Discussion Locked

Unionize IT Now!

0 helpful
725 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post

725 replies

by richard

I looked at you bio and you may do ok, but your history doesn't look as smart as you write.

We'll see how you do in the long run.
If I were you I'd remove the printer setup experience, it pulls down your value.
I have more then a dozen current certs, $100k in my computer lab, my education budget is 10-15k each year. My first career was building buildings, small business (50 employees). I had 19 yrs in a Union. I've been building networks for 15 years, No Union. I am sure, you are benifiting from unions now and you need a union to help you future and more so, the future of you sons and dauthters.
I can hold a job, I am an over achiever, I have my retirement made. I would be very happy to join an IT union.

by 50kilroy

Not with a hundred kilobuck computer lab and such a large edu budget. You must have been born independently wealthy.
I work for a multi-billion dollar international company which has over 10,000 employees yet we do not have a lab like that. We get along very well with quite a bit less and include software and hardware testing for upgrades and new applications.
Printer setup and customization, btw, is one of the very skill that we need (and thus require) in our technical support staff. Why would printer skills/experience lower one's value?

by absolutely

expecting CEO pay for entry-level ability. Don't [b]you[/b] think your [b]inability[/b] figures into the equation? When there is more competition for chief executive positions, meaning more people qualified to do that work, then the market will drive their salaries down. Until there is enough qualified competition, nobody has stepped up to put a cap on their salaries.

by paolo2k6

Where all used to corporate and technical migrations so why not techie migrations! if we all went to the place cities that have the highest salaries and stayed until they became depressed, we'd all make money because even Iowa would pay a premium to get us back!

by 50kilroy

Sorry, that just won't work. There are too many MCSE paper tigers out there. As sure as a qualified person leaves, a "hi-skooler" will take his place at dirt wages.
The employers DO NOT CARE. Most see I.T. as a necessary evil and outsource as soon as possible anyway.
The only way for us to get justice is to form a nationwide union, institute picket lines (which other unions will not cross), and negotiate for fair treatment and apprenticeship/journeyman/master requirements to work as I.T.

I.T. WORKERS UNITE!

by ralford100

Good idea! Then, if EVERYBODY in the nation joins a union, we can adopt the hammer and sickle as our logo! We'll call it Amerika.. Who needs capitalism anyhow.. communism works great.. right?

And, for those who don't join our union, we'll call them "scabs", yell at them, insult them, THROW stuff at them, and sometimes, we'll push them around a bit (it's for the greater good!)

In order to keep our union strong, we'll make sure we extend our projects by "accidentally" losing files. We'll plant bugs in our software; and defects in our hardware so that we'll be needed to fix them. Perhaps get OT for it too!

We'll form a committee to decide who can become an apprentice, and how much we can extort from them; uh.. I mean how much they'll have to pay.

Yup.. what a wonderful idea you have.

by paolo2k6

Firstly check to see if your union would gain any lawful recognition and isnt covered by some office & general workers union or the telecomms unions like here in the UK. Two toothless tigers if there ever was such a thing!

by scifiman

You can't bring executive pay into the discussion. Their pay, bonus's, etc. are NOT market driven. And if you'll look into it, only a percentage of them earn their huge pay. It's an entirely different game at that level, and has nothing to do with pay for performance. Plenty of them get increases and golden parachutes as they drive a once profitable company onto the rocky shore.

by noyoki

I have never worked in a company large enough to have CxO's, so I need to ask... What exactly is it that they do? How does one get to be a CxO?

From the little I know, they sit around and do nothing... I'll take my nitty-gritty tech job over that any day...

by jamesrl

I'm not one, but I work day in and day out with them.

Trust me, they don't do nothing. I've never seen a lazy one last more than a year or two. A CxO must deliver or perish like a salesperson. I have read a few articles about how fragile life as a CIO is - how quickly they are terminated.

The basics of the job is to help achieve the corporate goals - reduce costs, increase revenues, etc. They have to bring departments and divisions with differing goals together. They have to arrange the marriages of strategic partners.

I have no hesitation in saying the ones that I know work harder than I do. Typically they put in 10 hour days and are available to their peers anytime. A lot of what it takes are influence skills, time management skills, communications skills.

How do you get there? You have to have a track record of delivering on those corporate goals, and you have to be able to work with the bigger team - the president, board of directors, vendor partnerships etc. You must have great networking and communications skills.

James

by absolutely

That means, an entirely different market, not the absence of a market. I stand by the opinion that if more people were qualified to compete for those jobs, competition would have the same effect as it has on any market.

by whiteknight_

This discussion reminded of this great old song, thought I'd share the lyrics for our younger members.
-------------------------------------
PART OF THE UNION
(John Ford / Richard Hudson)
The Strawbs

Now I'm a union man
Amazed at what I am
I say what I think that the company stinks
yes I'm a union man

When we meet in the local hall
I'll be voting with them all
With a hell of a shout it's out brothers out
And the rise of the factories fall

Chorus

Oh you don't get me I'm part of the union
You don't get me I'm part of the union
You don't get me I'm part of the union
Till the day I die, till the day I die

As a union man I'm wise
To the lies of the company spies
And I don't get fooled by the factory rules
Cause I always read between the lines

And I always get my way
If I strike for higher pay
When I show my card to the Scotland Yard
This is what I say

chorus

Before the union did appear
My life was half as clear
Now I've got the power to the working hour
And every other day in the year

So though I'm a working man
I can ruin the governments plan
Though I'm not too hard, the sight of my card
Makes me some kind of superman

Chorus

by 50kilroy

Where in the world did you find the lyrics? I haven't heard that in years.

