Am I the only Admin looking at blocking hotmail.com to stop SPAM? (edited)
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by dr dij
by dr dij
It's indeed not enough to have a certificate that validates the e-mailaddress. It has to be linked to your personal identity. If you then only accept mail from that kind of e-mailaccounts, things should work fine.
But alas, still needs a lot of work all around the world...
by dr dij
by 1davis1
by dr dij
by dr dij
by bagmaster50
If you're using MS Office 2000 or better at work, make everyone use Outlook and configure the same filters on all workstations. And notice I didn't say Outlook Express
This way you can configure thier antivirus to scan all incoming and out-going email.
by choppit
Blocking hotmail etc. definitely would not work for us. Because a large proportion of our customers (end users) are paranoid about making their spam problems worse, they will only use hotmail/ disposable addresses for contact. I'm not too worried though as our ASSP server generates very few false positives.
We actually have a bigger problem with customers (end users again) who won't take phone calls unless they see a CLID.
by lkarnis
Hi:
Do not block e-mail where the sender says they are comming from hotmail.com. I did a quick check of my anti-spam software and here's what it said... since Feb 2, 2005 we have 236 e-mails from people purporting to come from hotmail.com. However, they came from 224 unique IP addresses and it is likely that few (if any belonged to hotmail.com). Of the 236 e-mails we received, we rejected all but 89 as spam. In a nutshell, simple strategies like blocking senders DO NOT WORK.
Larry
by choppit
by scott.geiger
Stopping or limiting SPAM takes multiple steps and functions and applications. I run a qmail mailserver, but I have added:
1. RBLSMTP checked against multiple rbl,cbl and xbl sources. After putting this in place my SPAM receipts dropped about 50% - 70%
2. SpamAssassin (an Apache Project). With SA I only mark messages that might be SPAM. Then my users can filter. with SA I can also black-list and white-list addresses as well.
3. Whitelist Recipients - If the mailbox doesn't exist on my server - message is rejected (you could also just drop the message which could prevent phishing attacks)
4. Injection limits - this can be done with iptables on linux and also with a patch I have on qmail. If I start receiving a large (my definition) quantity of messages from one source I can throttle down on the receipt.
With Domino, you can probably run some RBL checks, and if you are not you should. You may also be able to employ SpamAssassin as well.
So other items which I have seen mentioned on the qmail discussion list but have not implemented because there is still a lot of debate about them
1. Domain Keys
2. SPF
Gmail seems to be using DK, so that may lend some validity to it. We'll see.
Scott Geiger
by jdclyde
Charter Cable is big in our area among businesses. We even are looking at moving our internet access over to cable instead of with our frame relay provider.
3 x the bandwidth for 1/4 the price.
by jdclyde
by cactus pete
by guardianbob
Hey,
Canadian branch here. I have to tell you that you have no choice. In our case we have to block ALL emails from YAHOO, HOTMAIL, GEOCITIES, and ovewr 79 other domain. Yes, the whole domain! We have a list of 3286 spammers and 126 domain blocked by our mail server.
In a week we receive over 7000 spam emails. And this is without the user having rights to the internet! Imagine with every user surfing!!
In our case it's not fun cause most of our distributors and contributors come from the USA and so do the spam! We thought of blocking every single emails from USA except our collaborators but we can't do this cause we keep legitimate consumers from emailing to us.
So my point is: Is this another of the US gov scheme that makes them money and that's why they don't give a thought about it? Or is it simply lazyness and procrastination like we all know we're very good at?
These are my two cents and YOU ARE RIGHT, spamming is a plague and those big corporation are not helping by letting these people polute our lives! After all, money talks and bullshit walks!!!
by erikpaladin
by minstrel
by server queen
There are actually some DSL providers who set up small business customers with MSN as their ISP automatically, which means they only get Hotmail addresses. A customer that knows enough to ask for a different ISP can get real email addresses provided instead, but a lot of really small businesses - think of, say, a carpenter setting his business up on the Internet out of his home office - don't know any better.
I'm kind of hardcore about blocking. I block a LOT by default, then when we get complaints, we unblock selectively. Block it and see who squeals.
by deepsand
Oft times it is a matter of sheer economics.
For many SOHOs, paying for "real" e-mail represents a significant cost.
And, for businesses that need a large & variable number of addresses on demand for incoming only, free services, such as Hotmail, are the logical choice.
by fresnotech
Spam is a federal crime, thanks to the CAN-SPAM act passed a couple of years ago. It's not working, but it's trying. If everyone was prosecuted, there would be a couple of small problems.
1)Some people who "spam" are legitimate, in the same way that you might get a cold call during dinner. Instead of prosecuting them, there needs to be something like the do not call registry, or in this case, the do not mail registry.
2)Jails are overcrowded in this country already. If we are going to send everyone to jail, there won't be much room for murderers and such.
3)Some people who end up being the sender of spam are really just exploited machines which are spam zombies, sending out mail without the user knowing it.
4)It would be nearly impossible to charge people in another country with something that is a crime in the US, or UK, or whatever country, when it's not a crime in their home country.
by fresnotech
I am a networking person who has to deal with the spam issue, but I haven't always been. I use Hotmail as one of my main email sources. It is the one that I give to clients, who aren't related to the company I work for, when they need help with something. It's easy to remember, with no numbers or underscores or anything else like that.
I don't send spam. I never have. Heck, I don't even forward jokes. I hate chain letters, and if one comes my way, I break it. I am so far due for close to 1000 years of bad luck, will never find my true love, and will never have a lot of money. Darnit! If only I had forwarded that message to everyone I have ever known, or even thought about knowing, I would be a billionaire.
I understand the desire to stop spam, but blocking a full domain like that isn't going to help much. There are many people who use it legitimately, and do not clog up the email networks with spam. If you did block it, you could possibly stop a lot of legitimate mail from coming in, even though it doesn't look like it.
To stop spam, have you looked at SpamAssassin? Or PostFix. We run both SA and PF on one of our servers, the one sitting on the outside edge of our network. It is the first thing that any piece of mail comes to, and it is the last thing that any piece of mail goes through on it's way out. We get spam, but it goes into an account, setup on our mail server, whose only purpose is to get mail that is forwarded from the postfix machine for us to peruse and, if legitimate, forward off to the user it should go to, or to bounce back to the sender, with a request to investigate the IP that is sending the mail. If we get a lot of spam, we block the offending IP. It still gets into our "trash" account, but it doesn't hit the user, and the advertisements are seen by one person, instead of the people that the spammers are trying to get it to.
This solves most of the spam issue, and also serves the purpose of allowing us to catch emails that aren't sent to the right address, because our users can't remember their darned email addresses. If it is mailed to our domain, it gets here, and we find out who it belongs to.
BTW, Postfix and SpamAssassin are running on a Linux machine
by fresnotech
by deepsand
As several of my clients use Hotmail, for legitimate purposes, it would be illogical of me to assume such is not true for other Hotmail users as well.
For many, paying an ASP for e-mail service is simply not, in their minds, cost justified.
by deepsand
I did the same for one of my clients when setting up multiple Hotmail accounts in 2001.
They are still inundated with spam!
It had been reported, in industry circles, that MSN was then sharing their "customer" file with "affiliates," without regard to user preferences.
Of particular note is the fact that the accounts designated as "female" consistently receive more spam than do those designated as "male."
by deepsand
Like any other business, the spammers target Hotmail because that's where the customers are.
The larger the size of the client base, the higher the probability that any list of randomly generated user/account names will yield valid user/account names.
Such lists are used as BOTH recipients and spoofed senders.
by deepsand
unless you know of a way to stay in business without customers.
They're not unlike women -- can't live with them; can't live without them.
by deepsand
is and ASP which specializes in spam filtering software for use on enterprise e-mail servers.
I use USA.net, an ASP specializing in e-messaging servise, for serveral of my e-mail accounts. USA.net uses Brightmail, along with user defined black/white lists, for the detection & disposition of spam & possible spam.
