Discussion Locked

"Government Access to Phone Calling Activity and Related Records:

0 helpful
21 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/intel/RL33424.pdf

Ok, I've tried to read this and I will probably spend another week trying to read this.

[i]The statutes that enable the government to gain legal access to telephone records, whether for law enforcement or intelligence purposes, are examined in a newly updated report from the Congressional Research Service.

The report also discusses prohibitions on access to, or disclosure of, such records, along with exceptions to the prohibitions.[/i]

This is NOT from a newspaper, this is what congress is seeing. I consider this to be more authoritative then anything else I have read on the issue.

I think both people for and against the NSA program should read this, because I think it does remove some of the media hype and provides much more factual information.

Now if I could only wrap my hands around it, and understand wtf they are saying. Christ, this is going to take me a week to understand.

Dan

As a follow up, this is worth reading also:

[i]"Terrorist Capabilities for Cyberattack: Overview and Policy Issues," updated January 22, 2007:[/i]

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/terror/RL33123.pdf

21 replies

by dawgit

And I agree, it will need some time to digest. Also the sourse might some further looking into. I have heard of this organization, but it's been a while. Very Interesting for this to come up now. ?:| The real question though, is does anyone in the Congress realy read any of this? -d

by danlm

The point of the newsletter I belong to by them is that they believe too much information is made secret. Their political agenda seems more to the release of information then anything else.

They release information on various white papers the pentagon does, cia risk assessment, things like that. To be truthful, I get a newsletter from them a couple times a week. This really wasn't anything different. It was a paper that they got their hands on, that a normal citizen doesn't.. And they posted it... If you want, I can paste like 4 of their latest newsletter links they provide to try and show you what I mean. It's very diverse in the links they post. But the common theme is that it is information that is not readibly avaible, which they are making so.

Dan

This is what was in 02/22/2007 newsletter for links of released papers:
Some other notable CRS products obtained by Secrecy News that are not
readily available in the public domain include these:

"Armenia, Azerbaijan, and Georgia: Security Issues and Implications
for U.S. Interests," updated February 1, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL30679.pdf

"Vienna Convention on Consular Relations: Overview of U.S.
Implementation and International Court of Justice (ICJ)
Interpretation of Consular Notification Requirements," May 17, 2004:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL32390.pdf

"Pipeline Safety and Security: Federal Programs," updated January 25,
2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/homesec/RL33347.pdf

"Russian Political, Economic, and Security Issues and U.S.
Interests," updated January 18, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL33407.pdf

"Terrorist Capabilities for Cyberattack: Overview and Policy
Issues," updated January 22, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/terror/RL33123.pdf

And the previous newsletter:
ULING IN AIPAC CASE INTERPRETS ESPIONAGE ACT NARROWLY

In the unprecedented prosecution of two former officials of the
American Israel Public Affairs Committee (AIPAC), a federal court
last year upheld the government's controversial claim that the
Espionage Act could be used to prosecute the unauthorized receipt
and transmittal of classified information by private citizens who
are not engaged in espionage.

But as the case proceeds, the court continues to interpret the
Espionage Act in a restrictive manner that places an increasing
burden of proof on the prosecution, and that could even make the
case a source of embarrassment for the government by exposing
sensitive "back channel" diplomatic practices.

In a decision last week, Judge T.S. Ellis, III, denied a defense
motion asking the court to compel testimony from Israeli
government officials.

http://www.fas.org/sgp/jud/rosen021407.pdf

But along the way, the court also elaborated its demanding view of
the requirements that the prosecution must meet to win a conviction
under the Espionage Act, and indicated what sorts of facts might
tend to exculpate the defendants.

"To prove the alleged conspiracy to disclose [national defense
information, or NDI] to one not authorized to receive it, the
government must prove all of the following," wrote Judge Ellis, at
the beginning of a list of prosecutorial hurdles (at page 8) that
reiterates and expands upon the requirements first spelled out in
his August 2006 order denying a motion to dismiss the case.

Among other things, the government must prove that "defendants
possessed all the culpable mental states that would be necessary
for conviction under [the Espionage Act]," which include four
distinct states of knowledge or belief (at page 9).

Briefly, prosecutors must show that the defendants knew the
information involved was closely held and could harm the United
States; that it could be used to the injury of the United States or
to the advantage of a foreign nation; that the recipients of the
information were not authorized to receive it; and that the
defendants acted with knowledge that the disclosures were illegal
and could harm national security.

But if the defense can show that U.S. government officials
frequently disclosed confidential information to AIPAC for
transmittal to the Israeli government, the court observed, that
would mean the defendants could have plausibly believed such
behavior was authorized.

If "the governments of the United States and Israel routinely used
AIPAC as a diplomatic 'back channel' [to convey sensitive
information]" that would be "potentially exculpatory" since it
could "affect defendants' perception of the propriety of any
disclosures made by or to them."

