Discussion Locked

This guy should be stoned... (with rocks)

0 helpful
503 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

503 replies

by techjock

If this was a case of a simple home user, I would have more sympathy. But this guy was running a business. One of his initial business expenses should have been a consult with a computer expert since he was using the computers to initiate wire transfers.

But then, like most computer users, he most likely thought that meant getting a young relative to plug it in for him.

by mjmarcus

Seriously, it's like you went to an ATM, withdrew some money, walked away, and got mugged. And then sued your bank for it, rather than charging the mugger who committed the crime.
Everyone knows this is a risk and that they need to be careful - the internet is no different.

by markmcb

We really don't have enough info to make valid judgements about this case. However, I would agree that the bank should be expected to take reasonable precautions (as have become normal at many banks) to identify and prevent unusual account activity. That said, I don't know if this guy routinely made large transactions, or how many falsified transactions were made over what period of time that totalled 90k.

I would also point out that one could conceivably buy a house without locks on the doors and/or windows. If that house was broken into and robbed, would the builder or previous owner be at fault? Shouldn't it be incumbent upon the buyer or user of a particular good or service to use some common sense and avail himself of freely available and generally known information to protect himself?

What if I buy a motorcycle? I am able to operate it and it is fun to ride off-road. Now if I drive it off a cliff, who is at fault? Should we expect all vehicles to display warnings about driving off cliffs? Or should all land owners be forced to post signs identifying all drops of over
"x" feet?

In the end, I believe we are responsible for our own actions and thus our own safety. That includes who we associate and do business with. So I can tell you that BoA would be stupid to allow this guy to swallow that kind of loss if they could have prevented it. If I hear that bank "X" is better at preventing such occurrences while BoA makes to effort to protect me, guess who I will bank with?

by tonythetiger

of course, but there are a lot of people (I would say the majority) who don't know what a trojan is, while nearly everybody knows what a lock is (or a cliff). And I am not one of those who believes that the ignorant deserve whatever they get, that's for used car salesmen.

They put limits of liability on stolen credit cards. Why should checking accounts be any different?

Also, with all the security devices nowadays, it probably won't be long bfore they figure out where the money went.

by gregry

First off, I basically agree with your philosophy, but have some problems with the specifics.

"Shouldn't it be incumbent upon the buyer or user of a particular good or service to use some common sense and avail himself of freely available and generally known information to protect himself?"

Yep. I don't believe that information on computer security is either freely available or generally known. The people that sell them don't have an interest in worrying their prospective customers. And Grandma is not a member of Tech Republic.

'Or should all land owners be forced to post signs identifying all drops of over "x" feet?'

Nope. But this isn't a field out in the country. The bank has, for all intents and purposes, built a road from their place to yours. If you were going down a road that had a sign saying "Uneven Pavement" and suddenly fell into a pothole 10 feet deep you would probably feel somewhat put upon. Justifiably. The fact that it is a road implies a certain basic amount of safety in using it, at least in the absence of barriers and flashing lights.

My bank also has online banking and has spent some time and effort lobbying me to sign up. Think they made any effort at all to warn me of the dangers or what I could do to make myself safer? Even just a link to a security site somewhere? Nope, not a peep. It's not considered a good marketing strategy. I'm in IT, not marketing, but I bet they're right. "It's a pretty car, it's a fast car, it might fall apart at 70 mph but hey, it might not". Limited appeal.

by agilbert

I agree totally with the comment that ownership for one's actions reside with the individual. Blame/ culpability should only extend to another party when evidence exist where this party fails to fulfill the agreed terms for operating the system. BoA would have a tremendous legal arsenal to firstly solidify the terms of operating the service and secondly, to combat these types of instances. The proverbial David and Goliath battle line are being drawn here.

AMCOL has very good arguments and submissions. I believe that the systems and technology that we employ should reflect the common-sense approach to conducting our daily affairs in a responsible and informed manner.

BoA in my view would be culpable to the extent that a breach in the prevailing Banking Legislation has occurred. However, it would superfically appear that the guy may be wholly (or at best partially) culpable for the problem which is very similar to being scammed out of money.

Whichever way it goes it would be very interesting how the legislature deals with this problem. As previously posted, here comes another McD-like case.

by laserbrian

First of all his company sells Ink and Toner. If he knows enough about computers to sell ink and toner, don't you think his corporate network would be protected.

Do you get calls from Ink and Toner guys as much as I do? They all seem like scamers! Maybe this is a scam...

"Lopez runs a small printer ink and toner business in Miami."

by kaceyr

What OS he was running is not relevant to what happened.

His machine was compromised because he didn't have any protection installed.

Please don't make a larger fool of yourself by claiming that an OS exists that can not be compromised.

by tonay

It must be Microsoft's fault to right? So maybe this guy should sue Microsoft and BofA. Give me a break. I feel sorry for this guy and not knowing all the details I hesitate to judge. If he had no antivirus protection installed then he should admit his failure and fault in this mess. Beats me why some people want to blame Microsoft for everything bad that happens to someones computer, if they think there safe because they are using a Mac or running Linux, they had better think again.

by tomsal

An IP alone is enough if your machine isn't patched, you are careless with leaving passwords hanging around your "c" drive in plain text, etc.

For instance unless you are more keen than the average script kiddy -- I could tell you my IP for my home system and you won't get in.

IPs are cake to get off of a system, more reason why anyone who barely knows anything about computers should ask questions before doing huge dollar amounts of transactions first.

BOA does have security measures, they do encrypt information, they do use SSL for their online transactions, they do run virus scans on their systems routinely.

You said you don't need a trojan horse to capture information...well it makes it about 90% easier if one is placed on there, which means the converse is true. If your system has proper av measures in place, firewall and you use some common sense to keeping information secure on your system..it makes its MUCH MUCH harder for someone to do what happened to this guy.

As I said in a previous post, the one bit of contention I do raise that I think is a bit suspect after much thought is "why didn't the bank call this guy"? It was a 90k transaction. That's a lot of money. But even there I'm not fully convinced because it was a business account that the guy used several times it seems all being relatively large transactions, so their is a pattern there that the bank could say "well it did fit in the normal pattern".

And that's all banks do -- they don't call on everything for any customer unless it doesn't fit the pattern. And most banks, even though I admit this sounds bad (but its true) go by a list of countries that they don't allow transfers too..if the country isn't on the list and the transaction fits the pattern of your transfers chances are they won't call you.

Note this before ANYONE posts a whining complaint about this post..I'm not saying I agree with Banks doing/not doing...I'm just telling you the facts on how it is.

by hal 9000

There are a lot of business people who trot the globe and pay their bills by On Line Banking from various parts of the world with their LT and Internet connection to their personal or business Bank Account.

As for the 90K in most business it wouldn't raise an eyebrow as this is small potatoes even think about your local Super Market for a minute and ponder on just how much in $ stock they get in per week.

Col ]:)

by rossb2

Ahhhh. Nothing like a little logic turned on it's head spit out by a self righteous geek looking for attention to drive me right to the keyboard. Ok, lets extend his logic just a bit to include more than just the less than supertech newbies who "get themselves infected". Why not then include in his vigilanty rantings every late night customer who finds themselves the victim of a mugging in a dimly lit parking lot of a high crime area. Hey, they should have known better and we hope the video store sues them for the bad press it generated because, Hey it couldn't be the mugger's fault or the cheapskate video store chain that decided not to install better lights. Or how about this? Let's boo the victim of a drunk driving incident for suing the nightclub that served an obviously intoxicated patron because the victim should have known the local college won the basketball tournament that night and therefore everyone on the highway should be viewed as a potential drunk. Sheeez, I've looked Mrafronhead's posting over and over, but still can find no basis for his lame argument. If banks, who have made billions (that's Billions with a B) of dollars from charging every sort of bogus service fee imaginable can't spend a bit of that cash on better security methods, even if it means starting from scratch to build a safer system in this Identify Theft world, then maybe it's just easier to blame the "stupid" customers. That surely requires less thought and effort on their parts, right Mrafrohead?

Ross...

by deathtoliberalism

Read the "your responsibilities" section on the BoA website.

http://www.bankofamerica.com/onlinebanking/index.cfm?template=security#responsibilities

I quote: "Protecting your Online ID and Passcode. You should always guard your Online ID and Passcode from unauthorized use. If you share this information with someone, all transactions they initiate with the information are considered as authorized by you, even for transactions you did not intend for them to make."

End of story, this schmuck is 100% at fault.

by tgf.peter

Look when a bank offers online banking to reduce its fixed costs and make even more money it should include specific advice on security. If the customer ignores it then he is at fault. Why is that all the powerless punters just gang up on each other while the fat cats just smile serenly and count their taking ill gotten or otherwise. They love us small guys to just bicker amongst ourselves.

by swips88

Sorry guys, but I feel there is much at fault with the software the user is stuck with.

Rather than blaming the user for being stupid maybe we should blame MS for selling stupid software!

Why should a user have to buy seperate anti-virus software to prevent this anyway! Windows should not be susceptible to this and if it is, MS should provide the anti-virus blocking as part of it's automatic update system!

In our business we take telephone orders all day long and probably have at least 10% of the people say they can not get online because their computer is not working -they got a virus or something.

Face it, a large percentage of the public is not tech-savy, nor should they have to be. The Computer is a tool that should be expected to work as intended not require users to expect it to malfunction and steal from their bank accounts.
Nor can everyone nor every business afford IT staff to keep their systems completely idiot proof.

by hal 9000

Just how many business do not use an accountant?

How many do not use at some time or other a Lawyer to look over contracts that they are entering into?

Why then it it so hard to believe that at the very least they should have some form of IT Consultant to help them to keep their systems part way secure rather than having nothing at all in place to prevent identity theft?

What surprises me on this one is just how everyone is concert rating on the money and forgetting about the other data on that computer like client lists address books and the like. Not to mention Accounting Packages so he gets paid for what he sells. Just how much data do you think would be vulnerable to loss from this type of attack if it did actually happen?

Any form of computer attack that involves a Trojan or something similar is never restricted to just one computer!

Col ]:)

by rmaer

Do you really think that this "Trojan" found its way into only one guys machine that does online banking? Duh!

by rgacomputerdepot

I probably should be grateful to the virus writers since a great deal of my income is from virus removal and data recovery . Most customers have the same problem - too lazy or too cheap to maintain an antivirus. I am unable to understand why it is so difficult to download and maintain one of the many free AV programs out there. I install AVG for all of my customers and set it for auto update.

I recently removed 79 viruses and trojans from a customer's pc that is using the "virus proof AOL" version. I hope the bank does not settle with this idiot!

by jevans2

I have read most of the posts on this topic and agree with this author that the bank is responsible mostly for the reasons given.

I find those who blame the victim are those "lucky" enough to never have had their system compromised and therefore "feel" secure and feel even more secure by blaming the victim for his injury much like a rape victim is responsible because they dressed suggestively or were someplace " unsafe. Therefore the crime happened to them and could not happen to me because I don't do these foolish things. It makes you feel safe but is NOT really the case.

The following is somewhat offpoint, but illustrates my point.

I run a business with a small network on cable modem. I have Norton Corporate AV which is updated regularly and systems scanned daily. I also have adblockers, antispyware, plus recently installed Microsofts beta antispyware. I had never been compromised in the past 3 years online 24/7.

Yet in past month, some autodialer software got on the one system used to surf the internet. Only Microsofts beta antispyware software has found the malware and apparantly cleans the system, yet it is back within a few hours ready for re-removal. This isn't serious as there is no phone connection to dial out, but apparantly only way to permanently remove it is to take the system down, reformat hard drive and reinstall. Naturally this is the oldest system on our network and has lots of stuff that would make this a hastle.

Now within the past week a trojan has infested this same machine that Norton Corporate AV finds. Norton tries to remove and or quarantine this trojan repeatedly, without success.

My point is: Just because you haven't been hit doesn't mean anyone who has is an idiot and/or careless and that it is THEIR OWN FAULT!

I don't consider myself an "expert", yet I believe I have taken more precautions than the majority of those who use the internet for "secure" transactions and believe they are safe and "protected" from fraud.

PS I have also had an instance of Credit card fraud attack against my company and had the FBI investigating it this past October. Only because our IT is all done in-house were we able to provide information of use to the FBI and we blocked access to our site from the service provider and region from which the majority of the bank fraud was being commited were we able to curtail our losses. Unfortunately we also blocked legit sales from the same region until additional measure were instituted to prevent this in the future. This is what was happening. Since we process credit card transactions in real time 24/7, criminals were making small orders to test validity of credit card numbers. If the order was approved, they knew the card was "good" and and did whatever elsewhere to defraud others after finding the card "GOOD". Meanwhile we sent the order and ate the loss thru charge backs. this averaged $50/order. FBI told us this is a hugh problem. WE stopped this by installing a step before processing credit card where the user has to type in the characters they "see" in a box. This stops the automated software from using our site to check out valid credit card numbers. According to the FBI, Thieves set up apartments full of computers automatically submitting credit card orders to sites that process in real time. Another problem was that apparantly, the credit card companies were only checking for a valid number sequence near the holidays (Any idiot can get software that will generate valid number sequences (we use it ourself. We check to determine the number sequence is valid before attempting to process the credit card. Remember you pay for every number processed - valid or not. If we didn't do this we would pay substantial $$ to process every kids random fooling around on our site and submitting bogus credit card information) so not only did we get stung for real cards that were compromised we also got stung for unissued cards (valid number sequence but not issued) Then a month later we are charged back for charges that the credit card company approved(at a processing fee to us plus percentage of total sale) and we fulfilled in good faith. This is the way it is whether you like it or not. You are led to believe the fee for the credit card transaction is to insure that the transaction is valid and that you, the business owner, will be paid. Ha, Ha,Ha if you believe that. Those with the most clout win. The business owner is out for the loss and ultimately you the consumer because the business owner either find a way to pass the cost on or goes out of business.

The WEB is like the Wild Wild West. It is mostly lawless. There are many new ways to defraud invented daily and laws/law enforcement has not been able to keep up with it.

