oppose the war, support the troops .. dichotomy ?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
at least a little :^0
American in a Broad sense will cover N. and S. America though, and still be accurate.
btw -- killing a Mexican could easily be the same as an American -- even without the broader scope. How many illegals live in the USA?
by oz_media
by oz_media
To offer a twist like that, I knew you knew better.
Actually you are very right, I go to the UK and people ask if I'm an American (which isn't usually a good thing), when I say I am CanEnglish (UK citizen living in Canada, hey you can have African-Americans!) they warm up and buy me a beer, want to sit and chat etc.
I once booked a band who turned up in a South London pub for their gig and they got tossed out. I turned up fashionably late for sound check and wondered why they were all sitting on their gear outside the van. After talking to the pub owner and explaining that TWO of the guys were Canadian, not American, he apologized let them in and they had an awesome show.
You would never get that many Canadians or Americans buying the band rounds after a gig!
.....Righteous.
Yea, that's it - fits you to a tee.
by oz_media
While some would see that as insulting, I find it quite complimentary, thank you.
]:)
by deepsand
We're not talking about logistical support. Your seemingly deliberate misrepresentation in this regard, for the purpose of turning this into an opportunity for "liberal" bashing, is unworthy of further comment.
As for "victory must be achieved or their sacrifice is wasted," this is pure, unadulterated BS.
The efforts of those who play on the team that loses is in no way diminished by the loss; neither is that of those playing on the winning team justified by the victory.
by road-dog
Who had to watch those last few helicopters leave the embassy roof in Saigon. My Uncle Andy has had a lot to say on the issue....
He remembers the winter soldier hearings.
I'm betting that there are a lot fewer monuments to the poor schlubs who got drafted by the 3rd Reich than there are for the Allies.
To some degree, the honor in service is directly tied to the results. History honors the winners. Te losers are a footnote.
I'm not talking about logistical support and you know it.
by deepsand
Then there is no grounds for conflating the "mission" and the "man."
As for monuments, etal., there is a distinct difference between rememberances and "honor." If you've ever worn a uniform you should know that; that you seem not to suggests that you have not.
by deepsand
by deepsand
Mexico held the Security Council Presidency,
There was fear a UN Resolution, specifically 'Prohibiting' Military Intervention, would be tabled, One such resolution was 'In the pipeline'.
Even if the resolution failed, the publicity was likely to delay any Military Operation. The climate in Iraq, would prevent the start of any ops, till after the hot season. That would have given Sadam Hussein ample time to carry on a 'cat & mouse' game. The window of opportunity would have closed.
"mars gravior sub pace latet" A severer war lies hidden under peace.
This was the analysis at the time. as ever, "solituniemfaciunt pacem appellant." They make a wilderness and call it peace!
This was the Resolution that loomed over all the decision maker's heads:-
Iraq
Declaration Russia - Germany - France
(3/5/2003)
Our common objective remains the full and effective disarmament of Iraq, in compliance with Resolution 1441.
We consider that this objective can be achieved by the peaceful means of the inspections.
We moreover observe that these inspections are producing increasingly encouraging results:
The destruction of the Al-Samoud missiles has started and is making progress,
Iraqis are providing biological and chemical information,
The interviews with Iraqi scientists are continuing.
Russia, Germany and France resolutely support Messrs Blix and El-Baradei and consider the meeting of the Council on 7 March to be an important step in the process put in place.
We firmly call for the Iraqi authorities to co-operate more actively with the inspectors to fully disarm their country. These inspections cannot continue indefinitely.
We consequently ask that the inspections now be speeded up, in keeping with the proposals put forward in the memorandum submitted to the Security Council by our three countries. We must:
Specify and prioritise the remaining issues, programme by programme,
Establish, for each point, detailed timelines.
Using this method, the inspectors have to present without any delay their work programme accompanied by regular progress reports to the Security Council. This programme could provide for a meeting clause to enable the Council to evaluate the overall results of this process.
In these circumstances, we will not let a proposed resolution pass that would authorise the use of force.
Russia and France, as permanent members of the Security Council, will assume all their responsibilities on this point.
We are at a turning point. Since our goal is the peaceful and full disarmament of Iraq, we have today the chance to obtain through peaceful means a comprehensive settlement for the Middle-East, starting with a move forward in the peace process, by :
Publishing and implementing the roadmap ;
Putting together a general framework for the Middle-East, based on stability and security, renunciation of force, arms control and trust building measures
It is?.
Aside from being unfair, them having a heck of a lot of arms, and a distinct lack of peace. I can see great strides being taken, backwards.....
No nation of any type is going to disarm while having a gun pointed them by the people telling them they aren't necessary.
Just because they are unellightened foreigners doesn't mean they are imbeciles.
by jck
I am against the war, because the principle of beginning it was unfounded and a falsehood.
I am in support of the soldiers, because like me they do their job.
Some people say "well if you believe it's wrong, then you wouldn't kill".
A) Jessie is right. If you have an auto rifle and someone starts shooting bullets or RPGs or mortars at you, you aren't just going to stand up and offer them tea.
B) If you work in IT and your boss comes to you and says "I want you to migrate this server because..." and you know it's absolutely wrong...do you say no out of principle and just not do it? Lose your family, house, work future with a bad reference? Or do you do your job?
Anyways, I support the troops. They are just doing their job. Sure, there are the dingleberry troops that shoot people unnecessarily...but, they are a vast minority of those who are there either to get college money, or to supplement/provide an income for their family.
But, I don't support the administration...or the lie they used to put us there.
by jdclyde
by jck
your question prohibits me from making a choice in the future, whether it is Bush or Obama related.
You aren't even giving Obama a chance. You gave Bush 8 years, and look what a mess this country is in.
Give the man a break. He hasn't even taken office, and he's already trying to get great minds together to try and undo what 8 years of Bush and Cheney and Rumsfeld and Rove and the rest off "The Free Stooges" did.
BTW, I support Obama's effort and ideology of getting Iraq as stable as possible, then safely pulling our troops out and getting them home. We've lost enough of our men and women over there over a lie that the Bush administration perpetuated.
Does that mean Iraq will be totally stable when we leave? No, but little kids who are learning to walk have to fall down sometime and learn to get back up on their own. Give them the best training and chance you can, then make a reasonable withdrawl and let them live according to their own devices.
Will I support Obama's efforts? So long as he sticks to the premise of what he's said for almost 2 years...get Iraq reasonably stable...and get our people out of there.
As for opposing anything to do with Iraq...no...I wouldn't oppose [b]anything[/b]...because, I try to keep an open mind. :p
The people of Iraq never asked us to help. Other leaders (North Korea, Iran, Ivory Coast, etc) are killing their own people, and yet we don't go into any of those countries...some of which have more developed weapons arsenals than Iraq ever thought of having...and hunt them down and try and establish Democracy.
If Iraq had been a worst case scenario, I'd see maybe going in and stopping the genocide.
But, a country like North Korea can get away with starving and murdering and raping its own people all because it has a nuclear weapons program.
Anyways...are you ALWAYS going to belittle and grind down on Obama's efforts? Or, are you gonna cut the guy a break.
After all, he is YOUR soon-to-president now...like it...or not. :p
If the people in Iraq stop trying to kill us, we can leave. We can't stay forever but now we are in Iraq, we have to stay as long as the Iaqis are trying to kill us to make us leave. As soon as the Iaqis stop trying to kill us to make us leave, we WILL leave and they will never see us again. So, as long as the Iraqis continue trying to kill us to make us leave, we will never leave.
Hell! Worked in vietNam, didn't it?
the Iraqi death toll is quite higher than ours, so it isnt just us that they are trying to kill.
We will leave when IRAQ is without citizens anymore because they killed each other off completely.
Unfortunately, when we kill the ones who are trying to kill us, we kill some who are not trying to kill us which makes some who didn't want to kill us, want to kill us which then means we must kill not only the ones who previously wanted to kill us but also the ones who want to kill us because we killed people who didn't want to kill us.
So...
How do we kill all the ones who are trying to kill us so that none of those who do not want to kill want to kill us?
Because if we can solve THAT, we can go home. If we're quick enough...
by jdclyde
Nor slammed Obama in any way, shape, or form.
You said you were against the war because of why we are there. How will/can that change, no matter who the president is? The reason we were there will not have changed.
I think it is just your anti-Bush streak that distorts everything he is connected to.
Wanna bet Obama doesn't throw Haliburton out?
Obama has also already backed away from his original quick out plan, just like he is now backing away from his promised punishing of people that make over $250K.
This isn't about Bush, it isn't about Obama, it is about Iraq, what we are doing there, and what it will take to get out.
by jck
[b][i] I didn't put ANY restrictions on my statement[/i][/b]
True. You were trying to corner me into not giving myself the ability to decide where I stand based on the current facts presented.
[i]Nor slammed Obama in any way, shape, or form.[/i]
So, your insistence that I decide on Obama's actions (knowing that I'm not going to because I'm not a muppet like some people you argue with) before he even makes any (because obviously, he's not in office yet) isn't your usual prelude into how I won't decide because you [b]know[/b] that I won't because you [b]know[/b] that I feel otherwise inside?
I've seen this path of tactic on your part before. You were trying to twist it into that I am either "biased" against Bush, or that I am not admitting the truth.
Just like you tried to twist out of admitting Bush screwed things up...both economically here and tactically in the Persian Gulf region...for the past 3 years.
[i]You said you were against the war because of why we are there. How will/can that change, no matter who the president is? The reason we were there will not have changed.[/i]
You're absolutely right about that. Very obvious deduction on your part.
The thing that will change is:
Obama (and/or his Vice-President) do not hold major, vested interest in the single major non-bidding contract awardee for petroleum facilities engineering and placement.
Bush and Cheney do.
Obama has said that he will move the troops out within 18 months, I believe. I'm waiting to see if he does that.
Bush has been saying for 3 years that we're going to be bringing home our troops as soon as possible. Yet, we still have over 140,000 troops deployed in Iraq (as of August 2008, according to the Department of Defense). That is an increase of over 10,000 troops than the original 130,000 that were originally deployed.
Now, why (if we have been training the Iraqis on how to police and defend themselves) are we still there after 3-4 years?
It makes no sense.
BTW, you should go read the press report about how many $100Ms are being spent on contracts that never get done in Iraq. It's scary. The DoD and Bush Administration are signing off on contracts that have initial payouts...to contractors that have (in some cases) never done that sort of work before and can't complete the project.
Maybe...a little head-turning going on there?
[i]I think it is just your anti-Bush streak that distorts everything he is connected to.[/i]
It's not an anti-Bush streak. It's an anti-stupidity streak. It's an anti-liar streak. It's an anti-getting-American-soldiers-killed streak.
[i]Wanna bet Obama doesn't throw Haliburton out?[/i]
He probably won't, because Obama doesn't have the authority to throw them out of Iraq. He's going to be the President of the United States, not President of Iraq.
Plus if contracts have already been awarded and paid, the DoD would have to cut them off and end the contract based on the terms of it. Not the President of the United States.
[i]Obama has also already backed away from his original quick out plan, just like he is now backing away from his promised punishing of people that make over $250K.[/i]
He hasn't backed out from a "quick out" plan, cause it was never quick. What he suggested was either 16 or 18 months. Can't remember for sure.
As for punishing people...how much worse can the punishment get? Bush's administration
has punished all 300M+ Americans with an economy that is failed with record unemployment, record bankruptcy, record business closings, record homelessness.
How much worse can it really get, jdclyde? Unemployment in my county is over 9%. that's about 12,000 people out of work where I live. The highest unemployment totals here in over 20 years.
Ya think Obama can do any worse?
[i]This isn't about Bush, it isn't about Obama, it is about Iraq, what we are doing there, and what it will take to get out. [/i]
What it will take to get out is someone who is willing to tell the Iraqis:
"We are going to finish training your people within this amount of time, and then we are going to transition you into full control over this amount of time, then we are going to withdraw over this amount of time."
And honestly, I pray Obama does it like he said he would and gets our troops out.
I'm sick of seeing signs on the side of the road and billboards when I drive down the highways here ...of people who were killed over there all over a lie that was perpetuated by the Bush administration and the senior officials.
It's time to bring our people home. Too many parents have lost a child...too many children have lost their parent.
That's what it's all about. Doing right by America, and not what makes the administration look "successful".
by jdclyde
please show what and were Bush was responsible for the current "record unemployment, record bankruptcy, record business closings, record homelessness."
Thanks.
As for the handling of Iraq, he did to little to late. If you go in for a fight, you give them everything you have. That was his mistake. Not sealing the borders, mistake. Expecting there to be a quick rising up of the locals, especially after Gulf War when we led them to believe we were going to do more, and left them to be slaughtered. With all the anti talk going on from our own media and politicians, what confidence would they have that we were not going to bail on them again? There have been plenty of things Bush has done wrong. If we retreat and allow another slaughter, there will never be any credibility in anything we do, including in Afghanistan.
by gate keeper
by gate keeper
Following the overthrow of Saddam Hussein there was a small window of opportunity to use Iraqi nationalism and what it meant in terms of the self-identity and a sense of self-worth of the Iraqi people. The opportunity to use this force in setting up a replacement government (and thus get out of Iraq quickly) was severely curtailed by the invalid premise by which we invaded and by the method of invasion - "shock and awe". (Put simply, we had no justification for the invasion and we went about it the wrong way).
Then we gave away a whole chunk of their territory to the Kurds.
Saddam?s only real legacy to Iraqi was a strong nationalism. Given that, there is no reason to think that the Iraqis should welcome invaders who stayed beyond the overthrow of their leader and attempted to impose a political system which they didn't ask for and is not suitable. the legacy of the US invasion is high unemployment, high crime rates, unreliable electricity and other public services.
What are the Iraqis supposed to feel other than humiliation - which generated the prolonged resistance that we have seen?
by mpruett
http://www.antiwar.com/quotes.php
Allow the president to invade a neighboring nation, whenever he shall deem it necessary to repel an invasion, and you allow him to do so whenever he may choose to say he deems it necessary for such a purpose?and you allow him to make war at pleasure.
~Abraham Lincoln
Wars are not paid for in wartime, the bill comes later.
~Benjamin Franklin
Victory means exit strategy, and it?s important for the President to explain to us what the exit strategy is.
~George W. Bush
Cheers!
HAPPY THANKSGIVING!
by jck
[i]If we retreat and allow another slaughter, there will never be any credibility in anything we do, including in Afghanistan.[/i]
Actually, it's not a retreat. It's a withdrawl. No one is running us out. We are going to finish training their police and military, finish helping them establish their government, then leave because we are DONE there.
Hopefully under Obama, it's not going to be a mindless, on-going, never-ending run-around like it is now under the Bush Administration.
[i]please show what and were Bush was responsible for the current "record unemployment, record bankruptcy, record business closings, record homelessness."[/i]
Okay, here you go. Please read carefully. I don't want to have to show you another economics lesson or explain how an inept president making bad decisions and not doing his job leads to economic crisis in our country:
a) Bush has obliterated the huge (reportedly estimated to have been over $1T by FY2001) surplus that Clinton left this country with upon his exit from the White House.
b) Bush has gone and run a war in Iraq that has cost trillions to this country, but then he and his shady team have hidden the numbers as "off budget items" so that it doesn't so in the budget and isn't applied against the federal deficit numbers.
c) Bush sat idly by in his ranch every month as the American economy tanked and the housing market plummeted. He didn't push Congress to do anything to help. He didn't use his authority to put things into action. He just sat there, grinned a lot, and kept saying how strong our economy was.
d) Bush's administration and it's pursuit to deregulate has caused less oversight in a banking industry that went rampant after Bush and a Republican controlled congress further loosened up controls and restrictions on Federal housing lending programs in 2002-2004, and have continued to refuse to exercise their regulatory authority over the mortgage industry to keep them from abusing their badly placed decisions.
e.g.-
[b][i]"Bush administration objected to a proposal to have an independent regulator of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac be an independent unit of Treasury, much like financial regulators housed in the agency that oversee banks and thrifts. The Bush administration also objected to a proposal to have the Department of Housing and Urban Development have oversight over the companies' business activities. The independence provision has broad support from committee Democrats and Republicans. The HUD provision was pushed mostly by Democrats but had been accepted by Oxley and Baker as a compromise needed to move the bill forward." - Washington Post, 10/8/2003
...
October 26, 2005: House of Representatives passed regulation reforming the GSE's. The bill passed the House 331-90 (Republicans: 209-15; Democrats: 122-74), and would have given the new regulator broad authority over setting capital requirements and limiting portfolio size. Senate Democrats picked that bill up and offered it, but the Administration opposed that legislation. According to Mr. Oxley, the White House gave Congress and the GSE reform legislation "a one-finger salute."[/i][/b]
You see, his lack of ability and/or unwillingness to move the country in a direction using the powers instilled to his position under law...has caused a financial crisis that has led to the economic slowdown.
People spend less, people lose jobs.
People spend less, businesses close.
People lose jobs, people lose houses.
People lose jobs, people declare bankruptcy for protection.
So that's your lesson for today, jd. I hope you learned something about how a president who spends more time on his ranch lounging than being at his office working and making policy decisions and directing the country he is [b]supposed to be leading[/b]...that it causes these sort of things.
So now you know why:
Bush is inept as a president.
And that it wasn't solely Clinton administration housing plans that caused the mortgage and credit crisis that has led to this recession, but Bush and his administrations deregulation of control that allowed lending institutions to lend money stupidly because there was insufficient oversight.
Now, if you would be so kind:
Tell me whether or not you follow all that logic, or if I have to get the crayons out and draw you pictures.
BTW...Happy Thanksgiving. I won't be on for 2 days.
by jdclyde
Heck, I will be unplugged until Monday. Not even cell signal without having to drive 20 minutes..... B-)
And the difference, I know that Dems have their hands just as dirty as Bush on everything that has gone both right and wrong, and am honest enough to admit it.
I must have missed where Bush veto'ed a bill over the last two years from the Democrat ruled congress to do anything about anything other than lip service and run the country down. Should have known it was all his fault somehow, right?
Last statement about Iraq. My only question on it was IF things go perfect under Obama and we are out in 16 months, will it then be a good thing in your eyes, or will this always be a bad thing no matter how it turns out? No trap set there, just an honest question. Just do damn mellow lately to bother with anything more, ya know?
by road-dog
And then 3 more years with 4th ANGLICO, USMCR
Wrong again!
I've been "the man". I differentiate between the two. I suggest that constant derision of the mission affects the man and his morale.
My observation was about history's treatment of the losing side in a war. We honor those by remembrance. You're picking flysh1t out of pepper....
by deepsand
by jck
that you were off... lol
[i][b] Heck, I will be unplugged until Monday. Not even cell signal without having to drive 20 minutes..... B-)[/i][/b]
I was off all weekend too from my job, but I played computer tech, network tech, lawnmower service tech, ceiling fan tech, and super shopper....for my parents. Happy Thanksgiving, eh? lol
[i][b] And the difference, I know that Dems have their hands just as dirty as Bush on everything that has gone both right and wrong, and am honest enough to admit it.[/b][/i]
Maybe so, but one things seperate the Dems from the Reps: Until 2006, the Reps were in control of the White House and Congress.
They had all the say-so, and didn't do a whole heck of a lot.
[i][b] I must have missed where Bush veto'ed a bill over the last two years from the Democrat ruled congress to do anything about anything other than lip service and run the country down. Should have known it was all his fault somehow, right?[/i][/b]
And in the data I presented you, I told you that the big veto-ing and legislative deregulation of the banking process happened from 2002-2004...by Bush...and the Congress controlled by the Reps.
The Republicans were so gung-ho into deregulating everything that their plans didn't include making sure proper oversight of a capitalistic business sector would be in place. All they wanted to do was sure-up the "bottom line", which is a typical, short-sighted view of most conservatives only looking to short term gain and not long-term viability...both in business and government.
[i][b] Last statement about Iraq. My only question on it was IF things go perfect under Obama and we are out in 16 months, will it then be a good thing in your eyes, or will this always be a bad thing no matter how it turns out? No trap set there, just an honest question. Just do damn mellow lately to bother with anything more, ya know?[/i][/b]
Will "it"? Oh no, there's no trap there.
1) It will be good that no more American troops are killed...yes.
2) It will be good that we quit spending our money (actually, money we're borrowing from countries (soverign funds) like...CHINA?), and we can focus more on feeding our hungry, housing our homeless, educating our children, taking care of our elderly, and protecting our own citizens.
However, will it be good that we get out of the Middle East? For whom? Us? The Middle East? Israel?
That is an unanswerable question in its form.
If Iraq defends her borders and enforces her laws properly, then it will be good for everyone involved.
The region being more secure means lower oil prices, decreased sectarianism (since the Iraq government is multi-ethnic and working together seemingly), and another country whose participation with other Middle East countries means harmony in the region amongst those nations (compared to Saddam's reign invading Kuwait and often incurring his Republican Guard across their borders).
So the safest answer to the vague question of:
[i]...will it then be a good thing in your eyes, or will this always be a bad thing no matter how it turns out? [/i]
Maybe. lol
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending