This guy should be stoned... (with rocks)
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Malware
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by david_heath
I forgot to add to the previous post that the editor changed the title of the article to the very insipid 'Safe Surf.'
It was originally entitled "Do you want the Russian Mafia to know your Credit Card Number?"
by hal 9000
He could have transfered the money himself and then cried Foul. :(
Of course the Legal W H O R E doesn't help matters any and he is only out for himself and his own bank balance which like most banks is horrendous when compared to the amount of work that he will be doing to get the money.
Col ]:)
by dr dij
by dr dij
by dr dij
the reason some societies pay for health is that it can be life threatening.
This guy might be financially strapped and unhappy but he will not die from being out of the money.
Sympathy and advice OK but not necessarily money. Society or non-resposible parties do not have a resposibility to bail this person out. If you think this then you are committing a force act against those you take money unwillingly to bail this person out (tax collectors use power and force of law).
The whole point of capitalism is that having people able to lose money makes them more careful, and business that are not go out of business instead of being a drag on us all.
And we don't have to worry whether it is dishonest on the owners part as we're not paying for it.
There's business owners not knowledgable in the field of physical security either yet we don't bail them out if they stick gold bars behind a screen door. They buy insurance if they want reimbursement, and actually get advice from insurance agents. Biz insurance agents require changes to businesses to insure them, e.g. they often specify security measures required, etc.
And that's a pretty vague generalization that banks 'can afford the loss'. All costs are passed on to the consumer. If it was a small bank it could go bankrupt from large or continued losses.
The 'guy' in question was also a business. So automatically if one business is larger than the other, the larger biz should absorb the loss? Pretty ridiculous.
The bank in this article was not breached, the person's computer was. They provide a service to transfer money by computer to whoever provides the password and login.
I'd be happy to provide money to a food bank to keep this guy from starving but as to taxpayers bailing out his un-insured biz if it is, I would not want the gov't to do this. Or the bank as it appears they are not responsible.
I'm happy to let you put your money where your mouth is by you sending money to this person. It is always easier to spend someone else's money tho and say that someone else should pay for something.
by hal 9000
I don't think he would be making the claim or they could have refused to pay because he was in breach of their minimum standards that they told him they required for basic security.
Either way he didn't show any responsibility at all. He has a Lawyer to look over contracts for him and launch action to protect his clients, presumably he has an accountant to make sure he doesn't pay more in tax than he should and what happened to the IT specialist to advise?
No matter how you look at it I think the thing is fishy at the very least.
1 reported hit by a new Trojan in the entire world. I know AV programmers try to keep ahead of the new Virus being set free to fly but even still it only takes a few minutes to cover the entire world when one of these nasties is set free and the AV companies take at best a few hours to release a patch so if this was so nasty I would expect more than just the one complaint.
Then what about all of his client data which doesn't seem to be at issue or his address book was this Trojan passed on to everyone in his address book or was his accounting data spoofed and bills sent out to all of his clients asking for payment but having it redirected to a different location so he doesn't get to ever see it.
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Something a bit more solid than body fluid it might run through their scanning equipment way to fast. :D
Of course that could always demand a limb per transaction but that would limit the number of transactions you could make wouldn't it? :)
Col ]:)
by justinf
I agree that he should have had up to date antivirus software and the latest security patches etc but still feel sorry for him although it isn't the bank's responsibility for the theft.
However, the car analogy only goes so far; when you buy a new car it already has everything you need to drive it and it comes with an owner's manual telling you when and what to have serviced for the period of the warranty, which is 5 years for most cars. A new PC comes with no instructions, you need to get additional items so you can use it safely and the warranty usually only covers hardware for 12 months.
by hal 9000
Business units are completely different. Of course if you work in a big business the IT department may not pass these on but they already have the safeguards put in place.
Actually if you want to take the Car Analogy further Volvo has just completed a car designed by getting the input from women and it has no bonnet so you have no access to the engine, transmission, radiator, battery or anything else under the hood. They also wanted to do away with the fuel filler but couldn't figure out a way to keep it running.
Of course the owners manual when it eventually becomes available will only have one page in it which will tell how to put in fuel and if anything else goes wrong ring up the local service section for Volvo. The rest of the first page and the other side will be directions on how to drive it.
Col ]:)
by collins_rf
by oz_media
Firstly, Bank of America has some VERY easy to find and very detailed security advice on securing your identity, credit cards and debit cards, email fraud, and online banking fraud.
FIRST point made:
[b]Protecting yourself against e-mail or online fraud[/b]
* Make sure the security features of your computer software, including your Web browser, are up-to-date. Software companies continuously provide security updates to their products. To learn more about keeping your computer security current, get tips and information from Microsoft (http://www.microsoft.com/security/protect/) or visit the National Cyber Security Alliance (http://www.staysafeonline.info/e-tips.html).
Not only do they CLEARLY advise on protecting your OWN pc, they offer links to more detailed information, including the NCSA.
The banks OWN policy (these are all taken from FLorida's BOA where the clever man resides),
[b]How Bank of America Protects Your Security[/b]
How we protect your online security
Keeping financial and personal information about you secure and confidential is one of our most important responsibilities. Our systems are protected, so information remains secure.
* Computer virus protection detects and prevents computer viruses from entering our computer network systems.
* Firewalls block unauthorized access by individuals or networks. Firewalls are one way Bank of America protects its computer network systems that interact with the Internet.
* Secure transmissions ensure information remains confidential. Bank of America uses encryption technology such as Secure Socket Layer (SSL) on its Web sites to transmit information between you and the bank. See our list of recommended browsers.
