Discussion Locked

Are your users' home machines secured when they connect to the office?

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
According to a recent survey (https://www.techrepublic.com.com/2100-1009_11-5986344.html) by America Online and the National Cyber Security Alliance, 81 percent of home PC users lack at least one of three critical types of security, but the number of consumers using firewalls and updated antivirus software is improving. What percentage of your users do you think are protected when they connect to the corporate network? Have you taken any steps to help them or put policies in place?

26 replies

by stevegrieshaber

We only allow Corporate equipment i.e laptops with approved Firewall and AV software to connect via the corporate VPN. We also have policy in place governing the use of the VPN and corporate resources. Whilst this keeps us pretty secure, updating these can be a nightmare and we do miss some machines in our automated update process, which can pose a risk.

We are now finding that our users are increasingly being asked to work outside the office environment, whether from home or in the field and that we need to rethink the whole mobile/flexible working area.

by sandym

I am an outsourced sysadmin working for / with an in house IT Manager. He lets home users connect to the network and makes them agree to follow a comprehensive sheet of instructions.

I don't believe you can trust users to follow instructions even on something this fundamental and am just waiting for the first virus intrusion - or worse.

If people need to access the corporate network they should do it with corporate machines that have all necessary protection updated (as it is around here) automatically and without user choice.

BTW we do use webmail, that I think is a much lower level of risk.

by pvdongen

The corporates I work with are all geared up to use simple means that perform the same checks for home PC's as for office PC's. I.e. Desktop FW, Virusscanning, policies, last scan data, virus definitions, spyware. After all that is satisfied, all that can be done is a connection to a Terminal Server is about as much as they're allowed to get.

Most tend to go even further with having managed desktops provided for the folks that work remotely, in which case the exact same rules are applied, but no-one other then the worker (so no his family) has access. Rather then selling this as a negative, people have been given a workstation for the purpose of working remote and were positively affirmed as being "special" enough to receive this "benefit in kind".

The effort here has specifically been on the people management side of the solution. Not raising the expectation that any home PC will be capable of connecting is crucial. Making sure people understand that what is suitable as a home PC is not necessarily the best fit for the corporate network does a lot to address this issue. Providing people with "corporate" remote workstations is seen as a nice incentive and also guards that you can legally put limits on the workstation (after all a home PC is not your property and therefore you can get into several issues). After 3 years writeoff you should be able to let them keep the things. If that doesn't suit you, get them a corporate laptop.

Weighed against costs for traffic jams and resulting lateness and the tendency that people work longer hours when working from home, this is a relatively cheap solution.

Again I would like to stress the technical solution is only a minor (if not substantial part) for the re?nforcement of a corporate business policy. The big job is with getting people motivated to stick with it.

by aaronk

Something else that can be considered. There are alternative technologies available instead of the traditional VPN devices. There are SSL VPN devices that when connected, can scan a client computer for specific executables (ie, a virus scanner, a firewall, etc) and if those executables aren't running, won't allow the connection. Or, you could use Citrix that provides access through a SSL web page. A user gets access to their applications as if they were in the office, but their computer isn't attached to your network.

by gedda_g

We use VPN, SSL VPN and Citrix. The combo of all three allows for many different levels of access although it can be troublesome to manage all three. We hope to drop VPN with in the next 6 months since SSL provides much of the same functionality and is far easier for our users to work with. And with SSL VPN a users' access to the network can be more finely controlled.

by troyh

Thanks for the suggestions. Concerning Citrix, is it a safe product to run without SSL......as in a traditional setup where the home computer is running the Citrix client software to connect to the remote Metaframe server instead of it running it through a browser with SSL ?

by vmwarez

VMWare has come out with a new product last year (or early this year, i don't remember) that lets you insure that when your remote users come in, they are coming from an environmment that is exactly what you have defined. It is called vmware ace. Basically, you create a vm for them to use, set a bunch of policies on it to keep it they way you like it and then, they run this virtual computer from their computer at home... when they enter your network, they are using their ace pc, not their home pc. so no matter how bad their home pc is, as long as it can run the ace player, they have a secure connection. check them out... http://www.vmware.com/products/ace/

Jim
a vmware nut...
www.vmwarez.com

by vmwarez

and let me say just one more thing. end users don't want their own computer to be "locked down" so that it can securely access the company network. If security isn't an inconvenience for them, they're ok with it... but don't expect them to let us come in and turn their home pc into a company pc.