Folowing their having been recently purchased by Symantec, it is to be expected that their rules engines will eventually be incorporated into Symantec's Internet Security Suite.
by jaqui
on a linux box...
possible, but messy.
use real professional products, like a compiled cgi done in c or c++
instead of m$ Awfully Sh:{}y Product
I don't install support for m$ .asp, nor frontpage extentions.
neither meet any recognised international standard.
as a matter of fact they both only meet m$' requirement of sucking more money out of people that beleive advertising implicitly instead of thinking for themselves.
can ya tell that an asp product ain't a good suggestion for an open source os person?
by deepsand
Quite frankly, it is neither obvious that your post was intended as a response to mine, nor clear in its meaning.
Please clarify.
by john
I have been administering several networks for the past 12 months, and have completely blocked Hotmail.
set rules on the server that have the accounts and on the proxy server.
Zero mail from Hotmail, it is glorious
by bob21
by jaqui
but why use hotmail for business?it's the least secure, most commonly used for spam, and least respected email service available.
I have no respect for any company that uses hotmail as business address.
I agree with you when it comes to companies and business. Hotmail adresses and WEBmail is too easily discardable. Privately though, in Sweden you can walk to the public library, and send some mail, that ain't crucial.
gunnar@ChicagoRollingThunder.org
by bob21
by bob21
by jaqui
if I stopped bouncing hotmail from the domain list,it would still get bounced for illegal SPAM formatting.
hotmail only sends that spam format html email.
so why should I care if someone gets pissed cause thier spam got rejected?
anything but plain text is spam.
by bob21
by bob21
by sgt_shultz
to poster: check out the free redbooks and other wonderful technical articles on exactly how to implement security including filtering spam on dominio mail servers from www.ibm.com ibm would love to sell you services. ibm very interested in fostering domino on linux. if you are running on linux they may be helpful for free. point you in fruitful direction. you ought to make some exploratory phone calls imho and check out the website most thoroughly there is a ton and formums.
i'm sorry but it does not compute to me that you run domino and linux but are asking this question.
imho my job as admin is serve and protect, in that order, and i think you can finesse a better spam protection than banning website from router...
i use hotmail at work to debug internet and email. to use as an address when i don't want to register my work email address for something. for when i need to easily get at my email from anywhere as i travel. for poor mans file transfer. it is a useful tool. to 'maintain' it as a freebie i do have to go there and check and delete mail occasionally. so you would bum me out and all the users around me since i share so if they *want* to understand and use the concept of pop3 vs web based mail. they also understand about spoofing and about why spam is dangerous on unpatch boxes and stuff because i repeat it gently, clearly, kindly each time and it sinks in eventually. i think the root cause of admins who have this perspective of saying user too dumb for this or that AND not educating the user as part of the fix should take a look at this and see if it is working for them. maybe they think that having more information about IT than the users makes them more special so it follows that if users have less information they are less special. so glad to see you think you should cut that out. i think we should start erroring on the side of overinforming the users.
i should start a new thread:
You know Admin has gone to your head when you:
-have a password of GodLike
-ban aim
-don't allow users to install software themselves
-ban hotmail.com
etc
by jdclyde
That I am NOT the NOTES admin. The options you speak of are not open to me, and the person that they are open to couldn't care less.
So to try to support my users, I am looking for other things that I CAN do.
-My users do install software.
-My password is "IamGreat", not "GodLike".
-My users think aim is a toothpaste.
-I only asked for feedback on the idea, and looking for a better solution if someone has one.
If you would have ever read ANY of my postings you would see I am an advocate for supporting the user, not being the IT Nazi. But I guess that would have taken a little more effort than a drive by flaming does. Any positive Ideas, I would love to hear them.
by teamdave
I am already blocking Hotmail.com. We use a service based filter called postini and I have it blocking hotmail.com email by default.
It can allow certain addresses through and block the majority and is user configurable, so this doesnt seem to hinder anything and cuts down on the spam by a good amount.
by lompnaz
I use javascript to "hide" email address. Google "email scramble" and you should find a ready to use script.
It doesn't stop people who are prepared to click on the link then copy the address, but harvesting programs don't see through it.
I never publish email addresses on the web unless the client insists.
I too would block hotmail out of choice, but it ain't commercially viable!
by jdclyde
If you commit a crime in one country, as long as you can be brought to that country you can be charged.
