Discussion Locked

If this isn?t lunacy, I don?t know what is

0 helpful
832 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 9 of the discussion. Read the opening post

832 replies

by $$$$$$$$$$

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=joj_5NypSYI&feature=related

Climate modeling is getting better, with the direct result that the predictions made are more precise & accurate. Climate science is not the scam. Archer Daniels Midland's coercive monopoly on "alternative" auto fuel -- industry sub-standard efficiency, subsidized by the US government and sheltered from competition with Brasilian sugar ethanol -- is a scam.

by $$$$$$$$$$

You won't debate me because you don't know what the he|| you're talking about.

[i]I simply won?t engage a hostile person (with this one exception).

Moreover, as far as debating the science, as you (and deepsand) have both invited, that?s a silly thing to suggest. I?m not a qualified scientist; you?re not a qualified scientist; I assume deepsand is not a qualified scientist (even though he presents himself as a qualified expert on all things); and our audience is not populated by anyone who could discern fact from fiction.

Edit:

That was a terrible choice of words, but I'll leave it so everything that follows makes sense, and out of respect to those who've already read it.

I should have said:

I?m not a qualified scientist; you?re not a qualified scientist; I assume deepsand is not a qualified scientist (even though he presents himself as a qualified expert on all things); and no one in our audience is a qualified scientist, at least not that I know of

End of edit.[/i]

I am in fact a qualified scientist, and I restrict my comments to things that I know. Your choices to mouth off about things you don't understand, to substitute wishes and opinions for the knowledge you lack, and to assume that everybody who disagrees with you is as ignorant as you are, are invalid.

[i]I find it shockingly sad that most people just won?t admit that, in reality, they know absolutely nothing about the science behind the claim of human-(whatever) global warming. They can?t possibly form a meaningful scientific conclusion. Instead, whether they admit it or not, they?ve simply decided who to believe.

That angle of the issue is what we (out here in know-nothing land) should really be debating - the merits of deciding who to believe and why. That?s an offer I?ve extended, but it?s you and deepsand who refuse.[/i]

Your premises are in error, but you refuse to check them.

by deepsand

That "cost" is not a true "at arm's length" one, but one which already includes a profit for another member of the same corporate family as is the refiner, at margins that are deliberately manipulated so as to maximize the total net after tax gain of the family as a whole.

Therefore, since the vast majority of the gasoline products is delivered by fully vertically integrated corporate families, the only true measure of profitability is their margin from wellhead to pump.

by deepsand

As for his mention of "deciding [b]who[/b] to believe and why," such serves only to demonstrate his distain for Science, for empirical fact.

by deepsand

Your statement re. "[i]deciding [b]who[/b] to believe and why[/i]" serves to more than amply demonstrate where your true interests lie.

by nicknielsen

The person who states that we can stop global climate change has surpassed simple arrogance and achieved hubristic nirvana. Or he has an agenda.

by deepsand

the possibility of mankind's influence on climate, of those who take such a position without first gaining an understanding of the underlying Physics, of those who hold to the belief that infinite gain can be had by all without consequence.

In short, a description of max & his ilk.

by nicknielsen

I had thought you scientist enough to see that my words condemn the hyperbole from [u]both[/u] sides of the debate and not twist them to your own ends.

Did we cause the climate change? Most likely not; the Earth was warming from the Younger Dryas and the Little Ice Age well before the Industrial Revolution. Did we contribute? Hell yes, we're part of the ecosystem! Can we stop it? I seriously doubt it; at our level, it's an open system and we have no control over the outside inputs.

by deepsand

The problem with max & his ilk is that they insist that 1) man cannot possibly have contributed to radiative forcing (assuming that they even understand & acknowledge its existence, an assumption which cannot easily be had), and therefore that 2) man is free to do that which is deemed necessary to sate his desires.

They've already decided "who" to believe, and have no interest in giving consideration to any facts which serve to rebut their desired conclusion.

As for "[i]Can we stop it? I seriously doubt it; at our level, it's an open system and we have no control over the outside inputs,[/i] as a scientist, I find that to be factually incorrect, and therefore illogical.

We are not here dealing with a truly open system. Rather, we have one for which the external inputs remain remarkably stable over very long time periods; the factors which are must variable are not the influx of solar radiation, but rather the transparency of the atmosphere and the albedo of Earth.

It is precisely these volatile inputs over which mankind has exerted the greatest influence in a what is historically a very short period of time. Therefore, unless one believes that we have indeed already passed the point of no return, i.e. that thermal run-away is now inevitable, then one must allow that our reversing that which has so affected said inputs will serve to mitigate the consequences of such.

I for one see no evidence that we have yet reached such a point; therefore, to maintain that we are powerless to control our destiny is to voluntarily surrender it.

That which man has done he can also undo.

Doing so requires that we first still the voices of ignorance, and let understanding of facts and reason hold sway, rather than passions borne of desires for temporary gain.

by tonythetiger

[i]The problem with max & his ilk is that they insist that 1) man cannot possibly have contributed to radiative forcing[/i]

"man cannot possibly have"?

What they ARE saying is that your "evidence" isn't convincing, and that they don't trust the motives behind your claims.

It will remain that way until you deal with the naysayers by convincing them, silencing them, or beating them into submission. Tell me, do you fantasize a great deal about the latter?

by tonythetiger

between refusal to attend, and attending, but not coming to the conclusion you want. I have read every link you have provided and investigated quite a bit on my own. I simply don't believe there is enough evidence to draw the conclusion you want me to draw. Your assumptions of ignorance of anyone who doesn't see it the way you do is itself ignorant, because you're ignoring the possibility that YOU could be wrong... And your proclamations regarding someone else's "true interests" are no more valid than someone else's proclamations about yours.

by nicknielsen

[i]That which man has done he can also undo.[/i]

The hubris in that single statement is chilling.

Can man uncut the redwood groves? Can man unmake 239Pu or 135Cs?

Edit: fix html

by deepsand

I will allow that you unintentionally misconstrued my remark regarding reversability.

by nicknielsen

Except what I see as an implied assertion that you know what is best for me and an attitude that I am somehow less than you because, given the same evidence you have used, I have not reached exactly the same conclusion as you.

by deepsand

Rather, I make the [b]explicit[/b] assertion that those whose positions are based on [i]policy[/i], as are those of max and others here, are [b]irrelevant to the issues re. physical processes[/b].

To return to the issue of this particular sub-thread, [i]who[/i] to believe is a red herring, and serves only to distract from the important matters of fact.

As for "knowing better," I do explicitly assert that I understand the underlying physics of radiative forcing better than do those who argue against me.

by deepsand

If you truly read [b]and understood[/b] the scientific materials to which I referred to you, it is not possible that you could conclude that mankind cannot [b]not[/b] be contributing to radiational forcing.

And, yes, Tony, there those here who maintain precisely that. In fact, you yourself publicly hewed closely to that position early on.

The issue is not one of selecting appropriate data and properly interpreting it, as is held by many, yourself included it would seem, but one of understanding the inescapable Physical Laws of the Universe. (No, I will not here entertain any arguments to the effect that we don't know those Laws well enough for understanding radiative forcing. For anyone to here attempt to advance that argument is to admit to their ignorance of Science.)

In short, this is a matter of scientific facts, not, as you would have us believe, of opinions. Accordingly, your pronouncement re. my finding ignorance in the statements of others is irrelevant & inconsequential.

Whether it is the case that your lenses are colored by desire or ignorance I leave for you to decide.

by forum surfer

It IS possible to debate matters without resulting to calling other people ignorant. A little humility never hurt anyone.

by tonythetiger

[i]f you truly read and understood the scientific materials to which I referred to you, it is not possible that you could conclude that mankind cannot not be contributing to radiational forcing.[/i]

That's the only possible explanation, isn't it? You and everyone who agrees with you are right, and everybody who doesn't toe your line "doesn't understand"

[i]And, yes, Tony, there those here who maintain precisely that. In fact, you yourself publicly hewed closely to that position early on.[/i]

My position has always been that there is not enough evidence to reach a conclusion. Other possibilities I may have proffered were intended to be just that... possibilities... and I have never represented them as anything else.

[i]For anyone to here attempt to advance that argument is to admit to their ignorance of Science.)[/i]

Again with your belief that your knowledge is absolute... superior... and that any one who would question it (obviously) "doesn't understand"...

Smacks of an attempt to create a new religion to me... :)

[edit tense and punctuation]

by nicknielsen

You're right and anybody who disagrees with you either doesn't understand, isn't capable of understanding, or is being intentionally wrong-headed.

That's not the objective scientific method I was taught and I don't want any part of it. Put your method where it will do you the most good.

by tonythetiger

When I see the word or a form of the word "ignorant", I take it at face value (per the common dictionary definition), and when I use it, I intend it to be taken the same way. Specifically, I do not use it as a synonym for "stupid", as there are dozens of more colorful terms to choose from were that my intent.

by forum surfer

I don't see you tossing the term about in a disrespectful manner on the board like some others. You seem to be very polite and open to discussion without resorting to insults or taking the topic personally. Sorry if I offended you!

by deepsand

The Physical Laws of the Universe are not subject to the consensus, or lack thereof, of its inhabitants.

To say that "there is not enough evidence to reach a conclusion" re. radiative forcing is pure BS; radiative forcing is an undeniable physical process, well & long understood by men of Science.

Cling to your ignorance, since that is what seems to give you comfort. Just don't expect the Universe to give a damn about your beliefs or opinions.

Your denial of Science is, in fact, the most ancient of all Religions.

by deepsand

If the "objective scientific method" that you were "taught" holds otherwise, then you were very badly mislead.

Why do you persist in ignoring the inescapable physical process of radiative forcing?

by tonythetiger

[i]Tony: You clearly either fail or refuse to understand. [/i]

... rinse ... repeat.

I suppose that real scientists who disagree with you also "fail or refuse to understand".

[i]The Physical Laws of the Universe are not subject to the consensus, or lack thereof, of its inhabitants. [/i]

... including ones you may not know about!

Every generation of scientists, like every generation of teenagers, thinks it knows it all. It's the nature of things I suppose.

This discussion is closed to new replies.