BTW, your'e management, aren't you?

by whiteknight_

yes, I loved this song, thought it was funny.
Tried management years ago, did OK but determined my main strength was technical ability so back down to the ranks I went.

by sirlanse

The Detroit auto industry has collaped under
the weight of unions. If you want to speed up
the exodus of IT to India and China, go ahead
and join a union. Otherwise, do good work,
bust ass, go to that interview and when they
tell you $12, laugh in thier faces and walk out.
"There is not enough money to do it right the first time, but there is always enough to do it over."

by raelayne

The bottom line is this: these skills are no longer scarce or new. As many have pointed out, newbies just out of school have the most current skills, and they are cheap. And willing to work long hours. And a bunch of stuff is automated now. So we all have to live with the fact that skills or knowledge that used to make us really special and valuable is no longer either. Companies can get folks to do it for $12 an hour, so that's what "it" is worth. This isn't peculiar to IT; when H&R Block and TurboTax came on the scene, tax lawyers and accountants lost out. When Travelocity appeared, travel agents went out of business. Magazines and newspapers are going out of business because people get their news online. People can copy and share music online, so record companies are out of business. Trappers moved on when the wildlife was all gone ...

Sit around and talk about the good old days or move on. It's pretty straight-forward, I think. And it doesn't mean that what you did wasn't valuable, or that IT is unimportant today. It just means that things have changed. We can change, too, or we can sit around and wonder what the heck happened. And we'll have become the cranky old people we used to make fun of when we were young ...

by cslape9

I would dare say that you have an "uninformed" view of how thing "really" are.

Us OLD IT PEOPLE are not useless things to be tossed aside because of the newer things that have come along.

I think you have no respect for the elder IT people, who have paid the price of losing their families, friends and so on in order to be on top of their game.

Employers of years ago took advantage of our knowledge and skills, not paying us more for what we have learned on our own, on our own time away from work.

Though I don't get to use alot of the old style DOS commands anymore (because of Windows and Linux), I still remember them as plain as the day I did learn them. It is not that they are out of date if you will, its just that people don't use that kind of hardware anymore. But, once in a while, we find one of these systems around and it may need a tweak or two.

Anyone can teach a monkey to push a button or in this case, take an IT A+ or MCSE test, but without hands on experience and working knowledge of the material covered, its as useless as the paper its printed on.

My original suggestion was to ditch the CERTIFICATIONS in favor of returning to the old feudal system of Apprenticeships. At least this way, the Apprentice would be watched and observed and credentialed by a Master in the skills taught.

by larry,

Excellent post, raelayne.

Artificial price and wage supports never work well. Supply & demand aspects of economics and market forces are tough for anything or anyone to stand against, including unions.

One of the few constants in history is change. The I/S industry, like all industries, is changing and people must adapt. But remember, people had to adapt when steam drills, bulldozers, and robotic assembly machines took their jobs. In the end, old jobs often become obsolete and low-paying, while new, higher paying jobs are created. To try to stop this natural progression by creating new unions would be akin to a beaver trying to stop the flow of the Mississippi River.

Larry

by wildbear63

Sorry -- I have been in several unions (non-IT related) and I don't care for them. PLUS -- the only thing a cert proves to me is that you can study and memorize. The majority of the Microsoft certified IT people I have met don't know the real meaning of support and couldn't fix a Windows problem without the study manual in one hand. Oh -- and by the way -- I CAME INTO THE IT FIELD WITHOUT A CERTIFICATION. I feel that to learn this best is in the school of crash and burn -- not listen and learn. Training and studying help but they are NOT key. Attitude means a lot in holding down any job.

by tony hopkinson

are a management con !
First one I did I couldn't get full marks in any category because then I wouldn't have any reason to improve !

Not even for my attendance which was 100% !, damn lying cheating swindling f***wits.

Aside from that promotion of mediocrity is endemic in places where unions have a lot of control. As you say one member is as valuable as another, so they want them all to keep their job.
When this dead wood has seniority, its very hard to get on.

Course entrenched deadwood is not soley a problem for unionised shops otherwise I would have stopped running into it years ago.

by sjohnson175

Not just no but HELL NO.

I'll fight the anti-individualistic unions until my dying breath.

If you want to be worth no more than the slackest person in your job then go the union route.

by dsabbott

Not! I believe that the conceptual intent of unions is a good one. But I also believe that unions are a very very bad idea for practical reasons.

I have worked with many corporations on both the large and small scale. I have also worked within the realms of Government and Education. The absolute worst scenarios I have been put into were all created over time by incompetent managers. Technology moves fast, some people move slow. Unionized IT departments have been the worst off because of their unwillingness to change themselves or care about THE USERS OF THE NETWORK! They always feel "safe" even when things are falling apart around them. The unions ability to hinder the ongoing training and/or the removal of incompetent individuals really brings the efficiency of a technology department to its knees. A technology department needs to be a system not unlike the ones they are responsible for where the slowest links are constantly being upgraded. You have to be able to accept anything that is thrown your way in order to do anything with it. (Like each actor does on the comedy show "Whose Line Is It Anyway?" - Think about it!)

Although I have met many people that are good at this and some of them work in unionized places, I have never even heard of a union that would conform to the concept of fast and efficient people removal. (And if the person truly was really good at their job, they won't have any problem at all finding a position with a better company!)

by mc68000

"I currently work for a company that uses outsourced IT support in Malaysia and India, and our support it has been an absolute nightmare when dealing with them. No local support for this infrastructure has proved problematic, and as the industry sees issues the whole setup will change.

As for the $12/hour tech, don't be too worried, there is always bound to be someone that under charges to get the work and as their skill increases their price will go up."

I agree with all three of your statements.

