Discussion Locked

Has anyone else been blacklisted?

0 helpful
47 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Been going through heck for over a week now.

It seems our corporate e-mail has made it onto the CBL blacklist. http://cbl.abuseat.org

They state the reasons for blacklisting can be:
Being a Relay
Infected with Netsky, Bagle, MyDoom or others.
Or if using NAT'ed addresses, then another system on the network may be sending out the SPAM.

Have taken the following steps.
Blocked SMTP from all system except the e-mail server witht the firewall.
Double checked if mail server was running as a relay.
Server runs Linux, so the above mentioned viruses do not apply.
Have scanned the network and the server for anything that looks suspicious.

All come up clean.
Request removal from list, get removed and put right back on a day later.
After getting blacklisted 4 times this week, I am starting to get upset.

Has anyone else had this problem?
How did you resolve this issue?

Would this blacklisting be illegal for them interfering with the transmission of legitamate business usage that we have paid for?

How do I stay off that list?
Is there a governing authority that this organization can be reported to?
Is there a legal authority they can be reported to?

Or do I just have to sit here and cry in my oatmeal?

47 replies

by bfilmfan

No, it isn't illegal. Just like you can tell people to not trepass on your personal property, a company has a right to reject email from your domain.

Are the workstations that are sending mail through the Linux server infected with a virus and this is the source of the issue?

Usually the blacklist lists the reason you were placed on it.

And is it your organization or your ISP that has been placed on the list? Some of the ISPs are well known for being lax on enforcing action on spammers, which might be the source of the whole issue. If you have a contract with the ISP guaranteeing a level of service, then you may well have cause for legal action.

by jdclyde

It is the IP address for our outbound traffic that has been listed, not a range.

Our firewall is set to delete all suspicious attachments.

It also has a virus scan on it.

All pc's have Antivirus running and controlled by a central AV server. Symantec Corportate ver 9.

by av .

About 8 years ago before spam was that big of an issue, I received an email from ORBS saying that our mail server was reportedly spamming and someone had complained.

I emailed ORBS back and asked them when we were supposedly doing that and they gave me the dates. It was done over one weekend.

At the time I was running Exchange 5.5 and had a MS proxy server. When I looked at the proxy logs, it showed the username and workstation IP address that was on the internet the entire weekend. It turned out that the user had signed up with a site called Onelist and she requested many different newsletters. They were really just spammers.

I was an open relay spewing spam for one weekend. The Exchange 5.5 relay configuration was confusing and it didn't have the right settings. After hearing from ORBS, I fixed it immediately with the help of a MS knowledgebase article.

After I fixed the relay problem, ORBS remotely tested my server to see if I could still relay and I tested ok so they didn't put me on the list. But, they (or their equivalent) still test my mail server twice a year randomly. A message is left in an undeliverable mail folder that my mail server passed the test every time they do. Not exactly out in the open.

It isn't illegal for them to do, but I think some of them go too far. They should at least allow you some time to investigate or fix what is wrong. They have the ability to test your server remotely to see if you are still an open relay or virus infected. Its wrong for them to just blacklist you without giving you a chance to correct the problem.

You need to email them until you get an answer about what you have to do to get permanently removed from the list. Get a name. Ask them to test your server remotely. They should take you off the list if your server is OK. ORBS worked with me, even though I ended up on the "watched" list with them or their successor forever.

I really think they do a service to the internet community, but they should be more focused on correcting the problem instead of persecution. Alot of legitimate businesses end up there without being able to get off the list or ever put on it to begin with. It just isn't fair.

Good luck with it. It worked out for me and I hope it works out for you.

by jaqui

some apps will submit a private list of blocked addy's to blacklist servers automatically, if someone on your email list is using one of these apps and they blocked you instead of requesting removal, then they are the cause of this.

it could also be a unhappy (ex)employee getting you listed as payback for something they feel wronged about.

by oz_media

RBL listers re usually very inexperienced people who are out to stop hom ebased spam.

I had a company who's mail was blacklisted because they used GroupWise fr email. GW will accept relayed mail, however it doesn't actually relay it. So whenthey conduct open relay tests it gets blacklisted.

Novell wrote a patch to mask it and save GW users.

For the most part, they are inaacurate and unknowledgable script kiddies that start these things, although they appear to be internet watchdogs, most are just ISP wannabe's or people sick of spam and are trying to control the internet at people's expense.

I would be in contact with them BY PHONE and very upset, explaining that they are stopping your business. Unfortunately this is an Exchnge issue as many companies leave open relays when they configure theri servers.

NOTE: Only companies with REALLY crappy spam filters (Spam Cop and garbage you can get for home at about $30.00 copy) will be using RBL lists as the sole defense mechanism. A proper system will simply add a weihgted value to the RBL test and then weigh it aainst other moe accurate methods, such as a heuristic scan and keyword scan as wel las others, then weigh the total against a predetermined threshold.

So you are stuck between an unreliable and VERY crappy list and oeth Uneliable and VERY crappy Spamsoftware at the recipient.

If it is JUST a few companies that you can't get mail to, call and ask them to add an exception to their filter (or ditch the crap altogether fo real software).

I would then call the kiddies at the RBL sitte and raise blue murder! What the yae doing is okay for Yahoo and DCHUI76R*@$$Hotmail.com but not for businesses.

I scared the living crap out of one RBL lister ORBS, and was NEVER listed again, whether a lawsuit was valid or not, it got some action from him.

by roger99a

Some RBL lists are probably run by rookies, or aimed at purposes inconsistant with your particular business goals. No business should ever use Blars, for example, because you have to pay him to get removed. Running random open relay tests is just a bad idea, but accepting relaying messages would seem to invite spammers attention. But trial and error using various lists can give good results and low false positives.
If his server is an open relay then it should be listed. If his systems are sending viruses then they should be listed. If I need his email anyway then I can whitelist him and bypass the filter. Accidents and misconfigurations can happen and now he knows he has a problem to solve. He could have been sending spam forever otherwise. It sounds like this particular DNSBL is honoring his requests and delisting him like they should. I don't see a problem here with the DNSBL. He needs to find them problem, virus, trojan horse, relay or whatever it is.

by oz_media

RBL lists, no matter how accurate the CAN be should never be used as a sole spam source. I have studied this very extensively over a 8 month period where I studies tested and evaluated almost all SPAM software on the market I could find 8-10 hrs a day (what a pain that was). ALL, and I mean ALLm, cheap solutions are left to be mainly dependant on RBL lists and are just not reliable for busines use. A FAIR system will use RBL AND some keywording, a DECENT one will also check message body text and the most robust systems have 6 or 7 different types of scan they perform in order to scan SPAM effectively, EVEN then , the lists need to be SPAM vs HAM trained (another benefit of GOOD software).

So I stick to my oringinal comments in that it is most likely due to the recipient having cheesy or low end spam software installed that is simply STOPPING anything found in what could be 20 different RBL checks.

If you want REAL and PROVEN spam protection for business, be well prepared to spend from $1000.00 to $6000.00 in software and hardwae costs (obviously the low end not including new hardware).

THis is something I studied VERY closely for some time befor espending 6 month in serious test envronments and testing near 40 different busines targeted solutions. I actually did write a white paper on it and was asked by several companies,either by phone or email, to evaluate their systems and make recommendations.

RBL lists CANNOT AT ANY TIME be considered an deffective way to stop spam, they simply are ot monitored nor accurate enough.

How does an RBL list understand what YOUR company's acceptable and unacceptable mail is?

Just because a customer has an open relay, I still want them to be able to contact me. I wasn't worried about open relays at my office, GroupWise is a little more secure than most would think.

I took a company getting nearly 1500 spam a day to less than 5 per week between MANY users, four locations and without a SINGLE whitelisted address, yes not ONE. It did take about 4 months training expensive software, sorry but SPAM Assasin, Spam Cop and even the few thousand dollars for GW Guardian wasn't as effective.

What if company B wants to order aproduct from you and because of your system scanning 4 RBL lists it is then blocked and you lose the business, this costs many thousands each year in lost business.

RBL was the first and lowest weihgted score in the system I built. It then was scanned for keywords, then a FULL heuristic scan against a 45000 entry databse, then for address blocks, then against the HAM list, then scanned for viruses and trojans, then the attachments wer eal lscanned, this is before it enters the company's MTA, and long befor it got to the desktop. Yet it all took place in mere seconds and using the company's existing AV software. The footprint was a little under 100MB and it ran on the existing server while raising resource use only a few percent(2-4%).

Another system I tested did similar, ye required a dual processor server running Windows 2003 (for a Novell targeted product that works with GroupWise?).

There's a lot of garbage out there yes, there are lot in fact THOUSAND of incorrectly blacklisted companies, many not even knowing it.

RBL's should be used ONLY as a preliminary scan and always weighted against a threshold that it a result of multiple scans, but NEVER as a final decision for spam, they just aen't reliable enough nor managed well enough, and yes I have spoken personally with many of the list providers regarding their update and management measures, which for the most part are quite pathetic.

by hal 9000

How do you proceed from that point?

You can have everything locked down tight but that doesn't stop someone impersonating your business so that the recipients think that they are getting genuine e-mails.

As time goes on and things get tighter I can see this as more of a problem than it currently is. Particuarly if you have VPN's into the system and no protocols for securing Home Computers which have access to the network.

But even still the Logs should show up if there is any unusual traffic outgoing.

Col

by jdclyde

I have asked to be scanned for a relay and have also checked with the big relay blockers and I am not set as a relay and am not on any lists as one.

I am running Linux, so the viruses and trojans mailers they have listed can not be the problem as they only run on Windows servers.

Came in this morning and blacklisted for the fifth time in a week.

by house

We use the proprietary Mail Daemon spam filter. It is very intelligent, but of course, it is not without it's flaws.

It uses a point system to scan emails. It assigns points based on certain things like...

1) multiple hyperlinks
2) keywords
3) mutiple addresses
4) known subject lines

Obviously, we get a few complaints, but when we remove the filter, they cry like hell. It seems to be the way of the internet right now. We don't subscribe to any blacklists - they are a pain to deal with - even some of our client's addresses have been blacklisted on other servers. What a sad state of affairs. We are on the phone with other domain admins almost every other week regarding such issues.

by oz_media

I was given the task of removign ALL spam form ALL users at multiple locations without a single whitelisted email. It took quite a while and only ended up costing about $2500.00, even then with their ever so robust platform, it took months to train it for PSAM and HAM as applied to te nature of the company's business. There simply isn't a solution hat works out of the box for all companies, everyone has different requirements of what iis acceptab;le and what isn't it goes WELL beyond keywords and basic heuristic scan though. Good softwae is trainable it will run sample passes on a collection of about 1500 SOAM and HAM emails receieved by the company and will then take nearly 15 retest passes in order to betweaked properly. While studying all this, I learned just how many company's are actually just throwing solutions into place and not proerly configurign or training them past blocking addresses or adding keywords.

by av .

I know the users don't like them, but its a necessary evil. And of course they suffer if you take the filter off.

We don't use any blacklists either. They block way too much to be useful. We use GFI Mail Essentials and Mail Security. It has Bayesian filtering, keyword and content checking, blacklists and whitelists. It is highly configurable. Mail Security has Norman and Bitdefender Antivirus, Trojan and Exploit checkers. I'm happy with them both.

Today you can't have too much security. It is very sad because the internet and email is the greatest invention. Why some people want to ruin that is beyond me.

by roger99a

I set up Symantec's mail Gateway, ironically it's an anti-spam product, and the default configuration was to relay EVERYTHING! It relayed for a couple of days and finally crashed. I figured out what was going on, but I had been listed on a couple of blocklists. I don't remember one of them, but I went to their website and requested a test and was removed within 24 hours.
Anyway, it's legal and useful. I use two DNSBL's and maintain another private list.
You can test for relay here: http://www.rbl.jp/svcheck.php
You might try sniffing port 25 to see if any unauthorized computers are sending mail. Are you blocking all relaying or just external addresses?

by jdclyde

My firewall is set to only allow SMTP to come and go to our mail server. All other SMTP traffic is dropped as it tries to enter or leave our network.

We are not a relay. I have checked the lists and am not listed, and even went to the sites where you can ask to be scanned and have come up clean.

by house

I'm under the impression that an @mm (mass mailing virus) is exploiting your domain.

Does anybody here know where I could find a downloadable text file regarding these blacklisted addresses... without actually registering for the database synch services?

It would be much appreciated. :)

by house

Thanks a lot. This web utility will come in handy. :)

I deal with a lot of email issues that are usually the result of the kind of activity discussed in this thread.

by jdclyde

I am still looking into this, but right off the bat most of the viruses can be written off because they only run on Window servers.

Any advise from the linux guys out there?

Guess I will have to start a thread under the linux heading and refer back to this.

Thanks again everyone.

by hal 9000

Doesn't mean that you can not be transmitting the Windows Viri just that they have no effect on the Linux Server.

If you like most places have Windows Desktops I would start scanning everyone of them and look for infections or the like.

Yes I know it is painful but as this crowd keeps blacklisting you and it is adversely affecting your business you will have to make sure that there is no way that this is possibly coming from the business. Just one of the Desktops needs to be infected to cause this problem and most likely if one is than most of them will be. The Server should be OK so start looking at the week side of things and that is everything Windows.

If that all comes up clean then have you recently had someone leave under less than ideal circumstances? It could always be someone spoofing your IP but you first have to rule out any possibility that there is a problem within the network.

I hope that gives you something to start with.

Col

by house

...can exploit your domain without actually residing on your server. I can send from your address if I went through smtp without authentication... don't ya know? I don't necessarily have to be on your network.

by roger99a

You obviously have more spam experience than I do. I have to work with what I have, and it could be better. It relies on DNSBL's, keywords and return addresses to tag spam. The DNSBL check is the most effective of the three. I tested several lists and eventually chose less aggressive lists for final use, but the two I use stop 70-85% of spam without one reported false positive in 14 months. Lists that gave a false positive were removed and never used again. For almost no money an admin could set up a sendmail server using any old workstation and add a list check or two and reduce spam to an acceptable level. Not a good choice if the business depends on email to make it's money, but it could work for those that don't, or those that don't have a $10,000 budget for email filtering.
So, what's your favorite Enterprise solution, Oz?

by oz_media

Eithet GW Guardian ro GWAVA 9though I believe GWAVA still has much to be desired for MS applications.

GW GUardian has stringent hardware requirements, GWAVA is small but very accurate and customizable to your specificcompany's acceptable and rejectable mail, it has a REALLY REALLY good Ham SPam comparisson system that creates a customized set of heuristic rules. heuristic rules can been seen in most solutions and weights adjusted, however it is VERY VERY hardto accuratesly decide whether a specific rule should be scored 4.5 or 4.473, this is what a good trinaing system will help you achieve by running multiple passes of your own HAM and SPAM mail. You then select any white listed mail or skipped spam and run the pass again, this allows it to automatically adjust it's own heuristic values as needed. Just one or two points in the wrong direction can screw up a lot of mail, so I highly recommend a built in 'training system'.

GWAVA is fairly cheap, just under $1K Canadian.

Others I had looked at barely made it anywhere with me, I had REALLY tight requirements. Sales reps got lot of spam and needed complete removal of a LOT of mail, the president would have walked up and thrown the server out the window (not exaggertion here at all) if he lost a single email to the white list, so it was a VERY sensitive issue. Not to mention his wife and partner in crime was receiving a tonne of porn spam, I really don't know why of course! LOL.

That's why I am so passionate when discussing it, I had to take this more seriously than a complete network rebuild.

I didn't mean to bite your head off but I just get so many people saying "We use spam Cop on 17 RBL's and it's just great!" what about all the blocked mail you had no idea was never processed or passed to the SPAM vault?

When I have spent so much time on this issue, speaking with reps, reading endlessly and testing all these different systems, it becomes quite personal, perhaps I took your comments to heart and shouldn't have, my bad and I apologize.

GWAVA when I first started testing ws still good but had some interface issues with teh Archive Viewer etc. The staff quickly helped me at NO cost, sent me some updatesd files and even extended the upgrade protection by an other year, the support was great, the knowledgebase and forums wer excellent help and full of very friendly people. These are all issue I had to consider as a sole supporter of a reasonably new product at the time. From what I am told, it still works well, they have updated (just a JOE with basic PC knowledge took care of the update) and it still works well.

ONe last point, I was mentioning how it creates SPAM and HAM lists then analyzes them, this can be ongoing and you can assign the task to several departments to ensure accuracy throughout the organization. User just highlight some accptable mail and any nacceptable mail they receive and send it to the HAM or SPAM file with a click of a button. The mail is flagged and stored so the admin has a good set of sample mail to run through the tweaking filter and have it retrain itself if meal starts to slip through, it's really good software!

Sory to drone on with a slaes pitch but I am sold on it and believe in it. As for the length of my message, well....you did ask? Bet it's the last time you do that! :D

It's getting late so I can't even be bothered to spell check, forgive the hoards of typos and early spaces!

by dafe2

A hardware solution like Barracuda could deal with that quite nicely. :-)

by jaqui

depends on how much of the companies business is from email before I would concider it.
if it is only 10% from online then going with a multiple software solution would be more cost effective.
if 33% or more, definately go with a hardware solution.

by dafe2

How about a mail Server that serves up to say 2500 users but doesn't do any E-Business?

These guys get tons of trash...they subscribe to everyting and anything.

Worth 5k to me how bout you? or is there something better out there

by oz_media

Asfor hardware solutions, one's I have seen limit the software's ability to be trained specifically to YOUR company's mail and offer VERY limited access to it, as they want to ensure the hardware holds up and doesn't get fiddled with too much.

The one slution I mentioned was Novell targeted solution only, but it required a dual processor HIGH END server running a MS NOS?
WHO was the dolt who came up with THAT idea?
Would you buy a MS targeted replacement for MS Exchange that required a Novell server to run on?

Not only that, the software was twice the price and the BASIC server would have cost $4500.00 even after getting it at cost form the vendor due to a mistake they made in the sales process.

BUT!!!! I have seen someone build a 486 into a spam scanner (a good one too!) running Python code. Very slick, on a 486 too! So as for your interest in a $5000.00 hardware solution (understanding that HIGH END GWAVA is less than $1000.00 to implement as a software solution tha realy works) the 486 mentioned above was obviously FREE and just took a few hours of Python to setup.

I case you aren't familiar with Python, it is similar to C++ but 200 lines of C++ coed can equate to only 20 linesof Python to achieve the same results. It's easier to debug, less prone to glitches and far easier to update and rewrite as needed. That's why Python programmers make HUGE bucks, achievng expensive results in a short amount of time.

by jaqui

how much email through that server and why are you having it?
for business of some fashion I would bet.
that would be a good time for a hardware solution

Oz,
IRONMAIL
check the webcasts archive at sans portal, an isp went with ironmail as it, in thier opinion, contradicts what you said

by oz_media

There's no way in hell I would sit through even a 30 second Webcast on SPAM now! NO WAY! Been there done that for WAAAY too long.

I know about Ironmail and have considerd it too. It is no different than the $1000.00 GWAVA except;

GWAVA tweaks Spam and Ham heuristic rules based on your own submitted or gathered mail form various users or departments, FAR more accurate than Ironmail's HASH system.

GWAVA resides on your own server and can handle as many users and process mail as fast as your server permits.

I was using it with 1500 - 2000 emails per day, being distributed to multiple offices and YES it also scans webmail.

Gwava is tiny and resourceful weighing in at only 30MB on the server.

I have sat in on SO many webcasts, live seminars, flown to seminars, driven to seminars, studied MOUND of books and so on for WAY too long. I have seen the VARIOUS solutions, tried many of them, studied the benefits etc.

There were the same conflicting opinions as always, everyone has a different conclusions like PC vs MAC or Novell vs Windoze, mine was based on MY experience.

I don't even like THINKING about this crap anymore really.

It works, there's no hardware to replace or maintain, it handles immense volumes of mail (check the GWVA forums for examples from the high volume users), it is cheap and DEAD accurate, NO SPAM, no false positives, AT ALL.
Done deal!

How would Ironmail be a better solution...other than if you only had MS servers?

GW Guardian outperforms Ironmail too and it is a hardware OR software solution as needed, but it's also over $6000.000 all inclusive!

My point was you can also do this on a 486 running Python, works like a charm for say 50 - 100 users, then you may want to step up to an old PIII or something.

There's no need for a large investment nor a hardware investment, it is dependant on the TYPE of processing and 'configurability' the system offers.

by dafe2

We're testing with Barracuda & haven't had anything but succes....just wondered if others were finding any success with software based stuff today.

by house

We still put up with plain text and single hyperlink spam messages. We've also been getting nailed with these stupid full colour invoices... I'm not sure how our filter is missing those ones.

by jdclyde

And the site that (bastards) is blocking me isn't one that you report someone too.

They have their sniffers out on the web and if they detect what they feel is spam or a trojan they shut you down.

We have added traffic that I have pointed out to them. We have VPN's going gennerating a lot of traffic as well as just started to use Blackberry hand-helds. These connect to a server in Canada (blame Canada) which connects to our server via the internet to sync their e-mail.

Haven't been able to find anything in the logs that looks out of place yet. This is a linux RedHat server, can you recommend a specific log to check and what to look for?

Thanks everyone.

by oz_media

I am starting to think that the recpient is using a CBL list that is checking so many different data logs that everytime it rescans that databse and updates itself, you are reblacklisted again.

It could be that you are blacklisted by several lists and the CBL is just regathering that data periodically.

[b]"I delisted my IP, but it keeps getting relisted again. Why??[/b]

You have a virus, or an open proxy, a trojan spam-sender or some other sort of security compromise, which is causing your IP to be relisted. Always ensure that viruses, open proxies, etc. are removed or secured before trying to delist your IP.

[b]If you did all that but still keep getting listed, then see below for where to talk about the problem."[/b]

Is this happening when sending to specific clients? Perhaps THEY are using the CBL as a quick workaround and not updating it properly or simply using too many data files and some also have you blacklisted. If they haven't properly configured their CBL lookup it will also reflect inaccurate info.

I would PHONE the people with the list, send them email and ask how you can call someone directly, explain that YOU are running a business and need to resolve thi sproblem once and for all or else you will be exploring your legal options.

You see what a joke these guys really are, what kind of company only offers an email address for contact?

One with no proper stucture and usually one run by whoever can get to the email in their spare time, including perhaps lunch breaks at school, time between classes etc.

You are being blocked via a list with no contact information, no office and no staff?

This just enhances the importance of companies needing to use properly wieghted SPAM control and not just blocking based on lists. Cheap solutions = cheap results. People seem to forget they are running a business when it comes to stuff like this. $50.00 or $2000.00, how much is your companies correspondence worth? Can you IMAGINE if a similar system was on phone lines? My God, it would sure hit the fan fast!

More details on what mail is being blocked would be worth looking at, as far as where it is going if it isn't all mail. Whether a specific company or similar companies or if this is just randomly hapening to email.

by jdclyde

from all systems except for the e-mail server.

Any windows system with it's own mass mailer on it should be dropped by the firewall on the way out?

Will give them another check, just to make sure.

by hal 9000

Find OZ is on the right track.

What he has suggested further down is terrifying and all the more so because it is the most likely scenario.

Col

by roger99a

I'm not a Linux guy, but it could be that the mail server is relaying for internal addresses. Exchange will do it, and you have to specify which IP addresses it will allow relaying for.

by rknrlkid

I was reading through the responses explaining how someone can get listed on one of these blocking services, and decided to go to the CBL site to see what they had to say. While I think they do a service, they are also scary because basically these companies are loose cannons who can list anyone they choose, without ever disclosing why. Proof? From their own FAQs:

"What are the exact criteria for listing on the CBL?
Those will not be disclosed."

I have a problem with that. I have no problem with their being a standard, and having people adhere to a standard. But when the standards are not listed or given, then how can anyone know if they are failing to meet the standard? How can you fix a problem when you don't know how the problem was found?

I think I am going to shoot an email off to them for more clarification.

by jdclyde

If they have anything to say for themselves.

Yes, I have been real frustrated with this. And they don't notify you that you are on their list. You find out when your business comunincations start getting blocked and users start complaining to you.

This undermines the users confidence in the service that IT provides them.

by rknrlkid

I wrote to CBL, and they sent me the following response to my question about their policy. jdclyde, you were even mentioned in it:

"The CBL examines inbound email for "fingerprints" indicating that the source
IP is compromised: viruses/worms, spam trojans, open proxies and other mass-mailing "infections" of one kind or another. The CBL DOES NOT detect
open mail relays.

Indeed, a traditional open mail relay simply cannot trigger the CBL.

The detection methodology is very "sensitive", but is rarely definitive as to _what_ exactly is sending the email.

Since it's not very diagnostic, and that revealing information about how detection works might allow spamware and virus authors to program around it, we do not give out the precise details of how detection works.

We make up for that by allowing no-questions-asked self-removals up to a point, and prompt assistance with specific suggestions of what to look for or how to prevent recurrances if the listings repeat and the user contacts us.

If someone is having a problem with repeated listings, make sure that they contact us, we will help figure out what's happening. We've recently
made major changes to our online documentation (you see this while you're self-removing an IP) to help end-users make delistings permanent.

It's too bad jdclyde didn't include the IP in that thread, otherwise, we could have given some pointers in this email ;-)

And as a by-the-by, IP addresses _cannot_ be spoofed in TCP/IP connections. In UDP, it's trivially easy to spoof source IPs. But not in the TCP/IP required to actually send an email.

We strive to run the CBL in an ethical, responsible and professional manner that major organizations can use with confidence. And block a lot of spam and viruses at the same time ;-)

Given the large number of major (many enormous) corporations and ISPs that use the CBL, given that the highly respected SpamHaus republishes
our list as the main component of the XBL, and given that most people using the CBL (XBL) find it to be one of the most effective (and least false positive prone) anti-spam technique available, we seem to have succeeded.

[Indeed, the CBL has succeeded _way_ beyond our expectations.]"

email = cbl@cbl.abuseat.org

by jdclyde

I have been in e-mail contact with them, several times over the last week.

Did they get my TR ID from your e-mail or are they watching this post? Interesting.

I have in direct contact with them provided Full name of me and my company along with all IP information. You can understand why I wouldn't post that in a discussion forum. :>

I have now gone a full day without getting re-blacklisted. Waa Hoo! Hope it lasts.

Thanks everyone for your ideas and assistance.

by jdclyde

I would like to thank everyone who helped out.

I would REALLY like to thank everyone who was in contact with cbl.abuseat.org questioning them on my (our) behalf.

I am going to say that THIS DISCUSSION resolved my issue because I DIDN'T DO ANYTHING to my servers or network to resolve the issue that started up without me making any changes to my servers or network.

I was in contact and let them know that I had confirmed each point on their list, but didn't CHANGE anything. (accidentlly must have got it right the first time).

I HATE when there isn't a REASON for things to happen.

by oz_media

In many cases there's no point seeking the reason or justification. You are 'paid to ensure things work', when they don't 'you are paid to ensure things work', end of story.

I had a few issues thrown at me over time that after much frustration just all of a sudden worked again.

A quick thank you for your attention ot this matter was sent to me and that's that. Nobody cared how or why it worked, just that it DIDN'T work at one time.

If I was to go and call my ISP's and other vendors to route out the issue, the chances of someone owning up to simply dropping the ball on their end are slim at best, so I may never know that the ISP said yes he had looked at that when he actually hadn't.

Forget it and move on, not worth a headwreacker that's for sure!

P.S. ELated that you got it resolved either way, surely not as elated as you must be though. I know very well how these stupid little things can take up so much headspace.

by jdclyde

The reason I like to know what went wrong and what set it right is it helps you to avoid it from happening again or if it does happen again you know how to resolve the issue.

Believe me, I will not lose any sleep over this. (accept for the nap I could be taking now instead of replying in this discussion)

by hal 9000

Obviously the problem was down the chain and out of your control.

There are sometimes no solutions to problems and even better you are told direct lies to cover another companies mistakes.

Col

by oz_media

I think it was at the other end, not your own. Sounds like the CBL was f***ed, as expected from most of them.

I think the only way you could repeat it is by hiring a crappy RBL blocking team to handle your mail between classes and food fights.
How can you possibly avoid it in the past? You can't, there always some fool who thinks he is stopping spam when he is stopping his own business instead.

This discussion is closed to new replies.