Discussion Locked

e-mail monitoring

0 helpful
12 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
In our latest poll, we asked if you use software to monitor internal e-mail. Use this space to expound on your feelings of employee e-mail monitoring.

12 replies

by av .

To me, email monitoring serves several purposes. Its main purpose is to make sure that people are working and they aren't sending email that is offensive. Also, so much business today is conducted via email, its important to have an audit trail.

Even though employees may know they are being monitored, it doesn't seem to deter some of them from sending and receiving some really questionable stuff. Some people treat email like IM so they end up with 100 personal emails a day. It is amazing to me that they have time to work! I can only manage a couple of personal emails a week because I have no time.

Its an uncomfortable part of my job to have to deal with people like that because, in the end, they are just plain addicted to email and they always go back to their old ways. The worst thing is if their management is generally happy with them and looks the other way. It causes a morale problem for other workers and its more work for me because I have to monitor them more closely.

I really don't think that email monitoring should be the responsibility of IT. If you work in a smaller company though, everything IT comes to you.

by jmgarvin

Gotta do it. Part of the problem is that when harrassing or inappropriate emails are passed back and forth to users, the company can be libel.

Another part of the issue is that employees tend to abuse the system. They send huge attachments or use their email at work for their own private endevors.

After the whole Enron/WorldCom/et al fiasco, you HAVE to keep emails and monitor them.

by ana_ferreira

I believe it is important for a company to know exactly the way their employees work. Their work dynamics help the success of the company itself. It all should work to the company, so the goals could be reached. And if a certain employee doesn't work "with the company", he should be analized and discussed by various people of the company. His role on the company should be redifined, so that the company and all the employees could work to the same goals.

by the admiral

Being a former system operator, the legalities of connecting to a system and using it are the same for email systems.

I had every right to sit there and have every single keystroke logged and used against the person in a court of law if that was the case. Unfortunately, I never did.

However, employees need to know this: If the system is a company asset, it is subject to audits that a) are not contained in the employee handbook b) when it happens, they can take the system to a company and do datamining on it to find all email.

In otherwords, unless your are 100% sure that the company IT department is stupid or incapable of finding email (alot of folks believe that email don't go through a server) then it is best kept on your personal servers and email clients.

As the owners of the systems, they have every right to have an eagle eye, or sherlocks eye.

by christian

As the CEO of my network (the findwerk is not a medium sized web company but a medium sized online network) I am responsible, that my partners get done with their tasks by the time and that they do not feel monitored.

Of course I cannot allow all sorts of communication on our servers. But I think, that's not a big deal: we provide for our fellow findwerkers a separate E-Mail Adress for their private junk. This does cost nothing if compared to the result: business E-Mail accounts stay for doing business only and all of us got an account for a website and up to ten E-Mail accounts for personal use. Until now, this model works fine for me (it did work since 2001 like this) and everyone does use his/hers accounts in a proper manner. All for 5 bucks a month/findwerker. Not much money for avoiding frustrations and endless scanning procedures....

by thebassman

I know that some people in the workspace consider that scanning ond blocking of email is a infringement of their human rights but it is prerequsite in the modern world, It is a sad world that needs this kind of protection, firewalls and AV software should not be required. It is a sad trait in the human that we cannot trust eachother...

by usbport1

I work for a relatively small company (40 users) and I'm the only IT/Telecommunications tech here. I don't have enough time to checkup on everyone's e-mail let alone their online activity. We had all employees read and sign a company IT policy paper (downloaded from TechRepublic) telling them what was expected of them using the company's network and it's IT assets. It also warned them that the company had the right to check or monitor all e-mail and online behavior. If it came to my attention that someone was abusing our IT policies then I would investigate it (and I have had to do it a few times) but otherwise they're on their own. I have a friend who works for a company who's only job is to monitor an Exchange server all day as well as spot checking e-mail and tweaking the spam filter. Talk about repetitive and boring.

by roscojim

I hear and understand all of the excuses - we could be sued, they should be working, blah, blah, blah. I think it stinks. If your employees aren't getting work done, fire them and get new ones. Don't use that as an excuse to monitor e-mail.

Also, the only reason we have the stupid lawsuits is because our government lets the scumbag attorneys get away with it. Ban the lawsuits, the lawyers go away, and there are no more problems.

I would never monitor my employees e-mail. If they aren't getting work done, they're gone - plain and simple.

by jsilva2911

Most of times there's no only an abuse in e-mail use, but also in IM... this is a great factor in productivity decrease... I have to monitor the use of these resources, and moreover, check the way of use of the e-mail client... it happends that with some stuffs (like preliminar view, in Outlook), a virus or SpyWare enters easily to a network, saturating it or even dropping it down. The fact is not if monitor or not, but if the people knows how to use networking resources...

by philip golan

Bosses charged if they snoop
By Simon Hayes
May 05, 2005
From:
EMPLOYERS will face criminal charges if they illegally spy on workers' emails under legislation introduced in New South Wales parliament.

NSW is the first state to move on "tech snooping", with Victoria and South Australia understood to be considering similar legislation.

The Workplace Surveillance Bill introduced last night means employers will be required to notify staff of any monitoring unless they have a court order.

The bill also prevents employers blocking emails and websites involving industrial relations and union activity.

Advertisement:
Attorney-General Bob Debus said the Carr Government would not tolerate employers "snooping" on their staff with email scanners and GPS tracking technology.

The new laws will make it a criminal offence to take part in any form of covert surveillance unless an employer can prove they had reasonable suspicion of wrongdoing by an employee.

According to email and web monitoring software company Surf Control, about 30per cent of employers with more than 100 staff monitor the content of emails.

Most use commercial monitoring packages that can track emails and scan their content for restricted phrases, then issue an alert.

The NSW Chamber of Commerce warned that the legislation could force some employers to restrict access to the internet.

But unions and civil liberties groups welcomed the proposal, saying staff were often unaware their emails were being read by the boss.

"Lots of people have no idea how widespread monitoring is, and most of us have no idea what the technology can already do," Unions NSW deputy assistant secretary Alison Peters said.

The NSW Council for Civil Liberties hailed the bill as a "sensible step forward".

http://www.news.com.au/story/0,10117,15182938-2,00.html

This discussion is closed to new replies.