Discussion Locked

This guy should be stoned... (with rocks)

0 helpful
503 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

503 replies

by oz_media

Perhaps not atering to the mentally incapable. I would have said mentally retarded, but I know and have worked with some severly retarded people (not just my opinoin but actual brain deficiencies) and I don't think any one of them would not have an up to date Av system.

So I feel this may be considered discrimination of he idiot. Where do I sign on?

by oz_media

Whatever, mrafrohead, our past is just that, PAST.

I think that's probbaly why we had such a go of it at one time though, perhaps we think alike and that doesn't usually go down to well.

Thanks for the kind words though, and DITTO!

I was pretty happy to see you return after a short hiatus, I always appreciated your humor and cutting edge views.

by oz_media

How can you read that without seeing "AHOLE'?

Perhaps the bank SHOULD increase security and require that users have a brain. They could just yell in your ear and wait to hear the echo.

How can someone POSSIBLY run a business that does large international transactions to VERY odd countries actuallt NOT think of security?

It makes you wonder how many times the owner turned up at his neighbours business in the morning, only to be led by the hand to his own building and sat at his desk with the keyboard placed under his hands.

Does this guy get a call every once in a while to remind him to breath?

by oz_media

Scored between 5% and 18% for search engine optimization, good way to NOT have your business found.

He transfers large amounts of money to the wierdest countries, why? He may be better off keeping his business OUT of a courtroom.

by hal 9000

What's wrong with that provided he isn't caught with all the white powder inside the crates with the coffee beans. :D

Col ]:)

by tony hopkinson

How can you claim to be part of the IT industry and advertise your business with crap like that.
Just another indicator to me, this guy's cheap. 'Don't need a/v and firewall the risk of me being hit is very low' sort of manouvre. There again what can you expect of someone who sell's printer supplies, one of the biggest scams going that.
Used to amaze people when I got rid of toner low by shaking the cartridge.

by oz_media

Sure FP would have done a better job, but as far as WYSIWIG editors go FP sucks big time.

FP writes buggy, over coded pages with a tonne of whitespace that makes it easy for competitors to clone the pages.

As far as a WYSIWYG editors are concerned NOTHING has ever even come close to the robust functionailty and clean code generated by Macromedia's Dreamweaver and related products in the suite.

But all in all, FP WOULD have been better, thoug not much. You know how much code editing you have to do with FP code before pages are search engine optimized?

by tony hopkinson

I stopped using it in 98 as well. It's about the stupidest page design application I've ever seen.
The pages can look good, but in every other respect they are dismal failures.
Tend to stick with notepad, wouldn't mind giving MM a go after your previous comments on it, but FP absolutely sucks, and for no other reason than to make web pages more proprietry for IE and IIS.

by mrafrohead

@amcol:
"But what are the basics?"

Updated Anti-Virus - FireWall - Patching your sytem.

Most AV auto-updates itself. If it doesn't, it's usually just a click of a button to enable it.

FireWall - will usually configure itself on home users software. And usually updates itself out of the box too...

Patches, are automagikally installed and downloaded...

Anything above and beyond that, may take time to investigate and learn for home users. Anything before that should be done by default, and if the end users aren't willing to do it, then they should not have internet access...

by mrafrohead

That's why I use a credit union. No fee's... ;p

But what oz said, the customers will pay for it.

And the jerkoff that is suing, if he keeps his business with BoA (and in my opinion, if I was BoA I would terminate business with HIM) he will also help pay back what he stole from the bank.

He really should have gone after the bank in Latvia to get his money back, and tried to track down the person who stole it.

by mrafrohead

"Could someone really be that stupid?"

Well he is suing someone that isn't responsible for his own problems. He should be suing himself... Or the hacker... Or the Latvian bank...

by husp1

shoul look at some of the finance stats here in the US. half of all bankruptcy's in this country are caused by medical bills but it would be nice to have a natnl health service here, then our elderly could by food and pay rent instead of paying for medication and health issues. As to the banking issues the effects would be rippleing, the client sues and wins, next eploited person sees that then he sues using the first mans success to help his cause rising the cost to banks here. said banks cry foul stating that overseas banks don't have this problem thereby causing the goverment to take thing into their hands theating santions if they don't comply etc. etc. etc. (over simplified explination)

by mrafrohead

Wouldn't you guys care if you were a customer of this clown???