The nature of the relationship between the governments of the U.S.
and Israel may also have a bearing on the defendants' state of
mind, the Judge wrote, in language that may foreshadow close
scrutiny of U.S.-Israel relations at trial:

"The more specific the details of the alleged cooperation between
the two governments, the more probative [i.e., legally
significant] such cooperation becomes," Judge Ellis wrote. (p. 14)

In another important observation, the judge wrote that "testimony
that disclosures of alleged NDI were viewed by defendants, or their
contacts in the diplomatic establishment, as beneficial to the
United States' interests is exculpatory." (p. 13)

Similar reasoning would imply that if a news organization published
classified information in the belief that doing so was beneficial
to the United States, that would take it beyond the scope of the
Espionage Act's prohibitions on unauthorized disclosure of national
defense information.

The trial of defendants Steven J. Rosen and Keith Weissman is
scheduled to begin on or around June 4 in the Eastern District of
Virginia.

A separate ruling from Judge Ellis last week denied a defense
request to suppress statements made by defendants to FBI agents on
grounds that the agents used trickery or deception to elicit the
statements.

http://www.fas.org/sgp/jud/rosen021407b.pdf

The two rulings were first reported in the New York Sun on February
16.

NEW IC DIRECTIVE ON INTELLIGENCE ANALYSIS

Intelligence analysis "must be objective and independent of
political considerations," according to a new "capstone" directive
issued by the Director of National Intelligence.

The directive establishes the policy framework for intelligence
analysis and defines a set of methodological standards and
expectations, with an emphasis on inter-agency collaboration and
outreach.

"The IC will seldom have the requisite depth and breadth of
expertise to provide all of the insights and detailed answers
demanded by our customers. To satisfy their needs, the IC must tap
outside expertise and build and expand relationships with
non-intelligence government agencies, academic, business,
non-governmental organizations (NGOs), and think tank communities,
both domestically and internationally, while addressing the
counterintelligence and security obligations that are inherent to
such initiatives."

See "Management, Integration, and Oversight of Intelligence
Community Analysis," Intelligence Community Directive (ICD) 200,
January 8, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/irp/dni/icd/icd-200.pdf

Also new is "Intelligence Community Update to DCID 6/11, 'Controlled
Access Program Oversight Committee'," Intelligence Community Policy
Memorandum (ICPM) 2006-700-10, January 12, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/irp/dni/icpm/2006-700-10.pdf

SELECTED CRS REPORTS

Some recently updated reports of the Congressional Research Service
that are not readily available in the public domain include the
following.

"U.S. Foreign Aid to East and South Asia: Selected Recipients,"
updated January 3, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RL31362.pdf

"NATO's Prague Capabilities Commitment," updated January 24, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/row/RS21659.pdf

"Ballistic Missile Defense: Historical Overview," updated January 5,
2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/weapons/RS22120.pdf

"Islamic Religious Schools, Madrasas: Background," updated January
23, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RS21654.pdf

"The Islamic Traditions of Wahhabism and Salafiyya," updated January
17, 2007:

http://www.fas.org/sgp/crs/misc/RS21695.pdf

Though the general public is not permitted access to the
congressional database of CRS reports online, these same reports
can be purchased from a private vendor for about $4000 per year,
the Washington Post noted yesterday.

"How I get them is my trade secret . . . but I get them all," said
Walt Seager, who digs up the reports for Gallery Watch, a
legislative tracking service.

See "Information, Please" by Elizabeth Williamson, Washington Post,
February 19:

http://tinyurl.com/2hjayn

In fact, however, Gallery Watch only gets those reports that are for
common use by all Congressional offices. It does not provide the
significant fraction of reports that are performed for the use of
an individual Member. For the same reason, the claim by Gallery
Watch that its reports provide some kind of advance insight into
the Congressional agenda is exaggerated. Most of the reports it
offers are updates of existing publications, along with others that
are mostly undertaken at the initiative of CRS itself, not Members
of Congress.

What is true is that current congressional policy on CRS reports
promotes a kind of checkbook democracy, in which corporations,
other large institutions and wealthy individuals have exclusive or
preferred access to CRS products, while the general public is left
to fend for itself.

So, when I look at this newsletter... I consider it pretty a political with their primary concern being the openness of more information.

by danlm

They waste money asking for it, then never do anything with it unless it meets their political agenda. No matter what party it is.

Dan

by dawgit

Thanks, I did have a chance to check some of that out, it was the Lawer / Legal group (Legislative Attorneys, American Law Division) that had me wondering. How are they, or are they, connected to the CRS? That connection between the two I haven't found yet. -d

by deepsand

Can you provide details re. how to get this newsletter, how delivered, its frequency, its size, cost, etc..?

by danlm

Sorry about the flood. hehehehehe, oops.

Sorry, my mind is in Las Vegas... Heard someone talking about it wednesday at noon. I had a trip booked for me and the better half by Friday.

I must be out of my freaken mind.

Dan

by dawgit

You're Crazy :p Vegas? no thanks, I just seems to me to be a place to be avoided at all costs. A Diseny Land for adults, and I don't like that concept at all. Of course, with casinos everywhere in Europe, that is not a big thing to most of us here. I can not see a valid reason for Las Vegas to even be. (out side of the Air Base, which isn't what it used to be either.)
Oh well, I'm done ranting, have fun :p I've got some reading to do. (presently dealing with a paper on Socialogical Issues in the Post VN USA. And I keep getting thrown back to 'Abnormal' Physcology. :_| it's starting to p|$$ me off. X-( ) -d

edited due to pooooor spooling.

by deepsand

Instead, if they read anything, they rely on abstracts prepared by their staffers. And, it is not unusual for the full text to not even be available prior to a vote!

Bottom line - they take someone else's word for what it is that they're voting on.

by danlm

Its a pure text newsletter with description and links to the articles.

Looking through my gmail on my past issues, they look to be delivered every 2 days...

Looking at the bottom of one of them, they provide the following information on how to get it(I don't remember, I've been getting this for a couple years).

[i]To SUBSCRIBE to Secrecy News, send email to secrecy_news-request@lists.fas.org
with "subscribe" in the body of the message.[/i]

The main web site is www.fas.org.

If I can give you anything else on the newsletter deepsand, let me know. The content of what they post is very diverse. Which really is why I like getting it. If they have a political agenda other then they feel that too much information is kept from he American Public, I haven't seen it. But, I've been known to missunderstand content before.

Dan

by deepsand

What is the average [b]size[/b] of their e-mail?

I keep using up my e-mail storage quotas on nearly every address that I get. And, while I know that I'm going to regret it - I can't keep up with all that I receive now - I'm going to subscribe. So, I may as well at least make sure I've plenty of room before hand.

by danlm

I use gmail because I hate deleting newsletters... I more often then not, remember a topic but not specifics... At least with gmail, I can do a search through all my gmail.

Dan

Ok, I'm not sure if I did this right because everything is in gmail. But, I opened one of the newsletters in a page by itself then did a properties on it...

1.06 KB (1,086 bytes)

Thats what I get... That help?

by deepsand

some with multiple accounts. But, I don't have the time to check all of them regularly, and therefore tend to use each account for certain specific purposes, so that I can prioritize them with regards to the frequency with which they need to be checked.

I was expecting that the size of these newsletter e-mails might be considerably larger; at only 1 to 2K each, I've much more flexibility than I'd expected.

I know I'm going to hate myself for creating an even bigger backlog of materials to be read, but you've whet my appetite to the point where I can't stop myself.

Damn you. And, thanks.

by danlm

I get a boat load of newsletters too... And usually don't read a lot of them... But, I do save them... Most are tech ones... From here, onlamp, some web page stuff, mysql, stuff like that..
Truthfully, I think is the only non tech newsletter I get. I save them all.... Because, sooner or latter I know I'll need something from them.

Dan

by deepsand

And, as not all of my e-mail services provide for searching the content, I'm not constrained as which accounts are used for the delivery of which newsletters if they're available for a local search.

It sounds that, like me, you subscribe to the "there's no such thing as useless information, only information that you've not yet found a use for" philosophy. Or, as my ex would say, "packrat."

In all fairness, the ex is right; and, believe or not, there is evidence to show that the tendency for such is genetically based. You should see my mother's house!

by dawgit

You just hit a whole bunch of nails on their little heads. Sometimes this place here looks like a library (only worse) and a computer center. (only more chaotic) Both at the sametime in the same place. And yup, the folks's 'Homestead' is the same. Every time we talk, I always remind them it's their fault. :^0 -d

by deepsand

I've finally reached the point where I've no choice but to purge the place of decades worth of trade publications; by my rough estimate, there's at least 6 ton of them, spread over 3 floors.

Knowing that some do contain information that has not lost value with the passage of time, I'm skimming through them, cutting out a few articles here and there. So far I've gotten through [i]Electronics Design[/i], [i]Electronic Design News[/i], [i]Computer Design[/i], [i]Electronic Sytems Design[/i], [i]LAN Magazine[/i], [i]Network Computing[/i], [i]Network Magazine[/i] and [i]Data Communications[/i], plus several more whose names escape me at the moment. Next up, [i]DEC Professional[/i], [i]UNIX Review[/i], [i]Mini-Micro Review[/i] & [i]NASA Tech Journal[/i].

Of course, there are many more that will [b]not[/b] be going under the knife.

by danlm

I've always just clicked on the links, and never really looked into the actual web site until you guy's started asking questions.

I remember going through everything when I first signed up, but since then I have only scanned the articles as I receive them looking for topics of interest.

By the way deepsand, I'm glad I could offer something back. I do read a lot of the links you post, so it's a good thing to be able to offer you something for a change.

Dan

by danlm

I may not be very articulate in my arguments, but it is not for lack of reading. I try to read anything I can get my hands on with regard to various topics.
I use to read 3 newspapers a day so that I could have different views on topics. With the Philidelphia paper being one of my favorites. Now, alas... I use web sites and hardly ever pick up a paper.

Again, thank you deepsand.

Dan

This discussion is closed to new replies.