Discussion Locked

This guy should be stoned... (with rocks)

0 helpful
503 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

503 replies

by mikercol

You really believe that the Bank eats CC fraud?

Sorry taint so. We haven't had it happen in years, but i think they even kept their percentage.

In this case they don't have merchant to screw so it has to be the poor guy everyone wants to stone.

by pc

With so many viruses and Trojan horses attacking Microsoft
systems, and most users having very little time to keep up with
all the updates and current threats are hitting Microsoft daily, it
is impossible to keep most computers clean. I believe the bank
and Microsoft should be sued. Lets protect the user for a
change. Don?t you think it?s stupid that Microsoft has to keep
patching their software, almost weekly. As an example take a
look at MSN messenger recently found holes. This guy should
be praised not stoned. If anything stone Microsoft and the
bank.

I am a computer engineer and president of a computer company
and I am feed up with Microsoft. Think I will switch to a real
computer and switch 500 of my employer by years end.

by markinoregon

The folks commenting about people not having the time to become computer savvy enough to deal with these issues is an accurate argument. Simply put our society has become and will continue to become so complex no one can keep up with it. The paper version of this problem is the person who throws out personal information without shredding it first.

Step one we need a process that validates an identity and uses an encryption system that is hard to crack. This sytem needs to come with a willingness and commitment by the developers to continue to develop it as hackers get closer to cracking it. And systems have to be put in place initially that force users to upgrade these systems. (key fobs, electronic chips embedded in the body, retina scans, ???)

Step two all operating system installs must have systems installed in them to prevent this kind of thing from happening. And/or it must be shipped so someone can't put themselves into a vulnerable spot until they have installed software to secure their computers. With denial of service attacks and electronic terrorism this is more than an issue of individual security. Part of step two would be setting up tests of a persons system by outside sources to be sure the PC is secure. This should be the operating system manufacturer, the ISP, and the e-commerce site they are attempting to make a transaction at.

Step three the world needs to deal with financial fraud as harshly as it deals with violent crime. Identity theft can leave a person as capable of supporting him or herself as a crime victim who is left paralyzed. We need to deal with these kind of crimes just as harshly.

Step four nations that tolerate and support fraud operations need to be ostracized in the international community. With the most severe nations losing their sovereignty. (Yes I'm talking military action in cases where a nation refuses to do something about it and is known to be supporting fraud operations.) Steps prior to war could include disconnecting a nations communications lines.

by gdpine

While I don't disagree with all the posters who believe that a user has to take most of the responsibility, if not all of it, for not taking at least the minimum steps to protect himself, I would like to throw another factor into the discussion pot. I bank with Wells Fargo, and I do use their online banking service. However, I doubt that they are by any means unique in the following respect. I received a notice from them recently that I would need to upgrade my browser before a certain date, or they would no longer be able to guarantee that I would be able to use the service. I'm using the newest version of Firefox on Linux. They stated that I would need to upgrade to IE 5.X or 6.XX, Netscape 7.XX, Safari upgrade for Mac, or AOL online browser upgrade.

I don't want to just fuel the flames of the browser wars, but I think that it is not really very responsible of the bank to recommend the use of IE. I don't know about the others, except that the support of Netscape is probably going to ensure that my Firefox will continue to work. My point? I don't believe that the position of the bank is either very enlightened or very responsible in not supporting the more secure and continually more popular Firefox while continuing to recommend IE. Do I think that the bank should be held responsible if the bad guys use flaws in IE to get into someone's bank account? Perhaps under the circumstances I do.

by red_wolf9

From BoA's section titled "Your responsibilities"

*Protecting your Online ID and Passcode. You should always guard your Online ID and Passcode from unauthorized use. If you share this information with someone, all transactions they initiate with the information are considered as authorized by you, even for transactions you did not intend for them to make.

I'm thinking even a mildly competent lawyer could make the argument that you "shared" your information with the hacker. His lawyer better be able to argue that "sharing" was unintentional. And then BoA will counter with "and what did you do to prevent it?" Then it gets ugly for our business man.

by blueknight

A classic example of the ID10T error. First of all, it's not the bank's responsibility to inform its customers of every new virus/trojan etc that comes along. It's up to every user to install AND MAINTAIN anti-virus protection for their systems. It's a simple matter to subscribe to new virus notification, so he has no excuse there.

As I see it, he and the bank agreed by way of his electronic banking contract how that business would be conducted, and how the customer would identify his transactions. It is not the bank's fault... the transaction that siphoned money from his account "properly" identified the user and security code to carry out the transaction.

It is the user's responsibility to protect HIS system, just as it's the bank's responsibility to protect their systems and network.

For credit card transactions, the "user" is covered for unauthorized use except for the first $50. For debit cards, many banks don't provide any such coverage... at least that I know of.

In this instance, the bank should cover whatever it normally would cover (if anything) and the fool we're discussing should remain on the hook for the balance of his loss. If authorities can recover his loss, he'll be lucky. Otherwise it's a very expensive lesson for him.

by jennyn

I think the banks in the US are very slack about security. If this is a wakeup call to them - great.

They have an over dependence on unchanging nonprivate information such as Social Sec Number and mother's maiden name, and I have frequently been asked to provide ALL identifying security information, including passwords to bank staff when I phone in to do phone banking. There is no reason why that person can't walk out of their job that evening and phone in pretending to be me.

In the UK, where I am from, there are a few simple safeguards regularly used that help a great deal.

For an example of online banking take a look at this signin page from Citibank UK. It prevents keystroke loggers from aquiring information and uses this method for all sensitive input. Click in the password field and you'll see how they do it...

https://cukehb3.cd.citibank.co.uk/CappWebApp/capp/action/lang.do?languagecode=1&countrycode=gb&servicecode=signon&TS=1108410469600

For phone banking, I am never asked to give any human or nonhuman teller all information. Most information is collected by punching in numbers before being connected to the (human) teller, and MOST IMPORTANTLY even then I AM NEVER ASKED FOR MY WHOLE PASSCODE. The system will ask for (for example) the 2nd and 5th number of my code.

This way it is not ever punched in full across the phone line, or recieved in full by the computer. When tellers need to verify Passcodes their computer screen prompts them to ask the user for the Xth and Yth digit also, so they never hear the whole code.

Also no equivalent of public info like Social Security or Drivers License are EVER used for security purposes.

AN ANECDOTE:
when I first got to the US, I was in Wells Fargo Bank. The (over the counter) teller wanted all my identifying security information during some transaction I was making. That same day was called "Identity theft awareness day" and they were all wearning little badges about "don't let anyone steal your identity". I talked to the manager about the irony of all this - but he just couldn't get what my problem was.... "I-D-E-N-T-I-T-Y T-H-E-F-T A-W-A-R-E-N-E-S-S" I tried to explain.

by kaceyr

It uses a custom coding scheme for the keyboard and multiple cookies.

Not foolproof, but definately more difficult for a trojan/virus to figure out.

by gregry

I like it. That's the spirit, let's fix the problems. Good old limey know-how to the rescue. Um, wait a sec, isn't Citibank a U.S. bank? They're more careful in Britain than the U.S.? Why is that do you suppose???

by red_wolf9

Hope nobody comes and steals the money out from under your mattress. Do you honestly think :
A) BoA can't afford antivirus, and don't deploy them on their network (keep in mind US banking law).
B) BoA would go to all this trouble for a paltry 90k?