* To send us secure e-mail, you should use Bank of America Contact Us. Because an Internet e-mail response back to you will not be secure, we will not include confidential account information in an e-mail response, and we will not ask for personal information, such as passwords as PINs, through e-mail. Besides e-mail, you can contact us by visiting any banking center.
* New advances in security technology are constantly evaluated to ensure that we provide protection for information about you.
So what we have seen here is a bank that clearly has taken the neccessary steps to secure it's information. They have also advised USERS on how to protect their own PC's. They THEN sent out an update specifically to remind customers of virus threats and recommended security.
At what time does the customer become free of burden and the onus of securing the customers PC is up to BOA?
Should BOA jack up their rates so that you can pay them to send out tech's to secure all new customer PC's?
BOA did THEIR job, the customer didn't. It's really too bad he lost his money, and obviously he is going to try and take legal action to reclaim his lost money, but to sue BOA is a stupid move, he could have been on their good side and I am sure they MAY have even felt bad and helped him to deal with the bank in Latvia.
He lashed out at the wrong people at the wrong time and VERY unjustly at that. Big mistake, just echos why he would be dumb enough to transfer that much money from an insecure PC to begin with.
BOA is free of ANY blame, HE is 100% at fault for his own negligence and failure to heed warnings and written guidance from the bank.
by garner
The banking industry should have some accountability! They push on-line banking to customers. However, I do not believe they should be helt accountable for a business or individuals own computer problems.
I do believe they should have some type of awareness training for their customers and employees on the threats of doing on-line banking.
I have setup seminars for just that and have delivered them to computer users - it is a public service I do.
by hal 9000
Just now the latest MS stuff has come through and at the top of the page is a Security Issue at
http://www.microsoft.com/presspass/features/2005/feb05/02-15Updates.asp
If this guy can not even be interested in reading what is sent to him by the bank, can not be bothered to do the most basic things like patch the system or even subscribe to something as freely available as MS Microsoft Press Pass Newsletter he deserves all he gets.
Personally I think it was a good 90K lesson and he got off cheap it could and should have been a lot worse.
Col ]:)
by red_wolf9
While I love to join you in a MS bashing session, I must disagree with your logic.
All tolls have an owners manual, if you can't use the tool correctly, said tool should not be redesigned to over come the stupidity of the lest competent user.
Under that logic Ford would have to make a car that drives itself because some moron somewhere can't drive without wrecking. And all table saws would have to have rubber saw blades that don't turn fast enough to amputate a finger.
You seem to be in the Anti-M$ camp so why would you be advocating yet another single vendor solution to PC problems. Today every major ISP gives away free AV and for those that don't there is always AVG or Avast.
User education is the only answer to problems like these. As the saying goes... make it idiot proof and someone will build a better idiot.
by jdclyde
his account it.
a member since 99, and this is only the second time he has poked his nappy little head up. And after all that wait, this is what he has to say for himself. Sad, real sad.
No questions asked or answered.
Just a regular contributor, huh?
by red_wolf9
You better stick with OnLines Security because those of us in Computer Security know that a trojan is not the same as a man-in-the-middle attack.
Also those in glass houses should not throw stones, before you criticize someone?s lack of knowledge in this thread you might want to do a few things first.
A) Actually read the article, the suspected trojan is CoreFlood, this is definitely not a man-in-the-middle style attack.
B) Stop with the CAPSLOCK AUTOPILOT it undermines what little credibility you might have left after calling this a man-in-the-middle attack.
C) Stop studying OnLines security and invest in real Computer Security, perhaps look in to CISSP training.
http://www.webopedia.com/TERM/C/CISSP.html
This is a man-in-the-middle attack
http://www.vandyke.com/solutions/ssh_overview/ssh_overview_threats.html
Here is a simple diagram of a man-in-the-middle attack
http://www.e-government.govt.nz/docs/authentication-bpf/m-i-m.gif
And this is what CoreFlood does
http://securityresponse.symantec.com/avcenter/venc/data/backdoor.coreflood.html
http://vil.nai.com/vil/content/v_100312.htm
Read more about the case here:
http://nwc.compliancepipeline.com/60300288
by red_wolf9
You want secure connection here is my solution:
1) Install a frame relay link from your location to the BoA.
2) Have the bank supply you a PC to place at the end of that connection.
3) Remove ALL rights and lock the PC down, so you the end user can not install software, browse the internet, etc.
4) Use ISS Proventia Desktop to verify patch levels and AV signatures before allowing the secure connection into the BoA cloud.
http://www.iss.net/products_services/enterprise_protection/proventia_desktop/index.php
5) Require Secure ID card + PIN before every transaction.
6) Require a callback and verbal confirmation of the afore mentioned transaction.
The problem is NO user to lazy to install AV and/or follow basic computer best practices would follow those steps. Not a single one !!
So your back in the old catch 22- Security vs. Usability.
Perhaps if OS's had not been dumbed down to the village idiot level the public would think twice before they logged on. Think of an commercial aircraft cockpit, I have my private pilots license but even I would think twice before sitting down at the controls but if there was one big screen with a take off, enter destination, and land buttons any moron would think they could fly.
I do agree the coffee suit and this one are not equal. BoA has not been sued by several other customers that have lost 90k to a Latvian bank. And speaking of the Latvian bank it would appear that their audits caught an abnormal deposit to an account, which further makes me think that the 90k transaction was not prevented by BoA because it fit a normal pattern of use, 90k sounds like a lot but for many businesses it is a normal transaction amount.
by hal 9000
I have a few clients who roam the world buying heavy plant and they go to auctions or the like see a piece of plant that they want so they organize a wire transfer for a nonrefundable deposit for the piece of plant of something like 10% of its value. Normally these are well in excess of the 1M mark for the complete sale of the item and that is just one piece of plant if they want several pieces the transaction would be much bigger.
They not only wire larger amounts but do it from different locations mostly not even from the same country as their bank account is and they can do this several times within a week from different countries as they only need a day at one of the major auction houses to find what if they have something that they want there and then move on to the next one in a different country for more equipment.
Col ]:)
by cactus pete
If you read all the links about this company, you see it's a small one - 5 people. Lopez took out a second mortgage on his home for $30k and put up $20k of his savings, which wipes him out, but keeps the business going.
If the normal activity for this account ever came anywhere near 90k in a single transaction, I'd be very surprised.
Add that to the fact that the transaction went to a country on a continent with which he has never done business... Add that to the fact that this country [and bank] are somewhat notorious for having this sort of fraud...
Lopez may be at some fault for not having knowledge of how to protect his computer, but the bank has some responsibility here, too.
by red_wolf9
Had 90k moved to a country listed as supporting state sponsored terrorist then yes, if would be reviewed per policy, but Latvia is on no such list.
http://www.state.gov/s/ct/rls/pgtrpt/2000/2441.htm
Once again, this sum did not trigger BoA's audit because it was considered "normal activity". I know you and I don't move 90k around but this is a business, try and keep the amount in perspective.
Imagine if you will how crippled our economy would become if Homeland Security had to review every multi-national bank transaction? Would you want your Congressman to review and approve all your ATM transactions?
by dr dij
maybe we should sue the makers of that flat metal thing that lets burglars slip between window and pull up locks to get our car. and maybe we should sue screwdriver makers as some car thieves use them to turn the key switch. and sue gun makers because some users kill people with them.
How about instead finding the person who deployed the virus and took the data to break into the account?
by red_wolf9
That method is certainly much better but still not fool proof (nothing is). I could possibly compromise your solution with ARP poisoning or session hijacking, not to mention the off chance you might fall victim to a cross-site scripting attack.
If my zero-day trojan lies dormant and only fires off while your connected the transaction could accure via a script while you process a separate legitimate request, again NOTHING is fool proof it?s a question of risk assessment.
I applaud you for choosing a bank that takes such strong measures and your ability to recognize the risks; I wish others were as smart. Take care not to gain a false sense of security... Semper Vigilantia!
by dr dij
So you can mystimagically make up what the bank thinks?
I have no love for BofA but if they gave out $90k everytime some business asked for it, then people would quickly setup scams where they put a trojan on their PC and transferred money to their buddy in (brazil.. Latvia.. outer mongolia, etc).
Then get it back from BoFA and a portion of the other money too.
by dr dij
by dr dij
much as IBM is the customer of SCO if they win the $5billion they're suing IBM for!
As cartridge recyclers are often scam biz, he may have been looking for a new income source, as someone posted earlier
by dr dij
by dr dij
Might have been a remote-control trojan (e.g. sub-seven variants), in which case they could login when person not around and left computer on and send bank transfer from correct IP.
dial up ISPs give dift IP address each time you connect. Sure, then IP addr are in a range but if they denied trans based on this, hacker could have used another PC that was remote controlled on the same ISPs subnet of customers.
And anyway if it was NOT part of their current setup then they had no obligation to do this. Why check something that would not tell them if fraudulent? The guy might have wanted to do a bank trans from his cigarette cocaine smuggling boat via wireless, or dial up from remote location, would be dift IP addr.
by red_wolf9
What's next... we sue the keyboard maker because the keyboard should have prevented him from entering text into a trojan'ed machine, where would it end?
ISP's are shielded from most lawsuits by the "Safe Harbor" provision of the DMCA, as well as existing case law.
http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&c2coff=1&q=AOL+liability+suit&spell=1
If the RIAA's lawyers can't get ISP's for copyright infringement then I doubt you could get them for a trojan infection.
I was unaware that a there was a law that required my water company to deliver me fresh water, please provide a link to such a law. My water company does a good job delivering me clean water but we have had a "boil water notice" when a pumping station failed (due to an ice storm).
The argument could also be made that water is critical to your survival where the Internet (unless you addicted to EverCrack) is not. Not exactly an apple to apples comparison.
by red_wolf9
Judging by my users (who don't read their corporate hand book either) they would pick it up, smile at you, go back to their desk and file it never to be seen again. Most schools make you sign a paper to get into the computer lab, they don't read those either, they just sign. Note to self: include $100.00 per minute fee paid directly to the on duty administrator while in the lab.
When you battle user apathy you often come away bloodied and bruised with little to show for the effort. Most people have figured out the car commercials that advertise zero down and zero percent financing are for "qualified buyers", but when the finance guy tries to stuck you with 23% APR you can walk away with a lesson learned.
It's human nature you just don't care until it happens to you. I despise the concept, but I must admit it keeps me gainfully employed ;)
by mikercol
I'm glad you are not on the jury, not only would you find in favor of the bank you would try to put the poor slob himself in jail for fraud.
backdoor.coreflood was discovered Nov 2002. It took 10 seconds to find the first variant that Symantec cataloged.
So if someone being uninformed makes it ok to rip them off you had best RUN to the bank empty all your accounts, bury the money in your yard and sit on a bucket over the hole. Sorry you are uninformed.
by oz_media
Now you've been told. YOU are uninformed. LOL :D
I like tha analogy used to compare the comment too, talk about a different issue and ont even applicable.