That is if he really does have any "customers".

by oz_media

I would be unplugging MY internet connection, calling MY bank, FREEZING my own account, changing passwords and much more if I was stored in this guys PC.

Perhaps if someone loses a few million from THEIR business they can SUE the idiots ass for not securing HIS PC. NOw that would be a really funny twist to read.

"120 Local business go after idiot who is still trying to recover $90,000.00 to pay off the 2.4 million dollars they have sued him for due to his inability to secure THEIR PC's!"

Ahhh, thanks for the chuckle! :D

by hal 9000

Somewhere else here before I saw this posting so I didn't bother reposting it here.

Col ]:)

by sean®

...for his problem? I'm not big on speculative suing, but people are quick to knock the guy as lawyers make such an easy target.

If the bank was somehow responsible (unlikely) it should pay him the money back. If he was caught in a phising attack which used the bank's name, it isn't responsible, but it is arguable that the bank should have warned customers about this threat.

In the absence of the above then it appears to be his fault, but...

We all know that people go into a shop and buy a home computer without being told about security, so why are we surprised when people get caught.

It's easy to knock the guy, but we do this for a living. We all get frustrated with users not knowing what we think is bleeding obvious, why should we consider this guy as other then an inexperienced user.

I hope that if the bank is not responsible (he could argue, for example, that the bank should have noticed suspicious transactions - my bank and credit card companies have monitoring s/ware) that the case gets thrown out.

Perhaps he should check his home insurance.

Better still, box suppliers and software houses should take more responsibility for educating home users about security.

by m_pact

Too many people out there have no sense of responsibility. When he bought his pc (In my opinion) he assumed responsibility for it. This ranks up there with buying hot coffee, driving off, then spilling it on you and holding McDonalds responsible. Ford or GMC doesnt get sued when someone doesnt put oil in their car. This particular person was running his computer "without oil"(Anti-virus), and now complaining that something bad happened.

by hal 9000

The bank refused him this service not because he is a retard but a BLOODY IDIOT!

I think the courts would accept that as discrimination.

Col ]:)

by moira

Sorry if I made that sound a little personal. I'm sure you're not the kind of person I described, you don't sound it anyway. But you must admit it's an attitude often encountered (and more in the field of IT than anywhere else, I have to say).

I suppose my point is more that in all areas of life we offer sympathy and support to people with self-inflicted problems. This guy maybe should have known better, but do we make people pay for treatment of a self inflicted disease? Not in the UK anyway.

Undoubtedly there are people who are not as knowledgeable in the field of computer security and it would be a difficult line to draw. Banks can absorb this kind of loss and it might make them improve their own security measures if they took on the responsibility.

by hal 9000

They pass it on as an increase in fees or services to their customers.

I doubt many people would be willing to accept a fee of 90 K on each and every one of their credit cards just to have the things but if actions like this where to come about successfully a bank any bank would either have to remove the on line banking or perform a complete AV scan on the computer that is initiating the wire transfer. Now just how many people would be willing to sit at their computer for several hours on a dial up connection just to pay a $50.00 bill?

They would be the ones running to their Legal people complaining about an infringement of their privacy and they would be part way correct as who could really trust any bank to scan their computer without wondering just what else they where looking at?

Col ]:)

by moira

"They would be the ones running to their Legal people complaining about an infringement of their privacy and they would be part way correct as who could really trust any bank to scan their computer without wondering just what else they where looking at?"

You have a point I guess. I've just been outraged to discover that my router vendor added a couple of lines to the config file giving themselves backdoor access through the firewall ....

I just think it isn't as black and white as you make it out to be. But what *is* clear, is the real culprit is the person committing fraud in the first place. Perhaps when/if these people were caught they should have to pay the full cost of their damage (instead of the piffling little slap on the wrist normally dished out).

It's easy to view phishing as *cool*, in fact it's just plain stealing.

by moira

"I object to vilifying victims of crimes, such as the man whose banking account was hacked, and the sympathy for the person who was sentenced for releasing a virus."

Exactly my point.

by moira

You're right, I don't live in the US. Our NHS has problems though, as people are living longer etc and increased ability to treat disease has meant prioritising who gets what.

That's getting way off topic though :)

by mrafrohead

All I have to say is this house:

If you pull it, you best use it. When those are brought out, rules change.

by mrafrohead

I don't doubt that you did man... That wasn't what I was getting at... ;p Just may have missed it...

by house

Theirs. I'm not pulling anything but mad stunts. All I'm saying is that we don't know how [i]familia[/i] these guys are, or even who is involved.

