Discussion Locked

Accounting Quicken vs Peachtree vs ?

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
My company is about 25 people, we're looking to take the current accounting system of 4rth generation/unix to the pc platform. Can anyone advise of some good software to use? Peachtree vs Quicken vs ?..... the biggest part is that custom reports need to be generated for some clients. What do you think?

5 replies

by joseph moore

Here are my opinions on this topic:

Peachtree is the devil's program!
I worked at a place in Texas that used Peachtree. This was in 1998-1999. It was a new version of Peachtree.
All we had were problems with it. WE had consultants onsite 3 separate times over the year dealing with it. The upgrade to the at the time current version of Peachtree was fine. It was just database corruption problems with it otherwise.

I have never seen Quicken in a corporate environment, so I can't say how it is. IT is great for the home user, though. I've had the home version since 1995, with no problems.

Quite frankly, I do not think there is ANY good financial accounting software that works well in a networked environment, but that is just my opinion.
Good luck.

by oz_media

In a similar sized office I have setup Samco's veriosn of Real World accounting. It runs on a Unix server with full PC emulation and is completely customized to your needs by th vendor.

They are a Canadian company but am sure they can point you in the right direction.

http://www.samco.com

You can also try the Find Accounting Software Website:

http://www.findaccountingsoftware.com

OM

by oz_media

I can vouch for Chas on hie Quicken disaster comments. I had a customer BEG me to reformat her PC afetr installing Quicken to do her husbands books. She found it so intrusive that she was scared she was having her every move tracked. A little overboard with the paranioa but it is very buggy.

by thechas

Use extreme caution if you go with Quicken.

I have used both Quicken and Turbo Tax for years, but not any more.

Intuit has started playing many games with it's customers.

This past tax season, they added a very intrusive product activation scheme to Turbo-Tax.
The system worked so badly, that Intuit decided to drop it, and is now apologizing to it's customers in hopes that they will come back.

Similarly, the home version of Quicken attempts to take over ALL of your finances.

I have no experience with Quick Books, it may not have these problems.

Chas

by muzzaw

Quicken is for home users.
QuickBooks Premiere allows up to 5 users to use the datafile simultaneously.
QuickBooks enterprise allows up to 10 simultaneous users.
QuickBooks is a fine product - I recommend it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.