Discussion Locked

Scientists finally agree that humans contribute to global warming

0 helpful
359 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

No doubt this will bring Maxwell Edison out from wherever he is hiding, and lead to a few thousand more posts wasted on the question of whether or not humans are contributing to global warming.

[b][News.com.au, November 18, 2007][/b]

Governments must do more to fight global warming, spurred by a new UN scientific report and damage to nature that is already as frightening as science fiction, UN Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said.

?This report will be formally presented to the (UN Climate Change) Conference in Bali,? Mr Ban told delegates from more than 130 nations in Valencia and praised them for agreeing an authoritative guide to the risks of climate change.

?Already, it has set the stage for a real breakthrough - an agreement to launch negotiations for a comprehensive climate change deal that all nations can embrace,? he said.

Mr Ban singled out the US and China, the world's top two emitters of greenhouse gases, which have no binding goals for curbs, as key countries in the process.

He welcomed initiatives by both and urged them to do more.

?I look forward to seeing the US and China playing a more constructive role starting from the Bali conference,? Mr Ban told a news conference.

?Both countries can lead in their own way.?

Mr Ban said he had just been to see ice shelves breaking up in Antarctica and the melting Torres del Paine glaciers in Chile.

He also visited the Amazon rainforest, which he said was being ?suffocated? by global warming.

?I come to you humbled after seeing some of the most precious treasures of our planet - treasures that are being threatened by humanity's own hand,? he said.

?These scenes are as frightening as a science fiction movie,? Mr Ban said.

?But they are even more terrifying, because they are real.?

Delegates at UN climate change talks reached agreement on the 26-page document about the risks of warming, blamed mainly on human burning of fossil fuels, after several days of talks.

The document, which summarises the latest scientific knowledge on the causes and effects of climate change, will be put before environment ministers in Bali, Indonesia, next month - a meeting likely to agree a two-year strategy to negotiate a successor to the Kyoto Protocol whose first period ends in 2012.

The summary says human activity is causing rising temperatures and that deep cuts in greenhouse gas emissions, mainly from burning fossil fuels, are needed quickly to avert more heat waves, melting glaciers and rising sea levels.

Bali meeting

Scientists and government officials from the 130-state Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) have boiled down the findings of three reports of more than 3000 pages issued this year on the risks of warming.

Delegates from the environmental movement appeared relatively happy the synthesis had not watered down the message from the scientific advisers, as they had feared it might.

?The strong message of the IPCC can't be watered down - the science is crystal clear,? said Hans Verolme, Director of environmental group WWF's Global Climate Change Program.

"The hard fact is we have caused climate change, and it's also clear that we hold the solution ... in our hands."

Delegates said the US delegation had been at the centre of some of the fiercest debate this week.

Sources close to the discussions said the US had tried to change or even remove a key section of the report which lists five main reasons for concern about the effects of warming.

?This has been a very tough week and we've had to debate and defend everything we wanted but the draft report that we submitted has remained intact and has even had additions made in terms of emphasis and even facts that have come to light,? IPCC Chairman Rajendra Pachauri said.

?When you're on strong scientific ground, you don't yield any ground.

"We have to make sure that scientific truth is not suppressed.?

The Kyoto treaty obliges 36 industrial nations to cut emissions by at least five per cent below 1990 levels by 2008-12.

A new deal would aim to involve outsiders led by the US and China, which have no Kyoto goals.

359 replies

by jardinier

Well this is very telling, is it not? Hundreds upon hundreds of posts to the numerous discussions, mostly started by Maxwell "Pet Peeve" Edison, both for and against the notion of humans contributing to global warming, and now that it is universally accepted by the scientific community as well as governments around the world, no-one has the balls to say: "I was wrong."

Nor does anyone here apparently care enough to make a positive comment on this promising news item.

So I will leave the ostriches to do whatever it is ostriches do, and I for one will say that I am VERY PLEASED to learn that positive preventive action will now be taken.

by danlm

The restricting of the United States to try and drive it into third world status.

The tree huggers will argue for harsher and more restrictive energy generation to the point that it will not be produced.

Wind farms, not in any place that MAY affect natural wild life. Oh my, an owl will die. Oh my, it ruin my scenic view of the pretty mountains.

Wave farms, not in any place that MAY affect sea life. They don't care if it much more efficient and cost effective in specific area's.

Solar, you are placing these solar arrays in places that will adversely affect both plant and wild life. They don't care if it's the best place collection arrays.

Let's look at hybrid vehicles. I am sure they will find ways of placing restrictions on the distribution system so that these vehicles will not become feasible. You want this to work, you make it so that the common person will be able to afford and use it. Their restrictive policy will stop both of these achievements.

Tree huggers are after 1 thing only. Not more efficient and environmental friendly energy use. They are after the destruction of any and all established industrial nations.

When your all without jobs because there will be no more energy to power it. When you are without food because the distribution system has been crippled beyond repair due to tree hugger restrictions. Hell, when you are without food because the tree huggers have stopped proven growing methods because they feel a freakin owl is more important then a human life.

You sit there... In your cold lonely house wondering where your next meal is going to come from. Wondering how you are going to cloth your children. And you can blame it on the tree huggers and idiots that have no idea what the word compromise is. Because they are after the destruction of life as we know it, not their stated noble goals.

I'm sorry, I think the global warming community is being lead around by it's nose by people that have alternate goals in mind. They should have every examined as closely as what they say large business and government should. And if you argue that point, then you really are naive now arn't you.

And if you will notice, every energy position I put forward was renewable now wasn't it. So, don't flame me for being anti renewable energy. You can flame me for not being all geee, golly wiz. The global warming community said this. The global warming community said that. B.S. They have their agenda, and I don't think it is what they say it is.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

Not like those honest caring types in the oil, coal, power generation and transport industries.

They are only interested in the public good and the long term future of mankind.

ROFLMAO.

by oz_media

Without falling off your chair laughing.

Okay, well it' sobvious that you are speaking from empotion and not reality, as your comments are so blanket and so ABSURD.

WHat you are referring to is RADICAL left wing dogooders who don't know good from bad, they are no different than the bind Republican followers who do so just because they want to join that club.

REAL, environmental agencies do no such thing. IN fact, it is BECAUSE of the radicals that the real threats are easily ignored. Again, no different than the right wing media, hiring left wing radicals for FIX and others so that THEY in turn seem less credible, making the Right appear MORE credible. It's just such basic marketing.