Even if that crime was done from your computer where it is legal, you still committed a crime once you sent your spam to areas where their are laws against it. Just need to make sure their aren't extradition laws before you can think you are safe just by crossing a border.
by codejock
Sure, all IPs that start with the following are prevented from making connections on port 25 at the server.
Similarly, mail headers are scanned for origination or relay through the blocks that start with the same numbers.
60.
61.
139.
200.
202.
203.
210.
211.
218.
219.
220.
221.
222.
Make sure any filters check only the start of the IP address in a received line. You don't want to ban an IP because they have one of those numbers elsewhere in the IP address (friend of mine did that and blocked a major client until he fixed the filter).
Let me know how how much it cuts down on APNIC originating spam. I'd be interested to know whether you see significant reductions, as I have.
P.S. I am Canadian and have a sense of humor. :) Don'tcha know, we're just a branch plant for the US, eh? :)
by a1deydreams
by deepsand
The accounts that I referenced where and are used solely for legitimate business purposes; they all began receiving copius quantities of spam immediately following their activation.
The same is observed on certain MSN.com e-mail accounts.
by stevebuck
to block Hotmail from the company all by yourself? What kind of business does your company do? Is your CEO aware of your actions and the consquences it could be having on biz? What leads does your sales force follow if they are blocked? You don't get business leads from any hotmail accounted customers? (Well good for you.)
Our MIS cannot block one single mail here because it could be a false positive, and that especially includes Hotmail. Yes, many people and small businesses outside of North America use Hotmail for legitimate business. And why not? It is free, has a 250MB mailbox, makes linking with MSN Messenger easy, and has a secure SSL login that can be accessed from anywhere. Do these Hotmail users deserve less of your respect? I cannot believe that IT people in this forum are allowed to take it upon themselves to block any domain from their company servers, especially when it is obvious that most here have no clue as to the real origin of SPAM to begin with. Anyone can have a "Hotmail FROM header", without having a real Hotmail account, or Yahoo, or 163 or whatever are the favorite return addresses of spammers. But if the SPAM is not really from Hotmail's servers, what use is it blocking the domain name except to block that name only? Why blame Hotmail? Hotmail is an easy target for spammers, but the spammers don't need a real Hotmail account to send their SPAM (and Hotmail servers wouldn't allow it anyway). All they need is some poor shmucks open relay or virus infected SMTP engine to send as many million messages as they want, completely undetected. If you really get a SPAM from Hotmail and the originating IP is a Hotmail server, then report it!! Hotmail will terminate that user's account almost immediately, because contrary to what is believed, MS hates SPAM too.
If you do a little research you will find the most effective method to fight SPAM is by "graylisting". This uses the fact that a legitimate mail server will retry on an initial delivery failure, while a SPAMMER will give up on the first try. It will introduce a slight delay to mail delivery, but known good mail can then be "whitelisted" for future speedy delivery.
http://www.onlamp.com/pub/a/onlamp/2004/05/20/mail_filtering.html?page=2
by zczc23119
The whole concept of .NET services
Please indulge me for a moment and let?s look at a few user/admin fundamentals.
1. What a user is permitted to create, they must also be able to modify, or delete or view (after security validations are met.)
Firstly I hope you agree with the above, because if you don?t your not an administrator of a enterprise or Network.
Could some one please tell me how to achieve the following?
After I create me hotmail account, how do I delete it?
After I place a credit card in my passport, how do I remove it?
After I supply alternate email accounts, how do I view them in fact how do I view ALL the information that is contained in my .NET passport?
How do I delete an alternate email account that is in my .NET passport?
What information does get passed to others if I elect to sign in with my. NET account?
For all those XP Professionals there is a really nice security setting in ?Local Security Settings?, ?Security options? ? Do not allow storage of credentials or .NET passport for Network authentication?
I always enable this option.
Bottom line ? If you a company you have a company mail box for company purposes. You also have a PC and massive investment in technology for company purposes ? why have a hotmail address in a company environment?
- If you are at home, your ISP will provide you with at least 1 email address free, I have 4 address which I use for different priorities and I can log onto Web mail anywhere in the world with no space restrictions.
