Question Locked

Video card - salvageable or too damaged to mess with?

0 helpful
37 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Yesterday I decided that I would take my Radeon XT 2900 HD video card out and dust it out. I opened it up, got it a good, thorough cleaning, put it all back together, and put it back in my computer. After having thought I was very careful in making sure everything was put back together properly, I had managed to forget to reconnect the GPU's fan connection, and had turned on my computer and tried to test out how the games ran on it. About 10 seconds into my gaming, my computer locked up, and a few seconds later the video card had made a few "popping" sounds. I turned off the computer and tried to take the card out, only to find the card to be extremely hot (at which point I realized my error in forgetting to reconnect the fan). I cooled it off and took it out to do a visual inspection of it. I haven't opened it back up, but from the outside everything looks fine (the cover for it is transparent). I reinstalled the card (fan reconnected), and proceeded on very carefully. The video card works just fine when I'm doing anything that isn't gaming, but as soon as I start up some games, the fan gets up to a very high speed really fast (almost sounds like a jet turbine), and the screen will occasionally flicker.

All this being said, is it possible that during that brief moment the video card got hot enough that it damaged it, or might there be something I can do to repair it?

37 replies

by ---tk---

anytime you hear a popping sound it isn't good! You probably blew a cap. and when you put the heat sync back on did you reapply thermal grease? The grease will act as a conductor for the heat to properly transfer heat sync and then the fan removes the heat from the sync... Often times when people don't use the grease the heat sync will eventually melt to the chip set (I made that mistake once)...

Save your self a headache and get a new card... also if you "fix" the wrong part, you run the risk of frying other components of the PC....

by jaymzkerten

While I *didn't* reapply more thermal grease, I hadn't cleaned off the thermal grease that was on there already (there was quite a bit on there). Could this have lead to my downfall as well?

As far as the popping, I stated in the post below this that I didn't see any capacitors that looked damaged, but the cover looked like it might been what popped off.

by jamesrl

It conducts heat away from the GPU. Too much heat and it will shut down on its own.

As to quite a bit, its a rookie mistake to put too much on. Depending on the compound used, its usually about the thickness of a sheet of paper, not like an oreo cookie as some people try. But it should fill the gap between the heatsink and the GPU.

James

by jamesrl

That would be a capacitor, and unless you are very good, these are not user replaceable. Do any of them look swollen?

If the card fails when gaming, it could be that some of the video memory is gone - doesn't get accessed until you run something which demands all the VRAM.

Personally I would trash it, it is obviously damaged and even if it works now for non gaming use, chances are that it will deteriorate.

James

by jaymzkerten

That was my original thought on what caused the popping sound. I looked over the card, and i didn't see any capacitors that appeared damaged in any way. I had also checked my sound card (was directly above the video card in my computer), and it appeared fine as well. The one thing I *did* notice was that it looked like when it heated up, the heat sink expanded a bit and popped the cover off just a bit (one of the notches holding it on was popped off), so that may have been the cause for the popping sound.

by jamesrl

Dissaemble the card - take the fan and heat sink off the card. Look for any scortch marks. If none, continue.

Clean off any existing thermal paste.

Put down a new layer of thermal paste (according to instructions found with the product) and reattach the heat sink and fans.

Try again.

A tube of paste will cost $10, its worth it to try.

James

by slayer_

You can get yourself a nice econo card for like 100 bucks.

I personally recommend the 9600 GT, its runs great, good memory, and most makes let you overclock the snot out of it and it still works perfectly with the stock cooling system. You can get one from BestBuy usually for 100 bucks or less.

by jamesrl

Tom's Hardware rates the 9600GT and the Radeon 2900 XT as the same level of performance. So if the 2900 is weak sauce, so is your 9600.

But thanks for playing.

The good news is if he bought the 2900 new, he paid big bucks and now he can get an equivalent pretty cheaply.

James

by slayer_

I just suggested it cause it was cheap and you can overclock the snot out of it without heat problems. You can even use it in some of the most clastrophobic cases you can think of without it running crazy hot. You can nearly match the 8800 with it with enough overclocking.

by ---tk---

If its still not transferring heat properly, it would get glitch as it heats up during gaming... and the POP could have been the heat sync expanding... It is worth a try 10 bucks is a small price to pay vs buying a new graphics card...

by slayer_

while your gaming to see if it is getting hot?

by ---tk---

If it got hot enough to expand the Heat Sync causing it to pop.... I would almost me afraid to know how hot its actually getting... but then again, it would be neat to find out how hot ATI's chip set can get before its cooked...

by slayer_

I've overheated my cards before, they have always just turned off the computer on me, it just blacks out and restarts.

by jaymzkerten

The grease is there, as I hadn't removed what was already there. The thinkness on there is that of which Sapphire put on there (the company that manufactured it), so that amount is based on their specs.

by jaymzkerten

Alright, I'll give a shot at putting some new grease on there to see if it does anything. Would the grease that I bought for my CPU/heatsink work just fine? Just asking because I don't know if there's a specific kind designed for video cards.

by mjd420nova

Put the card up close to your nose and sniff. If it smells burned then it probably has cratered the GPU chip. The fan may be able to keep it running a bit longer but sadly to say you will have to replace it.

by slayer_

The good ole required smoke, if you let the smoke out of any electronic device, it will no longer work.

by jaymzkerten

So far from what I'm seeing on the 9600s, they're all rated for PCIe 2.0 x16. It looks like a nice gfx card for it's price, but are they only designed for 2.0, because I'm not going to upgrade my mobo just to get a new gfx card (mine has 2 PCIe x16 ports).

by jaymzkerten

So far I've only seen them compatible with PCIe 2.0 x16, but my mobo only has 1.0 ports, and I'm not about to replace my mobo to fix a gfx card problem.

So are there any versions of the 9600 that are compatible with 1.0? And if not, what would be the best gfx card for my mobo (while staying away from the $3-400 models)?

by jamesrl

A PCIe 2.0 card will work in a PCIe 1.0/1.1 motherboard.

But just in case check your return policy.

Of course it won't run as fast as it would in a 2.0 compatible MB, but thems the breaks, and to be fair, the improvement is more theoretical than real.

James

by jaymzkerten

Got back home just a bit ago, and decided the only sure-fire way of deciding if it was dead or not was to disassemble it again and see the internal damages. From the looks (and smells) of it, the GPU itself is fine. No burnt smells, nothing on the actual card that seems to be damaged. Upon further inspection though, it would seem the *actual* cause of the popping sound - the heat sink. The heat sink seems to have split itself into 3 separate layers, and the thermal grease now seems dry.

So all in all, the card itself is okay! But I doubt I'm gonna get very far without a heatsink....

Time to start shopping on newegg....

by jamesrl

usually heatsink and fan combos.

I've paid more for a card to get an Arctic cooling heatsink/fan set up, and they do run cooler. You can buy them as aftermarket as well.

James

by ---tk---

can always be fun.... a little Frankenstein rig is always a good time :).. but it might take a little work, and in the end might be easer to get a new one....

3 sep. layers! Nice, you should take a pic and send it into TR :)...

by jaymzkerten

I got the new heatsink installed on my card, but I realized something at the end: the power connector for the fan is a different style of plug than the old one was, so it doesn't fit the plug on the GFX card. Would it still work alright if I plugged it into the mobo, or is that going to cause some issues (namely with it selecting the right fan speed when the chip gets hot).

by slayer_

so it is running full all the time, otherwise, into your mobo should be fine, just use a tweaking program to turn the speed up to max at all times.

by ---tk---

wow, it really did come apart! HAHA... Sorry, I'm not poking fun at your expense or making fun of you. It reminds me of my own major Mess up's (cooked a couple CPU's, socket A's... Melted one to the Mombo)... I only wish I had pics of them!

PS. if you send them to TR, usually they will send you some swag :)

by jaymzkerten

Send TR the pix or the heat sink itself?

And don't worry about it, I found it rather interesting and amusing myself.

Just got back from Fry's with a new zalman heatsink/fan combo, so we'll see how that goes.

by jamesrl

And the bonus is your card will likely be much quieter.

James

This discussion is closed to new replies.