where I sit, I see you often mention the holes, inconsistencies, or hidden agendas in the skeptics' arguments, but you never mention the holes, inconsistencies, or hidden agendas in the advocates' arguments.
(Related to the message below called [i]bias and hidden agenda[/i].)
by oz_media
YOU are the advocate that downplays the GW theories, and presents what you feel are facts to support your thoughts.
I have a different view than you, therefore I'm looking at invalidating your sources, just as you work to invaidate anyone else's.
The discussion is between you and I, not them.
So when I post a link and you work to invalidate it, I do the same.
I am not unbiased on this issue at all, just as you are not.
I am also not FOR what most of these scientists are trying to implement so I wont suppor tthem, but simply look at what people pose as proof and fact and then see if it is truly fact or somethign to be dismissed.
You've been playing in this sandbox for years now, you know the playground rules well enough to work it out.
by jdclyde
of the saved proposed 33 mil?
Sure, we should be made aware of options, but how about Obama talking about telling us how warm or cold we can keep our houses? I can see limiting temps in government buildings, but there are times I may WANT my house warmer. If the house is warmer, it is easier to get the babes to shed excess clothing. ]:)
Should "the government" be able to put efficentcy regulations on your trail bikes? Limit how often or how long you can use them? If you say "no" to the bike questions, you can see why I am willing to say no for other issues.
by jmgarvin
However, there is no denying that moving to green energy is not only a matter of the environment (if you are worried about GW), but a matter of national security. So no matter the cost we need to move to nuclear, wind, solar, wave, etc power NOW. We need to get off the oil and onto our own energy.
Let me also say we need to focus on the whole concept of reduce, reuse, recycle. Western society is very wasteful and we need to find ways to reduce that waste, reuse that waste, or recycle that waste. It's a simple matter of using our resources efficiently....
This also bring me to the point of clean water. Why aren't we better with recycling water? Why isn't there a gray water supply that is cleaned? We don't we have desalinization plants in certain areas?
Being more green makes sense from a national security stand point, but the problem is that the environmentalist make everyone seem crazy.
by oz_media
that's my point all along. we have other reasons to be more resourceful, if that results in us saving the planet from GW then that's just fantastic too.
I see environmentalists to be no more extreme left as those opposed are extreme right. not a political reference but just one of absolute opposites. It is like politics in that respect though. One side is so far removd from the other that neither holds credibility anymore.
by jdclyde
as we were discussing earlier.
What can you do easily?
What should we do that requires effort, and why?
What should we not have to worry about?
What is the agenda of blocking solutions?
Ignoring people that cry about a problem but don't work towards solutions.
by jck
[i]However, there is no denying that moving to green energy is not only a matter of the environment (if you are worried about GW), but a matter of national security. So no matter the cost we need to move to nuclear, wind, solar, wave, etc power NOW. We need to get off the oil and onto our own energy.[/i]
Totally agree.
[i]Let me also say we need to focus on the whole concept of reduce, reuse, recycle. Western society is very wasteful and we need to find ways to reduce that waste, reuse that waste, or recycle that waste. It's a simple matter of using our resources efficiently....[/i]
i already recycle all i can. i even complained that they don't recycle glass where i live, but they said it was an insurance liability and it did not turn a profit and there was no grant money to keep a program going to do that.
[i]This also bring me to the point of clean water. Why aren't we better with recycling water? Why isn't there a gray water supply that is cleaned? [/i]
They have reclaimed and recycled water systems in parts of the area where I live.
And in my hometown in OK, they did take the run-off water as well as the liquid from the sewage system and purify it and return it to nature into a stream and it was actually more pure than water from the spring our town was fed off of.
[i]We don't we have desalinization plants in certain areas?[/i]
Desalination plants are, for the most part, inefficient as hell.
They built one in Tampa, and it is only somewhere in the range of running at 20% efficiency. They don't work real well yet.
Of course, I think part of that issue was the company that won the contract.
I still think that they need to learn to combine nuclear power with water systems. That water that gets sucked up and used to cool things and is made into steam has got to be about as pure as you can get.
Why not take the steam and turn it into drinkable water?
[i]Being more green makes sense from a national security stand point, but the problem is that the environmentalist make everyone seem crazy[/i]
Yep, and that's what drives me nuts. The radicals in the world ruin things for the majority.
Same thing with animal lovers.
PETA people who go throwing paint on fashion models wearing fur just ruin the standing of animal lovers who want to do good for animals.
They think they're making a difference, when all their really doing is ruining the efforts of the majority who are trying to do some good rather than get on TV or something.
by oz_media
There used to be a very young, very naiive 'looking' girl I saw each morning when I worked downtown and took the skytrain in each day.
She was a real granola girls and always had her hand sticked PETA bag over her shoulder.
I was so tempted to start her into debate over it but never did, as she was probably clueless as to the horrors that PETA also puts animals through hell too.
PETA, a 'nonprofit' organization that operates from their own multimillion dollar headquarters in Norfolk Virginia, has been proven to support local terrorism, such as paying 45,200 to Rodney Coronado who later bombed a testing facility and then later 'donating' another 25,000 to support his legal case. Funding people who teach others how to make home made bombs and blow up selected buildings is no different than funding terrorism.
PETA was also responsioble for "saving" thousands of animals by breaking into similar facilities. As they were unabel to house and feed the animals, hundreds were later euthenised (sp?).
When I worked as a security foreman for teh coliseum, the SKOAL rodeo would roll into tow each year.
Funny enough, PETA would always show up and protest, but we added more security guards, not because of PETA, but because of reports of rodeo cowboys having sex in the washrooms (the old glory hole routines).
But PETA groups considered it torturing the animals, when in actuality these animals were treated like family pets by the rodeo. It's thei rbead and butter, their liveliehood, why would they destroy their own industry? These animals were fed well, under constant medical atention, housed in heated barns, driven around in million dollar rigs etc. I WISH my life was that cushy.
Anyway, I never got into it with her as she just looked so sweet and innocent, and easily lead.
But I still often think about how I should have at least given her some facts to chew on for a while.
by jmgarvin
Ya, desalination plants are inefficient, but honestly places like LA REALLY need more water and that is the only answer (for the short term).
I like your idea for the nuclear plants, that make perfect sense!!! I wonder why we aren't doing that...
Ug, PETA is proof that radicals kill their cause.
by oz_media
Well if Obama said anything about my bikes I'd politely tell him to cross teh border again and go home.
As for Canada's laws, I pay for insuance on my bikes, that includes a fee that is used much like a carbon tax. Every litre of gas I put in them is more carbon tax, and iwth them being small 4-strokes, the CO and Co2 emissions are very minimal. It's just hydrocarbons mainly and that turns into a very neutral and harmless gas as it rises to great altitude an breaks down fast.
When it comes to heatign my home, I don't have teh heat on most of the year, in fact I don't think i had it on this winter at all, despite teh cold snaps. I have a good Eiderdown cover and I give off a lot of body heat so I stay nice and toasty. When up and around, I wear clothes mainly, I have a selection of clothes so that I can select the appropriate covering for the wweather, temperature etc.
I use VERY little electricity as I only have one light on if any, my stereo is efficient so I can play it at low volumes etc. I do not use a lot of resources outside of gasoline, and I'd happily make those sacrifices too if there were better options.
I was brought up by paremts who lived through the war and post war England, I wasn't allowed to waste anything, leave lights on, turn heat up or ruin my clothing, shoes etc. by plaiying in the wrong clothes.
We were all taught to take creat care of the things we had, it bugged me back then but today such presevation has taught me how to live more resourcefully.
by delbertpgh
by oz_media
Your post makes a LOT of sense, I have always known that was your perspective too, but while I can accept it, I also disagree with it.
"Where's the unbiased middle ground on the death penalty question, for example? A person either supports it or doesn't. One's belief defines one's bias."
Actually, I Think there is middle ground.
In the case of your example, the death penalty; I am all for the death penalty as a punishment for those who have caused such heinous crimes. as you know I've studied criminology, psyche etc. and I have a pretty good grasp of the destruction people can cause. In these cases I agree that a life deserves a life, at the absolute minimum.
But when it comes to enforcement I have great doubts. My studies have involved the RCMP, VICLASS, forensic pathology and law to a knowledgable degree at least. I have seen how many people are sentenced to life only to be released 10 or more years later, due to recent findings (DNA confirmation etc.).
Due to this lack of absolute certainty, I simply cannot bring myself to support the death penalty.
"Beyond a reasonable doubt" is fair when sentencing someone to imprisonment, however death should not be determined on reasonable doubt. 'RD' is pushed so far in courtrooms now that it is ridiculous to even consider it trustworthy. OJ, for a prime example, was reasonable doubt played to the 'nth degree.
Until we can be absolute, which is impossible every time, we cannot play God and sentence possibly innocent people to death.
Perhaps new laws describing a clear difference between resonable doubt and 100% certainty would be effective.
.........
On God and religion. I am not aethiest nor even really agnistic, I was born Christian under the Church of England. As a Scout leader I attended countless services and am very respectful of religious belief. I won't call someone stupid for having faith in any god, and while I don't have a strong personal belief in any one god, I accept people's right to hold faith in their religion or anything else they choose that doesn't harm anyone else.
As you can see, I am in the middle on both of these topics. That doesn't mean I don't have strong convictions, in fact it is because of my convictions that I cannot pass such judgement.
.................
In the case of MMGW/CC, I am neither skeptic nor believer, I prefer to err on the side of caution. This is not because of scare tactics, it is not for political motive or more/less government control. I just feel as a race need to be more resourceful. You know all about emission pollutants and the real effects they DO have on us each day, is that not enough? All it is is responsibility. I don't want more government imposed restrictions either, however people must be urged to participate and at least do their small part too. Urging should be done with education not scare tactice, unreasonable stories of pending doom and the end of the world though. There are realistic scientists looking at real science and speaking with really reasonable short and long term solutions. They are simply drowned out by the Al Gores and teh media of the world.
GW has a firm case on both sides, unfortunately we are trashing our environment right now, GW or not.
I'm not undecided of biased on these issues, I just think that the real message and reasons are being clouded by the extremeties from each side. It's easy to dismiss reality when it is shown in extremes that way,
by tonythetiger
[i]Perhaps new laws describing a clear difference between resonable doubt and 100% certainty would be effective.[/i]
100% certainty never is 100% certain :)
by oz_media
Clifford Olsen, tracked down, evidence stacked against him, admitted his crime and was paid many thousands of dollars each time ($35K per person) he released info on another missing persons wherabouts (of course long dead and disposed of).
Jeffery Dahlmer, Gary Ridgway (Green River murdered of over a known 90 people), Ted Bundy, Robert Pickton etc. There have been thousands of known serial killers who are 100% guilty and proven as much with 100% certainty, there is no debate, no reasonable doubt not even UNreasonable doubt.
We can prove their crimes, THEY have proudly spoken of their crimes and proven their relationship to them. These aren't nutbags who just want fame so they admit to a crime they haven't comitted, which is also very common. These are proven, admitted and known serial killers who deserve to be destroyed.
by dr dij
and the GW community does not seem hell bend on managing the world's economy.
I'm a dyed-in-the-wool free market person but also realize that GW is real.
You've failed to separate the evidence of man's action on the natural environment from what you perceive as the socio-political gov't interference that will result from attempts to control emissions.
It doesn't matter how clever your arguments are, they don't match with the real world melting and mankind's spewing of filth.
It also is fairly simple in a libertarian free-market kind of way:
socialized roads (govt sponsored road system) wiped out what would have been a massive, efficient and much less polluting mass transit rail system across the country that would have developed without road subsidies.
Automobile pollution (and CO2 emissions in general) have had their emissions added to the 'socialized risk' arena. If I took 10 busses and parked them on the edge of your property and ran them night and day, you would see that air pollution is using force to spew out crap and make others breath it.
Of course it is only when we reach levels we've been at for last 50 or so years - 8 gigatons of CO2 a year - 10% of the amount in the atmosphere, spewed EACH YEAR for 30 years into the atmosphere, that we really affect the climate ourselves.
If it were up to Max, who appears to be like a government committee, endlessly wanting to deny blame and debate the issue, plus deny actual facts and events that are happening, nothing would ever get done.
Among scientists in peer reviewed journals there IS concensus. So it is more like "what, if anything can we do or should we do to stop this?"
GW policy make the world go bankrupt? give me a break. It will be ALOT less expensive to switch to sustainable energy here in US and reduce pollution at same time than the costs of upheaval. There will almost certainly be a large war in the next 10 years, possibly sooner, and much of the blame for this will be starving people who: didn't get the rains this year because man-made pollution is sending climate change and weather patterns into hyper-chaos. Or who depend on mountain rivers for irrigation or drinking water. sorry but the glaciers / snowpack melted early this year and from now on so they dry up in the summer.
Even the pentagon agrees with me on the threat of GW on global strife. Huge percent of the world's peoples live very close to oceans. New York and Washington, among other cities will probably need massive seawalls. Miami and N.O. will most likely be underwater soon. In Britain, the 'common folk' like GW thinking it will get warmer but if the gulfstream stops due to melting arctic and greenland, it may get COLDER.
In the end people who are totally ignorant of the scientific evidence which is kind of like a giant landslide will not change what is happening to the climate.
It doesn't matter what clever jokes you make. It doesn't matter that Rush has a big audience of people ignorant of the real world, or that he pulls facts out of his nether regions (by quoting others who have done the same in print).
GW isn't here to debate or reason with us. It will do what our SPEW causes it to do. And unhappily our industrial and auto spew IS stirring up additional feedback in form of more gasses that are released when our manmade warming melts permafrost (CO2) and continental shelves warm (methane hydrate).
It's more like GW is that arch villan who ties up James Bond to a chair and sets the laser to slice him in half. James goes "do you want me to talk?" and the villian goes "No, James, I want you to die!"
by jck
wrong spot!!! :^0
I moved it up to the right spot, tony lol
teach me to have 2 browsers of TR open :^0
by jck
[i]He's a 24/7 hypocrite. He generates more greenhouse gases in a few month than I have in my entire (51.5 year) life! He and his family uses 40-50 times more natural resources than the average American family. And that's BEFORE counting his trans-world jaunts to spread his hype![/i]
If Al Gore (with all his travel that does far out-do most in the world) gets 10,000 people in his lifetime to cut back 20% on their carbon footprint, he's more than made up for what he and his family do.
Can you say the same thing? Remember: not everyone is as responsible as you, Tony. Some people have to be taught what is right.
[i]It's very clear what's really going on.[/i]
Enlighten me.
[i]Many of those in power (money) believe they should be in control of everything... especially if it might be running low, in which case they think they should have exclusive use of it. The Democratic process is an affront to what they believe should be the natural order of things.[/i]
But, those in power (money) should be in control...remember?
Since we live in a capitalist society, then those with power (money) are in control of everything: construction, petroleum, banks, grocery chains, textiles, paper products, publishing, media, etc.
And, that's whether you like it or not.
And as for the Democratic process: it's a myth. If things were really democratic here, we would not have U.S. supreme court justices placed on the court, but voted in by the people.
Usually the wealthy, [b]some[/b] of whom do actually know how to make money by growing the economy, generally will take the tact of maximizing return to those who contribute (shareholders, workers, service providers) whenever they make outrageous sums of profit.
Otherwise, they either tighten up the valve on the gravy train or try to find any other path to keep that outrageous level of money coming their way...even if it is somewhat ilkish or below-board.
In short: most wealthy people are greedy folks who don't care about what others get...just what they're gonna get out of the deal...and that they get the most.
And that's why unnatural flow happens nowadays, and why banks are failing, and mortgage companies are collapsing, and your investment portfolio is down the tubes: those people who are wealthy who are supposed to be able to make the economy grow with their infinite financial wisdom...were really too busy only trying to make their bank balance grow.
I just wish there were more people like Sam Walton alive running business. He actually grew cities, rather than building stores in numbers to run his local competitors out of business.
Wal-Mart with Sam: local economy boost
Wal-Mart without Sam: local economy killer
Goes to show you what happens when a bunch of business school, wanna-be-like-Sam capitalists take over the most powerful company in the world: they try everything to make the most profit no matter what...even if it means not doing what is right.