Your must be new to trolling.

by red_wolf9

Do you have any idea how many international banking transactions are made hourly. Our economy would crumble if each one was subject to government review. Use of the Patriot Act as an example is almost laughable.

I think the user should have his case publicized all over the world as a shinning example of computer ignorance and then have his case thrown out. If even one (L)user decided to install AV after reading that it would be a victory.

by red_wolf9

Being a Card carrying member of the Micro$oft Haters club myself I can agree with the car analogy. Unfortunately there are two greater issues:
A) Software makers have a sweetheart deal when it comes to EULA's, they current have the right to sell you totally worthless code and you can't do anything about it, their working is much prettier though.
B) People that don't follow even BASIC computer safety will continue to get exploited, it does not matter what OS they run. Stupid users on Unix/Linux/or even Apple are no different then stupid uses on Windows. It's sad but true.

by jtakiwi

Interesting thing about the now famous Mcdonalds hot coffe lawsuit that never made the popular press. McDonalds actually had multiple incidents relating to people spilling hot coffee on themselves (you ever had Mcd's coffee? It's like lava) Anyway, it was recommended to McD's that they LOWER the temp of their coffee because it is too hot and can cause burns. McD's uses such hot water to brew their coffee (I believe 180 vs 160 which is around the norm.) because they can use CHEAPER coffee and use the hotter water to extract more flavor from lower grade beans. The reason that lady got such a large fee was that there was a pattern of this type of injury, McD's knew about it and chose to continue as before. They actually lowered the original verdict as it was much higher than what was actually awarded as I recall.

by kaceyr

Sounds nutty but ...

The article stated that the transaction was "unauthorized" from the account holders perspective. All that means is that it was a transaction initiated without the account holders knowledge or consent. That makes it a "fraudulent" transaction.

From a data processing perspective, the proper credentials were presented, therefore it was a properly authorized transaction, even though the account holder didn't initiate it.

by kaceyr

That's why a trojan or virus like this one can be successful. Chances are that this guy is running Windows XP Pro, and he's *always* logged on with an account that has Administrator rights.

From an end-user perspective, really bad. From a virus/trojan perspective, PRIME TARGET!!

I always hate admitting it (being that I'm a Windows guy), but if I were doing large transactions (over $1000/transaction) on a regular basis as part of my business, at the very least I'd have a Linux transaction processor acting as an internal clearing house. That way I could set my own thresholds and I'd get flagged about a huge transaction before the bank ever sees it. And that baby would be locked down tight!

by tomsal

I'm well aware (and capable) of getting into systems with an IP, so I know what you mean.*

*disclaimer: Relax, I don't do illegal stuff, but if you want to be half decent at understanding your systems and how to secure them you better know a thing or two about how to break into them.

As for the 90k thing I'm 50/50 with you on that. While I lean on what you say that its small potatoes for a business transaction as a whole, but on the other hand they shouldn't go by other accounts as to what is big or small they should base patterns on this guys particular account history.

Don't get me wrong, I still think ignorance is no excuse.

by dr dij

You might have meant spyware progs too but till recently AV programs didn't touch the task of finding spyware.

by geekygirl63

I am an IT Manager for my full time job and a small computer services business owner all the other time. 99% of my clients are intelligent people but are simply baffled by computers and when you start talking about viruses, or especially ad and spyware, they look at you like you're speaking Greek. Couple that with companies who now send out new systems without anti-virus protection (it used to be a standard part of the package) and you have a recipe for disaster. Most of our time helping clients is spent eradicating viruses and ad/spyware and installing the necessary preventative measures. Even if you watch/read the news, and there's lots of news about these kinds of things, if you aren't "smart" about computers, you probably won't even notice the news item.

by techrepublic

Wrong. By definition computer users are generally ignorant (lack of knowledge) and many are very technically challenged. They struggle to survive in a technical world. It is IT's responsibility to assume the user is ignorant, technically challenged, intellectually challenged and perhaps a "fool". There are many ingeneous fools who can screw up a fool-proof system. But that is IT's job to plug ALL the holes.

We bitch and complain about security flaws in Microsoft software, usually because some hacker found it first and zapped us. Do we sue Microsoft? No. Do we stop using Windows? No. Do we plug the holes as quickly as possible? Yes.

If banks want to save money on staff and make their systems secure and trusted by the public, then it is up to IT to make it so. That is why we are paid the big bucks.

As with driving a car several million miles without an accident, you have to assume everyone else on the road is an incompetant idiot intent on committing suicide and taking you with them.

Financial institutions have to be certain their systems are incredibly secure and cover the losses through electronic fraud. Else, the bad publicity will undo the millions of dollars in advertising trying to get people to trust electronic online transactions. It is part of the cost of doing business.

Many on-line services (Yahoo Mail etc.) run very good anti-virus scanners to prevent mail from their system infecting the customer's system, assuming the customer has no current AV protection. At least the ISP will not be the source of the problem.

Trojans can slip in when your kid is playing an online game and is offered a new facility but they have to download this "Chinese character set". Hackers are much more knowledgable than the average computer user. IT professionals are suppose to be able to kepp up with, or ahead, of them.

Suck it up. IT screwed up. The customer may not always be right, but if you are lucky and treat them right, the customer will always be your customer and bring new cutomers, not take others away.

"Let he who is without sin cast the first stone." IT screwed up with an insecure system. More locks on the door are needed, along with bars on the windows, chimney and sewer.

by kaceyr

The banks IT didn't screw up, the guys own company IT screwed up.

Suck it up. HIS IT screwed up. The bank is already helping him get back the money that they can secure, but neither the FBI nor BofA can force the Latvia bank to do anything more than they've already done. He's out the 20K that already got withdrawn.

I'd like to see the Latvia bank initiate an investigation to nail the perp, but we'll probably never hear about any such thing.

by markinoregon

That's where one of the system changes I proposed in an earlier post need to come in. If the Latvian bank is regularly used by theives to steal money and the bank refuses to cooperate it needs to be disconnected from the international banking community. If it's government equally refuses to cooperate it needs to be disconnected from the international community.

In this modern world of huge corporations isolating essential parts of the fraud mechanism will be very effective. Keep in mind many corporations in the world now have economies larger than Latvia's. Many corporations rival major nations in power and finances. The business world was the driving force behind unifying the calendar for most of the world. That same need to do business can be a BIG stick in dealing with the fraud problem.

by mrafrohead

I used to live in Tumwater (scumwater)... ;p

What do you think of all of the state buildings that they put up??? ;p

by techrepublic

Nobody knows all the details of this case in short narrative supplied. However, this sort of action usually ends in a settlement to save bad publicity and lawyer fees. Trial is always a crap shoot.

by mrafrohead

@techrepulic
"IT screwed up"

NO WAY, IT didn't screw up, that lamer did.

Look at his site, he's a seasoned computer veteran. He apparently knows what he's doing, therefore there's no excuse.

Also, I NEVER assume those I"m helping are "ignorant, technically challenged, intellectually challenged and perhaps a "fool"". I just help them and go from there. I judge according to what I see. We all know what happens when you assume.

I love to teach people that want to learn. Those that don't I don't waste my time on.

