Discussion Locked

Exchange 5.5 to Exchange 2000 migration

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm looking for some suggestions for the best way to upgrade my existing environment to Exchange 2000. I am currently running a WinNT 4.0 (SP6)server with Exchange Server 5.5 installed(strictly email and user space) and a Win 2000 server which hosts our business software (main app). The NT 4 is a domain server and the Win 2000 is setup just as a workgroup server (Active Directory is not installed). My plan is to purchase a new server to host the Exchange 2000. Should I setup this new serveras the domain controller in the active directory and just add the existing Win 2000 as a member server or vice versa? Or could I just leave the existing Win 2000 as a workgroup server?

3 replies

by timwalsh

You actually have (potentially) 2 issues here:

1. Migration of your NT4 domain to Win2K and Active Directory.
2. Migration of Exchange from 5.5 to 2000.

Couple of non-breakable rules for Active Directory (AD):
1. An AD Domain Controller(DC) CANNOT exist in an NT4 domain.
2. An NT4 PDC CANNOT exist in an AD domain (although NT4 BDCs can).
3. Installing AD on any Win2K server creates a DC.
4. To successfully migrate an NT4 domain to Win2K (and AD), you MUST install Win2K on the NT4 PDC (will not work on a BDC).

Another issue: AD MUST be accessible someplace on the network before Exchange 2000 can be installed. Exchange 2000 doesn't need to be installed on a Win2K DC.

As I see it, you essentially have 2 choices to proceed with:
1. Create a totally separate AD domain (complete with users) and install Exchange 2000 in that domain. Create a trust relationship between that domain and your current NT4 domain. Conduct an inter-domain migration of mailboxes fromone Exchange server to the other. This is a lot of work for no reall additional gain in usabilty and efficiency.
2. Migrate your NT4 domain to Win2K and AD by installing Win2K on your current NT4 PDC. Install Exchange 2000 on your new server as an additional server in your current Exchange site (your choice as to whether to make this new server a DC or not). Move mailboxes from your old Exchange server to the new one. This is the option I would suggest. BTW, if your existing Win2K serveris joined to the NT4 domain, it will automatically be joined to the new AD organization. If it isn't currently joined to the domain, it is a simple matter to do so after the domain migration.

Hope this helps.

This discussion is closed to new replies.