I hope you never have such problems but if you think these problems are my own fault and that I should have seen them coming and prevented them, I think you are incapable of clear thought.

by deathtoliberalism

This is so stupid, it doesn't warrent a reply, but here goes. There are way to many antivirus products to make this feasible, and there is no way for the server side to check if it is up to date anyway. Also, it shows a lack of understanding of security problems for you and others to insinuate that Antivirus software is all you need to protect yourself. What if this SOB got infected through an unpatched IE on a 0-day targeted virus. Should he then turn and sue microsoft. A businessman doing large wire transfers online has no excuse for not paying a professional to care for and secure his business tool. The onus is definetly not on the bank.

by gregry

Let's look at the forest a little. Computer security is a devilish and frequently arcane art that most people will never know and should not be expected to. Period. So, maybe we have to approach online banking security from multiple angles. First, the computer security angle belongs to the bank. AV programs and firewalls don't catch everything, do they? No. Happy to give examples if you think they do. Absolutely we need to have and run them and keep them up to date, but it ain't a cure-all. They have the knowledge and resources. So what about Joe Blow. Well, the bank could allow us to set up some parameters for our accounts. Maximum amount per transaction, per day, by account, international transfers ok and to what countries. Requests only valid from registered IP addresses/MAC addresses. I know they can be spoofed, but it's better than nothing. If a business/person needs to break it's own rules they can by using a different set of credentials and method, call on phone with different pin maybe. Fingerprint, maybe. I'm sure that the people in this forum could design a much more secure system with a little thought and discussion. Make some suggestions. If we could, so could the bank. So, yes, I reluctantly have to side with the 'bank is responsible' crowd, at least for the actual amount of loss. If I can think of ways to make it safer they certainly can too, and should. Viruses and trojans keep getting better, this is just the beginning. Someday we'll get burned too, promise. Most of us already have, somehow, sometime, that's why we take this stuff seriously.
Now, about the McDonalds coffee thing, I was outraged as well, until I read the whole story. I still don't agree with the amount of the award, but McD dropped it in the dirt in a lot of ways.
See what you think: www.vanfirm.com/mcdonalds-coffee-lawsuit.htm
or look it up for yourself. I just grabbed that site at random from a Google search on "mcdonalds coffee".
Things are not always as straightforward as they seem.

by kaceyr

That's why banks have a silly little thing called a "Signature Card". Before he can initiate a wire transfer, he has to have an account at the bank. That requires a signature card. At some point in time, either when he opened the account or at a later time, he would have had to visit his local branch office to get the wire transfer capability set up, becuase there are some forms that need to get signed (see, that signature again).

Once it's been set up, you use a secure log in (which was captured by the trojan on his system) and continue with your banking business.

The whole point of doing it on the internet is to save you the trouble of going into your local branch office.

Banks are constantly on the lookout for fraudulent transactions, but a 90K wire transfer won't even raise a red flag. A common management report in the banking industry is the "Large Transaction" report. It *STARTS* at 100K. Given the amount of the fraudulent transfer, I'd say that the perpetrator knew this.

According to the article, Bank of America is doing everything that it can, within the law, to get the money returned to their customer. But the first thing their going to do is try to find out if he was running some kind of scam.

As for the 20K that was already drawn at the receiving end, even if the perpetrator is found, I'd say he can kiss that money goodbye.

In a nutshell, the bank is not responsible for dumb customers. If you want special coddling, go run to mommy.

by techsharon

I agree with you mrafrohead. Let me add that lawsuites are too easy these days. It seems as if everyone (I know I shouldn't generalize) is a lawsuite looking for a place to happen.
It doesn't help that computers and the internet have become so easy to use that people that shouldn't even own one are just out there surfing the net, getting email, sending email, downloading...and the list goes on with little or no knowledge on how to protect themselves from Phishing and other such dangers. I don't believe the bank should be held responsible for this morons incompentency.
I could say tons more but is best left unsaid.

by dhopp9

My bank is a good bank (old fashioned maybe nevertheless one of the largest), and would contact me before authorizing a transfer of an unusually large size.

Maybe Mr. X is a dunderhead even beyond his computer usage, and picked a bank that didn't give a damn about him.

by kaceyr

So you're answer is to sue Microsoft?

Go for it. I just want to watch when the judge smacks your around for being stupid.

"... but they have not lived up to their responsibility to give us the product that consumers deserve."

Are you really that obtuse?? They create a product that you *CHOOSE* to use. If you feel the product is inferior, don't use it. It's a simple solution. There are other OS's out there. Of course, they're *ALL* susceptible to trojans. If you believe otherwise, then you're just as stupid as the guy who's on the internet with no firewall and no virus protection.

by timeros

I prefer MS . ."All Hail Bill Gates" ,but the truth is LINUX doesn't take trojans. They have a thing called "Malicious Code". The actual known trojan is only suceptible in MS.

Sorry

by kaceyr

Exactly what do you think a trojan is?

A true trojan is a program that advertises that it does something, and actually does it, while capturing data or exploiting other parts of your system at the same time.

The protections that are built into Linux have nothing to do with the trojan getting in. They have to do with the trojan's inability to get the information it gleaned out to a target.

So ...... just thinking off the top of my head here, if I were to create a trojan that targeted Linux, I would have it collect the types of information I was looking for, then attempt to initiate a socket connection, and if successful transmit the captured data. Such a trojan could easily lay dormant until the day the user forgets that they're logged in as root and they fire up the application.

Not a difficult design. The single biggest problem with trojan code is creating a carrier application that someone will want to use.

IMHO, the only reason we haven't seen any trojans like this in the Linux world is that Linux still not a widely used end-user desktop OS, which makes targeting Windows the logical choice.

by techjock

That's funny. Isn't that what BillG calles Linux and the GNU?

{/me takes out soapbox, so stop reading if you don't want to see a rant}

Seriously folks. Modern Operating Systems are complex monsters. They are so large that NONE of them are 100% secure, stable or reliable. Some are better than others, but then others have better marketing teams!

While I blame Microsoft for a lot of shady business practices, I don't really blame them for a crappy OS.
(Heck, if you listen to some of the pundits, MS didn't write it anyway, they either stole it or bought it and hacked it so it all seems to work together.)

Anyone who wants to believe that the non-MS OS's are secure should try taking a look at the vulnerability lists. The primary reason that you don't hear about nasty worms and viri for systems like UNIX and Linux is that these OS's are fairly complex to setup and maintain. It means that their Administrators are aware of the risks, or rapidly become so, and when a package is found to be vulnerable, they patch it, and they tend to run firewalls (the horror!). They also don't tend to surf the WWW from their server machines, and they don't log into their workstations with Admin rights very often.

How do they know to do this?

Were they born with this level of paranoia?
(OK, some were!!!)

NO!! They learned it because they paid attention to the collosal mistakes of others. It's actually a good basic business practice people!!

It's just as much of a cop-out to blame Microsoft (or Apple, AT&T, RedHat, or SCO {yeeech!}) for insecurity in their OS's as it is to blame BoA for the businessman's losses.

Too many people today buy into the idea of PC's as appliances. They are not. They are tools, dangerous ones at that. I like wood working, but if I slice off my fingers on a table saw, who's fault is it? My saw has a guard on it, that makes it safe right? NO, it has a large spinning disk that can HURT ME!

My PC (a tool) also has a spinning disk in it that can hurt me. I treat it with respect and keep it properly maintained. That means patching it, keeping AV current and running, and keeping stangers away from it (firewall & router).

I also like the automobile analogy. If you fail to lock the doors on your car, and leave the windows rolled down, then someone steals it, do you go sue the manufacturer? "It was a Hot Day for goodness sakes, you should have made the locks automatic." But don't let them lock their own keys in the car. And you have to tell them where their car is now so the cops can go retrieve it, but don't invade their privacy and tell the cops when they speed through town.

GOD I get so tired of simpering, crying, fussing, punk a$% morons!! Open your eyes, enjoy life, and when you mess up, fess up, correct the problem and get on with life.

Life's too short for this kind of crap!

{/me puts soapbox away for now}

by robert.d.lewis

I am incredulous that you apparently believe that Microsoft has no liability in this situation. And just so you know, many laws are passed to protect "stupid people" who don't fully understand all of the ramifications of their actions.

Example: If you leave your credit card on the seat of your car, with your windows down, you only have a liability of $50.00 if someone steals your card. This is a similar situation.

Windows is not a fully mature product and we are testing it for microsoft. If you had a car which was built with faulty brakes and it caused you to have an accident, would you blame the builder or would you blame yourself for not buying the service of a mechanic who would check your brakes on a daily basis to tell you if they were defective?

Why is this situation any different? Microsoft has an ethical duty to provide a safe and secure product. They have ignored that duty for years. The vulnerabilities are there and Microsoft knows it. And they are still doing far too little to fix the problem.

So, you want to blame a guy who isn't as smart as you about viruses? Good job!

Ignoring the problem and the refusal to put blame where the blame really lies is the result of unclear thinking on your part.

I would like to add that the government requires anyone who wants to drive a car to pass a test. If the same requirement existed for PC's, then you might have a point. But until that happens, I think you should stop blaming the victim.

by hal 9000

Is in a IT related field!

That is the case here and he should have known a lot better than what appears to have happened in this case.

The whole thing just doesn't gel with me and I'm suspicious of the entire thing.

Col ]:)

by kaptkos

I do believe that this was a phishing scam because
I received an eMail from someone pretending to
be BofA; however, I don't even have an account
with BofA so I called them and informed them of
the bogus email that I had received.
People who are non-informed of potential threats
such as these phishing atttacks should at least
be intelligent enough to not give out personal
information to anyone; therefore, the sucker should
take the hit.

Kos

by manningda

...in other words, forget about who's responsible; banks and like institutions should be considering who's best equipped to "pay" in a scenario like this.

Consider this metaphor...

The city water department office is located downtown. The building is owned by the city and is adjacent to a public parking lot. In the parking lot there is a very large sign that is obviously posted in an area easily seen from the entire parking lot and reads...

"The City assumes no liability for injuries, accidents, or damages in this parking lot."

Basically a message reading, "...user beware..." wouldn't you agree?

Enter Ms. Smith. Ms. Smith is a 68 year old widow on a fixed income including a generous pension and estate inherited from her late husband. She arrives to pay her water bill on January 14th. The walk from the parking lot to the office is frozen and Ms. Smith falls and breaks her hip.

At this point many will be drawn to what in my opinion and experience are irrelevant questions. (ex: where was the warning sign posted; ...where did the parking lot end and the building begin;... what is Ms. Smiths income v. her ability to pay her own medical expenses.)

IMHO, the reality is that our system of justice provides each citizen with the same opportunity to bring their dispute to a judge or jury and seek some resolution. (...typically monitary

by tonythetiger

The guy is not entirely responsible though. He is a crime victim. If I leave my keys in my car, it is still illegal for someone to steal it. The police should be involved, if they aren't already.

by timeros

Do we allow a Class Action Lawsuit to open the door to placing the liablility of online banking on banks. If the bank has to be responsible for the security of the workstation, I can guarantee there will be no more Free Online Banking.

I hope our court system is intelligent enough to see this, obviously the lawers aren't.

Personally, I do consider it the responsibility of the user. If the bank had the trojan, it would be their fault, but the user had the trojan. I hope the judge throws this out. It could change the way the world does banking again and set up back 20 yrs.

by tonythetiger

Well, they'll certainly use that as an excuse. I remember when ATMs first came out. They were supposed to save a lot of money... fewer tellers had to be hired, etc. But the banks couldn't be content with that. Before long, they saw an opportunity to make money with the machines and started charging people to get their own money.

by jriding

At first (a couple of years ago) I felt that most users were not really at fault for not having spyware protectors and antivirus. But as time has continued to march on and how mainstream virus and spyware information is, I am putting more and more blame on the user.
People will say but I don't know how a computer works. etc... for an excuse.
Well lets put this into perspective.
I don't know how a car's engine works.. But I know I have to get the oil changed or it stops working. I also know I need to get tires and gas, or it stops working. Can lead to a blow out which would cause an accident.
So if I don't change my oil and my tires blow out and I have an accident and my engine dies. Should I be able to sue because I don't understand how a car works? Don't think so.
Even sp2 now tells you when your virus scan is out of date or when your patches are not up to date. (just like the change oil light or gas light)
So when do people start having to take responsibility for their actions or non-actions?

Just my 2c

by steven_crane

The banking community needs to be proactive in this area. Knowing that people are stupid and lazy, even those that should know better. If the banks want customers to use online services, they need to scan for this type of problem, because there is always a chance that a user is infected and not know it.

Steve

by jriding

At first (a couple of years ago) I felt that most users were not really at fault for not having spyware protectors and antivirus. But as time has continued to march on and how mainstream virus and spyware information is, I am putting more and more blame on the user.
People will say but I don't know how a computer works. etc... for an excuse.
Well lets put this into perspective.
I don't know how a car's engine works.. But I know I have to get the oil changed or it stops working. I also know I need to get tires and gas, or it stops working. Can lead to a blow out which would cause an accident.
So if I don't change my oil and my tires blow out and I have an accident and my engine dies. Should I be able to sue because I don't understand how a car works? Don't think so.
Even sp2 now tells you when your virus scan is out of date or when your patches are not up to date. (just like the change oil light or gas light)
So when do people start having to take responsibility for their actions or non-actions?

Just my 2c

by webworm99

He said the transaction was unauthorized. If the transaction is unauthorized by him. The bank must give him the money back, while they do the investigation. It is federal law. Failure to do is a violation of federal law and Bank Of America could be held criminal libel for breaking federal law. He could sue for 1,000,000 if that is the case. For those people claiming he should have virus protection. He may already had that protection.

by sparker

There has been a lot of discussion about a person really being that stupid as this. Well, I work for a large law firm with some of the countries best and brightest lawyers, but when it comes to their computers...let's just say they should stick to law, not IT. Sometimes I feel more like a babysitter than an IT tech. They know enough to use the programs they need (barely) but have no clue as to anything else.
On the other hand, I know how to drive my car, I know where to put the gas and can even change my own oil if I absolutely have to (Thanks, Saturn)but don't ask me to change the brake pads!

by herrroger

This person who got a trojan that resulted in him/her losing $$ and who thinks he can re-coup the $$ by sueing his bank, should become a politican. His/her mind is out to lunch! Everyone knows that the user of his/her computer is the first line of defense against virus's.

by obiwansmith

It was the law officials who say there was a trojan on the computer. But there is no proof that the infrormation on the computer was used in the heist...at least as the article mentions. There are scores of ways to get that information.