Why do people always use the worst comparissons and analogies to justify their means?
You should learn to become a little more PC savvy though, I know you try and pretend you know your stuff around here but you aren't ALWAYS right you know. Perhaps 99.9% of the time, but not always.
Why don't you visit MS in the states again, hey you can get a new BELL while you're there!
by hal 9000
I'd be buying lots of go faster bits the helmets are an easy one just a International Bank draft and wait 6 days for it to arrive I know what I'm getting there.
But I always like to see what I'm paying for when I'm buying any high performance parts if they are not coming from a supplier that I already know. Now if I could only get over there without my wife knowing :( Actually I can travel to the US provided I don't go anywhere near CA and I do mean anywhere as she has her own little map with a big red circle around that state as a "NO GO" area for me. Of course she still hasn't quite worked out how the bits keep arriving but she doesn't get near my main workstation I built her one and she will not use it so I'm safe from her prying eyes. :D
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Account number and BSB and you try to get all you can?
You will not even be able to get a ballance I have enough trouble doing that as I have to answer almost everything down to the color of my underwear but the best one is they want to know just how much should be in there and that iss what I'm asking! :)
I'm not silly enough to even consider on line banking let alone be part of it as I'm not happy with the banks level of security or means of access let alone the ability to keep my own system clean.
Col ]:)
by oz_media
Now that's a no brainer!
Yellow in the front and brown in the back, right?
:D
by mikercol
I'm glad you are not on the jury, not only would you find in favor of the bank you would try to put the poor slob himself in jail for fraud.
backdoor.coreflood was discovered Nov 2002. It took 10 seconds to find the first variant that Symantec cataloged.
So if someone being uninformed makes it ok to rip them off you had best RUN to the bank empty all your accounts, bury the money in your yard and sit on a bucket over the hole. Sorry you are uninformed.
by dr dij
by dr dij
by momtojustin
by dr dij
They should run virus scans, trojan scans, perhaps add video camera so they can view him inside his house, plus a fingerprint scanner and token random# card.
And they should pay for it all; maybe even buy him a computer. They should force him to take online tests of his knowledge of security. And not let him drive to any bad neighborhoods where his wallet with the online token card could be stolen.
If the bank is not willing to do this, I'm sure enuf people seem think it might then be the Govts responsibility to monitor us all (all in the name of 'security'). Remember folks, if you're not doing anything wrong, what harm could come of it?
All hail the all powerful CompanyState that will now run our lives. Remember 'righthink' or you could be put away for thinking security violation thoughts. Of course, the CompanyState will take all your income to pay for this and because they know better how to spend it!
We'll give the new COmpanyState a nice name like 'MaCorp' or 'CitiHall' (thankyou for occasional lafs, Futurama).
by dr dij
The money they collect pays for the service they provide. If they had to check every packet they still wouldn't catch everything and your fees would be doubled.
By that same logic, if you're scammed by a telemarketer, ATT or MCI or Sprint should be responsible for letting you communicate with a thief, and not knowing that a # in canada or vegas was a telemarketer.
by oz_media
They have CLEAR security information provided, see below, it ook about 2 minutes to find the security ifo for Miami. They actually make security info VERY easy to find, and they make it VERY clear where responsibility lies. So yes perhaps the=is guy DID go to the bank and just ignore everythng he was give to sign, perhaps his company of trained computer professionals was a big lie and he really doesn't have a clue OR a professional to help him.
We are not talking abou tclicking an install on some demo software or a licenced copy even, this is about signing a document stating that you understand HOW you money is handled, HOW it is secured. For a business owner, you would think this would warrant a little attention to detail, if not, once again HE is the dummy here.
The bank WARNED him, they printed it on their website, the lawyer even agrees that the bank had warned him, ANY breach past that point is 100% HIS responsibility. The bank wasn't breached, HE was. The bank is not at fault, HE is.
It has nothing to do with supporting the big bad bank, who's business practices you seem to really have a grip on, it has EVERYTHING to do with his trying to SUE an organization who provided all of the security implied and accepted by him PRIOR to being breached. The bank even when above and beyond what is needed by sending him an advisory oin security, they provide links to several security sites where he could and SHOULD have gone to ensure his safety. Negligence is nowhere but on HIS desk.
by oz_media
You are right Colin, if you have home insurance and go away with your doors unlocked and windows opened, KISS YOUR COVERAGE GOODBYE.
This guy is a fool, e knows it and his way of dealin gwith it is to try and pass the blame on to someone else with more money. "They SHOULD have been aware!" They WERE aware and HE was warned.
He deserves to lose his business, he deserves to lose his money, he is stupid and wrong in going after the bank, had he shown a little more tact and common sense, I am sure he would have found more sympathy.
by oz_media
MANY banks will setup an account based on your usage. Say a monthly fee of $4.00 will get you free withdrawls AT the bank and a half a dozen at other machines.
A $2.50 month fee may get you 4 withdrawls from the bank and all others are full service fee.
SO banks here actually do charge fo rwithdrawls but it is generally compunded into a monthly service fee (account package) that is designed to offer the best value for money on services you use.
by oz_media
Well the bank is NOT responsible because the BANKS security was NOT breached any anytime.
NO virus at the bank, and if you want to see exactly what measures they have in place, it's easily found and looked up BY STATE on the main BOA homepage.
This has nothing at all to do with the bank.
5 years you've been a member here and one of your only posts indicates you didn't even read the main article(s) in question?
by oz_media
Nobody is making the Latvian bank the third party, the third party is atually BOA.
