Time for a gas tax
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Software
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jamesrl
A flat tax is very appealing in many ways.
Charge everyone 15%, no one pays zero, no matter how many deductions. The IRS would shrink to a fraction of its size. There were be no disincentives to work more. There would be none of those wasteful tax dodge investments. We could do our taxes in minutes, without the help of accountants.
I haven't seen the math in years, but I recall when proposed decades back it actually worked out. Maybe Max has seen some.
James
by jamesrl
A flat tax is very appealing in many ways.
Charge everyone 15%, no one pays zero, no matter how many deductions. The IRS would shrink to a fraction of its size. There were be no disincentives to work more. There would be none of those wasteful tax dodge investments. We could do our taxes in minutes, without the help of accountants.
I haven't seen the math in years, but I recall when proposed decades back it actually worked out. Maybe Max has seen some.
James
by jdclyde
Ah,
gotta love how they look out for the disabled!
AND, to create class striation.
It will simply come to the point where the wealthy and elite will be able to have cars and the proletarian masses will be walking, Da Tovarisch?
by $$$$$$$$$$
Alternative energies are not being implemented so slowly because of [u]time needed for R&D[/u]. The electric motor, and therefore wind turbines which generate electricity by the opposite path, are not rocket science. Nor is solar collection. The reason deployment is stalled is the constant giveaways to petroleum, because it's a "critical national resource." BS. So long as, whenever the going gets tough the weak can get a handout, market forces which prefer "green" energy are competing at a [u]government-imposed[/u] disadvantage.
Subsidies to oil companies are un-Patriotic.
by $$$$$$$$$$
Handouts?
Y/N
by jck
when i worked at an energy company here in FL, they were "working with synfuels" to get $700M a year from the federal government.
know what happened after the 7 years of money was up?
they quit working with it.
they weren't trying to transition. they were there for the check. just like a lazy welfare recipient. just to get the money and do with it what they wanted.
by delbertpgh
If you hand money over to somebody to do something, he'll do it. And when you stop paying, he'll stop spending it that way. Unless a market opportunity presents itself, nobody in that situation has any reason to use that experience... if you can't make money off of it, then you won't try. Likewise, if any profitable opportunity carries a high risk of becoming unprofitable because of unstable prices, people won't exploit it.
If the government taxes petroleum motor fuel, it creates a profit opportunity in substitutes. If the tax is stable and does not look like it will be repealed, then people will take the risk.
One of the points of genius of American society is its ability to mobilize talent and capital around opportunities. It's why this place was the home of invention, and why so many greedy well-educated foreigners keep swarming in here to live. I believe that within a few years, Americans will be able to give the world a viable alternative liquid fuel technology... maybe big tanks of algae, digested by some bacterium that pees gasoline. They won't do it, though, if there is no confidence that the price will stay high.
closing down plants that produce trucks/SUV's?
Why not make some changes to them to make them more fuel efficient? People would by a truck if they needed one, especially if they were more fuel efficient.
Auto manufacturers can get more out of vehicles than they do. Look around at 'chips' and minor changes which increase mileage/power. Are these items offered stock? No! They are all after-market parts. And these are on the full gas powered vehicles
Why not make a medium sized hybrid truck which gets 30MPG (actual) and can still haul things? Instead they just plan to shut down factories and cause a more job losses.
by jdclyde
As Bill Clinton said when he was talking about global warming, "All we need to do is slow down the economy".
Looks like they are getting their wish.
Funny talk from someone who's claim to fame is being in office at the same time as the dot.com boom and a soaring economy (that was on it's way down BEFORE he left office).
"Why not make some changes to them to make them more fuel efficient?"
I don't want to seem too anti-American but you and your motor industry have asked for everything that you're getting. What's the opposite of "fuel efficiency"? Welcome to the 21st Century and the end of the days of cheap oil. Why moan because you're late getting on board? Too late, maybe! You had the same thing happen back in the days of the first oil crisis. Don't learn, do you? Didn't ANYONE see it coming in time?
"Auto manufacturers can get more out of vehicles than they do". Of course they can! But ask "Why not before now?". Why not ask "why can the Europeans and the Japanese do it?". Well, because we PAY for oil and we have to make the best of it and we don't allow our motor manufacturers to get lazy with design.