My main concern is against Bank of America. Why didn't anyone there catch the transfer to said foriegn country. A transfer of that size would be held up by Homeland Security at the very least to make sure it's not headed anywhere for terror purposes.

But like most of you, I disagree with the litagation because of self-incompetance.

by tonythetiger

Yet the credit card company covers for the people who stupidly leave their credit card on a counter somewhere and is taken and used. The difference: Whose money it is!

by tonythetiger

Even some "savvy" users fall prey to some of this stuff. I had a guy who thought if he just clicked on the "X" on a pop-up, thet he'd be OK, until I told him that some malicious program can reprogram that "X" button to run the installation.

by tonythetiger

The analogy with a car, or anything else, just doesn't cut it. You can see when your tires are worn, or if it's running a little rough.

by kenw

I think you guys are trying to add your own information to the article. No where in the article did it mention the guy did not have AV running. You all just assumed this to be the case. Also, and most importantly, before you start bad mouthing the victim you should make sure you know what you are talking about. You seem to act like you know it all about online transactions but obviously you don't. The fact that the problem was due to a trojan and not a virus means that not all AV programs would have found it. Even if the guy was the most diligent and updated his AV regularly there is still a chance that his AV program would not have found it since it is a Trojan. While I do not think the bank is responsible and the case will most likely get thrown out I do think the bank has the responsibility to verify all transactions. A simple check to see if this guy has ever had a transaction with the country in question would have been simple. Also, with the amount of money involved, the Bank has the responsibility to verify the transaction. A simple phone call could have averted this whole mess, so in this case I think the Bank should cough up the missing money and nothing more.

by laserbrian

I have to agree but the system failed also. I think it is on some level the fault of:
User, Bank, Microsoft, IBM, Internet, and of course the person using the trojan horse. Can't the money be traced. Maybe it's the bank?

Oh, did I mention the Bank?

by slimtim

Many banks are going on advertising blitzes aimed at the most novice computer users -- people who barely know to check their email -- with ads saying "online banking is easy, it's safe, anyone can do it in 5 minutes" and their materials never mention what an "AV scan" is. So we have to know the context: If the bank in question is doing this kind of marketing to reap the rewards of bringing in thousands of customers, then they need to be ordered to (1) balance their messaging and (2) bear some of the burden when things go awry.

by tonythetiger

As well, BoA might not want this drawn out too long. Several states' Attorneys General are already investigating some of their practices.

by threetoefrog

As a customer of BofA I have received several notices from them regarding on-going phishing frauds. These notices were by email, hardcopy in monthly statements, and on the e-banking homepage.

So his claim that he wasn't notified holds little or no credence. Moreover, when setting up the on-line account the user acknowledges the risks by clicking on the EULA. (Shows how many users really read these things.)

On our corporate account, we have stop limits on all outbound transactions and a list of routine payees, anything exceeding those limits reguires a verbal approval from one of our officers.

A delay or secondary release is helpful, but it slows down the transaction process. Maybe requiring the customer to validate the transaction at a branch office or forcing a secuirty certificate for clients performing transactions over $10k.

Whatever security protocol is used must be pushed from the bank side.

The other aspect I don't understand is how this transaction occurred without any reporting. Typically all transactions over $10k flowing out of or into the country must be reported to Federal Government.

In the end, I think BofA will cave and refund his money, but will require a non-disclosure.

by oldgrendel

Through all of this babble (much of it self-righteous, insensitive, grandstanding, name your own adjective), I see very little wrath being directed to the person(s) who stole the money, or the person(s) who wrote the code that enable the theft of the money... There is enough blame to go around but not including the actual thief seems a little disturbing.

by rfaass

These kind of things happen on a daily basis. Not only for banks but also for credit card issuing companies, which accept applications over the internet. To esthablish identity, a smart card can be used easily but is a littler investment from the bank and the cost of fraud is less until now, otherwise they would have done it. I on-line bank with ABN-AMRO, they provided me with a card reader where my atm card is inserted, I type my pin and a fresh code from the screen and type in the new generated code into the computer, verifying it is me.... fool proof.

by klaken

The trial should surface the facts regarding negligence. I expect my bank to guard my money, to act on behalf of my best interest. I expect the government to enforce the laws. If I am robbed, I expect the convicted criminal to be removed from society.

At the same time, I will continue to try to secure my home, and family from thieves or others that do me harm.

Regarding cyberinvasions, I have spent thousands of dollars just to keep my computer system useable by preventing spam, viruses,etc. NOTHING so far has worked for long. I am merely a simple user, I can only imagine what companies pay to keep the creeps out of their systems.

To me, the relative security of the internet is directly proportional to the security the US government provides it's citizens. Looks like a lot of activity, but we all know the government is impotent!

by hal 9000

Just how much he normally transferrers at a time. 90K may sound like a lot but I have several clients who that would be small change to and wouldn't even cover the deposit on a bit of plant.

It also depends on how it was sent out as well if it was a few transactions that started out small and got bigger with each transaction this could just be normal business. It all boils down to information we just do not have and are unlikely to see either as if that was made public it would only make it easier for others to jump on the bandwagon. But what worries me is that this appears to be one of a kind with no other reports of this Trojan doing the same thing to others so I'm wondering just how genuine it actually is.

Col ]:)

by dhoyt

Everyone is responsible for their own systems well-being. Banks are responsible for their system and end users are responsible for their systems, it's as simple as that! When banks are robbed, regardless of how, FDIC or FSLIC the primary insurers pay back the banks, these insurers are federal and get their funds from our tax dollars. In a nut shell everyone who pays taxes, pays for theft. It is absolutely irresponsible for people who have computers to ignore the threat of viruses and then go on line to do their banking. The banks may claim that their system is clean (of viruses), however they cannot possibly be responsible for their customers systems. We have been dealing with this topic for many years and we tell our customers that if they are not absolutely sure about what they are doing, don't do it! Further more it is irresponsible for anyone who uses the internet to go on line without some form of protection. If everyone had a good virus checker on their systems, there would be no viruses. The only reason the bad guys continue to create viruses is because they know many folks ignore the threats and don't take any action.

by hal 9000

He is a business person who runs a business selling re inks and toner refills. He claims to have a professional staff and be a professional company. :D

If you have a look at his Web page it is full of broken links poorly laid out and just plain bad. Their so called professional attitude would be called into question just by their web page alone without even considering the fact that he is the owner/manager of a business and doesn't even have the very basics installed on his computer. If his bank account details got taken what else was exposed to theft as well?

Col ]:)

by technicalmumbojumbo

If they don't pay then the guy's ISP should be held accountable. They rake in tons of dough from us every month. They should be required by law to provide a safe, virus-free pipeline. We wouldn't allow the water company to charge us for an infected product

by dennis.irvine

Next people will start sueing banks for not telling them about mechanical problems with their cars because they use their car to get to the drive up window.

by tonythetiger

I'm not sure how binding the contract is. If one party genuinly does not understand parts of it, it could concievavly be voided on the "Competent Parties" principle (or perhaps the "Meeting of the Minds" principle).

In any case, I think the bank owes him at least as much consideration as it extends to its credit card customers, which limits the customer to $50 liability for fraudulent use.

by hal 9000

But I didn't see it printed that it was just one transaction for the transfer. In fact since the other bank is holding some of the funds at least they have done the right thing but as yet have not been contacted by the right people to return the money.

BoA wasn't responsible for the transaction/s their systems where not breached so the person who is responsible should be the one making the claim for the return of the funds. If BoA got involved even if only for "Good Will" they would be setting a legal precedent and leaving themselves wide open for every boy and his dog to take action against them for things like this.

This is a perfect example of user beware and use things at your own risk. But on the other hand just how many people go shopping for their food and other things and pay for it by plastic? Do you know what the banks get when you pay by plastic a complete itemized list of everything that you have brought where and when.

They then compile this data and sell it on to interested parties who may be telemarketers or anyone else who has a new product that they want to push.

Col ]:)

by tonythetiger

The precedent has already been set. They limit liability for fraudulent credit card transactions to $50.00.

by sit ubu, sit.........good dog!

"Try our new Internet Banking. It's safe, secure, and easy!"

My bank (and others) blanket people with this advertising. Yes, it is easy, and it is secure (of course, they MEAN that it goes over secure servers, but to not elaborate on this).

If this person was like a normal non-sophisticated home user, he probably never heard of Ad-Aware, Spybot, etc. He probably has never SEEN a virus or Trojan (even though they could be running rampant throughout his computer). He probably feels safe because his computer came with Norton or McAfee pre-installed (but never downloaded the updates).

When he logged in to his internet banking account, he probably saw a warning popup on his screen which said "You are about to view pages over a secure connection." Then, after logging in, he saw the little lock icon in the lower right of the screen, which he heard should be there.

Based on these, he probably felt pretty safe. So maybe we should all go easy on him, since he was a victim of a crime. Should we all point and laugh at someone whose house was broken in to by someone who got in by circumventing the keypad for the garage door opener?

Here's the million dollar idea: How about some of you getting together and writing a short handbook about the basics of using a computer (shorter than a "...for Dummies" book). Cover the extreme basics, such as "This is the Internet (and it's not AOL), "Installing a Firewall", "Installing Anti-Virus Protection", "Never Answer e-mail from a Bank", "Internet Fraud and Schemes", "Making Passwords Secure", etc. A short 75 pager should do. Sell it to school districts. They can make it required reading for students who want to use the school's computer systems. Guaranteed royalties.

Geoff

by buschman_007

I agree with your sentiment that this guy isn't necessarily an idiot just because he was victimized.

But I disagree with your idea that the bank has a responsibility to secure it's user's machine. I feel it has a responsibility to secure the connection between their servers and the users PC. But further than that and I don't think it's a realistic expectation for the banks to bare responsibility.

Uninformed user has no A/V protection. Malicious hacker installs key logger on uninformed user's PC. User opens a secure connection with his online bank, makes a secure transfer, and concludes business with his bank. How is it the bank responsibility to protect the user from the hacker? The hacker now has all the info they need to login and remove money for the uninformed user.

The plaintiff in this case, much like the uninformed user in my example, failed to consult with someone who does have the experience to properly secure his machine. He decided that expense was not necessary, not cost effective, or maybe he just gambled that no one would ever attack him. He was wrong, and the fault lies clearly on his doorstep.

I don't get off of speeding tickets because I didn't know the speed limit. I'm expected to find this information out on my own. If I get raped at the car dealership cause I didn't take the time to figure out what a car is worth, that again is my fault.

This guy is an adult and should know better. I feel this is another in a long line of overly litigious and frivolous lawsuits that is a drag on our nation.

A classaction lawsuit like this is what's gonna kill online banking. And I do love my online banking. :)

Mike

by hal 9000

Would you still hold the bank responsible because they used your card at ATM's to empty your account?

It's still stealing but just using technology to perform the crime.

Anyway this person is supposed to be running a computer related business so he should have known better!

Col ]:)

by tonythetiger

Your sister is very fortunate to have a brother like you. Not everyone is so fortunate. At least 80% of people who buy computers don't know everything they need to know to operate it safely. What's worse, they don't know that they don't know.

by hkacz

(Just my opinion)The truth of the matter is McD's paid over 4 million to a woman for spilling the hot coffee (I could not believe it either). Non-technical users don't totally understand the brains behind the power of computers, especially when systems are being compromised through new techniques daily. The banks should have some type of protection for online users as well as any other company that uses the Internet for transactions. Nobody knows how everythng totally works that they own, nor should they. There is NOT enouogh education to end users, but that is life. There is no real education on how to be a parent! Sue Microsoft the poor products that they put out. If they were a car manufacturer they would have been out of business in a month.

by carpeweb

I admit that I didn't read every response here, but I get the distinct feeling that most were written by Nick Burns, the abrasive -- and very naive -- SNL character. One or two responses at least recognized that someone who doesn't install the latest virus protection software isn't necessarily an "idiot". But it seems that many of responses were driven by a need to call *somebody* stupid. If it makes you feel good to do so, you can laugh all the way to second-class corporate citizenship, and maybe you'll never "get" what most people find funny about the Nick Burns skits.

by red_wolf9

From what I read about the case it was normal for his account to have wire transactions of that size, perhaps not to the bank in question but the size did not trigger any warnings. I also assume that he could have spent time doing due diligence and setting a threshold for limits that would require notification. Further from what I understand the "bad guys" were only able to withdraw some of the money, if this genius wants to sue someone for not returning property that he was too stupid to protect he should go after the other bank.

This guy is asking to have his lazy, and negligent personal actions undone and not just for the amount "he's out" (as you state) but for legal fees and interest too. So apparently he?s not just happy getting his original amount back (he wants the interest on it plus his lawyers want their cut outside of his 90k). Last time I checked the American dream didn't include suing big corporations when you were the negligent party in the first place, well now that I think about it that might be a lawyers "American Dream".

Do you honestly think every company has an obligation (as highlighted but your caps lock) to notify every customer about every potential threat they might be exposing themselves while using the companies product? The torrent of email/snail mail would be so large that you would ignore them anyway.

Here is what I read... business man fails to take even the most basic security measures to protect himself, has 90k stolen from him. Tries the correct course of action notifying law enforcement. Finds out the hard way why criminals use foreign banks, multi-jurisdictional red tape. Then a local lawyer gets wind of the case offers his service for free, telling the afore mentioned business man its all big bad BOA's fault. Files a suit and hopes for class action status (cause that's where the real money is for the lawyer probably about 60 gajillion dollars in legal fees). Is it any wonder even the morons in Congress took action against Class Action suits, where tiny state courts were producing huge nationwide judgments (often for frivolous cases) because they were comprised of juries that think like you.

In closing if the shoe was on my foot I think there would be a 9mm hole in it as well (not so vague reference to shooting yourself in the foot), but I wouldn't expect anyone to rescue me from my own stupidity. The fine print on the American Dream says a vast percentage of small business fail? just for these reasons.

Stupid is as stupid does ? Forrest Gump

by hal 9000

And it also runs on every large business mainframes or server farms as MS doesn't have anything scalable enough to actually fill this slot in the market.