They were secure, THEY were not breached, yet THEY are being held acocuntable for HIS inactions?
BOA has already said they will NOT be responsible for reclaiming his money as they cannot legally get involed, there was NO breach of their security and they were not robbed of money.
As you sugested, the customer needs to take civil suit on the Latvian bank himself. Had he not jumped on the 'sue BOA' bandwagon, they MAY have been a little more helpful as far as how to go about TRYING to recover his funds. As it is now, they have wiped their hands of the issue, saying that it is NOT their problem, and it isn't.
by oz_media
Leave the door unlocked, NEW FURNITURE!!!
Leave my key in my truck's ignition while at the mall, YAY new truck courtesy of Safeway!
Drop my wallet from the ferry, "Hey someone robbed me for 8 grand!" (Hold the hand out to BC Ferries)
Man, that IS a good idea isn't it?! :D Oh, but what if I start paying for everyone else's loss too!? Nah, I like the 'personal responsibility' factor better.
by dr dij
regardless of what SHOULD be, the agreement, legally binding, in place states is that the bank is NOT reponsible for running virus/ trojan scans on user's PCs. That doesn't seem to stop juries from making stupid awards from perceived big pockets people. In this case it did NOT need paper and the person signed up with online banking to avoid this kind of hassle.
Most other people avoid online fraud unless they give away their passwords to phishers. I'm of the opinion this is a setup, to send transactions just under business limits to unverifiable foreign person them claim it was stolen.
Sure online banking could be more secure. The separate device that generates random transaction code combined with secure pipe would be only way. (the guy could have 'lost' the device and then claimed he was still scammed). So maybe biometric thing also. But it WAS NOT setup this way and his business agreed to do this.
by dr dij
by dr dij
The business guy here was using his own system. The bank is not supporting his home PC, just connecting to it. Why see what the courts say? They often make stupid decisions based on fact that one business is bigger than other and has more money. And YOU as customer of these businesses will pay for any decisions rendered against them.
We don't sue GM because it does not make theft proof cars. We assess the risk of where we drive and how expensive/ easy to steal is what we drive and either get insurance for value of car and/or add on extra protection so thief goes to next car.
So for this reason is not M$ fault either.
Just because he might not have known risk doesn't mean he shouldn't have asked his 'experienced IT staff' or security consultant.
Anyway, all this idiocy on his part and his failure to ask for his money back from Latvian bank makes it look like he is the scammer trying to setup offshore transfer untraceable so he can claim is stolen.
by dr dij
by dr dij
Many people in this thread ARE showing compassion but compassion<>money. Some here do not feel he was incredibly stupid, and even if they do may feel sorry for him but it doesn't mean he wasn't at fault.
It also does not mean the bank should pay for it or we as customer's of same bank should pay. If it was his fault or the problem was his responsibility (in the end it was the thiefs fault but sounds like the inkjet biz guy's reponsibility).
by hal 9000
Just to spoof the scanner and take a copy of his finger print off the HDD. I've actually not only used those things but also sold them and on every occasion if they fail to work you have a password to fall back on which gives the same data as the scanner.
Col ]:)
by tim
by kaceyr
... would be covered, and only up to the amount of coverage. There are many accounts that banks have that are only covered for a percentage of their total. Also, anything stolen from safe deposit boxes is not covered, as (most) banks do not insure their safe deposit boxes.
What you're implying is that banks should carry some sort of fraud insurance. I don't even want to imagine how much that would cost (a cost that would certainly be transferred to the bank patrons).
by roywads
by mrafrohead
Very aware...
As a matter of fact, I'm aware of it as I used to be at LCUC...
Check your dex... I think you'll know where that is... ;p
by mrafrohead
That's where I want to go...
I used to live across the street from the school behind the state buildings... My kids just walked across the street to go to school in the morning, it was nice.
But after they put those buildings up, I had to leave. I moved to scumwater to get away from all of the traffic in the other two cities, but after those buildings went up, traffic got to be unbearable for me, with all the new lights and crap, so I left... ;p
I can pay taxes in another city and not contribute to all of the clutter...
by kaceyr
has been building up. And what's going to happen to all that property that JZ ownes when she finally passes? I haven't heard about any family to take it over, so it will probably be taken over by the city and parcelled out. And with the shopping center just past the theater, the traffic gets pretty bad (at least on the weekends).
I have two boys who attended that school and you're right, it was much nicer when those office buildings weren't there.
They've now put up more office buildings across the street from The Point (two buildings, one behind the other and a post office) and across from the old fire station (two buildings, one behind the other and a multi-level parking structure). Olympia is starting to get a ticked because just over half of the government offices are no longer in the capital city (couldn't happen to a nicer bunch of weenies).
BTW: What ever happened to the lizard people? ;P
by jennyn
indeed - when I complained to Citibank UK about my treatment by Citibank US they denied all responsibility - the US operation is run entirely separately they claimed.
UK enviroment is much firmer on banks, expecting much more responsiveness, lower charges, better service and better anti fraud protection.
by hal 9000
So the correct answer is Brown all over. :D
The yellow stuff mixes with the brown so it spreads further.
Col ]:)
by david_heath
by hal 9000
But one isolated attack in the entire world from a supposed nasty Trojan is just a bit on the small side for me to believe. :)
I'd say personally we are seeing a whole truck load of what that end of the Horse produces. :D
But what is really getting to me is only his bank account details got at and nothing else. Each and every one of his contacts didn't get hit and his complete customer and supplier base remains intact.
As the Bard would be saying now "Something stinks in the State of Denmark."