Anyways...until we make the free market economy here a fair economy, then people like most of the corporate heads in this country will continue to rape the American people under the guise of: "Nothing I did was illegal."
by tonythetiger
[i]But, those in power (money) should be in control...remember?[/i]
But when they use their power to deprive others of their liberty, they're stepping over the line.
by jck
[i]But when they use their power to deprive others of their liberty, they're stepping over the line.[/i]
Define the point between "depriving others of liberty" and "getting everything for themselves that they are at liberty to do".
Is it an infringement on my liberty when someone overcharges me for a bag of ice after a hurricane?
Not really. I can always go somewhere else. But, the State of Florida made price gouging illegal after natural disasters.
So is it a legal thing that defines infringement? A moral thing?
How exactly are you going to define what "liberty" is, and the exactly defined line that has to be crossed in all cases for someone to be punished for crossing?
I don't think you can. That's why common sense has to come into play. Otherwise, lawyers end up writing laws with holes in them for their power monger buddies to use and then the common guy gets screwed.
Oh wait...that's already happening. ;)
by tonythetiger
[i]Define the point between "depriving others of liberty" and "getting everything for themselves that they are at liberty to do".Define the point between "depriving others of liberty" and "getting everything for themselves that they are at liberty to do".
Is it an infringement on my liberty when someone overcharges me for a bag of ice after a hurricane?
Not really. I can always go somewhere else. But, the State of Florida made price gouging illegal after natural disasters.
So is it a legal thing that defines infringement? A moral thing? [/i]
Well, both, but legal is the only one that matters "legally" :)
[i]How exactly are you going to define what "liberty" is, and the exactly defined line that has to be crossed in all cases for someone to be punished for crossing?[/i]
Liberty is simply the right to be or do anything one wants (assuming one has the ability... everybody can't be a rocket scientist...). When you, in asserting your liberty interfere with the liberty of another, laws are necessary to spell out which person's liberty takes precedence.
The mistake I see made most often is the making of laws that restrict a liberty that [b]does not[/b] interfere with the liberty of others but simply attempts to control behaviors that (some, many, most) people "don't like". Bans on gay marriage are an example of this.
Next most often is the making laws so specific that it restricts behaviors that most people can practice safely without violating the liberties of others because a few can't. Banning the use of cellphones while driving is an example... most people can handle this, some can't (those who can't probably shouldn't be allowed to talk to passengers while driving either!).
Personally I think laws should be fewer and deliberately more vague... This would let "common sense" have more say in the interpretation. It would also make for fewer required changes.
by jck
[i]Well, both, but legal is the only one that matters "legally" [/i]
True. Just like air is the only thing that counts breathing. :^0
[i]Liberty is simply the right to be or do anything one wants (assuming one has the ability... everybody can't be a rocket scientist...). When you, in asserting your liberty interfere with the liberty of another, laws are necessary to spell out which person's liberty takes precedence.[/i]
So, it would be an infringement upon my liberties that someone told me that I was "too tall" to work at a job because they didn't want to have to adjust the equipment then, right?
I was able to do the work, but they stopped me from engaging in employment of something I was fully qualified to do simply because they did not want to have to make an effort to accomodate me.
I was stopped from getting a job because of physical attributes which did not keep me from doing the work.
Should that company had to have paid me for discrimination and violation of my rights to life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness?
[i]The mistake I see made most often is the making of laws that restrict a liberty that does not interfere with the liberty of others but simply attempts to control behaviors that (some, many, most) people "don't like". Bans on gay marriage are an example of this.[/i]
I don't disagree about the gay marriage thing. Of course, I don't think laws should be written to specifically allow gay marriage. I think if it says in the law that "two people may enter into a state of union between them", then it should not matter their gender or sexual preference.
Now when law is written to state "a man and a woman...", then it is wrong. That is both gender and sexually discriminatory.
[i]Next most often is the making laws so specific that it restricts behaviors that most people can practice safely without violating the liberties of others because a few can't. Banning the use of cellphones while driving is an example... most people can handle this, some can't (those who can't probably shouldn't be allowed to talk to passengers while driving either!).[/i]
Personally, I think use of any communication device for anything other than emergency or public safety purposes while driving should be banned.