Hopefully, they don't pull sh*t but the sh*t in their drawers. ;)

by hal 9000

Now if this was a well know problem why just this one case?

In light of the standards that have been shown by this person I'm beginning to wonder exactly what did happen and if it's not all an attempt to rip off the bank. If this was such a nasty thing just why have there not been more cases like this reported? I know most home users can not give a dam about AV or malware protection and quite a lot do on line banking but only one case being brought forward about this supposed Trojan. Something just doesn't feel right to me.

Even if it did happen like he claims what about all his customer and supplier details that would have been easy pickings as well. Something just isn't right here and I can not put my finger on it to make myself feel happy.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Was no one wanted to pursue that line of thinking!

The more I think about this story the more unhappy I feel as there hasn't been the massive influx of complaints about this Trojan that should have come about if it was so bad. I'm beginning to think that something isn't quite right here at all!

Col ]:)

by mrafrohead

Though I stand by my last comment ;p

nyuck nyuck nyuck...

Though now that you've got me thinking about it, latin america... ;p

Heya Mr. Escobar, how's your day going... ;p

by mrafrohead

I think it smells funny myself. Like two day old tuna in a hot summer sun...

I poked around a tad. Some stuff looks "out of place", but then I stopped and thought about it and figured, I'm not a dick (pi) so what in the heck am I doing??? I fix computers, and I don't have a spare hand to do dick work (nudge nudge maxwell ;p).

All I know is, if I were the dude the started to press charges, I woulda thought twice about doing it, I think he has a very high chance of exposing some type of fraud by pursuing this.

by tgf.peter

Everyone agrees that all users should be aware of security risks when using the internet. However banks which are financial house that exist to make a profit from their customers have a duty of care to the customer. They should advise, with specific details, to give customers an adequate degree of protection. They are powerful institutions with plenty of professional IT advice at hand. The only reason is the ridiculous way that everyone in the US seems to sue everyone else for everything. The result is that no-one will offer help and advice. Its your own fault for being so greedy - you'll just have to live with it.

by aardvarky

Agree with your stance entirely, and like the way you have expressed it.

But, if drawing money at an ATM, the same individual allowed someone else to watch him input his PIN Number and left his card at the machine after walking away with the cash, could he at all surprised if later he found money missing from his account? Could the bank be blamed?

Yes, I know this is perhaps slightly different, in that it would be reasonable to assume that MOST users would understand the risks of acting in such an irresponsible manner at an ATM, and that on-line banking is rather more abstruse.

That said, in this specific instance, I agree with you that the onus is far more on the bank ... BOTH in terms of providing PROTECTION (as far as is reasonably possible - nothing is entirely secure) AND (perhaps the greater ommission here) in educating users of its systems AND ENSURING that the user is not the weak link in the security chain.

To avoid failing in their duty to keep their customers' funds/data secure, perhaps banks should require users to pass a test before providing them with an on-line banking facility? And only let them in if they properly specify WHICH anti-virus solutions they are using?

by gregaaa1

Well this is just about as stupid as Microsoft trying to chase the people who write these viruses.

He should actually be suing MS because MS has yet to fix any of their sub-standard operating systems.

Crap. I gave up waiting for them to fix Windoze NT4. I've been laughing at all you Windoze morons ever since.

I chucked windoze out the door and have not had a virus issue since.

I use a Mac to deal with the MS world. It's a thousand times better than a Windoze box but when it comes down to it. It's still just a toy.

The solution is obvious.

by paul.osborne

Just by the fact that you are reading this thread means that you are of a computing/IT mindset if not profession. Many many people are not, and how are they to know what safeguards to implement to protect themselves? Who is there to tell them? Fine, you can argue that it was his responsibility to find out what he needed to do, but if he wasnt aware of a danger, he wouldnt find out about protecting himself from it! one of my favorite sayings: 'you don't know what you don't know!'.
All this guy is guilty of is listening to his bank when they pushed internet banking towards him so that they can save costs and lower staff levels; and is quite rightly trying to get his money back from the only avenue possible.
Shouldnt banks be insured against this type of claim anyway?

by gary.peace

Congratulations on a well-constructed, thoughtful reply. I agree entirely. The facts provided don't permit apportionment of blame. We all have responsibility to protect ourselves to the best of our ability but we live in a society, one of which aims is (or should be) to provide mutual support. For that reason we help little old ladies to cross the road, provide medical treatment to victims of road-traffic accidents etc etc instead of shrugging shoulders and saying "its your own fault stupid - don't expect help from me".

by techrepub

People assume the internet is safe, and why should none techies assume otherwise ???