The only fool's are those who don't protect themselves, and considering all of the press and notices EVERYWHERE about a/v and f/w, there's just no excuse for this to have happened. NONE!

by jerrythompson

On the one hand, we have freedom of choice! On the other hand, we have knowledgeable people! I try everyday to educate people about computers and the Internet! Ever hear of buyer beware, Ever hear never assume, Ever hear Someone else is responsible?
The average consumer out there is Really Vurenable, taken advantage of, and lead to believe it is safe to do whatever they want to do! Until we Hold M$ responsible for the security holes, until we hold the hackers responsible for the damage they cause, until we stop using anti-virus for the solution to these problems, it is just a big circle of money and profits, damage, and repurchase, suit after suit, Corp buying corp, and this pore guy just trying to do his banking on line. We decide to be victims when we make uninformed choices! Send the boy back to school!

by swips88

While we still really don't know how the breach of his account occurred It looks like the bank is somewhat off the hook as far as their system not being compromised and giving out his password.

It seems that his password etc was in the hands of the criminal through Lopez's own computer security breach, not the Bank's.

The Bank IMO is at fault as far as them providing a system to users that is promoted as being secure. If they would have a disclaimer on their main page (in big bold letters - not buried in a typical computer style ELA) that you should not use this online banking if you are concerned about your funds disappearing to some crook in Latvia! Only use this system if you are absolutely sure you understand how to protect yourself and your computer against all possible Viruses, Trojans, Worms and guys/gals/kids looking over your shoulder attacks!

How many online banking customers would they get with that disclaimer present! They are promoting a service to get additional customers (and decrease their transaction costs)without being forthcoming about the risks to their own customers!

In other words they are providing a service which most users assume is a safe process. Just like when we buy a car we assume it will not go in reverse when we put it in forward! Would you buy a car otherwise?

Without a very liberal judge in this case or deep pockets on the part of Mr Lopez I am afraid he will lose when the bank proves the breach was on his end. - Just like the example of someone looking over your shoulder when he was typing his password. How can the bank possibly be at fault when someone gets his information like that! Unless of course he was standing in line at the Bank's branch not in his own private office or bedroom when he was compromised.

IMO his only true recourse is to add MS to Bank of America as a defendent as supplying an operating which allows this to happen. He will need even deeper pockets then.

MS sells an operating system with browser software which allows you to do online banking. If the system is vulnerable to this type of attack it just plain needs to be fixed. Not ask a user to buy additional anti-virus software to make it more secure! Or hire an IT staff to maintain desktops for a 1 or 2 man business. Still not proven if any anti virus program would have prevented this in the first place.

If the software needs improvements to make this secure then add it and charge for it in the purchase of the Operating system. Don't produce something that is vulnerable and expect users to be savy enough to know when they are infected or how to avoid being infected - because it just is not going to happen.

If MS will not improve the vulnerabilities of its system then it needs to also have a large disclaimer on every Browser screen when it accesses a https page that your computer may not be secure even if this site is secure - do not submit any critical data that could be used to rob you since we (MS) are not liable if you do!

Users use online banking because they assume it is secure. They also submit CC data online because they assume it is secure -going to a https page is suppossed to be secure, right - why would MS provide that in their browser if it wasn't?

Many users do not lose out when a CC # is stolen since as another poster pointed out the MERCHANT gets stuck with the bill! They shipped a product without having been absolutely sure it was a valid CC. The bank never loses!

With Banking there is a different type of transaction going on. You are authorizing a transfer to another bank. So you as the one authorizing the transaction are responsible. You are in effect the Merchant here. If it is not you doing it then too bad, your money is gone just like the Merchant processing a bad CC. If you want your money back you must file a lawsuit just like the Merchant!

by markinoregon

Yes Microsoft needs to help customers with security of the systems and do it in a way that allows knowledgeable users some choices in what method they use to secure their machines. My family computer has been a perennial problem to keep running because of spyware. Norton Anti-virus and Spy-bot helped but didn't fully resolve the issue. Norton would list things that it couldn't remove. The latest item is a spyware removal tool from Microsoft and it removes everything Norton could not. So Microsoft is working on the issue, a little late, but help is comming on their end.

The same is true for other OS manufacturers and distributors as well. This is especially true when I hear people talk about getting Linux or a Mac because those OSs 'don't have viruses'. Every time I hear that I want to run off screaming. Just like the builders and promoters for the Titanic they will meet their iceburg.

Hardening the systems (OSs) is step one in a process to eliminate this kind of problem. Step two is putting pressure or offering incentives to banks, other financial organizations and in some cases ISPs to help secure these systems from prying eyes. Step three is to take legal and diplomatic actions to shut down the perpetrators. Each step is harder to accomplish but the beauty is if step one is successful the other steps are icing on the cake.

by dr dij

What the first guy who mentioned the keys in car failed to mention is that if the insurance company finds out you left your keys in car and got stolen, many times (or possibly always if they find out) they will NOT PAY as you shirked your responsibility to keep your property safe.

by mrafrohead

Well just so you know.

If he hadn't sued the bank, I would have NEVER posted this thread.

I think that since he crossed that line, he has earned the harsh remarks.

There is nothing wrong with not knowing something.

But, if you research their website of AHLO.net, you'll see in there that the employees of that site are all seasoned veterans of the computer industry.

If that is really true, then they should have known what AV was and what a FW is.

This should have NEVER happened. But it did. He should have graciously admitted fault and tried to collect his funds from those responsible.

Not by suing his bank.

How cowardly that fool is. Hiding behind a lawyer instead of putting up his hands and going after the REAL thief!

Mrafrohead

by pmwpaul

Whatever happened to Responsibility? Can't people take responsibility for their actions, even if they're mistakes?

OH, WAIT!!! The lawyers work on commission! They get 1/3 of whatever the bank is forced to pay.

I get it. The lawyers convinced this idiot that it wasn't his fault. If it's not his fault, it must be the bank's fault.

So... sue the bank for money and legal expenses and EMOTIONAL TRAUMA. And this schmuck will come out of it with all his money and more, his lawyers will be very happy and BoA will increase fees for something to cover this.

The BoA customers and stock holders should engage in a class action suite against this bozo for taking their money.

It's going to make my BoA credit card interest go up, that's for sure.

by mrafrohead

It has too.

Otherwise, we're all f***ed... If you know what i mean.

Then every poor home user that has been infected will jump on the bandwagon.

And all of the sorry Sys-Admins out there that allowed themselves to get infected will jump on it too. Someone else to point the finger at instead of themselves.

I am confident that any judge in their right mind will throw this clown's case out of court and move on. Hopefully even charge him with some petty crime for wasting the courts time...

With the mockery of our legal system that has been made, when is enough enough???

by elcamin0

That seems to be the mentality of the "non-victims" An air of superiority and immunity comes across from those who are ever so quick to accuse of lack of computer security maintenance. Each of you are subject to the intro of a Trojan, it all depends on update timing and scanning and a bit of luck. The so called "skilled" will have a hard time admitting that one!

by dr dij

I'm never going to get one from scanning on my broadband as I have a cable router between PCs and net. I could get one surfing. I had to leave on activex (but with prompting) as too many things not run without. So I'm pretty unlikely to get one surfing, and if I was going to go online to bank, I'd probably run free online scan (e.g. ca.com ) first. Except for IM which I don't use and freeware (with adware built in) there's not much left as souce to infect me. I run scans periodically in case some site uses loopholes in browser to install without my knowledge. Could I have a trojan still? yes. My point tho is it's pretty unlikely and unlike the fellow in the article I do something to prevent it so I feel pretty confident for online banking.
I also check my transactions to be sure they are ones I did. Problems would be more likely to come from someone stealing my CC# at a restaurant or store.

by boardswapper

That's why I dont read these things much. There is alway a load of the smartest men(or women)in the world full of arrogant remarks because this happens to be their area of expertise. It says alot about what kind of people they are and how much their opinion really matters.

by go_browns_01

But when one of these "non-victims" loses their bank card, has their wallet stolen or lost, has their trash picked through and gets ripped off royally, well, we'll have a hearty laugh, no?

'Cause it will happen, and I'm already laughing.

by hal 9000

But kick him for being stupid with others money and data!

Remember it was a company involved here and what others do not want to even consider is the fact that just one instance has been reported and what about his customer lists, address book and any other sensitive company data that might be on that computer?

Col ]:)

by timm

BoA don't have the money, why should they be punished? They're trying to provide online banking which people seem to want. They should be making every effort to keep the service safe, and possibly they are. I understand they send warnings about the dangers of online banking quite regularly, and probably have a lot of safeguards in place. As a bank I'd expect my customers to be making every effort to keep their money secure also. Although it's hard to plan for every contingency, it's not that hard to run antivirus and firewall software on your home PC.

There's been a bit of Microsoft bashing through the threads, and although I like to point out MS shortcomings as much as anybody, I don't agree that this can be their fault. The online banking is platform independent (in that you could access it from a browser in Linux if you wanted) so in theory the actual criminal could have accessed the victim's account using Linux. Surely Linux should have foreseen this event and done something to prevent it? (yes, I am being facetious, but it's just as logical as the MS bashing arguments).

Regardless of your operating system there are available antivirus and firewall solutions (often free) that would stop this sort of thing. If someone has 90k available to be transferred from their bank account, why can't they afford to give it proper protection, even if they have to pay a third party to implement it. And quite honestly, I think the security features in XP service pack 2 are quite good for something virtually free (except for your original purchase of WinXP and the download of patches).

If this guy was a business, he'd have corporate responsibility to protect assets, including information systems / assets.

Still, the real culprits here are the people who got the money, not the bank and not Microsoft. The guy himself is pursuing recompense from the wrong party. However, being that it's in the United States (the new oxymoron), I'm not predicting he won't win :)

by mrafrohead

It really isn't MicroCraps fault that we buy buggy software. It's our own.

If I were BillyGoat Gates and Paully Allen I would be laughing all the way to the bank...

Seriously, if "WE" really had a problem with MicroSoft, we would switch software. It's all within our control, if we so choose to take it.

Myself, I'm STILL, yes still attempting to learn Linux. SLOWLY but surely...

Sadly I've been working on it for so long that I don't even know why I continue trying. I try a few hours every few months, and sadly that's about all, BUT one day, I'll be a real boy, and I'll understand what it is that I"m trying to do and it will all work... ;p

by donaldjj

not BofA's problem. Though they might have checked to see if he really did do the transfer. I can see a new system where you need to submit your fingerprint online with those fingerprint readers that you can now get for $150 or so.

by mrafrohead

I'm going to break down your post and answer your statements with my thoughts... Ready?? Here we go:

"Ok, lets extend his logic just a bit to include more than just the less than supertech newbies who "get themselves infected"."

This guy wasn't a newbie. Read about him a little bit. According to his website he's been in the computer world for a while. He should have known better.

"Why not then include in his vigilanty rantings every late night customer who finds themselves the victim of a mugging in a dimly lit parking lot of a high crime area. Hey, they should have known better and we hope the video store sues them for the bad press it generated because, Hey it couldn't be the mugger's fault or the cheapskate video store chain that decided not to install better lights."

I don't know about you, but I don't temp fate. If I'm going to go to the video store and it's in a bad part of town and poorly lit, I will drive on until I find a place I'm comfortable in. In that instance, yes, it would be unfortunate, but the person asked for it, by not practising common sense.

"Let's boo the victim of a drunk driving incident for suing the nightclub that served an obviously intoxicated patron because the victim should have known the local college won the basketball tournament that night and therefore everyone on the highway should be viewed as a potential drunk."

If someone gets drunk and kills someone else, it is the person who was drunks fault. Not the person who served them the liquor. That is absolute serious BS and you should be ashamed of yourself for even bringing some crap like that up. Think of it like this, you're responsible for your own actions. If you are going to sue someone for not babysitting you, you have A LOT of growing up to do, and you should be ashamed of yourselves. If you really want to point fingers, point them at the parents who raised the irresponsible shit and sue them instead of the bar.

Your example reeks of the same BS from the anti-gun camp. Guns don't kill people, people do. Bartenders don't kill people, stupid ass drunk drivers do!

"If banks, who have made billions (that's Billions with a B) of dollars from charging every sort of bogus service fee imaginable can't spend a bit of that cash on better security methods, even if it means starting from scratch to build a safer system in this Identify Theft world, then maybe it's just easier to blame the "stupid" customers. That surely requires less thought and effort on their parts, right Mrafrohead?"

Actually, I would use a credit union, as I don't believe in banks. But that's just because I try to be smart about the little bit of money I don't have.

And now a ? to you Ross... Are you a sue happy cry baby too???

Mrafrohead

by kaceyr

I agree completely!

BTW: Are you aware that your credit union is also a/many Merchant accounts at a/several bank(s)? Most people aren't aware of this. Being that it's a merchant account, they don't have the same restrictions that a personal or standard business account has, which allows them to conduct banking business (without the nonsense) within federal regulations (which really aren't bad regulations, the banks just want you to THINK there's a s***load of nasty federal regulations).

by timm

It must be the media's fault for not reporting often enough about computer security issues then.
I sure hope this becomes a class action!

by tomsal

My point *is* that many folks don't have knowledge one about computer, the Internet, etc.

And that is why I think its not asking too much or far fetched at all to say that if you don't know something and you are dealing with your own financial transactions (that pay bills, feed you and your family, etc.) it's as obvious as daylight to me anyway that you'd ask questions.

If nothing else but simply "How do I know its safe?".

Call this part of my post cruel or whatever -- but if you are too ignorant or too stupid to be responsible enough to ask things about something you don't know BEFORE you send your presumably hard earned money over the wire...then in the nicest of terms you shouldn't even think about Internet banking (or using a computer), in more blunt terms -- then that person is an idiot.

Someone used an analogy before so let me take a shot at an analogy....

You wouldn't leave your check book out in the open in a crowded restaurant would you? How about just leaving your wallet out with the cash visible?

Well if someone is thinking "No way, of course not! That makes it easy to steal!" to those analogies then why would you just blindly log into your bank and do a transfer with no clue on if your system is secured in any fashion?

Again, this all comes back to IGNORANCE IS NO EXCUSE.

by admin

Firstly, i personally hope that the bank is entirely blameless and receives a clean bill of health post court proceedings. This is definitely the desired outcome, however, this idiot should not have been given internet access to his financial institution without him taking appropriate safeguards and precautions that should have been enforced as part of the bank's terms and conditions of use.
The real scary bit for me, is that:

a. Either the bank didn't have those common sense requirements as part of their terms and conditions, or

b. If they did, they (the bank) didn't have an effective enforcement policy.

