Discussion Locked

Unionize IT Now!

0 helpful
725 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 7 of the discussion. Read the opening post

725 replies

by julie.davis

I am so sick and tired of being treated like all of my education and experience is worthless. I am making way to little for what I had to go through. We IT people are being used and underpaid by the industry because of all the new wannabe's. It is hard enough being a woman in the field and getting employers to take you seriously. If we unionize and take the power back then we can demand the respect and pay our specialized field deserves. We are cosidered to be a dime a dozen and easily exchangeable. It is not a good feeling that is for sure.

by absolutely

Poor you, with your feelings. Your solution is too join a gang and extort money that your skills don't warrant. Pathetic!

by dusterman

You must have been raised in a very poor rural area , much like myself .
.
You,unlike myself, must have decided that you now make more money in a day than you made in a week in the past .......... you will roll over and play "dead" for all of the [ here we go ! ] COLLEGE EDUCATED IDIOTS ....... that took business classes and are now your boss .
.
Never mind that [ most of ] these educated morons have never actually owned a company let alone had the responsibility of loosing their job if they cause the company "harm" ........... these are the people that control the hiring and firing of we " supposedly lower class " technical worker bees.
.
It's scary to listen to a meeting going on of upper management [ working on a foo-bar computer ]while they discuss how to "riegn in" the growing technical trend that they can't control because they aren't educated enough to just fire anyone that doesn't meet "their" expectations ! ! ! No matter the reason , including the fact that they cut the IT budget and expect you to "find ways" to fulfill the needed responsibilities ... one tech I know [ just to fulfill his responsibilities ] pays for small items out of his own pocket !!!! and no he can not get reimbursed either !!!!!!
.
Me ....... I am tired of having to train the young executives on basic real world business .... ya know ...... like paying the smaller service/vendors , if not immediately , at least on time ! ! !
No the dragging out of the billing into the next month or quarter or cycle or eon ........ is NOT the way real business is done .......that is how "they" want you to do business so that "they" look good !
.
Sorry all ...... week from hell dealing with .......morons ! !!! !!! !!! !!! !!!
.
Oh please ........
I have to stop now and go earn a living !
.
As always .....
.
Keep on ........ keepin on

by 35rjt

You may think you've paid your dues.
The jobs need to go to the most qualified, and that doesn't always mean certified.
It's survival of the fitest and the unions are spitting into the wind.

by tony hopkinson

But we are all interchangeable. If you want to be indispensable set up your own business, with your own money and hire yourself. If you want to be successful you should regularly assess your own competence, and value to the business.

Your education and experience is worth what you get paid for it. That's it's only monetary value !

Setting some arbitrary value on it before the market has valued it, will just price you straight onto welfare.

Profit is income - expenses, not income - mysalary - expenses.

Wake Up !

by hangin_online

I am completly shocked that this bickering has continued for so long. It seems to me everyone is trying to make a case one way or another. Thats great, but most of it isn't even polite arguements. I have my opinion regarding Unions. However; I will not push them on anyone else. Some of this is just mean.
Reading through this discussion I am thinking that IT couldn't unionize because you can't even have a civil discussion in this forum forget about contract negotiations. I used to work as a Building Contactor before this field and I think discussions were a bit more civil with those men and women that some of you consider beneath you than this one is. Some of the EGOs here are absolutly apauling. Good luck to all of you in your endevors, whatever they may be. However, remember we are all human and if we all thought the same way and had the same opinions this conversation / forum wouldn't even exist.

by ontheropes

Hey TR!! You there?

How about an opinions tab? A visible to all, multiple choice box users can create and attach to a discussion to keep a running tally on pertinent points.

One click per user.

by tony hopkinson

What was it exactly ?

hmmm

maybe it wasn't that good at all

I have an opinion on it somewhere but I aren't going to tell you.

What a spoon.

S' good idea my the way if everybody but the poster says it meaningless non contrubutive drivel, pull it from the thread.

And all it's children of course, because there can't be anything more meaningless than having a discussion on how meaningless something meaningless is.

LOL

by aaron a baker

Unfortunately you're absolutely right. What should have been an intelligent conversation, regarding the pros and cons of Allowing Unions in, has degenerated to a child's fight with name calling,verbal abuse,insults, petty bickering.etc.
And if that isn't enough, people go way Off Topic to"Prove a point" which is usually neither here or there.
This could have and should have been and intelligent,stimulating and informative discussion, but all we needed was a few dunderheads who spend far too much time in their parents basement or in their bedrooms and this is what you get.
Instead of discussion, we get arrogance,crudity, vulgarism and above all greed and selfishness.
It is for this reason That I have abstained from any further comment, I don't like to fight, however I really do enjoy a stimulating and intelligent conversation, one laced with courtesy and forethought. The idea is to talk, not beat the hell out of one another.
Like you, I am repelled and disgusted and so, I shall continue to sit on the sidelines and maybe, just maybe,the TR people will take note and add this kind of crap to the list of things not tolerate.
Hang in there, it's bound to get better, I hope? :)
Warmest Regards
Aaron.

by codebubba

>> But for those of us that understand what real I.T. means, we're not the least bit worried about outsourcing because we perform REAL work that our clients can't possibly outsource no matter how much they may want to. <<

That's very well put. I think you hit the nail on the head there, especially to those who are worried bout outsourcing. The majority of the jobs that get outsourced are non-specialist jobs (IMHO). In my case, for example, I am the sole individual in our organization that completely understands the business-rules logic of our product. Can you "outsource" my knowledge? No way Jose'. Oh sure ... in a few years you might be able to get another developer trained to replace my knowledge but what do you do in the meantime? Am I worried about being "outsourced"? No way.

We tried to outsource the development of a key section of our application and it was a DISASTER. We had to rewrite most of it because the individuals in the Indian firm did not have the core knowledge of our product. (They were lousy coders to boot - but that's a different story).

