Discussion Locked

Unionize IT Now!

0 helpful
725 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

725 replies

by bkinsey1

Why on earth would anybody want the job of running this world?!?! I'll pass, thanks. . . . Oh, and I'll pass on the union thing, too. . . .

by rw17

I hear you Mathew... moving is a very serious consideration. However, if someone moved every time that they desired their situation to change, what would ever be accomplished? Surely there would be no automobiles, trains, planes, phones, etc!
$25 / hour is not great if you are an SAP consultant... but if the cost of living is low, then it's all relative.
I suggest Unions for my, and my co-workers situation. In North Amjerica, it would appear that we have become slave labourers... and Canadians are even more of a victim of this for American companies because of our perceived inexpense. Canada may be a cheap cost of living generally, but Toronto and Vancouver are NOT!
The issue is: I want to work with SAP like I have for the past 9 years... I just can't do it much longer at 70 hours per week (much unpaid) with hardly any vacation, stress of an unbelievable nature, and the like.
When you work for a major consulting company like I do, and the average life of consultants there is 32 months, something is obviously brutally wrong! If the company won't remedy it, then the employees should!

by cactus pete

I'll bet you can't be forced to work that many hours without being compensated. Well, I won't bet much, but you really should look into it.

by too old for it

The US is on the way to becoming the next third-world cesspool. Hell, in some places (major cities) it already is: Turf ruled by gang leaders and war lords who would sooner shoot you as not. The Crips, the Bloods, the MS-13 .. THEY are in control now. The elected government just goes through the motions. The police send out a raiding party on some schlep with Danish porn on his PC, and hope they don't annoy the gangs shooting each other for control of the crack trade on the corner of Walk and Don't Walk.

Get a job you say? Where?? All the good factories are gone. Hell, all the mediocre factories are gone. "Shareholder value" is just code for screw the workers, blue coller, white coller, doesn't matter. Same with IT. Worse, because now you have an educated workforce enemployed and living under the Town Street bridge. All who have been sold the "retool and retrain" bill of goods.

Service economy, hell. While the near term shows an increase in the number of people who will need service, there will be a larger increase in those who don't give a damn any more, and quit buying anything.

The coming economy in the US will make the depression of the 30's combined with Pol Pot's Cambodia look like the good ol' days.

by richard

if you think that is what happened to the auto workers. You shoud beg for a clue

by apotheon

When a domestic industry gets into a routine, repetitive work in the industry gets cheaper. When workers start pulling extortionist crap like unionizing for better wages, the industry starts moving to other countries. Once that happens, jobs disappear, and the unions become useless tumors sucking the remaining domestic workforce dry while convincing them that unions are their buddies.

If you think outsourcing is bad for your career, just wait until the company isn't outsourcing any longer because it followed the outsourced jobs overseas.

by raintree

I worked in a department store in the late 60s that was a closed shop... for a short time. I had just been discharged from the military, this was the first job. When they had their charity drive they wanted 100% participation. The charity they were pushing was one I didn't go along with because their "management expenses" were ridiculously high. I tore up the participation card and threw it away. The company withheld my paycheck and would not give it to me until I responded. Now, I believe that is illegal (even then) from a federal or state perspective. It should certainly have not been tolerated by the union. I was not the only person this happened to. I don't see that the union was any help there. I worked there for a few months until I had a chance at a job where they actually respected their employees. It was a non-union shop, of course.

by kwilson

Unionize? Why, so we can create a new payroll deduction to standardize pay, opportunities, and benefits while the non-IT union staff rake in the dough? Are you an ethical worker? Are you willing to eat the slack that those less ethical workers create because they know how to take advantage of the Union? How about politics? You won't get rid of company politics you will add another set of union politics to the mix.

Some of the most talented and skillful IT folks I know have no cert, and they are old hackers (good hackers) who did what needed to be done and taught themselves... Of all of those hard working IT folk who were too busy doing their jobs and gaining valuable practical experience in the trenches to get, or update a marketing, I mean an IT certification so they could "have that piece of paper", would get shut out of careers they built... nice.

Better yet when some schmuck thinks he's worth $60/hour and forgets to factor in his benefits into the equation decides to incite a strike, then everyone will have to suffer...

Unionize IT? No thanks. There are plenty of employers out there who pay good wages for their locations, and when one factors in their benefits like the various insurances, medical, dental, vision, prescription and other perks that don't show up in one's paycheck in the form of dollars, one just might find they're already making $50 or more an hour.

That $12/hour employee is probably pulling down around twice that when the benefits are figured in, and that's just starting pay... Of course if $12/hr is laughable then no one should apply for the position and the company might get the idea to offer more.

On the other hand, if it's an "all about me" proposition and the BBD, then go solo but before you do, ask those who been-there-done-that... They might enlighten you to the fact that those bigger bucks will cost you more than you might have thought... Everything has a cost... I'm not sure the cost of unionizing offers the kind of ROI you think you'll get.

Don't forget, it's not just all about what you've done, but how well you've done it and more importantly, how well you've handled it and communicated to your peers and superiors in accomplishing the tasks required of you.

Finally, Why don't you take your Masters degree, and your MCSE cert some place that will give you $50/hr and 40/h/wk... someone who can afford it, but then you're going to have to find someplace that's not going to expect you to be strapped to a pager as an MCSE.

We all knew the terms of our employment when we took our respective jobs... If they no longer meet our needs, we can re-negotiate or head out. In a union shop, no one re-negotiates but the union... In a sense you belong to them - they don't belong to you... think about it...

by noyoki

> "Perhaps it would have been better stated:
>Laws preventing 12 hr shifts without being appropriately compensated and with adequate breaks."

I was actually referring to children. I meant that a child cannot work more than 20 (or so) hours a week, and much less than 8/day. That's for kids around ages 14-18?

Sure, adults can work 12 hrs a day, but yes, with breaks and compensation.

Sorry for the confusion.

by rw17

.... well.... from 40 - 48 is unpaid OT hours... then, the 10 - 12 hours of travel is unpaid per week... then, the administrative hours are unpaid as there is no billcode and is "expected" by the company...
Hence... unpaid hours...

by p_piluk

My father is a union plumber and I have always been astounded at how similar my job is to his. IT basically is the first White-collar trade. We should set it up like any other aprentiship, including organizing...

by p_piluk

Aside from Programming, which I have done plenty of it, most IT work is very similar to the trades. It is very difficult for me to explain but if you have spent any time around tradespeople and compaired their stories to those of two IT people you will see my point. We have far more in common with them than we do with an Electrical Engineer. Saying that, setting IT up as a trade would provide a standard method for ensuring the high quality of IT in North America. My union plumber father is constantly upgrading his skills as technology changes in his field...at a better rate than many of my friends in IT. I consider myself a tradesman and am proud of it!

by galt

You make absolutely valid points, and I do realize that business looks at everyone, ultimately, as units in a spreadsheet that can be moved about or tossed away if they get too expensive. I am not in favor of unions--I've seen too much bad--but something needs to be done for American IT workers. When you live in a $20/hr economy, you can NOT compete with workers who live in a $5/hr economy. And when anyone, anywhere puts their skills on the block for less than what it is worth, all of us are trivialized to the point of becoming like the shade tree auto mechanics of the 60s and 70s, hawking our skills for whatever we can get from whoever will pull over for a few minutes and let us "lift the hood".

by apotheon

Even if nothing is done to fix things, something will happen. Unfortunately, if we're very unlucky and companies like Microsoft have their way, that "something" will be that the US will start exporting IT workers the same way Canada is exporting healthcare workers.

If things are allowed to play themselves out the way they're going, the IT industry will go back to being what it's supposed to be: a service industry. At the moment, it's basically a manufacturing industry on the face of it with nothing but ephemera on the back end. Corporate software vendors like Microsoft have a vested interest in keeping things that way, so they do everything in their power to legislate away the openness of a free market that would allow things to evolve, and as communications capabilities improve it becomes ever easier to get people thousands of miles away to do your work for peanuts and get the results as quickly as if they were in your backyard.

Of course, what we end up with is corporate interests controlling all the software under that business model, and shareholders getting all the major profits while the rank and file just get unemployed or underemployed. Meanwhile, the people using this software get inferior, insufficiently customized software with which they simply have to live because there aren't any other options.

With the evolution and ascending relevance of open source software, however, the ability to customize and maintain system on-site, keeping control of assets within one's own hands. As that opportunity increases, so too will the demand for people to provide that customization and maintenance capability, creating more jobs. With elimination of some really egregious licensing costs, it's possible to afford the talent to provide this added value to the business, and everyone's a winner -- except the major software vendors' stockholders.

Help things move along. Support and vote for government officials who oppose the commoditization of the intellect. Invest in the future of the skilled IT worker rather than the corporation built on their backs to benefit the worthless layabouts in the boardroom. Turn the IT industry into a meritocracy again. Use open source software, contribute to it, and get better functionality for reduced outlay.

by problemslayer

2 things.

1.) From the text of your post one would think you are working in a Communist Chinese sweat shop with a gun to your head. I doubt that is the case, and I also doubt that you have so little control over your own destiny. If that is the case, you are in the wrong country.

2.) Even if I where to grant your premise, (which I do not), I would still say that Unions are not the way to go. Look at thier recent track record. They are killing the industries that are thier bread and butter. Unions are killing airlines and auto manufactures in this countries. If companies like GM go down the tubes, will the Unions have made thier members any better off? How about all those folks GM is going to lay off because they can no longer afford to pay them such high benifit packages? I would say not.

I think too often people sucumb to the idea that corporations are really infinitely wealthy and simply whithhold money from thier employees because they are mean and greedy. While this may be true in some cases, in many others it's not.

America is the land of opportunity. If you can't make what you want in IT, find another field, or even better quit and start your own corporation and be your own master!

by cactus pete

I think the managers are killing the companies, not the unions. But the unions aren't helping at all.

by dawuf

The workplace that we know in today's workplace came to be because there were unions that fought for them. Equal Employement, labor laws, child labor laws were created as result of people unionizing factorys in the late 19th and early 20th century. Things we take for granted.

Think about it, folks!

by peter.l.scalzi

Yes. Let's unionize.

Let's do for the IT industry what unionization has done for the US manufacturing sector. After all, China needs more jobs.

by is1

Greedy backstabber is what the definition of union should be. They had a place and a time that is no longer now or here in the US. Look at what the crooks did in NY and what about the teacher?s union scum!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

by gometrics

And our large economy and population are not accidents. It based on free markets. People want to come here because of it. Private citizens are more generous because of it. Bottom line is the U.S.A. gives the most money. Compare us to other countries with large populations to be really fair. And don't penalize us because our government doesn't raise our taxes to give more so they can look more benevolent. You bet our government would give more if we had the tax rates of the countries you mentioned. May it never be. Luxembourg? The GNP is probably smaller than the smallest U.S. state.

by wagnernd

I have many years expeience in Labor Law/Labor Relations. While to organize IT Dept.'s sounds very good, it is very complex. For starters you can't just organize one subsection of a Company ("Carve out a Unit". "The National Labor Relations Act" should be easily available after a web search. I wish you well as it is a very good idea, if done right! wagnerND

by tonythetiger

Suppose you are the best. You have honed your skills to razor sharpness and work with rapid efficiency. Not to mention the fact that you haven't been off on sickleave in over 20 years.

So you go to your boss and asked to be compensated for your higher work output and quality,

More than likely your boss says: "Sorry, if I give you a raise, the union will demand it for everyone in the same job classification."

So it's easy to understand the view that unionization might discourage innovation and efficiency, and promote mediocrity (Why innovate if you're not going to gain from it? Why work any harder than you absolutely have to?).

If you're among the best at what you do, you should be pissed at any unionization attempts, because what they get for your "buddies", they'll be taking away from you!

by tonythetiger

"there may be less incentive to cheat clients if their workers needs are already fully met"

... you actually said that. What a kick in the gut to American workers.

If American workers [b]were[/b] like that, they would deserve firing, not union protection!

by decimumaximus

I have been in the IT feild since 1986! In 1990 I was making $95k a year as a A+ Bench tech.I Now own a successfull IT business and am lucky to pull 75k myself, I also now hold 45 differnt certifications and 2 bachelors degrees. WTF why did I bother getting certified if some punk who has "Worked five years or so" can undercut me for $12 an hour!?
Yes over the years I found consulting to be the best way to keep my wages better than $12hour...But the consulting arena has it's share of hacks.. The phone book is full of morons who couldn't get that $12 hour job at Best buy on the jerk squad much less actually fix something..so they placed an add in the phone book and wolah! they are now a tech! Don't get me wrong they keep me busy ..But I am real tired of the reputation they leave and even more tired of fixing stupid $h!t that some dumb@$$ hack with a Certification of "NONE!" and his only
Qualification is that he Plays everquest and has a myspace.. that $12hour jerkoff cost the client $100's in downtime and probably lost their wedding pictures and their childs first steps in the process. Hey if it was as easy as format and restore what the hell would we need techs for !

I am ready for a Union lets get rid of these Stupid kids that keep driving our wages into the ground! and get our money Back!!!!!!
Hell I would be happy to get just recoup the funds I put into IT certifications...not to mention the years of hitting the books I could have been a lawyer or doctor by now.. $12 an hour what a CROCK!