The average size of a US domestic vehicle engine is exactly TWICE the size of a European domestic vehicle engine. You do relatively very little more miles per person per year and I can't believe that you haul much more crap around - other than huge bits of wallowing steel chassis, that is.
Oh, and your speed limits are LOWER!
Neil :)
Oh, and thanks for the Credit Crunch. If there's going to be a world recession it will be TOTALLY the fault of the US banks and the sub-prime mortgage fiasco.
he is either too good to do any work so he would just pay someone else to do it or he gets no pride from a job well done.
Either way, he must have plenty of money laying around and think everyone else must to. Buy a new car, buy a new house, and pay others to do everything for you. And that major part of the population that makes up this country will have to starve since they can't afford to.
by tonythetiger
[i]the best thing for the country would be to tax imports more (higher Tariffs).[/i]
Protectionism is the coward's way out. How about making a less expensive/higher quality product?
by tonythetiger
[i]How much gravel can you put in the trunk of a Neon?[/i]
Unbolted the trunk lid from a '66 Fairlane and hauled a side-by-side refrigerator :)
by tonythetiger
the fairest tax would be one which charges in proportion to the amount of public services one uses. A family of eight is probably using more public services than a family of four, and should pay more, regardless of income.
Per capita tax.
by tonythetiger
[i] What is it doing is making people pay according to the size of their car.[/i]
Weight, and number of miles driven.
by jamesrl
Well maintained cars, with the right air pressure in the tires, with clean air filters use less gas.
A well tuned V6 Accord may use less gas than a 4 cylinder accord which is running with not enough air in the tires and a dirty air filter...should we penalize those who do their part to use the least they can?
James
by jdclyde
we need to beat down all of you evil car drivers.
What kind of mileage (air-age?) do planes get, and what kinds of standards are being placed upon them? The amount of pollution AND consumption is so much higher, right? Heck, I bet we can completely destroy that industry while we are trying to take our economy down. A two-for-one bonus.
by tonythetiger
a heavier car will use more fuel, and place more wear and tear on the roadways than one that weighs less. And one that is driven more miles will use more fuel and place more wear and tear on the roadways. The relationship between weight, distance, fuel and roadway wear are fairly accurately predictable.
The state of tune of a vehicle's engine, as well as (you forgot this one) the driver's driving habits, are not as predictable without a lot of expense and possibly some intrusion into personal privacy, and the question then becomes, who should bear this expense or suffer this intrusion? Everyone? Isn't that a penalty to the people who are doing it right? On the other hand, the lead-foot, or the person too lazy to properly maintain their car will be "penalized" by having to pay for more fuel. Isn't that punishment enough? Or do you want to spend more money by imprisoning them?
by jdclyde
where they went by the weight of the vehicle.
People started going with smaller cars, so they weren't leaching enough money, so now they go according to the ORIGINAL VALUE of the vehicle because they can leach so much more for all the plastic and fiberglass cars.
And no, it is trying to PUNISH acording the the size and number of miles. Always a morally questionable tactic to take.
by tonythetiger
not the registration cost (though it could be collected at the same time).
It's not a punishment, it's paying for what you use. If you buy a lighter car, it won't damage the road as much, it won't pollute as much, so you [b]should[/b] pay less.
Same with mileage. If you drive less, you're polluting less and wearing the road less, so you should pay less. Why isn't that reasonable?
by jellimonsta
by jdclyde
China and India are so energy concious that of course this HAS to be the fault of the US, right?
I still love hearing on the international level about the US as major polluters when they don't DARE say a word about either of those two countries.
by tonythetiger
My post was about the inefficiency of US car design and how lack of foresight is contributing to the loss of US jobs in the automotive industry because when people shift away from SUVs and trucks, there isn't anything US-made to turn to.
My other complaint was about the Credit Crunch caused by the sub-prime mortgage selling that screwed up the world's finance system.
China and India are getting screwed over by the oil price exactly the same as you are.
by jdclyde
them bellying up to the bar is helping to cause the shortage. The don't need the oil, really. :D
US car designers have been producing cars based upon what the best sellers are, not an effort on their part to save the planted.
We have had smaller cars with the mileage, but they didn't sell as well, or have the profit margin you get with the truck sales. A market driven decision. What is hard to understand about that?
