Question Locked

Windows operating system upgrade

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Upgrading from XP to Vista or Vista to Windows 7, do we have to have the first operating system installed first. I wonder if we can install the upgraded system with the upgraded software by only somehow prove that we do have the first software, such as temporarily inserting the CD of the first software into the drive for verification during the installation of the second. If it is possible then we would have a clean install even though we are doing an upgrade. Though we still can install the upgraded system straight after the first I suppose it would take longer time and some residue of the first system would still somehow remain.

Of course, we can only do upgrade in this way if we can afford to wipe out the drive or partition.

11 replies

by kenone

There is no upgrade path from XP to Vista. From Vista to Win7 there may be but MS doesn't advise using it, perhaps because it's still in pre-release.

by healer

Thanks for your advice. I am not too sure whether we understand each other. I am sure there are upgrade paths from XP to Vista, from Vista to Win7.

I am probably just too naive to think that we can upgarde without actually have the first full system installed. I have never heard of it but I might have missed it.

by Member 23340214

Are you wanting to go from XP to Vista, or from XP to Win7, or from XP to Vista to Win7?

You can upgrade from XP to Vista; the upgrade works though every IT person worth their salt will tell you a clean install is the best way to go.

You cannot upgrade XP to Win7.

You could, I suppose upgrade XP to Vista, then Vista to Win7, but why would you want to? At this point it is best to do a clean install. That said, Microsoft appears to give its blessing to this aproach on their website: http://www.microsoft.com/windows/buy/offers/upgrade.aspx (Look under the heading "Love Your Current PC?").

As for doing a clean install without having the previous version installed, I'm not sure. I know the Win7 upgrade will not work if you have an XP disk, because there is no upgrade path from XP to Win7 that bypasses Vista. If you have a Vista install DVD, you may be able to insert it to show you have rights to use the upgrade, but I doubt it. Microsoft wants the license key and Genuine Advantage data to verify you are the owner of the Vista license before permitting the upgrade to install. This might change before the release date but I doubt it.

by balge

hi
think you have to check your definition of 'upgrade' - you appear to be using the marketing definition 'its newer so it's an upgrade' whereas you seem to be talking about 'inplace installs' which is a different thing i.e. changing the OS but leaving apps etc 'inplace' which is to say not formatting the HDD
MS don't list any 'upgrade' versions only full OS for 7 in any case, not sure about Vista
cheers

by healer

I apologize if I have been misleading. If I have it was unintentional probably because I myself wasn't too sure either. I was asking about both in-place install and clean install for upgrading XP to Vista and Vista to Windows 7. I have the impressions that both types of installs are available for both upgrades. Are you saying clean install only or in-place install only is available for Vista to Windows 7 while both types of install available for XP to Vista? Please clarify! Clean-install upgrade I suppose inserting the upgrade disk first while providing the former disk next for eligibility verification.

by kenone

Your supplied link indicates that one could upgrade from WinXPPro to Vista Business but when I tried to do that it was insisting on formatting the drive. Contacted MS support and they told me that it was "by design"

by healer

By the way, how did you start the upgrade install? Did you boot up the system from the Vista upgrade disk or did you run the Vista installation after the XP was booted up?

by 1bn0

Was the one where you boot ed the machien from the upgrade cdrom with a blank hard drive.

Windows setup would start and then request a disk fomr a previous version of windows to validate your eligibility to upgrade. Then theUpgradewould proceed to perform a Full Install.

by healer

I suppose you are referring to upgrading XP to Vista which allows for in-place install as well as clean install. Will Windows 7 allow for both types of installs for upgrading from Vista to Windows 7. I understand upgrading from XP to Windows 7 has to be a clean-install. Am I right?

You seem to be talking about the clean-install. Are you saying only clean-install will work properly? If that is the case, why would Microsoft allows for in-place install? What is the problem with in-place install?

This discussion is closed to new replies.