My personal advice is NEVER EVER use the Internet for Banking ......

Especially as there is no need to .....

Many Banks provide Direct (Modem to Modem) Dial-up connections to allow you to connect directly to their account servers.

They do this for a VERY GOOD REASON ..... your security.

The best I know is National Westminster Bank's (Now RBS) program called BANKLINE this dials directly to the bank (using heavily encrypted data messages). So there is No internet or any chance of anyone intercepting your information.

It has been around for nearly 10 years (ie before the Internet really got going), it is totally reliable and SECURE. You get complete records of your account(s) and transactions and the connection time is typically less than One minute (little time even for an outsider to know there is any connection, never mind access it). And because all of the transactions are done invisibly to the user, no one can ever gain access to your account information (even if there was an active trojan/virus on your PC) and the data is stored in an encrypted file.

As a another issue, why do people use Microsoft Software, even the Banks don't, they are not that stupid. They use the long forgotten , but extremely reliable "OS2" originally written by IBM (and M$).

(But then M$ went on to completely ruin it, calling it Windows, whilst OS2 remains as it was VERY GOOD)

People must realise that the Internet can be a dangerous place and there are a lot of predators out there trying to make money by any way they can, some legally, many not so.

The Banks should take some responsibility, for falling foul of the publics demands to use the Internet, when instead they should force people to use something like Bankline.

But it is also the responsibility of the public to be aware of the high risk of using the internet for anything involving their Money or their Privacy.

What people DO NOT realise is that there are also extremely powerful computers out there (the most notable being ECHELON run by the UK, US and Autralian governemnts) that has the primary use of intercepting ALL FORMS OF COMMUNICATIONS, DECODING and CODE BREAKING any encryption of the content, so that they can pass on the information to "people who need it".

BE WARNED.

by andrewf.payne

I have a second bank account with a debit card attached to it. I keep $20 in it. When I need to make a purchase, I go to my ATM, transfer the funds, then make my purchase. Not fool proof, but a little safer. No, I never, ever, ever do my banking online.

by buckberg

I do not understand your logic. The bank had a responsibility to provide a secure site for its customers. If the bank was hacked I would expect them to assume the customers loss. However, in this case, the customer had his secure user name and password stolen from HIS computer. In our legal system ignorance is not a viable defense(although many juries do not follow the law and continue to award punitive judgements.)
In this case the customer is at fault because he allowed his credentials to be stolen. I would even bet that in his agreement with the bank he was warned what may happen if those credentials got into the wrong hands.
You seem to subscribe to the notion that we have no personal responsibility and that big bad business is the source of all evil and they should be held accountable for mistakes people make that are completely out of their control.
What would you think if an important business deal failed because the bank doubled and tripled checked each and every secure login? You would probably award damages to the customer.
The bank did provide a secure way to conduct business. It was the customer who made his account unsecure.

by me_myself_&i

Maybe this is stupid, but I have two on-line banking account and the both have something like a key-fob. Which issues a 10 character number based on a challenge by the bank for any payment. And even for getting in!
If the bank does not supply this and they go for just a password, they know it would be unsafe and are guilty. (It's like selling tabacco and not saying it is unhealthy when everybody knows it is)
If they do and the guy lost it, or whatever, he is certainly guilty of groos neglicence.
But first of all, getting enough security is the bank's responsibility, not the users.

A safe system should not be compromised by a virus/trojan or whatever!!!
So, sue them for all they have if they did not!

by hugo-luyt

Don't be stupid.
A trojan horse is a way for a thief to steal your stuff. Don't blame people for the activities of the criminals among us. What if that guy was a 70 year old pensioner using the internet because the bank is to far from the toilet.
Thieves are thieves and they belong in prison. I hope that hacker goes to prison with some huge nazi black guy as cellmate.

by richards_unsubcribe

While the guy bears a lot of responsibility, I think BoA needs to toughen up on some of their own policies and procedures.... maybe I'm missing something here but I find it odd that I damn near need to prduce a DNA sample to the teller before I can cash my neighbours $10 cheque... all the while a cyber criminal, with a few mouse clicks, gleefully cleans out a guys bank account... with the banks help by sending nearly a $100grand over to some no-name bank in crime infested Eastern Europe... How did the transfer take place ...over 10 grand leaving the country without the "appropriate" forms being filled out and the authourties being notified first?? ...so much for the war against drugs and money laundering.

I'm going against the grain here but I'm willing to bet the guy will win the lawsuit.... well maybe his $300/hr lawyers will get most of it... I doubt if he'll get much of it back

And what about the bank in Europe... they seem to be dragging their feet... the ripoff was pretty well cut and dried yet "paperwork, regulations and investigations"... who says they are not in on the scam.

by 6f9g3x802

Isn't the FDIC also responsible for the loss as an insurance agency? If this crime was not done over the INTERNET do you still think the customer is responsible. For example, lets say my house is robbed and in the process they find a receipt with my account number and then go to the bank and withdraw funds. If the bank does not verify the identification am I still responsible for the withdrawal? It does not look like the bank verified the transfer with the INTERNET. Same unverified withdrawal just a different method.

by rnackerman

First, I work for a bank in the IT department and I help manage our Internet Banking application. If I had my choice, the bank would NOT have internet banking. Too many customers have no clue about computers and this is the root of the problem. I have seen customers come into the bank with access problems and just blurt out their username and passwords to the tellers loud enough that everyone can here. We have customers complain that we have put viruses and spyware on their computers. We have customers that complain their computer crashes every time they view a check image online. We ask customers whether they have a virus program or an anti-spyware program and we here "Why, we only go to your site!" We know better.

We have grandparents write their pin number to their ATM card on the bank and send their grandkids to the ATM for them and when the grandkids clean them out they complain to use about allowing them use their ATM cards.

We preach we will never ask your password but daily dozens of people speak their passwords out loud. To stop at least some of the fraud, we have stopped the ability to transfer funds out of the bank via internet banking or even to accounts not associated with that person.

But for years we have seen customers come in and get cashier's checks to send to all kinds of scams and we can't stop them. We know it is a scam, we advise them, show them bulletins and notices we have received alerting us to these scams, but still the customer walks out with the check. Some have come back and complained and we tried to stop them, but ultimately it is the customers responsibility.

Banks have set guidelines to follow and there are a few things we can really do. If the customer has the money they can do just about whatever they want with it. If the customer gives out, or writes down, their pin number for the ATM card or Visa Debit card, the bank cannot be held responsible. The same should be so for internet banking.

Will BOA be held responsible? I don't know. They may settle just to quiet it down. But, lawyers have sued McDonalds for serving hot coffee that the customer later spilled in themselves. Who knows what our legal system will do next.

by jimcandia

For any banking institution to allow a wire transfer to another bank without requiring the account holder signature is irresponsible. The root of this issue really has nothing to do with the Internet. If all you need is an account number to transfer money then our banking system has already failed and its just a matter of time before someone taps your account.

My brokerage allows wire transfers but requires a signature document to set up the target account before any money can be transferred. This should be the minimum standard. BoA is clearly irresponsible.

by doctordisk

I run into countless clients in homes and small businesses who just plain don't know that they should have virus detection.
They are often really brilliant people in their own fields but just don't keep up with technology.
They are often so busy trying to keep up with knowledge about their own profession, they just don't have the interest or the time to read about much else.
My worst example a year or so ago, I would not have believed if it had not been me that was called in. A brilliant professor here in Hong Kong asked me to show him how to connect his computer to the Internet. When I arrived at his home, I discovered that his computer had a Z80 processor and was running the CP/M operating system and he was still using it to write up and print out all of his reports on the oldest dot matrix printer you have ever seen. He called me because he was getting sick of everyone he dealt with asking him to use e-mail. Someone had installed the computer for him in about 1985 and got him all set up and he had just assumed that this was his computer for the rest of his life. Thankfully, he has now treated himself to a new PC and is learning it and has good AV.
These people are actually out there.
And many times I have been called in and discovered people using on-line banking without a thought to using AV to protect themselves. They know which parts of the Bank's site to use to do what they need to do and never bother reading the rest of the page. Every bank that I know of here has prominent warnings on their login pages about the need to use AV programs, but the users just don't seem to read them or even notice them. They are genuinely shocked when I tell them that they could lose all their money if they don't install AV software. However, most of them take my advice and do so.
So for some people, we just have to teach them one at a time.

by highcarbdiet

Is it possible that the banks could have some sort of AV checker to verify that an AV program was running on the client's pc before allowing a successful connection to their online banking website? At least this would help protect all involved. Thoughts?

by vesa

Uhmm.. there ARE banks that use encrypted connections, one time passwords, smart cards... and don't have these problems. It should still be possible to hijack an authenticated browser, especiall IE, but it doesn't seem to happen.

by gazoo

I have been reading this thread for some time and the odd thing to me is that a bank and customer would use a technology which could be breached by a trojan on the users computer. If I want to transfer any money I have to use an independent device to generate a code in answer to a code sent me by the bank. First to log in with, and then for any transaction. If I just log in with id and password I can see my bank statement, with some numbers x'd out, and that's it.
Is id and password the normal way of accessing banking services in the US?

by b2b

With the bulk of the Banking Industry et al pushing for electronic banking, most users are not capable of ensuring that malware and spyware are not placed on their computers. This is especially so as a lot of software does not live up to there promises. The level of sophistication on spyware makes it impossible for the average (and often underaverage) user to keep up.

by christineeve

It's a fine example of how everyone in American blames everyone else for their problems. Sue McDonalds because you ate too much, sue the bank because you can't buy a 30 dollar virus protection program, or even use a free one (!?)etc.

I take this one step further, when I get a Phishing email, I make sure to send it to the company being spoofed. I try to report every single spoof I get. I hope the system administrators can find a way to shut down the originating IP address.

I'm not a networking expert, so I'm not sure if my idea is theory or a possiblity.

So, we can throw stones, but we can also make sure that we do what we can to stop this activity.

by pickleman

Sounds like you fall into the same idiot category as the moron that's suing the bank.

How could you possibly make excuses for him?

Sure, chances are he isn't a computer security expert. So what, neither are 99% of the other people on this planet. Does that mean that every time a person gets a virus, they should start suing someone? Get a grip.

This loser DESERVED to have his money stolen. Let's go by your logic for a second, and assume that he knew NOTHING about computers. Okay, fine, granted. But the fact that he had 90K in his account for someone else to steal, and the fact that he was a businessman, tells me two things:

1) he should've known better
2) if he didn't have the expertise himself, then he should've HIRED someone to safeguard his computer for him if he was too clueless to do it himself

This guy deserves no sympathy whatsoever. It was his own stupidity that led to his downfall, and nobody else should have to pay for it but him. The bank did nothing wrong. Millions of people use online banking every day, and isn't it funny how you don't hear stories on a daily basis of people having $90K stolen from their accounts?

As long as the bank didn't deliberately infect his computer and steal his money, they should not be responsible for it.

His money was safe IN THE BANK.
If he decided to make his money UNSAFE by letting other people get access to it through the internet, then that's his fault and nobody else's.

The money I have in my bank account is perfectly safe and insured. If some guy goes and robs my bank, my own money will still be there the following day.

But if some low-life manages to get into my bank account through MY COMPUTER because of MY stupidity, then I deserve everything that comes to me as a result.

by p-j-h

Sure as hell would not like to get you on the phone if I was to have a PC related problem.
You would be the type to gloat that I did not know the answers to my own questions.

by phamohara

"Basically, this schmuck got himself infected with a trojan".

Users are to lazy to update the AV defenitions and preforming scans, but sonner or later they will learn too.

by andrewf.payne

I have cautioned customers repeatedly about the hazards of online banking. If banks weren't worried about their security measures, why would they be offering virtual credit card numbers? I use to get mad when I saw what dumbasses did to the computers I fixed for them but then I remember, dumbasses are my bread and butter. God Bless them, one and all. Oh, and I'd like to thank all the free porn sites and p2p music sites. They made last year a pretty decent year for me.

by graeme

I think mrefrohead misses an important essential which I will postulate thus.......

"The pace of change of threat is far faster than the average computer user can keep up with."

Though by now most people know what a virus is, spyware, malware anmd phishing are beyond most user's grasp. We give a staff training/security seminar to all maintenance contract customers and even the most computer savvy are appalled at what they don't know.

It is frightening that we update the talk weekly with the latest exploits.

For an exercise - just this weekend we sandboxed a virgin machine running up to date Norton A/V 2005 and Microsoft Anti-spyware. Even with those protections - when we clicked on one dubious (but to the end user apparently legitimate) link the machine went into a spiral of self cleaning by both products which failed to eradicate all traces. We had to initiate manual scans in safe mode as well as remove manually DLL's and EXE's we could identify. Not something your average end user does. Total time wasted - 3 hours.

"Schmuck" deserves to be protected by the computer industry which has sold him tools which we claim empower, which rarely do for the average end user - especially at home.

If "Schmuck" has a case - it is against the perpetrators of the scams AND the computer industry for failing to build moderately secure environments.

Of course you expect the driver of a car to be competent enough to get it right but if the car is a different and more lethal model every day you are likely to get killed. Till "Schmuck" gets the level of protection from the industry that he deserves - there is only one safeguard - education about the problems - regularly broadcast in public forums.

Hey maybe we should stop people computing till we get it fixed!

=====================

and as for Bank of America.... Well The suit IS frivilous against THEM but I have little sympathy for an organization that breaches its own Privacy Policy by mailing out marketing offers in window envelopes that reveal my personal details - sufficient to start building an identity theft portfolio against me. I closed all my accounts with those guys just before Xmas for this reason....

by g...

it's quite right that the brain surgeon probably doesn't know that much about computer just as you don't know that much about brain surgery. But the question is: will you start a brain surgery without knowing how. It's not up to other people to watch what you're doing, you have to inform yourself. Your mother cannot be around you all the time

by amanabala

Hello all,
I think user was well, negligent in protecting his confidential information. I agree with this poster that the user may not have been savvy enough (and he is not expected to be savvy - he has other things to worry about...) to protect his computer - he should have atleast not stored his passwords on his machine. We all know the risks of storing account numbers and password for online banking / credit cards on the local harddrive as cookies. Once a computer is compromised, regardless what worm/trojan attacked the computer, that information is vulnerable. He should have known that and someone should be telling him that he has the responsibility for protecting his information, which, btw, is in the online user agreement that we click "I Agree" without giving a second of our time.

On the other hand, while I do not agree with the claim that the Bank did not do enough to protect this user's account, I think they are responsible as well. The banks systems did their job perectly well: the user id and password presented are valid and the transaction is honored. I think the bank goofed up by sending that kind of money to a foriegn bank without raising a redflag and probably a Patriot Act violation.

I think the user should be compensated - for the amount he lost from his account, not a penny less not a penny more. I think Bank of America should be penalized, not in a Tort Case but by Federal Regulations.

I rest my case.
Ravi

by guapo

Yes, the guy is an idiot. He used Microsoft for business transactions, so he bears a huge load of responsibility. So does the bank for not questioning the transfer, and of course, the criminals. What I find incredible, though, is that thread parent gives Microsoft a free ride.

And please don't make a larger fool of yourself by claiming that other OSes are just as insecure.

by strey

I agree with mrafrohead. Users need to take responsibilty for there own actions. He was basically asking for a virus. The banks have so many things that they have to be compliant on they don't need to be responsible for the incompetance of their users. If this goes anywhere banks will start pulling online services because it just won't be worth the risk anymore. As a society we need to stop blaming everyone because we are too fat, smoke too much, drink too much, or are just too lazy to protect ourselves. This guy needs to grow up!

by techrepublic

On the whole my sympathy is with the bacnk in this case. I know they warn customers about the risks of internet banking, and warn people to keep confidential data secure.

However a relative recently obtained a credit card from them on my account, bearing my photograph and signature. It turns out there is a security loophole in their processes. I told the local branch, and they were not interested because they had followed the (flawed) BoA procedures. I called BoA customer services who were not interested in the security flaw, only in sending out another card (which also bore my details - it took 4 attempts before they got it right). I wrote to the BoA head office and never even got a reply.

I conclude that BoA do not care about security. When I have any dealings with them I take particular care, knowing that they will not.

by the docman

Would you hop in the cockpit of a 747 without proper training... or without a proper pre-flight check?

This fellow had a responsibility to know what he was doing BEFORE using his online banking service. He still has a checkbook, access to ATMs, and bank branches, and could have conducted all of his banking WITHOUT his insecure, virus-ridden PC.

He made the choice to step into the abyss, and is solely responsible for the consequences.

This type of PC user is also responsible for propagating most of the ugly viruses and spyware out there. Maybe the whole PC community should file suit against him for all of the lost man-hours and bandwidth he has stolen from us!

What ever happened to personal responsibility?

by halonsx

the bank and FBI should look into the problem and fix it.....since the user is partly responsible.

by lking1172

I think we all need to look at who REALLY is responsible. Yes he should have kept his AV updated and all associated OS updates as well. However the real problem here is that someone or some group of people are activley trying to still information and $$$ from unsuspecting people. I don't believe that the bank is at fault but there needs to be some sort of recourse for the account holder in any case like this so they don't lose all their money. Because if I don't lock my car door in my driveway then anybody can take it if they have the know how to get it started.

by robert.d.lewis

We are too quick to vilify the user here. The issue is poorly designed and written software. Microsoft has given substandard software for years. And now...

Now, even professionals no longer blame the culprit, but the poor schmuck who doesn't know how or what to do to protect himself. If the microsoft operating system were a car, it would have been recalled long ago and sued within an inch of its corporate life.

That being said, I don't think Windows is all bad, but they have not lived up to their responsibility to give us the product that consumers deserve.

by jlester

I bet he commits ID10T errors all the time. I am happy he does not at my organization.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by tonythetiger

Yes, the guy was ignorant. But the fact is, someone stole money from this man's bank account. The fact that it was done with the help of a computer makes no difference. If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?

I predict that BoA is going to lose.

by xmlmagician

For your information someone got burnt by his McDonalds coffee and he sued McD. McD lost a stupid amount of money for not having a written warning that the coffee is hot. I live in UK and this kind of lawsuits not happening. Although at your side of the pond you can sue for anything and everything. There is a website with this kind of successful claims. I wont be surprised if he won his case

by clenhard

Perhaps online banking needs to rethink online banking security.

That's all I have to say.

by techjock

It's wide and very shallow in places.
It's VERY possible he was (and is) that stupid.

by dean.pengelly

Since this kind of suit along with hot coffee and stolen bicycles ends up costing the rest of us in the end, one of these days someone should mount a class action suit against the winner of one of these stupidity suits and their lawyers to make sure they can not benefit from their ill gotten gains. Judges wake up these types of rulings are not in the public interest.

by mhasf

Although I agree, that the bank is not morally lable, the message here is that we could do with some better ways to ensure Internet security.

So some poor schmo gets nailed for $90K. What about that new Trojan that sneeks into a large company before the AV checker code is updated? What then, when that company starts having its coffers emptied slowly (below scope) but into the millions over time? Then who is the fool?

The problem is that we expect "Joe Schmo", the home user, to be diligent, and yet any Net Admin can attest that this is a daunting task at best.

Back to the bank who has to have all of these fancy controls on their pages. Why not get back to basics and disable all of that fancy cr?p and get the work done of banking and the security of same?

by laserbrian

If this guy had 90K in the bank, how could he be so dumb? He was smart enought to buy a computer, get online, but didn't realize he needed antivirus protection?

Although... I have a lot of friend that have '98 computers with virus definitions from '99. They don't understand why there computer isn't working anymore (with the original install).

Why would the bank allow a transfer of 90K by Internet without at least a transation delay or transaction limit?

Most people use very week passwords anyway...

by hfigueroa

First fo all: OnLines Security is my line of work. This attack is called Man-In-The-Middle. THE BANK CAN PREVENT IT WITH A SMALL INVESTMENT IN THEIR SW.

I think we should stone to writer of this article to death for his/her lack of knowledge on how this attack works. A trojan is not necessary for this attack to be successful. Knowing the customers IP address is sufficient. YES THE BANK IS AT FAULT BECAUSE A TROJAN IS NOT THE ONLY WAY TO ATTACK IT, IF THE BANK HAS NO MEASURES IN PLACE TO HELP THE CLIENT.

by ravenhawk

I have to agree. Everyone has made stupid mistakes in their life. It's human. We are failable. But that still doesn't give us the right to shout at the world 'something bad happened to me, compensate me!'. Life isn't fair, and if you don't watch out for youself, bad things can happen to you.
You don't protect your system and are attacked, that's life. It's not fair, it sucks.
You probably own a car. Did the dealer warn you that you can get into an accident while driving? I'm guessing not. If you get into a car accident (that isn't your fault) two years later while driving that car do you have a right to sue the car dealership? Of course not.
The bank made a service available to the user. It's up to the user to protect themselves properly before using that service, just like it's up to a driver to make sure the car is properly serviced (oil, wheel alignment, etc...) before getting behind the wheel. Nowadays, you don't need to be a power user, or in IT to know that there are dangers out there. I'm not a mechanic, but I know my car needs attention ever so often. And should it break down due to negligence, it's not the dealership's fault.