My point is that virus infection at ANY level of network access, must put the entire network at risk. Maybe it's time for banks to get serious about network security, right down to the end-user level. This can only benefit us all.

by hgordon

Without knowing all the facts, I can't say whether the bank deserves to be sued or not. What I can say is that for most of us, failing to protect our PC is NOT a matter of laziness. To paraphrase what I believe Harry Truman said about economists (Line them all up and they still can't reach a conclusion) all the world's computer experts can't provide straight forward advice for protecting a PC.
So the hackers and scum of the world have destroyed the internet, e-mail and computer usage and decent people despite mammoth investments of time and money are at their mercy. And computer experts, despite best of intentions, are a Tower of Babel of indeciperable and useful advice. At least now I understand the meaning of the story of Humpty-Dumpty.

by munezrhep

This is what immature people do when they get hurt and start blaming others for their own actions. Let's say he really was infected with a Trojan. And that he was aware of Trojans and how they spread. Then now he blamed his bank for the loss. Childish.

by mrafrohead

According to this schmucks website, he's been working with pc's for a long time... ;p

I would think that it isn't the stores responsibility to warn users of the internet, but more the isp... Who says someone who buys a computer will get online?

But the ISP is giving them the access... I know all of the isp's I've EVER had (for many many moons) have ALL sent out notices of what to watch for and all that jazz...

Dude was just negligent.

by mrafrohead

Is ONLY as secure as the person securing it.

You can take your nice and secure *nix and bork it by making your su or your root a blank password...

Now, it doens't matter how good your OS is, as you just screwed yourself...

Thank you, come again...

Mrafrohead

by 6f9g3x802

I'm no lawyer but here is a copy of the EFTA. It does say "ATM card, debit card or other device (not including credit cards) used in handling an electronic deposit, payment or withdrawal".Note it says other device. So wouldn't this law apply to online activity?

The Electronic Fund Transfer Act (EFTA) limits your liability for the unauthorized use of your ATM card, debit card or other device (not including credit cards) used in handling an electronic deposit, payment or withdrawal. If your ATM or debit card is lost or stolen, your liability under the EFTA is limited to $50 if you notify your financial institution within two business days of discovering the loss or theft. If you wait more than two business days to report a lost or stolen card but you notify the card issuer about an unauthorized transaction within 60 days of the date the bank mails the statement containing the error, you could lose as much as $500. If you wait longer than that, you may be liable for $500 plus the amount of any unauthorized transactions after the 60-day period. However, to promote the worry-free use of debit cards and ATMs, many financial institutions are voluntarily treating the fraudulent use of those cards as if they were credit cards?that is, a maximum liability of $50 per card, and sometimes less.

Note: No federal law limits your losses from check fraud, but you do have protections under state law. For example, most state laws hold the bank responsible for losses from a forged check, but they also require the bank customer to take reasonable care of his or her account, including monitoring account statements and promptly reporting an unauthorized transaction to avoid being liable for losses.

by mrafrohead

Here's the problem though, he is blaming BoA for something that they had NO control over. UNLESS THE BANK ITSELF INFECTED HIM.

If someone stole his checkbook, he would have had to report that the checkbook was stolen.

If he lost his checkbook, then it would be an unfortunate series of events, though if someone did cash a 90K dollar check before he reported it lost, he actually could be held accountable for the lost funds and not reimbursed.

This is virtually what happened to him here...

He lost his money.

He's a seasoned computer vet, he shoulda known better.

Case closed.

I would LOVE to be the attorney for BoA on this one, I would make that guy feel about as small as his nuts probably are.

by mrafrohead

And the guy that plays him does it so well.. ;p

IMO the only real important posts to read are regarding AHLO - read them and go to the links provided... And make sure you browse AHLO's site.

I think after you read that much, you'll agree with Nick Burns...

by dunkleosteus

What if the situation were different? Say, the businessman doesn't lock the doors to his business, and a crook sneaks in and installs a wiretap on the phone. Then the crook listens in on the businessman while he made wire transfers, then uses this information to impersonate him and make fraudulent wire transfers. Is the bank liable?

Or perhaps to make the the analogy more apt, the businessman locks his doors with locks widely known in the business to be easily picked, yet he fails to back up the locks with deadbolts. Who is at fault?

I think the case is going to hinge on whether the bank billed its services as highly secure, without warning that the consumer end of the transaction must remain secure or else the entire system will be compromised.

by swips88

If again the bank had no failure in their systems of security and these systems are generally accepted as secure in the industry then it is up to Mr Lopez to find the thief and recoup his losses on his own, since the thief walked in to his physical establishment to steal his data.

The difference in the original case is the plaintiff is using a generaly accepted system supplied by the bank to access his account. He is not aware that his data is at risk by using this system that the bank is supporting for its customers. He has no way of knowing if his own system is compromised just by accessing his BAnk Account via the Internet. That is the only way he can be successfull in suing the bank or MS.

Unless the court decides that Internet Banking is inherrantly unsecure the way it is being currently conducted. Then the bank is liable even if someone breaks into Mr Lopez's business to steal his account data and perform an online transfer unbeknownst to Mr Lopez.

Personaly I prefer to walk into my own bank and perform the wire transfer face to face with an Account mgr whom I recognize and who recognizes me!

The Banks are pressuring us to use online Transfers, by way of extra fees on walk in transfers, also to (of course) cut their own costs! We have to call our local branch whenever we see a fee related to this "personal" wire transfer and get the fee removed as a courtesy! So the banks are pressuring us into this "unsafe" online system whether we like it or not and whether they admit to how unsafe it can be or not!

by tonythetiger

If I were the man's lawyer, I would argue that the same rules should apply to fraudulent bank transactions that apply to fraudulent credit card transactions, and that the man's liability be limited to $50.

by mr. tinker

There is a point of no return. This type of user would probably be better off with WebTV. Now more than ever before Just about 99% of the public KNOWS what Anti-Virus is about and used for. There's little room for excuses.
"Here's your sign..."

by wti

?
Pointy Headed Geeks Miss the Larger Picture
===========================================

The vast majority of banks and other online financial institutions already have blanket clauses, in their online banking/transactions agreements, indemnifying said institutions for damages to online customers caused by hacking/malware.

This should tell every safe and sane person just how inherently "unsafe" online banking/finances is for consumers.

The institutions *know this up-front* and expect/deamnd that each consumer sign away her/his rights, so that they, too, may jump in with the other Lemmings.

There should be a long list of red-flag violations that should automatically hold a bank/finaicial instituion liable for loss and damages to consumer customers, as caused by "hacking/malware:"

?- use of broken encryption, like SSL2
(conversely, turn off SSL2 and then find out how many bamking/financial sites won't allow you to connect via TLS1.0/SSL3 or better...)

?- failure to provide and enforce two-factor authentications

?- failure to rigorously adhere to digitally encrypted and signed communications to/from online customers

?- failure to perform a remote host security scan, prior to permitting customer account access across/within networks

?- failure to enforce remote host quarantine (including pro-active notification of host compromise to customers) when a remote host fails said pre-access security scan

?- use (in USA) of a SSI number as any kind of password and/or authenticator

?- improperly implemented hierarchies of digitial certificates/authorities

?- failure to log and audit all *internal* accesses of customer data (insider abuse is not a new thing in banking or finance)

My complete list automatic liability triggers is much longer, but this short list includes some of the most ubiquitious acts of negligence that I have observed, first-hand.

??...

The vast majority of anti-virus/adware/spyware tools are definitions-based and, therefore, inherently reactive.

Some systems are almost always compromised *before* a new definition set is coded up and distributed to the rest of the subscribing community of Sacrificial Lambs.

This reduces the effectiveness of anti-virus/adware/spyware to the level of being a necessary and woefully insufficient evil.

Personal firewalls are also necessary and woefully insufficient evils.

??...

There also needs to be concurrent, pro-active hardening of client OSes and network aware applications/subsystems.

This includes the category of tools that includes QwikFixPro, SurfinGuardPro, PrevX, etc.

??...

Even these layers/levels of protection leave too many openings for remote compromise, but they effectivey defend, in-combination, against most
low-hanging attacks.

How many banks/financial institutions formally require that all of these layers/levels of protection are implemented by their online customers???...

How many banks/financial institutions provide their online customers with an integrated suite of said protections and technical support, in order to pro-actively safeguard online banking/
fianances???...

??...

I think it is abundantly clear that most banks/fianancial instituions should be held liable, everytime they are negligent and I believe these real-world deficiencies amount to negligence.

Negligently implemented online banking and finances creates an attractive nuisance and invites exploitation and abuse.

And, ultimately, all customers/consumers, whether we opt online or not, are made to foot the bill for all of this negligence.

by hal1976

Don't now if anyone bothered to check; the Coreflood is more than a month old, detected by AV and deleted. A basis AV setup and update subscription would have sufficed.

As a business owner doing the kind of business he was doing as evidenced by his bank balance, he could have purchased a setup from any average reseller and gotten an AV already installed.

by ewriggs9

all the facts about the McDonald's coffee case. You might want to check it out. It was a "good" case, and McD should have been dinged a heck of a lot more than they were. See:

http://www.lectlaw.com/files/cur78.htm

About this case, however, I generally believe in "caveat emptor" - and the guy who lost out on his banking needs his head (and computer) examined! A lot of people are just clueless - maybe this will wake up a lot of people. Wonder if it was really the Trojan or if he got hacked some other way?

by ewriggs9

You don't have to "sign" a signature card to set up PayPal to access your bank account. I don't remember at this point if the original post told us whether the transfer was 90K or a series of smaller transfers that totaled 90K. But I can send all kinds of money via PayPal to various places without any questions either from paypal or my Bank. I suspect the electronic transfers are the same. ISTM that all aspects of electronic bank transfers need to be reviewed and revamped - big time!

by ewriggs9

your tablesaw with a radial arm saw. Still has a big dangerous spinning disk, but it goes where you put it - there's even a blind female woodworker who uses a RAS! I'm not blind, but I'm female and I use a RAS for cutting up my lathe blanks.
Same analogy, though with the OS - use a "safer" OS and your risk goes donw, but NO OS is truly "safe."

by afoshee

In this day-and-age of $12-million for a spilled cup of hot coffee, headlines blaring warnings of every kind about computers, when (if ever) will our society start making individuals take responsibility for their own actions?

Of course your analogy with the car IS very apt. Unfortunately I know more folks who take very poor care of their cars than those who take GOOD care of them - and we spend a LOT more money buying a car than we do on computers!

Otherwise intelligent folk are just as susceptible as idiots to the "it only happens to other people" mentality. The problem is that so few are willing to accept responsibility when something bad happens.

Oh well, job security...

by tomsal

This is a large thread so I didn't read each post separately, but yours is the first to spell it out.

I online bank and what the "anti-BOA" supporters in this thread are forgetting when you sign on to use Internet Banking there is "Terms of Use" kind of agreement and it defines what the risks/responsibilities are. Further more you HAVE to accept the terms to create your account. Now I'm going to point out I'm doing something bad -- that is I'm ASSUMING BOA has a brain to follow the majority of the banking industry. I've never been a BoA customer. However at two different banks I had online banking and BOTH had such an agreement that needed to be accepted before my account was created.

Soooo...let's look at this ...

1) The guy is lazy and/or doesn't have clueone about the dangers of the "cyberworld" so to speak so does he seek advice (at best from a computer consultant or the bank itself, at worse in today's day and age you are hard pressed to find someone who doesn't know at least one person who is "into computers" as they say).

2) With etremely high probability BoA has an agreement that must be read/accepted when new customers sign on for Internet banking transactions.

3) The BoA is aware of the patterns of the particular account in question, thus less chance they view the 90k transfer as "out of character" for that particular account.

4) BoA uses SSL to secure the connection of the transfer, they secure their own on-site systems/server infrastructer. They have IT personnel monitor their systems, perform maintenance, configure firewall policies, virus scanning, spyware scanning, etc.

BUT....because our American society has formed into a bunch of whiney, sue-happy, blame everyone else, ignorance is my excuse complainers....nothing matters...the guy is innocent, the big bad corporate institution (BoA) is at fault.

umm..yeah...OK

by careyuselman

BoA really pushes their on-line banking.
The rep even points out how secure it is and
"even has the little s after http, that's
secure". So the point is How computer (il)literate
do you need to be to have an on-line bank account.
There are plenty of folks that only e-mail and
know nothing of software. Should BoA be required to post some minimum computer standard for users of on-line bank accounts? Why should they expect someone to be a computer major to use a service that basically is to their best interest?
Just a Thought and join U.P.

by chameleon186

I ask the same a transfer of 90K seems like a awful large amount their should have been limits unless authorized with local banker. An if their was a limit and mulitple transaction occured the bank should have had something in place delaying transactions past a certain amount in a given day untill a human verification could take place. Something just doesn't seem to add up with this story.................

by buschman_007

I'm wondering why BoA would allow such a large amount to flow into a bank where they had no ability to get it back? I since some policy change in the way BoA does their transfers. I mean if that amount of money was sent somewhere in the US or to a state/country where the US citizen had legal recourse, then I would say the bank can grant those transfers with a little more confidense.

But to send such a large amount to an area where it is basically unretreivable, seems unwise.

Mike

by danag429

A computer is not a toaster, it's more llike a car. I have been ranting on this to anyone who will listen, but the hypnotized sheep just look at the commercials and think they can get a machine that requires no attention.

This is exactly my argument, you don't have to know how an internal combustion engine works to know you need to change the oil, you don't have to know physics to know you need to check your tire pressure.

I think this clown should be put in jail for wasting the public's time and money. Yes, he got ripped off, but it was his own stupidity that let it happen.

The problem today is nobody wants to take responsability for anything, it's always someone else's fault. Well, I have to say that if you screw up you've nobody but yourself to blame.

by chameleon186

Their are many stupid people and many desperate people. I say something is strange with this story. Doesn't add up and still ask why the bank doesn;t have simple policies to protect stupid fraud. again limits & authorization

by chameleon186

Their are many stupid people and many desperate people. I say something is strange with this story. Doesn't add up and still ask why the bank doesn;t have simple policies to protect stupid fraud. again limits & authorization

by buschman_007

You might want to reread the story. I think what they are saying is the trojan is on the plantiff's computer, not the banks computer. Obviously it would be the banks fault if the trojan was on their system. But that's not the case here. We are talking about an infected user.

By your same logic, do you really think the pres of BoA is gonna cover this loss out of his own pocket? No, this will go through insurance and in the end, we the tax payers will pay for the plantiff's ignorance. I for one am not in favor of that.

He should have been aware since he worked with computers for a living. Even if he lacked the know how he should have seeked the aid of someone more expereinced in security and Virus protection.

Mike

by buschman_007

I reread the article and it doesn't actually say his computer had no Anti-Virus or Anti-Spam software. We are assuming he was ignorant. But what if he had installed these things. What if this variant of coreflood was just newer than his defs?

Who is liable then?

We all realize he is going after BoA because he cannot go after the criminal who actually took the money. I don't feel BoA is liable, just cause they are accessable.

Mike

by buschman_007

We don't know if he did or did not have anti-virus. But we can clearly see this seasoned business owner didn't have any insurance.

You know after I thought about this guys business for a second I became far less sympathetic to his situation. Out of the 1000 or so toner companies I have been contacted by in the past year, I'd say maybe 10 were legitimate companies that were selling good product. The rest were slick ass used car salesmen.