Why do I need a Hotmail address?
by jdclyde
60. China
61. India
200. COLOMBIA
202. AUSTRALIA
203. AUSTRALIA
210. AUSTRALIA
211. Japan
218. China
219. Japan
220. Japan
221. China
222. Japan
The rest using http://www.dnsstuff.com were easy to find and I have clearance from the boss to block these.
Can you help me determine where the 139.0.0.0 range is from? Need to show that before I am allowed to block.
Thanks! between the e-mail masking on the web sites and this, I should finally be able to make a dent in the crap coming in.
NOTE: as a Canadian, didn't you misspell humour? Someone might think you were a damn yank or something. lol!
(thanks again)
by stevebuck
by codejock
Yes, they are broad. Before criticizing, read the original post it was based on. I provided the basis of why those IP blocks are used.
To acknowledge the technical point, 139.x.x.x should not be on the list. It's not part of our denial filters. Again, we don't do business with Germany so the likelihood of receiving e-mail from that part of the net is remote. I point out, again, we provide alternate means for legitimate interested customers to reach us via our Web form.
Your reply contains several baseless assumptions. I would characterize it as a "knee-jerk" reaction to the reply with the IPv4 blocks I provided without having read the original post.
1. I am the boss. For my own domains, these IPv4 blocks (except 139 as noted) are denied connections to port 25 in accordance with RFC 2821 with a 550 error.
2. The effect of creating a Canadian intranet is baseless. We accept connections from mail exchangers elsewhere in the world. Read the original post before you spout off.
3. Thousands of spam messages were analysed for patterns in origination IPs. We've received thousands of spam messages from KR, JP, CN, and TW.
4. I don't care if you can't reach us by e-mail. You get a 550 error telling you an alternate means of communication. What part of we don't do business with APNIC/LACNIC countries did you miss in the original post?
5. I don't care how you feel about blocking IP ranges. "Feelings" are not a primary basis for deciding action. I care about results. Blocking those ranges has resulted in such a drop in spam that what little is getting through can be adequately managed by the limited human resources I have.
6. Spammers do NOT pay for the bandwidth, added storage, and processing equipment I MUST procure to deal with their garbage. They don't pay for the personnel time wasted having to filter through or delete their crap. They don't care that I have to buy larger drives. They hose the entire Internet with their fecal matter hoping some of it will stick. Obviously enough does to make it apparently lucrative (though I think the returns are diminishing, hence the increase in volumes seen recently). Filtering is having an effect.
Further, you don't pay for it either. If you think the policy is so unfair, then you're welcome to put your money where your mouth is and pay for it. Then you can dictate to me what my policies are.
7. To restate something from my original post, "Your freedom of expression ends at my network boundary." I'll even go one further, "My staff expresses themselves in a manner consistant with my policies or they find somewhere else to work." Censorship can only be performed by governments and not private individuals or companies.
8. I don't force my views on ISPs in Korea, Taiwan, China or Japan or anywhere else. If an ISP chooses to host spammers on their systems, then I choose to block them.
(Oh and since you don't have the statistics at your desposal: we have not received a single piece of legitimate e-mail from servers in the APNIC IPv4 address block for 2 years. Not one. Chew on that.)
by codejock
by jdclyde
My company manufactures concrete pipe and other similar products. We will NEVER do business with anyone but our state, and the states that are directly connected to us (and that big place up north of the border, can't remember what it was called.....)
So blocking e-mail from other countries would never impact me where I am now. The only problem is my current firewall won't allow blocking by a range (I can't believe it either) so I will be looking to add an access list to our router to drop them.
We literally get about 600 Spam messages EVERYday, and only half get blocked out by our spam filter.
Short of commando raids on spammers, this seems like the next best option.
by codejock
by codejock
Humour, neighbour, flavour, eh?
American English is pretty much the standard for the Internet. In courses I took regarding Web design and development, instructors said that most people who learn English as a second language and use the Web tended to learn American English (something about being the lingua franca).
I could write my replies in French but that would create a whole different set of problems. / Je pourrais ?crire mes r?ponses en fran?ais mais cela cr?erait un ensemble diff?rent de probl?mes.
by cactus pete
Does your HR department allow people to email into the office about days they expect to be absent? What about an employee who is out of the office [on vacation] who is asked an important question... they decide to write in to the boss from a hotmail account...
