Discussion Locked

What's better for ACAD - Pentium III or

0 helpful
10 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I've been reading and hearing the arguments between the Pentium III and 4, that in some cases for the same Mhz or Ghz, the Pentium III is actually faster than the Pentium 4 in some applications, like standard business application. I also hear that the P4 is faster for things like video editing.
But, given the same speed, which is better to use if you were running ACAD 90% of the time.
Additional question, same idea:
Also, if you had a PC running MS Access most of the time, which would be better.
Thanks for your help; appreciate it.
Joe

10 replies

by buffalodan

Neither....

In a recent PCmag comparison, the AMD Athlon outperformed any Pentium CPU in Graphic Intense apps.

Much more important to your solution however, your graphics processor.

And as with any Windows System, memory is KING. have lot'sof it.

by joe

BuffaloDan,
Thanks for your answer, I appreciate it, but it didn't quite give me the answer I was looking for - P3 vs. P4 in ACAD use. I realize memory is extremely important along with the graphics processor. Also, for whatever reason, I'm not abig AMD fan, so I'm not even considering an AMD processor. Once again though, I do appreciate your input.

by dave5168

Here are some numbers for you to crunch. A benchmark for CPUs in SiSoft Sandra gives the following results:
P4 1.6Ghz 3065 MIPS
1955 MFLOPS
P4 1.2Ghz 2300 MIPS
1466 MFLOPS
P3 1Ghz 2700 MIPS
1340 MFLOPS
P3 750Mhz 2260 MIPS
1005 MFLOPS

The numbers give you a percentage wise comparison. Run the numbers and see if they are worth the $$$.

by joe

Dhuber5168,
Thanks for your input and I apologize for not responding sooner!

I'm not sure this benchmark helps in the area of ACAD, does it? I thought that the MFLOPS test was not a real good test to determine whether a certain processor actually runs a certain application faster. For example, I understand that standard business apps actually run faster on a P3 1Ghz than a P4 1.2 Ghz, even close to a P4 1.Ghz. even though the MFLOPS are higher?
Thanks,
Joe

by katlynnc

I have used Acad for 10 years now and our office has both P3 and P4. There does not seem to be much difference in the day to day use on these systems. The first difference you will see is after you load your first session of ACAD the next secessions load much faster. This was the first real thing I notieced in going to a P3. The next thing is what are you using ACAD for. In my office we do nothing but just drafting, and all the systems work fine. The only place that you will notice a big difference in in hatching or 3d work. My recomendation would be to buy the most system for you money. The P4 ram is still quite pricy comepared to ehte PC133 ram. Either system would be great for you.

Roy Nelson

by joe

I wasn't sure how to post a comment under your response katlynnc, because when I made a comment and did not select a "status" like accept or reject, my comment under your response was not there? I have a follow up please

katlynnc,
I am so sorryfor not responding sooner. This project kind of feel by the wayside and to be honest, I forgot about my posting here. Now this project is "full steam" ahead again. I am really sorry for my lack of curtieouscy especially since you were so great torespond.

1.) The ACAD is used mostly for mechanical drawings. The user does design work for a machine shop (dont' think he use any 3D stuff, but then if he had a decent system he might want to)?. He's currently using and old standard Compag Pentium running at 200Mhz. with 64 MB of memory!!

2.) I don't think his files are that big so probably a ATA100 IDE drive would be ok?

3.) I guess it might be better to get something like a P3 1.1 GHz verses a P4 1.6 and put the extra money in a better graphics video card, what do you think?

4.) Also, I guess more memory would be a big plus also? What would the minimum be you think?

5.) I understand that in many applications a P3 actually is faster than a P4 for the same speed, even with P4s at higher speeds. I didn't know if this applied to ACAD or not though?

Thanks again,
Since I am asking more than my original question, I will of course increase the points.
Joe Boyd

by maxwell edison

For your mechanical application, AutoCAD (Release 2000 and/or 2002) will run equally well on a PIII or P4. 256 MB RAM would be best. Windows 2000 will be the best operating system.

Maxwell

This discussion is closed to new replies.