I didn't go to school for 8 years, AND WORK IN IT. FOR the last 20 JUST to earn 12$ an hour. I AM SURE MOST OF WHO WHO CAN SYPATHIZE DIDN'T GO TO SCHOLL WITH 12$ AN HOUR IN MIND EITHER! = NOT YELLING ! just excited ; )
Please keep this ball rolling !

by bg6638

I've been in IT for 30 years, and I have to admit that it is frustrating to see what has happened to the wages. But consider, between advances in technology, heavy outsourcing, and an oversupply of CS grads, wages have no where to go but down! Think $12/hr is bad? I was sent to apply for a Help Desk I position(better than nothing when your unemployed), and was told by the receptionist not to apply because I didn't have a Master's! I asked to see the job description (all 7 pages worth), and besides the Master's, they wanted 5 yrs exp., virtually every cert offered by Citrix, Cisco, Msoft, and Redhat. Add to that exp with as400 websphere, and HP3000 MPE/IX ManMan Erp. It was a temp to hire position with a starting rate of.......$9/hr! That's right $9.00/hr for all of those qualfications for an entry level job!!!!!

How is a union going to change the business world? Demanding $50/hr and 9-5 days will only cause business owners to increase outsourcing to the point where India will run all IT services for the U.S.!

by tonythetiger

that the average IT wage is $12 an hour. I know dozens of IT people, and none make less than $20. Most are in the $30 to $45 range. If you are unhappy with your wage, change companies, or go into business for yourself. Creating a gang of Union IT thugs isn't going to solve your problem... It will just put more people in the same boat with you... Misery loves company.

by kwilson

It is admirable that you have so many certs you can get the acronyms on a regular sized business card, tht you actually went to school for the field and know what you're doing. I respect that and I know several others who are just as skilled through experience and have no certs.

I also sympathize with all the wannabe's out there, I've cleaned up after several myself. But, I don't think unionization for IT will help. The bottom line of business is profit: That's why India, Russia, and Indonesia are so attractive. But, many companies are reaping the rewards of cheap IT much like the clients you help clean up after the "Best-Buy-Rejects".

Frankly, the possibility is very real that unionizing IT will have the same future as unionized manufacturing... A new home overseas or south-of-the-border.... Compared to unemployment, I would think that $12/hr. for starters will look pretty good then.

We need to make a decent living, but at the same time, we can't make choices that drive companies out-of-business, or out of the country. There is a balance and it is uniquely achievable among individuals without a union... Maybe you should start a wage-negotiation consulting service for IT professionals and see how many of them would like to pay "union dues" to you to negotiate them a dollar or two an hour wage with one extra day off per year. I have seen several companies close their doors rather than get strapped down by a union. They opened up under another name with lower wages than before the union came, and guess what? People still applied to work there.

Personal greed is something that cannot serve us or our families, but sound financial and spending choices can. I want my career and career choices in MY hands, not a Union's. Don't forget: a union is also a business, and it too must make business decisions based on the factors that keep it in business... its member ship is just one of those factors.

Think about it...

by spitfed

...we will, when it's hegemony finally self-destructs.

From a different perspective, all of what SimonJester says can be equally applied to the U.S.A.

It can be argued that the USA is still (only just though) holding the world to "hostage" - in an economic and military sense.

Unions may put (have put) the final nail in the coffin of US manufacturing, but the body inside is dead due to lack of firm trade barriers, minimal import tariffs and a 'bend-over-backwards' attitude of the US government towards developmental countries such as those in South-Asia.

The health of most of the world's economies now rest upon the ability of the average US citizen being able to spend and keep on consuming cheap imports (silicon-based products, steel, autos, etc).

At this stage, intoduction of new unions would probably push most of the remaining US businesses over the edge or over the horizon into other countries.

Shirkers of the world, wail with the rest of us when it all comes crashing down.

by fractalzoom

squaredge said:
"I say we apply rules of work that apply to a 40 hour work week and serious overtime. I say we demand $50/hr for any IT related work, as a minimum. If we join together we have the power to run this world!"

Ummm...do you wanna get real, sir? You are dealing with a painfully outdated worldview. There are eager IT hopefuls in India for whom $12 is a princely wage...and in the world as it exists today, trying to hold corporations over a barrel the way you describe will make the decision to replace you with somebody in Mumbai a very easy one.

Let me know when you make your move. I wanna come watch you crash and burn.

by evisscerator

Yes, they may work for $12.00 per hour,considered a princely wage, however, you cannot understand a dang word they are saying. Furthermore, if you invite them to dinner, you can't eat beef because they would think you're eating their Uncle or some close relative to them.

I would work for $12.00 an hour if ......

My house payment decreased by $200.00 a month,
My car payment was cut in 1/2 each month,
My utility bills were cut in 1/2 each month,
My taxes were cut 100%,
and
My employer realized what a tremendous value and asset I was to his business, rather than a huge cost to his bottom line.

Perhaps then, folks, we could live as they do in 3rd world India, Japan, Korea, or China. All things being equal, don't you agree?

Or by chance, are you smart enough to figure out that NAFTA/GATT were the things that took your livelyhood away and gave them to those 3rd world India Guru's who couldn't command a vowel of the Kings English?

Here Here !

by onbliss

...yes majority of the Indians do not eat it. Yet, majority of them would not take to offence if someone else were to be eating it.

by boogaloodude

I think we're losing sight of the beginning of this thread, although it seems like it's been up here forever, it's only been 2 days (I think you struck a chord with this one) This started as a discussion about unionizing HERE in the US, not India, unless that $12.00 an hour includes Travel time. I'm assuming that most of the IT people involved in this discussion have a home base, or a corporation that they work for, and those jobs cannot be outsourced to India, China or Korea..There are just certain jobs that will never leave the country, like Car Mechanics, and Home Theater Installation (my niche) which, by the way I'd love to see unionized, because I've been doing it for years, and I see those hungry young upstarts who live with Mom and Dad, charging $12.00 an hour, and the people I work with charge a flat $40.00 plus travel! So if you think of yourselves more in terms of an Electrician or a Carpenter, (which, by the way are Union Positions) you'll see that your job is not likely to go to another country. I can't say one way or another which is best Union or Non, but I've never heard a Union member complain about Health, Dental, or Retirement Benefits, or Job Security for that matter.

by tonythetiger

"but I've never heard a Union member complain about Health, Dental, or Retirement Benefits, or Job Security for that matter."

That's because they don't realize that the money paid for all of those 'benefits' comes from money the employer could be paying to them and/or saving the consumer of the product or service. It's a shell game, and as P.T. Barnum said: "There's a sucker born every minute.".

by decimumaximus

Well Said I agree Whole hearted!

We are the Doctors and Lawyers of the IT world but with so many Spineless Cowards willing to take 12$ and hour and bitch about free trade BULL and how the auto industry suffers we'll never make it.
Comparing us to the auto industry is assanine comparing the IT feild to Doctors is so much more accurate and look what union's have done for them !
I dont know about you but when I deal with an end user I am a doctor, shrink, mechanic, engineer and even a maid! not to mention a Lawyer. If I got a dollar for every time I am asked legal advise "Mostly Software Licensing" I would'nt need to worry about wages !
So Why should'nt we get paid like a doctor or lawyer? I have gone to school just as long. I have more pretty little certificates in my office then they do! I SAY WTF you cowards need to find another feild to go corrupt and those of us with a SACK need to ban together and fight for what is ours.

by cactus pete

Do you know economics? People pay what they are willing to pay for something.

You will never make as much as the top heart transplant surgeon. Live with that fact.

The $12/hr was for what? A small company with small needs? Did they just want an entry level guy? Maybe they didn't want someone with all the certs and years in college.

Maybe they just wanted someone worth $12/hr.

What's wrong with that?

by decimumaximus

Ponder this
Without doctors the world would be sick and there would be alot more death.

Without I.T. the world would not function.< PERIOD ...Hmm

Why don't we make more than Doctors?

Cowards! Get a spine and stand up for yourselfs!

by jamesrl

Do you honestly think someone on a helpdesk or fixing PCs (both jobs I have done by the way) deserves more than a doctor, who by the way, has a Bachelors degree, 4 years of medical school, and 4 or so years of low paid apprenticehsip as a resident(where in some areas they may make as little as $10-15 an hour)?

If you do, I hope you think better of it when you have a medical emergency. If they doctor seeing hasn't done a lot more than take a 3 year degree and/or write the MCSE, I'd be very concerned.

James

by tonythetiger

what if I am superior in skills, efficiency, and even work ethic compared to most of my colleagues, and am compensated more because of it. After we unionize, the union will exert pressure on the employer to increase the wages of the other employees to match mine (after all, we all do the same thing). This will make it more difficult for me to negotiate better compensation as I further increase my skills.

Not only that, the increase in others' wages causes the employer to raise the cost of his product, which I happen to buy so it results in a decrease in my buying power, which effectly is a REDUCTION in my wages. An even further reduction occurs because I am to start paying Union Dues.

So tell me, Mr. IT UNION YES, how does this benefit me?

by mot_esach

This world functioned rather well without all of our durrent IT gadgets. Industry is so deperate to sell the gadgets that they do mix and match to try to attract sales.

Every one has to have a gadget. Most can't even use them correctly or to their fully capability.

Get a life. If all of us IT folks dropped dead tomorrow, the world would still go on. 80% of the world lacks basic food, medicine or shelter and you think it will go away without you. Pooh!

Many people in my state of Oregon can't even afford simple health services. Face it. A lot of the world needs IT due to corporate infrastructure, but IT only makes it easier - it does not replace the human condition nor become a panacea to existance.

IT is not the "God of All".

If you want a real understanding of the necessity for IT live in east Tiajuana for a week. Then go home and be damn glad you have one to go to.

by jamesrl

They do some analysis to account for private giving as well. I don't discount private giving, in fact the author of the study makes the case that private giving is more efficient than government, something I personally agree with.

It isn't the totals that count, its the % of GNP, or per capita if you prefer. If you compare similar economies, say Canada and the US,the US is roughly 10X more population wise, with an economy that is more than 10X in terms of GNP (Canada's economy has been growing to close that gap). So it would be silly to compare Canada and US in terms of absolute $$, it makes more sense to look at it on a per capita or % of GNP basis. On that basis , Canada gives .27 % of its GNP in government aid, while the US gives .17%. The adjusted figures which include private giving show a % of GDP as .07 for US and .14 for Canada.

I am not trying to say that the US should give more or that they give nothing, I am simply attacking this myth that the US gives more than the rest of the world combined that I hear repeated often.

James

by jamesrl

They do some analysis to account for private giving as well. I don't discount private giving, in fact the author of the study makes the case that private giving is more efficient than government, something I personally agree with.

It isn't the totals that count, its the % of GNP, or per capita if you prefer. If you compare similar economies, say Canada and the US,the US is roughly 10X more population wise, with an economy that is more than 10X in terms of GNP (Canada's economy has been growing to close that gap). So it would be silly to compare Canada and US in terms of absolute $$, it makes more sense to look at it on a per capita or % of GNP basis. On that basis , Canada gives .27 % of its GNP in government aid, while the US gives .17%. The adjusted figures which include private giving show a % of GDP as .07 for US and .14 for Canada.

I am not trying to say that the US should give more or that they give nothing, I am simply attacking this myth that the US gives more than the rest of the world combined that I hear repeated often.

James

by questor1

You are obviously locked into a small company where you seem to be happy. You are probably underpaid for the quality and quantity of IT work you perform to the clients satisfaction. I hope you get satisfaction from this contracting gig because it can change from good to bad in a moments notice. What recourse do you have if the client company abruptly terminates you or your contract? If the company you work for changes its mind for any small or unknow reason, you can be out on the street in a heartbeat.

As I stated in my original post, "Fear and loathing of Unions is unfair" - you have not address that fact that non-union IT staff have no job security (they are considered "at-will) and are subject to the subject to unfair and irrational management conditions. I have seen this done to people and it is not a pretty sight.

Unions offer social stability to represent employees to management with a unified voice of concern. Unions enable IT staff to work with management in confidence and realize that IT workers do have a voice in the company that cannot be easily ignored.

Small IT shops that you seem to work at may not have exposed you to many of the IT issues experienced at larger companies. Try working at a large company IT department for an extended period of time and you will see the office politics that often burnout employees. IT Unions help members provide a measure of fairness and enable union members to work with office politics that often burn non-union IT staff.

by cactus pete

Obviously not!

You don't know where I work, and you won't. So you'll have to take my word for it that it isn't small. Granted, I've worked in much larger places, and smaller.

But so what if the company fires me? I'm good enough to find another. My state is an "at will" state. I can leave whenever I want, and likewise, they may terminate me whenever they want. C'est la vie.

I can talk to management. If I can't at some time, my boss will relay the concern. I have no worries there.

I don't fear or loathe unions. I just believe they shouldn't affect my wages.

It sounds more like you fear and loathe business without a union, though. And that I find unfortunate. Not that it bothers me, as I can then negotiate my wages higher than yours. Thanks.

by apotheon

I'm a libertarian. Some would call me fiscally conservative and socially liberal. I would just say I'm a free-market capitalist who believes government shouldn't be all up in my sh*t.

by bndplus2

Unfortunately.

CWA is the same union that handles Verizon and many of the telcos.

Although at one point the telcos workforce may have been considered "tech", I think that's much less true these days (or, should I say, we're "more" tech).

I went to a CWA meeting once, and all I heard was whining and moaning about doing much of ANYTHING without getting compensated.

As much as I hate to admit it, a union would stop a lot of us from doing our jobs effectively. If there's a problem and Joe Blow isn't around, we all step in to figure out the problem. In a union shop that could prove far less likely.

I'm tired of 60 hour workweeks without additional compensation, too. And believe me I think we have a diluted workforce because of the Cert-Monkeys out there. I think employers DEPEND on their ability to have us do more work than we rightfully should, taking advantage of most of our "can-do" attitudes. Yet when we get raises, we compete for the same percentage pool as the non-exempt workforce. What motivation is THAT?

Is anyone aware that most of us (admins, at least) should probably NOT be exempt from overtime? The rules are pretty clear... Look into it. Unless you're making at LEAST 50 some odd K per year, or if you are supervising 2 people, you probably should be paid overtime... In California I think it's 100K per year to be exempt!

Do we need a union? I think it couldn't hurt, but it'd have to be a good one, designed by US, with OUR guidelines. Given the choice of union or no union, if it was the CWA, I'd rather break rocks for a living.

*shudder*

by chuck

I researched the laws and it was clear to me that I am (and most IT people) are not exempt from overtime pay. However like any other law they are written to be interpreted by lawyers, It is not so black and white.

I brought this up with my superiors along with all supporting documentation and they swept it under the rug and told me their lawyers said that we are exempt. Complete BS, I?m a Network Engineer making less than 45K, 5 years experience, it is ridiculous. What am I going to do? get a lawyer and sue my company who is gracious enough to employ me, but cant quite afford to pay the wages? Small company, good people, but uncompensated overtime is what gets me the most. I will continue to go above and beyond to complete the tasks, but sure would be nice to be compensated for it.

You say find another job, but its tough, I apply to 40+ positions a year that I qualify for, I get maybe 5 interviews/testings a year each competing with 50+ other additional applicants/interviewees. I feel I do well in the interviews but I never get that call. A lot of competition out there, its a tough market, I?m not sure if unionizing will help. If we do unionize we have to take a different approach than traditional unions.

by cactus pete

Call them, explain your situation. They may clarify things for you, and you won't have to pay for a lawyer.

by boogaloodude

I'm not sure if I understand, are you saying that American unions would send the IT Jobs overseas out of Greed?

by kriaken

Oh where to start.

Heavy subsides propping up inefficient and outdated practices.

A political system which sees the man with the most money and family connection take power.

Major government appointments going to friends (some with significant criminal records) with no discernable qualifications other than political connections.

Military terror to force opinions upon people whom disagree with their dogma.

Economic displacement of a major portion of the population and health services which are near non existent to the majority of the population.

God Bless America, the third world country without compare.

by heml0ck

well said tony...
Having worked for unions before there are pros and cons.
The main reason I agree that unionizing is a good idea is to protect us from exploitation. All too often, employers are demanding 50+ hrs /wk while offering no further compensation. That is a violation of most labour laws in NA, and needs to be addressed.
As to the money, well I believe if you're good enough, you'll never want for work.

by davew

I cannot reply directly to you since the max thread level has been reached so here goes..

BUAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!

Though your comments are amusing I dont understand the french. I visited france recently and I have to say of all the coutries that I have visited I was treated far worse in france than in any other country.

We provide more aid to other countries that france on any given day, now france does provide some relief to others but it is no where near the scope of the US's efforts.

All I am saying is that we dont run over to french websites and blast your country, please show us the same respect.

by davew

GNP is ridiculous, the countries that need donations care about raw dollars and the fact is OUR country gives more than others.

Lets look at some facts:

In 2001, the United States gave $10.9 billion, Japan $9.7 billion, Germany $4.9 billion, the United Kingdom $4.7 billion, and France $4.3 billion..

The United States is the world's largest contributor of foreign aid in absolute terms ($15.7 billion, 2003), and Private foreign aid donations in the United States are on the order of $35 billion a year (2003)

what counts are bottom line dollars...

The whole GNP argument is basically a feel good for other countries, GNP doesn't feed the starving or house the homeless, RAW DOLLARS ARE ALL THAT MATTER...

by cmcarlson.com

Hey lets remember that unions gave us minimum wage, the forty hour work week, OSHA laws and don't forget your OSHA breaks.

Just because the UAW is struggling and has become a bloated corporate/thug entity don't forget that the concept of unions is to protect it's workers.

So many times I hear people poo-poo the unions for being a means to protect the lazy. It protects the hard working too.

Those people who do not like unions tend to be those people who boo-hoo and cry foul when they are randomly downsized and have no recourse except to work a hotdog stand.

United we stand, divided we crash...

by cactus pete

Unions did such a good job, we don't need them anymore?

They have come full circle and now exist just to exist?

by pete1978

Where is the US steel industry? Where is the US automotive industry? Answer, both of these formerly very powerful US industries are now very much struggling. In both cases, they were unionized and, ultimately, the cost of jobs forced the "exportation" of many of the jobs. We do not have foreign cars outselling US cars because they are better cars or even because they are less expensive (though arguments could be given for both ideas). We have foreign cars outselling US cars because they are better cars per dollar! This is very much due to the high cost of wages in the unionized US plants. Let's face it, when the cost of wages is lower, the manufacturer can afford to use higher quality parts because they are spending less on putting those parts together into a car. Ergo, cars are being built where wages are lower. Detroit is dead!

Where are IT jobs going? The answer is that, even without IT unions, IT jobs are going overseas where the wages are lower.

Go ahead, unionize. But when you do, US IT workers will ALL be unemployed. You should have saved more money when an MCSE was a rare commodity. Today, an MCSE is a dime-a-dozen and you just are not going to get high $$. Deal with it.

by peter warren

Thanks for your compassionate advice to just
"deal with it." It seems you should have looked a little further back in our glorious history to the days of child labor, company towns and indentured bondage. I'm sure you would have found many fellow travelers.

According to your program, we can all look forward to working for pennies an hour and living in abject poverty. Way to go! I suppose you think that you and your children will be immune because you are so special. Wake up. You're probably going to go down with the rest of the us.

I'm so tired of the whining lament that nothing can be done to manage our economy to better meet society's needs. Let's face it. It's just another way to avoid responsibilty and pretend everything is fine. Maybe unionization isn't the answer. But there are answers and we need to get serious about finding them. Enough of this nonsense about the untouchable state of American style capitalism.

by ralford100

There IS a way to improve the economy, but few are willing to put the effort in:
1) Up the quality of your work.
2) If you CAN'T do the work at high quality, don't BS your way into a high paying job just to sit at your desk and play solitair.
3) Lose the "job security" BS. Instead of hoarding information to make you "indespensible" (and keep you in a cushy job), expand your skills and responsibilities.
4) DO NOT under ANY circumstances sabotage the job effort to keep your job longer (something that union members are notorious for)!

IN OTHER WORDS, EARN YOUR PAY. SIMPLE, BUT EFFECTIVE

by tonythetiger

They talk about solidarity, but it's out of the other side of the mouth. What they should say is:

"Yeah, we can get most of you $20 an hour, but you have to decide which of your 'Union Brothers' you're going to kick to the curb in order to do it."

by jamesrl

But what I have been tryign to say is that it has been asserted that because the US is the largest giver in raw numbers, that they are the most generous.

Let me try a simple analogy. Homeless person sits outside a restaurant. Rich man comes out, opens up his wallet, and peels off a 20, gives it to the homeless man. Bus boy comes out and does the same. Which one is more generous?

Much of this comes down to attitude. I have many American friends and coworkers, who I know to be reasonable people, but here on TR and elsewhere there are a few Americans who continue to boast and crow that their country is the most generous and other countries do little in comparison. I'm not suggesting you have that attitude.

James

by phurcum

I am lucky i have a very good job now. After two years of waiting. I just finished working for one of the largest banks in the world,your local bank. i can say that in my group what Tony has described was accurate. while no one in my groiup was "shipped home" that methodology was very much implied on the level above in the States. it's too bad really, i found the Indians very knowledgeable, bright and wonderful people, mostly operating with this threat hanging over their heads.

by onbliss

...for the hotel. The salaries in India have been raising to the satisfaction of the IT workers there. Money has been made to rotate, and the middle class in India is now about 300 million strong.

by Member 25348569

I just got a bit chewed up by the "American Forum" thing and decided that - as the discussion was (is!) merely in a repeating loop - I'd both cause and take offence at someone being told [b]not[/b] to post. If you - and others - didn't like tech@whatever's argument then you should have either ignored him or countered his points but to round on him because he was a non-American posting a valid viewpoint on an international forum was and is not really on even if it is a US organisation. It's hosted on the West Coast for chrissakes. That's more foreign than anywhare!

Anyway, if you can't take criticism - or even accept that there might be a different viewpoint - from outside of your borders then you really ought to get a few more firewalls! Check out how many of the TR peers are Canadian, Australian and - like me - British and if you don't like what we say then feel free to kick back (hard, if you like) but you shouldn't try to stop us posting.

The French "farty" thing was a Monty Python quote, by the way, which you US sorts seem to like. I just said I was French because I know how much you (and we) all love the garlic-chewing b'stards and I wanted a reaction. StarTech provided me with one although I only found it by accident.

You responded with a tad more dignity and I apologise for the wind-up.

by jamesrl

I've been to many Indian restaurants in North America, including a few which cater more to immigrants from India.

Beef is usually available but not prominent on the menu. As I quite enjoy lamb, this is not an issue, personally I think the lamb dishes work better.

My fav though, is butter chicken. The supermarket that I shop at has a butter chicken frozen dinner that I buy for my lunch at work - microwaveable. They also have Chicken Korma, Chicken Biryani, Pad Thai and others, but for me, the Butter Chicken reigns supreme. Probably not the healthiest choice - no veggies except the onion and tomato in the sauce, lots of butter/ghee.

James

by cactus pete

I don't consider it a trade. Not what I have every done. (I worked my way up, too.)

So, unless you are able to provide more depth, I'll respectfully disagree.

by jamesrl

Though this is my second profile, I've actually been using this board since 1999. And gasp I am not American.

This site may be hosted by a US company and the staff of TechRepublic may be based in the US, but this is the internet, it is advertsied and available to all. I believe I can say with some level of knowledge that in no way do the staff want this to be an American only forum.

Don't take it so personally. I have had Americans here call me a socialist, and make all kinds of nasty remarks about my country. Believe it or not, I now call some of those people friends.

You aren't the first to complain about this kind of thing. But think about it this way. What the US does, especially the actions of its government, affects the rest of the world. More than any other country, the US has a global impact, economically and politically. So naturally that inspires alot of discussion. But I have to say compared to most Democrats what we say is pretty mild. (humour alert).

You say I have a choice whether or not to interact with the US. In reality, no I don't. Every employer I've worked with over the past 16 years has some relationships either directly or indirectly with a US company or a US firm. Thats a fact of life for any medium or large business in Canada. My current employer is a US company. Sarbanes Oxley applies to us as well as our US counterparts.

I was under the impression that the US favoured Free speech and open markets. It seems you may not agree with that.

James

by davew

Please dont construe my comments as personal attacks, I might have gotten a little heated but that is the nature of this beast and the whole reason that we come here..

Now let me get back on topic.

The problem that I have with GNP is that it does not take into account the tax money that the government reimburses people for personal donations..

I suspect that if you were to take personal donation tax deductions into account our GNP would look a lot more robust.

We have a different system, This is what we are all about. Because of this difference I believe the GNP numbers for the USA to be grossly inaccurate.

The US is a different system where the people make the decisions not the government (at least thats how it is supposed to be). This puts the power in the peoples hands which includes a large portion of relief spending.

Your analogy about a homeless man further reinforces my stance on this issue.

1: Rich man(the US government) gives homeless guy 20.00 and the rich guys clients(the us people) give the homeless man 35.00

2: bus boy(some other country) gives the homeless man 20.00

Where does he come out better?

by jamesrl

Don't worry I don't take it personally.

I would argue that you don't have a different system than Canada, I will let peers from other countries talk to how it works there. Canada too provides tax relief for those who contribute to charities, including the charities that provide assistance. And in many cases, Katrina included, in addition to tax relief the government will provide matching funds. If a Canadian gave money to the Canadian Red Cross for Katrina victims, they got a) a tax receipt and B) the Canadian government matched that money dollar for dollar.

So how is the US system different, other than fewer government donations.

James

by boogaloodude

I'm a Nam Vet myself, and I can't think of anything more closely related to a Union then the US Military, and you spent 21 yrs. in it..you surprise me. Do you have any idea how long it takes to move up the ranks in the Union/Military? of course you do, you start as an E-1/Journeyman, and through time you aquire the skills to TEST your way up the ranks (Yes, Union workers have to pass a test to). They pay for your Health, Dental, for you and your Family, they have thier own Credit Union. They set you up with a retirement program, and even take care of you after you retire (Both the Union and the Military) What's the difference? I'm not in a Union, but my brother is, and he's a very proud Heavy Equipment Operator (those are the guys who build the highways we drive on), with a lot of specialty skills on a number of pieces of equipment. All you keep referring to are a "Bunch of Bolt Screwers", and there's a hell of a lot more unions out there then the AFL/CIO. Have you ever dated a waitress? I have, and she came home every night exhausted, and smelling like the catch of the day. She belonged to a Union (yeah, they have one for restraunt workers to), and I know for a fact that without a union, she never would have gotten her own Health/Dental, let alone put money away for retirement, it just wasn't a priority for her, but like it or not, she had someone covering her ass (besides me) in case something did happen. Please stop waving the flag and calling Unions un-American, this country has it's problems, but I don't think they were caused by the Unions, it has more to do with the Elected Idiots!

by equintie

I had the displeasure working for a major financial paper that had a union for its non-managers. It was the worse `8 month I ever had on a job. It was a trail to get them to perform the simplest of tasks. Those who knew they were protected by the union would use this advantage to the fullest. Below are just a few example of what I had to deal with. From my experience UNIONS are definitely not the way to go. They were cripple the IT innovation the US has become known for and push companies to use other courtiers as resources quicker.