The scenarios where legitimate communications from hotmail.com occur abound.
by jaqui
then why does microsoft passport aka hotmail
insist on using html formatting for email?
if it's a legitimate email it will be plain text format.
no pictures or coloured text.
no attachments.
plain text.
by jdclyde
I need my pretty coloured text and pictures and attachements.
I can't really stress to the boss (who I am too sick to call but not too sick to log into MSN and write them a letter?) of just how sick I am?
While it is remotely possible there are valid reasons not to ban hotmail, their are many valid reasons to ban it.
In conclusion, I do not think I will do the hotmail ban. I did do the country banning of China/Japan/India/Colmbia/Australia, so it will be interesting to see how the logs look in a few daze.
by stevebuck
by codejock
Hollywood North
Canuck Country
The 51st State
The Great White North
Land of Igloos and Mounties
The Northern Discount Drug Store
Thunderin' Tundra
Snowshoe Country
The Nation Hudson's Bay Company Built
Taxation Town
The True North Strong and Free
Molson's Mooseland
Home of the Two Solitudes
Poutine Palace
Last but not the least, Canada (meaning "village" - isn't that what they called the place they stowed Number 6 in "The Prisoner"?)
And to those of us living here, it's "Home". :D
by noel.moyes
by zczc23119
Once upon a time I had a .NET passport with 1 hotmail addresses in it and my credit card details were in place to provide billing purposes for ninemsn premium, whilst I loved the product it is far too ahead of its time and required over 200 exceptions to my software firewall to function. Express purchase was then in place and my credit details were abused by people who had access to shaded information, dependant on that particular provider and I lost over AUD3000.00, because I clicked on a button without reading the individual privacy policy for that provider - My misstate.
Now I cancelled my subscription to nine msn premium which was built on ***************@hotmail.com....and indeed this address is no longer valid.
However the duplicate details have been transferred to my alternate hotmail address ##############@hotmail.com, and my partners email address ????????????@hotmail.com, however in the latter the credit card details are not present.
Now I am faced with 2 problems.
I cannot cancel my hotmail account #########@hotmail.com as in my .NET profile is the duplicate cancelled ninemsn Premium account still with billing information in it, and I want to cancel that hotmail address also but the system wont allow it - as there is a cancelled ninemsn premium service in place including billing information.
My partner cannot cancel his hotmail account ???????????????@hotmail.com as I granted a second user and details of a cancelled subscription to ninemsn premium is present.
No one seems to be able, let alone me to cancel ###########@hotmail.com and my partner ???????????????@hotmail.com as .NET services have gone made and I have no faith in them.
After investigation and reading the fine print. I am NOT permitted by the aggrement I entered into to cancell my account untill 90 days grace period elapses after the signing up of the service...In essance its my error. Always read the fine print
We block the entire Yahoo domain - as well as a few others. If anyone is considering to do real business with us with a Yahoo mail account, odds are they're not a player.
For our customers - there's a form they can fill out on our website.
And we don't even give people the courtesy of an NDR. Why should I make my mail gateway work harder or eat up bandwidth on my T1 to tell someone to get a real mail account?
by deepsand
I've some serious clients who would seriously disagree with you.
If pressed to, they might even seriouly considered inflicting serious harm on you.
Your's may be a "real" business, but you've obviously got a real problem with both your atitude and knowledge & understanding of the way real people think and act.
by paul681
Wow, and what do you say about people who shop at discount stores and not the Macy's of the world.
We to have some customers that use Yahoo and yes, they are Real players.
Thinking like yours is going to cost the company eventually.
by deepsand
this post was directed at twilson, not myself.
It is quite instructive to view here, & in other discussions, how many people, from which one would expect better, make snap judgements based on the flimsiest evidence & for the most irrational of reasons.
by curlergirl
by /usr
by the admiral
Your not the only one. Anything from Hotmail immediately goes into the shredder without even being looked at.
Dominofiles.com has agents that are pretty good at whacking SPAM as it comes in, so you can look there.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending