Discussion Locked

This guy should be stoned... (with rocks)

0 helpful
503 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Alright, well you've all heard what I think about stupid users getting themselves infected and then expecting someone else to clean it...

So here's a PRIME example:

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/02/08/e-banking_trojan_lawsuit/

Basically, this schmuck got himself infected with a trojan and now his bank account had 90K pulled out of it... The feds think it was due to the trojan, so now this assclown is suing his bank for the lost funds, because he was too lazy and incompetent to run his own AV scans...

Sickening..

Just thought I'd throw this out there in case anyone else wants to sit back and sip a glass of lemonade while laughing at this jerks problems.

I hope BoA countersues him and takes him for the rest of what he's worth.

Mrafrohead

503 replies

by tony hopkinson

went into worth a try mode, or his now famous lawyer convinced him it was doable.

I think it would be in BoA interests to get him the 70k back out of Riga. The twenty he can swallow for not spending some money on a virus checker.

If it was a known threat then he had the chance of knowing about it.

The bank did not supply anything he used to connect to the service.
If he didn't know that ebanking is always a risk then he ought to pull his head out of his ass on a more regular basis.

I do hope they weren't stupid enough to tell him he was perfectly safe though, cause that just ain't the case.

His and their lawyers will be in the bar downstairs for the whole case, shaking their heads as much as us.

by hal 9000

After all this profession used to be called "Ambulance Chasers" now they have something different to play with.

More money for them and I'm betting that his lawyer is telling him that he did nothing wrong!

Col ]:)

by tony hopkinson

Could your online banking service have been hacked.
Call VirusChasersAreUs for a free no win no fee consultation.
This guy's getting shafted by so many people, he might as well go into porn/prostitution and get paid for it.

by dr dij

Maybe he worked with an accomplice to take the money out so they could sue BofA. Could someone really be that stupid?

by amcol

I'm generally not sympathetic to people who cause their own problems, nor to those who seek to pass the responsibility for their own mistakes onto others. But you've made a broad assumption here that this fellow is wholly in the wrong and is looking for an out at someone else's expense.

We can debate from today until tomorrow how much responsibility everyone has for protecting their own PC's from intrusion. The plain fact of the matter is that there are many, many, many people who are quite brilliant and accomplished in their own fields and at the same time clueless about computing.

Just because someone's a world famous brain surgeon with 56 letters after their name doesn't mean they know how to install firewalls or virus protection, or how to keep those up to date. Or even that they're supposed to. And just because you know all about this doesn't mean everyone else does, either.

I've seen CEO's of Fortune 100 organizations stare blankly at monitors, confused and intimidated at the mere thought of composing an e-mail. That doesn't make them irredeemably stupid.

You read what you read in the story. Here's what I read...an independent businessman who's trying to make a living and pursue the American dream was victimized by an electronic scam. While he could have done something to protect himself, those in authority (the bank) who also could have protected him, AND HAD A RESPONSIBILITY TO DO SO, failed to do so. As a result he's suing them. Not for 60 gajillion dollars, but for the amount of money he's out. That's all.

Your condescending attitude toward this, and that of the other posters who appear to agree with you, doesn't speak well for your character. If the shoe were on the other foot in an entirely different set of circumstances, I suspect you'd want all of us to be sympathetic to you.

by passwordchanged

mister mafro's picture is next to the word "condescending" in the dictionary. chain yanking is his specialty.

"I object to you. I object to intellect without discipline. I object to power without constructive purpose." Spock to Trelane, ST the original

I object to vilifying victims of crimes, such as the man whose banking account was hacked, and the sympathy for the person who was sentenced for releasing a virus.

by mrafrohead

I didn't say that I sympothise with the virus writer. That's hardly the case.

But I sure as hell don't sympathise with some schmuck that won't accept responsibility for his own actions.

This guy apparently runs around blaming others for his own misfortunes. He should stand up, act like a MAN and admit his fault. He allowed his computer to get infected, his bank didn't do it for him. Unless a teller ran over to his house and installed that virus, the bank is NOT at fault, and this guy can rest in piss for not accepting fault for his own worthless shoddy actions.

by tomsal

I read your entire post and while I think its good that you obviously have compassion in your heart -- after reading the full news story about this guy I fully disagree with you.

I do my personal banking online all the time, I do my own money transfers all the time. I know that when I do business online, I have to be aware of the risks involved. This is not being computer savvy, this is not being brilliant even...ITS COMMON FRIGGIN SENSE!

My sister who barely knows anything about computers for example, she has common sense enough to update her virus definitions and do scans on a regular basis, keep her firewall updated and be anal about protecting her passwords.

Of course I gave her the advice -- all of a 15 minute conversation, because she had the COMMON SENSE to ask about something she didn't know anything about BEFORE doing financial business online.

YOUR mentality and others who think the same as YOU, makes me sick...its one of EVERYONE ELSE is always responsible for my bad, my faults, my mistakes and its NEVER my fault. What you are saying is that ignornace negates all self-responsibility. BULLSH*T! If this guy's machine was clean of virus infection, if he had a firewall, if he used strong passwords, if his software was fully patched, etc. AND THEN this happened...then I *may* feel some sympathy for the guy. But that isn't the case, so therefore I don't.

End of story.

by amcol

You say you read my entire post but apparently not very carefully. I don't know where in anything I wrote you got the idea that I was saying the bank is wholly responsible and the man's ignorance excuses his own culpability. Quite the contrary.

There's no question this man had a personal responsibility to protect himself. Just as there's no question he (and anyone else, for that matter) has no right to expect any redress when he's the victim of his own screw-up.

That's not what happened here, however.

He didn't have proper or sufficient intrusion controls in place. That's his mistake, and he should pay for it. The bank, on the other hand, did nothing to protect their customer. They processed a transaction that should have rung every alarm in the building.

Read the article again. It says he was regularly wire transferring money in the US and to Latin America. What possible business could a Miami printer ink and toner dealer have in Latvia?

Have you ever received a call from your credit card company questioning a transaction? I have. All retail financial institutions have very sophisticated pattern recognition software that makes sure if you're the type of consumer who mostly makes small purchases on the East Coast, a very large purchase on the West Coast is something that should raise a flag.

High quality, responsible financial institutions perform this service for their customers. This bank didn't do that. Therefore, they have some responsibility here.

You're so angry about this man not protecting himself, so let's look at something else the story talked about. After reporting the bogus transaction to the authorities, the US Secret Service was called in and had to do a forensic examination of his PC in order to identify what happened. You expect that your normal, average, everyday jerk is going to be able to protect himself against something the government had to be called in to uncover?

Don't get me wrong...I don't buy for one nanosecond his shyster's argument that the bank should have known about and warned its customers about Coreflood, therefore they're responsible. But we're talking about Bank of America here. This is a major financial institution. In the IT shop I run, I put out a weekly PSA to my entire customer community on whatever current threat is out there that I think they should know about. Sometimes I talk about phishing, sometimes virus protection, sometimes product features that if used incorrectly can create problems. No one asks me to do that, but it's all part of my customer service.

This man didn't protect himself and he should take some responsibility. The bank didn't protect him either, and they bear some responsibility for that. I don't see this as black and white as you do...it's a shared responsibility, and since the man's only asking for his money back I don't think he's deserving of the vitriolic reaction the original poster had.

Nor do I think I deserve your insulting post, considering you obviously didn't read either the article or my post too terribly carefully. Think first, write last.

by mrafrohead

"Of course I gave her the advice -- all of a 15 minute conversation, because she had the COMMON SENSE to ask about something she didn't know anything about BEFORE doing financial business online."

And TomSal didn't have to drive to this jerks house to do what he did with his sister because the NEWS does it almost NIGHTLY!!!

"Microsoft just released a precedent setting 10 patches"

"Beware, there is a new virus on the loose"

"Users make sure you have updated your computers and your antivirus because..."

This guy owns his own business, means he's probably a smarter guy, which means he probably reads or watches the news, which means he has NO EXCUSES!

Now his bitch ass is going to sue BoA and cause all of it's customers to get increases in fee's to cover the costs of the case. I think that if he is allowed to go to trial, he should have to mail me a check for 7500 bucks to cover MY costs to cover his sorry, waste of skin, ass...

by awfernald

This guy should sue the company he bought the computer from for not installing an Anti-Virus, or having it update automatically, or not teaching him to run it/update it.

Also, he should sue his ISP for not warning him about the dangers of the internet, or telling him that a virus/spyware was possible (not like he probably didn't get 10,000 ads/popups warning him about the risks).

I have had many clients who were TOTALLY IGNORANT of computers, however, at no time have they even considered holding a third-party responsible for that ignorance.

From what I read in the story, the bank was already trying to get the gentleman his money back, so what was the lawsuit for? well, as someone else pointed out, to earn some lawyer some big bucks.

You know who wins in a class-action suit, right? The lawyers! So now they want to make this a class action? hmmm, sounds like the lawyer is pushing this issue, not the client. Seems to me like the bank is responding in the correct manner, and the idiot sticks are out.

by mrafrohead

Per amcol:
"You read what you read in the story. Here's what I read...an independent businessman who's trying to make a living and pursue the American dream was victimized by an electronic scam. While he could have done something to protect himself, those in authority (the bank) who also could have protected him, AND HAD A RESPONSIBILITY TO DO SO, failed to do so. As a result he's suing them. Not for 60 gajillion dollars, but for the amount of money he's out. That's all."

First off, it isn't the banks job to tell you that you should install a firewall or AV software. The bank is there to do the banking. If I had a home user call me and ask me how to support their home machine, I'd politely tell them to piss off. I work for the bank, NOT the user.

If you are going to be a big boy and play on the internet with the big kids, act like it. Don't point fingers.

"Your condescending attitude toward this, and that of the other posters who appear to agree with you, doesn't speak well for your character. If the shoe were on the other foot in an entirely different set of circumstances, I suspect you'd want all of us to be sympathetic to you."

In all honesty, I could give a rip about what you think of my character, though I do appreciate how polite you put that. :)

If the shoe were on the other foot, screw the bank, I'd be banging down the door of my ISP for tracking information to catch the shit monkey that took my money. Oh wait, that's not the ISP's responsibility, it was mine, so I guess I'd just have to look at my own logs... And if I can't figure it out from there, then tough. ;p

Actually, if anyone is going to be called to figure out the problem, it sure as hell wouldn't be the bank, it would be the ISP. Even then, it's STILL not the ISP's fault, as he was the dillhole that allowed himself to get infected. He coulda just subscribed to the one year of free AV that Micro$hit has been pushing from CA...

But that was too difficult huh???

I've had PLENTY of expensive lessons in life, this guy just got one for himself.

by amcol

Which is why I'm mystified as to why you're not getting what I'm saying. I doubt you're as close minded as you're trying so hard to appear...it's easy to put on an act in boards like this where you can hide behind an alias and not have to worry about the consequences of your actions. I have a hard time believing you'd actually spout any of this drivel if we were face to face.

But, I'm a glutton for punishment. So here's one last try.

Let's put this whole thing into simpler, non-technology terms.

Everyone knows you should put a lock on your front door, right? You'd have to be an idiot not to know that, right? So if you live in a high crime area and you don't lock your door, then you get robbed, well what did you expect? You didn't take responsibility for yourself, even though it was obvious what you needed to do. You got what you deserve.

Now let's suppose you decide that because you live in a high crime area you're going to store your valuable stuff at Acme Safekeeping Company. You pay them a reasonable fee for putting your stuff in their safe, and you have a reasonable expectation it's going to be there when you go to claim it, right? The only problem is that Acme's safe is in an even higher crime area than yours, and although it's pretty common knowledge that Acme can't be trusted you, for whatever reason, are unaware of this fact. Acme gets robbed, your stuff is gone.

By your logic you're screwed. You should have known Acme was a sucker's bet, and therefore you have no recourse, except maybe to file an insurance claim. On the other hand...weren't you paying Acme to provide you a service? Did they in fact provide that service? Don't they deserve to share some of the blame? Yeah, you absolutely should have known they were bogus...everybody else did, why didn't you? So you merit some of the blame too. But neither you nor Acme is ENTIRELY to blame...it's a shared responsibility.

Let me repeat that, just so I know I'm being crystal clear. NEITHER YOU NOR ACME IS ENTIRELY TO BLAME. THAT'S THE POINT. NEITHER THE GUY NOR THE BANK WAS ENTIRELY TO BLAME. THEY BOTH ARE.

Do you get what I'm saying now?

The world is not black and white. Things are not nice and neat and binary like you're making them out to be. There's never a situation where one extreme or the other is the right answer...that lies somewhere in the middle. As it does in this case.

by oz_media

NO they don't.

The bank has a responsibility to provide security that your funds will not be disturbed in transfer or rerouted, your information will remain classified and other general issues regarding the security of your funds and personal information within their system.

This they did, and they have NOT been breached. They haven't allowed your personal information to be broken into, nobody had accessed their system without authorization. Their system had ot failed.

The bank notified the customer of the risk.
The customer, obviously understanding the amount of cybercrime in that region, had ignored the warning.

The bank isn't at risk here, the CUSTOMER is and he has been told so in a manner that supercedes the banks responsibility.

The customer was breached, HIS computer failed. What is he gonna do? Sue Microsoft for not warning him it may be breached? Sue the ISP for providing a link to his insecure PC?

He's wrong. It's HIS responsibility to secure his OWN equipment, the bank is just contracted to protect their own breaches not yours.

by stress junkie

I agree that you can't expect every pc user to have the expertise of a system administrator. It is the bank's responsibility to know the risks of online banking and to take steps to ensure that their customers' money is safe. I basically condemn the entire practice of online banking. If a bank is going to make their services available over the Internet then it is up to the bank to take the responsibility for security. The bank management should know that online banking is easily hijacked. It is their job to know that.

Blaming ignorant end users for the consequences of trusing their bank is wrong. It is reasonable for bank customers to believe that their bank management has a better understanding of the technical issues associated with online banking than the average bank customer. It should be reasonable for the average bank customer to believe that their bank wouldn't put the customers' assets at risk.

When you expect the average pc user to remain up to date about computer technical issues you are in effect saying that everyone using a pc should maintain a level of expertise equivalent of a professional system administrator. Yet we know from experience that keeping up to date about computer issues is a full time job. When you put the burden of expertise on the end user you are in effect saying that they should spend hours a week studying a field of knowledge that is not their principal vocation. Hell! Most system administrators don't even keep completely up to date on security issues. It is reasonable for the typical end user to defer to the 'experts' when it comes to computer security. In this case that should be the bank management.

In the U.S. many people hire a professional to fill out their tax forms each year. Why? Because keeping up to date about all of the tax code changes is a full time job. Would you blame a taxpayer for not knowing about some niche tax regulation? You shouldn't. The tax code is too complicated for people to be experts in that and in their own job expertise. That's why people hire experts to inform them about tax code regulations that affect them.

Would you blame someone who uses a dietary supplement and has a bad reaction even though their was no mention of the risk on the label? You shouldn't. The average person cannot be expected to be an expert in pharmacology. We all have to defer to the people that work in that field to be experts and to guide us. We expect that risky substances will not be available or will have the risks listed.

The same is true of computer usage. The average person should not be expected to be an expert in computer security. Sure we hear about computer issues all of the time because we read sources like TR. How many times do you hear about computer security on the evening news? Not often. The average person cannot be expected to know what they don't know.

As long as computer security is a problem for the average person then it is irresponsible for the 'experts' such as bank managers to abuse the trust of their customers by taking risks that the bank customers may not even know about. On line banking is a blatantly irresponsible practice. The responsibility of mitigating that risk is in the hands of the people entrusted with the safety of the customers' assets; the bank management.

by amcol

One of the most excellent postings I've ever seen ANYWHERE on this board, and I'm not just saying that because you and I share the same point of view.

I'm saying that because you've written a well thought out, well articulated, highly intelligent treatment of a serious subject. There's a minimum of emotion and editorializing, and your examples and comparisons are directly on point. What you've written adds value to the discussion, and (equally importantly) treats the reader with respect. And, as an added bonus, you display near perfect spelling, grammar, and sentence and paragraph construction (not that I wish to sound like an English teacher).

Thank you for making a valuable contribution. You've set the bar higher for all of us. It's a shame other posters use these spaces somewhat less nobly.

by tomsal

I disagree. The problem with the arguments on this matter is some of us think there is a line of responsiblility (look at it as a the Demarc point where your phone company is concerned) to a certain point the bank is responsible. That has to do with sound privacy practices of their customer's information, encrypting all traffic that has to do with their online banking services, keeping their servers patched and secured and informing the consumer of risks as well as all the things the bank does to keep data safe.

Then there is the customer side which is THEIR computer, THEIR internet connection -- anyone, even if the entire world was against me and I alone had this point I'd still feel the same...anyone who believes the customer has no responsibility for securing their end of the connection is way off base in my opinion and is just dead wrong.

What folks on here, in my opinion, who say its the banks fault is preaching is what's wrong with this country to begin with...more and more, day by day its a blame someone ELSE mentality, we have sue happy people suing for stupid things (then when you have a REAL reason to sue, the court system fails...talk about irony) and everyone is allowed to sit back and be lazy and they just claim stupidity or igorance and that's supposed to make everything ok. Sorry I continue to say this guy screwed up way more than the bank did.

by mrafrohead

Very well put, but I have a few things to question...

First:

"The bank management should know that online banking is easily hijacked."

That actually would be the banks IS department. The bank managers are usually techno dolts... Scary thought I know, but man oh man, it's sadly true.

"Blaming ignorant end users for the consequences of trusing their bank is wrong. It is reasonable for bank customers to believe that their bank management has a better understanding of the technical issues associated with online banking than the average bank customer. It should be reasonable for the average bank customer to believe that their bank wouldn't put the customers' assets at risk."

I agree, but in this case, the bank didn't do it. The man infected his own computer and then from that he lost his information. The bank itself had no part what-so-ever in this scenario. At all. Now if the bank had been hacked and money was removed, that is completely different and at that point, I believe the bank would owe the funds + all fee's that may have incurred. I may even not complain if the users sued at that point, because then it would be actual negligence on behalf of the bank itself. But this man did it to himself, it wasn't the bank.

"In the U.S. many people hire a professional to fill out their tax forms each year. Why? Because keeping up to date about all of the tax code changes is a full time job. Would you blame a taxpayer for not knowing about some niche tax regulation? You shouldn't. The tax code is too complicated for people to be experts in that and in their own job expertise. That's why people hire experts to inform them about tax code regulations that affect them."

I've done my own taxes for the last 10 years. I've been doing them just fine and it only takes about an hour for me to do them. If I can do it so can anyone else. Again, I'm not the brightest bulb in the box. Though I do understand your point.

"Would you blame someone who uses a dietary supplement and has a bad reaction even though their was no mention of the risk on the label?"

No, but I would say that they should have consulted their DR before starting any type of medication, herbal suppliment or 'roids... ;p

Seriously, it's common knowledge and usually printed on labels of any kind of drug (beit herbs or chemicals) that you should consult your doctor first. That's very important, and here's an example why:

I read an article about a guy that was taking I think it was Ginkoba, and he decided to take an erectile disfunction drug. He ended up with a woody that lasted him DAYS!!! DAYS!!!!! He had to have surgery to get it to go down. He can no longer get it up and also, lives in pain. Not to mention, I'll bet his ego is scarred. The point is the Ginkoba and a key ingredient in the dysfunction drug reacted innapropriately. Had he asked his doctor, it may have been prevented (this is something that he said himself in the article). I feel truly bad for this man, but at the same time, it could have been prevented. And that was the point of the article to open peoples eyes to simple things like that...

"We expect that risky substances will not be available or will have the risks listed."

Echinacea is acutally a toxin to the body and if taken in excess and regularly, can kill you. Yet I know people that will pop it like candy just because they think they are being healthy. It's sold over the counter.

"The average person should not be expected to be an expert in computer security."

There's no need to be an expert at all. Computers are so dummied down now that it's silly to think that a user could get infected. Computers auto-update the OS, auto-update and configure the firewalls and A/V. There is truly no excuse.

"How many times do you hear about computer security on the evening news?"

About once a week, occassionally a little more. But I usually see something on the news once a week.

The banking customers if they are going to risk banking online should understand the risks that they are taking. NOTHING in a digital world is secure, NOTHING!

BUT there are steps (common sense steps) that can be taken to help prevent the risk, just like wearing a condom. Make sure when you connect to a site that before you enter your user/pass the connection is encrypted. Make sure your computer is CLEAN! Just those two simple little steps can make all of the difference. Otherwise, you may as well scream out of your window your SSN/Name/DOB/Address every single time you logon to your bank...

BTW - LOVE your nick!!! ;o)

by awfernald

1. Nobody twisted this guys arm to use online banking.
2. 100% guarantee that this gentleman had "signed off" on the banks on-line policies (whether he read them or not)
3. As far as requiring an "average" computer user to be an "equivalent to a professional system administrator" or an "expert in computer security", I disagree. Antivirus, spyware, etc... does NOT require a high level of computer knowledge. What it DOES require is asking someone who is trusted and PAID (maybe) to set up your computer. If you do it on your own, you take your own risks.

As far as comparisons go.... You walk out onto the streets of NYC with a ton of gold chains around your neck, diamond rings on your fingers, etc... Then you get mugged. Was it the polices fault? The doorman at your hotel's fault? Seems to me that you did not take the appropriate precautions, and you paid the price for it.

In this case, unless you have been in a cave (in which case you DON'T have a computer), you must have heard about computer virii, identity fraud, computer fraud, internet security problems, etc....

If you are working on a computer, doing your banking online, etc... and you choose to ignore all of this, or are too cheap to pay for some expert advice (hmmm, probably 1 hour of time at $25-50/hour), then what can we say? The bank is supposed to spend millions of dollars in security precautions so that you don't have to spend $50?

Granted that there are multiple places where this type of theft could have been prevented. But, in the end, it is the persons whose money was stolen who is responsible, because it was he who made the decisions, and neglected to take appropriate precautions to protect himself.

The bank could have stopped it, at a major cost and a major inconvenience to hundreds of thousands of clients.

The computer manufacturer could have stopped it by providing the appropriate software & updates. At significant expense to them in money and competitive margin.

The computer vendor could have stopped it by adding in the appropriate software & updates and teaching the user how to use them. At an expense to them in moeny and competitive margin.

The ISP could have stopped it by providing more information (or maybe it was there and the user didn't read it), providing anti-virus/firewall/anti-malware software (as Cox Communications is now doing for their broadband customers).

Or the user could have done it by taking responsibility for himself, and by asking questions, and taking some basic precautions.

by oz_media

The bank doesn't state ANYWHERE in ANY contracts you sign that it will accept responsibility for your own lack of security.

If someone steals you bank card after you tell them your pin number, is the bank responsible then? No it is common knowledge that you don't share your pin number, yet this was also NEW technology not that long ago.

The bank protects THEIR systems from being breached. Their system WASN'T breached. Therefore they have NOT breached their contract.

by erich1010

I agree. The bank should have warned the customer about potential dangers. Perhaps they did. In any case, the bank should know the dangers, itself, and provide some insurance against such fraud.

When you go into a restaurant and pay for a meal with a check or credit card, you are giving someone who probably makes minimum wages enough information to potentially clean out your bank account. That's why such transactions are usually insured in some way. The bank usually guarantees a limited liability for using such a service.

On the other hand, any business owner should have his own insurance against fraud. It is possible for him to get sued for breach of contract to his customers if he can't afford operating expenses. These things could wipe somebody out.

The person most at fault here is the hacker who stole the money. Unfortunately, there's little anybody can do to wring the cash out of him, if they can even find him.

by moira

I have to say I agree with amcol - nothing annoys me more than the arrogance of a lot of people who are knowledgeable about IT and rate everyone who isn't, as generally more stupid and lacking in intelligence than they are.

And if we go down the road of the original poster, are hospitals going to refuse to treat road accident victims because they "were too stupid to anticipate the lorry pulling out ahead of them" or "too inexperienced to know that the car coming towards them was going to fast to be turning left"?

IMO banks make enough money to absorb this kind of fraud (try overstepping your overdraft limit), and are also insured against precisely this kind of thing - costs they pass on to the client in any case.

Had the guy known his CC details were stolen and *not* informed the bank, that would be different, but we seem to be forgetting that the real blame belongs to the people who carried out the fraud in the first place. It's verging towards the theory that people ask to be mugged by carrying money around and the person who mugged them is innocent in comparison.

by amcol

I hadn't used the word "arrogance" up until now but you're exactly correct...that's just what it is. If I know something, then you should know it too, and if you don't you're an idiot who can't ambulate and respire at the same time.

It's the same attitude that leads people to believe, or express the opinion, that there's only one true way to see things. And it's always theirs, of course.

by mrafrohead

"nothing annoys me more than the arrogance of a lot of people who are knowledgeable about IT and rate everyone who isn't, as generally more stupid and lacking in intelligence than they are."

For starters:

I don't think that I am being arrogant at all with my stance on this. I don't consider myself to be an arrogant person, nor does anyone that I know.

Also, I don't think that people that don't understand IT are stupid or lacking in intelligence.

The problem I have is that this guy is trying to sue a bank, when the bank did nothing wrong. This "knowledgeable computer professional" chose to not install AV. He got burned from his choice.

That's where I have a problem.

I have no problems what so ever helping people that don't know anything, that's how you learn. That's how I learned. The more I learn, the more I learn I don't know jack...

As for lacking in intelligence, just because I am good at computers doesn't mean anyone else will be. I believe if I can do it so can you, BUT you may be good at physics, and I sure as hell am not.. Or Geometry... ;p

by jessie

AFAIC... the dude is out 20k and should be grateful that that's ALL he's out. Maybe he should sue M$ for allowing the popup that installed the trojan...

I work with several banks, and have worked with BoA before, and whenever there's "unusual activity" on my account, i.e. larger than normal sums of money, somebody at the bank always calls me to authorize the transaction. In a business account, a $90k transaction is presumably not all that unusual, so, really, what was the bank to do? Call him to authorize EVERY transaction? It's not their responsibility to make sure his computer is protected. I do know that all banks have a list of countries to which they do not do wire transfers, or to which all wire transfers must be authorized. As long as Latvia is not ON that list, then BoA did their due diligence in protecting his transactions.

For EVEN MORE stupidity, check out THIS link... RIAA SUES the DEAD

http://www.theregister.co.uk/2005/02/05/riaa_sues_the_dead/

by mrafrohead

What ever happened to being a responsible banking citizen and balancing the damned checkbook???

I mean, crap, banks used to count on that to detect fraud. Once a month you get a statement, then you check it with your records and report any discrepancies.

Come on now, saying that the freaking bank in anyway is liable is just assinine...

And the RIAA can burn in hell with the dillhole that is suing BoA... They're equally as bad in their own flowery special ways...

by tony hopkinson

The prepubescent, the poor and the dead.
I liked we'll try and cancel the case.
Oh dear couldn't, so we'll go for it in anyway ?

You know why they call heaven Heaven ?
Because there are no lawyers in it.

Say maybe the RIAA should have a look on this guys pc, just in case he got the trojan from an MP3/Warez site.

by husp1

the worst part of it all is that if he succeeds then he will have set a precident for all the others taken in by this type of scam to be able to sue and win, causing a huge problem for banks world wide. feel sorry for the guy but as was posted preveously it was his fault for not haveing proper securty for his system. hope he learns a good lesson from this and gets a good security package for his system.

by hal 9000

I hope the bank gives him their business to run. At least if that happened they would have a valid argument when they next want to raise their charges.

