When you've unchecked the 'Enable Hibernation' box (and hiberfil.sys disappears), you should run a complete defrag before you reboot.
In fact, to be even more thorough, I suggest that you remove your pagefile too (right click 'My Computer' > Properties > Advanced Tab > Performance Settings button > Advanced Tab > Virtual Memory 'Change' button > select 'No Paging File' > OK > OK.
NOW run your defrag program.
THEN shutdown (NOT restart!)
When you next boot, it'll take a bit longer 'cause you've not got a pagefile now, but don't panic. When you've reached the Desktop just follow the instructions again and turn ON the Pagefile, then the Hibernation file.
If you haven't self-combusted by this time, enter Hibernation mode again and see how long it takes to come back out of it.
Post back.
Good luck! :)