by craig_b

I agree that most home computers are not up to corporate standards. Companies seem to want you to work from home. So what is the answer, the company should provide you with a computer\vpn access for business use only. However most companies don't want to pay for this equipment but still want you to do more work from home. So people use their home computers to connect and we have the current problem.

by demroyer

I agree completely. In my company, the owner wants everyone to have access to anything on the network from home - however, the company does not want to pay for any home equipment. We recently put a Work From Home policy into effect, which encourages many users to access the network from their home PCs on the days they opt to work from home (not to mention all the management level people who have been regularly working from home during off hours for years). Basically the deal is "you can work from home occasionally as long as you provide all your own equipment". My team is trying to piece together appropriate security policies and "recommendations" for home PCs, but since HR launched the WFH policy before we had the IT policies in place we are playing catch-up. We are looking to implement a solution that will perform some level of scanning when a user establishes a VPN connection, and will disallow the connection if a firewall or virus scanner is not running on the remote box. Even so, I find myself crossing my fingers and praying that someone doesn't unleash some malevolent virus/malware from their home PC, despite the precautions we've already (and will continue to) put in place.

Given the Executive level position on this issue (it's better to let users have as much access as they need from wherever they happen to be), I don't think we'll ever be 100% secure - hopefully through education, technology, and policies though, we'll be able to maintain a reasonable level of protection while allowing a flexible environment.

by tantor

eeek.

I would no sooner unlock the loading dock door over the weekend than allow users to connect to my network with machines I don't own and control. That's insane.

Complete security is a myth, and good security people analyze risk and figure what level is acceptable. And any machine I don't control on my network is unacceptable.

I don't even allow my users to connect *my* machines to our VPN without them acknowledging and signing off on an acceptable use policy and secure home router configuration guide. We use two factor identification, and limit resource access through the VPN subnet (No confidential/proprietary data is accessible via any VPN connection, it's all on a different Server).

We are just getting underway on our NAC (Network Admission Control) initiative which will help us catch what has already fallen through the cracks.

I'd go insane if I had to allow unchecked machines on my network.

by teligence

The bottom line for business is to make a profit. There are primarily 2 ways to increase your bottom line - increase sales and reduce expenditures. While IT is not in the sales arena we are tasked with providing a cost-effective means of connectivity - among other things. While there is something to say (and I won't say it here) for administration allowing or endorsing personal computing resources (not just limited to PCs, but now also handhelds, mobile phones,etc.) they are often lack security concerns.

In the last 18 months we have replaced all of our 150+ dissimilar OSes, PCs and laptops with one of 2 basic configurations. It is almost unbelievable how much the standards-based computers have reduced the support demand. To allow re-implentation of home PCs is something we discourage - to say the least.

Regardless of what users agree to, they - more often than not - are absolutely clueless regarding the real or potential threat of an unsecured PC.

by kevinkfred

I provide about 1 1/2 dozen IT staff and remote salemen with VPN connectivity into our corporate network (I use mine 15 to 20 hours a week from home). Several members of another department want access via the VPN also - one I have had to deny again and again - she has brought her home PC in three times in the past year and a half for me to cleanse / nuke and re-install due to her family's "browsing habits". And she seems incredulous that I won't provide her with VPN access even after explaining my concerns !!! Some folks will never understand the concept of a secure and safe PC and the steps required to ensure it.

by bchan

Since it is difficult to Police every remote access end-user, use end-point security
technologies.
Examples:
Juniper SSL VPN appliances have a host checker option that allows you to restrict
access by antivirus parameters,antispyware,registry parameters,and keylogging and malware features.

'Cisco Clean Access' is another option that scans
your computer prior to giving you denying or giving access into the Intranet. If your system
is not compliant, it will install software onto
your system and check you again.

At our college we're using a Juniper SA-1000 for SSL VPN access. Some other colleges are using 'Cisco Clean Access.'

So far this has been working pretty good for us and the end-users.

by ttfh

This is our plan for when we allow students to connect wirelessly. All machines trying to connect will be queried - if they're up to date, they'll get in. If not, they'll either be redirected to a quarantined minimal access area and/or a web page telling them how to secure their devices. We won't force users to secure their machines, but if they don't, they won't get the access they want.

by bfelts

We only company owned and administered computers to have access (VPN or LAN) on our network. Nobody else can get access to or through our network.

by snag

AOL is the last company that should be running a survey on how unprotected PC users are. Their commercials brag about protecting members, yet they do nothing to educate those same members on running their own firewall, anti-virus or spyware software. AOL's IMs are now the focus of a new worm, yet they have sent nothing to members warning them about this.

I spent more than eight years helping AOL's members get out of trouble from not knowing how to protect themselves, while AOL convinced them they were completely safe. The most common reply was, "I never knew."

Any user connecting from home needs to have a utility installed that connects to the company server for them - after checking the system for all three forms of protection. Depending on users to educate and protect themselves is like depending on teens to always use protection, each time, every time. It just ain't gonna happen.

Paul Matthews
Los Angeles

by blueknight

Before any employee connects to our network from a remote location, whether on the road or at home, our Network Services group (handles networks, desktop and servers) makes an assessment of the user's machine to determine that the OS is supported and has all current security patches installed, the user has current anti-virus software with current signature data and all other relevant security precautions are met. If the machine passes the assessment, then the tech will install and configure the VPN software. User's also sign an agreement to maintain their system in compliance.

There is only a small handfull of authorized home users. All other machines that connect remotely are employer owned and maintained laptops and are issued only to those of us who are required to provide support at any hour.

One additional item of note is that we have worked out a deal with McAfee so that any employee can download and install the current version on their home computer free (organization picks up the minimal cost).

Will this totally protect us from security breaches? Probably not, but in the 10 years I've been here, we have not had a single instance. I look at it like that big earthquake out there in the future... it [u]will[/u] happen, we just don't know when. All you can do is to prepare the best way you know how.

by starderup

Only company assets are allowed to connect to the network, and even those are required to pass stringent checks through VPN. Cisco Trust Agent must be installed, antivirus pattern file must be updated, and the Officescan firewall must be enabled.
Home computers have web access to timesheets and email, but that's it.

by wtdriscoll

The wonderful thing about Windows2003 is that you can now quarantine remote access users that access through the VPN. Set policies on firewalls, virus protection settings and if they do not have it or are OUT OF DATE, it will deny access. That is your POLICY today. NOT UP TO DATE! UNLUCKY.... Best thing that has come out of Microsoft in my book for protection against sloppy home users.

by wtdriscoll

The wonderful thing about Windows2003 is that you can now quarantine remote access users that access through the VPN. Set policies on firewalls, virus protection settings and if they do not have it or are OUT OF DATE, it will deny access. That is your POLICY today. NOT UP TO DATE! UNLUCKY.... Best thing that has come out of Microsoft in my book for protection against sloppy home users.

by wtdriscoll

The wonderful thing about Windows2003 is that you can now quarantine remote access users that access through the VPN. Set policies on firewalls, virus protection settings and if they do not have it or are OUT OF DATE, it will deny access. That is your POLICY today. NOT UP TO DATE! UNLUCKY.... Best thing that has come out of Microsoft in my book for protection against sloppy home users.

by sfarhanj

The best way to secure your home PC is to regularly check for security updates from microsoft and your antivirus should also be up to date. Firewall should be enabled, use any third party firewall like zone alarm, sygate personal firewall, etc. You should also have a know-how that how many applications are running in your system processes.

Must install Anti Spyware software, Spybot Search & Destroy or Ad-aware Professional are the best anti spyware softwares i have ever seen. Update them and scan your systems on a regular basis or once in a week.

by sfarhanj

The best way to secure your home PC is to regularly check for security updates from microsoft and your antivirus should also be up to date. Firewall should be enabled, use any third party firewall like zone alarm, sygate personal firewall, etc. You should also have a know-how that how many applications are running in your system processes.

Must install Anti Spyware software, Spybot Search & Destroy or Ad-aware Professional are the best anti spyware softwares i have ever seen. Update them and scan your systems on a regular basis or once in a week.

by liquidxit2

I dont allow anyone to know the login and pass to VPN. I will shortly be allowing the owner to do so after I "tweak" her new computer and install syamntec corp edition as well asinstalling a cisco compatible firewall vpn tunnel. After said business Ill feel safe allowing her to remote access. But as of now Im the only account in active dir that has remote assitance enabled.

by whatsauser

Fortunately, at present, we only have 3 of these user types. So, requesting a minimum of Zonealarm plus AVG be installed on their pc's isn't too problematical as these are free. Plus I insist on an acceptable print screen from the results of Steve Gibson's Shield's Up program prior to giving access.
I also provide them with a different user account - same name, just different context - providing more control over what they can access, on a need to know type basis.

This discussion is closed to new replies.