Discussion Locked

The Case of the Missing File Attachments

0 helpful
60 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

The story described herein is true. The names were changed to protect the innocent.

Case Number 1:
Oscar sent an email (no attachment) to Sally. Sally received that email.

Oscar sent another email - with a 100k-file attachment - to Sally. Oscar received no errors related to that delivery. Sally received ONLY the email, not the attachment. Her ISP had no error related to that email.

Case Number 2:
Felix sent an email (no attachment) to Sally. Sally received that email.

Felix sentanother email - with a 100k-file attachment - to Sally. Felix received an error stating that the attachment exceeded the allowable size. His mail server has no file attachment limit (so he says). Sally received neither the email nor the attachment. Her mail server (hosted by her ISP) has an attachment limit of 3mb. Her ISP had no error related to that email.

Testimony:
Felix and Oscar are not in the same location, nor do they use the same email system or ISP.

Oscar is able to send email attachments (so he says) to everyone else without problems.

Felix is able to send email attachments (so he says) to everyone else without problems.

Sally is able to receive email attachments (so she says) from everyone else without problems (atleast that she is aware of).

Summation:
This is the classic case of all involved blaming the other. And there are really four parties involved, Oscar or Felix, their respective ISPs, Sally, and her ISP.

Deliberation:
Sally is the one being held ultimately responsible to solve these problems. Should she be? Is she the best one suited to solve the problem? Who is the best one suited to solve it?
What happened to the file attachment Oscar sent? Felix had his email rejected. Why? And who rejected it?

This certainly is an odd couple of problems.

Does anyone care to testify to any or all of these questions?

Maxwell

60 replies

by maxwell edison

.
.
By the way, has anyone noticed (or is it just happening to me) that an error is returned, and the question is rejected, if there are any apostrophes in the text of a question? I must say that it was rather challenging to re-write this questioneliminating all the apostrophes that I had.

Maxwell

by penguinsrule

Let's start breaking this down into small manageable pieces:

1) What is the computer hardware configuration/ operating system and version for
Oscar, Felix, Sally, Oscar's ISP, Felix's ISP
Sally's ISP.
2) What mail product and version are each of the above 6 separate computers using.
3) On all 6 systems have any data corruption problems been ruled out? Anything wrong with the file system of any system will produce all kinds of mail oddities.
4) can you send smaller attachments like in case #1 - at what size does it break?
5) Can you enable any further headers/error tracing.
6) Silly question - does anyone have forwarding turned on?
7) I would look at Sally's client machine and her ISP first for any irregularities.

Since you didn't indicate any mail products I can only guess:

Outlook, Exchange, Notes, CC:Mail, Sendmail, VMS MAil, Gold Mail, Eudora, Pine, Microsoft Mail, All in One, and on and on and on - I have no idea what any of the machines is using and how they are configured.

interesting problem - thanks for sharing.. I hope I can help. First thing to do is to break it down into small pieces.
Rick

by timthetoolman

Hi Maxwell,

Felix's one is the easiest. I've always seen the rejector of the message named in the error message returned. It should be a simple case of looking at Felix's rejection message to determine who rejected it and often the "why" is mentioned too!

It IS possible that it was rejected for some other reason than its largish attachment...

Oscar's one is a little more mysterious, though. First off, I would question whether the attachment was successfully made in the first place. Itspossible that it wasn't...

It may be possible to look at Oscar's "sent messages" (if he keeps them) to verify that the message was properly formed.

The other possibility is that he ISP didn't check the success in the message logs at all. He may have sat back in his chair sipping his coffee and said, yep no problems at our end... Maybe I'm too cynical...

Obviously testing by re-sending would be the way to go for both cases.

Who is responsible? Well, not Sally. She cant be expected toknow whether a message contained all the expected attachments - unless the body of the message says "as per the attachment" or something like that.

The best "person" to fix the problem is not a single person but a collaborative effort between thepeople involved. As techies, we can look at logs but we really need to find out what does and doesn't work first before leaping into solution mode.

Hope this helps,
Cheers,
Tim.

by timthetoolman

Ok,

Since Sally is the victim in all this, I suggest she be allowed to step down for the time being.

First of all, make sure that Oscar, Felix, Tom and Jerry all can *reliably* send messages with attachments to YOU!

Once you've established that, then you can send Sally a message or three with various sized attachments and see if they get through.

If not, then whoopee! - you can ignore several of the troublemakers. If they do, then just deal with the one troublemaker. Oscar would be the obvious one as he is consistantly failing but worked before.

So... If Oscar can reliably send you mail but not to Sally, then the problem is with Sally and you only "need" Oscar for his format of message - the format that Sally doesn't like.
Then get Oscar to send a barrage of mail messages at Sally. Big ones, small ones, image attachments, word attachments - anything you can think of.

If none get through, then its not likely to be a filter based on file type/size - rather by person.

I think I'll elave it at that for the moment and see what come up next in this exciting series... :-)

Cheers,
Tim.

by shanghai sam

Case in point would be that Sally's machine is not configured properly to receive e-mails over a certain limit or that the mail server configuration on her machine is not properly configured to receive emails of a certain size

What type file attachments are being sent to sally,which in point if they are sent in HTML and see is configured to for Rich Text,she then will not be able to receive the attachment

Also her e-mail server configurations is set to limit the size of the attachment that is received,either is her e-mail server configuration or by her ISP,which is stated in case 2.

Sally needs the help desk assistance in troubleshooting the email configuration on her computer or placing a call to her ISP and inquiring about email size limitations.

So,no blame needs to be placed it is apperent that Sally's machine is the culprit.

by maxwell edison

.
.
More testimony:

Oscar hosts his own mail server - Exchange (version unknown).

Felix hosts his own mail server - Exchange 5.5.

Sally does not host her own mail server. Her ISP hosts her mail server for her.

Oscar uses the ACME company as his ISP.

Felix uses ACE company as his ISP.

Sally uses AT&T as her ISP.

Sally uses Outlook Express as her mail client. Her network administrator insists everything is setup correctly.

The mail client used by Oscar and Felix is unknown.

----------

There may be more testimony to come. And we may even have to recall a witness or two.

Maxwell

by isys

Tim's on the right track. First thing, did the situation with Oscar and the missing attachment reoccur? If so, Sally could set up a scenario with the postmaster where Oscar sends a test message with attachment and the postmaster looks at the message in Sally's mailbox with a text editor (they are all text at that point). Then Sally retrieves the message to see if the attachment is there. There might also be an attachment filter set to exclude files meeting certain content issues but not notifying the sender. I've had that problem because the return message was addressed to the sender at my domain. I delete those messages automatically.

The problem with Felix might be attributed to miscommunication on ESMTP size. Same question, didit reoccur?

The best person to fix this? A collaboration between all three postmasters. The average user doesn't have a clue what can go wrong with a message after they hit the send button.

by penguinsrule

I'll still bet that the problem is Sally's machine. Are you in a position where you can run test messages between the different machines.

like do you have addresses for Felix, Oscar, and Sally and their ISP's and can you contact all of them?
Map it out on a big chart. What works, what doesn't work?

by maxwell edison

.
.
Upon further cross-examination, the following testimony is also being considered:

This problem that Sally is experiencing occurs on every machine in her office. It is not isolated to her computer only.

Furthermore, it was revealed thatOscar, at one time, had indeed sent Sally an email with an attachment, and that Sally was able to retrieve it normally. In fact he successfully sent her an email with an attachment the very day before this problem came up. Since then, no email attachments would go through. Of course, Oscar and Sally, as well as their respective network administrators, all claim that no settings were changed in either email client program.

Also, two additional witnesses were brought forward, Tom and Jerry, who both work in the same office. Tom can send Sally an email with an attachment, and Sally receives it fine. However, when Jerry sends her an email, she receives only the body of the email without the attachment. A strange set of circumstances indeed.Of course the network administrator for Tom and Jerry claim everything is working properly at his end, and therefore this is obviously a problem for Sally (or her network administrator) to solve.

----------

By the way, even though I’m trying to have a little fun with this question, it is real, the circumstances described are accurate, and I am looking for a real solution. My involvement is that of a troubleshooter. Since everyone is pointing fingers at anyone and everyone else, I stepped in to communicate with all parties involved to attempt to find the cause – or causes, which may indeed be the case. I suspect that I will end up having to suggest possible resolutions to one or more reluctant mail administrators, who havebeen steadfastly certain that this is not a problem generated by their system

Maxwell_t_Edison@yahoo.com

by purple713

This looks like a classic case of confusion.

Assumption 1: If on a server, the server side could be setup to remove attachments with certain file extensions when sending out or receiving a email. That would be the first thing to check for.

Assumption 2: Depending on the email program that is used, there is a setting on the program (assuming Outlook is being used) where you can setup the option of what file size send or receive the email.

The ISP or the Network Admin should be able to look at this a little further.

Hope this helps.

by dmiles

Considering that Sally's office is using an ISP mail server would be the determining factor if the ISP has implemented in changes to the mail accounts or changed mail servers has reached a capcity on the ISP servers that requires that all email stored as one account is 3mb.

If this is a work group setup then it could be that the storage capacity for each individual profile has grown to exceed the limits set by the administrator and some of these files need to be deleted from their personal folders.

Sally's administrator is the best one to solve the problem by checking with the ISP concerning the configuration setttings that may filter emails sent thru as an attachment,which could be the factor of the office as a whole.

by jackal314

hi this sounds like a good problem. felixs problem sounds the easiest. in the eamil if it has a an attachment it should say who rejected it,and why it was rejected.one other reason could be that someone could be playing around with your emails electronically[hacking into them]and doing what they want with them. this happened to me at one stage.also your ddifferent isps could have something to do with the prob by not accepting the different files. well this might not help at all but i hope it will. sorry if it doesnt.

by xanderoth

No no no- everyone is wrong. The answer is so simple. It is right in front of your eyes. It is so obvious that it amazes me and should shame all of you that you haven't seen it. The answer?

Sally is having an affair with Felix. Oscar has been hired secretly by the suspicious husband who knows of this situation as has been monitoring the e-mail with some type of software. The 100k mail attachment in question is rather "racy" photos that Oscar needs to build the case against the two unfaithful lovers, but the system administrator has been hired by Felix to deter the efforts of Oscar to unveil the scandalous affair and ruin his chances at Sally.

Honestly people, I thought you were all more observant.

by Member 35711908

If Sally is using a recent version of Outlook Express, and the various senders are sending attachments of different types, OLEXP may simply be blocking some of them? See Q291387. Checking the file size may also indicate whether there is an attachment present which isn't being displayed

by joseph moore

I would go to Tom and Jerry, and have them both send Sally 2 e-mail. The first should have the same 10K attachment, and the second should have the same 100K attachment.
The attachments need to be the exact same files to analyze properly. If Tom sends one file and Jerry sends another, perhaps both files are not around 100k; maybe Jerry's file was 80K.
What I am saying is, make everything as exactly the same as possible, to eliminate one path towards failure.
Personally, I tend to blame Sally's mailbox. So, try the Tom & Jerry tests, see if they get the same results (what I believe will happen) or if you see the same results previously reported.

by sataychicken

I think KathrynB might be on the right track.
Try sending Sally several emails with attachments using Plain Text, Rich Text and HTML emails. Then check her inbox to see which emails are received correctly.
If any are received without attachments, then check the email for a MicroSoft error message, or aload of MIME encoded garbage at the end of the email. Also note the size of the emails (as this may include the size of the missing attachment).
I believe there is another MicroSoft article on Outlook Express and the way it handles different email formats, but I cannot at this moment find it. If I do then I will let you know.

JA

by jereg

Ok, I'll throw my 2cents in. Is there any kind of virus filtering going on with Sally's mailbox? The attachments could be rejected because of the file name used. It's happened before.
Next, I guess my troubleshooting would be to get a copy of the file. Use a generic internet mail account( hotmail?) and send the attachment to Sally and yourself. If you get it and Sally doesn't, there is a problem with Sally's Outlook, or her ISP. If you both get it, then the problem may be with Oscar or Felix. Has Sally tried another mail client? Eudora or something?
Hope that helps.

by penguinsrule

Certainly you can't take anyone's word for anything -

it's going to be a matter of trial and error.

1) can you obtain a copy of the same attachment?
2) can you send that attachment to anyone? to Sally, to Oscar, To Felix, To Jerry, etc.3) can they send the same to you?
4) Is the ISP stripping off the attachment? THey can do that you know.
5) How many alternative clients have you tried - do any of them work? Have you tried alternate servers to send to? Do they work.

Youhave to get yourself a great big drawing pad and map out what everybody is using, and each and every senario. I worked for the mail team at Digital for 3 years, and by the time I got the problem it was one huge convoluted mess.

You can't take anything at face value, or anyone's word.

I highly suggest the book - The New Rational Manager by Kepner and Tregoe which is THE book on problem solving and troubleshooting. It's excellent.

hope this helps.

by shmaltz

The last time I traveled, I went to JFK and upon arriving the Terminal was locked. Why? it has been evacuated because someone had a bomb. When I asked who and why? I was told the following:
When the guy with the bomb put his stuff for inspection they noticed the bomb. They asked him what it was he said it was for security reasons. When asked to explain he said: It never happened that 2 bombs should be on a plane. So I decided to take a bomb with me whenever I travel.
Sounds funny but the story isn't true. What is true is the fact that it actualy never happened that 2 bombs ended up on one plane.
Which brings us to the conclusion: Sally's email system is the one not set up correctly, Or there are restrictions somewhere. Since they are dealing with an ISP (AT&T) which is too large to deal with such a small customer (that all they have is a pop account, and maybe some dial up and Long Distance). I guess the problem is with them.
The following are problems that might occur when you have Size restriction on either your mailbox or attachments.
If you don't download all the email (by all I mean for every POP account you have with that ISP for your company) and REMOVE it from the server. Then the next attachment might not arrive since you are already over your limit.
Stay with the assumption that the problem is with the ISP. Since you have multiple people trying to send to one troubled email account it makes sense that the problem is with the receiving account. Also since everyone in that office has this problem. The problem is there in Sally's office and not anywhere else.

by penguinsrule

I think I isolated it to Sally's office right away.. It's obvious to me - I'd go right to her ISP and then not take any guff of these people until you get the answers you need.

Ya gotta ask all the right questions.. The burden of proof is on you..

by information_superhighway_patrol

I think that the problem is with the SENDERS' email settings, not Sally's.

The common factor could be Microsoft Exchange Server and/or Outlook Mail Client.

Many Exchangeand Outlook users have discovered that if a local user sends mail with an attachment, the message appears without the attachment using OE. Then, when you connect using Outlook 97, the same message is in the mailbox with the attachment. The reason this occurs is that Exchange has "Send messages using rich-text format" enabled in the address book. This, in turn, causes the server to use MS-TNEF encoding for the attachment, which Outlook Express then refuses to decode. Either uncheck the RTF box, or get their Exchange administrator to mark the global address list entry as non-rich text at the site, server or mailbox level for the POP3 Protocol. Thereafter, the server will use MIME and all should be well.

Even if message recipients can see the attachment, they still may struggle to be able to read it. This can occur for a couple of reasons. For starters, Exchange/Messaging and OE may have a character set incompatibility (OE uses ISO-8859-1 and Messaging employs US ASCII). As described in Missing Attachments above, OE does not particularly like rich text formatting (RTF) that is part of Wordmail. As a result, one thing that you can do is to ask senders using Messaging that they turn off RTF from inside Messaging. Also, Messaging/Exchange and OE appear to have MIME incompatibilities. To remedy this as apotential problem, you can resort to using Plain Text and UUEncoding by going to Tools | Options | Send | Mail | Plain Text | Settings. Exchange still won't like HTML formatting, but will work correctly with plain text and you should be able to decipher attachments.

There 'ya go.

ISP

by penguinsrule

Maxwell

Instead of keeping everybody guessing can you let us know the answers to all the questions we've asked you?

I think you as the troubleshooter have a lot more that you can do than we can since we can't actually test and play around with all this.

What happened when you sent Sally email? with attachments? To what size?. What happens when you went to see Oscar and as Oscar you sent one to Sally. Did you turn on all the headers - did you track the path.. I can go on for an hour with the break down of all the questions trial and error you have to do. You have to check each person, every setting and then eliminate.

Once you have answers then you can share with the group.

After all you are the one being paid to do this and points aren't really worth anything right?

by maxwell edison

Thank you all for your replies. I've been quite busy lately, and haven't had a chance to look into all the suggestions. Some of the problems have been solved, while with others the jury is still deliberating. I plan to complete my investigation bynext week, and report the verdict in a final comment.

I must say, however, that some of the witnesses in this case (other mail administrators, for example) are being considered "hostile witnesses", since they don't want to implicate themselves ortheir systems as contributing to the problem. The term “taking the 5th” is being put into a whole new light! That certainly does make it quite challenging. I’m in a position where I have to query not only into the type of system the “other guy” has, but also into how their mail servers and the clients are configured.

Thanks again for all the replies. I will respond to each and every one of them (when time allows). In addition, most all answers are both insightful and helpful, and will be accepted accordingly.

Maxwell

by packratt

Perhaps the butler did it...

Actually, that would be a third party mail filtering service, like MAILWATCH.COM perhaps?

Check for mail forwarding on the back end and also check to see if anyone has a mail proxy service enabled and where either of those may be pointing.

by johnfriz

Taking into account all the information we have, and assuming that the information we have been given is accurate and correct (a dangerous assumption I know), we can come up with the following....

Fact: Felix and Oscar can send attachments to everyone bar Sally
Fact: Felix and Oscar host their own mail servers
Fact: Sally used to be able to receive attachments
Fact: The problem is not confined to just sally any more - it is now happening on all machines in the office
Fact: Sallys office does not host its own mail server. This is hosted by AT&T
Fact: Tom has successfully sent Sally an email with an attachment since the problem started?
Fact: At first the only common link was Sally. But since the problem has spread to her entire office, the only common like is AT&T.... All attachments that have not been received has passed through AT&Ts Mail Server

Supposition: All machines in the office are on the one mail server
Supposition: Sallys network administrator can only check her mail client configuration

Question: What type was the attachment?
Question: Has anyone else tried to send this type of attachment and not succeeded?

Conclusion: The problem MUST lie with AT&T. Because an attachment has got through sincethis all began, it can not be that the mail server is blocking all attachments... thus it is either blocking attachments based on size, or type.

Suggested course of action: If possible take a first hand look at AT&T?s mail server configuration. If not, find out what mail server they have, get a copy of it and use it to find out where filtering can be set. Then when you ring them, you can direct them to the exact screen(s) where filters can be set. This way you can at least make sure that they are actually checking the settings and not just fobbing you off.

Failing all that...resort to riders on horseback delivering messages!!!!!!!

by johnfriz

The 2 questions relate to the attachment that Tom successfully sent since the problem started.

by juanita marquez

There are a few other factors you may consider. It would be helpful if you could tell us the OSes, file types and applications everyone was using as well.

You might ask if the senders are using the Send To function from a MS application program. Using that to create emails with attachments is buggy. We have found that many times attachments will go through ok, but then spontaneously it will NOT send an attachment. We have yet to figure out precisely what conditions cause an attachment tofail, as it happens unpredictably. We have had problems with this particularly when GroupWise users in a sister office try to send Excel files to Outlook users here, but even within the Outlook environment, we have had original source files go corrupt and a number of other issues. Therefore, we have told the users to avoid using this option when sending attachments.

We also encountered problems with a vendor who used Eudora vs. our Outlook - again, Excel files, they couldn't receive themfrom us. We tried many different email tests with her and finally got a configuration to work.

You might have the senders try zipping their files and seeing if that makes a difference in receiving. The Level 1 security on XP/Outlook 2K Service Pack 2 doesn't seem to mess with zipped files, and perhaps the users aren't properly estimating the size of their files, and antivirus heuristics may leave them alone if they aren't scanning for compressed files.

We have also had rejections like these happen from our small-business local ISP when they were doing server tweakage; with someone like AT&T that likelihood seems small...but you never know. Asking them if they are making changes may be an option to consider.

Good luck.

by maxwell edison

I haven't answered all these replies or closed the this question because I haven't taken the time to put together all the replies with all the problems, and I want to answer each and every one individually and thoroughly. Some of the problems havebeen resolved, while others still require some research and testing.

I've mentioned that it's difficult (at times) to convince other I.T. people that this problem may indeed fall into their realm of responsibility, but another thing I've learnedwith this experience is that other I.T. people just don't return phone calls. (I also have to remember who Oscar, Felix, Tom and Jerry really are!)

I will compile all the answers and problems, and comment accordingly. I hope to do this within another week or so. Thankfully, in the meantime, email problems have been nonexistant lately. And I have concluded that the problem was not (is not) with Sally's machine. So stay tuned for the final chapter in "The Case of the Missing File Attachments".

And, as you all probably know, points are worthless, but a note of thanks is priceless. In that regard, thank you all for your time in helping with the email question.

Maxwell

by mike (from canada)

For the two mail messages Felix sent to sally, Logic states that sally had 3MB worth of atachments before Felix sent mail! That is why he got an error the 2nd time.

by maxwell edison

Thank you all for providing your expert testimony in the case of the missing file attachments. All deliberations are completed, and the jury has delivered the verdict. The following has been concluded and so ordered:

(See the following commentsfor the conclusion...)

by maxwell edison

Oscar could send email to Sally; however, any email with an attachment would lose said attachment. Oscar insisted during his testimony that all of his settings were correct, all of his email infrastructure was working properly, and that the problem must be with Sally’s client or her ISP. Oscar did admit, however, that he was not an expert in this area, nor was he familiar with his email settings, his company’s email server settings, or how email settings should be configured at all. Therefore, Oscar was declared a hostile witness and his testimony was overlooked as being biased and uninformed. In addition, Maxwell entered into evidence something that suggested a cause contrary to Oscar’s assertions. It was revealed thatOscar also had a personal AOL account which he could access from his office. Maxwell suggested that he send the email and attachment using his AOL account from his office computer. Oscar did comply with that request; thereupon Sally was able to successfully receive Oscar’s file attachment. Oscar, however, remained adamant that there was no problem with his mail server, his client, or any of their settings. To further show a lack of cooperation, Oscar’s network administrator, Abner, did not answer the subpoena for his testimony. Abner has not returned any of a number of phone calls, nor has he answered his email. Therefore, a warrant has been issued for him to appear before this counsel and answer the charges of “contempt of courtesy”. Moreover, because of the unworthiness of Oscar’s testimony, and because of Abner’s failure to cooperate, it was so ordered that some unknown setting within Oscar’s email system caused the problem with Oscar’s email attachments. Oscar was sentenced to spend 40 hours of Internet surfing with his old dial-up account instead of the high-speed connection to which he has become accustomed.

by maxwell edison

Felix, when sending an email with a file attachment to Sally, received an error stating that the attachment exceeded the allowable size. His mail server had no file attachment limit, and the file attachment size was well within the limit imposed by Sally’s ISP. Based on all the testimony and facts entered into evidence, Sally’s ISP was the suspected culprit. However, after a few days of unsuccessfully attempting to pinpoint the problem, it just mysteriously went away. All of the sudden, and without anyone changing anything, Sally started receiving Felix’s email attachments. It was therefore surmised that the initial problem was merely an unknown glitch (a little technical lingo) in Sally’s ISP’s mail server.They have not, however, admitted any culpability, and all blame in this particular matter has been simply dismissed. Felix and Sally continue to discuss this incident.

Tom and Jerry, you’ll recall, work in the same office; and while Tom could send his messages and attachments without incident, Jerry’s emails arrived without the file attachment. Jerry’s network administrator, Amanda, finally conceded (after a little coaxing from Maxwell) that a setting in Jerry’s mail client, Outlook 2000, was stripping his email of the attachment. (She did not elaborate on the particular setting.) Nonetheless, their problem has been successfully addressed and the case dismissed. Maxwell further suggested that he and Amanda have lunch to discuss all those hard to diagnose anomalies that pop up from time to time.

(continued..)

by maxwell edison

Sally was totally exonerated. Her Outlook Express settings were configured correctly, and her client station was not the cause of any of these problems. (And, of course, her network administrator, Maxwell, addressed the situation flawlessly.)

The council further issued a “class-action” order, and strongly suggested that all IT personnel and their respective IT departments within different companies make a better attempt to work together instead of pointing the finger of blame. They will be monitored to ensure compliance.

I’d like to profoundly thank all the jurors for their deliberation, and all the expert witnesses for their testimony in this case. It was most helpful and insightful, and, I must admit, the most fun I’ve had seeking the solution to a problem.

Maxwell_T_Edison@yahoo.com

This discussion is closed to new replies.