The ink toner cartridge market is overflowing with seedy individuals. I'm guessing honor amongst theives does not apply between hackers and conmen. :P

Mike

by david_heath

I recently wrote an article that addresses pretty-much exactly the issues that lead to this guy's problems.

Maybe it is his fault for not bothering to understand how his tools work, maybe it's the bank's fault for just being a bank (hey, they have lots of money, it MUST be their fault!).

Anyway, I've written some simple guidelines aimed at home users and the technically-aware people who help them out.

You can find the article here...

http://www.smh.com.au/news/Soapbox/Safe-surf/2005/02/09/1107890264552.html

by hal 9000

It was all over the news and I got no end of grief for allowing our systems to become infected from the Head of the Data Processing section.

Of course it didn't matter a DAM that we had not been infected but it was on the news so we must have been taken down. :D

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

I hand out one to every potential customer as well and guess what they never get read!

I also tell any customer what is required to maintain security on their systems when I install them and they act surprised when they realize that they have to do things to the computer and it doesn't make them their first coffee for the day.

I only do business accounts and as yet have not had one of my system hacked the operative word here though is "YET!"

But customers just do not read what they are given and worse still click on those pop ups without thinking. A very good recent case was with a new company that I had just started doing business with I told them not to install SP2 for Windows XP and explained not only why but what would happen. Two days latter I got a call out because the Office Manager had clicked on yes install SP2. Of course someone had turned on the Auto Update and added the check before installing. But did she even read the information that she was being asked about no and because it was the end of the 3rd month she had to have in her tax for that quarter that day. Just the thing you need to hear at 3.15 PM on a Friday Afternoon and the customer is 50 KMS away.

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

Goes out gets totally tanked drops her knickers lays back across a table and invites all comers while opening her legs is that RAPE?

What I find offensive in this entire thread is

1 One one reported case of fraud form this supposed infection.

2 No one is the slightest bit concerned about other data on the so called infected computer.

3 No one has even thought about either his clients or suppliers who would be hit as well because he didn't take even the most basic steps to attempt to secure his system.

4 It is assumed that it was the Trojan that was responsible for the fraud but I've yet to hear of only a single case of data stealing from any form of malicious code that was spread over the Internet. It is accepted that a new viri released into the wild will have world wide coverage within a few hours so why just this one case?

5 The majority of the funds are still available to him but he doesn't want to go through the hassle of recovering them.

6 He screwed up and wants to pass the buck onto a corporation who is big and can afford to pay for his foolishness.

7 He setup the ability to transfer funds of amounts like this without requiring authentication before being processed He asked for this it wasn't offered to him. He got exactly what he wanted! :(

Col ]:)

by jpersons

The guy got what he deserved for being stuoid - like they say ignorance of the law does not make an offender innocent. In his case (no pun intended) he didn't do the least effort to protect himself or his system. Its like your mother told you not to touch the stove because it was hot but you did it anyway. Stupidity obviously does have a price tag in this case. On the other hand, BoA should bear some punitive responsibility for not red-flagging the transfer before allowing it and checking with him to verify that it was a legitimate transaction. I know for a fact that credit card companies do this when they suspect a strange transaction. As far as lawsuits go, I agree that customers should be able to sue their banks for stupidity on their part also. That's my 2 cents (or maybe 3 or 4).

by technogal

Who are we to decide that it was all on him? How about we talk about how cheap it is to buy a PC? Or how there is no education for the consumer when it comes to spyware, viruses, etc? PCs tend to sell with a 90-day trial of some anti-virus/anti-spyware product, and that's it! Consumers at NOT taught how to maintain their PCs! Where would any of you be if you hadn't been taught to change the oil on your car and get a tune-up?! Show some compassion! Share your knowledge and quit being so darn greedy with it! You're not going to lose your job to some poor schmuck who has gotten hit with the latest Trojan!

You can talk all day about news reports, magazine articles, etc geared to the general public regarding these attacks, but most people have the mentality "It won't happen to me" or "I'm protected because I have X on my computer".

The best thing we can do is help educate the general public. I have cleaned more PCs than I can count, and always try to do so with education and awareness. That's what works! Not some smug "I know more than you do because I'm a computer guru" attitude. That's what keeps people from getting help and education.

As for getting BoA (or any other corporation) to own up and take responsibility, you can keep waiting til long past the cows come home. It's not going to happen, put that dream away.

by hal 9000

It is a different story for Business PC's! :D

If this guy is so cheap that he brought a home PC to run his business and then didn't even buy or download one of the free AV products who fault is it them? :(

He has a Lawyer to help him with any legal problems, no doubt he has an accountant if for nothing else to make sure that he doesn't over pay his tax, So what was wrong with hiring an IT Professional to advise him what he needed as a minimum on his business PC. If they actually got his bank details from the Trojan which I'm not so sure about what else was there to get? How many of his customers/ suppliers got the same Trojan sent to them from his computer? What happened to his accounting keeping package was it spoofed and every one of his clients got a false bill from his company?

If he wasn't instigating legal action against the Bank in this case who he no doubt asked for the ability to transfer large amounts of money around to different parts of the world and there was other damage done I would be far more sympathetic and be willing to help him but running to the courts because he screwed up and wants someone to blame for his own stupidity makes my blood boil.

But just how many other cases of this particular Trojan have you heard of?

I find it hard to believe that something so dangerous is released onto the Internet and only affects one person. Now would you like to fill us in on the time taken to spread a Virus completely around the world from the time of release into the wild? This is measured in minutes not weeks, days, or even hours!

Why only one report of someone getting hit?

It sounds fishy to me and in light of his actions I would be thinking it is a scam to try to get money for nothing. :(

Col ]:)

by moira

Even someone smart who works with computers can become the victim of someone smarter (well, that's the wrong term, because there's nothing smart about theft).

But you get the point. It could happen to anyone who embraces the net into their lifestyle.

To be honest, I don't even think banks would want to make their customers pay for any losses, because in the long term, they'd be the losers, as customers simply wouldn't bank with them or be so willing to use the internet for transactions (thereby saving the bank a massive amount in running costs and administration).

If people are not confident enough to use the net for financial transactions, that's bad news for every bank and mail order company. Sure, people should take steps to prevent fraud, but it's impossible to make yourself totally immune and still have an online life!

by red_wolf9

"It is reasonable for the typical end user to defer to the 'experts' when it comes to computer security. In this case that should be the bank management."

This is where your argument falls apart. The bank looks out for the banks interests, from their stand point online banking (read THEIR internal network) is secure. BoA's Service Agreement with the customer says NOTHING about the customers PC.

Here look:
http://www.bankofamerica.com/onlinebanking/index.cfm?template=service_agreement

I had a glimmer of hope that you understood this when I read your very next sentence.

"In the U.S. many people hire a professional to fill out their tax forms each year. Why?"

I thought you had seen the light, you even close saying "That's why people hire experts to inform them about tax code regulations that affect them."

Now answer two questions for me :
1) When you enter into a contract do you bring your own lawyer or do you think the "other guys" lawyer is looking out for your interest too?

2) Would we be having this discussion if your business man had hired a PC expert (even for a one time consultation)? If you say NO, then who failed to hire the businessman's PC expert?

Was it BoA or was it the business man? That is where the liability lies, in my view firmly with the business man. I have a good analogy but it is far to long to include in this reply.

by red_wolf9

Would you ever think of doing even a 10k wire (much less the 90K)transfer from that PC? The article does not say how frequent and how large his ?normal? wire transfers, this could have been SOP for his account.

As others have pointed out (and I think it should be repeated) the business man's account had a history of large wire transfers. What if HE told the bank to set a 100k limit or asked BoA to run the account uncapped, companies that make last minute rush purchases would not survive having to authorize every transaction. Again, no word on whether or not he asked for account fraud protection/notification triggers.

Now for my Spyware rant.... it is a well know flaw in all "cleaner" programs that if the process is running it can not be deleted/cleaned (thank you Windows architecture). Might I suggest downloading AutoRuns and Process Explorer from http://www.sysinternals.com and use them to hunt down the running malware. Kill the processes, and remove their calls from startup locations? and just for fun then run whatever spyware app you like. For really nasty bug you might have to boot into Safe Mode : Command Prompt Only or the recovery console (NO a command prompt windows is not the same, it runs within the GUI context) and make use of the old DOS commands ATTRIB and DELETE, very few malware can withstand that process.

by red_wolf9

We?re NOT talking Credit Cards here people, this was a secure wire transfer. The difference between the two is as deep as the Grand Canyon.

The business man should direct his lawsuit, in civil court, at the Latvian hackers. Had he followed this course of action I would have absolutely not problem. But he isn't going to win a dime from a faceless foreign hacker, even if he wins in US court by absentia (look it up we'll wait).

What he should do is press BoA to recover the remaining cash from the Latvian bank (who everyone is treating as an accessory to the crime), the problem is this takes TIME. Both banks have huge stacks of legal paper work to fill out before the funds can be recovered (remember BoA didn't tell this guy to pi$$ of, they are investigating along with the US law enforcement). I'd be interested to know if he still banks with BoA?

Since I have had a personal funds recovery problem with BoA that was finalized just last week (but occurred November 2004)I'm real familiar with the process. The best part... both banks are headquartered not only in the USa but in the very state in which I live.

by red_wolf9

Smokers have found sympathetic people (like yourself, based on your posts) and actually won huge judgment against cigarette companies. They did it to themselves, cried about it and foolish juries gave them MILLLIONS. They showed total ignorance, sometimes claiming "they didn't know", and managed to do it with a straight face. I lump this case in with those... more proof we as Americans have become an overly litigious society driven by an Entitlement mentality. At times it makes me ashamed to be American.

From what I read our business man NEVER hired a consultant to so much as look at his PC setup. Yet he trusted eBanking enough, from what it appears, to handle his entire business. Anyone that can't secure their critical business process (accounts receivable/payable) has no business running one.

Thank you.... drive through

by mkrech

interesting concept. That would certainly make him a creative thief.

I am more inclined to believe he is just a wealthy idiot with zealous lawyers.

by red_wolf9

Since I posted the same link I agree with you, the one trouble spot I see for BoA's legal team is this overly vague statement.

http://www.bankofamerica.com/onlinebanking/index.cfm?template=guarantee

$0 liability
With our Online Banking service, you can be confident that your Bank of America accounts will be secure and protected. We guarantee $0 liability for any unauthorized activity originating from Online Banking, including Bill Payment. Read Your Responsibilities for information about reporting unauthorized transactions to preserve your rights under this guarantee.

by red_wolf9

Everybody on TechRepublic knows how I feel about Microsoft, but seriously if you think BoA has an easy out in this case, read a Micro$oft EULA. The reason people don't sue Micro$oft is because it's damn near impossible.

Remember you don't own Windows... Microsoft is allowing you the privilege of using it. You might own a physical CD but every little chunk of code belongs to M$ and you have merely been given license to use Windows. Microsoft does not warrantee their software for any purpose, so if (some say when) it breaks (or infects you via the exploit de-jour) in no way is Micro$oft liable for your losses.

Be sure to thank your congressmen for giving software makers the sweetest of sweat heart deals, and that was WAY before the DMCA.

And Amcol, last time I checked BoA was working to resolve the problem, not sending in the legal stormtroopers. It's our Miami business man suing them because they won't cough up 90k (he thinks he is owed) on his time table. And your "BoA is an evil corporation" rant sounds oddly like lame excuse the Anti-Micro$oft crew uses to justify their positions. A company's bank roll does not alone make them some kind of evil entity.

I despise microsoft for reasons other then their bank account value, which I consider living proof that:
A sucker is born every minute
-and-
A fool and his money are soon parted.

by red_wolf9

I'm trying to understand you logic here.

Let's just ignore the fact that the bank didn't "lose" anything... you did.

You think that the bank should be insured for the amount of every deposit on it's books?

What do you think the insurance premium would be..?

You are aware that banks don't even have enough cash on hand to cover every deposit much less insure those deposits (that's where the FDIC comes in and our fine federal government will only insure 100k of your account).

But I'm sure your ideal would be a big hit with Insurance companies who assume almost no risk and would make profits that Bill Gates would envy.

by kaceyr

And that's a very important difference (especially since they were taken to court in Mass. for operating an illegal bank).

PayPal is a contractual third party for handling monetary transactions. The accounts that they use to hold the funds are merchant accounts that are held a various banks, but they themselves are not a bank and do not perform "banking practices", that is, they make their money off of processing fees, not interest on money they're holding for others.

They transfer the funds to where they need to go based upon the request of the buyer/seller. If a bank that they're using has a restriction, then the funds transfer gets restricted.

Also, to become a "verified" PayPal account holder you have to provide personally identifiable information such as a bank account at a US Bank and/or a credit card application that includes your social security number.

On another note, your first sentence is correct: "For any banking institution to allow a wire transfer to another bank without requiring the account holder signature is irresponsible.". However, this only applies to the SENDING account. There is no requirement AT ANY BANK ON THE PLANET to disallow a funds transfer INTO an account. The fact that this guys company does regular wire transfers already indicates that the bank already has signed permission to conduct this type of banking business.

by red_wolf9

Well done Oz, thanks for the extra info.

I do however think that the next illogical step is a biological fluid requirement to complete a transaction (taking a page straight from the movie Gattaca). Yeah... if the DNA don't match, BoA better not cash.

Just think of all the fun bodily fluids we as customers could offer to provide.

by kaceyr

... where this may buy the guy a way to sue BofA, but only for the amount of the lost funds (the ~ 20K already withdrawn).

The problem I see is that the bank can still argue that it was his failure of due diligence that caused the problem in the first place, so he would still have to suck it up.

by red_wolf9

My BS Klaxon is going crazy over here.

I ask myself.... What is so odd about:
1) Having over 90k in an account but the business can be sustained on a 50k loan.
2) Multi-jurisdictional banks are working to get your money back all you have to do is ASK !
3) Your lawyer makes public statements like "If you lost $5,000, you are going to walk away from that $5,000 because there isn't an attorney in town who will take the case"
4) Your lawyers publicly stated goal is class action status, where he makes TONs and you get $2.60 after it's all said and done.

This stinks worse then the blended frog smoothie I saw on FearFactor last night.

by kaceyr

Since the bulk of my consulting is to the State, they're very conviently located. Unfortunately they're also very ugly, generate a lot of traffic congestion, and (here's one TumH2O didn't see coming) provide a place for the elementary school kids to ditch to that's out of sight so that they can smoke, etc.

I live on the outskirts of the city limits, but it's getting closer as I type this. They have 3 new housing developments in progress (about 130 new homes) and deplorable building inspection standards (that's all I'm allowed to say about that one) so I've already begun my search for where to move to next.