Discussion Locked

USB 2.0 vs. ATA 133

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
Just wondering how a 7200 RPM 40GB ATA 133 hard drive would stack up against a 7200RPM 40 GB USB 2.0 hard drive in terms of data transfer rates.

11 replies

by shanghai sam

Hi,

Well... at a straight comparison, ATA 133 has a bus speed of 133Mb/sec and USB 2.0 allows up to 480Mb/sec. No prizes for guessing the winner there!

But there are other things to consider...

Sticking with the disks themselves for the moment... The actual disks themselves are likely to be very similar so we need to consider theoretical data throughput...

Ive taken the Western Digital 40Gb 7200rpm disk as an example...

Number of cylinders : 16,383
Number of platters : 2
Numberof physical heads : 4
Formatted capacity : 40,021 Mb
Read seek time : 8.9 ms (Avg)
Track to track seek time : 2.0 ms (Avg)
Latency : 4.2 ms (Avg)
Rotation : 7200 rpm

So lets look at one read and move to the next read.

Data/cylinder = 40021000000/16383 = 2442837 bytes per cylinder

At 7200 rpm means that it does 120 rpsec or 0.008333 seconds per revolution.

So it reads a cylinder worth and then needs to move to the next at a best time of 2.0 ms (going for one track to the next) and additionally you have the latency waiting for the track to start so the total time (at best) for a read of a complete cylinder is 0.0083 + 0.0020 + 0.0042 = 0.0103 sec

So we can do 1/0.0145 = 69 of these operations per second

or 69 * 2442837 = 168Mb/sec

(continued)

by timthetoolman

(continued from last answer - TechRepublic is doing wierd things to it...)

Now this is the absolute bestest best you could get and realistically its far too high for reality... It assumes you're reading the whole track and then moving directly tothe next track and reading the whole track and continuing to do this.

Realistically, the reading happens all over the disk so you can expect to use the average seek time of 8.9ms rather than 2.0ms. This gives... 114Mb/sec

Furthermore, you dontread the whole cylinder and so the Mb/sec drops still further.

So you see that 133Mb/sec is perfectly adequate to transfer all the data at normal speeds.

Also the disk cant push data through your PC faster than its FSB (Front Side Bus) so you're further limited by that. More and more PCs these days have FSB's higher than 133Mb/s so its becoming less and less of an issue. None have FSBs of 480Mb/sec, though!

Summary: How do they stack up? Comparably, I'd say.

USB gives you an external PnP drive. If thats important to you. Dont drop it, though.

Cheers,
Tim.

by timthetoolman

Hi,

Ooopp... I've made a flaw in my calculations due to the fact there are four heads on the disk - so you can multiply the figure by 4 !

That means that the USB device may well give you better performance...

Now I'd better go and look for articles on this... :-)

Cheers,
Tim.

by techkid

That answer above is not correct. The USB interface (as with Firewire) is based on Mb, which is equal to MegaBITS. The ATA standard is MB which is MegaBYTES. You haveta divide the Mb by 8 to get the MB. That puts the through put for a USB 2.0 HD at60MB or 60 Megabytes per second as apposed to the ATA standard which is 133 Megabytes per second. Hardly faster than the internal drive

by techkid

Wait.. I was right the first time. The internal drive is going to be way faster than the external drive... I need more coffee

This discussion is closed to new replies.