1) Unions can be a Godsend or a curse depending on how and when they're instituted.
2) My organization's costs have gone up as a result the vendors we deal with outsourcing their IT support to Malaysia and India. This is due to increased turnaround time on repairs in the shop. It takes longer to call in the problem, go through the diagnostic process & get them to ship the parts than it does to replace them, re-build the PC's and get them back on the floor.
3) I started out as a $12/hour tech 10 years ago and now earn right around $30/hr. Not too bad for guv'nment work, I suppose, when you consider my skills have been aquired 90% OJT and 10% formal training. Not a king's ransom, but as in Ohio, I'm in a region with a typically lower-than-average pay scale.

by 50kilroy

Hahaha..I've had a few brief forays into management. Didn't like it at all. I'm now a happy tech type finally with a supervisor who understands that not everyone wants to be a manager.

by ralford100

members get brainwashed into believing that the union is the only way to go. Union membership is like a cult; there's no way to talk reason w/a member because they're right, you're wrong. Period.

by tony hopkinson

Different histories ?

You look up the early inception of unions and the labour movement in the UK. I come from a mining village, so I guarantee that in order to keep food on the table at some point I got at least one strain of owner's blood in me.

You've got to look at it from a historical perspective as well. A lot of my ancestors would gave started working before they hit twelve. My dad used to go out picking coal to earn a few bob and left school at 14 for his first full time job.

That'll have been 1954. What do you image it was like in 1854 ?

Only the union and the labour movement itself gave me the right to vote.

Before all those people with no self respect got together and fought for their rights and mine, you had to be rich to vote. In fact they fought for yours in a way as american notions of individual empowerment didn't come from King George and his mates did they ?

So show them some respect they deserve it as much as the patriots who set up your constitution, it was an effort in some ways even more heroic.

I'd have probably been there with them, there again several times they lost so I could have been dropping my daughter off at the squire's place in order to stay healthy enough work for bugger all to feed the rest of my kids, who can say.

by tony hopkinson

I'd question your assertion that we are highly skilled profession. You may be highly skilled I know I am, I'm also aware of a whole bunch of people in the profession who aren't, not by my definition anyway. The univerity of X or Redmond's definition perhaps, not mine though.

Face it, our skills have been devalued to the point where they are common and easily achievable. Whatever the orginal reasoning behind certs as soon as they became a cheap narrow focused replacement for experience and or a degree, high skills became a luxury to many employers.

I aren't even going to mention diploma mills and Degrees'R'Us

The is of course why we are hearing stuff like unionise IT now, from people who can't compete on the playing field we have now.

by raelayne

I live in Michigan. I say ask the folks at Ford and GM what they think of your idea.

by navy moose

I had the displeasure of being required to join a union when I was in high school working for a retail store chain.

I found the unions to be corrupt, self serving, and only cared about themselves. They took a lot of money out of my pocket for zero return. The one and only time I went to them for assistance, I was treated rudely.

My grandmother told me of the good things her union did in the 1930s regarding the sweatshops she worked in. But, times have certainly changed.

As far as I'm concerned the UAW has killed Detriot. The NEA has turned the public education system into a shadow of what it was when my parents went through it. In short, unions sicken me and should never be allowed into the IT field.

by peter warren

It's not the unions. It's the unadulterated greed, the blind faith in "America", the unwillingness to see beyond our noses that has damaged US industries. Like corporations, unions are made up of people. It's the people who need to wake up. As long as we allow ourselves to be snowed by neo-conservative faith healers, we can only go deeper into decline.

by peter warren

The fate of the US auto industry has as much to do with corporate and union management that lacks courage and imagination. It's a fact that the Big 3 auto makers, along with union leadership, have fought every attempt at improving the safety and efficiency of their products. And we can't forget the US oil companies that have fought every attempt to develop alternative energy sources, as well as energy conservation. And last but not least, let's not absolve our wonderful neo-consevative leadership, which seems to enjoy fiddling while Rome burns.

by pkr9

I'd say they should ask management avout how long time 'the big three' think they can churn out the same old stuff. The US car is unsellabel anywhere than in the US, and even there you see a LOT of much better Japanese and European cars.
Saw what they presented at the lates Detroit Motor Show? Remakes of old successes and a SUV with the looks - and size - of a locomotive.
All this at a time when oil prices skyrocket, the unrest and instability in oilproducing middle east rises, Chinas demand of oil rises, where Toyota (unskilled low-cost japanese remember?) owns the market of alternative energy cars.

Don't blame the unions for management blunders.

by 50kilroy

Slow down there, Hoss. I'm not talking about a government take over. It's too late anyway since the Socialists did that in 1963. What I am advocating is only that a section of the American workforce band together and require proper pay for the work. Sure, it's socialism, but you are accustomed to that by now.
While things would be a little rocky at first, the outcome would be an increase in quality for all concerned; the employers would get seasoned, skillful technical workers, the consumers would get a better, more robust product, etc.
I.T. WORKERS UNITE NOW!

by icubub

No longer in management, so you can stop the socialist revolution!

I just think of IT as a profession, much like doctors, lawyers, engineers. Was an enginner for 10 years, enjoy IT much better now. I think we are cheapening IT more down to the level of an assembly line worker (and there's nothing wrong with assembly line workers either). But some of us have worked long and hard to get where we are in our careers, and don't appreciate the effort of some to lessen the importance of IT!

Now to climb off the soapbox...

by ralford100

Of course it's not.. it's all over the place: politics, religions, unions. When you get groups that use unethical business methods to get their way, you have choas.

Just like I don't support democrats or republicans 100%, or support radical religious groups, I don't support unions. I feel that when any radical group becomes too big (or loud), chaos ensues.

by server queen

that a corporation is an "individual" deserving of the same rights as actual persons. That particular legal fiction has led to a whole host of other problems.

Unionization - collective bargaining - in its essence is nothing more nor less than a way for the less powerful to negotiate with those who hold all the cards. Like any human institution, it is only as honest and trustworthy as the persons who use it to gain personal power. When it is simply a way for those without a voice to be heard, it is a great thing. Without unions, we'd be dying in sweatshops, working for true slave wages, denied benefits and pensions, and thrown out the door for refusing to comply with whatever absurd and/or inethical whim the current management had. Unions still provide a necessary buffer for even the non-unionized employee, and if you don't believe that, then you don't understand what it is that management truly fears about collective bargaining. It isn't just that wages will go up - if that were the case, maybe they'd think about lowering their own obscene salaries. It's that employees en masse equal the power of an owner.