- After we had sent 3 engineers to a 5 day class on XP for MS certification, they were expected to take a MS cert exam within 6 months. After which, they went to the union with a compliant about the cert exam. The union in turn demanded that the company provide them PAID TIME OFF TO STUDY for the exam! I thought those who wanted to better themselves should do it on there own?

- Part of our requirement is a contact phone number so a person can be reached at all times for shift changes. When a member moved to another apartment, they refused to give us a phone number until they were provided paid time off to wait for the phone company to install a phone.

- Several times I would ask for a laptop or desktop to be rebuilt. Knowing these systems are rebuilt the same way each time with auto disks, the union insisted I provide documentation with step by step instructions to address every troubleshooting situation that could happen. When I tried to engagement the engineers to assist with this, the union insisted the manager were responsible for this documentation. They also suggested (which was NOT approved thank god!) if certain situation was not documented the union worker did not have to try and resolve the issue.
- Also ? I cannot tell you how many times I had to pay for OT to an engineer because they spent an extra 10 to 15 minutes finishing up work with a user before they left for the day. Of course if they were late, I was not encouraged to be negative towards them.

This is not to say that some of the professionals managed were not good. They were exceptional. One of the problems was I was really not allow to address them individual in public for their good work. The union indicated it was not positive feedback to praise one member and not all. Ridicules! Needless to say I left the organization. Funny thing was 6 months later when I spoke with a couple of the people I managed they indicated the union actually thought I was a decent manager, but they could not admit that while I was there.

It that the type of union you want IT to have?

by raintree

If you want an American Hybrid car, you can buy one that has an American Manufacturers name on it but the guts of it still comes from Japan.

by boogaloodude

Have you ever been to Downtown L.A.? I have and it ain't a pretty site, on the other hand, the 7,000 homeless there don't have to worry about Freezing to death like those in the Midwest, and the East Coast. Either way, there definitely IS a Huge Poverty Situation in the US, just because you can't see it out your front window doesn't mean it isn't there. And as far as our government giving it's fair share, I'm sorry, but I can't even go there because it makes me so angry to read what you wrote that I might be kicked out for what I think about the ignorant rants!! YOU MUST BE KIDDING!!

by wagnernd

I feel sorry for those who seem to have such a limited grasp of just what a Union is. All a Union is is a group of individuals, with simular interests, who have baned together for the common good. It is a very democratic society. Very heavily regulated too.
Your employer understands the importance of such groups. Just go into your Employer's office some day and look around at all the plaques hanging on the walls there signifying all of the like groups he/she has joined to further their common good, and, to control you! john Wagner

by boogaloodude

Wake up Dusterman, Mr. NYIT is just as much a Publickin as You are, problem is none of you realize that your on the same side cause some of you are Religous Fanatics, and some of you are anti-labor fanatics, and all of you are a sandwich short of a picnic. Damn Ditto-Heads

by sql_joe

A couple of notes....

Yes, business is about making money...but at one time it was also about the employees and the community. That is no longer the case with many businesses (most) and that is the problem. You will find that with many small businesses, they still do care about employees and community.

On the offshoring. If you look at the recent trends in congress to change the immigration laws to lift the H1B requirement entirely (and grant work visas to all family members of anyone granted a work visa AND to increase the total immigration allowed by an additional million per year) I think its a signal that offshoring is not saving as much money as hoped. Back when the HiB cap was much higher, BB (Big Business) threatened to offshore of congress didn't extend the cap. They didn't so BB offshored. I know for a fact that many of those BB's are losing customers right and left (and MAJOR ones too) because of problems (some having been mentioned in other posts here). So, now BB is putting pressure on congress again to lift the H1B program entirely, because it is actually CHEAPER TO IMPORT labor than to offshore it, BB just doesn't want to publically admit that, and with the issues of non-existant cybercrime laws in India and other countries, security and regulatory compliance are becoming an issue as well as increased concerns over identity theft occuring legally in these other countries by persons legally (no cyber crime laws) accessing personal information stored on systems that have been offshored and selling it. My company offshored a huge chunk of work to save money on engineers - BUT with all the reword required, they ended up having to hire back many of the laid off engineers just to make the stuff coming in from offshore usable! So now they're paying the offshore AND their own guys, and R&D tunraround time has skyrocketed! which just isn't good for business.

As long as executive bonuses are based on the bottom line, this sort of short term thinking will continue to prevail. If bonuses were based on other items, such as reduced employee turnover (which is expensive), product improvements, factory efficiency, improved sales in numbers (not dollars) etc etc - then things would be much different, and upper management would begin looking more to the long term.

I heard it put very succintly recently. How can an American worker compete with a worker making 50 cents an hour and no benefits?

In the long term a rebalancing will occur, if we truly ever achieve a global economy, and wages will drop here (USA) and rise elsewhere - but this is a long way off. What do we do, if anything, in the short term. Do we let the US economy die in favor of improving Mexico's economy? What is most important, the bottom line, or the American People?

Guess its all a matter of perspective.

George

by tonythetiger

Is that the union protects the mediocre and lazy worker, while forbidding management to reward the guy that's doing their work. They can't give the better worker a raise because they'd have to give the other ones a raise too, and they can't create a new position because the lazy ones would get it because of seniority.

It's the unionist mindset that is the very reason for a big part of the disparity of class in this country, and the reason other countries are going to catch up to and eventually overtake our economy. You can't compete with genius and innovation on a level field, so you band together to drag the achievers down, and you pat yourselves on the back and call it a success. You've lowered the bar (now every kid gets an award in school, don't you know, and aren't there tens of millions of cars running around with those "My child is an honor student at ..." stuck to them?). You've stifled work ethic, (why go the extra mile if you're not going to gain from it? and will other employees hate you if you outperform them and make them look bad?), and punished innovation (If I discover this better way of doing things, how many people will it put out of work?). You think laurels are something you get when you graduate from college with a degree, and that they are to be rested upon for the rest of your lives.

