Discussion Locked

Alcohol and breast cancer- a causal relationship?

0 helpful
33 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Start here:

http://www.forbes.com/feeds/ap/2007/09/27/ap4165351.html

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/n/a/2007/09/27/state/n060603D52.DTL&type=health

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/21009784/

http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/09/27/health/main3305492.shtml?source=RSSattr=CBSEveningNews_3305492

http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601202&sid=axziudfl1CX4&refer=healthcare

So consuming alcohol daily raises your chance of breast cancer 30%. Interesting. I don't consume alcohol daily.

Last I checked, there are specific genetic markers associated with breast cancer. Neil, correct me if I am wrong, but BrCA1 and BrCA2 are more likely to tell you if breast cancer (or prophylactic mastectomy) are in your future. Also last I checked, breast cancer has a causal relationship to Hormone Replacement Therapy (HRT) for estrogen positive cancer.

What has me ticked is that the study group was not validated nor marked based on genetic pre-testing nor was HRT a factor. But the story is sensational, let's run with it.

AAAAAAARRRRRRGGGGGGHHHHHHHH!!!

I spent my day today trying to talk women around me out of the trees. They all assume that because they have a glass of wine with supper, they are giving themselves breast cancer. And I was asked more than once how much I drink.

Cancer is a horrible and terrible disease. Surviving is tough, mentally, emotionally, and physically. Why do we seem to feel a need to vilify the survivor? Why do we seem to feel a need to blame the victim?

My immediate knee-jerk response is to call this irresponsible crap masquerading as responsible science. I do well to remind myself of the "reputation" that Kaiser Permanente has built for itself over the years.

We used to call them "Malpractise Central". It fit.

What are your opinions?

Edit- I missed a letter. Remind me to not post when I am ticked off...

33 replies

by av .

They don't know what causes breast cancer after all these years and they're getting desperate for answers. Ooooh, it must be that demon liquor!

Honestly, I don't trust any studies lately. They don't seem to be fully vetted before they are released and publicized.

And, you know what? I don't care. I'm still going to drink wine and beer because I think the benefits outweigh the risks for me . . . . AND I think they're full of sh*t.

AV

by tig2

I didn't get cancer because I drank too much. I think I drank too much because of cancer. I have the genetic markers, I am working to deal with all that.

I am just so tired of crap science invading how we are able to manage breast cancer. WHY IN HELL do we need this? We finally figured out that survivors weren't at fault. Do we now need to go backward in time and vilify women with breast cancer?

WHY?

I am just so frustrated that I can't find a way to educate better- even in the eyes of those "scientists" who are just so knowledgeable. I've been there and done that. Make you a bet that not one survivor was ever queried.

It should make you wonder.

DAMN, I am really ticked. And tired of being blamed for my cancer.

Edit- reversed letters. Over it.

by maecuff

I just think it sucks that you had it. Tig, you know I mean this in the nicest possible way, right?

Stop worrying over what other people say/think/write..you can't control it and it doesn't mean dick. You are you. You didn't cause your cancer. I had cancer, too. I didn't ONCE consider it was my fault. And if someone suggested that is was my fault? Well, I'd tell them to run outside and play hide and go f*ck yourself.

Let it go, babe.

by nicknielsen

but my response to this kind of sensationalism has always been to point out the "fact" that over the past 50 years, the single common factor for cancer in laboratory rats has been laboratory scientists.

by Member 25348569

The media reports are derived from a paper presented in Barcelona which simply reported that alcohol from [b]any[/b] source increases the risk of breast cancer. There have been many previous epidemiological studies that have shown the same effects of alcohol but have not particularly studied the source.

I didn't, personally, see anything in the original research that bothered me. What happened here is that the paper was presented at an international conference and the media got hold of it. Then, they ask around until you get the quotes you want - notice the "not connected to the study" - from anyone who likes to talk. Nice, easy headlines and people panic.

The risk factors involved in breast cancer - or any cancer - rarely get presented in a non-hysterical manner with an explanation as to what it means. As you know very well, Tig, BrCA1 and BrCA2 tell you you're more likely to get it than not over your lifetime and is the cause of most male breast cancers. Why doesn't everyone know that?

Yes, persistent, [b]high[/b] alcohol use increases the chances of women getting breast cancer by up to 40% over non-drinking women but that's actually a marginal effect compared to increases in the risk of developing cancers of the mouth, throat, oesophagus, and liver and increased chance of falling over drunk in front of a bus, falling down stairs or crashing your car. "BEING PERMANENTLY DRUNK INCREASES YOUR CHANCES OF AN EARLY DEATH" is not an unreasonable headline.

A recent televised non-scientific but interesting test on young (20-35) London office workers used a new technique to measure liver damage. The consultant (US equiv attending physician) overseeing the test was shocked by the findings - as were some of those tested - and the unexpected conclusions pointed to "regular drinking" i.e. a couple on most days rather than huge weekend-binges from which the liver can recover. I know it doesn't have anything to do with breast cancer but it just shows that the effects of alcohol are not completely understood.

The stuff you posted is all media spin. Sorry, Tig, but you're stuck in a world of irrational people who believe what they read in the papers. "DRINK CAUSES CANCER" [b]is[/b] an unreasonable headline but it sure looks good and [b]sells newspapers[/b]. Cancer frightens people and this fear stops them going out and finding the truth just in case it gives them news they don't want. The fact that you've hit their fears head-on and beaten it makes you a target for that fear and they don't react rationally.

At the very least, hold your head high, babe. I would recommend a right cross for anyone who asks "how much do you drink" but you're in the USA and everyone has lawyers. "Push off, you vindictive, ignorant cretin and just pray that this doesn't happen to you" might suffice.

Neil :D

by hal 9000

This was doing the rounds just before you went for that walk and I didn't have the heart to post anything to you them mainly because you where walking hard and the Paper Headlines where not Representative of the real facts that where found by this study.

The original study was at best a Limited Study that needs to be expanded upon to see what if anything it actually means. Unfortunately however the Press has run with the story and twisted the original study so far out of shape that their reporting of it bears very little resemblance to what was actually said as the findings.

Everything in the listed articles is Media Driven and the entire thing is Sensationalised by the Media to [b]Sell Advertising.[/b] It has no relation to the real world but maybe a study several generations from this one just may come up with something useful. This was more of a starting point not the End Result.

Col

by hal 9000

There was a study a few years ago now who's findings where that if you worked Nights under Fluros you had a greater chance of getting Breast Cancer.

The study was one of Nurses and looked at those doing night shifts who had a higher rate of Breast Cancer than others in the same industry. So you can just as easily claim that it's the Fluros that are the problem not the Booze. :D

The trouble with these studies is that they are really a starting point to research not the [b]Definitive End Point[/b] that answerers every question so attempting to gather any definitive answers from these studies will never give a suitable result. Both of these studies where preliminary work that laid the ground work to further the studies and refine them so that something useful maybe can come from the future studies and possibly maybe a cure or at the very least a means to reduce the incidence of this disease.

But if you want to shot down the fools who think that this particular study is the [b]Be All & End All[/b] of everything just repeat this. Several years ago there was a study that found females who retain seamen where less likely to suffer depression. It to was an early study but as it was published it's possible to use it the same way as the Alcohol Study and claim that any female suffering Depression needs to not rely on any form of Barrier Method of Birth Control and the cure for the current depression is self obvious as you have this study to rely on. This response will go down marvellously with the parents of a Depressed 14 year old girl or the carers for a 95 year old Granny and is clearly wrong.

Clearly it is ridiculous to draw these conclusions from such a basic study but if others are doing the same to suit their own ends then returning the favour doesn't hurt. :D

[i]Edited to add[/i] No giggling to the treatments for the depressed Females listed above Right?

Col

by tig2

Is that I personally know people who have devoted their every waking moment to education about breast cancer. And no matter how many people we are able to reach, no matter how often, sensationalist cr@p is what we are going to spend the next year's energy on trying to dispel.

I caught this for the first time on the Friday morning newscast. It breaks my heart that mis-information so often gets traction where real information leaves hardly a ripple.

Welcome to October- Breast Cancer Awareness Month in the States. :)

by dadspad

for cancer. It is only journalism to gain profit that you see. This goes for internet articles also, but that is common knowledge here.

Stay mad, because you can always stop being mad later. Blaming yourself can lead to depression and that is much harder to overcome.

What makes me mad about articles such as this is there are so many people that have a friend or relative that suffer or die of cancer. Then, even when tests show they are cancer free, will literally jump when they hear or read articles like this.

The stress can do a lot of harm, especially when it is high stress for a long time.

by hal 9000

The best that they can say is that they can find no Infection, Cancer or Cause not that you are clear or uninfected.

Currently the Australian Broadcasting Corporation in Brisbane has had 13 women I think come down with Breast Cancer at the one studio. After the first 8 came down they studied the environment and stated that they could find [b]No Reason[/b] for this [b]Cancer Cluster[/b] and since then several more Women have been affected by this nasty disease. But no matter what the so called Experts can find no reason why so many unrelated women suffer the same disease at a rate much higher than what is considered as [b]The Average.[/b]

As a result the ABC here has now shut that Studio and is working from another location in a Commercial TV Station till their new premises become operational. The old building is being decommissioned but not demolished just in case latter they can find a reason [b]Why This Is Happening.[/b]

My daughter suffered a Needle Prick at work and all that the medical people will say is that currently there is no sign of HIV/Hep infection but come back and be tested in 12 months again to see if there is anything showing up then.

All that you will ever hear out of the Medical People because of Legal Restraints placed upon them is that they can find no sign of anything that they are testing for not that you are clear of this.

Col

by locrian_lyric

First off, the article mentioned >3 drinks a day or in other words, 4 drinks or more a day.

If you are drinking that much, you likely have an addictive personality and are doing other things that are self-destructive and unhealthy.

From the description given in the article, it does not sound like they examined other factors.

Are these women also taking birth control pills? Are these women smoking? Are these women drinking smoking AND taking birth control pills.

What are the diets of these women, other than their liquid lunch?

Sounds like something designed to terrorize women needlessly.

by tig2

In many, one drink a day was sufficient to raise your risk category. But sensationalist, the whole thing certainly is.

The greatest risk factor for breast cancer is pure genetics. The second is HRT for hormone positive cancers. The two most significant things a man or woman can do to know their risk is to take a genetic test for the presence of BrCA1 and BrCA2 and discuss the result with your doc. If you are a woman on HRT, you need to know what potential impact that can have.

To my knowledge, no one has defined a causal relationship between birth control or smoking for breast cancer. There is a causal relationship between both of the above and increased risk for high blood pressure and heart attack, especially if there is a family history present.

The greater issue is the misinformation that clouds an already charged subject. We can't hope to educate when we are constantly swimming upstream as it were.

by locrian_lyric

The "dark side" of awareness is that everyone wants to get their 15 minutes of fame commenting on it.

Information is only useful if it's meaningful.

From the articles, there didn't seem to be any relationship other than a casual one.

They are not controling for outside factors.

Genetics is the number 1 determining factor for cancers. After that, we deal with environmental issues such as mutagens and carcinogens, stressors, et cetera.

Since there is good amount of research money out there now, unscrupilous individuals will be playing on our fears to get some of that money, and the innocent be damned.

by tig2

I will learn how to do that. Tell someone to go play Hide and go F*ck Yourself, I mean.

I think that it sucks that anyone has had to live with trying to survive. I hate that we not only can't cure it, we can't even provide honest information.

I apologise if I am reading too strong. I just know from my email since Friday and the phone calls I have fielded what little positive education I will be able to do and the mis-information that I will be cleaning up.

Years ago, a woman was to blame for breast cancer. 20 years of trying desperately to raise a different awareness, we are right back where we started. It just breaks my heart.

But you're right. Have to find a place to let it go. Working on that.

Thanks! :x

by maecuff

is wonderful!

But for your sake, you have to let go of the dumbasses. You're never going to reach them all, they're always going to be there (for our entertainment) and that is that.

by Member 25348569

the study that provoked this thread was quite a straightforward analysis of whether the [b]source[/b] of alcohol changed the risk factors and not whether high alcohol consumption [i]per se[/i] increases the risk.

The fact that high, persistent levels of alcohol consumption can be linked statistically with an increase in the likelihood of breast cancer (amongst others) has already been shown. A 2002 study, by the charity Cancer Research UK, published in the British Journal of Cancer, estimated that alcohol accounts for around 4% of breast cancers in the developed world and around 2,000 cases each year in the UK alone.

The mechanism for promotion of breast cancer by alcohol is not clear and may be linked to hormonal changes as heavy drinkers have higher levels of Oestrogen. The chances that it is unrelated directly to alcohol and may be a lifestyle effect seems [b]less[/b] likely following the thread-starter study.

The Bloomberg report best sums it up as it has no sensationalist remarks from researchers outside of the study.

It isn't simple, though. The same BJC study that I mentioned above reported that "The balance between the harmful effects of alcohol on breast cancer and its beneficial effects on heart disease depend on a woman's age."

"Before about 60, breast cancer is a more important cause of death than heart disease.!

"After the age of 65 or so, when the risk of heart disease becomes much greater than the risk of breast cancer, the benefits of moderate drinking are more apparent."

I don't see where you get "unscrupulous" from. Given the almost ubiquitous nature of alcohol consumption in Europe and the US, we damn well [b]need[/b] to know what it does.

Just my two percent by volume...

Neil :)

by locrian_lyric

That's what happens when I try to make several points at once.

1)Unless they control for other risk factors, the study may not be worth much.

2)When there is money up for grabs, the rush to publish can outweigh the concern for accuracy and meaning.

3)When there is money up for grabs, there are always hucksters and snake-oil salsemen in the wings.

by absolutely

2nd sentence, so awkward it borders on
nonsense:

"What mattered was how much women in the
study, more than 70,000, drank a day, said
lead author Yan Li, a researcher with
health-care provider Kaiser Permanente"

More than 70,000 drinks? No, not
possible ... Oh, more than 70,000 women in
the study. Awkward.

Too much attention to "interesting"
sentence structure, too little emphasis on
clarity. That sentence (and the one
following it) would more clearly (and
succinctly) convey the same information
like so:

"Yan Li, a researcher with health-care
provider Kaiser Permanente, said the study
of more than 70,000 women showed a
correlation of alcohol consumption to
developing cancer only in comparisons of
women who drink 3 or more glasses per day
versus women who drink less than 1."

That's 47 words versus 60. You're entitled
to your own opinion of which is clearer,
but I'll stick to my opinion that mine is
better on both counts.

Also, the summary at the beginning of the
article exaggerates the facts contained in
the remainder of the article.

An informative first sentence would have
been:
[i]Drinking [b]three or more glasses of[/b]
any kind of alcoholic beverage, even red
wine, raises women's risk of developing
breast cancer, according to a study from
Kaiser Permanente.[/i]

The story, as printed, only says:

[i]Drinking any kind of alcoholic beverage,
even red wine, raises women's risk of
developing breast cancer, according to a
study from Kaiser Permanente.[/i]

The omission of any qualification regarding
the quantity implies that the statement is
true, [b]without such qualification[/b].
In fact, the statement is only true [b]with
that qualification[/b], which is provided
only in later sentences. The sentence, as
written, is not true.

You know, Tig, I was trying to minimize the
problem, in order to sothe you, when I
started this post. But, after analyzing
just 3 sentences of that Bloomberg article,
I have to conclude that you have very good
reason to be annoyed.

Journalism and science both
emphasize "asking the right questions", and
both assert pursuit of the truth as their
goal. Questions such as which profession
to trust less are not very useful, IMO. My
question is, since scientists already print
their results in far more detail, wouldn't
the public be better served by publication
of those reports, with the addition of
explanations in-line for the less
scientifically informed readers? This
wouldn't put an end to the jobs of AP
science writers, but would make their jobs
more productive and useful to their
audience.

by Member 25348569

I agree that the grammar in the Bloomberg report was not completely unambiguous but they did avoid any sensationalism. However, crap reporting doesn't devalue the study.

The point that most seem to have missed in the study, anyway, was NOT the relationship between alcohol consumption and breast cancer. The epidemiological investigation was designed to show whether there were differences between different SOURCES of alcohol. The conclusion was that there is not.

All this goes to prove is that researchers don't necessarily talk as unambiguously as they write and the media will print anything.

Neil :)

by tig2

The place where something like this becomes damaging is when non scientific types try to read and understand. Information the way it was presented is fearful and provokes strong reaction.

It becomes important to defeat the "noise" in order to present a clear and unambiguous message. The inroads we have made to date have been dependent on empowering men and women by giving them good information. Poor information or ambiguous information isn't helpful.

The media is NOT my friend just now. I wish there was a way to communicate to them in a meaningful way, the damage they are capable of through irresponsible reporting and sensationalism.

I don't get it...

by absolutely

"[b]All[/b] this goes to prove is that researchers don't necessarily talk as unambiguously as they write and the media will print anything."

Therefore, what?

by Member 25348569

things are as they have always been. I'm not too sure why you're getting quite so stressed about this.

I'll try again: What we had here was a perfectly acceptable epidemiological study on 70,000 women with the aim of ascertaining whether or not their specific beverage of choice contributed to any difference in the increased risk of breast cancer that heavy drinking is known to bring about.

This was followed by the usual media misinterpretation with some good juicy quotes. What little reporting the UK media did, I found OK. I read an article on this in the Independent newspaper - in the health section rather than news - before I'd read anything on this thread and didn't think it anything special or new. I've found it on-line http://news.independent.co.uk/health/article3001632.ece and there was further information in the newspaper.

The fact that ignorant people have picked up on the "drinking as cause" isn't anything that I can control. I'm not sure that anyone can control it although I do believe that the media are well able to predict it.

"Drinking as cause" isn't anything new. Yes, I KNOW that there are other causes, age, obesity, HRT and genetics but, if high alcohol consumption DOES increase the risk of breast cancer then, given the large numbers of women who drink and the increase in young women's' drinking in the UK it may be a hugely important factor.

Piffle? Hmmmm. What else do you want? I'm really missing the issue, here.

Neil

by gadgetgirl

YOU aren't Joe Public.

You have an enquiring, logical and scientific mind (yes, I mean it, no, I'm not flattering you for the hell of it) Joe Public speed reads pieces like that and sees the words that they want to: Causes; Alcohol; Breast Cancer. Therefore, in their minds, alcohol causes breast cancer. They then think (naturally, for them) that anyone who has/had breast cancer must be an alcoholic. Or, at the very least, has "issues" with alcohol.

See?

Same way as people jumped all over me when I admitted I'd had cervical cancer twice. Yes, it's caused by HPV. Yes, it can be caused by either sex too early in life, or too many different partners.

But.

It can also be genetic. Take the girl in Australia that they think got cervical cancer at age 12, purely through using tampons. (Sorry, don't have time to find the link, will possibly try later) She had an intact hymen, hadn't had sex, hadn't even fooled around, but her mother and sisters both had HPV leading to cervical pre-cancer, too.

Yes, I was pregnant when I found out I had cervical cancer, so obviously, I'd had sex. Hadn't had that many partners though. (Think Methodist parents, here, and you'll see why.....) What didn't help me, was that apart from a genetic predilection to HPV, I started using tampons at age 11. (No criticisms: back then, you used them as soon as you could; sanitary wear in those days was abysmal)

I'm with Tig. It's not the people who ask questions of us, or people here on the board who will LISTEN to explanations, it's Joe Public, who immediately class Tig as an alcoholic, and me as a "loose woman". (Ha! If only they knew the truth!)

That's the issue, Neil.

I know you know I'm not ranting at you personally, but it's a subject guaranteed to get me on my soap box, as you well know and understand.

But for Joe Public to jump to their own conclusions, just after Tig is getting people to a higher level of understanding - well, I'm with her. They should write to their readers' levels.

Eejets.

GG

by tig2

And thank you for putting so clearly what I could not.

When the value of ones information is abysmal, it is still extremely difficult to replace with better information. It is disheartening to spend so much time and effort trying to educate only to be shot down by the sensational.

I know the value of that education and have to keep trying. I believe that I can reach... someone.

GG- with you and Mae, I am in some good company. :x

by jamesrl

....but you can't make them think.

If you go back to some of the political discussions we've had here, you might find something I wrote on lazy thinking, and I find its just as applicable to this area as politics.

It isn't that the "masses" aren't capable of critical thinking, its that the vast majority chose not to. To a certain extent its a skill that can be taught TO A MOTOVATED INDIVIDUAL.

But many seem to prefer to be passive filters like coral reef dwellers. They hear alot, accept those things that fit into their belief system and spit out the rest. They don't examine their own thought processes let alone question the sources of information that provide datapoints that validate their own view. This is true of many people, on many parts of the spectrum.

Critical thinking is hard work. You have to consider source, bias, perspective and seek out other sources.

In the case of the alcohol/breast cancer link, it reminds me of the easy aristolean logic questions we got in first year uni. If a cow eats grass, and a horse eats grass, and they both have 4 legs, are a cow and a horse the same? There are many factors in any cancer, and to my mind there are many unknown variables. Alcohol in large amounts to a person with an already unhealthy lifestyle may have many times more impact on someones immune system than moderate alcohol consumption by an otherwise healthy person. I know personally that when I was an athelete than my body would react less to alcohol than when I stopped the intensive workouts. Metabolic changes and other factors play into it.

The larger issue, both with the alcohol question and the HPV discussion is why some elements in society are looking to "blame" people for cancer. I might suggest it isn't coincidence that these are two "female" cancers (yes I know breast cancer affects men too, but not equally). If I put on my socialologists hat I'm sure I could conjecture why that is. If someone suggested a link between alcohol consumption and prostate cancer, would we still be blaming the victim?

Another datapoint pulled out of last nights news. A class action lawsuit in Canada against those agencies and individuals involved in the tainted blood scandal failed to find anyone liable for negligence. The outcrcy is massive. People were seen crying and yelling and wailing at the injustice of it all. THEY WANTED SOMEONE TO BLAME. Now I have every sympathy for those who contracted AIDS or Hep C or other ailments through tainted blood. They did nothing wrong and caught life threatening diseases.

But think for a minute. Did those at the Red Cross and in other areas in the health system act in a negligent manner, or did they do they best they could with the information they had? I didn't study the trial in minute detail, so I won't offer an opinion. But I will also offer that many of the emotional outbursts are from those who reacted not to legal opinions expressed by the judge but to the shock of disbelief that those they blamed for the situation would not be held legally accoutable. I see a parrallel here.

James

by Member 25348569

I am of the opinion that the causal factors for all cancers that HAVE known causal links should be out there for everyone to know as much as they want and as much as they can.

Given that, if the media doesn't do it - however sensationally - who will?

Yes, genetics is important and very much more so in respect to breast cancer than any other to date. It's reckoned that up to ten percent of breast cancers in the UK are hereditary and that means that the other ninety percent are not. So we need to get the knowledge of the risk of familial breast cancer out to women but we also need to get information out for those women who have no genetic disposition as to what the other risk factors are.

Given some of the crap that's around on the Internet, the off-line media are paragons of accuracy. So far I've found reports that bras, breast implants, underarm deodorant and high-fat diets cause breast cancer and - superb misinformation - women who have had abortions have an increased risk. None found for any of those. For tobacco, surprisingly, no reported link for secondary smoking and none even for smokers. None for pesticides or

If Joe and Joanna Public jump to their own conclusions because of a report that is mainly true then there's not a lot that anyone can do about it other than to keep plugging away

"They should write to their readers' levels."

The one thing that I believe the media is good at is following exactly that advice. Don't forget that the UK's biggest selling daily is The Sun. I don't think they reported on this although The Independent did and reasonably well, too, but the Sun sells ten times as many copies.

Neil

by absolutely

whatever that means, is simply that the article on Bloomberg typifies the shortcomings of popular coverage of science news, which in the country supposedly leading the world in scientific advances, is abominable. The pattern I've noticed is an excess of summary information about the context (general/background information on breast cancer research and research on the side effects of alcohol consumption, in this case, as opposed to more info that isn't "yesterday's news") and a shortage of information about the specific research project, and worst of all a lack of direct links to the original data. Inclusion of the last, I think, would tend to have a synergistic effect, encouraging readers to learn enough to understand the background material if only that background material were more available. Something is very much in need, in this country, to increase students to learn science and math, and the Department of Education has proven, conclusively in my opinion, the ability to do more harm than good. But, I only get my news from the popular press, so I could very well be totally wrong!

;)

by tig2

You touch on many of my thoughts, if not points made. I stop thinking well when angry, and this whole thing has served to make me very irritated.

Check this link to see how we approach specifically male cancer- https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196080&tag=rbxccnbd1

I think that this whole issue is driven, maybe more than we care to see, by Him vs. Her. And I think that women are getting short shrift.

The need to blame someone is endemic in society in general. To me, it is high time to quit blaming and start thinking. Start thinking of what the impact of the "sensational" story is- a woman who never drinks alcohol may think that she is safe from breast cancer. If she has BrCA1 and BrCA2 in her genetic makeup, she would be wrong about that safety thing.

Can't we just put an end to the "silly season" reporting and the need to blame? Can't we be happily educated and aware?

Maybe not.

I don't know what the answers are. I wish I did.

by tig2

How do educators sort through those often wrong media opinions to get real facts in the face of those at risk?

I'm on the front lines with this. I have to help the "viewer" get past the mis information and into real education and I have less than a minute to do it.

When the media presents the sensational without the factual, I am left with an educational dilemma- how do I get through and give a person real and solid information?

It isn't enough that the educational materials I use come from respected resources- The Komen For a Cure, the ACS, and Astra-Zeneca- I have to make receiving that material matter enough for someone to READ it. And sometimes that is tough.

I agree that the information needs to be out there. I am all for that. But it should be right and responsible information.

by Member 25348569

I think my attitude to this thread is probably different when compared to yours because I read a report on the original article in a UK newspaper before reading the thread and it didn't strike me then (and still doesn't) as anything that would cause anyone but the totally irrational to draw the conclusions that you described.

I'm not sure what else to say as I really can't get angry over what I read.

Sorry,

Neil :)

by absolutely

[i]You have to consider source, bias, perspective and seek out other sources.[/i]

I also consider things such as context, plausibility, and applicability to myself and my personal interests, which in my experience lead to great savings of time, in that discarding the trivial and irrelevant without the necessity of a detailed report on [b]all the reasons[/b] why certain things are not of interest to me.

[i]Another datapoint pulled out of last night's news. A class action lawsuit in Canada against those agencies and individuals involved in the tainted blood scandal failed to find anyone liable for negligence. The outcry is massive. People were seen crying and yelling and wailing at the injustice of it all. THEY WANTED SOMEONE TO BLAME. Now I have every sympathy for those who contracted AIDS or Hep C or other ailments through tainted blood. They did nothing wrong and caught life threatening diseases.

But think for a minute. Did those at the Red Cross and in other areas in the health system act in a negligent manner, or did they do they best they could with the information they had? I didn't study the trial in minute detail, so I won't offer an opinion. But I will also offer that many of the emotional outbursts are from those who reacted not to legal opinions expressed by the judge but to the shock of disbelief that those they blamed for the situation would not be held legally accountable. I see a parallel here.[/i]

You "see a parallel here," to what exactly? What I see is that those folks just got bad news. The first thing out of their mouths do not indicate to me that they don't think, only that they are asked [b]about their emotions[/b] by reporters trying to appeal to your emotions. Your post seems to indicate denigration of the people quoted, meaning that the reporters' cynical appeals to emotion worked -- on you.

"THEY WANTED SOMEONE TO BLAME."

Wow, you've got them all figured out. You feel so smart. Want an award of some kind?

by absolutely

And if my country's press were portrayed to the world that way, I would also not have a complaint. In other words, the article you posted was much better than the ones Tigger posted about the same topic, which I still maintain are crappy. Not erroneous, but far less informative than they might have been, with the same amount of space.

This discussion is closed to new replies.