Discussion Locked

Why taser a 72 year old woman?

0 helpful
145 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

As much as I respect, in general, our nation's police forces, I also believe they overstep their authorities by leaps and bounds.

This may go against popular sentiment, but I don't believe that a police officer, by the mere fact that he/she pulled you over, has the right to demand that a person must [i]obey[/i] all commands issued. Where is it written that a police officer can instantly and unilaterally, without judicial review, suspend all of a person's civil rights and individual rights? Sorry, that dog just won't hunt.

Just because a person is pulled over by a police officer for a minor traffic infraction, it doesn't mean that person is guilty of anything; it doesn't mean that person's free speech is suspended ([i]You're a dirty, rotten pig,[/i] for example); it doesn't mean that person's right to privacy is suspended ([i]Where are you going? None of your damn business[/i]).

Just write the ticket, and let a person be on his/her way. There's no need to get into a power-struggle. Besides, in any [i]power struggle[/i], the police officer works for the citizen, not the other way around.

In the case of the 72 year old Texas woman who refused to sign a speeding ticket, and the officer let it escalate into a circumstance in which he actually tasered her on the side of the road, he acted without regard to her individual rights, assuming the posture that he was God and Dictator, and that she must do everything he demanded. That should be 100 percent unacceptable to ALL Americans.

True, she was feisty; she was rude; she was not cooperating; she was defiant; she was pissed-off. BUT SHE WASN'T A THREAT. If he actually thought she was a [i]threat[/i], then the officer is a wimp and doesn't deserve to wear the uniform.

Here's what should have happened:

Just issue the speeding ticket. If she refuses to sign it, tell her that you'll make a note of her refusal to sign, but tell her that she still must either pay the fine as indicated or go to court to challenge the charge - and then hand her the unsigned ticket. If she refuses to take the ticket, tell her that it will be placed on her windshield, but she STILL must either pay the fine or go to court to challenge the charge. Tell her that if she does neither, a warrant will be issued for her arrest.

He might have even said, [i]"I'm sorry, ma'am, but I'm just doing my job. You have a nice day, and please drive carefully."[/i] Let her scream and rant, and let her verbally abuse you - as you walk away.

Instead, he went on a power-trip; he insisted that she obey his every command; and he tasered her (tortured her?) because she refused.

This country is going to hell in a handbag when police abuse like this goes unpunished. And not only is it going unpunished, but it's being justified.

145 replies

by cg it

to bad the press doesn't make this a huge deal that it is.

When police have unbridled authority then they are no better than the terrorists who demand the populace obey them.

by maxwell edison

The police have too much power. They can trump-up charges, and a person is expected to prove innocence instead of the state being required to prove guilt. And the notion that you must [i]obey[/i] a police officer - without question - is absurd. It reminds me of the things I've read about Nazi Germany.

This should be on the front page of EVERY news outlet in the country - if not the world. Why isn't it? Where's the outrage?

The way I see things (not only things like this, but now the federal government is on the verge of MANDATING that every American purchase medical insurance), America, as we knew it, is on the verge of becoming history.

People better be concerned.

by maxwell edison

..... and I'll be arrested for what I just said.

And there are people (Americans) who would actually wish/hope/support as much.

by santeewelding

Three camps. One, that it was not acceptable. Two, so what? Three, that it was acceptable.

You, in camp One, have your work cut out for you.

You, dear man, rather than resort to what so many here, and yourself, salubriously refer to as, "government", will have to go deeper.

You, in order to make any final sense, have to sort out how any one of us stands in relation to the rest of us; how the rest of us stand in relation any one of us; and, how one stands to another one.

You, and anyone else here, must fix how you stand in relation to your self, neverminding anyone else.

Tall order. It is precisely that which your (deeply) understood lore of American history subtends. They, the founders, and we since, have only temporized with respect to that "final sense".

What you spout is not final. Save your outrage. It would be better spent when the force applied, unlike this time, is directed at you, and is lethal.

Meantime, I ask you, So what?

by lordazoth

Santee you put things into perspective. This is something that each wo/man has to think about for themselves rather then let the media decide for them.

by boxfiddler Hot topic

I took it as him noting a sign of the moves in authoritative places to bring about a dependent and fearful populace.

by shasca

What major event, in your opinion started the downward spiral? Can we reverse it?

by maxwell edison

[b]1. The US Civil War:[/b] Contrary to popular belief, the Civil War was not started as a fight to end slavery (although that was a positive outcome), but rather about the States' rights to secede from the Union. Lincoln pretty much answered that question by forcibly preventing it, trumping the only [i]Ace in the Hole[/i] the States had if they wanted to opt out because the federal government became too oppressive. (Not intended to suggest that the Federal Government was [i]oppressive[/i] as it relates to slavery, but used in the general sense.) I can't imagine a state, or a group of states, successfully seceding from the Union today, or even using it as a threat. If it were more probable (or possible), it would actually be an effective method to keep the Federal government in-check. (One of the reasons the Founders placed so much emphasis on [i]States' Rights[/i].)

[b]2. The New Deal:[/b] It was the first significant trespass by government into the personal lives of the citizens, establishing itself to be responsible for the personal well being of each and every citizen. The proverbial [i]Nanny[/i] found her way into government. It was also the first significant time that the population turned to government en mass to provide their every-day needs.

[b]3. Lyndon Johnson's [i]The Great Society[/i] and the [i]War on Poverty[/i][/b]: This greatly expanded what was started by Franklin Roosevelt's New Deal - same thing, but much more of it. (Lyndon Johnson, by the way, initially made his way into politics as a New Deal Democrat, and quickly gained favor by Franklin Roosevelt himself.)

Are we currently defining the fourth major event?

[b]4. Barack Obama and his Democrat majority in Congress[/b]: Led by Harry Reid, Nancy Pelosi, and Barney Frank, expanding the [i]nanny-state[/i] even more, burdening future generations with a troubling amount of debt, nationalizing major companies - and entire industries, etc. Are we writing the final chapter?

How do you cook a frog? If you put it into a pot of hot water, the frog will jump out. If you put it into a pot of cold water, slowly heating it, the frog will eventually become cooked.

We've been frogs since 1932. We're almost cooked.

Can we reverse it, you ask? Well, we not only need to turn off the heat (stop doing those things), but we need to put some cold water into the pot of very warm water (reverse the trend, and start discontinuing the [i]nanny[/i] influence).

Will it happen? Once the medical care industry is nationalized or controlled by government (in the name of compassion and or a [i]right to health care[/i]), and when the nation's energy suppliers (and users) are equally controlled by government (in the name of stopping global warming and controlling climate patterns) it's not likely. I can't cite a single government program that's ever been reversed or discontinued. Monsters never seem to shrink, they only grow.

by jamesrl

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hrwmSKJPCXU&feature=related

Please not this is disturbing,don't watch if you are squemish.

When we discussed Robert Dziekanski's death in Vancouver, there were those here who argued that absolute compliance to police was a requirement and that tasers could and should be used for compliance.

My argument is that the only time any instrument of force taser, baton whatever is when someone is in danger of harm.

In the Vancouver example, what was the risk of 4 RCMP not being able to subdue a confused befuddled tired man without resorting to a taser. They knew he didn't grasp english. If you watch you will see he does walk away .

You might be interested in the results of the inquiry. The RCMP lied through their teeth. But at least there was an inquiry.

James

by maxwell edison

Was the Texas officer out of line? Should he be fired? Should he be prosecuted? Is America turning into a police state?

by jamesrl

If I say that use of tasers should not be used for compliance but only to prevent harm to the officer or others, then the officer was guilty of a needless use of force. Frankly I think its a case of assualt.

In the Vancouver case, they killed someone. At a minimum fired, but also prosecuted.

Max, I don't know that one incident makes a trend or that one bad tasering makes a police state. But certainly if the trend continues....

James

by ontheropes

You were spoon fed as a baby.

Edit: If you think that I am going to try to convince you, of all people, of anything you're sadly mistaken.
I'm not going to enter into any kind of debate where you can cleverly use your pre-held notions of the way things supposedly are against me. I've forgiven, not forgotten.

by jdclyde

Between cops on power trips and legal systems setup to control rather than protect, the amount of respect for our legal system is dropping fast.

Sure, there are many cops doing a hard and dangerous job, but it goes beyond that. The whole focus is screwed up.

Job number one seems to find traffic violations (most minor) and hand out tickets. How about pull a few of the cops looking to give speeding tickets and add some to patrol our neighborhoods instead?

As for the taser, I find it unthinkable that this could even be considered a valid use of a taser. "Don't taze me bro" is going to be replaced by "Don't taze me sonny"?

by santeewelding

The execution, thereof, is I think what you are talking about.

The entirety -- codified experience of humanity -- does not bear such an immediate dismissal, I think.

by jdclyde

It is based upon decades of seeing government and law enforcement in action.

I don't respect many of the laws, so it is impossible to respect the enforcement of those same laws.

As I said, the laws are to control, not to protect.

by jdclyde

at 2:40 when she attempts to push by him and informs him that she is getting back in her truck, SHE crossed the line.

I just wonder if anyone out there knows if refusing to sign a ticket is in its self, an arrestable offense?

by cg it

is not an admission of guilt. Says so right on the ticket. That came about because the prosecutors tried to say "they signed it thus they are admitting guilt".

Still I think that the laws that say we must follow all instructions is giving way to a police state.

The cops who tasered the 78 year old lady over a traffic ticket was imo out of line. He should have left it alone, handed in his ticket book and let the court mail her the required bail or court date. Besides, if he had in dash video, it's all there.

by santeewelding

Lose the "protect" crap. Unless you are throwing it back in the faces of those who are so fond of that concept. If you are, then you are in danger of assimilating it yourself.

by jdclyde

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20090612/ap_on_go_co/us_fda_tobacco;_ylt=Ai.MESXELKrAwWS78BgV9lJH2ocA;_ylu=X3oDMTJ1MWdlcXVsBGFzc2V0Ay9hcC8yMDA5MDYxMi9hcF9vbl9nb19jby91c19mZGFfdG9iYWNjbwRjcG9zAzUEcG9zAzUEc2VjA3luX3RvcF9zdG9yaWVzBHNsawNub3Ntb2tpbmdoaXM-

ah, another attempt to protect us from ourselves.

Oh and it will be paid for by fines to the company, which will pass it on to the customer. Guess Obama really didn't mean it about not increasing taxes for those under 200k, did he? The Obama lied? no surprise there.

by dhcdbd

The part that was not mentioned is that the increased taxes are to fund CHIP (Children's Health Insurance Program). The idiotic part is that if, as is intended, smoking decreases, then so does funding for CHIP.

by dhcdbd

If you give a person a weapon and tell them that it is not lethal that person has less hesitancy about using that weapon.

If you train an authority figure but fail to teach that people do have rights, including the right to not answer questions or to be rude about it then you have an ill-trained officer.

In today's world police walk in residence doors without probable cause if the door is unlocked and will arrest you if you stop them and tell them to get out. You have police and other figures that have no idea of civil rights. Part of the reason is no real accountability; police boards are useless and the police unions mostly prevent prosecution of the police.

I have been tazed three times in my life. Once just above the butt cheeks on the spine. This took my legs out. The other two times, once in the stomach and once in the upper chest. These just pissed me off, got the cops butts whipped and then mine whipped and me tossed in jail when even more cops were called. The police forced their way into my home when I opened the door and I put them out. The prosecution made the most of it until the security tapes were revealed, then they quietly dropped charges.

Today, a cop is rude until he runs a make, then he is very polite.

That is todays life. If you do not like it then raise a stink and vote the politicians out of office at each election until you get what you want; otherwise just accept it and b!tch impotently.

by dhcdbd

"if he had in dash video, it's all there."

You are from LA and you don't know that those in dash camera's fail all the time. Something about interference with the recording I believe.

by robo_dev

wouldn't THAT be convenient? Do something bad and 'oops the camera failed'.

These are digital DVRs with a locked recorder in the trunk. Everything is very well grounded and shielded, since police cars have lots of radio gear and a very powerful radio transceiver on-board.

by dhcdbd

Happens all the time when police are caught doing something wrong; the evidence disappears or had some technical problem. The cams are usually switched on by the cop. and do not run 24/7 because it would be too expensive in materials (tapes and DVD's) and would carry too much inconsequential data. Same principle applies to my home/business alarm - video is not activated unless you have first triggered one of the peripheral motion detectors, either of which I can selectively turn off.

Last ticket my wife got the records for the Ladar maintenance were subpoenaed. They were lost. How?

by dr dij

gets MAD COP disease,
doesn't mean this is the law.

What are they officially supposed to do in this case? I really don't think the official response is what he did so the problem is not the law but this cop I would think.

Am I wrong? is there a law saying he could tazer or shoot you if you don't sign a ticket?

And as for the mandated health care, it would put me in a hard place. Currently unemployed, wife has job, I could be under hers but choose not too. I'm real healthy. BP 110/70, haven't been sick for years or decades. Fining me when I'm unemployed sounds vicious. Almost sounds like fines they used to levy on vagrants.

On the good side am graduating med pgm next week and might find a job. Also completed my stick-needles-in-your-arm card thanks to some helpful gals in the class who lent their arms for our stick-fest today.

I lent my arm back and got 2 venipunctures, 2 IMs and 2 SQs.

Last week helped with 3 eye surgeries. the most recent one was redo of surgery from another doctor and was quite bloody and long.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U-8RVYt4m9w
This is not us but is the same type of surgery.

wear your SUNGLASSES outside, TR'ers or this will happen to you!

by santeewelding

Phlebotomist?

That course takes some doing. It's the beginning of the meaning of, "invasive". Gives one pause.

by dr dij

fairly soon we will eliminate needles!

(ok here's the catch)

instead they will be replaced with self seeking carbon tubes that will detect what part of the body they are in as they enter the body. they will then stop inside a vein.

(unhappily similar to the Borg nanobot injection tubes :)

by the 'g-man.'

Let anybody scream, rant & verbally abuse you?

Two wrongs don't make a right but if the above was happeing to me I would have some recourse.

by the scummy one

this post will be censored
then Max gets arrested
then Max gets waterboarded
then Max gets shot before the courts can get to it
Then the press is told Max was released, and shot by some gang somewhere

by tonythetiger

"Bring in the guilty bastard. We'll give him
a fair trial, and then we'll hang him."

- Judge Roy Bean

by cmiller5400

In my state, Massachusetts, they can arrest you if you refuse to sign the ticket. It is considered a criminal offense. Thus the officer has the power if he so chooses to arrest you on the spot if you don't sign the ticket.

by the scummy one

If she wouldnt sign, then the officer is supposed to call it in and have a shift supervisor show up to explain things, and/or look into the problem of why she wouldnt sign it.

Tazed?? at that age??? WTF -- I would think that it could kill her. Geez, what a moronic cop.

by ontheropes

I remember a few years ago when some police academy applicants were disqualified because they scored too high on an IQ test. Moronic might be correct.

by the scummy one

completely sad. But I dont actually disagree with the assessment. Just hope we all rebel before it gets to that state of affairs.

by the scummy one

this right will go away shortly before the free speech.
and the ATF will likely enforce it with the aid of local police for anyone that has a registered firearm

by jdclyde

Yeah, our grand new free health care was suppose to have been paid for by stealing from corporations via trade and cap, but that fell through.....

They need to find a new scheme to find SOMEONE that should be paying for everyone else to have insurance?

by mjd420nova

When you sign the piece of paper that ALLOWS YOU THE PRIVELEGE TO DRIVE, it plainly states that you will follow the directions of a police official or your privege will be suspended. The officer does instruct you that you must sign the ticket. It is not an admission of guilt, merely an agreement to appear in court to hear the charges against you or pay the fine. Any refusal will result in your arrest. How many people read that before they sign. Driving a motor vehicle is a privelege and not a right. Follow the rules and you'll not have a problem. Too simple??

by the scummy one

I hadnt even thought of that, but yes, even in the driver ed class they bring it up. Once you mentioned it, I remember reading it.
Of course, I had to take the driver ed class a couple years ago all over again :( -- damned cops with tickets!

by jdclyde

and rules that vary from state to state, can make that an issue.

So, if I am a traffic cop I can instruct the hotties to show me her puppies? Seems reasonable to me..... :D

by shasca

The hand off the violation and walk away would have been much better of a conclusion. I guess he felt she was a danger to herself, and the public with frame of mind she developed. If he had tried to wrestle her inro the cuffs he could have broken her wrist/arm. If they tumbled to the ground injuries could have been even more severe.

by ksoniat

I noticed in the video that the officer kept trying to keep her out of the road. Everytime she tried to go back to her vehicle she went into the road.

She sure wasn't acting like a 72 year old grandmother.

by crispy_critter

I can definitely see Police Academy programs using a high threshhold IQ for means to disqualify police candidates. In teaching these future officers police procedures, having the officer do the procedure step-by-step without thinking why is probably more preferred than an officer thinking why he or she is doing this way. With a higher IQ, the candidate will think through the whys of what they're doing, not doing it and that may make a difference between life and death for the officer and/or perpetrator and/or victims and bystanders.

But what I have a problem with is how a person becomes an officer these days. To my understanding from knowing a marine who was a former D.C. police officer from the 1960s, departments used to recruit candidates from people who either needed a job or came from a police family where their father, grandfather, brother, cousin, uncle, etc. were police officers and it was a tradition. That I can understand, make people police officers if they need a job or if it is a familiy tradition. The solution for people who wanted to be a police officer who didn't fit the above criteria, i.e. someone who's life goal was to be a police officer and didn't come from the police family background was to NOT hire them - put their application/resume in the trash make notes to never hire them because they were profiled as potential power trip nutcases. Note that I'm not saying that all people who want to be cops are nutcases - this is how the police profiled and performed their quality assurance on new officers to prevent incidents such as 72 year-old getting tased.

Nowadays police get their new officers from police candidacy programs/academies that are populated by people who want to be officers. It seems as if there is a 180 degree turn in direction on people who become officers. In light of this, it seems that the rise in police 'misbehavior' has greatly increased in the past 20 years because of this, not in spite of this.

I wish that my direct experience with officers, while I have seen some good ones, contradicts what I wrote above, but, sadly, it doesn't.

by the scummy one

that dont want guns wouldnt worry about the guns being ripped out of the hands of the rest of us.
after the guns are harder to get, then they can work on other issues like speech -- then those wussies would wake up and see just what mess we are in.

Of course, they would likely be jailed for complaining at that point

by tony hopkinson

Was she wearing a head scarf?

ROFLMAO.

Why should the nice policeman take abuse. Some nice law abiding young negro might have took her as an example, abused his next policemen and caused him considerable expense replacing the saturday night special used explain the corpse.

This is just the thick end of the wedge, the time to act was decades ago.

Anytime you give up someone elses rights in society, you give up your own, so don't be in too much of a hurry to exercise your rights to privacy and free speech, unless you are prepared for a shock...

Not aimed at you personally Mr Eddison, just the f**kwits who can't do their sums.

by dhcdbd

I suggest that the funding come from the politicians pay. After the poly's term is up, then he or she is tried for treason for taking payoff money and then executed. That might stop some foolishness.

by dhcdbd

Just last week the UHP tazered the son of one of the state senators and killed him. The kid had a heart condition. Waiting to see the fallout from that.

The situation was that the kid stressed out from studies at AZU freaked out on the drive to SLC got out of the car and started running. His wife called UHP. UHP tazed the kid when he did not respond to commands and kept running. The kid was running down the highway. If UHP would have just let the kid run, rather than shoot him with a tazer, eventually he would have stopped from exhaustion.

Also had a similar situation in Ogden in which a man was killed by using a tazer on him - he had a pace maker.

Police are taught that tazers are not lethal. And that is a problem. "We will use force - just not lethal force." The police have no concept of just what may be lethal force. It does not punch holes through your body, therefore it cannot be lethal. Force of any form should be the last option and not the first. Just vote the politicians out of office that do not take a stand on controlling the police and other agencies.

by santeewelding

This monolithic "police" that forms the hinge of your argument -- this comes of the reasoned life you lead?

by dhcdbd

My reason comes from the belief that if you do not stand for something, you will fall for anything.

Society was formed by sheep wanting protection from the wolves, so people flocked together believing there is protection in numbers. The wolves were not going to starve, so they hide in sheeps clothing until they could begin a quasi military force selectively known as the police that allowed them to feed at will. Some people believe that individual protection is up to the, well..., the individual.

In my life I have known a few decent police, but those are very few.

by tonythetiger

They're reducing the amount of nicotine, so they''ll have to smoke MORE to get their fix. It also means that they'll will get MORE of the chemicals that does all the bad stuff that some smokers get.

Government cares... take as much as they can get out of you, then die!

by jackofalltech

This women is NOT your typical grandmother, she has to be the most obnoxious person on the planet.

It wasn't just a ticket, she was being arrrested.

She refused to cooperate at all, even when the officer repeatedly asked her to step away from the traffic lanes.

She was warned at least 5 times that she was resisting arrest, she dared him to try it.

We don't know all the facts, so let's not jump to conclusions - in either direction.

Max, I'm a little surprised at your attitude on this and a little disapointed as well.

by tony hopkinson

of your peers, and justify electrocuting a 72 year old woman?

If she'd have been 71 would he have just shot her in the leg?

What if she had died, at 72 it's more than possible. Of course attempting to restrain her physically could have been just as problematic.

It was a no win, copper lost.

She'll walk in court, and if she decides to sue, she'll probably win

by jamesrl

But other than being rude, what threat to the officer made using a taser, which is after all a weapon that can be leathal, justified. Did she hit him? Could she have even hurt him with her bare hands?

Sure a taser on a fit young male is unlikely to do damage, but as we've seen, it can and does hurt people, especially those on the margins.

My brother (one of them) was for a time a police sargent, and he would have fired an officer who was so reckless with the use of force rules. Sadly though it happens all too often.

James

by jdclyde

Sorry, from the point she tried pushing past him informing him she was getting back in her truck and leaving, she deserved everthing she got.

She is clearly someone used to bullying people around, and found someone that wouldn't back down.

That she did the interview afterwords pretending to be the sweet old lady to build on peoples EMOTIONS shows what a manipulative beotch she is.

by maxwell edison

..... police officers in this country often assume too much power over people - obnoxious people or otherwise?

Think about this. Regardless of the reason a police officer approaches you (whether on foot or automobile), you're automatically expected to [i]toe the line[/i] - however that police officer defines it - or you're subject to arrest and charges. Don't talk back, don't swear, don't refuse when he/she wants to search you or your property, etc. Because if you don't obey every command and afford every respect, you're in big trouble.

In this case, it all escalated just because the lady was rude and obnoxious, and she refused to sign the speeding ticket - at which time, she was still in her vehicle. I outlined in the original post one alternative course of action the police officer might have taken, but no, he chose the power struggle route. She didn't [i]obey his command[/i]. The only thing she threatened was his over-inflated sense of power.

Police officers should not be dictators with the power to immediately suspend ALL of your civil and individual rights. If you're disappointed by that, I don't really care.

P.S. And if I said all that to a police officer who pulled me over for speeding, chances are 50-50 that I'd be yanked of the car and arrested.

by maxwell edison

(Cut and pasted from my original post)

[i]While she was still in her vehicle - being obnoxious, ranting and raving[/i] .....just issue the speeding ticket. If she refuses to sign it, tell her that you'll make a note of her refusal to sign, but tell her that she still must either pay the fine as indicated or go to court to challenge the charge - and then hand her the unsigned ticket. If she refuses to take the ticket, tell her that it will be placed on her windshield, but she STILL must either pay the fine or go to court to challenge the charge. Tell her that if she does neither, a warrant will be issued for her arrest.

He might have even said, "I'm sorry, ma'am, but I'm just doing my job. You have a nice day, and please drive carefully." Let her scream and rant, and let her verbally abuse you - as you walk away.

Instead, he went on a power-trip; he insisted that she obey his every command; and he tasered her (tortured her?) because she refused.

by thechas

Max,

You of all people I would have expected to check the laws of the State of Texas before making a claim of what should or should not have been done.

Per Texas Statute, the person stopped for a traffic offense must sign the ticket or be physically arrested.

"Sec. 543.005. PROMISE TO APPEAR; RELEASE. To secure release, the person arrested must make a written promise to appear in court by signing the written notice prepared by the arresting officer. The signature may be obtained on a duplicate form or on an electronic device capable of creating a copy of the signed notice. The arresting officer shall retain the paper or electronic original of the notice and deliver the copy of the notice to the person arrested. The officer shall then promptly release the person from custody.

Acts 1995, 74th Leg., ch. 165, Sec. 1, eff. Sept. 1, 1995. Amended by Acts 1999, 76th Leg., ch. 701, Sec. 4, eff. Aug. 30, 1999."

http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/

http://www.statutes.legis.state.tx.us/SOTWDocs/TN/htm/TN.543.htm#543.010

Allowing the person to leave without signing the ticket would be the same as letting them escape from custody. The only discretion the officer had once he stopped the offender was whether to give a warning or a ticket.

Once the decision was made to write a ticket (warrant) the offender then has the option to sign the ticket or be arrested.

Note: I suspect like in many parts of the US that the officer had no option to issue a warning for a speeding violation that took place in a construction zone.

Watching the dash-cam video you posted, I would fully side with the officer. He was not on a power trip. He was following the laws he swore to uphold, and was in regular communication on his radio. I did not see any evidence that the officer acted in an inappropriate manner. Only when the accused repeatedly resisted arrest and repeatedly attempted to escape did the officer use his taser.

The only option the officer might have had was to detain the woman until a superior officer could arrive. Even that may have required physically restraining the woman.

Sorry Max, you are asking the State of Texas to change it's laws to match the way you think a traffic stop should be handled. In fact, you are asking the officer to disregard the law and do what feels good!

Chas

by maxwell edison

Post them as a reply to this.

[i]The Plant is called hibiscus, but it won't get you high. Trained officials mistook the popular foliage for pot and storm home of contractor.

Landscape contractor Blair Davis was in his Houston home around 2 p.m., when there was a knock at his door. Davis said he hadn't even gotten his hand on the doorknob when it flew open and he was looking at the barrel of a pistol.

Behind the gun were about 10 members of the Harris County Organized Crime and Narcotics Task Force, who burst into the home, guns drawn, and began shouting at him to get down on the floor......[/i]

http://www.policecrimes.org/police_brutality/Texas_police.html

by jdclyde

What To Do If A Police Officer Stops You

To stop you a police officer must have a specific reason to suspect your involvement in a specific crime and should be able to tell you the reason. This is known as reasonable suspicion. Most times you are probably getting pulled over for a traffic violation such as speeding or maybe a tail light is out. Although the stop may seem wrong or unfair, the police believe they have a reason to stop you

Your Rights During a Police Encounter. Rules you should know to protect yourself from the police:

Rule #1 - Never talk to a police officer. Keep your mouth shut! (You never have to answer any questions a police officer may ask, except for your name, address and date of birth.)

Rule #2 - Never talk to a police officer. Keep your mouth shut! (How can you be charged with something if you haven't said anything?) Remember anything you say or do can be used against you.

Rule #3 - "Am I Free to Go?" As soon as a police officer ask you a question, ask the police officer, "Am I Free to Go?" If you are detained or arrested by a police officer, tell them that you are going to remain silent and that you would like to see a lawyer.

Rule #4 - Safety. Never bad-mouth a police officer. Stay calm and in control of your words, body language and your emotions. Always keep your hands where the police officer can see them. Don't run away and never touch a police officer!

Rule #5 - Refuse to Consent to Searches. Just say NO to searches! Remember if the police didn't need your permission, they wouldn't be asking you. Never give permission to a police officer to search you, your car or your home. If a police officer does search you, don't resist!

Rule #6 - Ask for a Supervisor. If all else fails and you feel the police officer is abusing your rights, ask him to call his "supervisor" to your location.

Traffic Stops

You usually will be required to show the usual documentation, such as your driver's license, registration and proof of insurance. You don't have to open your window more than a crack to hand it out.

On traffic stops the police usually will ask you "personal" questions such as, where are you going, where have you been, who did you see, how long did you visit, ect. At that point it's the perfect time to exercise your RIGHTS by asking the police officer, "AM I FREE TO GO?" There is NO legal requirement that citizens provide information about their comings and goings to police officers! Another words it's none of the police officers damn business! If you are ordered out of your car, lock the door behind you.

Remember that the officer is not trying to be your buddy and become a new friend, they are on a "fishing expedition" to find something against you! They have nothing criminal on you, so they're looking for anything while they have you pulled over.

A good time to ask "AM I FREE TO GO," is after the cop has given you a "warning" or a "ticket" and you have signed it. Once you have signed that ticket the traffic stop is legally over with, so says the Supreme Court. Now if you want to stand around and shoot the breeze with the officer or answer his questions, that is up to you. Just remember you don't have to! After you sign the ticket ask, "AM I FREE TO GO?"

For more information on your "Rights" click on this link: http://www.policecrimes.com/police.html

by thechas

Boy Max, are you in a mood for complete anarchy this week or what?

There are many stories of police entering the wrong house or working from bad information when attempting to enforce our drug laws.

The problem here is that they cannot just go up and politely knock on the door of an actual drug house and expect to make an arrest or perhaps even survive.

This often happens after a team has been working well together and gets a little lax with following procedure.

Is that an excuse, NO. But, we place our drug law enforcement teams in a very tough and risky environment where split second response and action is required.

Chas

by deadly ernest

only relates to a situation where the police are investigating a crime and have informed you they are investigating a crime. There are some other's where the laws on the use of roads and motor vehicle give them the police and other authorised persons the right to direct people and traffic or to refuse them access or usage of a road. But there is not overarching 'you must obey the police,' and I think a close look at most US jurisdictions will show the same.

by jamesrl

I'm fine with throwing the legal book at her.

But not the book with a taser or a nightstick.

She wouldn't have s story to manipulate with if the officer hadn't overreacted.

This is a speeding ticket we are talking here, not armed robbery.

James

by ic-it

The police officer had recently returned from a tour of duty in Iraq.
I think a touch of PTSD affected the situation. A civilian officer should have had more restraint and control of the situation.

by jdclyde

than she should have been in cuffs too.

I don't cut idiots slack, regardless of race, gender, or age.

You will see where she did resist arrest by pulling back when I was going to cuff her. That would have been a nightstick upside the head if that would have been an 18 year old black male.

If the reaction SHE brought on herself caused her injury, it is just more chlorine for the polluted gene pool.

by tonythetiger

like to see stupidity bear its natural fruit, but I also believe that the police have a duty to use the minimum necessary force.

If she had died, this would be a completely different discussion... people would be demanding that the officer be charged with murder!

by techaaa10

Yes, there are some police officers that abuse their power. Yes this country is going to 1134 in a hand basket.

However, after reviewing the video and available information in this case. They were BOTH WRONG!

She should not have been abusive to him, she started with verbal assault, not following his directions and then physically assaulted him. She was wrong! She was causing a very dangerous situation on the side of the highway. She should have been arrested.

A policeman that was a friend of mine was killed along the side of the interstate by a wheel that came off a passing Semi. I have seen too many photos of accidents on the side of a busy highway, and it is a much more dangerous place than most think. This is especially true today with people texting while driving and not paying attention like they should when they are driving. Driving requires 100% of your attention. If you are on the side of the road you must be EXTREMELY cautious, because many of the people will not see you in time to react especially if you are in the travel lane, or within a couple of feet of the travel lane.

The officer, did not show the needed restraint. I believe he was within the law to arrest her for refusing to sign the ticket (at least that is the case in my state your signature is a promise to appear, sort of like bail). However, if a police officer can not subdue a 72 year old woman without a taser or excessive force he should not be on the street. He was wrong, and should be disciplined.

The last time I was stopped for a ticket was believe it or not in my driveway. I was issued a ticket for traveling 53 in a 30. I told the officer that I had lived there for 25 years and offered to show him where the "Begin 30" sign was. He refused and issued a citation, which I signed. The case never made it to court. I went in the house, got my camera, and went taking pictures, then got on Google Maps and pinned the areas in question. Location of Speed signs, Stop Signs, location I was pulled over . . . Took it to the prosecutors office and they dropped the charges.

Your Civil Rights are not automatically violated because a policeman requires you to comply with his orders. Perhaps you would like to live in a lawless society where everyone can do anything they please. Complying with a police officer, is needed for the safety of everyone and everyone needs to learn that there is a time and a place for rebellion. The side of a busy freeway is not the place. Because you are getting a ticket is not the time. She was at a minimum a threat to the officer and herself, not to mention the passing motorists by pushing the office toward the travel lane of the highway and by trying to enter the travel lane to return to her truck (without checking for traffic).

In some states they have decided it is best not to pursue some criminals who refuse to stop. All this does is empower the criminal. They know that if they speed up and start driving erratically the police will stop pursuit. This is really no different than parents who fail to discipline their children, and then are surprised that their children don?t do what they are told and misbehave in public. There are rules and everyone needs to follow those rules.

To the many conspiracy theorists here, while I will concede that corruption exists at all levels in this country, still this country is not nearly as bad as most. In most all cases that I am aware of the Dash Cams come on, on demand of the police officer and any time the lights are activated. Most are digital now, though there are still a few VHS recorders out there. (I work for a law firm and frequently deal with video from dash cams and security cameras and their software). Often the video is not high quality, and the audio is not high quality, but it is rare that it is not usable.

Now if you want to discuss the state of the nation as a whole, the federal government has far outreached the powers granted it by the U.S. Constitution. The constitution gives the federal government a very limited role to play and explicitly denies the federal government the right to enact any law not expressly granted it by the constitution. For the most part they justify it under the ?Interstate Commerce? clause. However, this is really outside the scope of the original issue in this post, so I will refrain from getting into this as it would take pages and pages to explain all the ways the federal (and state) government walks all over our Civil Rights.

But in this instance both parties were wrong. She should have been arrested, but did not deserve to be tazed and the officer failed to show good judgment and should be disciplined. Officers are supposed to be trained to diffuse a situation, not escalate it.

by tonythetiger

[i]after reviewing the video and available information in this case. They were BOTH WRONG! [/i]

but, as an on-duty public servant, the officer is expected to NOT behave wrongly. As citizens, we have the right to demand it.

by av .

The whole point really IS that she wasn't a threat, as you said. Rude and uncooperative, yes. But she didn't have a weapon or try to attack him.

The fact that the officer couldn't handle her rudeness in any other way and ended up tasering a 72 year old woman over a traffic stop is disturbing. He used extremely poor judgement in a routine traffic stop. What will he do in a more demanding situation? Of course, she also used poor judgement because she was rude, but that doesn't mean she should be tasered for it. He should have known how to diffuse the situation without using force.

The sad thing is, there are many more police officers everywhere just like him. When I grew up, the police were really there to protect and serve. They were more like watchdogs of the community and always respectful. Not so today. Most police today scare me.

AV

by michael jay

but if she had just signed the ticket she would have been on her way.

Where it went from there is just wrong, is there not a protocol for not signing the ticket other than arrest?

by jdclyde

If someone is a REAL threat, such as someone that is armed and dangerous, the threat should be removed.

by maxwell edison

Why do people do what you just did? I advocate taking away some of the power the people gave the government (or have allowed the government to assume), and suddenly I'm painted an anarchist. That straw-man don't hunt.

No, Chas. I didn't get a ticket for jay-walking this week. I also didn't have my house invaded by storm-troopers because I was growing hibiscus in my front yard. (Although I did get ticketed for blocking my own driveway about a year ago.)

But if they couldn't tell hibiscus from cannabis, they were incompetent drug enforcement officers, not worthy of having their jobs. (Not to mention the fact that outlawing cannabis is not only a waste of tax dollars enforcing, but it's an invasion of individual privacy rights.) And if they had the resources to assemble a team of ten storm-troopers, then they surely had the resources to do a bit of surveillance and checking on the individual who lived in the house. They simply didn't prepare by practicing ANY due diligence.

P.S. I'd guess thay you'd be singing a different tune if that had happened to you.

by maxwell edison

You actually did some research and cited something like that. That's not at all like you.

Nonetheless, I don't buy into the argument that just because it's written into the statute, then the officer MUST cite (or arrest a person) if it's violated. (Not to mention the fact, or opinion, that too many things are written into various statutes - so many, in fact, that ignorance of the law SHOULD be an excuse.)

Police officers often give warnings, even though some statute has been technically violated. If your argument had any merit, then every police officer would have to cite every infraction every time without exception. (Sorry, but you're going one mile over the speed limit - or jay-walking! Time for a ticket.)

Contrary to your assertion, I'm not expecting the officer to [i]disregard the law and do what feels good[/i]. I'm expecting some reasonable discretion and good judgment. In this case, if you want the lady punished for refusing to sign the ticket, he could have issued a second ticket for refusing to sign the first, and turned both (unsigned) tickets in.

Just because a person [i]could[/i] be arrested for refusing to sign a ticket, it doesn't mean she [i]must[/i] be arrested for it.

I'd bet a dollar to dirt that not everyone who's ever refused to sign a ticket has been instantly arrested.

by beoweolf

It does not take a bunch of research to find the exact date when policing changed. I would place the end of reasonable policing as coinciding with the release of the 1st "Dirty Harry" movie. No doubt, it was on the wane before that, but it became "acceptable" once Hollywood glorified the genre, Television picked it up and never looked back.

Politicians gloomed on to it as a popular sentiment/issue; they gave police brutality, harassment "calling" when they authorized the "War on drugs"... we tacitly agreed as long as it was waged against "those people", after all they needed to be controlled. We make it official, that unreasonable force could be used by further codifying an expanding list of enhancements - handing down 3-strikes laws in nearly every state.

The Genie was released from the bottle - there is probably, no way to put them back in the bottle without anarchy taking root. Power (like taxes), once accepted, is seldom give up without a bloody battle.

As always, be careful what you wish for - Your wish just may be granted.

by santeewelding

I suspect you have read a word or two by Bonhoeffer, or that what he had to say about it touched on a long, already, and still distributed realization.

by beoweolf

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,526146,00.html

"...But proclaiming innocence was not going to be good enough. The Dominican immigrants needed proof.

"I sat in the jail and thought ... how could I prove this? What could I do?" Jose, 24, recalled in Spanish during a recent interview.

As he glanced around a holding cell, the answer came to him: Security cameras. Since then, a vindicating video from the club's cameras has spared the brothers a possible prison term, resulted in two officers' arrest and become the basis for a multimillion-dollar lawsuit.

The officers, who are due back in court June 26, have pleaded not guilty, and New York Police Department officials have downplayed their case.

But the drug corruption case is not alone...."

Lets go to the video tape. If one is avalable that was not compromised by being in police custody - before it was reviewed by an unbias thrid party.