The changes now are based on dramatic changes to the market, and it is questionable how long things will go in this direction. I don't see many in the US buying the crappy little "smart cars" because they are completely impractical for the way we live, with families and time spent on the road.
They are making a big deal about the Chevy Volt that is suppose to be out next year though. Electric car, and the only motor is a generator to keep the batteries charged. Will have to wait and see how that turns out.
by jdclyde
Don't point out the intentional hypocrisy of the people that own multiple hybrids, where the environmental impacts of MAKING the TWO vehicles with a shorter shelf life completely negates the lowered pollution from these more "efficient" vehicles, compared to your single vehicle.
Currently, I am getting between 38 and 40 mpg with my little saturn.
by jamesrl
Do a google search and you will see what happens when North America had no commercial planes flying for a few days - they noticed an immediate improvement in the atmosphere.
Jets expend a lot of fuel talking off. Newer jets are cleaner, but compared to a train.....they are awful.
James
and it will take five in comfort with no problem. Five adults, even, so long as they don't all have lardarses. Fitting three kids anything less than full-grown in the back is no problem at all! There are three seat belts in the back so I presume that the manufacturers think it OK too. It will do 120mph and 0-60 in 10 seconds. That doesn't stripe rubber on the road but it will do for me.
Tell you, bring any US car that you want onto our roads and you'll see what I mean about design.
Because you all ain't from my country, I can't really have any problem with you owning SUVs, trucks or anything until the moment the owners whining about the cost of gas. Once you start doing that, then I feel the overwhelming need to comment.
You shoot yourselves in the foot. The Ford Focus on sale in the US is an appalling piece of car design. I hired one and took it back the following day. Gutless, poor roadholding and looked crap.
The European model is light-years ahead of the US model, on styling, interior design and, above all, chassis and engine design.
Why doesn't Ford US sell the European-designed Focus as a compact car in the US market to take the fight to the imports? I think that Ford are mad not to sell the European spec model in the US!
The design is done (that there are separate design departments is obvious!) - you could build them in the US - so I'm not advocating jobs moving out! Sell some diesel ones. They get 65mpg and still do 115mph!
Neil :)
p.s. One of the many things that used to ANNOY me about US cars was how small the trunk was!
by tonythetiger
by jck
Dad,
i heard all sorts of stories about diesels that get 50mpg in the UK.
same models here get about 28-34.
probably all the emissions equipment we have to put on em here.
i don't care tho. send me your car. i'll pollute to get 2.5 times the gas mileage!
Son :)
by delbertpgh
We got into our last two wars against Iraq for oil. The dollar is losing value because we spend $400 billion per year importing oil. We send billions to regimes that support terrorism so we can get their oil. Our back is against the wall in so many ways because we can't stop slurping up the crude.
What's to be done? Cut down on oil use. How to do that? Ration gas? Ban trucks? Require that for each F150, Ford sells two Focuses? The most efficient way, and which also keeps the government from calling the economic winners and losers, is a tax. To avoid the tax, drivers will use less.
Everybody who uses oil hurts us, but there is no sense in trying to ban high consumption in America. Much better to just let Americans freely choose. Want to drive a Humjob? Go buy one, and pay to fill it up. Don't want to pay $200 to fill the tank? Make a different choice. Everybody's free to choose.
by jellimonsta
I never drove when I lived over in the UK, the Canary or the Balearic Islands. I walked, rode my bike or took the train/ bus. However, here in WI, public transport is barely existent, and very much unviable. :(
My 97 Grand Am can get about 30MPG and up to 34MPG when exclusively highway. Not great but better than the SUV. I really don’t care too much for driving so do it as little as possible.
I agree with your thoughts on the designs of US Ford versus European however. Also, I am sure my 2 door Grand Am does not need a 3.1L V6.
Some of us have tried getting better emissions out of vehicles for years. Most of us just took what was offered.
Just because the manufacturers are not offering more efficient models does not mean that all Americans never wanted the option!
Just like this!
I don't dispute what you say at all. The whole US car industry is (oh, sorry, WAS) geared towards a different perspective - one that included cheap gas. WE haven't had cheap petrol for YEARS. The price of petrol in today's terms was the same in 1983, dropped down to around 70% in 1993 and then kicked back to today-equivalent a couple of years later when the "green" think kicked off and our "tax-multiplier" was introduced. Only this year has it really gone beyond the 1983-equivalent price. That's more than TWENTY FIVE YEARS.
This has forced car manufacturers to design small-engined cars and then to increase the efficiency of those small engines to deliver enough power to make the cars drivable. It's fueled (PI) the development of really efficient diesel engined cars. Japan has NEVER had oil so they have always built small, fuel-efficient cars.
The US had to do it during the 1973 fuel crisis but not since the price went down again it failed to carry through in the same way as Europe and Japan.
The rest is Economics. Now.
Neil :)
by delbertpgh
There are lots of economic motivators. Some people want to amass profit. Some want to conquer markets. Some want to control risk. And some want to do nothing different than they did before.
The U.S. in the 1950s and 1960s built a dream industry around cars, big cars that told a story of American optimism. Hundreds of thousands of auto workers demanded, and got, fancy middle class wages and secure health care for talent in holding a screwdriver. Investors got rich. Cities built monuments. Car executives talked to politicians. Nobody wanted it to end.
The economic situation changed, but America had slipped into an economy where it made sense only to build huge numbers of very big cars, which may not have had the greatest quality, but they looked good and their drivers looked good in them, and the cars were all designed to be thrown away in six years, anyhow. When efficient little cars from Europe started making a dent, American car makers decided it was not profitable to try to compete with them. Any way, they could only get 10% or 15% of the American market, because real Americans still wanted those big American cars.
Between the expensive labor contracts and the fact that car executives just didn't want to think out of the box or take chances, when the tide turned, the American car industry was screwed. It lost half the market. The only way Americans could make a buck was to build the big cars, which is why when the SUV came in, that's what they concentrated on. The labor unions supported it, because that's where their rice bowl was, and with identical pressure from industry and labor, the politicians caved on fuel economy standards. That's where we are today.
That's why we haven't built decent cars for our domestic economy, and why Americans who want a fun and efficient alternative don't get one. We're officially dedicated to the life support of what used to be our major industry, which is permanently stuck in the past.
by jamesrl
The new Chevy Malibu/Saturn Aura/Saab 93 is your Opel/Vauxhall Vectra. The Malibu was voted car of the year. The engine is not the same however - there is a 2.4 litre 4, a 3.6 litre V6 and a hybrid(with the 4).
I have driven a decent US spec Focus - the SVT(no longer made). SVT stands for special vehicle team, they take regular cars and tweak them. The Focus SVT had a 2.0 litre Cosworth, Getrag 6 speed tranny and 170 horsepower. I drove it all over southern California, and wish I had it here.
When you talk about imports, you may be under the mistaken impression that the japanese makers are importing cars. The Honda Civic/Accord, the Toyota Corolla/Matrix/Camry, Nissan Versa Sentra are all made in North America.
The other thing that is hurting Ford GM and Chrysler is the fact that the Japanese makers are competing in the pickup truck field with full size trucks that are as powerful and more fuel efficient.
GM is working on a hybrid truck, and already has an SUV (Tahoe Hybrid) that is based on a pickup truck body and engine, but with a hybrid component. It also has active cyclinder management to turn off some cylinders. It makes 9.8 litres per 100 kms city/10.5 highway. Thats better than my minivan, but it is very expensive.
James
by delbertpgh
I've driven a lot in France and Italy. When I rent a car, it's compact, sips fuel, and goes fast. The interior space is well thought out, and it handles better. You can't sell a vehicle in Europe if it's not fun to drive. I don't know why American small cars don't do as well, especially since Ford and GM are making successful Euro cars. Maybe they want to keep us all disgusted with the little cars so we'll buy large ones that are more profitable.
In Pittsburgh, I've got a Neon and a Dodge Caravan. We drive the Neon (built in 2000, 225,000 miles) whenever possible. My last Caravan, a '94, had a 3.0 liter engine that was great up any hill in Pennsylvania. The new Caravan, an '04, has a 3.3 liter engine that stinks. I don't know why the car couldn't have gotten better with ten years to practice making it, but they made it worse. I can't say why this is, but it's the way American car companies seem to do it.
If I didn't have two dogs and two boys to drive around, I wouldn't have gotten this stinking hulk of a minivan, which only gets me 22 miles per gallon on the highway. My last trip to New Jersey cost me $150 in gas.
by jdclyde
Maybe they were made like crap in the US to KEEP people from wanting them?
"sure, here is your small car! Isn't that better than your gas guzzler?"
You try it and it is a dog, so you go back to the truck or whatever.
Just a thought.
by tonythetiger
[i]I don't know why American small cars don't do as well, especially since Ford and GM are making successful Euro cars.[/i]
... extra 500 lbs of weight they put in front that makes it handle lousy :)
by tonythetiger
[i]They are making a big deal about the Chevy Volt that is suppose to be out next year though.[/i]
Thus cheaper than current hybrids. No transmission.... engine perfectly tuned to specific rpm, maximizing its efficiency charging the battery... adaptable as electricity producing) technologies improve and new ones emerge...
While it is somewhat wasteful to carry your "charger" around with you all the time, the technical simplicity will keep the price down, letting more units be sold, and more gasoline saved.
It seems a smart idea but as you said, wait and see.
by tonythetiger
[i]Subsidies are bad[/i]
Is it wrong, for example, for a city or state to give a company a tax break for building a plant there?
by $$$$$$$$$$
by tonythetiger
A tax break, a grant, even a low interest loan to get an employment boost and nuture a viable economic concern is one thing.
Continually funding a loss making business with 'tax dollars' to get campaign funds and votes, is an entirely didfferent animal.
Far too easy for subsidies to turn into the latter....
by jck
why give a tax break (wave taxes) if it is going to only employ 50 people? does that more than make up in personal income and/or sales taxes locally what they lose in property tax?
with the "synfuel credits", the company i worked at was really doing nothing significant to create and/or use synfuels. they took the monies they got from the government and poured the majority of it into "overhead" budgets that could be moved around and redistributed under the guise of "support" to the synfuels program.
i know for a fact, as of about 8 months ago, they are still not using synthetic fuels in the power generation stations. they are using coal, nuclear, or water-vapored oil mix.
plus they are about to ask the state of Florida for a 16-25% rate hike because of higher fuel costs to run generators.
i say let em build nuke plants, or put wind turbines on the gulf. one good hurricane could power Florida for weeks. lol
by tonythetiger
ever paid any taxes. It's a business expense that's passed to the consumer along with other business expenses, so who is really paying it?
WE are! So why not eliminate business taxes and place them all on the consumer? Why was it set up this way? So we wouldn't know how much money the government is spending! Yes, yes, I know, the figures are publicly available, but it's a perception thing. If you are paying 22% in direct taxes and 22% of the remaining 78 in extra money for goods and services because of corporate tax, the perception is that you are paying 22% in taxes, when in reality it's more like 40%. [added: Wouldn't you be pissed if you saw a 40% deduction on your paycheck?]
Since the consumer pays all corporate taxes anyway, why not just collect it directly from the consumer.... right out in the open? Why are we allowing our representatives to intentionally deceive us?
by jamesrl
A) Suburbanization. Post WWII, inner cities drained and people moved into the burbs if they could afford to do so. So people travelled longer distances to work than they had. Cars also became more affordable about the same time the baby boom and new economic prosperity hit.
B) The oil crisis. The US government (and Canada copied) in its infinite wisdom decided to implement mileage targets (CAFE). But there were much looser rules for CAFE for trucks than cars, as well as looser safety standards. Years later, station wagons are dead, minivans and SUVs(defined as trucks) are popular - coincidence? I think not.
James
by $$$$$$$$$$
of course,
s/King/chief or chair
s/Earth/Agency with legal jurisdiction
Anyway, what I'd do is ask for volunteers from only companies with the lowest rates of customer defaults, to re-assess the various foreclosed persons' real creditworthiness. I'd then assess the difference to the mortgage houses, liquidating to the last penny if necessary. I'd never pay them Citizens' taxes for taking a risk that didn't pay off. That's fascism, that is.
by tonythetiger
[i]What would you do about sub-prime mortgages [/i]
caveat emptor
If you did it, you eat it.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
Bring full employment to the area and get the tax base from the employees.
Business will love the cheap environment and stay there.
"the best thing for the country would be to tax imports more (higher Tariffs).
Protectionism is the coward's way out. How about making a less expensive/higher quality product?"
Less expensive + higher quality? Those rarely go together properly.
We built quality here in the states, but they cost too much for many who picked up the cheap stuff from other countries, which usually wears out quicker :(
My Grandmother had machines from the years ago that just kept doing what they were designed to. Newer versions would cr@p out after a few years.
Seems that companies have found out that people will buy cheap stuff repeatedly if there is a little incentive such as 'this model is better', etc..
Even many very expensive items seem to fail the longevity test, as they are made to be replaced as well, not made to last..
"Protectionism is the cowards way out"
Well, I see it like this. The US Trade needs to be overhauled. We import more than export, and tax less than we should on imports to help companies save money and bankroll more.
In the process, small businesses have suffered, so much so that many went out of business because they could not compete unless they went overseas.
Is this a good practice? weaken your economy so that the large companies make a little more???
by jellimonsta
Scummy,
I agree with you. It still sickens me that we can pay $1400 for a fridge/ freezer and have the sales guy tell me it will be good for maybe 10-15 years.
Same with all appliances and electronics like TV sets. Damn plastic junk!! :D
by $$$$$$$$$$
especially since my Grandmother had a freezer in her garage -- that she was using for 30 years. The only reason she got rid of it was because she didnt want to take it to another state when she moved...
My mother has a mixer/blender/slicer that is about 30 yrs old. It works great still, however some attachments are missing :( (it happens after many moves). The closest thing to it does half of what this did, costs 5 times more. :(
Anyway, replacements will last 5-10 yrs...
and cheap replacements -- well can we say 5-10 uses :0 :^0
by tonythetiger
[i]We built quality here in the states,[/i]
We USED to, but we don't anymore... The drive to make luxuries out to be necessities REQUIRED a deliberate drop in quality.
by tonythetiger
[i]Is it the same rate as individual taxpayers?[/i]
individuals' [b]should[/b] be..... zero!
by jdclyde
is how many of the products are made in the US anymore? I know the Whirlpool factory in Michigan recently moved down to Mexico.
People would rather go to Borgmart and get cheap crap made in China than buy a quality product that will last, but cost more.
You have to go to specialty shops to get a decent product. Bath, Bed, and Beyond has a grand selection of kitchen appliances (small) and utinsels.
by nicknielsen
38 MPG at 70 MPH
Still laughing?
I've had it for 3-4 years and it p1sses people off even more today than ever! :D
Edit: can't spell emoticons
by jdclyde
by nicknielsen
by w2ktechman
Tony -- Yup, I am sorry too... That is why I used a past tense (built) instead of present (build)...
JD -- There are some out there, however most utensils at BB&B are made in China.
However, I did find 1 manufacturer of plates there that are made in the USA -- and not much more expensive either (something like $10 on the set) :)
Can you tell which I bought???
Personally, I have gone out of the way many times to get something NOT made in China. However too often I gotta cave in cause I cannot find anything else :(
by nicknielsen

by tonythetiger
[iPeople would rather go to Borgmart and get cheap crap made in China than buy a quality product that will last, but cost more.
[/i]
They think they HAVE to have it, and they HAVE to have it now and they can't afford to wait. They've decided they'd rather buy it twice than buy it good. From offshoring to the mortgage crisis, that's the root of it.
by tonythetiger
[i]Personally, I have gone out of the way many times to get something NOT made in China. However too often I gotta cave in cause I cannot find anything else[/i]
Be ingenuous and make something they're not making :)
by w2ktechman
however not the ability to make them :(
Example, those hoses for the sink! How about one that fits on the faucet for us renters that are not going to re-pipe the sink. It can also have a flow switch to use it right out of the faucet or better yet, have a quick release when it's not wanted.
I tried piecing one together, however the adapters needed made one heck of a problem...
That is just a more recent example -- I get ideas like that often...
by jdclyde
had someone comment how they thought it was GREAT that I was doing my part to fight global warming! :D
No, I didn't explain it to her. who knows, maybe I will get to play with the mommy parts if I don't spill the beans? ]:)
what a dumb dummy! :D
by $$$$$$$$$$
by $$$$$$$$$$
They claimed they knew what they were doing. They didn't. 00:33
I don't trust people who reassure me too much, but give me too little independently-verifiable data. Maybe their lenders couldn't sucker you, or me, but that doesn't mean they're not liars, and doesn't mean they aren't culpable for their actions.
Why should only the buyer beware?
And FFS, why should the lender get a bailout, ever?
by $$$$$$$$$$
If they're paid by the proletariat, it's communism.
If they're paid by the congregation, it's theocracy.
If they're paid by their own employees via the state, it's fascism.
I'm sure further variations, some yet-unnamed and others merely unknown to me, are possible. At root, they're all just systems for replacing universal human rights with rare class privileges, all at the expense of the majority.
Real capitalism is the economic system that accompanies political recognition of human rights.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by jdclyde
by jck
I wish you all could see what reducing a tax did to Florida.
Last year, Florida decided to change property tax code to "ease the cost on owners".
Well, they did so well at lowering taxes not only for those on fixed incomes but mostly larger businesses as well (who really didn't need the taxbreak) anyways...that the state figured it was going to have to cut billions from monies it gives to counties for operational budgets.
I know the first county i worked for...a smaller county...was itself looking at a $22-28M shortfall the first year alone and having to a) reduce services to the public, b) layoff people, and c) close/sell facilities.
And, they didn't have an over abundance of things. Modest offices and decently staffed.
So, before some of you go saying to eliminate all taxes...please consider what that would do to things in your life.
by nicknielsen
Without that as a fallback option, of course tax collections were going to decrease.
All that happened there, J, is that the Florida legislature demonstrated that it, just like Congress, meets the definition of a committee as the only known form of life with two or more stomachs but no brain.
by w2ktechman
I wonder how this country ever got along before income taxes?
hmmmm.. things to ponder....
by jck
FL has no personal income tax, but we pay in other ways. We also have no sales tax on pre-packaged food and medication. That's a thing to accomodate limited-income seniors.
As for how the USA survived before income tax. Well, that was quite a bit before things like interstate highways and medicare.
I guess we could go back to dirt roads and people dying younger in life and conestoga wagons.
by $$$$$$$$$$
by tonythetiger
by $$$$$$$$$$
by delbertpgh
Taxing companies probably suppresses the business urge to a degree, but if you do not tax companies, you turn them into tax avoidance gimmicks. To "incorporate" means to become like a body, or as a person; corporations enjoy the rights of property ownership and the protection of the law, just like a real person; why shouldn't they enjoy taxation, too?
If you don't tax people, then all the tax pain is hidden from individuals and placed on somebody or something else. People would become like irresponsible children, demanding the world from their government, because the tax money is a free resource to them.
I don't believe that excusing the poor and "the little guy" from taxation is a good policy, because it makes them behave irresponsibly. To be a citizen, you have to know what it feels like to pay taxes. If you want to be sweet to the little guy, you find some way of feeding him a break on the back end, like the earned income tax credit, or rebates of taxes. Likewise, I don't think that the rich should be taxed extravagently, but I don't see a problem with a mildly progressive tax rate system, either. I don't think that government should be offering special tax breaks for long-term capital gains; you wind up with government trying to steer the way individuals invest for the sake of some imagined social benefit. Government should stay out of that, and let individuals make their own decisions.
Hey, Tony, were you genuinely curious about that timeshare in New Orleans? It's five blocks from the French Quarter, and normally has week 15 (Jazz Festival week, most years), but I moved it for this year only to Halloween week. Halloween is the second most rowdy event in New Orleans, next to Fat Tuesday.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]I wonder how this country ever got along before income taxes?[/i]
IIRC, land sales were not a significant source of revenue for a significant period. Please correct if I'm mistaken, don't feel like visiting teh Google at the moment.
by $$$$$$$$$$
[i]If you don't tax people, then all the tax pain is hidden from individuals and placed on somebody or something else. People would become like irresponsible children, demanding the world from their government, because the tax money is a free resource to them.[/i]
We'd still notice increases in cost of living that result from "unfair" taxes of businesses. Also, I think your point that corporate tax "suppresses the business urge" overstates the matter. Corporate tax tends to eliminate the tax-avoidance impetus to incorporate, resulting in more small entrepreneurs, thus a net gain.
by tonythetiger
Were the corps taxed, and not the citizens, the corps would include the tax as a business cost, but the citizens would have no idea of what percentage of their purchase price went to the government.
Put it on the cash register receipt... in plain sight.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
I BC, they have been pushing forth a legislation to impose a carbon tax on all fuel. The 'broad' on the radio this morning really PO'd me on my way in.
"We burn carbon fuel and it is important that we realize that we must find new ways or getting around without our cars. Cars are the problem and we must impose a tax to discourage people from driving."
No kidding, she was really that simple minded and ridiculous soudning, she didn't cry but she sure as he11 whined about it.
"We have to find a way that we can work towards improving our environment, but at the same time do it in a way that keeps our economy strong," said Taylor, as she presented a budget that, aside from the carbon tax, commits $1 billion over four years to fight climate change."
"...Taylor said the new carbon tax will begin July 1, starting at a rate that will have drivers paying about an extra 2.4 cents per litre of gasoline at the pumps.
If you drive a Prius hybrid, the government estimates the new tax will cost you about $20 extra per year. If you have a Dodge Ram pickup truck, that number will be closer to $68 it says.
The tax will then increase each year after that until 2012, reaching a final price of about 7.2 cents per litre at the pumps."
So instead of promoting responsibilty or investing in better technology, which they APPRENTLY aim to do through ths carbon tax, now we are going to be [b]financially penalized for buying gasoline.[/b]
Furthermore, say by some stroke of luck, should they ever find a better fuel or combustion process, I am confident that all the drivers who paid for that research will not see a dime given back to them.
'kin crooks, gotta love the government. LOL
by oz_media
Canada is deemed an energy superpower, a leader in hydro electricity production, #7 for natural gas and nearing #3 for oil production. Yet in BC, just hours away from Alberta (Canada's oil rich province) we pay over $1.40/L (Canada's highest gas prices).
I have been dirt bike riding along the pipeline that pumps from Alberta to BC, I have seen the Natural gas pipes, which pump out so much gas that the friction inside the pipe stops anything from growing on it.
Yet we pay through the nose for gas.
Canada has proposed to double the oil flow by 2012, requiring a major upgrading investment, seeing sa Petro Canada showed the highest first quarter profits (a record topping all corporations of any sort in Canada) but today the same pump pumps the same oil from the same well so there's no increase in production costs. Where did the cost of doing that change?
We are sitting on one of the 10 largest reserves in the world and yet paying the highest prices. Global oil pricing sux!
by tonythetiger
by delbertpgh
A tax inhibits the money-making activity of anyone who is taxed. If an individual is taxed at a marginal rate of 90%, he'll have little reason to try harder once he hits that tax bracket. If companies are similarly charged, they run short of investment money, or engage in strange business practices that twist the income into some form that escapes the tax.
Of course, if you don't tax at all, and give up the idea of having a broad base of governmental services and regulation, then the wild west environment that ensues inhibits economic activity, too. You wouldn't send your wife out to work if you figured she would get attacked in the lawless streets; you wouldn't freely trade stocks or bonds if there was nobody enforcing security laws to keep out the scammers. There's a golden middle to taxation, regulation, standardization, and freedom, where money made and happiness realized are at a maximum.
by jdclyde
Is that this is caused because of America and their big bad SUV's, and if we all switch to hybrids and sing qumbiya, all will be well in the world.
The truth is the increased demand in China and India is what had changed to cause the increases, and NOTHING we do in the US short of either using our OWN oil or not using oil at all, will make any difference in the price of gas.
by $$$$$$$$$$
Am I the only one here who has heard or seen [u]any[/u] reports that speculation, not supply vs. demand, has been the primary driver of gasoline prices past ~$2.50/Gal. or ~$80/barrel?
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-roberts10dec10,0,7648253.story?coll=la-opinion-rightrail
Not environmentalists, speculators.
by oz_media
The oil comes from Alberta, there is no provincial tax in alberta (rish and all that) yet they pay just slightly less than us.
I KNOW gas prices are up all over the world, but with our oil coming from a neighbouring province, it is complete Bs that they must follow global oil pricing and charge us so much.
YOu can't expect me to believe that it costs as much to get oil to my gas station as it does to get to Arkansas or even Vancouver Island for that matter. The largest western refinery and HO for Canada's largest oil company is about 15 minutes from my front door! I want cheap gas damnit! I'll go to teh refinery and pick it up there if it saves them driving a truck to the local filling station.
Makes me wanna go kick 'em all in the ding-ding! ]:)
by tonythetiger
Sort by Trending