Discussion Locked

Is "(beep) save the Queen" offensive to anyone?

0 helpful
22 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

http://www.newsmax.com/archives/ic/2007/1/25/121413.shtml?s=icp

An in flight showing of "The Queen" was overly edited for offensive content. The California company that edits the movies stated "We excise foul language, excessive violence and nudity."

The new editor thought that the word "God" fit that term, and beeped it out, even in the " bless you ma'am," as one character spoke to the queen.

It is not said if this lunatic was promptly fired or not, but it does show the mentality of many in the godless world out there.

Edited to change the "<" to "(" in the title so it isn't confused by the site as html code.

22 replies

by why me worry?

that somehow find the word "God" offensive, simply because they are atheists and don't believe in one. They whine about Evangelical Christians and other religious people shoving their bibles down everyone's throats, but how are these liberals any better by shoving their Godless liberal mentality upon viewers of a movie that may not think that "God" is an offensive word?

Like I always say, liberalism is a form of mental disorder.

by jamesrl

Growing up we had to sing it every morning before we sang 'O Canada'.

I'm not a huge fan of the institution as it stands today, but the person herself has mant admirable qualities.

Obviously, some American liked the song so much, they poached the tune for "My Country tis of thee" , though usually 'God Save the Queen' is usually done more slowly and 'regally'.

There was an attempt to make "O Canada" gender neutral and take out the God reference a few years back but it failed miserably.

James

by Member 25348569

who better than God to do it? But I'm an atheist and a republican so I want to have " save the ".

If I can't have that then let's leave things as they are and take the bleeping PC idiot outside and his so that he can never again.

:D

p.s. Added because of worry's post. I don't reckon any atheists that I know find the word God particularly anything unless we're forced to. I would suggest that the majority of "nice" people who become PC idiots such as the bleeper are probably not atheists. They probably don't know what they are at all.

by oldbag

What is wrong with the word 'God'? This is getting WAAAAAYYYY too politically correct!

by jdclyde

is that it isn't some kind of political statement or pushing of religion on people, by keeping the movie intact.

Shall we re-write all history to take out any and everything we find offensive?

Remember people wanting to do this to Huck fin, for the constant (and accurate for the times) references to "the jim"?

Aw man! They are starting to censor ME now! :0 run away! run away!

by charliespencer

the lost luggage, the often less than courteous security personnel, the waiting on the tarmac to leave, the holding pattern to land, the waiting on the tarmac again for a gate, the indecipherable pricing schemes, the ridiculous frequent flyer plans, ...

by absolutely

There are REAL things being lost, ruined & destroyed, and these ***holes are worried about censorshi* of the free in-flight f*ction. What f*ckwits!

by delbertpgh

The article (any of you actually read more than the first paragraph?) says the company acknowledged it was dumb, and blamed an untrained and overzealous employee for censoring way past the limit.

The article says they are distributing un-edited tapes, to replace the g*dless ones.

I would not be surprised if this overzealous idiotic censorship were the work of some right-wing nutbag who figured he would make the whole enterprise look ridiculous. Judging from the crowd here, hooting and thumping their tubs and hyperventilating about idiot liberals, he has a ready-made audience.

Anybody here maybe remember, that censorship is a CONSERVATIVE attempt to rein in public dialog?

by jdclyde

If you took the time to notice, at least HALF of the respondents are from the UK, and not known to be the more conservative people in the lot. Some of them have also clearly stated they are NOT religious people on MANY occasions.

We are also talking this was NOT U.S. Government censorship, but a service the airlines PAY for to keep from offending their INTERNATIONAL PASSENGERS ON THEIR INTERNATIONAL FLIGHTS.

You also clearly missed where I specifically addressed the nutjob that took it upon himself to find the word "God" to be offensive. Some of the Anti-god crowd forget that "god" is a generic name, not a name for any specific religion. It is WHAT "they" are, not WHO "they" are.

Don't "skim" the postings next time and you will see a different picture.

by delbertpgh

I am so amused by the generally mindless response to this story, the invention of non-existent facts followed by feel-good complaining about liberalism, that I have spent a good 20 minutes trying to get some background.

The movie was made by Miramax, the former Weinstein brothers company that is now owned by Disney. The director and cast are English, and I believe it was filmed on English sets, not in Hollywood, but I can't actually verify that.

The film was prepared for airline showing by Jaguar Distribution, a Studio City, CA company. Jaguar doesn't seem to have a website, so there are no press releases from the horse's mouth. I read in the Ottowa Sun that Jaguar does the censorship and editing for airline release, and that an "inexperienced" editor made the mistake of blanking out every "god" in the soundtrack. It also said that the editor was still in Jaguar's employment.

That's the end of the facts. Now, I'm sure you can find lots more non-fact; all you have to do is read folks' uniformed comment on the incident, and you'll have plenty to rave about. However, you're just wasting your time. This is not a story of liberal extremism run wild; this is about one kid who didn't know how to do a job. Or maybe an adult. We don't know if the person actually thought "god" was offensive to somebody; maybe the editor was a religious extremist who was himself offended. It seems so irrational that I can more easily imagine it as the boss's pothead nephew thinking he would pull a big joke on everyone. Of course, I can't be sure of that.

The bigger story is about human nature, and the silly thrill some people get from complaining about their imaginary enemies.

by absolutely

The movie was originally made in Hollywood. No further editing was required from the point of initial production to "make the whole enterprise look ridiculous."

by absolutely

Then, Tipper Gore is a conservative?

It was her shock at the song "Darling Nikki" by Prince that led to censorshi* stickers on popular music. Sorry, dude, your boys are the other half of the problem.

This discussion is closed to new replies.