"The restricting of the United States to try and drive it into third world status"

OYU dismiss reality with ease, "oh no an owl may die", or "my view of the mountains will be lost". Your right in singular instances it is a little absurd. On that same note though, how many times have RIGHT wing Americans freaked out entirely over a single camera beingused somewhere or RFID being used for asset tracking. Of course it's never the single issue they refer to, but it's the 'give them an inch and they'll take a mile" mentality that drives them.

In that same sense, it's not ONE owl or ONE view lost, but when one is lost, how can you tell the next guy he CAN'T developor CAN'T remove a tree, why not, the other guy was alowed too. And such is the common loser mentality.

You also run on about hybrid vehicles, displaying what little you actually know on the subject (as do many others right and left). In reality, it creates MORE pollution to make a hybrid, and even mroe for an electric car. The emissions reduction is considerable when brand new and maintained carefully, yet doesn't stay that way.
Consider the Toymotor Prius for example, first of all, his great vehicle costs $15K more than a standard vehicle of teh same size, meaning you'd have to drive it a long time to see any financial benefit over a normal gas vehicle. the prius also has, at last count a few months ago, 52 that's [b]FIFTY TWO [/b]recalls in its short lifespan already, with two complete design changes.
There's no way a consumer will save with such a car, and therefor eat such a high price, it is not going to be a benefit to anyone. Electric cars are just awful when it comes ot manufacturing, the pollution saved for teh life of these cars will often be les than the added pollution of manufacturing them and the waste created.

A clear example of of your rash conclusion is in the rest of your post, you instantly start on about living in cold homes with no food. That is the most retarded response to a real issue I've heard. As with most Americans, there is no middle ground.

It must be extreme left vs extreme right, radcial vs radical, becaus eif they meet and agree at somepoint, the US speration of the people is lost, and then where would you be? Getting along and progressing as a nation?
Not bloody likely to happen in my lifetime.

Get real and discuss real issues, you may want to start here, no radicals to be found: http://www.davidsuzuki.com

When you come down to reality and discuss real issue with other real people, yuo'll get somewhere. While it it simply left vs right, and political motivation with little to no real factual information, it will not get anywhere....look at US politics for that example.

by deepsand

I know that you're capable of a more reasoned and measured response.

Why this instead?

by doublebarrel

You are exactly right. If Intel has trouble controlling the environment in a small controlled space so they can make processors and other IC's how can anyone pretend to be able to tell what the environment of earth is going to be like. Does anyone remember the 1970's when we were going to have the next "Ice Age" in less than a century? Al Gore and his "Global Warming" cronies are some of the biggest polluters on the planet but it is OK because they "buy Carbon Points" ??????? Check into the energy consumption of his house. We better get real or the wackos will have us back in the dark ages.

by oz_media

Even after the initial invasion of Iraq when Cowboy Bush said he was wrong and that they hadn't found teh stockpiles of WMD he was "assured" were there, they were still here saying it was true and they had been MOVED. I think you remember that one, man, some people's pride just cannot allow mistakes in judgement. Especially after all the flaming and 'anti-American' name calling that flew here for a few years.

How can a rooster tuck his tail between his legs after cocking all those doodles for a year or so?

That's okay, silence speaks volumes too.

by oz_media

While in some ways we appear to be clean and globally concerned in Canada, we still don't fit quite yet. It seems more Canadians use heat in the winter, and burn a lot of wood go figure, that's why I used to cut a few cords every summer!

As for GW in general, talk about old hat! C'Mon Jules, you have better fodder than that, mate. :D

Global warming, even Cowboy Bush has picked up on that one now, why not it's a great way to gain press...I mean Republican voter support, same thing.

by deepsand

be replaced by fluorescents by 2010.

A small step, perhaps; but, more than most have done to date.

by dr dij

20% of e- will need to come from geothermal sources in two years. (5% now)

the good thing is that geothermal runs 24hrs a day. and is almost pollution free. why almost? the steam they get from underground is not in pipes. they inject water into drill holes in the rocks. This picks up small amounts of metals, other elements.

However still less than any fossil fuel plant.

They also create earthquakes. But only small local ones, and these can be controlled by limiting steam injection when they start to occur.

by jdclyde

Besides making incandescent bulb manufacturers a lot of money, what is the effect of this mandate?

Sure, now we have warnings about Mercury poisoning if you break one.

If ALL bulbs world-wide were changed over, this would have WHAT effect on GW?

by danlm

I'm saying they are not the nights in shining armor that everyone thinks they are. They are no frikin better then who you just mentioned. How's that. They have a hidden agenda that is just as twisted and sick as what they accuse others of.

But they are getting away with not having everything they say and do being scrutinized like every oil, coal, power generation, and transport industry is.

And I don't think they want to be scrutinized like they do to others.

Does that qualify my position enough for you?

They are as two faced, as big of lairs, and as uncaring as every section of industry that you mentioned. They go out of their way to stop progress when it is in their favor. They go out of their way to criticize continuously any company that sets records in becoming 'more green'.
[i]On the other side, a coalition of 23 environmental and human rights groups that issued a report earlier this year critical of Wal-Mart's efforts said it still believes Wal-Mart is simply too big and too reliant on global sourcing and shipping to be green.[/i]
http://money.cnn.com/news/newsfeeds/articles/apwire/268df1f82220faff88fe6bb104cea0d3.htm

In other words, they don't want to see them succeed.

Tell me they aren't out to bring down big business. B.S.

Dan

by tony hopkinson

treehugging unamerican commie ratfink.

They were right about unamerican of course.

I'm a pragmatist. Every measure that's greener than what we have now I'll take.

Walmart are not green, they are starting to become greener, as pubic (??? public :D ) perception changes.

Walmart sell out of season produce, because we buy it.

They put the produce in free plastic bags, because we won't pay for them.

They buy in bulk and then throw away the excess, because we won't pay for anything else.

They drive down suppliers prices forcing them to use short term but effective growing techniques, generally involving shed loads of various chemicals, because we won't pay for anything else.

Walmart are not anti green they are anti making a loss.

There are dumb asses on both sides of this debate.

Do things need to change, Yes.

Will putting big business out of business do the job, No.

My agenda is for my grandson, not to be left clearing up all the sh1t we are leaving behind.

by danlm

I'm pretty sure that you know that my girlfriend is a teacher in the 8th grade. One of her favorite subjects happens to be history.

When it comes to the Revolutionary War, she does it a little different then most class's. She has an online friend from the U.K. who has sent her the history lessons from the U.K. for the same period. When she does this period of history, she also teaches what the English thought and learn on the subject. The school found out she is doing this and think it's a great idea, which I do also. She is trying to show all perceptions of that period of time of history.

I just thought you might find it interesting.

Dan

by oz_media

Try nto being so politically opposed. Focus on teh real issues and the real people involved, not just left and right radicals, and you will actually get somewhere with this.

Who are 'THEY' if not right wing radcials and inexperienced unqualified speakers.

You see the people who make the news and teh papers, nto the people who are actually tryign to improve with reason.

again ,take some time to learn about who is really dseeing issues and not just freking out: http://www.davidsuzuki.com
There's no way you can consider such a man as radical, misinformed or unqualified, in fact his opinion and skill is sought out worldwide...yes he is a descendant of the Suzuki family of motor fame.

by danlm

I did not see it till I had replied to all of your other rants.

But, then again. I don't think you took the time to read all my response's before you went at me.

dan

by mjwx

same as not all businessmen are greedy money grubbing people who don't care who they screw over so long as there is a buck in it.

The stereotyped people are a tiny minority in both groups that unfortunately create these bloody inaccurate stereotypes. Radical nutjobs ruin it for everybody.

In actual fact one of the most successful businessmen I know is also the biggest greenie I know and manages to tie the two successfully. He runs a tree farm out of his home (which is a few acres) which turns a profit.

All the greenies I know will simply give you tips on how to be a bit more green, they don't want you to change your life that dramatically. For example, if I'm purchasing two items at the supermarket they would say to ask not to have a plastic bag or will it really hurt to put my plastics, paper and cans in a second bin to my general refuse. I actually do both, with these reusable bags http://www.planetark.com/plasticbags/go_green_bag.jpg
I have cut plastic bag usage down to almost nothing (I just have to remember to take them with me). Just small things that can reduce the consumption of natural resources.

Granted that recycling is made a bit easier over here by [i]some[/i] councils making recycling pickups when they collect the garbage (single and dual bin recycling)

by danlm

If it is as you say, that most of the groups are like Tony and yourself. Then remove these extremists from any position of responsibility or spokesman ship. Because, otherwise you will get people like me that point out their total oppressive views and how they are trying to destroy industrialization.

Because that is their ultimate goal. I will not stand here and listen quietly as they preach the new gospel without showing the oppressiveness of their positions. There is not a person here on TR that doesn't hate the extremists. Left or right. Political or religious. Theirs is just as oppressive and extremist as any political or religious position that is in the news today.

Dan

by danlm

If you don't beleive it, thats fine. But when I can find postings where they try to block wind farms. They say nothing that Walmart does will be good enough(this post, see link). In my mind, the radical element of these groups has shown its true colors.

Dan

by oz_media

What a rant, certainly far too unqualified for TR debate. Needs to do some homework first I think.

by tonythetiger

Some humans aren't getting "their way" and they believe other humans are the reason why. They therefore feel they must control these other humans' behaviors. It's not limited to the environment... most '*ists' are that way, and they all recruit new members by appealing to either fear or selfishness. Everything's an "us vs. them" to them.

by oz_media

Broad assertion, first of all I don't think Tony and I are anything alike, however we may have similar interests if we ever explored that path. For YOU, someone who knows absolutely nothing whatsoever about the two people you are referring, and I mean NOTHING, ZIP ZERO ABSOLUTE NIL, how the hell can you POSSIBLY suggest we are alike or even begin to compare us to anyone else? That's simply absurd to even consider. And I never said that most groups are like Tony and myself either.

Give your head a shake man!
[i]Then remove these extremists from any position of responsibility or spokesman ship.[/i]

So you think it's just left wing extremists, who are practicing their Constitutional right to free speech and government protest?

YOu still completely stick your head in the sand when it comes to realizing the RIGHT WING is absolutely no different? If you do see it, then you too should REMOVE THAT RIGHT WING EXTREMIST WHO RUNS YOUR COUNTRY, but America chose to reelect him, mush to the dismay of the rest of the free world.

Your understanding of the real issue is obviously so unqualified and unresearched beyond paying attention to teh radicals who spew to the media. How can you then make such assertions as "trying to destroy industrialization."..."Because that is their ultimate goal."

That's exactly th ekind of right wing ignorance I am referring to, thus making YOU a right wing radical, no different than the left wing huggers you are trying to pathetically oppose.

From your reply, I can tell that you ave no REAL invested interest into finding out what the issue are and who is actively working to help. Otherwise you would have investigated the links I posted and seen a different picture.

Remember it's always the most radical that make all the noise, that's why most of the free world doesn't like America(ns), think you are arrogant, crass, ignorant, undereducated, stuck up without reason, wasteful, gun crazy, warmongers that ruin the world, hasty and often wrong, unwanted where you feel you are needed etc.

We are forced to see the BS right wing like it or not, especially since the biggest farce of them all is running your country. If you would like to shut these people up and put them aside because you can't see the reality from the BS, then you should petition to have your Constitution changed and remove the First Ammendment.

But again, to suggest you know even the tiniest iota of information about Tony or I is just ridiculous.

by danlm

Piss off.

And you twit, I did say that the extremist buisness should not be part of the final solution. So, again. Piss off.

You don't like the fact I want you greenies under the microsope as you place others> Whats wrong, can't handle the heat. don't like your movement can be shown to have aholes just like you consider everyone else. too bad... i will point out your extremists every chance I get just like you do with the right wing, the left wing, and everyone else you don't agree with. Deal with it. Too bad if you don't like it.

And Oz, you idiot. I was trying to compliment you. I was trying to say you was a moderate that looks at all sides.

Quite obviously, i was wrong.

Get your head out of your a$$ and learn to take a compliment.

What an ahole, you really are. This is the very first time that I tried to show someone in a totally positive way that i was trashed talked for it. What do I consider postive? someone that looks at all sides. Damn, that is real bad to be considered that way now isn't it. You twit, you didn't even take the time to read my response. Or you was narrow minded in how you interpeted it(isn't that what you accuse me of) and missed the whole point.

You fkn prick, I can't beleive you flamed me when i was trying to show I agree'd with you.

fk off oz, no chit. Just fk off.

dan

by danlm

Which are the mainstay of what is shown in the media. You will also notice, and I know you read all the posts. That I point out if the grass root movement(people like Tony and Oz) don't want to have that opinion flaunted. Then they should remove these radical groups from any position of spokesman ship.

There are posts on TR where green groups have tried to stop windmills, and there was mutiple links to the story. I provided a link here where it shows that a number of groups will never be happy with what Walmart is doing. That is an example, I know Walmart has is not liked by alot of people. Myself included. I can show you links where various green groups are still not happy when companies go with cloth bags. They cry the process these bags are created.

They are not happy with any forward movement unless it is oppressive and backward growth.

And truthfully, what I did get out of the response other then to point out the foolishness of the green/global movement for allowing these extremists to be so vocoal was to see what the average grass root green person actually wants. Which is in line with what I want. Now to remove the extremists, and you will see positive forward progress in all aspects. Why, you will be able to get laws written which provides a direction of how business's should proceed. And yes, the extremist business's should be removed from this decision process.

Its time to cut to the chase, remove the nut case's from both sides of this argument. And move forward, otherwise the forward progress of nations will be stopped. Either by what the global changes that the scientist's are warning of. Or by the oppressive rules put in place by the extremists. Because NOTHING is happening now, and it's because of what I am posting about.

Dan

by tonythetiger

We need extremists. They make all of us think. If not for them we'd all think alike, and that is a real danger to the human species. What if we all thought the same thing, and it was fatally wrong?

by santeewelding

You put succinctly what drives me and most of my posts.

Take care. Some may accuse you of a con.

Even to frame it as you did admits of lower-case absolute ("we'd all"). Taken to uppercase, to process of mind, as you did, puts me in agreement with you about real, solemn danger.

There are also the lesser dangers of fierce resistance to what you call into question. Particularly if taken not as an extremist but as a turncoat.

by oz_media

First of all, grass root movement (Peple like Tony and Oz). What makes me or Tony similar? What akes me or Tony part of what you call a grass root group? I can tell you that Tony and I rarely agree on much at all, we don't support the same political parties or core values. It's obvious that, with such little attention to the issues your are trying to downplay, you are simply not getting the real picture and that's probably why you are way off track with your ranting.

Example: DO you REALLY think cloth bags is the problem people see with WalMart or do you just think that' some more thing to add to the endless list? Do you have any idea how many lawsuits employees have launched on WalMart for their repressive management practices? Do you know how many fair and just US and Canadian companies have been forced to comply of shut down due to WalMart's purchasing practices?

Do you know how many third world workers are forced to work longer hours for less money just because WalMart demands it? Do you know how many jobs WalMart has TAKEN from Americans while providing a much smaller employment rate at lower wages?

Form your comments, it is clear you do not. You just listen to a couple of guys ranting who make the press and the press runs with it. The benefit is that it makes the right wing look more credible. I'd love to review your information sources or what you consider "mainstream media". I will almost guarantee that I will find the right wing operated SBG ownership behind it.

Check your sources before you start making false claims and ranting at others, or else as you like to say, piss off.

by danlm

That has spent the amount of time and money that Walmart has into becoming green.

You show me another company that has made as much progress in cutting back on carbon emmissions.

Listen you. I don't like walmart either. You quite obviously missed that now didn't you. I did state that in another post. Take your head out ... and read everything I posted.

Your so anti walmart you won't take the progress they have made that can be used by other companies. Your a total twit for having that attitude. You say your not a left winger? No, your just so anti american that you won't take what progress is being made by it's various companies to go even further forward with the whole global warming solution.

That, in a nut shell. Is what I consider an extremist. And that in a nut shell, decribes you right now.

dan

Message was edited by: beth.blakely@...

by deepsand

I strongly suspect that your so labeling them owes solely to their failing to hew to your beliefs.

Furthermore, that "nothing is happening" owes not to the actions of "nuts" in any camp, but rather to a palpable lack of political will, owing to both the enormity of the task and its costs, particularly with respect to lifestyles.

The hard & cold fact is that looking to alternative sources of energy [b]cannot[/b] solve the problem, as the problem owes, not to a dearth of supply, but an evergrowing surfeit of demand. Seeking solutions on the supply side can ameliorate the consequences of the problem, thereby postponing the deadline for attaining a satisfactory solution; but, such alone can do no more than postpone the inevitable.

Tackling the supply side is, of course, the easier task; it's the demand side that's incredibly difficult, for it is here that the hard choices need to be made, choices that will affect the quality of life of all that have yet to draw their first breath of air, both human and otherwise.

It has been noted, by those who account for such things, that Earth's present living human population exceeds that of all its dead! Try to wrap your mind around that, and you might then to grasp the enormity of the task at hand.

"Nuts?" They are an insignificant few, are incapable of affecting the course of a determined multitude.

The real issue is if and when that multitude will rise up to save itself from extinction.

by tony hopkinson

Define progress.
To be successful in the current system?

Some other rdaicals, the establishment would have liked to have silenced.

Jesus H Christ.
Nelson Mandela
Mahatma Ghandi
George Washington
Ernest Bevin
Abraham Lincoln

....

Radical !=wrong

It's much easier for the extremists in business to silence the greens. Shut them up as annoying as they are, you keep the status quo.

Let the tree huggers shout, if they make enough noise to force the establishment to change, they've served my purpose if not their own.

by danlm

I'm sorry, but if the only thing I find in main stay publications is from what I consider radical members of the green movement.

Screw em, I'll say what I bloody well want to about them and what they promote. Maybe if more individuals such as yourself, Toney, Dr. J were the the voice that was heard. i wouldn't feel this way.

Until your radical element is silenced, then you will have to deal with my rants.

Hows that.....

Dan

by oz_media

WalMart is the poison of free enterprise. If you like WalMart in teh US, that's great, they are not wanted inmost other countries though, that's just sad, pathetic and repressive business. Here's some real info for you, I've WORKED for WalMart, by default during an unwanted takeover. Their prioces were not lower, in fact the store prices rose as WalMart took over, they are a crock of shite, keep them in your own country.

Show me how WalMart is an ethical, respectable company, AFTER taking your head out of the sand of course.

For another tidbit of information about me, I don't support the left wing either.All these false assertions you make, are just detracting from the validity of your statements, you prove yourself uninformed and then pretend you're informed, it doesn't work that way.

You can find postings about RADICALS trying to block wind farms? So what? I ca find postings about Bush being responsible for the 9/11 terror attacks, how the Republicans were responsible for the WTC bombings.

You are either trying to state that you believe everything you read on the internet?

Talk about a long way to go! You've really got to start looking outside your own miniature little world and learning to actually research and double check sources and credibility. You assume, you make assertions you even create personalities for people in your mind, get real, you couldn't be more misinformed.

I'm not saying that radical tree huggers/greenies DON'T take unqualified stands on matters but you can't stand there with no facts and simply point a finger without looking at where the rest of your finger are pointing too. Question the government, question the press, question everything because everyone is trying to make you believe something that simply isn't the whole truth.

by oz_media

[b]Mainstay publications?[/b] Please do tell.

[b]Who YOU consider radical members?[/b]
Well from your assertions so far, you have proven you make rash judgments and don't actually look for the reality behind anything anyway. Who cares who you consider radical, they are no more radical than you if you are unwilling to seek the truth.

[b]MY radical element?[/b]
[b]I have to deal with your rants?[/b] Please explain, as far as I can remember, I don't HAVE to deal with anyone here, it's just a public forum you can all disappear and shut up with a simple mouse click. From what I see, you aren't really capable from separating reality from press and fantasy.

by oz_media

YOU just rant and rant with no qualification.

Uh, I'm not a greenie NOR a left wing (NDP)supporter.

The rest of your unqualified opinion is just fluff as it is all based on a false premise thenisn't it?

And to echo your "comkpliment" piss off then.

Until you learn to understand what you read, you are an absolute waste of space, time and oxygen. I don't know why I have to share my air with the likes of you, there ought to be a law.

by oz_media

All I've seen is radical ranting and false assertions, unqualified opinions and nothing of any real structure at all.

by danlm

What can I say. And this just shows it futher.

It was a rant against not what is being accomplished, but against what can be accomplished if both RIGHT and LEFT extremists were taken out of the picture.

But, again. You idiot, you see what you want to see. You pick and choose what you want to.

You ignore the total point of this post now don't you.

Dan

by oz_media

Greenies, tree huggers etc. were all your assertions, I said it comes equally from both sides.

You need to get a clue, every post you make is rife with false assertions, character assumptions, finger pointing,name calling etc. Try reading your own posts for once, others have to.

by deepsand

Dan is indeed capable of far better than that which you see here. Whereas here we see irrational man unleased, elsewhere we have that side kept on a much shorter leash.

It is part of the human condition that, when ones rational & irrational portions attain sufficient discord, it is the later that invariably forcibly seizes the throne.

Absent personal enmity, a patient waiting will suffice for weathering the storm.

by danlm

Your biased oppinion about Walmart is skewing what they are accomplishing. And you know what you twit. Who else has the money to spend on the research that they are doing? Hu? You don't think other companies will follow what works for them? Everything from how they design their trucks to get better fuel ecomony to the way they design they stores?

What, you won't take the progress that can be gained from this? Because you hate Walmart.

What a total idiot.

Dan

by danlm

Your the only one that should have a say?

Only your rants about how my nation does nothing right?

Again, your a twit. A total moron right now.

Dan

by danlm

I point out extremists. Not what has been accomplished for the betterment. You take issue with it.

You is talking crap here. You or me?

Idiot. Shut up, your fouling the air of two nations now.

Dan

by oz_media

OR at least some relevant fact.
Trucks that are more fuel efficient. You seem to be missing that picture entirely.
YOu want to get into pollution responsibilty and vehicle design? You also suggest I am unaware of this industry? I am a certified alternate fuels specialist, a member of the Society of Automotive Engineers (yes SAE just like on your oil can) and a licenced mechanic for 15 years.

WalMart ships product from foreign countries, thus not creating products in America where the shipping pollution would be reduced. WalMart looks for more fuel efficient ways of delivering goods and you think this is to help reduce pllution? Don't be so blind, it is to [b]REDUCE THEIR OWN COSTS OF SHIPPING THEIR PRODUCTS INTO FOREIGN COUNTRIES.[/b] The development of hybrind vehicles also createsmore greenhouse gases than most trucks would emit in two year anyway.

And ot bring a little more light to you, DIESEL FUEL BURNS INTO SAFE HYDROCARBONS! It is the GASOLINE engines, not found in WalMarts trucks, that are emitting high Carbon Monoxide levels (CO not CO2). That's why there are no clean air laws passed on diesel trucks th eemissions dissipate into harmless gases at very low altitude, unlike CO.

WalMart now ships products clear across the ocean from China and teh Phillipines into America and Canada, from there goods are shipped across America and Canada. The company they forced out of business was local, bought locally produced products when available. WalMart is just making you believe they are helping, when all they have done regardless of shipping methods is increase shipping pollution. That's why Canadoans try to choose locally grown, manufactured and sold products, it suports the countries economy, not WalMart's greed.

As for the petty name calling, you can stop that now. It doesn't comply with the guidelines for posting on Tech Republic and will be removed if found undesirable.

by oz_media

As you have such an obviously poor command of it. SO I will offer some room for your inability to speak without logic.

Your last post was aboslutely senseless, I couldn't figure out what you were trying to say if I had a literary historian research it for years.

And again, if you can't make your point and stick to FACTS and provide proof to support the BS you assume, you should try to do it without simply ending with name calling. It just makes you look so weak,immature and incapable. And is also grounds to be booted as a Troll on TR.

by tonythetiger

When they moved to our town, it was at a time of high unemployment, and the stores that were here had high prices. They filled both needs. There were several other shops in the same mall that were on the verge of bankruptcy before Walmart moved in. Things are picking up now. People who were on the verge of desperation, spending every dime on necessities that were increasing in price can now save a little money at Walmart, then go to Kohl's or Bath and Body works to spoil themselves just a little. They feel better about themselves, have a little more dignity and self-esteem, and these things are the keys to bigger and better things.

That scares some people... people who have their laurels and are content to rest upon them... they don't want others to "catch up". They think that would make them "less special". Little do they know, they already are!

by oz_media

YOu seem to feel that the company that throws the most money at something is the one trying to fix it. That's exactly what WalMart would LIKE You to think, I'm sure.

Once again, for the visually imparied, diesel emissions are relativeley harmless. They are not the same as gasoline emissions in any way at all, save relatively harmless hydrocarbon emissions (that black smoke from big trucks everyone thinks is so dangerous).

The PROPER solutionwould be toSTOP importing fromoverseas, STOP driving your product thpusands of miles simpy to gain another market share. START putting your money back into your own countries economy and supporting Aemrcian business instead of forcing them to comply with overworked and underpaid Malaysians and ultimately forcing them out of business. HOw does THAT practice support America? Ship farther distances, ecploit workers in third world countries and force local business out of the market.

I am sure that you will reply without any answers to these issues, as you seem to be blind to the reality of it. But you will pepper your post with insulte in a pathetic effort to have something to say, relevant or not.

[i]You show me another company that has made as much progress in cutting back on carbon emmissions.[/i] Canadian Tire, Safeway, The Hudsons Bay Company.....oh you are talking monetary only as that's what you feel the solution is! Sorry, don't know how to be that illogical myself.

You say you are not AntiWalmart and then post about how they are the only ones workign toward a pollution solution,ignoring the fact they are anything BUT looking for a solution to pollution.

AntiAmerican? Because I oppose American business pushing low quality products into another country and forcing local retailers to comply or shut down?

Give you rhead a good shake and get a clue, your just lost at this point and not making any sense at all.

The rest of your post is just offensive and has been repoted to the PTB as SPAM, as you display your inability to do anything but be a TROLL.

By the way, numB has a B in it.

by oz_media

You bugger! You posted and ran, that's trolling! Did you see the riff-raff you dug up? Anyway, had an exit post from him now so unless, as most likely, he returns with a new alias to go again, it's over anyway.

by jardinier

Hey Oz. Check the date of my initial post: November 17.

Check the date of my next post: November 22.

No I didn't post and run. I posted and when there was not a single response for five days, I assumed no-one intended to post.

[Edited for typo]

by deepsand

The greater portion lies on the demand side.

Alternative energy sources alone cannot begin to solve the problem, but only ameliorate its consequences so as to postpone the inevitable.

by deepsand

You stated that the goal of environmentalists is to "destroy industrialization."

Your claim; therefore, your burden to prove.

Absent proof, no belief.

by deepsand

Have you no knowledge of the number of its own suppliers it has forced out of business in this country? Or that now, having run out of domestic victims, it has turned its sights abroad, particularly Chinese suppliers?

Have you no knowledge of its widespread & well documented instances of violations of labor laws? Most recently, a friend of mine left WalMart, owing to the fact that warehouse workers were forbidden to use the ventilation system during the summer months, so as to reduce operating costs.

Are you in fact satisfied with the limited selection & inferior quality of many of the goods offered by WalMart?

There is one thing that WalMart does well - sh!t on anyone who refuses to be subservient to them.

by tony hopkinson

say the same for the UK.

How a bout the chinese view of the boxer rebelion.

Indian, or african view of colonialism.

Even american view of british colonialism.

History is written by the victors, when you read it (as opposed to make it), you have to remember that.

by tony hopkinson

Clearly stated in the gospel of Luke.

Oh well no point in arguing with people like that, punch them in the face or leave them alone are the only two options.

by jardinier

For my North American friends who probaly couldn't give a sh!t what is happening in their antipodean ally, we have just had the most important federal election in my lifetime. The ultra right-wing, compulsive and unrepentant liar John Howard not only lost the election, but made history by becoming only the second incumbent PM to lose his own seat at an election since Federation in 1901.

The relevance to this discussion is that climate change was one of about four major election issues. Howard, who had scorned it for 11 years, suddenly decided it was important about two weeks before the election.

America can look forward to a more independent ally under Labor. Labor would never have sent troops to Iraq.

However both parties still support Australian involvement in Afghanistan, where we have lost two soldiers in a short period of time.

by Former member

At on time scientists knew that frogs and toad caused warts.

So much science today is based on fallible methods that we don know what to think.

When will there be a return to empiricism?

by tony hopkinson

Frogs and toads.

They were warty, they were about ....

Easy mistake to make. :D

Until the advent of chaos theory, 'everybody' believed weather could be explained through reductionism. Model a cyclone, by modelling air and water molecules.

What's fallible about science nowadays is scientists, they keep coming up with theories that suit their paymasters.

It's not a lack of empiricism that's the problem, but a complete and total lack of objectivity.

Ably demonstrated by both sides of the debate spending more time 'proving' the opposition is wrong than showing that they are right.

It's not science, it's politics.

Why else would the debate have polarised around left or right wing dogma.

It's the sort of Yah Boo drivel they like to distract us with, while they are all snuffling in the public trough.

The only two positions allowed are treehugger or moneyhugger. Anyone vaguely pragmatic, just gets labelled as an extremist by both sides.

I'm a right wing capitalist eco freak treehugging commie as far as I can make out.

Strange but it's a more sensible position than that of the outright loons, who decry me as such.

by dr dij

I won't say stupid but you ARE ignorant of most of the evidence. Maybe you get your
'news' and 'science' from pundits who babble with 'facts' they pull from their nether regions?

I find that people who think they are 'smart' in one area (e.g. you probably in computer related topics since posting here) tend to think they know alot of other things when really they don't have a clue and have very little broad knowledge outside their specialty.

I suppose we have to be towing our homes up the Rockies before some people will believe the facts.

Fact is CO2 has risen to 30% more than 200 years ago at the start of the industrial age.
Fact: the last time CO2 levels were naturally this high, the oceans were 300' higher with the continents flooded.
Fact: we are now emitting additional 5-8% of the total amount in the atmosphere every year which is why natural mechanisms such as atmosphereic CO2 dissolving in ocean and turning into limestone on the seafloor are not working to remove it all.

Fact: .8o warming at the equator causes 4-5o at the poles because heat flows more to areas with greater temp difference. This is why poles and greenland are melting.

fact: if warming causes the oceanic heat conveyors to stop (the gulf stream bears east instead of north) due to dilution of the salt water by meltwater at the poles, the UK and EU will be in mini-ice age despite the rest of the planet being warmer. the UK is on the same latitude as Newfoundland Canada, not exactly tropical hot spot, yet palm trees currently grow in the southernmost areas of England.

Fact the ice caps, and glaciers are melting.

Fact: 21 of 33 major cities worldwide are in danger from rising water. Fact: climate change will / is causing unrest and local conflicts, which will get worse when people are 1) flooded out and 2) can't get water to drink or for crops because they depend on glacier meltwater that is not there.

Fact: the warming effects of CO2 are not the only problem, pollution from the carbonic acid it forms when it dissolves in the ocean 'melts down' phytoplankton, by dissolving their calcium and silica skeletons. These produce 70% of our oxygen. Good luck breathing tail pipe and coal plant emissions. And other pollution problems are probably just as bad as GW.

Fact: al gore does pollute excessively. That doesn't stop global warming from being real. (in fact increases it :(

Fact: those who deny global warming appear to be irrational ignoring evidence and reason, which is the traditional reason to call someone a 'wacko', so Hi there, wacko!

Fact: vast amounts of pollution WILL put us back in the dark ages! both from increased destructive weather events and 'global dimming' which is when the greenhouse gasses trap heat they also block light from reaching crops. 10-20% in china and 10% in the Andaman islands off India, caused by fast clouds of smog reaching these pristine wildernesses.

Fact: you being ignorant doesn't stop global warming from being real.

Fact: global warming does NOT pre-dispose to one solution, e.g. money grab by politicians. GW is a problem not a solution.

If you don't like the poly's proposals, rather than denying it based on your dislike of their solutions, propose your own solutions that don't involve destruction of free enterprise (or destruction of socialist economies in other countries since GW is affecting them too).

China is finally starting to do something. They are just starting a large spending spree to control emissions, clean water, etc. Don't think India is doing much tho. Their cities are getting smoggier by the day.

by jdclyde

The FACT that we are not currently in an ice age proves that the Earth has cooled and warmed more than once, quite without our help.

I see you didn't even bother to deal with any of the issues that DB brought up, why is that? How about the points that Dan brought up before that?

What has been and will continue to be in contention is how much of an effect HUMANS have on Global warming, and how much of an effect CAN humans have in controlling the ever changing world.

If we shut off all power sources in the world, global warming would not stop, now would it?

How much are WE responsible for the changes?

Where are you getting your information that China is doing ANYTHING positive about ANYTHING? They are trying to do some photo-ops because they want to host the Olympics.

As Dan pointed out, there are MANY solutions that have been attempted, but they are always blocked. Please explain why that is. I will do it for you, the GW alamists don't WANT [b]solutions[/b], they want a crisis so they can bring about the atrocity of a world-world government.

by deepsand

"[i]... the GW alamists don't WANT solutions, they want a crisis so they can bring about the atrocity of a world-world government.[/i]"

This is naught but pure speculation, of the sort that is greatly insulting to those of us who prefer to use our intellect rather than our emotions in matters of great import.

As for Dan's supposedly pointing out anything, he was not making a logically cogent argument, but ranting, just like you are here.

by tonythetiger

[i]Fact: the last time CO2 levels were naturally this high, the oceans were 300' higher with the continents flooded. [/i]

Who's fault was it "the last time"?

[i]Fact: 21 of 33 major cities worldwide are in danger from rising water.[/i]

They should have thought of that when they built them (per your first "fact" quoted above). And now they want everybody to pay for their lack of judgment.

[i]Fact: climate change will / is causing unrest and local conflicts, which will get worse when people are 1) flooded out and 2) can't get water to drink or for crops because they depend on glacier meltwater that is not there.[/i]

Sucks to be them... Most of the "environmentalist whackos" are also firm believers in Darwin... so "survival of the fittest" will be the order of the day. Of course, I can see why one would be upset when they come up on the short end of Darwin's stick!

[i]Fact: those who deny global warming appear to be irrational[/i]

I personally don't know a single person who denies global warming is happening. I know several, however, who question whether humans are a major cause of it.

[i]Fact: global warming does NOT pre-dispose to one solution, e.g. money grab by politicians. GW is a problem not a solution. [/i]

I'm not convinced that it's even a problem!

[i]China is finally starting to do something. They are just starting a large spending spree to control emissions, clean water, etc.[/i]

I'm not as confident in any "news" coming from China as you seem to be.

by deepsand

This is the root cause of wrong thinking about the problem.

And, as we've discussed many times before, I fail to understand why you continue to view past as prologue.

by jdclyde

it has never been shown just how much of an effect humans have on changing the temp on a global scale. It has also never been shown how much of a difference we can make to STOP the global changes that are naturally accruing.

Your welcome to show some of this information for a change instead of following the same high road of only pissing on anyone elses posts to smash them down.

If we have gone through ice ages before, that are completely natural and the SUN is hotter now than it has been in ages, you are more than welcome so show what percentage of THIS temperature increase is caused by humans, and after you show that, what CAN we do about it?

by jdclyde

Not when there are efforts to put the UN in charge of GW and the pretend efforts to do something about it.

There are also many efforts to hand over control to the UN in ridiculous efforts to recognize "world court laws" over our own Constitution. Any treaty that steps on the Constitution is by definition, unConstitutional and should not be supported.

As for ranting, call it as you will, but I notice you didn't break each part down to disprove any of it, but rather turned your nose up at the thought that someone could disagree with "most scientist". Yeah, "most scientists" have never been wrong, huh?

Follow the money and you see where the GW bs is coming from.

Someone speculating on something insults you? How dare someone question your line of thinking? Get over yourself.

by tonythetiger

/i]This is the root cause of wrong thinking about the problem.[/i]

... "wrong thinking" exactly? Would that be the opposite of "right thinking"? Or would that be "left thinking"?

[i]And, as we've discussed many times before, I fail to understand[/i]

Yes, you do!

by tonythetiger

[i]This is naught but pure speculation, of the sort that is greatly insulting to those of us who prefer to use our intellect rather than our emotions in matters of great import.[/i]

Those who "prefer to use their intellect" are spending too much time in their reports and tests aren't getting outside and seeing that most people don't give two $hits about what they think are "matters of great import".

Some of the politicians, however, are sure trying to make it an emotional issue. How do those "who prefer to use our intellect rather than our emotions in matters of great import" manage to align with them?

[edit: fix italics]

by jdclyde

is shown because it is the job of the "majority of scientists" to PROVE that:

1) How much man is responsible for GW.

2) What impact CAN man have on GW.

No, it is much easier to pretend to be above it all because they are so grand and full of themselves.

Anyone with a clue would know where science is involved, the book is NEVER closed on a subject and debate should not stop just because of political BS.

The burden of proof lies with the [b]deep[/b]chicken[b]sand[/b]littles.

by deepsand

Mention of the U.S. Constitution is irrelevant to both the physical facts and the geo-political nature of the problem at hand.

And, your lack of a sufficient understanding of the underlying physical processes involved does not serve as rebuttal.

You can, of course, hope that the problem will simply go away; but, to bet on such happening would be foolish.

by deepsand

And, the will to solve any problem has its foundation in a desire, i.e. and emotional impulse, to do so.

by deepsand

Past causes are merely possibilities, and are granted no special standing with regards to those causes which are presently most probable.

The underlying science has been well presented here at TR alone on numerous occasions, such that there should not now be any need for its being re-presented.

by deepsand

to explain current phenomena.

And, yes, we have previously addressed this very issue.

by jardinier

I am quite sure that if all the posts to the various global warming discussions were added up, they would considerably outnumber those of the EL thread.

Why is it that so many people cannot accept that humans MAY contribute to global warming, and proceed with appropriate measures to reduce human-generated greenhouse gases.

Australia's very new Prime Minister Kevin Rudd has ratified the Kyoto protocal. And good on him.

I really don't care if this is just a symbolic gesture. Global warming was one of about five primary election issues in Australia. There was a swing of 5 per cent against the Howard conservative government, resulting in a landslide victory for Labor.

We take global warming seriously.

May the children, grandchildren, greatgrandchildren and many further generations of the global warming ostriches/skeptics/cynics suffer direly for the ego-based pig-headedness of their parents of today.

by tonythetiger

accept that humans MAY contribute. The problem is that the fanatics don't want to operate under the assumption that humans MAY contribute. They demand that the whole friggen world operate under the assumption that THEIR VIEW is THE ONLY POSSIBLE CORRECT VIEW to have that their solution is the ONLY POSSIBLE CORRECT COURSE OF ACTION!

Until you get rid of your "I know how the world should be run, and the world will comply!" attitude, you are going to have to contend with heavy resistance at best, and starting a world war at worst.

by jdclyde

First, the poster children that push this global agenda are bigger offenders than the mindless masses they are preaching to.

Second, there are not any valid SOLUTIONS being put on the table. We hear a lot of lip service about "renewable resources" but when the resources are tapped, the eco groups stop them.

If you want to setup a hydroelectric plant, you have to do a 5 year environmental impact study before you can even THINK about APPLYING for the building permits.

Burning FOOD in our cars and homes is just stupid. It is still burning, and takes away from the food supply. Also there is not enough corn/sugar grown to make a dent in imported oil.

The eco groups prevent us from drilling our own oil resources, FORCING us to be dependent on imported oil.

An electric car that can drive 40 miles? That is worthless to me. Oh wait, don't we STILL have to generate electricity to continually recharge these cars?

Here in Michigan, there was just a request put in to build FIVE new coal burning plants, and as you can guess, it is being opposed. They know better to go nuke because the general masses are stupid enough to think it isn't safe/clean. Liberals love the French, so why don't they ask THEM how it works out?

Until someone/anyone can show how much man contributes, this is a fraud that is just political.

Until someone/anyone can show what the ROI on following a "green" plan is, it is nothing but a mindless "feel good" show.

Offer facts, offer solutions, or go away.

by deepsand

Your refusal to acknowledge such will not alter the laws of physics; nor will it serve to ameliorate the problem.

by tonythetiger

and I still disagree. It would be gross negligence to ignore past causes.

Q. What caused the sun to come up this morning?

A. The same thing that caused it to come up yesterday morning!

by jdclyde

for it to be real.

So the factors that caused the natural warming and cooling of the planet in the past are no longer factors? Yeah, you do your agenda a great service with that kind of logic.

Still has never been shown what percent of the current warming trend is natural vs man-made, not has it EVER been shown how much of an effect on the current warming trend ANY conservation efforts can do.

When did emotion replace facts in the science community?

by tonythetiger

[i]Burning FOOD in our cars and homes is just stupid. It is still burning, and takes away from the food supply.[/i]

... and these are the people who think they know how I should be living my life ... scary.

by jdclyde

because they can use the hybrid corn for this that they could not use for consumption.

The local sugar companies are also looking to get in on the act.

Follow the money. GE is a big backer of "alternative" energy sources, and also make wind turbines...
[i]
"things that make you go hmmmmmmm"

by deepsand

by which time we will have passed the point of no return, with no hope then of saving ourselves, knowing only that civilization as we know it has but a short time to live, that it will inexorably perish in its cradle, amidst its own excrement.

by jdclyde

It is still sad that science is about politics and emotion instead of facts, when it comes to GW.

by deepsand

pay attention to the evidence and give it its due?

I suggest that you get up to speed on the physical sciences, most notably physics, with a concentration on thermodynamics, along with a smattering of chemistry, all of which have been amply here provided in prior discussions.

Being one so trained, I find your insisting that there is no factual basis for the finding that man does indeed significantly contribute to global warming naught but the whining of a know-nothing, of one who is afraid that he might be called upon to accept responsibility for the consequences of his actions at a cost that he would greatly prefer to avoid.

The facts are at hand; get them.

by deepsand

A better analogy would be the cooking of foods.

Suppose that you had only seen food cooked using a word or coal stove. Would this perforce mean that all cooked foods are most likely to have been heated in such a manner, even when in fact some were cooked via an electric or gas range, or a microwave oven, or over an open fire?

by deepsand

a corresponding reduction in the amount of CO2 released into the troposphere, thereby reducing the rate of increase in radiative forcing.

by jdclyde

and not man made, how much of an impact CAN be made? Your following of junk science and fairy tales is surprising.

by deepsand

Carp all you like about the deficiencies of others; such will serve to neither disway the laws of physics from inexorably having their way nor to avoid the inevitable results of maintaining the present course.

by jdclyde

it doesn't validate your case though, but I hope it makes you feel better.

Global Warming is a fact, yes, and accepted.

The part that man is the cause is BS and junk science, or even a SIGNIFICANT cause. Never been shown or proved, and won't be either.

by deepsand

as one trained in the physical sciences, I both understand the physical processes involved, and have studied the data, such that your protestations to the contrary are naught but empty denials.

You can't learn what you don't want to know.

by deepsand

If you can present [b]current [u]scientific facts[/u][/b] to support your position, then present them.

As it stands, the facts do not support your cause; deal with it.