These places are a perfect target as even a million dollars wouldn't be missed quickly but for some reason they just do not get hit from outside {at least.} There is a reason that Windows gets targeted so often and that is because it is just easier to hack.

Col ]:)

by gregry

If this is about cocaine and 90 grand is all he had he really does deserve to be stoned. Let it go, natural selection will take care of it. Those guys play rough.

by gregry

If this is about cocaine and 90 grand is all he had he really does deserve to be stoned. Let it go, natural selection will take care of it. Those guys play rough.

by bnordberg

All of society is to blame for this. First George W for dumb decisions that created a bad economy that has forced people to steal. Next to blame are the parents that had the child who grew up to write a trojan. Next the teachers who did not instill values onto the child who wrote the torjan. Next the society that allows trojans to propogate. Next the person who invented computers, next the person that invented the internet. I sure am glad I am not having kids!

by mrafrohead

This is how I see it:

The bad economy is actually getting better, and it was tanking before George got into office. But that's another topic for another thread.

Those that stole the money more than likely are not from this country.

Teachers are not there to instill any kind of value in a child. That is solely the parents job. If you aren't doing that as a parent, you are failing as a parent! There is NO passing the buck on that one.

Re: society, I can't knock that one. I think we should all be standing up and stopping this problem. But instead we want to pass blame onto banks and anyone else. Why take responsiblity for your own actions when you can hire a lawyer to do it for you... sickening. There is NO honor in that guys actions.

There are two problems with what happened to this guy.

1. He was ripped off. Sure it sucks, it sucks REAL bad. BUT - he asked for it by not protecting his stuff. If he wasn't acting how he was, I would actually feel quite bad for him, but I think he's a jerk and is deserving of what is happening considering his sue happy actions.

2. The people that hacked him, should be busted. NOT the virus writer unless the writer was the one who transferred the funds.

If I write a virus and don't release it, but then you get it from me and use it then it's YOUR fault for what happened, not mine. We can't just point fingers at the author. You need to point fingers at the person who actually used the virus.

As pointed our earlier and something I failed to put together until now:

The gun doesn't kill people, people do.

The coder of the virus doesn't infect people, the person who released it does.

mrafrohead

by hal 9000

Just ask any home owner who has recently brought a new computer what size HDD they have. My guess is you will be told how much ram is in the thing if anything at all.

They rely on the salesman to sell them what they need and while they may quibble on price of some items they generally get something close to what they need.

But Business is a different kettle of fish they should have professionals on hand to at the very least advise. Do you think that this guy doesn't have a Legal Adviser or a Tax Adviser? Why then doesn't he have an IT Adviser or if he does why did he chose to ignore the advice given to him?

Col ]:)

by dean

There is a presumption that an unauthorized wire transfer was made using information from the users computer. Maybe he disposed of his banking records by tossing them into a dumpster without shredding and a dumpster diver recovered **written** records. Could he have emailed his account information to a partner/spouse/relative for safekeeping and it was intercepted at the other end? The "facts" presented in the news article are pretty sparse to be driving this discussion.

by tonythetiger

The first thing that needs to be determined is "Was the transfer authorized by owner of the account?" and proceed from there. If it wasn't, then a crime was clearly committed, and law enforcement should be responsible for figuring out the who, when, and where.

To say he deserved it is clearly wrong... as wrong as saying a girl in a short skirt deserves to be raped.

by hal 9000

He would have a far better case if he had even the most basic AV product in place. He had nothing at all and should have known better as he runs an IT related business.

At the very least his customers could have told him how to secure his system. He chose not to and then cries foul when he gets hit.

Well if he had taken even the most basic steps and there is plenty of Free AV products out there that are more than capable of part way protecting the system most likely this would not have happened.

Now I know enough to know that there is no such thing as a totally secure system unless of course it has no way of getting power and no input devices then the data on it will be secure provided it is in a place that you can not physically get to it and walk away with the thing. Of course it would be nothing more than an expensive paper weight but it would be secure and totally useless. We all make compromises when it comes to security but to not have any security at all is just plain stupid and I'm betting even a 6 year old would be able to tell you that you need some form of AV product in place if you are connected in any way to an outside source.

Col ]:)

by rcruz

If you have unprotected sex with a prostitute, and get infected, do you have the right to sue the her? No!!! You knew what you were getting into. Same with pc viruses if you surf unprotected,and get infected, you have nobody to blame but yourself, ignorance is no excuse. Serves the A-hole right, hope he looses. Banks will defenitly be making disclaimers and pre-requisite about these types of situations to make themselves free of liability.

by tonythetiger

"Ignorance is no excuse". Unfortunately, too many business depend on this ignorance for their survival. Sad but true. Might as well just make fraud legal.

by hallinfoserv

Problem is not necessarily a stupid user, more ignorant. I help out a lot of people (mainly elderly) in my home district who buy PC's from big stores. The stores do not tell the people anything about the dangers, nor do they install firewalls or anti virus software. I spend a lot of time doing this for the people after they find machines not working or running slow, they simply were unaware the internet was such a hostile place. If it can be shown this guy knew the internet was hostile, then he deserved all he got, if he didn't, then he is an innocent victim. Whether the bank is liable of not I don't know. We can sit here and scoff at the victim, we are all educated IT people, not everyone is.

by br-tr

Your post shows that you have no idea of business and user's needs. If a bank is going to allow online/Internet banking, then it is responsible for seeing that the endpoints are secure before allowing the transaction. It needs to run a virus/Trojan scan on each machine that connects to it and only allow connections from clean machines.
As well, in needs better than siple password authentication. If it is going to allow $90,000 transactions it needs a $5.00 piece of paper with one time passwords to be given to users of its service. The law in Europe requires 2 factor authentication (one time transaction IDs plus regular passwords, or RSA tokens handed out by the bank) for every financial transaction over a certain limit. Bank of America has shown its incompetence by not doing the same thing. They allowed an unauthorized transaction to defraud someone of $90K. Maybe this suit will wake them up to their fiducial responsibilities

by mr. c3

If the trojan came from the bank's system, then the bank is at fault. Where is their virus scanner. They have control of the money in this country, can't they even buy a cheap virus scanner for their own system, or would that keep the bank president from buying his new Mercedes nest week? I have no sympathy for banks. Who is to say they didn't plant the trojan themselves> I don't and won't ever trust them

by hal 9000

Have a Lawyer or Tax Agent who works for him to read every contract and do his tax is that what you are getting at?

Worse still this guy runs a business which advertises its products in Computer Mags so he would also have a copy of every issue in which he had an add. Just how much information do you have to give to someone before they begin to take the potential problems seriously?

As they say you can lead a horse to water but you can't make it drink! :D

Col ]:)

by sbj11

Well I still feel that the bank need's to take a hit on some level. Remember banks and CU's want the business and they do alot to keep there customers safe and sound, but if I went in to a bank with a fake I.D. of somebodys walet I stole and cashed some check's they would get there mony back. At my job I think of my users like the AOL Add does they want the virus and the spyware and it's my job to help them not get it. To me the bank should have a policy in place to cover the customer and themself.

by hal 9000

When every bank and financial institution increases its fees to cover the projected losses.

If the banks security was not compromised they are not at fault and as far as keeping every access point secure would you trust your bank to secure your computer?