This whole idea of "Unionization" of the IT field is driven (I believe) by individuals who either have not, or won't specialize and WORK to become valuable to a specific company or marketplace. If you just want to be a "code weevil" (I.E. ditch-digger) and don't really learn the business you are working in, then you're likely to be outsourced. Anyone (I mean, relatively speaking) can just write code (dig holes). You have to learn to figure out WHY you're digging the hole and learn how to dig said hole better than your competition.

-CB

by avid

unions are great when it comes to things like safety and working conditions. when it comes to "the right person for the right job" they are a joke. i have certs. but i have met a million "certified idiots" great at taking tests, no common sense. i am sure that bill would love unionization. it would make everyone take his tests every year and he could charge whatever he wanted for them. by the way, do you work for MS ? my next point is this. who are you going to unionize? just the large companies ? you can't force the small consulting firms to unionize. maybe the formation of something similar to the bar association would be more befitting. as for me. i own my own business now and do not really have to worry about it too much.

by the.erinyes

Based on your screen name you should get this.
The world pays for absolute value, not percieved value. If you cannot compete in the IT space, then it will be outsourced/offshored, as I said before functions (products, services) will always move to the low cost providers if the absolute value is the same.
So what is the strength of the IT market?
In a word: Innovation. We are the world leaders (still) in innovation and as long as we continue to innovate there will be IT jobs. The key is innovate or die!
When we try to retract and protect poor quality and lack of innovation, then the obvious will happen; the industry sector involved will move on where the absolute value is higher.
If you think otherwise, then now is the time to check your premises and reevaluate the situation!

by tonythetiger

That's a clarification.

The only people who [b]ought to[/b] know how much you make are you and your employer. How's that?

by tonythetiger

All it does is replace one set of boundaries with another, more restrictive one. Individuality is lost in the process. But I suppose if you can't be a sucessful individual, being a successful mob member is something.

by the.erinyes

Is this fantasy happening in Middle Earth? Are we wainting for the Return of the King?

NO good can ever come of collective endeavors no matter how well intentioned.

When the needs of the many are dominant over the needs of the few, it is the beginning of anarchy.

I wish to work for myself, not for everyone else.

If I decide to offer support to slackers or people in true need it should be my choice, not the choice of a politician!

by 50kilroy

May I presume that you _like_ living here in "Amerika"?
The U.S.A. was and is a collective effort.
Maybe you should get yourself out and head on over to France or Quebec or somewhere.
Noone has mentioned politicians as being part of a union. Unions are most definitely not a governmental body, they are, however, a good tool to help protect the worker from greed and bias.
Reference AK Steel in Ohio. Check their record and get back with us.
I.T. WORKERS UNITE NOW!

by apotheon

I guess that's not exactly "self-regulating" so much as being regulated by market forces. Still, the result is the same.

by tonythetiger

A bureaucracy's' first mission is to ensure the survival of the bureaucracy. Some in government think it is in their best interest to keep some people down, so that they will 'need' the government.

by tony hopkinson

Otyherwise known as the ME syndrome.
The same one that is driving US business's to outsource IT to other countries so there more profit for them.
What this does to your economy as a whole, the future of your economy or in fact the future, is immaterial when the guys in charge is 'I got mine F'U'

by tony hopkinson

management and businessmen. Not teh first port of call for ethics either.

Don't go mad, I'm a brit and the english word union and the american one are a tad different in meaning, and wildly different in historical context.

by tony hopkinson

Never heard so much crap in my life. Critical that we successfully address this issue. Go for world poverty, traveling faster than light, cold fusion or proving the existance of deity, at least you'll have a chance then.

I get paid as much as the person with the money values my effort. What the worker's committee thinks my value is compared to theirs is meaningless unworkable drivel.

Unions are NOT about me being paid the same as you they are about me and you being paid enough to live.

Your solution no more fits into the marketplace than the blind fool who suggested $50 an hour.

Get this straight I worked hard to get where I am, I aren't taking a pay cut so you can get more.

If you aren't valuable enough to your employer, move or make yourself so.

You want more money, earn it.

by absolutely

"You must have been raised in a very poor rural area , much like myself."

Whatever observations you used as basis for that conclusion, your application of logic was not good enough to lead you to the correct conclusion.

"you will roll over and play "dead" for all of the [ here we go ! ] COLLEGE EDUCATED IDIOTS ....... that took business classes and are now your boss ."

What is your basis for that incorrect assumption?

"It's scary to listen to a meeting going on of upper management [ working on a foo-bar computer ]...Blah, blah, blah"

You have let your fear get the best of you, and your assumptions are all incorrect.

Your excessive punctuation implies that you are the problem, not your peers. Exercise is good for reducting stress. I recommend it enthusiastically, and based on first-hand experience.

by raelayne

I'm really enjoying your posts. Itching for a fight, are you? God help you if any of these folks ever gets his hands on one of your computers.

What is your background, anyway? Other than avid Ayn Rand reader. (Obviously not rural -- not sure where that came from)

by absolutely

I'm Absolutely Serious. And that is all that you, or anybody else, needs to know about me or my background.

by absolutely

"A bureaucracy's' first mission is to ensure the survival of the bureaucracy. Some in government think it is in their best interest to keep some people down, so that they will 'need' the government."

Try asking yourself "why" about some of these silly facts you insist on spouting. Then ask yourself "is that right" and "can I think of a better way to accomplish the same goal, or a more worthy goal."

The next time I read one of your posts, will be the one whose title is "I decided to begin thinking".

by apotheon

Correct me if I'm wrong, but . . .

It looks like Absolutely said something, adunlap agreed with and expanded upon it, and Absolutely told him he wasn't thinking.

What did I miss?

by apotheon

The tech industries need not move geographically to move. The protectionistic industry practices have become so ingrained and narrowing that there is room for the software industry to recreate itself in the same problem-space, because what the software industry has become in its established form is so restricted and insular that it no longer addresses the relevant problem effectively.

Twenty years ago the software industry still shared some recognizable relationship to a (nonfree) market economy, and had some kind of passing acquaintance with natural economic laws. If things had reached these dire economic straits under such circumstances (and they would have, given time, if things didn't change), a complete removal of movers and shakers in the software industry from first-world Western economies, in any sense meaningful for we the "IT professionals", would have been inevitable.

Because the major software vendors have been "forced" to keep tightening their grips on their profit models at the expense of applicability of their productivity to the problem-space the industry is meant to address, the problem at hand has been left increasingly unaddressed. It is this that gave open source software an opportunity to flourish and grow as an alternative market influence, and it is this that provides a possibility to keep some effective software industry here at home. A competing market would otherwise have had to grow in alternative geographic zones, but because the competing market uses a wholly different profit model it can coexist (unpeacefully) in the same geographical markets. Because an industry based on open source development principles is more in line with natural economic laws, the only way the entrenched software industry will be able to compete against it is through governmental interference (legislation, et cetera).

Thus, the greatest threat to the IT industry job market and innovation in the US is legislation favoring tech industry corporations, such as software patents and further copyright protection legislation.

by the.erinyes

I agree. The incumbent software industry will give way to open source judt like the market moved from a mainframe centric view to a distributed view.

I believe the open source model is the future for IT and it will cause the proprietary providers to respond.

It is interesting that IBM is now a proponent of open source, because I believe it provides an avenue for them to break the MS software dominance.
What comes around goes around, since MS is exactly where IBM was in the 70's and 80's.
It will be an interesting future indeed however as you have stated software patents are a vile and evil thing and should not be allowed.

by maldain

Sorry, I needed a good laugh. First of all, the market sets the rates if the market place for network engineers has gotten too tight for you try changing specialties. I've been in this business since the late 1970's and I've gone from being an assembly language programmer, to COBOL programmer to C to DBA to Sysadmin/DBA for nearly 80 servers spread all over the North American continent. You either evolve or starve in this business. When you young pups flood into a field it's time for us old hacks to move to more current fields. Afterall, anybody coming out of school is about 3 years behind the times and should be working entry level jobs.

by bg6638

I perfectly agree that the idea of a union for IT workers is pure nonsense! The biggest problem is simply oversupply in a field that is rapidly maturing, and requiring far fewer personnel. Also, the idea of "entry level" jobs in IT is a misnomer! At a MINIMUM, you need a BS in CS/MIS,
5 yrs exp., virtually every cert offered by Citrix, Cisco, Msoft, and Redhat just to have an employer even consider your resume! When you have employers requiring a CCIE for a Help Desk I position, and prefer a Master's, you know that the workforce is oversaturated! That position should not require any more than an Associates with little or no experience.

by tonythetiger

... behind technology? To be able to get more done with less people? To give us humans more time to persue the intellectual and the artistic?

by absolutely

He is not presiding over a capitalist country. For decades, the 2 parties have been fighting over altruist collectivism (Democrat) and mystical collectivism (Republican). The Red Menace really screwed the political dialog in this country. I think communism is more of a danger now than it was in the 1960s because it's creeping, unnoticed, in the background, while "radical Islam" makes the headlines. Neither the Democrat nor Republican parties represent (consistently) the right to live for oneself and to own the product of one's own work, or any other principle of capitalism, either democratic or republican.

by peter warren

The most incompetent president of all time is in the white house. Does this mean we've gone over to the communists?

by absolutely

I should stop reading Miscellaneous at work. Sorry, adunlap, I read a couple of your other posts this afternoon, and should have addressed 'The next time I read one of your posts, will be the one whose title is "I decided to begin thinking".' to Boogaloodude, and thanked you for your agreement.

I'll do so now, while paraphrasing some words of Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.: those who have (unjust) power seldom relinquish it unwillingly. I advocate withholding value (boycott, strike) and not the threat of force (terrorism, war of aggression, mugging, and laws that assign excessive recognition to collectives, including corporations & unions) to achieve social & political goals.

by apotheon

I don't think he's the most incompetent. There have been some other truly, horrifically incompetent presidents. In fact, Bush has succeeded at quite a lot -- just not much that's all that good.

by raelayne

The point isn't who's responsible for the debacle. There's plenty of blame to go around. I have two questions (other than why am I sicking my nose into this NASCAR tail-gate party):

1. To paraphrase Dr. Phil on the ability of unions to protect workers: how's it working for them?

2. OK, short-sighted management was focused on short-ternm profits and lacked the imagination to compete. I'm assuming the unions were focused on creating better, more competitive products? Were the unions part of the solution to the problem then? Or were the unions self-serving as well, attempting to enforce a "keep doing it the way we've always done it" mentality that rewarded longevity rather than creativity and talent? That protected the status quo?

It reminds me so much of the teachers who bemoan the sorry state of education while fighting tooth and nail any attempt to reward results, quality, or talent.

I come from a union family and I understand the value of unions. But our unions are corrupt, self-serving organizations that stand in the way of growth and acheivement. It's a sorry thing.

by raelayne

Well, I mostly agree, although I think you over-state things a bit. Not everyone has the talent or starts out with the education and family support required to succeed in our "capitalism." In spite of our mythology, we don't really have a country in which everyone starts out with the same opportunities for success. Our idiot president is evidence of that. From a poor family, he'd be selling used cars. It's not all about hard work & inventiveness. [do I hear Ayn Rand in there?]

But ... anyone who chooses to be part of the business world, the world of commerce (we are, after all, a nation of shopkeepers), and does that expecting to be taken care of, is foolish indeed. If you're playing the game, know the rules. And yes "your skills will be obsolete someday if you fail to add new ones."

Your bluntness is refreshing, and besides, it provoked lots of comments!

by absolutely

Neither the Constitution nor the Wealth of Nations are based on the premise that all people have exactly the same opportunitites. The USSR, however, was.

"In spite of our mythology, we don't really have a country in which everyone starts out with the same opportunities for success."

[b]Our[/b] mythology? Are you writing from Cuba? China? North Korea?

by raelayne

This has been a hoot.

Lots of people who can't understand why their companies, their managers, the world isn't NICE to them. All they want is a good salary. They went to school. Why should they have to do anything else? [Ever notice how many of these posts seem to be done during the day, when people MUST be at work ...] I'm thinking maybe this is all fallout from the big self-esteem movement.

And the solution -- unions. Because unions are how the poor, powerless workers organize against the big powerful corporations. I do happen to support that notion, by the way. Organizing to gain power is a good thing.

But aren't IT guys professionals? Don't they have skills of value to the world, skills that are scarce, special, and in demand? Then why do they need to unionize? And I think the answer is kind of obvious -- the skills aren't scarce, special, or in demand anymore. So IT is no longer a profession; it's, as some have noted, now a trade.

That hurts. That makes people feel BAD. But nobody ever clawed his way back into a profession with a union.

Sorry you feel BAD. Sorry some people haven't been NICE to you.

God, we have it so damned easy in this country, we're so spoiled, and we're so on a downward spiral it scares me. We're alive, most of us have jobs, we eat, we have places to live, and we have so much free time we're hanging out online. And we're whining and carrying on about being under-appreciated.

by apotheon

Most of this "hanging out online" qualifies as research for me. I don't mean I mark it "research" in the "what I did today" column, but that I learn a lot that is applicable to my livelihood. In addition, I occasionally make business contacts, so aside from research it's also a bit like a business conference.

Granted, I haven't learned much from "IT UNION YES", but that nitwit isn't the only person posting here.

by peter warren

I agree. We need to defeat the corrupting influence of big money in government. Strict spending limits with completely transparent public financing of campaigns. And while we're at it, let's limit the length of our campaigns. One to two months is more than enough for a real discussion of issues.

As I've said elsewhere, blurring the lines between the US government and corporate America is costing all of us more and more each day. It's time to put the "corporate individual" back in its place.

by tony hopkinson

Classic management put down.

What did that shop floor oik say Tarquin ?

I have no idea Timothy, I could not understand his arcsent.

That's a deliberate mis-spelling by the way, and I believe it communicated my point admirably.

by absolutely

Election debates [b]avoid[/b] topics like competence, I don't know why. Because it would be rude? "Governor Bush, you barely pulled C's while taking the easiest classes available at your college. Why should we believe you understood what you were taught while your performance was barely mediocre? You weren't busy with work-study, were you?"

by x-marcap

I think that my 180 IQ and George may have had similar lower level acedemic success. I had 4.0 in Calculus at MIT, but my Poli-Sci D carries the same weight as the A's in Physics. (I disagreed with the moron who was teaching the class on everything.) The Philosophy D counts as much the Chem A does. Frankly until I found a good woman to share my life I pulled inconsistant grades myself.

Remember he came in sixth in the MBA class at Harvard. He isn't stupid, but when younger he was often drunk, and chased women. A fault I may have shared (Not the drinking, Alcohol isn't my vice.)

The guy isn't stupid, but people who underestimate him are. I think he is much smarter than he appears. Some of that is the slower speech pattern of the American Southland. His Spanish is better than my wife's Spanish, or my ex-brotherin law's spanish (Puerto Rican born and raised.)

He is competent, and has made many democrats look very stupid in the past. I see people still thinking he is stupid, but not seeing the signs of the good ol' boy who robs you blind. He is so stupid he is taking money from my pockets, not me taking money from his...

I only wish he'd listen to me for direction...

by tony hopkinson

It's vastly annoying to me that I have to basically agree with all you rabid capitalists.

The main reason I have to is because the opponents you are painting as socialists don't even start to meet the definition. Anyone in favour of sinecure's, closed shops, restrictive working practices etc is not a socialist, they are capitalist hypocrites.

Socialism is inclusive, it's about bettering the lives of all individuals, not a small minority who paid at the door.

The guy who started this thread off is a case in point. Many including myself the archetypal socialist tree hugger have jumped on his ass.
He wants $50 an hour, if the rest of us end up on $10 and have to blow our employers to get that much, he don't give one. Even worse he wants us to give him $10 a week of our $40 and vote for him so he can get his money and for us to feel happy about it.

Socialist my f'ass.

by apotheon

Background doesn't matter. What matters is the truth of your premises and the validity of your arguments. So far, you're doing pretty damned well in both categories.

by ontheropes

If they pull all of the non-contributive meaningless drivel from any meaningless discussions it would mean precluding any mean meaningless children from becoming more meaninglessly mean.
But, that would mean that posting meaningless non-contibutive drivel only to have it pulled by the poster would meaninglessly change the children that didn't mean to be posting meaningless drivel which would skew the posters thread by a mean average of .052%, by my latest PIFMA calculations.

There is no spoon.

by tony hopkinson

well on average anyway, somewhere about the mean which isn't the median and that has a different meaning, though the value itself could be meaningless dependant on the meaning.

Tee Hee

by absolutely

Date: Sat, 4 Mar 2006 21:41:21 +0000 (GMT)
X-Comment: Sending client does not conform to RFC822 minimum requirements
X-Comment: Date has been added by Maillennium
Received: from alias-3.c10-ave-mta2.cnet.com ([206.16.1.163])
by rwcrmxc14.comcast.net (rwcrmxc14) with SMTP
id <20060304214120r140061076e>; Sat, 4 Mar 2006 21:41:21 +0000
X-Originating-IP: [206.16.1.163]
Message-ID: <5217125.1141508480957.JavaMail.app@c10-btg-app1.cnet.com>
From: "theofficeconnection@juno.com"
To: "Absolutely"
Subject: Message from a TechRepublic Member
Mime-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/mixed;
boundary="----=_Part_7_28591553.1141508480954"
Content-Disposition: inline

------=_Part_7_28591553.1141508480954
Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1
Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit
Content-Disposition: inline

One of your fellow TechRepublic members has sent you a private message:

From: Dusterman
Subject: Hmmmmmmmmmmm
Message:
Something to hide ?
.
Unless you work for one of the "soup companies" you ain't that special .....
.
Don't get me wrong , you are probably , pretty "special" to your family ...
.
But to your friends here on this site ,,,,,,,,, you're just another tech.
.
And if you do work for the guvment ....... well that's just too bad .
.
But please let there be no mistake about me , I live , work and breath air here in Denver and am readily available to talk .........and learn :-)
.
As far as I know you've never done anything to deserve any rude or discourteouse [ sp ] jibes .......... so if anyone is badgering you , I will stand with you against these people ..... I do not tollerate people that "pick on" others ......... on the other hand ...... if you work for the guvment ..... well you are on your own ................sorry :-(
.
So anyhow , if you decide to block me I won't take it persoanlly .
.
As always ...............
.
Keep on .......... keepin on
.
Mike
------=_Part_7_28591553.1141508480954--

That entire message is off-topic & meaningless, but this appears to be the only thread in which Dusterman and Absolutely have both participated, so I invite Dusterman to explain the intended meaning of that rambling bunch of nonsense.

by dusterman

Who posted this or reviewed this message and under what jurisdiction did you do so.
.
You just violated my rights ............. and I want satisfaction ............
.
Please do not be a coward and shirk your need to take responsibility and stand tall here ........
.
I will offer you the option of a face to face meeting at which time I will demand a formal apology at the least or you can be the coward that you have been to this point and hide .
.
It is time to cease this conversation as I am now violated and will not rest until I have a form of satisfaction .............
.
Ok ?
.
Mike

by raelayne

Yes, of course, the argument stands on its own. The person who makes it does not add to or detract from its "truth" or validity.

However, the fact that a person is making a certain argument is interesting to me, so I was asking about background for that reason. Just curious. But never mind -- your response said enough.

I am not deadly serious, by the way. I was once, but gave it up for sanity's sake. Why in the world would you be arguing with this crowd except for fun? Do you really think anything could be accomplished?

by absolutely

I'll exercise frequently and eat a balanced diet.

If I wanted to have frivolous conversations, I'd seek the company of frivolous people and discuss frivolous topics, not ideas that have proven to destroy entire industries when enacted.

If the serious tone here troubles you or challenges your sanity, you're welcome to leave and never return. Maybe you'd prefer the Friday Yuk, for example. Some people whose serious opinions I respect also contribute some very amusing anecdotes there, although they also contribute some horrendous trash there, and I prefer not to visit regularly.

In short, you are free to read, or ignore, whatever you like, and to treat it as seriously, or as frivolously, as you prefer. I have exactly the same options, including the right to take my own life and the issues affecting it, absolutely seriously. You have no right to change my attitude, however much it bothers you.

That's final.

by dilbert9

The AMA may set recommended fee's but they don't have an influence on what the doctor actually gets paid. His actual payment is set by his contract with the insurer which sets his rate at a small percentage over what the govenment pays for that procedure under Medicare. The doctor can bill the insurance company any amount he wishes but he will have to write off the difference between what the insurance company pays plus the copay and deductible paid by the patient. The only thing he accomplishes by raising his fees far above the rate paid by insurance companies is to artifically inflate his AR on his books.

Doctors are not really hurting but their income has dropped compared with the inflation rate over the past 20 years while the CE and malpractice insurance premiums have increased dramatically.

by dilbert9

And it's equally as difficult for someone in India to fix your database server problems when the machine that holds the data won't even power up. That's just one example. I have a thousand others I can give you where the person doing the work has to be on-site.

I totally agree. As a IT "generalist" with a small medical software company, around 60% of my calls can be handles with a phone call or a Logmein Rescue session but there ate those 40% that require hands on access. My advice is to find a small, growing comany that needs your skills and you will find that not only the pay rate will exceed what the more structured scales in a larger operation will pay but you will have more freedom and job satisfaction than being a faceless droid in a huge company. The one drawback of a smaller operation is fewer benefits like health insurance or 401K contributions but less stress and more job satisfaction makes it worth the trade off.

I retired in my 40's from a trade (electrical and control technician) with a strong union tradition because I was tired of all the union BS. Too many deadwood "workers" whose primary job duty was hiding until lunch or time to go home, depending on those of us who actually enjoyed working to carry their sorry a**. Since I was much "too old" by most IT standards I decided to stick to the small mom and pop companies. Not only did I weather the dot-bomb bust but I prospered through it. I just passed my tenth year in my current position.

by jeffin90620

If you want to see what would happen to IT, just look at the decline of the Automobile and Steel industries. GM is teetering on the edge of bankruptcy because their costs (mostly due to union contracts, including health care for retirees) do not allow them to compete.

The steel industry union gets good wages, but can survive only so long as protectionist legislation is maintained (Bush surprised many by signing an extension a couple years back, but continued tariffs are not guaranteed). And the price of that protectionism is borne on the backs of American consumers, most of whom do not work in IT, so the only way to guarantee their support is to protect them, too. The problem with that is when we increase protectionism for our people, other governments do the same. When that happens, our exports go down, leaving less money to pay those $50/hr salaries you think you deserve.

Europe has a lot of the characteristics that make union leaders here drool (limited work weeks or good overtime rates, long vacations, cradle-to-grave health care, near-impossibility to fire, etc.); they also have unemployment two to five times that of the United States and economic growth of 1-2% (which will not be maintained if they start meeting the pollution limits specified in the Kyoto Accords by buying credits from Russia, as is the current plan).

I would suggest reading the works of economists Dr. Walter Williams and Dr. Thomas Sowell, both of whom do a much better job than I of explaining the results of protectionism on economies around the world.

by peter warren

The new standard 2006 Ford Fusion got the lowest side impact safety rating, and only an acceptable front impact safety rating from the Insurance Institute for Highway Safety http://www.nytimes.com/aponline/business/AP-Crash-Tests.html?_r=1&oref=slogin.

I guess the senior Ford management team will be taking a hefty pay cut for producing yet another flawed standard product for the non-luxury market. It must have been that their collective brains were fixated on those terrible unions who are raping the poor American auto industry with a desire for high pay and decent benefits.

I agree that union leadership is far from perfect or innocent, but while we?re all trashing the concept of strength through numbers, let?s give the dunderheads running American businesses their fair share of the responsibility. American CEOs are typically being paid 500 times more than the average employee working for them. On average, that?s 22 times what their counterparts make in Japan and 17 times what their counterparts earn in Europe. (http://www.beggarscanbechoosers.com/2005/04/ceo-pay-soared-in-2004-as-us-economy.html.)

If the justification for this disparity is the terrible weight of responsibility these people have to bear, then let them bear it. The other reasons offered, like creating jobs, increasing shareholder value and dynamic performance certainly don?t apply here.

Union bashing is just another way for us to avoid looking at the serious problems faced by American business and American labor. And empty rhetoric from the US administration and US Congress about free markets, the need for education, the American spirit of ingenuity and competition do not begin to address the problem. Unfortunately for all of us, emptiness is the major characteristic of our current leadership. We don?t need more PR; we need strong, intelligent and open-minded leadership, in business, in labor and especially in Washington DC.

by delaaguilerae

Most people don't know that it was the Unions the ones that gave us the WEEKEND. Years ago you were lucky to get Sundays off.

by pkr9

You forget one of the major points in 'unionizing'. If your job is outsourced, the unionized employees of THAT company will object, and your job will stay where it is.

Unionizing will give you - the employee - the same power as business owners have.

by apotheon

Sure. 'Cause unions are strong in India.

Oh, wait, no they aren't — and they won't be in any way helpful to us in our working lifetimes.

by 50kilroy

I _do_ work for a "major corporation". It has over 10,000 employees, over 200 sites worldwide, and a multi-billion dollar bottom line.
That's pretty major.
They also pay their I.T. people like entry level "hi-skoolers"....no, worse that that.
Average in our dept (for those who actually do something) is $30k. Manglers, otoh, are making 6 figs. The dept mangler is knocking down $250K, and is not now, nor has she ever been, a computer or I.T./MIS person of any kind. She is, by education, a musician but she does possess an MBA which makes her worth a 1/4 million.
right.
She is also the worst user we have, can't even turn on her laptop..I'm not joking. She doesn't know where the power switch is, just puts it into hibernation by closing the lid.

by 50kilroy

I've been working with computers as a professional since 1975. I've worked with ac, digital mainframe, personal computers such as TI99, Commie, TRS-x series, Apple, MAC, Big Blue, the clones, printers since then, O/S from DOS 2.0, Windows from v1.0 thru XP, Novell, Unix, Posix, Linux, Apple O/S thru O/S-X. I've set up Token-ring and Ethernet on thinnet networks and on twisted-pair, wireless, VOIP in 1889, ..... Yeah, I can do his job. Twice.
Born wealthy? Fine. Just don't tell me that you have built a 100kilobuck lab like you _need_ it. That's just bragging. The best computer lab in the universe won't help an induhvidual who doesn't know what he is doing or who hires it done by professionals and then claims the credit.

by apotheon

What is this "digital mainframe" nonsense? Mainframes are computers, and are all thus "digital" by definition. Are you making up terms to try to impress us with your knowledge? There is no operating sytem by the name "Posix" -- the term POSIX refers to a standard of OS behavior, and it's a standard developed from UNIX.

There are definitely instances where a business needs a $100k computer lab. If you're not aware of this, you're not paying attention.

by delaaguilerae

I have a Union and I am an hourly employee anything beyond normal hours is overtime pay for me. The engineers complain that Techs get a bigger paycheck because they aren't Unionized. Sometimes I have come close to doing 40hrs OT in a week.

by tonythetiger

There are those who get favor based on who they know. Human nature is a thorn in the side of all 'isms'. :)

by apotheon

I'd say "especially", not "even". Especially in Socialism, who one knows helps to determine one's conditions. Socialism relies on bureaucracy, and bureaucracy is effectively synonymous with corruption.

by ralford100

Perhaps, all of the Analogs got together to form a union, but then they couldn't get any work done efficiently so the Digitals took over. Ya think?

by 50kilroy

Thanks Ralford100. I couldn't have said it better. Our friend, Apotheon, has ignored the entire genre of analog computing. I will reiterate that I have indeed worked with analog mainframe computers. Computer does NOT equal 'digital'. His nitpicking extended _almost_ to my error in that post..I, due to fatfingering, ran VOIP in 1889, a hundred years earlier than I did. He also seems to think that while POSIX is not an O/S (he's right), that Windows _is_ an O/S (he's wrong. Windows is a shell;always has been, always will be. No matter what M$ says about it)
O well. I guess a noob needs that kind of thing.
As for a business needing a .1Mbuck computer lab, why? Are they designing VLSI? Are they running a server farm? Are they running a credit reporting agency?
A 'puter lab of that magnitude is just ridiculous for a common mfg, var, retailer, or warehouser.
for a bit of history:
My first job in 'computing' was to fetch the patch cables for the programmer while he set up equations on the AD/5. The AD/5, I believe, qualifies as one of the analog mainframes on size alone, if nothing else.

by apotheon

Hm. I spoke hastily. I should not have said that all computers were digital: I should have said that the default of computers is to be digital, and thus referring to a mainframe as "digital" is superfluous, redundant, and very strange. Your reference to working on "digital mainframes" indicates to me that you probably haven't, since nobody I've ever run across who worked on mainframes referred to them as "digital mainframes". They've only made reference to the model (AS/400, for instance).

The application of electric/electronic analog computing is and always has been an extremely rare thing, so unless you're contrasting your mainframe work with using a sliderule (a mechanical analog computer), you sound like someone who's slinging jargon without knowing what he's talking about.

"[i]I will reiterate that I have indeed worked with analog mainframe computers.[/i]"
Reiterating would require that you'd iterated once before. Since you hadn't, you're talking out of your arse.

"[i]I, due to fatfingering, ran VOIP in 1889[/i]"
It was obviously a typo. I'm not that petty, and there were better targets to address in your statements.

"[i]He also seems to think that while POSIX is not an O/S (he's right), that Windows _is_ an O/S[/i]"
Funny, on one hand you're saying I didn't identify any actual problems in your post, and on the other hand you're agreeing with one of my statements of the problems in your post. Stop contradicting yourself. Meanwhile, the various Windows releases are indeed OSes: an OS includes the operation of the interface. Would you say that Solaris (for instance) isn't an OS because you have to interact with it through a shell? Windows includes everything from the interface down to the kernel. Windows, these days, does [b]not[/b] run on a DOS kernel -- it runs on a Windows kernel. You're trying to split hairs, and you just end up cutting off your fingers instead.

By the way, ralford100 sounded to me like he was ridiculing you. Do your reading comprehension skills really lack so badly that you couldn't figure that out?

Why don't you provide us with some kind of link to something related to this AD/5 on which you worked? I'd like to see that.

by 50kilroy

that those who are against unionizing are not about to be swayed, so I will stop trying.
Have a nice life.

Never try to teach a pig to sing. It just annoys the pig and frustrates you

by the.erinyes

The most recent Foote "IT Insider Professional Salary Survey" and "Hot Technical Skills and Certifications Pay Index" (4Q2005 editions) specifically identify numerous Windows-related management titles and salaries (all numbers listed below describe compensation, expressed in rounded thousands as $77K for $77,000.)

Note: The Foote numbers below denote averages taken from 63 different major U.S. metro areas. They describe half of the IT population that earns a median salary plus-or-minus 25%; thus, a range of $25K to $50K means that half of all professionals in that job or specialty earn salaries in that range. The numbers define base pay only, so when you add in other pay components, the numbers increase. (Certification Magazine numbers report total annual pay.)

VP/Director, NT Systems Engineering ($130K to $158K)
Manager, NT Systems Engineering ($99K to $118K)
Director, Information Security ($109K to $140K)
Manager, Information Security ($88K to $117K)
VP/Director, Enterprise Infrastructure ($117K to $157K)
VP/Director, e-Commerce ($120K to $167K)
Director, Web Systems ($107K to $146K)
Manager, Web Systems ($89K to $120K)
In the realm of the technical, a number of specialization titles rise to the top of the salary charts and again are likely to confer six-figure yearly earnings on those who practice them. In the list below, the numbers from the Foote report are marked f, those from Certification Magazine are marked c:

Senior Information Security analyst (f, $73K to $100K), especially for holders of information security-related certs such as CISSP (c, $105K to $115K, with add-ons such as ISSAP or ISSMP) and CISM (c, $106K)
Senior Storage/SAN Administrator (f, $84K to $108K), especially for those who hold Brocade (c, $89K to $108K, depending on credential held) or SNIA certs (c, $66K to $99K, depending on credential held). Though hard evidence isn't available for all storage-related certs, anecdotal evidence suggests strongly that competency in Hewlett-Packard, IBM, Dell Inc., McData Corp., EMC Corp. and other storage systems pay in the same general range. (This applies to the next item as well.)
Storage/SAN Administrator (f, $64K to $94K)
Senior Infrastructure Engineer (f, $76K to $95K) especially the CCIE (c, $104K) which continues to hold exceptional value and name recognition
e-Commerce Project Manager (f, $84K to $107K)
What the numbers mean
Interestingly, both studies show strong correlations between well-developed project management skills and pay. The Certification Magazine study shows fairly high average annual pay of $96K for those with the Project Management Professional (PMP) certification. That indicates a maturing IT marketplace and that those who possess both hard technical skills and soft skills are in growing demand, with pay to match.

What these numbers don't say is what skills and titles are on their way up and what's going down. Foote's statistical analyses show that demand for information-security related skills is flattening out and even slowing, now that most companies have met Sarbanes-Oxley compliance goals and information security hiring and implementation goals have settled down. Interestingly, both studies indicate a recent resurgence in Web and e-commerce developer jobs, which may mean that the last vestiges of the Internet boom and bust at the turn of the century are over. Foote's trends analysis shows strong interest in database positions and in .NET-related developer jobs, as more companies ramp up Windows-based development efforts in the wake of last November's release of the .NET Framework 2.0, Visual Studio 2005 and SQL Server 2005.

Another phenomenon lurks amid these salaries and hiring trends -- namely, a need for professionals to broaden their perspectives as they climb higher on technical or management ladders. Though an exclusive focus on Windows may work well for IT professionals in entry- to mid-level career positions, increasing one's knowledge and understanding of the Linux/Unix and mainframe worlds becomes more important the higher up the food chain one goes. Foote analysts opine that basic administrators and developers can prosper modestly in the Windows world, but moving into senior-level and management positions inevitably brings a need to master other platforms, technologies and whatever development environments apply.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR:
Ed Tittel is a freelance writer who specializes in information security , IT certification, and markup lanaguages. He created the Exam Cram series, has contributed to over 130 computer books, and writes regularly for numerous TechTarget Web sites. E-mail Ed at etittel@techtarget.com.

by jkowolf

If I can create a program that could save the trouble of hiring one minimum wage employee, my value is the biggest piece of this savings I can negotiate. I don't care if it takes me 5 minutes or 5 months to code.

by jardinier

This is the first instance I recall of an IT union threatening strike action in Australia.

Sydney Morning Herald, March 10, 2006 - 3:48PM

Computer technicans are threatening chaos at fast-food outlets, supermarkets, banks and airports unless they get a pay rise.

More than 100 staff from NCR - a company responsible for repairing computer breakdowns at KFC outlets, Aldi supermarkets and Sydney Airport's baggage handling systems - are planning to to walk off the job on Monday morning.

"In terms of industrial action in the IT industry this is easily the most significant one we've had in Australia," said Australian Services Union secretary Sally McManus. If the strike goes ahead, it might last up to a week, she said.

"If you are Qantas and people can't get on planes, it's an enormous amount of money. For the banks, it's really the consumers who'll be affected.

"For KFC and Aldi supermarkets, if the cash registers are broken down it's going to cause delays," she said.

However, NCR area general manager, Noel Pettitt, said the ASU was exaggerating the potential effects of the proposed industrial action.

"I think that's a gross exaggeration," said Mr Pettitt. "I don't think it's a major concern for the community.

"If [the strike] does happen, and at this stage it's not certain, we have contingencies in place that will ensure that NCR continues to meet its service obligations," he said.

"We've re-jigged our workforce and arranged things such that we'll certainly deal with priority calls in the first instance but continue to deal with the balance of calls."

Mr Pettitt said the union had exaggerated how many workers would take part in the industrial action.

The strike has been called following a breakdown in negotiations over pay, Ms McManus said.

"[The workers] are concerned that NCR is attempting to stonewall so they can use the Howard Government's new WorkChoices laws to cut away at wages and conditions. These workers do not want to inconvenience the public, but have no option to achieve pay increases."

Mr Pettitt said: "We continue to work directly with our employees to reach a conclusion to the negotiations."

The union said their industrial action could affect:

- baggage handling and ticketing technology at Sydney Airport

- regional ATMs across Australia

- ATMs operated by CBA, Westpac, ANZ and some credit unions

- IT systems for Wollongong University

- KFC outlets

- Aldi supermarkets

- public schools with Apple computers

- private companies with Dell computers

by peter warren

Thanks for the info on IT worker activity in Australia. The results of IT workers fighting back should be instructive. Do you have any more info on the issues?

by delaaguilerae

I am a Union member and activist, I wish I could give some advise but I don't know the Labor Laws Down Under. However am in solidarity with any attempt by workers to get better wages and treatment.

by ebeck

This is quite a long active post. I'll apologize for not reading all responses and if so, for being redundant. I want my opinion in here.
I feel for you. I've been there in the ERP world wathcing as rates went from near $300/hr for gurus down to $40/hr in some places. That is called a lifecycle though. Unions are a thing of the past, that now do nothing more than bleed entities dry.
What happens when your career goes up, you now manage these union employees, and want to change the rules/roles/workload or terminate them for performance issues? Have you ever sat in any union negotiation or dispute case (if so great - just asking)?
No - what we need is to keep educating management to seek quality resources, and weed out the ones that don't cut it. I've seen my share of hacks, but while I hate competing with them in the marketplace, I'd hate even worse how difficult it would be to get rid of one if he was on board and in a union.
Just my $.02.

by fnm48

I am a member of Nabet (National association of broadcast employees and technicians)a Broadcasting union. I firmly believe in "Unionization". However, I still feel, that if you ask for too much, (at first) you'll turn people off and drive buisness to "India" or other foreign countries.First, establish the Union, then gradually, increase your demands(when your sure you can get the leverage you need).
Also, in todays "anti-union" atmosphere(thank you mr Regan)be careful, that the members will back you with a "walkout" if necessary !

by navy moose

Don Regan was the Secretary of Treasury. The President was Ronald Reagan.

Learn to spell it.

by decimumaximus

Unions are too hard to create successfully
there is just too much controversy.

What we need is licensing. Simple easy to roll out and cuts out the riff raff. Look at electricians for example not all of them are union but all of them are licensed.
keeps the hacks out and let them make a honest wage.

by davemori

I've seen more negatives with unions than positives, and there are no guarantees in a free market economy. A masters degree and certifications does not guarantee anything, and neither does a union.

Having a union has not guaranteed airline pilots and workers salaries stay at previous high levels. They have had to take pay and benefits cuts for some years to stay employed. In the case of IT, a $50 across the board minimum is simply going to drive executive leadership over to more outsourcing. This is very much an internet world, now, and corporate servers as well as the help desk or the NOC can just as easily be physically located in India, Spain, China or any other place. There are people there capable of doing at least just as good a job or good enough a job as someone here -- and they are very satisfied making $12,000/year.

Outsourcing happens when business leadership gets unhappy with the performance of IT and the cost of IT. When an IT department dictates too much to its corporate users, and when it fails to keep promises and when it is perceived as costing too much, it is ripe for outsourcing.

Business users figure that if they are already getting lousy service out of IT, and if they already have a bad, adversarial relationship with IT, they may as well outsource IT and at least have a relationship that is cheaper that stands some chance of being better or no worse than the bad relationship that they already have.

When IT people complain about outsourcing, it is time to look in the mirror and see how their own attitudes and relationships and service level performance contributed to the decision.

Business users are not always right, but they are also strong allies, not adversaries. A professional manager has to learn to only do battle where it really matters the most, and to always push to live up to schedules and promises.

When business users have a good relationship with their IT department, outsourcing doesn't stand a chance.

by pitairis

unions like all man made institutions are only as good as the members. a union will give some protection against these greedy corporations. remember united we bargain divided we beg.jim

by psifiscout

I have never nor will I ever work in a Union shop. My son works in one now and his non stop headaches dealing with incompetence that is protected by union rules is unbeleivable. Also other members of my family have worked for unions run operations in the past, I see little benefit of a union that votes to strike then charges 'union dues' so they can tell you you aren't allowed to work. Unions are nothing more than one more layer of bureaucracy between the worker and his paycheck.

by it survivor

It's said that the people in this country dont remember the time when all working class men and women were exploited by business and the wealthy. Those who refuse to remember their history are bound to be exploited by that lack of historical understanding. You have only to look at the stock market and the wealthy to see how so few have taken some much from so many with little or no effort at all. Dont get me wrong I'm not again anyone making good money but is any CEO really worrth 600 times the normal man or woman working today ?

by it survivor

I just wanted to say that I am finally glad to see a posting of someone who (appears) to be old enough to remember. Most of these posting seem to be from the 20-30 something crowd who hasnt been initiated by Big brother yet. Just wait all you who spit on unions and think that the free market is the next comming of Christ. Youf get a a chance to see first hand when the free market chews you up and craps you out.

by it survivor

Please your response doesnt even warrent a rebuttal. Bad english ? Just read what you have written and you'll find the perfect example.

by it survivor

Remember that the next time your company calls your IT group into a meeting and says OH by the way you've been outsourced. Good Luck.

by it survivor

Close mouth and engage brain. Liberal or Conservative ? Just words that divide. Think first then speak.

by it survivor

Let me buy you that ticket to India so you can make what your really worth to the IT industry in the good old USA