What have you achieved. Medical insurance? Bull, the companies who offer paid medical do so at your expense. They could be giving you that money, or, better yet, reduce the cost of their products or services. You wonder why medical care is so expensive. Well maybe it's because the medical workers have to pay more for the products and services they need because those companies raised their prices to cover the cost of medical insurance their employees' unions demanded. Higher wages? Yes, and higher prices, higher taxes, and union dues. It's a spiral without end.

And at what cost this 'achievement'? Well, lots of companies are downsizing. In order to meet the increased payroll costs, they had to let one of your buddies go (what's your union doing for him now?). Not only that, but now the rest of you are doing his work in addition to your own (uh oh: more stress, more illness, more medical bills, higher insurance premiums, ad infinitum). Or the company decides to set up shop in another country where labor is less expensive, and now EVERYBODY is looking for a new job. And lets not forget the retirement plans that were hit because they were invested in these companies that went belly up (what's your union doing for the retirees who are taking it on the chin?), and these people end up dragging down the one's who didn't get directly hit.

Yep, you've done it all right ... achieved through compassionate ([b]not![/b]) solidarity. Congratulations.

by decimumaximus

I wonder if telecom workers union would be interested in the IT feild? we could just join and wouldn't need to wait.

by boogaloodude

I've got a friend who works for the Operating Engineers Union, but she's an office administrator and therefore belongs to another union altogether. I'm based in the Milwaukee area, so the only number I've got is that of the local "Office and Professional Employee Intl. Union" and that is 414-771-9730. All you really have to do is ask Dawn what is involved. Those of you against, don't bother, all those who are at least slightly interested, give her a call and see what she's got to say. There Problem solved, now let's get on to more important matters like Niels Bookclub!!

by tonythetiger

And the unions were a good thing THEN. They've shifted their purpose lately though from one of protecting workers to one of punishing business (of course, the businesses are not really being punished... as any costs they incur are ultimately borne by the consumer, meaning that union workers nowadays are shooting themselves in the foot).

by whistl3r

Well put Joe! Your statements postulate uneducated BB. If BB's want quality, they need to start paying for it, some pay more than they bargained for; as you stated redunted overhead.

Personally, I do not belive Unionizing IT will "resolve" any problems, but will come down to it. However, every union is different and CAN be prejudice of whom they enroll, besides being prejudice is not illegal by any sense. Though BB will hire minorities over the well qualified canadiates because of the cheap labor.

by decimumaximus

Sure I Agree we .."that is those of us that have actually put in the time and have the training, degrees <--TWO and certifications <-- OVER 40"
Should get paid... But the reality of it is licensing would cure the pay issues doctors dont rely so much on union as much as the licensing .. require a license to practice and that'll cure the $12 hour BULL$

by decimumaximus

""what if I am superior in skills, efficiency, and even work ethic compared to most of my colleagues, and am compensated more because of it.""

Your probably not.. But lets think you are for now. How long do you think that will last? when your employer thinks he can get someone almost as good as you.. and alot less whiney for $12 an hour do you think he's gonna keep you. NO WAY!
unless you are that $12 hour guy...or is it $15 now? since your such a good boy! Fools like you are what a union wouldn't want and that scares you... oh by the way most of my family is in some sort of union and each one has great benifits, Awesome retirement, long vacations and doesn't have to worry about some snot nosed brat taking there job for 1/3 of what they get...
YOUR SCARED I understand... you could always go to flipping burgers... Mickey D's pays 60k to managers and I am sure that your superior skills will get you there... Good luck.. don't let the door hit your...............

by flowahpla

That's funny, but it isn't unions that put individuals with degrees in wood science "in charge" in charge of IT departments working for large multinationals.
However, it is unions that protect the individuals in these departments from uninformed and incompetent decision making with regard to IT staff, and services.

by vlpresher

First of all I grew up in poverty. I am where I am today becuase I was unwillingly to sit back and let some knucklehead feed me a bunch of lies.

If I can get ahead and then everyone else can to. Stop believing the lies passed on by the likes of Jesse (high)Jack(your company)son and get to work.

We have the standard of living we have today in America because of the opportunities we have here.

How many more people could be employed if Unions officials did not insist upon the unfair wages and benefits stolen from America's coprorations.
\

by sctang73

But I must say I can not help but synpathize w/ the author of the original post. Too many wannabe's out there in a world that does not give the IT world enough respect. We really should have some sort of way to properly "license" technicians out there... turn it into a "practice" of sorts, like a lawyer or a doctor. Certifications can & do help, but certs alone are never enough.

by cactus pete

Why should I pay you $50/hr if all I want from you is $12/hr worth? I don't care if you can solve the world hunger problem, if I need some cables run I'm not paying more than what it's worth.

If you won't do the job for what I'm willing to pay, I'll find someone who better fits.

If you DO have two degrees and over 40 certs, and you're unemployed, perhaps you won't mind spending a few hours at $12/hr running cables for me.

Your choice.

by cactus pete

You're making a lot of assumptions there.

I have great pay, long vacations, more than enough benefits, etc. Why do I need a union? A union would just cost me money and be another layer of bureaucracy.

by tonythetiger

"How long do you think that will last?"

As long as I continue to keep abreast of new methods and keep my skills sharp. If someone comes along and offers my employer more bang for the buck, more power to him. I certainly don't want to be kept around simply because I've been around.

"Fools like you are what a union wouldn't want and that scares you..."

The union doesn't want me because I make the others look bad. I don't catch the three-day flu (Friday, Monday, and Tuesday). The only thing scary about the union is that it forces employers to pay certain amounts to certain positions, regardless of how good the current holder of that position (ranging from outstanding to barely adequate). Because he has to pay the lazy ones as much as me, he can't afford to pay me more, and because the lazy ones have more seniority than me, he can't post a higher position lest the lazy ones bid on it.

"oh by the way most of my family is in some sort of union and each one has great benifits, Awesome retirement, long vacations and doesn't have to worry about some snot nosed brat taking there job for 1/3 of what they get..."

That's hilarious. I guess you should read my profile before comparing me to a snot-nosed brat. I've been working here for longer than the average poster here has been alive! and like I said, if some snot-nosed brat thinks he can beat me out of my job, he can just bring it!

(added: Oh, and when you need a job done around you home, do you shop around for price and references, or do you just automatically accept the guy that's been in business the longest? Why should your employer not be allowed to do that?)

If you think the company is "giving you" benefits, you're the fool. They don't just pull benefits out of their ass. They come from money they [b]could[/b] be paying you, and/or money they could be saving the consumers of their product or service (at least some of which are likely to be union memgers) by lowering prices. It's a shell game, and your family seems to have been suckered by it.

Oh, here, in case you missed it.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11181-0.html?forumID=6&threadID=190031&messageID=1959899