For that matter would you give access to your personal computer to just anyone that asked for it?

But this guy did even better than that he did absolutely nothing to protect his system and then cries foul when something goes wrong.

He certainly has Legal Representation I'm betting he also has an Accountant to do his tax returns and minimize any tax that he pays or at the very least make sure that he doesn't over pay any tax but for some reason he doesn't need an IT person to at the very least tell what he needs on his computer to make it safe.

You really can not be serious can you?

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

"If someone stole his checkbook and wrote $90,000 worth of checks, would this conversation be happenning?"

No it wouldn't even if every check was singed by the person responsible because it just wouldn't rate a mention on a Tech Forum.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

But it is too hard for him to make an application to have it returned so he is hitting his bank for the problem.

Secondly this guy runs a business which supplies guess who The Computer Industry!

Thirdly he has a lawyer to read any contracts he might get involved in an accountant to do his taxes but for some reason no IT Consultant to at the very least advise him of what he needs to be protected from a dangerous place.

Should every bullet have a message engraved on it saying "Caution Dangerous and I may Kill You?"

For that matter he also advertises in computer magazines and he would have a copy of every mag that an add of his appears in so just how much information do you have to put under his nose before he even begins to take some responsibility for his own stupidity?

Col ]:)

by carrera811bt

You have reported that someone has lost 90 K of his bank account.And this one was the prime minister of idiocy.It was a mistake to be careless and unaware of scammers of internet but should you know more (if you read this of course)unlike those warnings i have been sent,posted,screamed out.Xcuse me for my french but no one gave a f..k not even FTC nor yahoo nor Microsoft not even the big spamcop.What do you think the damages exceeded already of? By chinanet scummy spammers and weareaolandwantyoutoconfirmyouraccount
criminals? Yes sir the ignorance is waaaaay beyond stupidity
Aren't those who has the capacity to trace then prosecute internet criminals deserve the same idiot of this year and the past 3 award? Or they did not have enough damage to be pissed about???
Well i KNOW there are brilliant network pros that have the ability and position to simple block chinanet off the US access along with internet criminals.My HD crashed the third time by them and i am going to report their activity and i hope this time i will go all the way with it.If this community really aware of potential possible losses i suggest we unite and work on to protect our selves and if we succeed we will get the appreciation of the whole internet world at least i think.
Your comment will be appreciated
Sincerely TC

by herrickca

With all the barbs going back and forth from the techies and business people, we are forgetting one simple point. E-business is risky at best, even with higher levels of security, e.g. token authentication systems.

Banks accept fraudulent credit card transactions every day. Some transactions are in the tens of thousands of dollars.

However, when the customer informs the credit card company (by the way BofA started VISA), the credit card company removes the charge from the customer's account and eats the loss. For small transactions the financial institution requires little or no proof.

WHY... Because credit card companies like banks consider the Billions of dollars they lose to credit card fraud, as a cost of doing business.

They know if they forced the customers to absorb these costs credit card use and the money credit card companies make from such transactions and the interest customers pay each month would "Evaporate."

SO... Banks unless they provide tokens to their users like major banks in Europe do need to "pay up just like the credit card companies" and treat these losses as "The Cost of Doing E-Business.

By the way, our bank allows us to keep our larger accounts separate from our online accounts and only accept ?hard copy ? with wet signature? transactions to move money out of these accounts.

by lymon1

He probably did not read the EULA or ToA that probably states that BoA is not responsible for E transactions gone wrong. If this is not stated in the EULA/ToA fine print then BoA may not be protected from the wolves. But I agree that anyone who boots-up a computer w/o any kind of protection(which alot is free)is asking for trouble. I read 15 to 20 seconds on the WWW with no protection your infected. So, everyone SHOULD update, upgrade, and use the protection. This will be a FED case, so either way it goes if the government gets involved, because banks are federally protected, the taxpayer will lose a little for the FDIC lawyers.

by benoddo53

Technology is a key part of life in 21st century America. Too bad most of the population still lives in the Stone Age. That is by design. Corporate America has used technology to turn American consumers into mindless drones primarily by spoon-feeding consumers with just enough information to open their wallets and spend their credit lines on consumer items based on a list of features which amount to nothing more than a collection of superfluous bells and whistles. Gone are the days of research and analysis before spending your hard earned cash on a big-ticket item. That is evident by the popularity of SUV?s and pickup trucks on the road. If one were to actually do an analysis of their transportation needs 90% of current SUV and truck owners would not be driving one today. Does an urban dweller or suburbanite really need off road capability on the highways or city streets? Not really. Does a 175 lb. commuter need a 275 horsepower behemoth to drive to work or the train station? What a waste of resources!

Consumers do not know what they are buying, and worse, have no clue on how to properly use what they have bought. All they know is what they see on television.

On the enterprise level, professionals are paid to protect their networks and IT infrastructure from all those who wish to do harm. Unfortunately for every one professional there are at least 100 clueless users who have no idea of what lurks in the Internet waiting for an opportunity to steal their personal information. I attribute this to basically to the corporate initiative of making everyone?s job ?idiot-proof?. The ?Dumbing Down? of technologies in order to mass market them to people who have no business using technology more complex than a blender or a toaster.

I have been in IT for over 22 years and in application and user support for most of that time. Even today, I come across users who should not even have a telephone on their desk let alone a computer. Let?s face it, not everyone is cut out to use computers and mass marketing technology to the general population is fertile ground for hackers.

I?d like to close with one of my favorite quotes:

?Programming today is a race between software engineers striving to build bigger and better idiot-proof programs and the universe trying to produce bigger and better idiots. So far, the universe is winning.?
? Rich Cook, author

by mikercol

Instead of trying to crucify/stone the victim/OS/bank for stupidity talk about improving the system. This sort of thing will NEVER be completely eliminated by "protective" measures.

The problem is that the system does not have a reversal mechinisim that works. There is $70K that is caught up in limbo, 78% of the total loss is NOT lost just stuck. The rest of the loss isn't lost just in the hands of a criminal. If the system moves the loss "onshore" from Timbuk2 then there is no motivation for "foreign" banks to improve their systems.

The loss needs to be as close to the crook as possible. It puts the motivation to stop this in the right place. If nothing else, after the first $xxx,xxx dollar/euro/sheckel in losses, pull the "foreign" banks ticket to play electronic bank.

by andeanderson

That's the new attitude of most Americans. "It's not my fault they, big-brother whoever, should have protected me from myself."

Banks do not have a need or responsibility to double-check and verify every electronic transfer of money when the correct identification and verification are utilized. If they did try to impose such a restriction the outcry would soon drown out any possible safety provided.

I am pretty sure BoA, like most banks have a disclaimer about their obligations and the obligations of users for electronic banking that must be agreed to before the services are provided.

Plus, think about the possibility of the virus going from this guys computer to one of his customers or vendors systems and the chaos that would cause. If they tracked the problem back to him he would be sued for his lack of due diligence in protecting their confidential information.

If you choose to be involved in electronic banking do not claim ignorance. Most agreements, even EBay's, are pretty clear.

The cry of "You should have stopped me from ...." has been used for so many frivolous litigations that even a child can now sue a school if they don't like the lunches.

Why can't people just stand up and accept their responsiblity for their own actions, or lack of action?