But there are more things to be done to resolve our labor woes than unionize (and by the way, you can join a union to show solidarity even if your job isn't unionized - I'm a member of Washtech. It doesn't really buy me anything, but it's a way to show support for the concept). One of the principal things we need to do is get our legislators off the corporate teat.

Because corporations have been defined as "individuals" by law, one of the things they can do is political advocacy and political contributions. We've reached a point now where you almost can't win anything beyond a school board race without corporate sponsorship (I just finished a run for office, so I know whereof I speak). And you gotta dance with them whut brung ya - if the global multinationals and their billions are the reason you're in office, then they expect tit for tat, or next election, their dollars go to someone else.

The #1 thing we could do to improve the employment situation for ALL of us is to truly clean up campaign financing. NO large private donations. NO money from corporations. Public financing of all political campaigns, with strict spending limits.

by rkuhn040172

No to unions. They are a waste.

Does the IT industry need more political clout? Sure, but not by using unions.

I'll let the free market determine my wages and if I don't like it, I'll move, change jobs, change careers, get more certs or education, etc.

Whatever it takes, I'll be there.

But absolutely, 100% no way to unions.

BTW, I have made a decent living in IT for many years now and one piece of advice for me: don't work for the big boys. They screw you over everytime.

There are plenty of consultant jobs available, small employers, etc.

by decimumaximus

Just wanted to clarify the meanning of a consultant. On who cannot obtain a real job or one who cannot retain a real job.

This should get some hostile posts....

Seriously I look in the local phone book once a year. When it's new just to see how many of those schmuck's who applied at my company started their own consulting bussiness and sure enough the worst applicants have the biggest adds. but Next year they are gone.............ussually see them working the computer Isle at Costco or Worst buy....Consultants what a joke... With that said there are a small few who are worth a Damb and for those I give cudo's.

by tmcclure

What is your Master's Degree in? Certainly not economics. There is a reason union membership is falling. Unions don't work. They keep good people from entering in an occupation. They keep cost artificially high.

I used to work in as a merchant marine. Imagine walking into a union hall looking for a job. You go to the union hall looking for work. He tells you you need to pay 50 bucks to apply for membership. Then "you" need to find a job. Once you have a job, you have 24 hours to pay us (the union) 900 bucks for full memebership and also pay monthly dues. This was 1990. I can imagine the cost of finding and keeping a job is much higher today. I walked out of that union hall thinking this was exstortion. I had to pay them to find keep my own job. Give me a break.

by absolutely

I'm glad to see that one person can make the correct case against corporations. That, by the way, is the only one. All the proposals to [b]add[/b] laws to remedy this injustice are only throwing fuel on the fire of totalitarianism. Too many laws.

by apotheon

I agree: remove the legal identification of corporations as individuals with rights. It's mucking up the whole works.

Unions are, in theory, exactly what you say: a way for people to affect change in the industry. In practice, they're coersive extortion rackets. Unions don't work without basically everyone joining, so they have a vested interest in strongarming people into joining against their will (or leaving the industry). To make matters worse, the legal situation in the US has evolved to treat unions in much the same way the law treats corporations. They've become a mirror image of that against which they're supposed to protect workers. Union regulation legislation needs to be repealed, in its entirety -- then, if you still want to rile up a bunch of your buddies for a picket line, you're welcome to do so with my blessing, right up to the point where you directly interfere with someone's right to pursue a livelihood.

As long as unions can use the law to become extortion syndicates, however, I'm opposed to them. Period.

by pkr9

The US autoindustry has not reached the bottom due to labor unions. GM, Ford and whoever hit bottom because they turn out oldfashioned products nobody outside the US wants to buy. They aren't even at the bottom yet, but it is only a question of time.

In a time where fuelprices skyrocket, unrest and unstability in the middle east gets worse by the hour, the demand of fuel from China rises by the minute, they market 2? ton 4WD 6-litre V8 powered monsters mostly used for going to the local supermarket.

In the field of using alternative fuels they are absolutely nowhere, a growing market owned by Japanese and European companies.

All this is due to poor management, and not labour unions. The cause of most bancrupts can be found in the management floor, not the factory floor.

by raintree

The US auto industry (among others) has been brought to its knees by greed. That includes management and the planned obsolescence mentality and labor unions wanting more and more pay and perks until they price themselves out of a job.

by van helsing

I totally agree with you guys!

Nothing beats good old experiences, if you've been a veteran in the industry, you don't owe it to whatever certification titles you have. Getting that coveted management position is not a product of your certifications. Do these certifications give you the credentials to manage a team properly? Getting certifications is no longer a good basis in hiring people at this level.

Introduce these so-called "certs geeks" in a complex corporate environment for just a few weeks weeks and then try asking them how much sleep they get since their first day... i believe most of them will give you the same answers as that of the newbies without certs.

Get real... Man does not live on Certs alone, but from every bit of good and bad experiences he was exposed to for every years of service he has.

by pkr9

The reason is not that japanese workers have low wages, they just produce better cars.

by raintree

There are two (at least) reasons why the Japanese produce better cars. Their employees are interested in dong quality work and management is interested in produding a quality product. They both get compensated well for what they do because they are not building in their own obsolescence factor (into their cars or into their jobs).

by member357

This comes up every couple of years or so. Probably a union boss trying to increase their evaporating memberships due to many years of abuse. A number of states are closed shops meaning that everyone that works there has to be a member of the Union if it is unionized. In the past I have worked at such places and I can tell you that the Union did me absolutely NO favors. They also took a lot of money in dues, even increased the dues without a vote violating their own written bylaws. They didn't care. They did it with impunity. There was also nothing we could do about it. I tried everthing from the local police, States Attorney, even the Feds - no dice. Unionizing is like literally asking for trouble. "please send a few thugs over to jack us up." No thanks. Just say NO! They have also put many US industries out of business - Textiles, Shoes, Electronics, Steel and soon Cars. Don't let them ruin the IT industry too.

Maybe unions could be outsourced to India.

by don'tquityourdayjob

Maybe you are not getting ahead because of other things. The following could be an example:

You posted "There is know light...." when it should have been written "There is no light..."

When you communicate, especially internally, make sure you write in the correct context. Try to spell words correctly and use them correctly.

It can (and will) be used against you by others as an excuse to exclude you from being promoted.

I know this is an "informal forum" but it can be used as a place for everyone to practice some of their communication skills, which is sadly lacking in IT professionals.

I know someone will probably "blast" this post but it does not alter the message. Business communications is a reality and we have to deal with that reality or fall behind and stay at the bottom.

The choice is ours to make.

by bigbadfish63

Unions are good for you, your family and your community!If they are run right!! People forget or just don't know the history of unions. I agree with cmcarlson! I didn't pay the money for colledge to earn $10-$12.00 an hr.School cost me a lot of money, sacrfices and hard work.

by doug m.

we no longer have any job security. I worked at a union job at one of the largest telecom companies in the country. Guess what, I and about 125,000 of my colleagues were still laid off. And the union had no qualms about taking their dues out of my severance checks. Unions have given us some good things over the years, 40 hr. weeks, decent benefits, but some of them have gotten downright greedy, like the steelworkers and autoworkers unions. Not to mention the teachers unions. But unions are not always the answer to everything.

by memememe

The biggest problem I see in this thread is that both sides -- the left and the right -- have so filled everyone's heads with propaganda that there's very little good information and almost no well-informed opinions about unions floating around.

Are unions good or bad? The answer's clearly "yes."

I'll work briefly on both sides of the argument just to prove that they are, indeed, both correct, and then move on to the solution.

Pro: Unions can accomplish great and necessary things that we cannot accomplish individually. In the US, unions are the reason we don't owe our souls to the company store. They were also instrumental in the implementation of child labor laws, the 40-hour work week, the creation of the minimum wage, workplace safety standards... I could go on, but you get the point. We take a lot of these things for granted, but without unions, we probably wouldn't have them.

Con: Unions protect the incompetant, asocial and otherwise reprehensible coworkers. I'll cite a direct example: I knew a guy who worked in a Carrier air conditioner factory in Tennessee. He punched his foreman on the shop floor while both were on the clock. There's no way in the world this guy should have been back the next day -- instead, he should have been facing assault charges. However, his Union was strong and abused its power, so he was pretty much untouchable. It took them years to fire him, though they eventually got him when he failed to show up to work for several weeks straight without explanation. And, yes, it took several weeks for the company to have a strong enough case to try to fire him. Here's another: A union in a glass factory in Pennsylvania successfully protected its workers' rights to perform their duties stoned, even if doing so caused a physical risk to other human beings, who also happened to be union members.

Here's the bottom line on unions, folks: They're like any other powerful and flexible tool. They can be used for good, for evil, or anything in between.

If we want an IT union, we can have one, and we can make it do what we want, and *only* what we want. We can control it and keep it responsible.

Of course, we can also elect idiots to head up our union and end up in a situation similar to the American automotive parts industry, where at least one union contract guarantees that the guy who cuts the grass out from gets $40 per hour to do so.

If we choose the former, we could benefit not only ourselves, but our employers, because a union doesn't *have* to be the enemy. That's just traditional.

If we choose the latter, all those nay-sayers who believe our primary effect will be to export most IT jobs to India will be 100% correct. In the process, we'll hurt ourselves, our families *and* our companies.

So the question really is this: If IT unionizes, what ground rules for our union should we create to ensure that it functions, as a collective bargaining agent, to improve our welfare.

It's become clear that unions need to be more than an opposition to management. A good union works in partnership with management to curtail abuses on *both* sides.

Should a union ensure that the guy getting $12 an hour is actually earning a living wage? Certainly. Should it ensure that the guy who doesn't pull his weight doesn't stick around? You bet. Should it make sure that new hires are actually qualified? For the good of *everyone*, the answer's yes.

What we need isn't mindless pro-union or anti-union statements. We've seen that unions can be forces for progress *and* nurseries for corruption and greed.

If folks are serious about making an IT union, let's hear some proposals concerning, specifically, what we need our theoretical to do.

For the anti-union folks out there, tell us *specifically* what things unions do wrong, and let's see if we can work out a plan that avoids them.

Maybe we won't find a way to make it work, but maybe we will. Either way, we won't actually know if we don't give it an honest airing.

by memememe

I'll start by putting my money where my mouth is:

The original poster to this thread suggested that the minimum pay for all IT jobs should be $50 per hour. I view this as unrealistic.

In most rural areas in America, $20 per hour is a nice sum. If IT pros in rural areas get $20 to $30 per hour, they're members of the middle class in good standing.

Now, it wouldn't surprise me if you need $50 per hour in a metropolitan area to get the same effect. So if we want to work on the issue of pay in IT, we should first examine who's making what and where, and see what wage corrections would be good.

The qualification of the IT person in question is also a serious consideration: The "cert monkeys" that have been referenced in this thread sure don't deserve top pay, but skilled IT pros with track records of technical excellence and good people skills deserve to be properly rewarded for it.

The next thing to consider is, "How much can management afford to pay IT?" Because, realistically, here's where we're looking at jobs being offshored, environments where folks are swamped because there aren't enough bodies on the line, and the like.

Here, I think, is a better idea: We should tie IT salaries to the cost of living of the areas in which the pros work and live. Your basic skilled, competant techs should receive salaries that, statistically, put them in somewhere in the middle class, and we can deteremine this through goverment census data.

Scaling up salaries, where appropriate, should be carefully negotiated with management and gracefully accomplished, perhaps over three to five years, to avoid the destruction of the very companies where we want to work, and to prevent offshoring from being a better option for those companies than keeping IT local.

At the same time, we should test and rate our peers to show management that we are, in fact, justified in asking for the money that we do. Potential hires should be tested, and we should also have numbers on the folks already employed.

Low-skill techs *should* make less than the average IT pro, and those with advanced skills should make more.

That means we need to find an objective way to measure technical competence.

Let's presume that such a way can be found and agreed upon by both management and IT staff. (Because arguing about the method should be another thread entirely.)

So try this on for size: Mid-level techs, tested as competant, with appropriate workplace skills, should receive something akin to the median wage for the county or metropolitan area in which they live.

Those new to the field or who test out to have similar skills, should make anywhere from 5 to 20 percent less based on how bad they are. Similarly, those with high technical skills should make 5 to 20 percent more.

I say that if we make an IT union, it is critical that we successfully address this issue, and I believe the guidelines I've posted are reasonable and attainable, *and* I believe they'd positively impact the companies we work for.

How's that sound?

by the.erinyes

Computer rags publish this information on a yearly basis.
Wages will always be adjusted based on the area cost of living in which they are being earned. They will also be influenced by the job's complexity, skill level required, experience, size of the organization, technology required, sophistication of the organization and how many people are competing for the job.
The more important issue would be how you would determine "pay grade".
What are the classifications for your IT pay scale? How do you progress from one pay grade to another? How long must you stay in a pay grade before being advanced? What are your entry level requirements? Is a college degree required, or just certs? If no college degree is required, are you classified as a blue collar or a white collar career path? What is required to go from developer to DBA?
Let's pick on one IT role: the DBA. What certifications do you need? Must I be a relational guru or a hierarchical guru or both? Must you be certified in DB2, IMS, Oracle, SQL Server, Ingres, MySQL, PostgreSQL, or all of them? Must you know how to write queries using inner and outer joins and other DML, or just be able to write DDL and backup and restore databases?
All this information is factored into a job and what an organization is willing to pay to fulfill the role.
If a person in India can fulfill the role and the organization can deal with the communication issues and the fact they are on a different timeframe and the organizations level of support does not have to be realtime, then that position will be outsourced. This will happen whether the organization has a union or not.

by tonythetiger

Unfortunately, whenever humans are involved, nothing is ever run right. I would, however, settle for "less wrong".

by klfarrell

http://www.dol.gov/esa/regs/compliance/whd/fairpay/fs17c_administrative.htm

I know we do not want to admit it, but as IT professionals we fit the definition of administrative staff.

The requirements are:
The employee must be compensated on a salary or fee basis (as defined in the regulations) at a rate not less than $455 per week;
The employee?s primary duty must be the performance of office or non-manual work directly related to the management or general business operations of the employer or the employer?s customers; and
The employee?s primary duty includes the exercise of discretion and independent judgment with respect to matters of significance.

by mattforchat

Ok Squaredge...back away from the soapbox that you're standing on..it's not your freind. while unionization looks very much like it could be a good thing, If you look at current examples of unionization you begin to see that once unionized, an industry tends to marginalize itself and its' members creating mediocrity at it's best. We in IT must, by definition of what we do, not be cubbyholed into being a total commodity, thus reducing our overal inate value to our employers. This means that although we may be excellent technically, we MUST aspire to effectiviely and efficiently bridging the gap between the tech and the business side of the house. That way our true value becomes clear and we can be duly rewarded for it.

by the.erinyes

2. When a product becomes indistinguishable from others like it and consumers buy on price alone, it becomes a commodity.
When your industry reaches this point, then the migration to lower cost producers will always occur. Usually it starts with things like manufacturing and other blue collar trades, and then moves to white collar professions as developing countries churn out lots of college grads.
Specifically for IT, as business knowledge is codified and abstracted, it is developed into COTS applications which reduces the need for one-offs and custom applications. This is evident in all of the ERP, CRM, Accounting, etc. packages that exist in the marketplace.
Since there becomes less of a need to develop custom software, there becomes less of a need to hire developers. So the value moves up chain to the implementors which requires little or no coding, just customization of the application to fit the "unique" needs of the new COTS customer.
All businesses seek to drive cost out of their product or service to make it more appealing to their customers. This has been going on in the computer industry for decades and we are now seeing the effects.
Once commoditization occurs, the margins evaporate and the primary mission is to drive out cost or you concede the business to someone else.
The bottom line is this will happen whether there is a union or not. If you are in a union and this happens, more likely than not you will have to now rely on your own individual skills to become employed again, just as you would if there were no union!

by memememe

Of course these stats currently exist. I don't have them to hand. If you do, please post either some stats or, preferably, a link to the table.

I agree that methods for determining pay grade are very important and should be examined. Using your DBA example, how do you think we should determine answers to your questions?

Of courese it's true that any corporation will offshore if driven to do so.

So here's the nest question: Are DBA's receiving compensation in keeping with the revenue they generate/allow to be generated? I've never seen stats on this one.

It's possible that the majority of DBA's are being fairly compensated. If that's the case, then a union wouldn't make sense for them.

If DBA's arent, and there's room for scaling up their salaries before getting to the point of forcing corporations to outsource, *then* a union makes sense.

Remember, too, that we're looking at the possibility of a different type of union than we're used to seeing. Unions that follow the traditional model don't make sense and don't work for anyone (other than themselves) any more.

For a union to make sense in this day and age, it clearly has to have positive benefits for members, their employers, and the industry at large.

For example, if a union were to provide policing for its own ranks -- the way the American Medical Associaion claims it does but fails to do -- and did not make crippling demands during contract negotiations, we might be able to find a structure that makes sense.

My understanding of the offshoring trend is that companies do not wish to offshore at all. Certainly, their employees are against the proposition. So part and parcel of a healthy union would be its willingness to ask only for those changes that are 1) necessary, 2) beneficial to all and 3) do not force employers into positions bad enough that offshoring or understaffing look good.

This may or may not be possible.

by apotheon

In the United States, unionization has become overly regulated by federal and state laws. As a result, informal (meaning: not legally registered) unions are effectively impossible to create and maintain and formal unions inevitably succumb to bureaucratic corruption, becoming a bane rather than a boon. Persistent unions are a bad idea: unionization should never have been more than a temporary fix for temporary problems.

Unions, by their nature, consolidate the power of disparate individuals in a very few individuals. When that happens, such consolidations either give rise to imitators whose ulterior motive is that consolidation of power or they become dominated by such power-hungry people themselves. Ultimately, unions' primary purposes mutate into self-perpetuation, resulting in a permanent "fix" to a temporary problem that long outlives its usefulness.

It is this consolidation of power that allows lobbying for legislation that helps to perpetuate unions, and it is that legislation that essentially forces unions to grow into detrimental influences on industry.

The effort put into organizing unions would be better spent organizing political action groups whose purpose is to begin repealing corporate law (the other side of the coin from unions), rather than to create more corporate and union law. If governmental support of the corporation as a legal entity were to evaporate, so too would the perceived need for unions.

by memememe

If I replace the word "union" wherever it appears with "government" or "corporation" in your post, I get the exact same results: The consolidation of power in the hands of a few, the growth of a stultifying bureaucracy, a temporary solution that becomes a permanent fixture of everyday life... Your points fit any large collection of human beings into a body.

Now, if you're willing to saw that all corporations and all governments have the exact same flaws and should be expunged for having outlived their usefulness, I'm with you. Otherwise your logic fails.

Your statements concerning PAC's and their influence on government are much more compelling, and I agree that the influence of business on government is a problem.

What, though, is to prevent a labor PAC from doing the same thing? Absolutely nothing.

We see this writ large in California, where the teachers' union, functioning as a PAC, has had a great and negative influence on the law.

That being said, my notion that a different kind of union can exist could be replicated in regard to PAC's, and I agree: It's entirely possible that a PAC would be better for us than a union.

by tonythetiger

"So here's the nest question: Are DBA's receiving compensation in keeping with the revenue they generate/allow to be generated?"

What does THAT have to do with anything, and how is it any of your business if the owner chooses not to reveal it?

by memememe

Or, at least, that's the theory. A worker receives compensation based on two factors: 1) The value he creates for the employer and 2) The ready supply of workers available for the position.

And, yes, that's definitely my business. Corporations, of course, view that particular issue differently, primarily because they have nothing to gain and everything to lose by disseminating that bit of information.

For example, if a worker is being paid a disproportionately large amount compared to productivity, then something's gone wrong and there will likely be someone higher up the food chain to answer to, culminating in the possibility of angry stockholders.

On the other end, if a worker finds out he's making a heck of a lot more money for his company than his salary suggests, then there's employee dissatisfaction to deal with.

Off-Topic: Really, you can find better people/communication skills than you showed in your post.

by the.erinyes

Here is a link: http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes151061.htm for DBA's. Basically the 10 percentile is $34,530, the median $61,950 and 90 percentile $97,940.
So basically I would say they are being fairly compensated and the best are very well compensated which is how it should be.
Again, a company will move to do offshore if it is in it's best interests and can provide high quality at a lower cost.
I have a good friend that works for one of the Indian outsource companies. He does the high level work, requirements analysis, design and then the coding is sent offshore.
I consult to a company that has a lot of chinese workers in the US, and also outsources testing to resources in China. They are also trying to train them to do development.
If US companies were not interested in cost savings, then the whole issue of offshoring would not be relevant.

by apotheon

What about all the worthless pieces of crap holding down 9-5 jobs for corporations?

There's deadweight everywhere. The best consultants usually don't bother getting ads in the phonebook because they get enough work by word of mouth that they don't need it -- until they're successful enough to hire other people to expand the business, at which point they advertise in trade rags rather than somewhere useless like the yellow pages.

Don't judge consulting by your obviously limited experience. Friggin' troll.

by apotheon

You're right, adunlap, that's exactly as it should be. Unions, on the other hand, tend to sort for "sink or swim" based on how long and how reliably someone has been paying his union dues, and they tend to make consulting impossible.

by absolutely

Just why do you think there is a job market at all? Your attendance of college and receipt of a master's degree does not [b]create[/b] jobs. Jobs are created by [b]better[/b] people than you, whose inventiveness and hard work eclipses yours, and created an industry. The phenomenon of human ambition, and the resulting advance of technology, are not yours to control or stymie. It is your personal responsibility to understand that markets change, and with them, employment opportunities. You are not a child. The world is not responsible to give you a warning label along with your job.

"YOUR SKILLS MAY BE OBSOLETE SOMEDAY IF YOU FAIL TO ADD NEW ONES."

by mcak

Capitalism, unchecked, is not the kind of world I want to live in. Maybe you'd like to live at the same level as your counterparts in Bangladesh, not me pal....

by absolutely

Is that okay with you?

mcak: "Capitalism, unchecked, is not the kind of world I want to live in."

Absolutely: You're free to leave, not to obstruct my pursuit of my happiness.

by absolutely

If you want $50/hr, no legal prohibition exists that can prevent you from gaining the necessary qualifications, even, unfortunately, if you are a convicted felon in prison. No union can make you more talented than you are. Only your own effort can make you [b]worth[/b] what you say you want to be paid.

GET THE HELL OUT OF MY WAY!

by bigbadfish63

unions also provide pension plans not 401k which a employer only contribute upto a certain amount of what they feel is worthy, also they can provide disability insurance, morgages at a cut rate,auto insurance discounts, medical benefits, dental,optical, with minemal cotributions if any from the employee, stop overseas out sourcing,yea free trade only befits other countrys, we need to take care of our own people first! wages whithin reason not like the UAW!RIGHT TO STARVE NOT RIGHT TO WORK IS WHAT IT SHOULD BE CALLED!Fair wage for a fair honest days work. there are pros and cons to unionization, thats why i stated if it is run correctly, not the UAW, U Aint Workin.

by bigbadfish63

I think $50.00hr is a bit much, but a fair days wage for a fair honest days work.how much does it really cost for school today(4yr program)or cost of living for that matter?if your in LA, Then you know what i'm saying.and i chose this proffesion because it was supposedly close to what i use to do, wage wise.and yes, they tell you in mcse school what your potential is!! that how they get all thease young kids to tap out their parents or whoever to get thease degree's

by dusterman

Ah yes my young whipper snapper ............
.
A determined beaver can do it ......... the point at which the dam is built is the determining factor ..........
.
No .... we shouldn't subsidise the wages as it will eventually lead to over priced goods , but we could start by having "groups" like they used to have in the trades [ 1700 or 1800's ] and then we can regulate how much each of us independent business "folks" charge for the same service or part ............
Darned if I can remember the name for these groups ......... maybe someone here can remember .
.
I was just told they were called "guilds" .... ?
.
So anyhow ,,,,,,,, just how and why did "they" go away ??????
.
As always .............
.
Keep on ......... keepin on :-)

by apotheon

Government, in its most minimal form, is a relatively permanent solution to a relatively permanent problem. About 90% of the US government at the moment, however, is cruft created by permanent solutions to temporary problems. Otherwise, yes: what I said about unions does apply to organizations like corporations and governments.

by tonythetiger

Some people worry more about how much other people have than about whether they are worth what they're wanting.

Frankly, compensation is between the employer and the employee and the tax collector. Nobody has any business knowing how much someone else makes.

The socialists are losing though. Union membership outside of 'closed shops' is falling fast (and if union membership is so advantageous, why even have closed shops?)

by the.erinyes

Tony, I am not sure what you mean by personal wealth creation because in my mind that is a good thing (unless you are referring to people extorting money on the behalf of others).

It is interesting that people will always try to protect what they have, in the hopes that market forces will not catch up with them.

After WWII, when the free world rebuilt most of Japan and Europe (with the possible exception of rebuilding England) they used current technology (1945) while in the US and others were still using circa 1920's technology. This was especially true in the US. Of course when given a huge technological advantage one would expect that over time their ability to compete would be better and we have witnessed that it made a great difference.

Couple that with government meddling with the markets (we give you access, you do not reciprocate)then imbalances will occur because of the artificial constraints created.
The market if left unimpeded by politicians is extraordinary at driving out inefficiencies which means a particular function (product/service) will always migrate to the most efficient/cheapest producer.

From a nation perspective, can you trust those producers to look out for your national interests? Since the answer seems to be no most of the time, politicians stick their nose into the market from a protectionist perspective and create artificial constructs that will eventually fail, since in the long run you cannot bet against the free market.
When this happens, you will see industries fail, workers displaced and generally bad things occur, which are then blamed on the "market".

by tonythetiger

I understand what goes into the decision, and that all of the factors are variable. I just don't see where there is any obligation (legal or otherwise) to explain it to the employee.

Contracting is a good example. Publicizing the 'formula' you use to generate a profit would make it a lot easier for another to consistently underbid you.

by the.erinyes

I agree.

It is amazing to me how many people will abdicate themselves to the notion that the mob will give them a stronger voice.

by absolutely

What you described is how mixed economies are failing.

MemeMeme: "Or, at least, that's the theory. A worker receives compensation based on two factors: 1) The value he creates for the employer and ..."

That's [b]a[/b] theory, not [b]the[/b] theory.

The theory that all people are equal & have inalienable rights means that the owner of a business has the right to judge for himself, herself, or theirselves, as the case may be, what your value is. An estimate of the [b]importance[/b] of your work is your employer's right to make according to your employer's premises, not yours. If you don't like the offer, you can peddle your skills on the free market.

Unless you build, market & distribute your product personally, it is not possible to quantify how much value your contribution adds to the company's assets. You can be paid what the market will offer for your skills.

Because [b]That's[/b] How Capitalism Works.

by neilrieck

I am a full time software developer for a large Canadian telecomunnications carrier and have been a union member for 30 years. At first I thought this was a bad idea but over the years I've seen managment take too many liberties with employees and have changed my mind.

by apotheon

The tax collector has no (ethical) business knowing how much money I make. Damned thief.

by codebubba

(I've been in the business since '86 ...)

Yeah ... I've been in it since '78 and there's some credence in what you say though I don't agree with all of it. In my case I've found that I've always been able to find work. I've had very few periods of unemployment myself. Back in 1991 I was laid off during the recession. At that time I had a job offer in-hand but decided to make a go of it on my own developing custom software. Had a great time for 4 years. Lost my shirt at the end of it but had no problem re-entering the market.

Yeah ... job hunting can be tough, but my personal opinion on the matter is that if you focus on being very good at what you do and you demonstrate the willingess to PERFORM that you will seldom have real trouble finding something to do.

As for this Unionizing Idea ... I simply don't agree with it. Want to completely ruin the industry? Let's send the REST of the work offshore by unionizing. Unions had their place back in the 1920's - but now all they do is burden business with inflated expense and lazy workers.

-CB

by mcak

I'm free to leave, you say? Leave what? The country? The planet? It's a global market. Corporations have no political boundaries. If nothing stops them from getting labor for 10 cents an hour, they'll pay 10 cents an hour. If there are no regulations against pollution, they'll polute. They will not self-regulate, it is not in the interest of capitalism, which knows one and only one God ... profit.

by absolutely

There are two basic methods of pursuing greed: rational and irrational. The "planned obsolescence mentality and labor unions wanting more and more pay and perks until they price themselves out of a job" are irrational.

Greed is good.