Col ]:)

by moira

Huge problems for banks worldwide? LMFAO ... the banks will take out more insurance and just pass the costs onto us.

However secure your system is, there is no such thing as totally safe. Unless there's clear evidence the guy acted in a way that would be deemed irresponsible for Mr Average, I don't think you can expect him to necessarily absorb the cost himself.

After all, when people don't take care of their health and end up in hospital with self inflicted illnesses, the NHS treats them for free.

by house

We have a client who just got infected with a long distance, 900 type porno line virus. She was charged almost $1000 in long distance. She was freaking out saying, "I've gotta lawyer... I'm suing!!!"

When I asked her who she was going to sue... she didn't know what to say. At first, I thought that she was going to blame us (ISP) as this is the typical response, but she couldn't answer the question.

by golfer740i

It is interesting that a business will hire a lawyer, accountant, buy insurance and do other things to protect themselves, but leave their information unprotected on their computers. This guy is responsible for his actions. I am sick and tired of people turning to a lawyer when they refuse to take ownership.

by notsochiguy

Perhaps BoA shareholders should get together and sue this guy; claiming that his negligence cost them profit (it will cost them money no matter what happens with the judgement)?

Personally, it seems as plausible as blaming the bank for failing to click UPDATE on your virus protection app.

Next time I have to pay $3 to use an out of network ATM or $5 to speak with a live person at my bank, I'll curse this ID10T to a long eternity without cold water or SPF 10000.

by jdmercha

Businesses hire lawyers to protect their assets, they hire accountants to manage their assets, and they get insurance to replace damaged or stolen asstets. The problem is that none of these people treat information as an asset.

by tomsal

I still disagree with you - strongly. If you think my post was insulting to you, that is something you have to deal with yourself -- because I said nothing intentionally defaming you or solely to hurt your feelings. I should add, that I believe my post matched the tone of your original post in fact.

Like another poster on here pointed out, should a bank call their BUSINESS accounts (that regularly do large dollar transactions) every single time? I think that is unreasonable. Our own company here does WAY more $90k transactions every month and we don't get a call each and every time, even if it's switching locations.

I stand by my post therefore. Like I said if you feel you were insulted, well my gut reaction is - I matched tone with the tone you set first and if you feel badly about it -- that's something you need to deal with.

I did read the article and I did read your post...Think first write last....I find that insulting. ;)

by amcol

I see no difference between a bank's responsibility to their personal and business customers. I expect my bank will call me if the pattern of my credit card usage is inconsistent with past usage. I pay fees to the bank to get this and other protections. If I don't get this level of protection, then thank God I live in a free country because I'll just take my business elsewhere.

Likewise, there's no difference in the management of business accounts. No, the bank shouldn't be expected to call any account, business or otherwise, every single time. However, when the usage pattern is clearly different, then yes, absolutely, in that case it's far from unreasonable to expect the bank to follow up.

Not that it matters at all, but I didn't say i was insulted. I said your post was insulting. My skin's pretty thick. I was objecting to your use of phrases such as "YOUR mentality and others who think the same as YOU, makes me sick". Should I not find that insulting?

by tomsal

"Your condescending attitude toward this, and that of the other posters who appear to agree with you, doesn't speak well for your character. If the shoe were on the other foot in an entirely different set of circumstances, I suspect you'd want all of us to be sympathetic to you."

That's what I was referring too when I said I merely matched my tone to the tone of your post. WE used different words, mine were intentionally said to prove a point. If you don't think what you posted (as I pasted above) isn't the same as what my line was..then you really have my logic confused.

I still disagree, but others on here make the point that I support much more clearly than I do - I admit that. I don't believe the bank is at fault in this particular case BASED ON WHAT THE ARTICLE states..now if you show me an expanded version of the article with more information that hints that someone slacked at the bank..I'd love to see it and then my opinion could be altered.

Bottomline this is a dangerous precedent to be set if this guy wins in court.

And I read your other replies to other posts. I certainly think ANYONE (pick the most uneducated person on the planet or the most brilliant...doesn't matter) needs to be responsible. You seem to be insisting the bank has a responsiblility to protect the consumer and I'm not saying this isn't true. I'm saying there has to be a point where the customer is liable for their own ignorance.

It doesn't seem unreasonble for a regular business account that is used all the time for large transactions, using secured connections that the bank doesn't call the customer on every transaction. Even if it is to a different location. Now where I'd be on your side is if Latvia (or whatever place the money went to) is on the "no no wire transfer list" of countries yet they let it go.

I just think the answer is extremely simple -- if you know NOTHING about using computers/the Internet why would you just go ahead and transfer $90,000 over it. That's putting a lot of faith in something you don't understand. In my world, that's called ignorance.

Ignorance is no excuse in this case.

If you don't know -- you ASK!.

by awfernald

I just read your next response, and am flabbergasted :)

Basically, what you are saying is that because US Secret Service agent was brought in (standard response to international monetary wire fraud) to trace what happened, that this guy couldn't have protected himself?

"You expect that your normal, average, everyday jerk is going to be able to protect himself against something the government had to be called in to uncover?"

As far as the "wiring money to Latvia" vs. "credit card ... raised a flag" statement. The money wire was made with a trusted account (the business owners), using a secured connection, assuming that the appropriate user name/password was used, the bank assumed it was real. Of course, credit card fraud is a totally different animal. Get the number, get the name/zip code, and it's easy to scam.

The trojan virus with wire money fraud is relatively recent compared to the sophisticated software they use for tracking credit card systems. Also, I believe that it's the credit card companies that utilize the software, not the specific issuing financial institutions, so, BoA may/may not have this type of software available, unless they have their very own, internally processed credit card.

by amcol

Thank you. You're proving my point.

My original objection to the original poster was his preposterous, condescending attitude that anyone with a single functioning brain cell knows enough to do whatever is necessary to protect their PC's, and the fact that this guy didn't do that means he's solely, 100%, no questions asked, completely responsible for the consequences.

My position is that it ain't necessarily so that even smart people know enough to take the necessary technological precautions. More importantly, I've also been saying that while the guy is certainly a victim of his own ignorance he's not in any way solely responsible. The bank has to shoulder a fair share since they didn't take reasonable steps to protect their customer.

You say this particular trojan virus is relatively recent. OK...so if the bank doesn't have the software to deal with this, we should expect some poor schnook running a little retail store in Miami to be able to do so?

In no way am I saying this is like that woman who sued McDonald's because she burned herself on their hot coffee when she spilled it in her lap. For her I harbor zero sympathy. This guy, on the other hand, certainly should have taken more proactive steps to protect his electronic assets...however, he's not only the architect of his own demise and a victim of the thieves who ripped him off, he's also a victim of a corporation that could have done more to protect its customers than it did.

by awfernald

It reminds me more of the case of our local school district losing over half a million dollars over a two year period due to fraudulent checks cashed in a bank in China.

The school blames the bank for taking so long to recognize the fraud and reacting, and of course, everyone else is wondering why the school district NEVER caught the fraud, even though following simple standard accounting practices like balancing your checkbook would have caught it almost immediately.

I actually think (due to the level of a large part of internet users out there), that the computer vendors need to take a more active role in protecting the user base by providing as a standard anti-virus/anti-malware software, and providing in writing some specific instructions as far as how-to protect yourself.

This will NOT happen due to economics, but, as I am currently starting small business building custom computers, I've already put this in as a standard, specifically to reduce the amount of follow up support I'll be expected to provide.

The user is the one ultimately responsible for his account, and regardless of what the banks actions/inactions in this case, the user took some sort of risk which resulted in him getting a virus. Was this his fault? maybe, maybe not, maybe even if he DID have his anti-virus software updated, that particular virus would have gotten through due to it's "newness".

However, if he did have anti-virus installed, and up-to-date, and if he did have a personal firewall program installed which blocked outgoing communications unless specifically permitted, and he did read all the popups and didn't blindly click on "Yes" to everything, etc.... I would say that he probably would not have gotten "screwed" by the bug.

So, in summary, I think we all agree that the USER is the one to blame and be held responsible, and I think we also all agree that the BANK could take some action (at a large pricetag though) that would have prevented this, and further, though I haven't read elsewhere about this, I think we all will probably agree that the computer INDUSTRY and the internet PROVIDERS could have taken some actions (whether training or packaging) which would have averted this situation.

However, in this case, the user will get his money back (BoA is already working on this), and everyone will go along all happy, and maybe 3-4 years down the road, one (or all) of the above groups will take some type of action that would assist in preventing this type of stuff from occurring.

by mrafrohead

So you're what I'm reading here is that before you log into your bank site and initiate and "personal information transfers" that the bank should FIRST run a full virus/trojan scan on your computer to verify that you haven't allowed yourself to be compromised?

Dude, you have to live under a freaking rock to not know that AV/FW is damn near mandatory.

The bank legally needs to encrypt the signal, if the end user has a logging program on their end, how is the bank supposed to do anything about that, or even be able to KNOW about it without violating your privacy. If they just did a scan on your box for bugs, that would be an invasion of privacy and then there'd be some other jerkoff complaining about that.

Your own computer is your OWN responsibility. If you aren't ABLE to run it then do the rest of us a favor and DONT! It's not different than driving a car. If you can't do that either, then just don't.

by amcol

You're absolutely right...all we know is, as you say, "based on what the article says". It's slanted, as all articles are, to make a particular point.

A dirty little not-so-secret secret of the media is that you don't just find editorials on the editorial page. EVERYTHING in the media is editorialized...of course it is, because it's created by free willed human beings who all have their own point of view, and deliver news reports through media outlets that all have particular editorial policies.

This article's intent was for us to shake our heads at the NERVE of this man, who DARED to think that he could make the bank pay for his obvious mistake. OK, maybe because I've worked thirty years in Fortune 500 financial institutions and have a wee bit of knowledge about this subject, I'm in a better position than most to be able to read between the lines.

Let me help you a bit with your logic. You say you matched the tone of my post, therefore it wasn't insulting. Or, it was only as insulting as mine. My comment about "think first, write last" referred to the fact that the strong words I used to refer to the original poster were included on purpose. I meant to be insulting. I thought about it first, because I found his attitude and the way he expressed himself to be immature and imbecilic. Your post smacked of emotionalism, and since you strike me as an intelligent person I doubt very much if we were face to face you'd say what you said.

by amcol

I agree with most of what you've said, but not with the part about computer vendors not including perimeter controls due to economics.

They don't include this stuff to limit their own potential legal liability. If PC providers included antivirus, antimalware, firewall, etc., then we could all claim when hacked that it wasn't our fault but that of the provider.

In a way that is economics, although I suspect you meant it as a reference to the price of the software and not the cost of losing lawsuits. If I were you, I'd think about this in light of the business you're starting.

This is precisely what this news article has been about, and the crux of my position in the matter. The guy is partially responsible because only he could have put appropriate protections on his own PC, but the bank is also partially responsible because part of their service is to catch suspect transactions before they're executed. It's a shared responsibility.

In your case, you're proposing to put the protections in place on the PC's you provide. Your service could be interpreted as providing complete protection, and might make you solely responsible for any nastiness that results. I'd consult with an attorney well versed in this area of the law if I were you.

by jdmercha

Typically law suits are filed against people/companies that can afford to pay.

In this case I agree that a lawsuit should be filed. But not against the bank. The suit should be filed against the creator of the virus.

How many viruses would be written if the author knew that he could be sued, or put in jail at any time for the rest of his life.

by awfernald

basically, even if they follow the instructions to the letter, there is still a risk of an infection, and my company is indemnified against all damages, losses, etc... yadda yadda.

Basically, the only thing I'm responsible for is that if they have a virus/malware issue, then I am responsible (for a service fee) for fixing it, or they can restore from the install CD, which of course wipes their hard drive.

by thechas

Actually, this case presents us with a new IT opportunity.

More than likely, this guy had to click on an accept box agreeing to the terms of his bank's on-line access agreement.

The agreement either exonerates the bank, or limits the banks liability should the customer provide his account information in any manner to another party.

In place of the simple "agree" button, we can introduce a "test" that verifies that the user has indeed read and understands the agreement.

Jobs for legal consultants,

Jobs for programmers,

Jobs for support staff to explain to the potential user WHY they cannot get access until they pass the test.

I myself wonder why he is not suing Microsoft, or the maker of the software that stores his account number and password information.

Chas

by bfilmfan

Let's sell that project to him.

Cobble up some code.

When it half-way works, call it a success.

Sell a new client on the method and tell them how well we did it for this guy.

Ya ever notice how a lot of projects act like a herd of locusts? They arrive, eat up all your resources and then fly away leaving you with dust?

Perhaps I should start a blog on that..haha

by amcol

You're being facetious, of course, but how many of us alleged professionals are guilty of clicking blindly through those annoying disclaimers and license agreements ourselves?

There's been a lot of talk in some states about equipping cars with breathalyzers, so drunk drivers can't get behind the wheel. This is, to a certain extent, the electronic equivalent.

Click on the "agree" button. Then, another box pops up with three or four questions making sure you understood what you just agreed to. Sorry, no peeking...you can't click your "back" button and reread the agreement. Just answer the questions, and if you get them wrong you're out. Do not pass "Go". Do not collect $200.

Of course, no financial institution or software vendor would do this because there's FAR too many people out there who are just what they want...ignorant customers. Make sure they know what they're signing? Oh oh, no thanks, bad for business. Just pay the money, folks, we'll take care of you. And if we can't...well, that's too bad, you should have known better.

The overall sad theme of the original article and this thread, and the thing that a lot of posters have been missing. Bank of America COULD NOT HAVE CARED LESS about our poor unfortunate friend from Miami. He got into trouble...no big deal, we're the big bad bank with a lot of big bad lawyers, so even if he sues us (not bloody likely since we can intimidate the hell out of him) we'll crush him like a rotten grape. And if he takes his business elsewhere...no big deal, we're the big bad bank with the big bad business and we can always get more customers.

And THAT'S why I've been maintaining the bank has to shoulder some responsibility here.

by hal 9000

The next in line after he finishes with the bank and looses big time.

Think of it this way as I've often been told by my friends/fiends in the legal profession those with the big money alway win in the end. Even when they loose they appeal and have the matter tied up in the court system for years if not decades. If the bank was to follow this course of action his grandchildren could still be fighting the case and by that time the 90K would be worth about $1.50 when inflation is allowed for.

Col ]:)

by mrafrohead

@amcol
"What possible business could a Miami printer ink and toner dealer have in Latvia?"

What possible business could a Miami printer ink and toner dealer have in Latin America???

" the US Secret Service was called in and had to do a forensic examination of his PC in order to identify what happened."

They probably JUST installed a freakin a/v program to just take a peak.

"The bank didn't protect him either, and they bear some responsibility for that. I don't see this as black and white as you do...it's a shared responsibility, and since the man's only asking for his money back I don't think he's deserving of the vitriolic reaction the original poster had."

The bank owes us nothing! And I don't feel that I should have to pay for this jerk being stupid and ignorant and lazy! Yes, that's right, you and me will pay for this (if you are a BoA customer).

"Nor do I think I deserve your insulting post, considering you obviously didn't read either the article or my post too terribly carefully. Think first, write last."

Per TomSal's response, I believe that he was talking about readint the "news article" not your post front to back. If that's the case, as that's how I interpretted it, follow your own advice...

by mrafrohead

"They don't include this stuff to limit their own potential legal liability. If PC providers included antivirus, antimalware, firewall, etc., then we could all claim when hacked that it wasn't our fault but that of the provider."

Microcrap is building their malware program as we speak. You can get the beta version right now if you so desire, and XPSP2 has it's firewall.

MS also acquired an A/V company not too long ago, and has researched starting their own AV program.

Computer vendors sell their boxes with Windoze, which means it comes with these products...

by russell

If you're car was stolen and used to rob your local bank which held your money I doubt if you would be too amused.
His money was taken from his bank by criminals. His claim is that the bank knew of the threat from the trojan and yet didn't put any security in place to defend it.
I think he every right to try and reclaim his money - it's the banks responsibility to ensure the money in its care is safe.

by tony hopkinson

The bank would not be amused if you left your keys in the car, put a big sign on top of it saying please use this to rob my bank, and then parked it outside a place frequented by bank robbers would they.

The bank did, they verified his account, his passord etc. Someody else used it, cause he left them lying about where a criminal could get hold of them. If he wrote his pin number on his ATM card, would you have the same opinion ?

Security on this guy's system was effectively non-existant. Wonder if he's sorted it out yet ?

We can only hope for maybe some more PR security from the banks and a raise in customer awareness of the potential risks to on-line banking.
Nothing else good is going to come of the court case, unless your a lawyer.

by jdmercha

Lets say I leave my checking acount information and my drivers license out on my coffee table. I then lock my house while I go to work. My twin brother finds out that someone in our neighborhood is randomly unlocking houses. So my brother eventually finds my house unlocked, comes in and picks up my ID and bank info. Then he goes to the bank and withdraws $90k from my account.

IMHO
The bank should be insured to cover the loss. The bank should then go after my brother to recover the stolen funds.
I should then go after my brother for enting my house and taking my personal information. And I should also go after whoever unlocked my house.

by tomsal

If my car was stolen and used to rob my local bank..that is a COMPLETELY totally different situation entirely. That's not even comparing apples to oranges its comparing a candy bar to a vegetable.

by tomsal

But are you implying you are a tough guy or something? I know that may get you worked up, but I swear I'm just trying to ask a question and not meaning it as some smart arse remark.

The reason I ask is because you said the same thing in a post to me and now to someone else "I find it hard to believe if we were face to face you say the same thing.."

I can't speak for anyone else..but actually Yes I would say the same thing if we were face to face -- not because I think I'm a tough guy though..its because I call it personally integrity..If we are a coward to speak what we feel truly about something...I just don't think that says alot about us as individuals.

by amcol

No implications, and I'm not trying to be tough or anything else. Just myself.

I never write anything anywhere that I wouldn't say to someone's face. That's how I make sure I'm saying what I really mean.

Unfortunately, I find that same quality is relatively rare. I've had thousands of conversations over the years with people who I've called out on something they've said in an e-mail or memorandum or report or whatever, and they start backpedaling all over the place.

Say what you mean, mean what you say. If I'm honest with you I expect you to be honest with me. Maybe I'm being naive. I've been called worse.

by tomsal

Well I know we have had somewhat "hot" debates over this topic but I have appreciated the fact that you stick by your guns and you cut me as an honest person. And I appreciate that, I hope you understand I veiw myself in the same way -- and I know I sometimes come out blunt, but it comes with the territory unfortunately when you are honest, direct and stick by your guns.

Thanks for understanding I was just asking a question.

ps. I still think the guy bears most of the responsibility in this one though..LOL! :)

by mrafrohead

That is an extremely fair expectation!

I don't see any naivety (if that's a real word) in it what-so-ever.

As for being called worse, I'll bet I've got you topped:

I was once called "A Creepy Hermit"...

Man, that one was so below the belt it took a week before I felt the full effects, not to mention, it sadly enough may be true... ;p

by amcol

From your post:

"there is a line of responsiblility"

"to a certain point the bank is responsible"

"anyone who believes the customer has no responsibility for securing their end of the connection is way off base in my opinion and is just dead wrong"

"I continue to say this guy screwed up way more than the bank did"

Precisely. The guy is wrong. And the bank is wrong. Both of them.

I'm not assessing relatively degree of wrongness...the bank is more wrong than the guy, or the guy is more wrong than the bank. My objection has been to the posters who view this as a simple binary event. It's not, nothing ever is.

by amcol

Frankly, I've enjoyed the interaction with you not only because you strike me as honest but your intelligence is also obvious. Your comments add to the dialogue. The only part I was a little unhappy about was when you got a bit emotional and said something I found disrespectful.

There's nothing necessarily wrong with being disrespectful. I'm certainly that way to certain people myself. But I try to limit my disrespect to people that earn it...like the original poster, who for some reason seems determined to be as troll-like as possible. I have no patience for nonsense. We're all adults and professionals on this board (presumably)...a certain decorum and expression of intelligence is a reasonable expectation. Save the juvenile, mindless claptrap for somewhere else.

And I respect your opinion. You don't have to agree with me, and I don't have to agree with you. How boring the world would be if we all saw things the same way.

Don't apologize for being blunt. Candor and forthrightness are rare qualities.

Here's hoping our paths cross again sometime.

by hal 9000

I have a friend who is a brilliant surgeon and I'm constantly on his back to install the latest AV Updates or the next generation of AV product. To him this just isn't important until he starts getting e-mails back telling him his computer is infected with XYZ virus/Trojan or whatever then it is panic stations and things have to be fixed immediately.

Now this is on his home computer and he doesn't do on line banking only has power point slide shows for lectures and the like and for sending/receiving semi-personal e-mail. I was literally bashing him over the head last year to install the new version of Norton's and it took me 6 months to get in to do it so I stuck on AVG at the same time just to be on the safe side.

Then for something scary a possible new client that I went out to today, they have Windows 95 unpatched in any way no AV, no Firewall no nothing they just expect the computers to work. The only thing I can say in their defense was the previous manager didn't touch his computer and had a card system it was the cleanest old box I've ever seen but the new manager talks about this being a steam powered computer {That is the only printable thing I can use here :D}

I fixed the immediate problem which was a data save & reload of Windows 95 which wasn't all that easy as it's been a long time since I've actually used 95.

But the best thing that really got me was one dial up Internet connection so if the receptionist wants to send an e-mail or check her incoming stuff everyone else has to get off line so she can do that. Of course the same applies to everyone else and when I suggested networking the units with a single High Speed Internet connection I was asked what a "Network" was! Then I was told we want to keep our existing e-mail address so we need to stay with what we have. I just explained that was not the case and that they could retain their Domain and e-mail address and still have a high speed Internet connection as well as a Dial up connection for the LT when the people where out in the field and I could even connect them to their digital phones so if there wasn't a phone socket handy they could still dial in to see what was there. They thought I was talking Science Fiction and that this was just plain impossible or it would break the bank to implement. I did explain that using the Cell phones to dial up was expensive but because of the type of work that they do it would allow them to stay in touch but was mainly only as a backup for the work situations when they had to get something urgent through. But the rest was relatively cheap to implement and would in all likely hood be saving them money.

Then I suggested to the owner that there where tax benefits in having new hardware not to mention the lost productivity with all the old hardware and asked hadn't their account suggested something similar?

I'll see what develops but they sell multi million dollar equipment and that is the best that they have in the place.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Don't ever write something down and expect it to be read. I do exactly the same as you are doing and while I do provide written documentation with every system I don't expect it to be read so I tell them. Over and over in as many ways as possible about the {potential} problems of Electronic Fund Transfers I also tell them right from the start not to expect any guarantee on HDD's that are used in computers where EFT are used as it is just far too dangerous to let the data out of your control and a HDD is far cheaper.

Now for the Bank in question, they will be factoring in fee increases to cover their loss in this particular incident that everyone will be paying in the future.

I've worked for banks and the only certainty with them is that they are going to make money out of each and every customer that they have no matter what! If you don't like it they think you are not worth the effort and welcome you taking your business elsewhere as they in all likelihood will still be making money of you in some form further down the line.

The only good thing to come out of this story is that I've sent it to every one of my customers to help reinforce just how potentially dangerous Electronic Banking actually is, it really makes them sit up and listen when they realize that they can be hit in the hip pocket so they then if only for a short time keep things up to date before the next jolt that comes along to get them to do the right thing again. Some people for unknown reasons just have to click on the "YES" button every time it appears without thinking. While they drive me nuts they also keep in a job so I shouldn't complain too much.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

What I do find interesting here is the way that people seem to want to blame the bank for allowing this to happen. Actually they are attempting to protect their own industry rather than the person in question.

If the same thing had of happened because he left a blank singed check laying about do you think there would be a different response?

Just because he didn't know in my books is no defense as it was his job to know not pass the buck to someone else. Sure the bank is at fault but mainly because they allowed him to have access to on-line banking.

Over this side of the pond things are quite different and every customer is given a booklet explaining the potential risks associated with on-line banking as well as being informed when they set it up or at least they should be if they can be bothered to listen when they make the application.

I'll agree that nothing is ever 100% safe but you should at the very least make it as hard as possible for things like this to happen, not leave an open door for someone to walking and take what they want.

Col

by tomsal

I'm a little confused since your response is exactly my point all along but it seems like you are trying to convince me of your point. In other words -- well said! That's my point too!

My base argument is some folks on this thread -- the ones screaming foul at the bank, are saying (to me anyways) -- its ok if you are ignorant, ignorance is a perfect excuse and that shall hold you harmless.

by mrafrohead

One of my absolute most favorite sayings ever:

Thank you Matrix!!!!

I know this steak isn't real. I know it's just in my mind, but I just can't get over how good and juicy it is. Man, Ignorance is Bliss...

by mrafrohead

That is one thing I think we could do different in the US.. A little more stringent authentication requirements for online banking.

But why would we do that, it's not as convenient and costs a little more money.. I mean, it's not like we really have anything to lose do we??? Well, except for 90,000 dollars... Oh, so I guess we do have something to lose, so maybe it would be worth it.

And in all honesty, you would have to live in a hole to not know that there are risks of doing financial transactions online.

But as long as it's easy, most people don't care, nor will they take the time to protect themselves. Look at Windoze for peats sake. Or better yet, Microsoft BOB...

I happen to live in a country full of fat lazy people that like to pass the buck. Granted I'm fat and lazy, but I accept my own faults, and I don't point fingers at others when I should be pointing them at myself. Which kinda sucks as it makes things more difficult on me at times, BUT it sreally is the right thing to do... On a side note, you know how hard that is to teach to your kids??? Bleh, that's another topic for another thread...

The problem is, if the bank didn't give him access to online banking, this jerkoff would probably sue for discrimination for some reason...

Mrafrohead

by hal 9000

Laughing. You're probably right he would sue for discrimination if he wasn't allowed this option.

Over here I've seen cases where people have sold off old computers and then cried foul when they loose not only their bank account savings but their houses as well. The really idiot thing is that they know just how vulnerable On line Banking is and they take steps to prevent it from happening but them take their brains out of their heads put them in a nice glass jar on a shelf and sell off an old computer with all of its data intact.

They honestly can not understand that the data is on the HDD and when they sell their old computer it is still there even though they transfer the data across to the new one. Some how magically it gets removed from the old one and moved to the new one. At least it hasn't happened to one of my customers and I doubt it ever will as I always make sure that once a HDD enters a business it stays with that business until it is destroyed warranty just isn't a word in my Vocabulary when it comes to data protection.

Actually you will not find a person who is lazier them I am buy I have the idea if you do it properly the first time you don't see it again!

It's not because I'm a perfectionist but I just don't want to see the bloody thing again once I've fixed it once I shouldn't need to fix it again because I'm not doing my job right and worse still the second time it is costing me money not the owner.

Anyway all my staff work the same way maybe I've warped their brains by now as they all have come around to my way of thinking except of course the office manager who thinks she owns the business and I'm a necessary evil that she has to put up with. When I went out to jobs where they had been ripped off by so called professionals I fixed the messes at a reasonable rate just to gain the customers confidence and at least make them think that everyone in IT isn't out to rip them off as much as possible well the OM used to go nuts over this and complain that I was stealing from the company although how I can steal what I own is quite beyond me but she had all the others scared of her now I'm hearing when something similar crops up and I can't attend for at least the initial fix "Talk to Col!" being said to the OM who never mentions a single word to me.

Finally they are breaking her into my way of working she may not be overly happy but she isn't game to make a complaint to me as the last time that she did I went off the deep end saying he charged way too much I'll talk to him and you'll have to organize a refund. :D

Well what can I say she used to get to me so a little scare didn't hurt.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

If this guy had left a blank singed check laying about would you still be saying the same thing?

After all he is supposed to run a business and while I do accept that the bank bears some responsibility so does the user who choses to use this service. He/She should know enough to at the very least have the basics covered or they do not belong in that position in the first place.

Now if it was one big transaction that was carried out to a previously unused source it should have been at the very least postponed until it was certified that it was a real transaction by the person involved but if it consisted of several smaller transactions over a period of time then that is a different story. Until we get to hear the full story of what exactly happened we'll never know for sure and more to the point I'm betting that none of those involved want the full story to get out because it would just make it that much easier for like minded people to do the same thing to someone else.

Col

by amcol

If he'd left a blank check laying around without a care in the world, he'd get exactly what he deserved and have no one but himself to blame. The question is where you draw the line.

EVERYONE knows to keep their blank checks secure. NOT EVERYONE knows how to cyber-protect themselves.

You said it yourself..."He/She should know enough to at the very least have the basics covered". Precisely. But what are the basics?

Installing perimeter controls and keeping them updated is hardly what any reasonable person would classify under "the basics".

Do you smoke? There's mountains and mountains of evidence that smoking gives you lung cancer. Why aren't you protecting yourself? Will you expect sympathy from all of us when you're on your deathbed?

Do you go out in the sun? There's more mountains of evidence that too much exposure leads to skin cancer. Why aren't you protecting yourself? Will you expect sympathy from all of us when you're on your deathbed?

Do you drink? Over consumption of alcohol leads to cirrhosis of the liver. Why aren't you protecting yourself? Will you expect sympathy from all of us when you're on your deathbed?

Where do YOU draw the line?

by hal 9000

Now what hasn't been reported is if the money went in one hit or dribs and drabs. But no matter what he should have hired someone to at the very least tell what was required to secure his computer. You can bet he has an accountant, a Legal Representative and insurance to cover any injuries that may occur in the work place so why didn't he have someone to at the very least consult on computer security.

What is not known by us at least here is just what else has been copied as well. This is one thing that most people do not realize that DATA has a VALUE if only to the company involved but so very little is actually done by business to protect this data and its value to them.

I've seen numerous examples of what borders on Criminal Stupidity by companies and only yesterday I saw another example where the company has Win 95 unpatched in any form no AV product internal Modems constantly connected to a phone line while the computers are switched on and absolutely no thought put into any form of security. They have a Dead Locks on the Door and Intrusion Alarms in the building but absolutely no computer protection at all. It's not as if they haven't been warned they just do not think there is any real risk and when something eventually happens they will be the ones kicking and screaming about just how unfair things are, but if you where to suggest that they treat their products like their computers you would get a stupid look and be asked if you are insane or something.

Now what would happen if a business man in the same position took his LT and went on the road, while he stops for smokes a drink and fuel his LT gets stolen and they access the bank account details directly from his unprotected LT because he doesn't even have the bare minimum of a password lockout. Yes I know it will not stop the professional but most of these crimes are not committed by real professionals but by those who get lucky and stumble across something that they shouldn't have.

Now should the bank dish out a large amount of funds to an unknown entity in one hit "HELL NO" they should have checked that the transaction was legit first before transferring the money. But if it was sent out in what started as small amount and then got larger that would appear as a normal business transaction with a new supplier.

While I've worked for banks I'm no great lover of them and I actually dislike them intensely but I just can not see how the bank has done everything wrong in this case. There is more than enough blame to spread around to all the parties involved particuarly the person responsible for writing the virus/malware if that is what actually happened.

Have you heard of any similar occurrences happening with others? If it was a true malicious code exploitation wouldn't there be far more people adversely affected?

But I honestly do not think that this particular person applied "Due Diligence" in his actions by not having at the very least some form of AV product fully updated in place. If he even had that minimum he would in my humble opinion have a far better case against the in question.

Remember we are not talking about a home owner here who just has a computer to play games and do a bit of banking this was supposed to be a business man and if he ran his business this badly just how did it survive to this point in time?

From the report I see it as an attempt to get money fraudulently from a bank because of a failing business. White Collar crime is the growth industry in the Western World and to me this just looks like a good example of it.

Col

by awfernald

Actually, you assume that everyone knows to keep their blank checks secure....

However, that is not the case. But, the bank tells people about keeping them safe. Just the same as the bank tells you about keeping your login/password safe to your online account.

In this case, just as if a person were looking over you shoulder at the ATM when you punched in your PIN, a thief stole the information by "looking over his shoulder" electronically.

The bank CAN reasonably be expected to put up barriers to prevent theft. However, the bank can NOT reasonably be expected to track millions/billions of "routine" transactions on a daily basis to detect fraud from stolen account information.

I'm just surprised the bank did it without having all the federal forms filled out for sending $10k+ overseas. Maybe the guy wasn't really a ink supplier, maybe he was really a money launderer.

by mrafrohead

Something I have been thinking about since last night with this guy...

What about all of his customers information???

I mean, if he had his banking information "borrowed", then that means that the chances of his customers personal information being lost is just as likely.

Do you think this dillhole will contact his customers and tell them?? I'll bet not because he's too busy crying and pointing fingers.

Better yet, if his customers actually lose money because their information had been compromised, do you think that this guy would even consider giving them the money that they lost back? I'll bet not...

Something else to consider.

This guy should be prosecuted for neglect!

by mrafrohead

"Now let's suppose you decide that because you live in a high crime area you're going to store your valuable stuff at Acme Safekeeping Company. You pay them a reasonable fee for putting your stuff in their safe, and you have a reasonable expectation it's going to be there when you go to claim it, right?"

This is NOT what happened here. The bank was safe! It was this clowns computer that was not. By your accounts, here's how the example should have gone.

The buttmonkey puts his stuff into Acme Safekeeping Company, gets his keys to the storage locker and then tapes it to the side of his car which is parked on the street with a BIG neon sign that says "MY ACME SAFEKEEPING COMPANY KEY - KEEP SAFE - FOR BOX NUMBER 420". Where everyone and their grandmother can see it. Someone will take it eventually.

That's what he did, now he's crying because he was a retard about it and lost his own money. The bank DID NOT, I repeat, DID NOT! lose it for him.

As for me "hiding behind an alias", dude, you'd be surprised. I'd actually have a lot more to say if we were face to face. I talk faster than I type and I only want to type so much.

by amcol

Talking with you is a complete waste of time. Your ideas are foolish, your mannerisms puerile, you have the maturity level of a two-year old, you use insulting and derogatory references, and you add nothing to the dialogue. You don't belong on this board since all you do is clutter it up, and I'm done wasting my time with you. Others may do as they wish.

by mrafrohead

Man, I think... I think I'm going to cry...

You haven't exactly been the nicest either... ;)

And having the maturity of a two year old is by far better than that of a one year old, so I guess I'm better off than I thought.

You seem to forget, that this would the a thread that I started, I didnt' start it to be nice. Consider that.

This waste of skin that is sue happy needs to be thumped hard, he along with Ms. McDonalds (the old chic that won all of that money) are causing more problems in this country. They should be deported to the sun. Those sue happy people are the reason our health care costs so much, as well as other trivial things.

There is no excuse what so ever for this lamer to sue his bank when he was at fault for what he did to himself. He should be ashamed of himself. If I was him I would not be able to walk with my head up any longer, I would be completely ashamed of myself...

And apparently I added something (maybe not too much, but something) to the dialogue as you did intially respond didn't ya...

This thread is more of a venting thread. I'm disgusted with the status quo in this country with sue happy people and ignorant people that won't take responsibility for their computers. Oh, I got a virus, silly me. Oops, I just lost my bank information, darn. It's their OWN fault, I'm sick of these piss poor excuses to defer fault from each person that gets themselves into trouble!!!

by bhunsinger

Rather, he carries the key in his pocket, with a tag on it that says "ACME SAFEKEEPING COMPANY KEY - KEEP SAFE - FOR BOX NUMBER 420". He goes to the gym and hangs his closes in the locker, using the lock that comes with the locker. While he is swimming, devious bathouse attendant, uses duplicate key to mak a wax impression of the acme key, and uses that impression to make a key, etc.
It is just not as clear to everyone as you make it out to be.
As for the law suit, it gives the guy some leverage on the bank to get them to free up the money that is sitting in an account in Latvia. BoA does have an internal credit card last I looked, and should be suspicious of sudden activity like that.
Did you see that he is trying to save his business.? that the bank inLatvia is holding $70,000 of his money- what seems to be his working capital? Is he as much of an idiot as you say? Last month the cops barely stopped a multi person ring out of russia targeting accounts. A little compassion might well be in order.

by oz_media

He has already taken out another mortgage and decided not to use online banking again.

His lawsuit is unjust, if it ever sees a courtoom.

BOA has already stated that it is NOT their responsibility because they were not themselves breached and it is up to him to take a suit out upon the bank in Latvia.

As for the raising a red flag on a sudden transfer.

He apprently does this with larger sums of money on a regular basis himself, what red flag should be raised that may impede the flow of business when it is business as usual?

If I had read about the poor guy losing everything I would have been sympathetic and it may have even became a lesson on personal security for other people.

When he tries to start outlandish lawsuits that no bank or judge is going to take seriously, one loses all respect. And judging from the case he's opened, he is TRYING to sue for FAR more than he's lost. Seen this crap too many times first hand to take such tripe seriously.

by mrafrohead

He chose to not get a/v software in his own business. That was a very stupid mistake that cost him a lot of money.

He earned that theft. He allowed it to happen.

He basically stamped I have 90 grand in my pocket and took a leisurely stroll through a neighborhood of theives.

The bank has nothing to do with what this man did to himself and he should be ashamed of himself for suing the bank.

If he had just asked the bank for help, that would be one thing and I would shut my freakin mouth, but the lawsuit is what has me all fired up. There is NO justification for him to sue someone else for a problem that he brought onto himself.

He could have taken that 90K and spent 50 bucks or hell even used the free MS A/V that was offered to him and he wouldn't be in this boat.

It's his own fault.

by mrafrohead

But then again, I don't know who should be more scared, me or you... ;p wocka wocka

Spooky how similar we tend to be considering out introduction... ;p

You kick ass oz!

by awfernald

Or they could require all of their clients to obtain bio-authentication devices, and have their own techs go out and set it all up, etc...

Of course, that's kinda expensive as well, but, one day soon.

by oz_media

Thanks mate, that's a real rib tickler.

I found another, more in-depth article if you like.
http://deposits.interest.com/content/articles/deposits_story.asp?story_id=64534630&ID=interest

Also, here's dumb dumb's website if you want to send him a god laugh. http://www.ahlo.net/eng/about.htm

So I'm reading this article thinking 'this lawyers just a nobody who's trying to make a name for himself with some breakthrough lawsuit'.

The lawyers OWN comments, "If you lost $5,000, you are going to walk away from that $5,000 because there isn't an attorney in town who will take the case," Patino said.

Indicating he is doing this to make a name for himself and open up the world to a string of unjust lawsuits that will in turn stem into other areas of WHO's responsible, right down to the ISP if they choose.

Whadda PUTZ! You can just picture the greasy bugger

So here's some fun from the article I found:

First of all:
"Bank of America knew of the coreflood virus," Patino said. "Why not tell their customers?"

okay, the bank should tell their customers of virus threats that may jeopardize security.

THEN
"Patino cites a letter from Bank of America to customers in July recommending they strengthen their security measures as proof that the bank knew online banking was risky. He and Lopez say a large wire transfer to Latvia, which is known in financial circles for its problems with cybercriminals, should have raised a red flag."

Okay so you have been warned, the BANK's system is up to date, obviously, and they are openly admitting and informing customers of a security risk.

So far, I would say it is CLEARLY the customer's responsibility and any security implied by contract by the bank has been removed from further blame if YOU are infected, no more breach of contract.

BOA's response: No bottom feeder lawyer trying to make a name for himself.
"... the bank was not responsible for the loss because no one hacked into its system to initiate the wire transfer.?

OOOOOH! Nobody BREACHED the bank's security and therefore they have NOT breached their promise of security!

What a farce! They MAY take it to court because the little lawyer has his heart set on it, IF a court has a judge that will see the case that is.

The guy doesn't have half a matchstick to stand on, this is the weakest case I have seen a lawer take on in a looong time, if not THE weakest. Yet BOA has the most ROCK solid defense that you could possibly muster.

The bank warned him, beyond their duty, the guy even admits he received the warning.

The bank was NOT breached in anyway, their systems provided ALL of the protection and security you are assured they will.

But more importantly, the BANK didn't lose a dime, thus they really couldn't care less and it is up to HIM to collect his lost money, their job was legally done.

"Heilbron wrote that Parex had told Bank of America that any action to recover the funds would require a request to Latvia's Office of the Prosecutor for a criminal investigation. "Since we are not responsible for the fraud and have not ourselves sustained a loss, we are not in a position to make such a request,"

You just gotta laugh at what some lawyers are willing to do to get their name out there. This one has even convinced the loser that he has a case! Let's hope the judge is as dumb as the guy who can't use virus protection.

What do they expect, a weekly virus list update from the bank? BOA AntiVirus software?
Even if the bank DID provide a full Antivirus System and a list of every threat, many wouldn't update it or read the lists.

Then they would say it's BOA's responsibility to force updates, then a few months later someon would sue BOA for taking over their PC and being too nosey.

Oh when is someone going to invent something to make the computer obsolete?

by tony hopkinson

Even Parex of Latvia leapt on it after one transaction. Looks like everybody did their job except this Lopez guy.
His web site is class, Weeks of IT effort, got products I've never heard of as well. What's an
ikjet cartridge. Also got products he's never heard of called 'page not found'.
What do you charge for a twelve page website and a bit of advice on computer security in the US ?

Must be a lot, poor guy was saving money by doing it himself.

by mrafrohead

but... this is directly from this dillhole's site:

"A full time staff, all veterans of the computer industry,"

If they were really all veterans of the computer industry, they would have been smart enough to truly have a/v software AND their site would be functioning properly. No "page not found" errors... ;p

Man, I develop web sites as well as I eat cardboard, because i've never had to try or had to do it. Meaning not well at all, but if I was putting that out for a business of mine, I would have put the time and energy into it to make it worth it!

by mrafrohead

Maybe we should just cause the internet to crash.

that might help fix the problem right there... then the stupid users couldn't even connect.

OH wait, I forgot, we don't need to stop the internet, just AOL... ;p

Better yet, we can use that dipsh*t's computer as the start of the backbone DoS since we know it was comprimised. Probably still isn't fixed either...

Ha ha ha ahahahahahaaaaa

And I am only joking, should anyone take me serious on this one.

by mrafrohead

I can't believe you found this to be funny.

This is a VERY serious thing and the man who is taking the lawsuit deserves your sympathy!

D4mn you oz, what is wrong with you?

Oh, the inhumanity!!!!!!

Oh, wait, I forgot, blehahahahehehahahahehehahhehhheeeeeooooaaa....

by hal 9000

Misrepresenting itself when you see things like this on their web page. :D

"The company goal is to provide the most efficient and reliable framework to deliver a complete line of quality computer and copier supplies at very competitive pricing. AHLO, Inc. has assembled a highly professional team to deliver its commitment to both its customer and vendors."

If the "Highly Professional Team can not even think of a simple AV product you do have to wonder just how professional they actually are don't you? :D

But because these people work in the Computer Supply Industry they at the very least should have a better idea of what is going on than a home user who doesn't read anything from their bank, computer maker or any technical publications.

For God's Sake even the gamers mags have a lot about security in them let alone any of the more technical one which no doubt this company uses to advertise its products so they should at the very least have copies of every Mag that they advertise in.

Col ]:)

by house

An unprofessional website, with almost no body, based around IT related stuff, with a silly little IRC/proxy backdoor, an incomplete link...

Something about this doesn't sit well with me.

by mrafrohead

I am glad to hear someone else say that house...

I can tell you one thing, after seeing what I saw, I intend on "investigating" further after I leave work...

Time to ask my magik googleball...

by awfernald

A lot of the premise in the discussions here has been that the end user was too ignorant of computers to protect himself.

So... in a quote directly from their web-site:
"A full time staff, all veterans of the computer industry..."

So, according to them, they are not "ignorant" of computers, according to their lawyer, they were informed, and yet they STILL failed to take any action to protect themselves.

Hmmm, /looks for a /kickban bot for this channel for the idiot comp pros who got hacked cause they didn't know any better.

by oz_media

That was just miserable, sorry but it stunk.

First of all, BOA is not Acme's safe in a high crime area. Acme's safe wasn't broken into.

So lets try and keep this in YOUR simplified terms then, Acme stores your safe. YOU have a key and it is YOUR responsibility to hold onto that key. When you go to ACME to visit your safe, they check your identity and ask you a secret password.

You then tell someone your password, and go to the bathroom while they steal your key and identity.

The guy uses YOUR identity, YOUR password and YOUR key to walk into your safe and take YOUR money.

Who's fault is it now?

Has Acme failed to provide the security they had propsed, based on a good lock, good strong safe and a security check on entry?

by mrafrohead

awfernald - I swear I feel like i just read a response I would have typed.

Very nice :)

IMHO - you hit the proverbial nail right on the head!

by oz_media

The bank will be receiving VERY expensive legal representation.

Who pays for the banks legal representation? WE do, that's who. The same people that take it upon ourselves to ensure security will be paying for our banks to defend themselves againt idiots who can't protect their own business and feel that it is th banks fault.

Did you enjoy adding up your sevrice charges for last year?

Did you smile happily when you heard the mortgage rate was goin gup?

Did you blame the bank when th einterest rate rose?

These are just a few of the ways WE pay for other people's negligence.