Col ]:)
by jdclyde
We don't have time for facts, they just slow us down and get in the way.
Move aside, I'm tripping through.
by mrafrohead
You got me on that one...
It's funny, I was going to a job interview at the LnI building the other day.
I was sitting at the light by the Chevron and Quizno's and almost thought I was lost with all of the trees that were cut down.
I thought i was in the right place, but it didn't look like I remembered. On the way back, I found out why it looked so funny..
So many renovations, they just need to S T O P...
by oz_media
If the bank is breached. Online money transfers where YOU are jeopardized, no coverage.
This guy 'could' have PURPOSELY transferred the money himself and just played the game.
by guapo
...crap from guys who feel they have to defend their choice of crappy software, but no evidence is ever offered that shows any other OS in the world to be as easy to compromise as Windows. If you believe that any modern distribution of Linux is as easy, out of the box, to crack into as out of the box XP, then you simply don't know what the hell you are talking about.
I see you some of you ignored my advice about making larger fools of yourselves.
by hal 9000
If the person who is using the thing doesn't have enough brains to actually secure the thing properly it really doesn't matter what was being used. Anyway if he is really that silly do you think he could handle a "Nix" Distro? :)
What I haven't even heard mentioned here is the fact that only one hit world wide has been reported, now doesn't that sound just a bit strange to you? :(
Even for a Windose box that is a marvelous security response one unsecured box across the whole world is affected.
The really good crooks would be skimming a few $ off each account and in their own currency so no alarm bells would be ringing when the people get their statements at the end of the month. I saw something similar recently but because each transaction was in US$ it was picked up immediately. If it had of been in the local currency most likely it would never have been notices as each transaction was only about $5.00 per hit and three or four hits per month. Add that across 10,000 accounts and it makes for a decent ongoing income that no one or very few would even notice.
Col ]:)
by jwbogart
by kaceyr
(disclaimer) In My Humble Opinion ...
Throughout the entire time of this thread we've heard absolutely *nothing* about anyone else being hit in this way. This leads us to believe that this guy isn't on the up-and-up.
In fact, it leads me to believe that he was indeed, as suggested earlier, laundering money.
So, someone who dislikes him (in the money laundering circles I can imagine he'd have a few enemies) broke into his office and used his computer to make a wire transfer (what? no honor among thieves?).
His first notification is that the folks who were *supposed* to get the money, didn't get it. He checks his (shady) books and finds that, indeed, 90K went out, but not where it was supposed to go.
Now he needs to figure out a way to come up with 90K (plus interest) to prevent having himself and his family "removed" from the picture.
How do you come up with lots of (legit) cash in America quickly? You file a lawsuit against someone with the ability to cover the money and hope that they settle without a battle.
Somehow I think my scenario seems a bit more plausible than his story. Of course, I've been wrong before ...
by tonythetiger
People here probably protect themselves better than average. Also, identity theft is in the news, and this is just another form of it (assuming the guy is telling the truth). I mean, would you feel any sorrier for him if he threw a credit card receipt in his garbage and someone got it and charged up 90K worth?
No, since the credit card company would only hold him responsible for the first $50
by kaceyr
Not all accounts are covered. Certainly the most common ones (standard savings, standard checking) are covered, and several types of corporate accounts are covered.
The term "depositor" refers to a depositing entity, not an account. So let's say that you have 2 savings accounts and 1 checking account at your bank, each with a balance of $90K. Let's say the money is stolen and can't be recovered. The FDIC will have the first $100K or your money covered, AND THAT'S IT! You're out $170K!
In addition, FSLIC and FDIC do not, and have never, insured anything contained in safe deposit boxes. This is because the very nature of safe deposit boxes is so that no one but the person who rents the box knows the contents. No insurance company will give you blanket coverage for unknown articles.
by kaceyr
... were a hot subject when I first moved up to here. I worked with a couple of folks who lived in Yelm and said that when they got in the car they'd put on their foil-lined baseball caps so that the Lizard People couldn't read their thoughts.
At first I thought, yeah right. You're pulling my leg. Then they showed me their foil lined baseball caps. Blew me away!
One of these guys was really upset that the state made him move his mobile home. It seems that he was one of the people who put their mobile home underground to "escape detection by the lizard people".
I'm not kidding on this. It's really died out over the years, but these guys were kinda freaky.
Then, of course, there's the Ramtha followers (or Ramsters as many call them). Definately a cult all their own.
by grace.garcia
Next time you think of how ignorant this users was for infecting his computer "not himself" da!!
This bank should not even be in business, if they do not have all the proper software, firewalls, etc, etc, to protect their customers assets. My opinion their network administrator (security)geek should be fired!!!! Even if the customer was not computer literate to not know better, that is why we get paid the big bucks to protect massive corp systems. Yes, users should be on alert, but you know as well as I do... If the IT Dept for this bank would of been doing their job... "THIS WOULD OF NEVER HAPPENED" The only cost this customer should of been out was to have his pc scrubbed..... Not 90K..... I also would be sueing the back for trying to save $$$$ on ignorant IT employees that can't protect their systems.... I feel sorry for the Co. you work for if these are your thoughts... Ouch!!!!
by kaceyr
You either haven't been paying attention or haven't bothered to read any other posts.
The Bank was *NOT* compromised in any way. All of it's security precautions were, and are, intact.
The transaction was was put through as a proper, authenticated, authorized transaction. The bank has no fault in this, the customer has 100% of the fault.
Let's say that you do on-line banking from home. One day, one of your kids watches you enter your credentials and writes them down. Later, you leave to attend a pro-outsourcing rally. Your child logs on to your on-line banking site with your credentials and wires their own account $1,000. Guess what? Your bank isn't at fault. You are, and your out the thousand bucks because it was an authenticated, authorized transaction.
Have a nice day.
by oz_media
"Later, you leave to attend a pro-outsourcing rally."
That was just damn funny! :D
by oz_media
Does your company go out and setup antivirus and turn up once a week for Virus Scanning services for all of your clients?
If a client bought something through YOUR website and HIS PC had been hacked, how and WHY are you to blame? Do you accept responsibility for your customers PC's now too? Do they need to register them with you and install remote maintenance software so you can keep them up to date like some free help desk service? Does your BOSS know this?
Give your head a shake, the bank conducted a standard transaction using it's authentication methods, that checked out fine. The BANK was not breached, the BANK's security is not an issue in ANY way AT ALL.
IF the bank was breached then yes I would agree, but the bank did nothing other than request the standard ID information and confirmation as ANY other financial organization on the planet does.
If YOU left your bank card on the coffee table, along with a note with your pin code on it, and I stole it. Is the BANK responsible?
It's customer negligence, NOT the bank's negligence. The bank issued warnings, has security and secure banking information printed clearly on it's website. They did MORE than most would just by sending out notices that such things were possible, as they are with ANY bank.
The customer ignored warnings, failed to secure HIS equipment and was hacked. The bank is NOT in ANY way even slightly liable for the loss. It's black and white, no grey area and no IF's.
by hal 9000
You would be up to your neck in law suits so quickly alluding a breach of Privacy that it wouldn't be funny.
Also just how many of your customers do you think would be willing to stay on line while you performed a Virus Scan on their equipment after first updating it to the latest available?
As for the outsourcing convention or was it a picnics I'm willing to accept their work without question easy money and very little work to keep a machine as open as that one was. Perhaps I would have to log on daily just to make sure that nothing had been added to prevent some form of attack from succeeding. :)
I just love those who have to bash big business because it is there and never accept responsibility for their own stupidity.
Col ]:)
by tonythetiger
Like, what was the IP address of the computer that made the transaction?
I wonder why there's not been an update?
by dcperich
Blame will be determined by where the money falls...and which lawyer's pockets get the fullest.
Banks are currently eager to make transactions easy and disregard possible safeguards. It's a good come-on for new customers. Eventually, they will probably only allow transfers under specific conditions they have control over, with their own software, and large or frequent transfers will require verified collaboration from the owners of the accounts.
"Verified collaboration" could be innitiated with a fingerprint or retna scan associated with the account.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
Someone using a credit card is VERY diffeerent than someone hacking your PC. The credit card is often unauthorized under a certain amount. Therefore the bank accepts that the cost of verification of ALL transactions will be higher than the losses due to incorrect use. By NOT requiring authorization you then accept responsibility for misuse or the client's card. This cost is also passed on to the merchants who pay to provide such services at their stores, it is up to their diescretion and the bank accepts the responibility if the store doesn't properly validate the transaction, as the store is an acting agent for the bank.
Just as if the person could transfer money online without verification, THAT is the banks issue, THEY did not verify security. Most online purchases are protected the same way and covered as the store is again acting as an agent for the bank. The gains far outweigh the losses.
In THIS case security measures WERE in place and verified accordingly, the bank has accapted NO responsibility and has transferred money securely.
It is a different animal than credit card authorization.
by hal 9000
The merchant does and it is the seller who is always out of pocket not the Credit Card Agency!
Col ]:)
by dcperich
Blame will be determined by where the money falls...and which lawyer's pockets get the fullest.
I suppose banks will only allow transfers under specific conditions they have control over, with their own software, and large or frequent transfers will require verified collaboration from the owners of the accounts.
"Verified collaboration" could be innitiated with a fingerprint or retna scan associated with the account.
by hal 9000
The only real way to make sure that these transactions are for real is to halt them until the bank can make contact with the account owner to make sure that the transactions is wanted. Of course the several days that will be taken for each and every large transaction verification will probably mean that the contract is lost. But why would that matter as the money is safe right?
Col ]:)
by david_heath
...and the movies too!
NO-ONE does retina scanning in any commercial application. Whenever you see an eye-based biometric it is the iris being recorded.
And furthermore... ignore any imagery that suggests some kind of laser-pass over the eye. That NEVER happens. Irises are recorded using a simple camera in the near-infrared spectrum.
As for spoofing, yes the most important feature of biometric systems for high-security authentication is SUPERVISED use. If you can't see the person apply their biometric sample, assume it's bogus!
by oz_media
by seeker532
There was a story on the news that said banks won't install anti-hacking or any software unless they are forced to by the bottom line. They can write off any losses while the victims are left high and dry. As long as they don't steal too much the banks won't bother. The cost of protecting our money is more then the losses. Bottom line.
Why didn't the bank have anti-virus software to protect their system?
by oz_media
The bank wasn't hacked, the CUSTOMER was.
The bank can't be responsible for the customer's anti-virus.
PERHAPS, a bank could have a birus scan CHECK to ensure all clients have AV products installed and operating, but they STILL wouldn't be able to get people to UPDATE scanners. I would think the customer had some form of virus protection and it was out of date, or an expired OEM install.
They took a measure of sending online banking warning letters to their clients to remind them of new parasites that may jeopardize security.
Would you REALLY expect them to do more?
by hal 9000
What would you like the bank to perform a scan on every On Line Users Computer before they where even allowed into the transaction area?
Now I'm no great lover of banks in any form and view them as a necessary evil but in this case even I can not hold the bank responsible for this incident if it did actually happen and is not some form of scam to rip off the bank in question! The banks tell the users to secure their own systems and I've even received warning bulletins from banks that I do not deal with about security issues for their on line banking services. If this person was incapable of even reading their own e-mails I really don't feel the slightest bit sorry for them and even consider them as more of the offender than a victim.
Now if this person did actually have a Trojan that did this why is it the banks responsibility? But actually I'm thinking more along the lines of if this did actually occur what about everyone on their address book wouldn't they have got an infected e-mail from that workstation? Why is it just the money that is in question when all of the other data on the computer is equally at risk and if this is a genuine case is most likely stolen as well?
The money while important is chicken feed in comparison to the damage that should have been done to the business in question. And then there is the BIG ONE why only one case of this type has been reported if it was such a prevalent problem there must have been other cases and that makes me think that it is more a scam than anything else.
Col
I got one of those e-mails. I dissected it, e-mailed my bank for an address to send my findings, and never got a reply. I still have it sitting here.
True, the guy was lazy and certainly a person that takes things for granted. Hopefully he learned a lesson from this about keeping up with the going-ons in the cyber world. But the bank too, is at fault for having a complacent attitude. Why heck, it ain't their money they're losing! If it were the bank's, there would have been a lot of scammers in jail a looong time ago.
by moira
That's the gist of what I've been saying here .... yes, the guy was lazy and to a certain extent responsible for what happened, but the bank should also take responsibility.
And don't forget the actual villain - the biggest culprit of the lot!
(I wonder if he was ever caught?)
by hal 9000
It isn't the banks money that was lost in this case and that is exactly how it should be if you are unwilling to protect your own money why expect someone else to?
He effectively left his money out for anyone wanting to take a handful and walk off with it. The banks only offer to protect your money when it is in their keeping and constantly tall you how to go about making sure that your system has not been compromised.
But if this case does go to court and is not thrown out as Frivolous and Vexatious and he wins guess who will be paying for it? It certainly will not be the bank and every other bank will take their lead from this case so even if you are not directly connected with the bank in question you will be paying for this persons stupidity.
Do you still want to hold the bank responsible?
Col ]:)
by dr dij
Is a customer responsible for failing to
secure his computer system, or is the bank responsible for accepting
fraudulent ID, in the same way they would for cashing a check with a
fake driver's license?
Be sure to check out our exclusive online feature by a bank insider:
http://searchsecurity.techtarget.com/columnItem/0,294698,sid14_gci1062440,00.html?track=NL-358&ad=506214
==========
by dr dij
by hal 9000
As it is a waste of my time. I've paid my money and want my goods and I'm not really interested in the EULA or software licence I know basically what they say.
ONLY USE ON THIS MACHINE.
However in this case this is not a run of the mill normal customer he is running a business so at the very least he should be aware of the Laws so again at the very least he doesn't break any Laws as Ignorance of the Law is No Defense.
Just the same here he handles large sums of money through Internet Banking so he should at the very least be aware of some of the risks. I'm constantly bombarded with warning notices from banks about On line banking and even from ones that I do not use and I would never consider using On line Banking. Perhaps these so called warnings are an attempt to gain access to my on line banking details but they have no reply URL and do not ask for detailed information, they actually warn you not to do this.
Now a person who is running a business who claims that he has "Professionals" working there and is related to the Computer Industry doesn't know at the very least he should have an up to date AV product installed to me has a very loose term of Professional. Perhaps to him professional means that his staff never spill any ink when refilling ink cartridges.
His business Web Site is at best poorly laid out with numerous broken links again not very professional in my books and they are not broken links to different companies sites but to his own web pages.
Now the fact that this has not been reported on numerous occasions tends to make me think that there are one of two options
The first is that everyone else who indulges in On line Banking has adequate protection against this type of thing.
Or the second is that is is a bogus claim in an attempt to gain a financial reward at a different companies expense over here we call it FRAUD.
At best I would consider this as Frivolous and Vexatious Litigation which here in AU would make it extremely hard for him to approach the Courts again to seek compensation against a business who he claims has done him wrong. Any claim would have to be looked at by a Judge before it was allowed to proceed at least that way we minimize wasted time by the Courts and a constant money making stream to the Lawyers who are only too willing to take your money with promises that are impossible to ever meet.
Col ]:)
by jotom102000
by mshatswell
That's why we are technicians. End users are supposed to be clueless. We get payed to educate them, not critisize them. BofA has ways to authenticate users' credentials no trojan could duplicate, so if they were hacked by a virus they should pay up.
Michael Shatswell
Owner
Shatswell Systems
by moira
I would probably have to conclude after reading a lot about this that the guy has to accept responsibility because he didn't take all reasonable risks to prevent his PC becoming compromised.
However I don't think that can be taken to mean banks will always be absolved from responsibility. As someone pointed out, even the most l33t can pick up a trojan and the blame should ultimately be put on the person carrying out the exploit. Sadly they're not often traceable.
Ultimately, banks will have to pick up the tab for something like this, because (like car insurance) the individual can't afford to, so their costs will just be reclaimed in extra charges levied on all of us.
by hal 9000
Programs we are hearing just how unsafe Internet Banking actually is because while the banks systems may not be compromised the users computers could very well be compromised.
While it is a bit late and the latest Shock Horror story it at the very least will get those who see it and use On Line Banking to think about improving their security to some extent until the fear wears off and they all revert back to their good old ways. :D
Col ]:)
Sort by Trending