I also think that reading the newspaper or a book or comic book (I've seen all 3) while driving should be disallowed.
Anything that distracts your attention from operating a 2000+ lb motor vehicle that could strike and kill someone should be disallowed.
Your right to communicate while driving does not trump my personal safety while driving.
[i]Personally I think laws should be fewer and deliberately more vague... This would let "common sense" have more say in the interpretation. It would also make for fewer required changes.[/i]
Thing is...most people...especially lawyers...have no common sense.
Until the day in a court of law that a judge or jury can use common sense and it not be appealable, that will never work...unfortunately.
by jck
by tonythetiger
[i]So, it would be an infringement upon my liberties that someone told me that I was "too tall" to work at a job because they didn't want to have to adjust the equipment then, right?[/i]
if your right to "force someone to employ you" took precedence over an employer's right to offer employment to whomever he chooses.
[i]I was able to do the work, but they stopped me from engaging in employment of something I was fully qualified to do simply because they did not want to have to make an effort to accomodate me.[/i]
It depends... In severe cases, the cost to accommodate may be more than "the value of the work you would accomplish minus the value of the work someone who didn't require the accommodations would accomplish". That is, and should be, a business decision.
[i]Your right to communicate while driving does not trump my personal safety while driving.[/i]
That's what I mean about "vague". It's enough to have a law banning "distracted driving", and leave whether a particular occurrence qualifies in the hands of the judge or jury. The alternative is to create a law for every conceivable thing which might cause one to be distracted, and constantly add to it as new things are invented.
A couple more things... How do you prove that a particular thing is a hazard to your safety? and, since people are different and have different capabilities, what's distracting to one might not be distracting to another. Do you really want every law to restrict us to do only things that the barely qualified are able to do?
[i]Until the day in a court of law that a judge or jury can use common sense and it not be appealable, that will never work...unfortunately.[/i]
I was an alternate juror on a case... A woman whose husband was cheating on her tried to run the "other woman" down in a parking lot after this other woman harassed and berated her repeatedly in public. There were over twenty eye-witnesses. The charges were assault and attempted murder. I didn't get to the jury room, as no other juror got sick or anything, but I later found out the jury acquitted her of all charges.
A jury can't [b]make[/b] laws, of course, but they [b]can[/b] determine if one that's put before them should be enforced in that particular instance... a pretty cool power if you ask me.
by delbertpgh
Bias is unavoidable in human affairs, true. Acknowledging one's biases is good, and often information is useless unless it is illuminated by a point of view. For example, information about Harry Truman at Yalta is only useless trivia unless you have a body of facts and opinions that you hold to explain the cold war. I'd call this a point of view instead of a bias, myself. It's useful.
To push the analogy further, there were people in Truman's time who thought Truman was an ass for seeing such problems with those nice communists. Only a reactionary fool would dream up such issues. Others thought he was a dupe or a communist agent, because only treachery could explain the problems the U.S. faced in 1951. I would call these types of bias useless and counterproductive.
In science as in politics, there is no shortage of theories that explain perceived facts. There does develop a main stream of accepted theory, the establishment of which usually gets entrusted to university PhDs. Some hardened individualists go against the main stream, earning a reputation as visionaries, others as cranks. Some are pretty definitely tools, who are loyal to some institution outside of science, such as tobacco company researchers or creation scientists. It's not to say those people can't be true believers as well as water carriers for their masters, but it sure makes suspect their place as "scientists".
The point is, there are lots of contradictory ideas, and even reality-denying ideas, held by people who are allegedly scientists. There is a scientific mainstream, which tends to run closer to the truth than not, and its banks are carefully tended by PhDs who usually do it for the glory and the esteem of their colleagues, more than for the money or power. There are plenty of people outside of science, politicians and businessmen and think-tankers and editorialists, who want to make use of science to establish their points. They've got a strong point of view, or bias, and often they lie or obscure apparent truth if it doesn't serve their goals. They play hardball; they play for keeps; there's real money, power, and purpose on the table. Fine, that's humanity. However, it's a mistake to confuse the ideologues with the scientists.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending