Wardriving - Legal or not?
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by rogerf
"Radio Stations and the TV Stations" are receive only and if you transmit on those frequencies you are breaking the law.
" and take away all Ham and CB Radios" - if you have your own gear AND licence no issue; but if, e.g., you identify youself as someone else: illegal
"and Cell Phones" - if you use a 'hacked' SIM this is also illegal/theft. If you transmit anything on these frequencies with other than a cell phone - oops!
Getting back to wireless connections: if I have paid for a facility (anything, not just a wireless connection)and someone uses that without my permission then this is, if not strictly illegal, unethical. Just because someone does not have the knowledge to secure their system does not automatically make it Public .
Outsiders accessing a system to download/upload a few files may take a person over their limit and incur either charges or throttling. I quite often use up most of my allotment early in the month and cool my heals for important stuff later in the month. So, if you grab my last few Meg then I am restricted to 64K for the rest of the month. Would you be happy with that on your system?
by ludedude25
Try filing a claim with your insurance company and tell them but I leave my house unlocked or my car unlocked with the keys in it all the time. Lol that's just great.
I don't have to enter someone else's house to use their internet, Heck some neighbors around here have stronger signals then my own router in my own house!
It's not a ethic's issue or a legal issue it's a responsibility issue.
If the broadband distributer doesn't want there internet broadcast then they should Clearly state that in their aggrement when you sign up for it. They need to say something along the lines of "Open wireless routers will be cause for termination of services."
Hell the dsl company here will ship you a wireless modem wide open!
If they are really worried about there service being "stolen" then why on earth wouldn't they ship the Wireless modem/router with either wifi turned off or locked down and instructions on how to configure your wireless card to connect to it.
That is either stupidity or lack of responsibility on the providers part.
Think about it, your cordless phone is not made to be open to everyone, and the telephone manufactures make sure of that, Cel phones are somewhat secure also. The satellite TV companys also keep their stuff secure or at least try to and it's open air.
If anyone is to blame then it should be the wireless manufactures and people who distribut them for not shiping their items secured. If the general public isn't smart enough to simply log into a router and change some simple settings then how on earth did they manage to use the internet???
You can't tell me most people are too stupid to follow instructions as simple as most wireless routers are. I'm no genius and I can figure it out.
by paymeister
You're quite right about the key issue being that of the agreement with the ISP. Murjo08 brought this out also, and made me realize that the issue your voiced here is probably the key one. Sure, nothing was "removed" from the fellow's access (so it would be ethical in that sense), but it caused him to violate his agreement with the provider (which, for those of you who are so inclined, would be a "damaging the good name" issue violating the "don't bear false witness" commandment). See https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html?forumID=82&threadID=185931&messageID=1905151 for Murjo08's post.
Thanks, Zig Zag! And I like the "5yo rule". I've found, too, that if I can't 'splain it to my wife, I'm usually in the wrong, too (not to equate my wife with a 5y/o, of course).
by briggs0558
by mindtickler
by dohnotgood
by hellums
by wojnar
That is the worst analogy I have heard yet.
First of all, you are not taking any object which you can control. (tried to put the light beams in a jar and use it in your basement lately ?) Second, your 'use' of the light does not reduce the quantity or quality available for the stated purpose (otherwise with enough people looking, the light would be used up - like bandwidth). Third, as the owner retains full control, they are not diminished by your use of the desired object. Now, if you were to steal the bulb, the electricity or the fixture, then you are stealing because you have taken control of the OBJECT, prevented the OBJECT from accomplishing its stated purpose and diminished the true owner's rights to everything they are paying for (can't give back used bandwidth). At this point, the owner no longer has control and in most cases is forced to incur monetary cost to replace or maintain what you have stolen.
As a consultant, you should be well aware of the cost involved in bandwidth stealing. You wouldn't steal my office pens and pads would you ?
Like mom used to say "If it doesn't belong to you, don't touch" . One for my soapbox - Why does everybody think they have a RIGHT to anything they want. You don't have a right to something just because 'everybody else' has it.
by briggs0558
The use of bandwith is like using water from someones stream or light from their bulb. Light and radio signals are just different forms of energy. You do not degrade the signal by using the carrier. True, you are using part of that persons bandwith, but that limit is inmpossed by the provider of the connections, not the connection itself.
This thread is "wardriving - legal or not". If you want to protect your connection for personal, legal or due to an agreement with the service provider, that is up to you. BUT, if you don't protect that connection but instead let it transmit freely, then you are inviting trouble just as if I had left my Gun on the counter of a day care.
I have every right to intercept any radio transmission. What I do with that is a seperate thing entirely.
I guess your Mom would have held her breath when visiting my house so as not to touch my air that was encompasssed by my house. By several of the definitions here, she would be a thief.
Give me a break!
by briggs0558
Now that I have your attention, I work in IT and I'm glad your not my manager! You sound pretty overbearing in your responses. Might want to try a little more tact in your approach. I'm sure your employees would appreciate it!
You are not using someone elses property anymore than you are using someone elses property when you use the light from their bulbs to read. Are you stealing their light? Maybe we sould all keep our eyes and omputers turned off when we walk down the street at night.
You masquerade as no one when using their connection. How can you masquerade as someone you don't know? Fraud of what? Does intercepting un-encrypted radio signals constitue fraud? The government has ben doing it since radio was invented!
Give me a break!
by dohnotgood
by jdclyde
until you get caught, my dear. Don't you know that by now? ;\
As for the anti-hacking, my understanding wasn't he doing illegal activity with the wifi? Not the same thing we are talking about if it is what I am thinking of.
And yes, I THINK once in a while! :p
Rejoice! I can finally get in and out of TR! That beotching I did must have paid off!
by jdclyde
the "if you take someones car" or "if you take blah blah blah blah"
It would be more educational if most of the posters here would to that "thinking" thing before they post something and show how clue-depleted they really are.
"I think this is wrong, so that makes it illegal and unethical?"
"What a moroon." by Mr Buggs Bunny.
Now the ones that reference existing laws and try to apply it to this are few, but there are a few good ones out there.
Craig had one of the best I have read yet.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-11189-0.html?forumID=82&threadID=185931&messageID=1904995
by dohnotgood
by jdclyde
do you even have a door? these are all things that tell people not to come in.
enabling wap is the same thing as closing the door. not going to keep most out, but the casual person will know that it is not for general use.
locks just keep the lazy people out.
by jdclyde
is that you in a real marathon? how high do you rank?
Used to be a runner, but bad knees put an end to that. most fun I ever had (standing up, that is) was pole vaulting! woo woo!
Oh yeah, I was looking at your roses too. you may notice I looked some of the color right out of them and I am sure this will set you back somehow. :D
by dohnotgood
someone blasted me with a "if you found $100,000 you would keep it"
Actually you are supposed to make an effort to find who it belongs to.
It again is sad at how many people need a law to tell them how to act
by dohnotgood
by dohnotgood
by mickey6
Your argument has merit in sentiment but i think you are mixing terminology.
It is right to say it is immoral to steal but to say it is unethical you must assign the group by which you obtained their set of ethics.
As to the question of ethics vs. morality, remember that morality is a standard by which we measure right and wrong. Ethics need not be good to be ethics.
The Mafia has ethics.
Any group that has rules of operation have ethics. They are simply the rule of operation for that group and need not be good to be ethics.
ref:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=82&threadID=185931&messageID=1904402
by dohnotgood
What a jerk.
Glad you dont live next to me.
Ethics...well....if you think it's right, then ethically it's OK with you and you do it. If someone else thinks it's wrong, ethically it's not OK with them & they don't do it.
I don't feel that any particular individual is qualified to state categorically that partaking ina bit of free airtime is Unethical And An Offence To Mankind. If you think it's unethical, good on you, mate - you won't be doing it.
How are your ethics when it comes to eating burgers, then? Or littering, or driving a gas-guzzler, or wearing a garment that was produced by child labour in a land far, far away??
Tricky things, ethics.
Personally I wouldn't do it, but I'm not horrified or particularly upset that others do. Society probably won't fall if some citizens go on wardriving - and jd & others aren't doing anything BAAAAD, like kicking over rubbish bins or targeting kids with Tobacco ads and pretending that Ignant McNuggets are actually good for you.
If a person does this for some kind of nefarious reason, or for personal gain without giving the unwitting host or hostess a cut of the profits, or to be a winner & making someone else lose, then it's A Bad Thing and there should be a law against it. IMHO.
by georgesr
First I don't know anything about if it is legal or not but :
1- Thinking that besides their monthly cost there is no other cost involved in a broadband connection is wrong. Depending on your ISP their may be some bandwith charges, for example the company I do tech support for has various service, the High Spped does not have any bandwith limit while the lower speed service (now 512 kbps) has a 2 Gb bandwith limit and the customer is charge for extar. Some of our customers who have that service also have a router, therefore when you pick up the signal and connect to it you may cause that person some prejudice because they may be billed for extra activity.
2- Most Wireless routers that I have set up the router whithout security by default
As IT pros that most of you are if you set up your routers with no security on then if people use your connection well...
Problem is with home users, there are still users who still don't know about this capability of their routers and the "threat" of an open system, basically because the vendor did not advised them or as usual they did not read the user guide or if they did very quickly.
Also configuring a wireless adapter for a WEP keyed access may be tricky for some card and baffle the casual user as an open system is so easy and home user beeing home users... (nothing bad in mind just
3- Although there are differences in the purpose there was outrage everywhere about Sony rootkit and most want to sue, boycott or wahtever against Sony
Differen ? maybe but htey have somthing in common
Sony: installs its software without user knowledge & consent
Wardriving: using somemone else the connection without his knowledge & consent
To me if I think that Sony did not have the right to install it's rootki then I should not give me the permission of doing the same thing to another user (maybe naive but that is what I believe in)
And by the way Sony does have a "valid" reason to do it (protect their rights) as for wardriving ?????
by red3india
by red3india
by beilstwh
by sarah_hh81
jdclyde:
"If it not against the law, how can anyone claim it is unethical?"
There's a vast difference between law and ethics. Ethics are a person, group, society, or era's overall group of morals based on what they think is right, or deem to be correct behaviour or practise. Law is just that - law, sure I don't have to explain that one to you. Of course often laws do change to reflect the society or country's ethics, or those of the time, but they do not necessarily go hand in hand. One consideration is of course if the person is not on an ulimited plan they may be charged for your usage, which hardly seems fair (in my book). I'm sure current laws will cover it if put to the test. I guess one way to tell is to think 'would I be peeved if I had set up a wireless network and someone piggybacked on to it?' If yes then I guess thats your answer. And I don't think the excuse that 'they should have known better' is a good enough one to justify this.
by jdclyde
it is people imposing their moral views on me?
I thought that is suppose to be a bad thing in this "I'm a victom" age?
But yes, many ethics are based around what is acceptable behavior.
If it isn't illegal, and there isn't a clear standard of bahavior on something, then it is kind of a craps throw, yes?
But for the most part, that is why I TRIED to point this to the legal FACTS instead of peoples opinions.
An opinion discussion on wardriving will have all the results of getting into an OS bashing war. Nothing gained and nothing lost but time.
Thanks for stopping in and welcome to TR. :D
by hjleevta
The law exists in California and has for several years. I could find no prosecution of someone for use of an open wireless connection, but I have no doubt such use violates the law. It is a network and you do not have a permission of either the owner of the router, or the ISP.
The code section allows for civil and criminal penalties and includes a specific fine for use not involving an injury to the victim. I did find a successful prosecution of someone using public hardware but accessing the non-public operating system, even though no damage was done. No idea what the penalty imposed was, if any. I would guess it was the minimum $250 for a no injury crime as the appellate court commented on that provision. The law in general has been found constitutional for fighting spam - another provision and section.
Depending on prior activity, value of services, and the subsection you are prosecuted under, it could be a felony.
by sales
Found it! I thought there had been a case in the UK and I wasn't wrong.
"Gregory Straszkiewicz has been convicted of dishonestly obtaining an electronic communications service contrary to s.125 of the Communications Act 2003 for accessing using neighbour?s Internet access through their unsecured wi-fi access point. He was fined GBP500."
Here's the link:
by ed-m
You have no way of knowing whether that $100 was lost through carelessness or a totally unavoidable accident or whether it was all the grocery money for the family for the month. The point is that losing something for whatever reason in no way gives automatic right of ownership to whoever finds it.
It was probably earned by the toil and sweat of the person who lost it and is still their's. You turn it into the police or the lost-and-found department or whetever and they check to see if someone reported it lost. Any small child who is responsibly brought up understands this. How this manages to escape a mature adult is a genuine mystery.
My God, doesn't anybody believe in "do unto others as you would have them do unto you" anymore!?
It's not your place to punish someone for what you presume to be their carelessness or ignorance by taking unseen advantage of them. The same goes for people who expose their access. So they aren't as "intelligent" and "technically savvy" as you are. You were that way once until you learned. Their inexperience gives you the right to leech off of them without their knowing and let them do the paying? Let me make sure that word was not missed...L-E-E-C-H!!
Something-for-nothing any way you can do it and rationalise it as "legal" - that's the spirit of the age, it seems.
by brokeneagle
by tonythetiger
by jamesrl
Sure the police and insurance company will ask, but that doesn't mean thta insurance wont pay or the police won't investigate.
You can blame the manufacturers if you want - I think making security easy to set up would be a selling feature. But I believe in personal responsibility - the person sponging wifi off their neighbour is the one responsible.
James
by sand_and_sun
so someone may have already said this.
I believe that this probably falls under the theft of services provision of the law that exists in many states in the US. You are using ISP resources for which you haven't paid.
by csr-tech
by beilstwh
by hellums
There is a huge body of law pertaining to theft of use or services, and has been since the 80s. Bottom line is that if it has value or cost someone money, and you intentionally use it (hijack it) for free and without permission, you're breaking the law. If your neighbor leaves his mower out, you can't use it and return it. Same thing with his electric weed whacker, or his frisbee, or his bicycle. He paid for it, it's his. You can't use it without permission. If he leaves his doors and windows unlocked, it doesn't mean you can come in and watch his cable TV.
That being said, it's a waste of breath trying to convince the new generation about a morality topic. They all consciously prefer to think of music (and movies) as information and thus free, and don't think twice about sharing and downloading copyrighted material, regardless of the impact it has on the artists and the industry. They know it's warped thinking, but who cares? There IS such a thing as a free lunch--they know it, and want it, as often as they can get it. Heck, it beats working for it, right? Robin Hood, for all the romanticism, is still just a hood, and still just a thief.
But just like the "you can have my gun when you pry it from my cold dead fingers" crowd, you'll have to fight hard to take such a privilege of digital information or service theft away from them--they'll argue and fight (if not work) for that free lunch, to the bitter end. These types of morality questions should be standard fare during HR interviewing of potential new hires. If you don't want to work for it, fine with me, try getting through life without a paycheck! :)
by jdclyde
or at least some of us are.
Playing dumb? I did not make a discussion proclaiming that this is legal or illegal. I ASKED a group of professionals who work in this field if they knew of specific legislation that covers this or not. ASKING if there is a law is playing dumb?
My statement was [i]"I think most people that do this (myself included) would not if it was clear that there actually is a law against it. How close do you think we are to that?"[/i]
As for the "new generation" bit. While I am not an old timer (yet), I am far from a spring chicken. So while I agree that the new generation has been brought up with no morals or standards of behaviour (Thanks to the liberal progressive movement in this country), I am not a part of it.
Not to mention the cold dead fingers. I would bet I am a better shot than you, so it wouldn't be MY fingers getting cold! B-)
If you would have been around "the water cooler", you would know these things about me by now, but 7 months and 14 posts doesn't seem like enough time to make such statements about me? Especially when the majority of your posts are in discussions I haven't been in?
Now, about that paycheck.... ;\
by jpc1958_989
How about this scenario, I like to park my car in my driveway (or right in front of my house in the street - not true, but good for this example) and I like to leave the keys in the ignition and the doors unlocked. Sure, that's stupid, and inviting getting my car stolen, or at least ransacked, but anyone who uses that property without my permission is still guilty of a crime. Just because I was stupid, that does not give you a right to take advantage of it. Think about this HONESTLY, is it moral or ethical to use something that "belongs" to someone else without their permission? Answer honestly, and I'm pretty sure you'll agree that using someone's WiFi connection (unless specifically designated as a free public hotspot) is just plain wrong.
JC
by csr-tech
Do you live in a place where it is commonplace for others to park their vehicles with the keys in it specifically for the purpose of allowing anybody who needs to use a car for awhile, to use theirs? If so, how is the user supposed to differentiate between the cars parked with the keys in them that he is allowed to use, and the ones parked with the keys in them because the owner was stupid or careless? Obviously, the people in this area that don't want their cars used by the general public will remove their keys are lock their cars.
Next example?
by hellums
by hellums
by ed-m
Radio stations and TV stations, etc. are *intended* to be free and accessible to the public without subscription. (Here in the UK we all pay a BIG yearly fee (tax) for the privilege of receiving a TV signal). An ISP connection is not, and the provider is entitled to fair compensation for use of their signal by all who use it. It doesn't really matter whether the signal is intentionally or unintentionally leaked out by those who do pay for it and don't know how (or can't be bothered) to protect it. It also doesn't matter if the provider can never detect the unintended use of the signal.
The real issue is the right of the provider to be fairly compensated for use of their product. To take this to its logical conclusion (albeit not necessarily a likely secenario in real life), the possibility exists for many users to have their signal leeched by - say - 3 or 4 other households around them. The people who get the signal and pay for it are knowingly or unknowingly "sharing" the signal to all the others. "All the others" are then a lost market to the ISP because they are already getting the product for free. If this setup was widely practised, ISPs would not have a sufficient market base to be profitable and survive. Potrentially, NONE of us would then have access!
You might ask, how is this different from loaning my lawn mower to 2 or 3 of my neighbours whenever they need it? That's a lost market share for the lawnmower manufacturer and it's both ethical and legal. Agreed. The difference is that the lawnmower is shared by agreement and there is likely a sharing among all of the costs as well. Also, this kind of sharing is relatively rare and much more difficult to manage than, say, sharing of a signal.
When you are leeching an access signal on the sly (and I'm willing to bet that 99% of situations can be described this way), you are not behaving in good faith toward your neighbour, because you are taking advantage of a service he or she is paying for and without their permission or knowledge. You are also depriving the provider of fair compensation for something of value (that they invested heavily to provide) by surreptitiously taking the product just because it was available to take without your being found out. I would be very much surprised if an ISP permitted the practice of sharing their signal freely with others without compensation, because to do so would be cutting their own throats.
The difference between a lawnmower and a Wi-Fi signal is a fine distinction that is necessary to make. Generally speaking, hard commodities are not reproducible by the owner and can only be used for a single task by one user at a time. Electronic media such as software or a signal, which are easily and indefinitely shareable or reproducible (in the case of software) by their nature, represent a huge shift in the very definition of a commodity.
The way they are accessed, and the value that is derived from them, usually represent no loss to the original, rightful owner if it is shared with another. The loss is shifted entirely to the producer of the product through deprivation of a potential customer. Something-for-nothing is very, very much easier to come by with electronic media and the temptation is to take advantage of it is much stronger.
Wide-spread acceptance of this kind of ethic leads to an "everybodies' doing it so why shouldn't I" attitude that inexorably leeches the strength out of society's moral spine.
Gosh - listen to me rant. (OK - pulpit mode off.)
by hellums
I looked everywhere on the Internet and I couldn't find anywhere that it's illegal to spit on cars in public parking lots. It's not really vandalism. So let's all start doing it, shall we?
By the way, I didn't find anywhere that says it's illegal to don a Halloween mask and scare babies at the mall, or squirt them with water guns. I guess it's OK for me to do it, eh?
There is also no law against belching loud in restaurants, or farting in elevators. There is no law that says I have to take a bath, ever (except in a few states). There is no law that says I have to take off my dirty or muddy shoes when visiting a friend. There is no law that says I have to donate to charities. But all in all, isn't the world better off when we have internal morality along with a legal system.
Don't try to hide behind lack of a law as justification for doing something that you should know is immoral (or at least that you think other people might frown on as immoral). Without a conscience, we're not much of a society.
by mpitt
by ksat
Your Blues Clues comments are unnecessary and disrespectful as this is a debate of opinions. We are all entitled to our own opinions and apparently some feel much stronger about thier opinions.
I believe wardriving to be unethical. And, as you said, the discovery of an open WAP may not be an illegal practice - it's what you do with it once you find it. Using that open WAP for anytype of personal gain, regardless of the effects on the owner, I believe would be found to be illegal in a court of law.
by ksat
What would I do?? I would identify where the unsecured connection is coming from. Inform the owner that their wireless AP is unsecured and offer to secure it for them for a nominal fee. This is called free enterprise. I would fix it, configure the workstations appropriately and send them an invoice for the work I have done.
Even if you didn't do any work to secure it, you have done the right thing to inform them of the unsecured access point.
Leglity does not have much to do with whether you should be using someone's internet service they have paid for and have reasonable, albeit missguided, impressions that it is for their private use.
The fact that you don't ask if you can borrow the service indicates that you know that what you are doing is wrong.
The right thing to do would be to educate, and help protect them from the idiots out there.
by ksat
by jdclyde
we can tell where your head is shoved.
Why would you indicate I have a girlfriend and then turn around and say I couldn't get laid anyways? Do you have some personal issues in your life that are spilling over into your posts? Your "life mate" cheat on you? With your wit and charm, it is hard to believe....
I bet you giggled your a$$ off when you typed this, thinking just how clever you are in your own mind.
"Schmuck"? Oh, you cut me to the quik with your use of the English language.
By the way dumbass, you misspelled your own user name!
You have really shown yourself to be a major contributor to the Tech Republic family, and have really added to this discussion with your insights.
by j alley
Agree whole heartedly but I think most others do too so no need.
BTW - very interesting discussion.
I think the law you are breaking may be 'stealing' bandwidth from ISP of the person with the open access point. But, I think it would be really hard to say you are breaking a law. You are really using available radio frequencies in a band the government has said is a public, no-charge band.
I think it could be worked out that the person breaking the law (contract law) is the person with the open connection because their ISP probably has terms that the connection cannot be shared.
But turned around, given the level of expertise that the ISP has vs the person with the open connection, the defense would be that the ISP didn't take any action to protect their interest. They should have done so by providing instructions to set up a secure wireless point.
Morally you might be doing a good thing. Without this, no-one really takes responsibility for educating wireless router purchasers. Concerns about bandwidth sharing might actually drive ISPs to start educating??
by unclerob
and could very well result in your TR account privileges being revoked. The discussion at hand is whether or not wardriving is legal or illegal.
Your post doesn't have anything that adds to this discussion.
On a side note, TR needs to review it's TR techpoints situations, apparently this clown was awarded 25K Tech points for this type of submission - something is definitely wrong the system in this regard.
- just my 0.02 cents cdn
by jdclyde
but I am getting used to that.
Going onto someones property and taking or using something there is not even close to the same as radio waves.
But if it amuses you, continue down that path. Who am I to ruin something you seem to think is so clever?
by jdclyde
for one of the few posts that attempted to answer the question that was asked.
Like you, the closest I have found was the case in the UK of they guy doing nothing but connecting to the internet. Even with that, what happens in the UK doesn't define how it will happen here when it goes to trial. I just don't want to be the test case.
by nwarfield
by jdclyde
While that wasn't QUITE what I was looking for (an ethics discussion), it was the single best ethics post I have seen in this AND the discussion that is specifically asking for ethical opintions.
As far as your final statement, If I take the statement a few lines up to be true that two people on each side can have different view and both can still be right, they why would it matter if the other person agrees or not as we can both be right, meaning my "rightness" is not dependant on what his view is?
Note, Don't know exactly which neighbor it was to ask anyways.
And most importanly, if someone was not slighted or shorted in anyway, then what is the problem?
The ONLY reason MY WAP is locked down is to keep people out of my SYSTEMS.
by jamesrl
I worked for the Humane Society when I was in high school and went out on calls with the by-law officers/animal control officers.
In Ontario, if a dog wanders into your yard, you may not shoot it, unless your are defending yourself(you'd better have bite marks). There is a law that in rural areas, if three dogs come onto your property you can consider them a pack, and if you have livestock, you may shoot them.
James
by nickinsd2004
by zig zag
People in your office come under the your employer's account and are therefore OK, if they have your employer's permission.
Wardriving is theft of services. The confusion comes because the theft is from the ISP and not the person with the AP. It is the same as stealing a password and user ID and dialing up an ISP. That is clearly theft, so is wardriving.
by kaptkos
Last Fourth of July, I took the AmTrak from Chicago to my hometown in Nebraska and was using a Verizon wireless modem on my laptop and all the way there and back I kept picking up other peoples private wireless routers and piggybacked on them to hit the internet. I thought it was sorta cool.
As for the legality of it I am going to go out on a limb and say that it is perfectly legal. It is the same as dumpster diving for alluminum cans. Or as a police officer searching through someone's trash bin without a license. There is court precedence that makes it perfectly legal to dumpster dive as long as the intent to commit a crime such as identity theft is not present.
With a wireless access router, if the user does not secure it, it then becomes public domain and
anyone can access it as above, IF there is no criminal intent upon usage of such wireless system.
KaptKos
by beilstwh
by jdclyde
site case law that supports your opinion.
All the stories people have been telling in here, both pro and con, are a complete waste of time and effort because it doesn't matter if you THINK something is legal/illigal. It only matters what IS legal/illigal.
Do you not agree? After all, as a working professional you must be used to having to support ideas instead of just offering unfounded opinions?
by beilstwh
A couple of Articles found on the first page of a google search. Many states have made it illegal to access any network without authorization. It is just a matter of time before all the states expand their laws to cover wardriving like florida already has.
by jdclyde
I am pleased to say I have been suprised a few times with this discussion.
[b]It started out that the majority of the posters didn't CARE what the question was or what the Discussion was meant to be. Everything became a "if I take your car blah blah blah" and showed most just weren't and aren't THINKING.[/b]
But then it changed. There were ACTUALLY a few that would come up with well thought out arguements, either for or against if this would be legal or not.
Yours was one of these, and I thank you.
As for the educating, as I said in another post most ISP's won't even TALK to you while you have a router on your DSL/Cable modem. They would rather you have your PC plugged directly into the net and get hacked than to deal with vendor specific router issues. I don't see them doing ANYTHING to help this situation.
As for Alien boy, it wasn't until KSAT started a different discussion asking for the ability to report abusive people and linked directly to him, that I had even noticed this little bottom dweller. ;\
I at that point felt OBLIGATED to stop by and say "HI" to him. :D
I wonder what it feels like to have a discussion about banning people based on something you post?
by ksat
by liquidxit2
Ok Ok maybe its like your stealing someones cable. But your really not. Not only did they screw up and leave it unsecure, but you can alwasy look at it this way: I invite a friend over he brings his laptop as he needs to do something on it (something reasonable) or hes coming over to LAN with me. He just tapped into my WAP and is using my ISP, so whether he went through my WEP key or I left it unsecure is the same darn thing! He is utilizing an ISP he isnt paying for. I dont see a problem other then the fact that if someone failed to secure thier WAP they most likely failed to secure thier PC with a password and I can runa a simple work batch file and bam I own that PC. Thats where there is an issue. But for the average user or when I wanna check my email or chat on IM when Im away from home at my parents I can always bank on a decent connection with someones wireless unsecure. The onyl issue is that I have strict morales and wouldnt go farther then using it for email and chatting. Its the other crazies out there you need to worry about.
I agree its a morale issue but by far it shouldnt be against the law..its a God given freebie. Now any malicious activity or theft is and should be illegal. But come on if you leave your wallet laying around full of bills buldging out someone is bound to take it....
by zig zag
It is just like going over to your friend's house and "lanning" with him... EXCEPT YOU DON'T KNOW THEM OR HAVE THEIR PERMISSION!
Duh!
by unclerob
I agree with both your & murjo's post but this guy actually does have an interesting point he brought up.
No one talked about dropping a wallet on the street and yes it's still yours even though you dropped it on the street.
His point was that he didn't ask for wireless signals to be broadcast into his home. Since those signals represent the property of their owner, aren't they technically invading this person's space and thereby trespassing?
If you want to argue that tangible resources like cars, money, wallets, etc. carry the same weight & value as intangible resources (ie. wireless signals broadcasted from someone's unsecured wireless access point), then technically you also have to grant this person his point that it is trespassing if those signals are being broadcast into his own home. He made no mention of using them in his post, he simply stated that he felt that it was trespassing if those signals came into his home from a source outside of his home without his consent. Technically he's right.
If you want to argue that this intangible resource which techically has no physical form (smell, sight, taste or touch) is the property of it's owner and using these signals without consent constitutes theft of property (which I would agree), you must also grant that these wireless signals which are strong enough to reach outside of the original owner's intended area of usage (his property) are technically invading this other person's house (ie. neighbor) without his consent and that is technically trespassing. If you grant value & ownership to these wireless signals on one side of the equation, you must also add it to the other side of the equation.
What if we find out years from now that all of this uncontrolled broadcasting of wireless signals from all of these "dollar store" wap's causes a disease like cancer or worse.
I don't think trespassing in these terms is that far a leap if you look at it from this point of view and maybe if you want people to understand & listen to your point of view, you need to be willing to listen as well.
I don't think a minute was that much to ask for either.
just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree or disagree.
;-)
by murjo08
UncleRob, you stated:
"His point was that he didn't ask for wireless signals to be broadcast into his home. Since those signals represent the property of their owner, aren't they technically invading this person's space and thereby trespassing?"
To make a very long story short, I believe there is a body of legal opinions in several countries stating, in effect, that electro-magnetic (EM) waves, such as light, radio, and others cannot be personal property meaning no one can own the waves. These came in cases of disputes over frequency assignments in the early days of commercial radio. Application of that theory to trespassing means that since the waves cannot be owned by a natural person, they cannot trespass. The further expanation of this is far beyond the scope on an IT discussion.
Even though no one can own EM waves, they can own the benefit of the modulation of those waves, in this case Wi-Fi connections, and their access can be regulated. The value is added in the use of the waves.
by mwatch
The trespass argument is old old old. Many posting for free use will say that if it is not secured it's free. They believe that it is the responsibility of the owner to protect his property from invasion. If you buy the bandwidth protect it or loose it.
So if you are concerned about radio waves in your house why can't I say protect it or be invaded. This is the kind of response you get from people that DON'T have anything but law as a guide, and often they just ain't very familiar with the law on top of it all.
What was not discussed is that if my signal was causing my neighbor a problem I would make efforts to correct it. Even if the device met all FCC regs and should be able to be operated without concern. The law may say it's not my problem but my ethics would.
If your only guide is Law my hunch is that you won't make a very good neighbor IMHO.
by murjo08
First, thank you Paymeister for the kind words. I'm happy to see civility is still alive.
Let me expand on the concept of unjust taking. You alluded to it yourself with the heavy downloading and the occasional email example. From an ethical and moral standpoint, they are the same; the difference is only in magnitude.
Ethical use of the benefit of the resource comes under one of the two following conditions: 1. Procuring the rights directly from the service provider (paying for the connection), or, 2. Procuring the permission from the person paying for the connection. (Of course, the granting of that permission must be in accordance with the agreement between the connection subscriber and the service provider).
The concept of theft is binary: Is it yours to use by payment of the service fees or permission of the payer, yes or no? If yes, there is no theft. If no, theft has occurred. Please consider this:
Does someone performing unauthorized heavy downloads on another?s connection deprive the connection owner of bandwidth and other benefits of the connection?
Yes. Someone else is getting the value of the owner?s connection and depriving the paying subscriber of the value for which they pay. The outside user meets neither of the conditions for just use.
Now consider this: The subscriber has a maximum of one hundred concurrent connections to the Wi-Fi service. That person has one hundred family members and friends needing to use the Wi-Fi connection under the owner?s permission and in accordance with the user?s agreement. However, a neighbor is using one of the concurrent connections illegitimately, and one person with a just right to use it now cannot connect. Is this theft?
Yes. The rightful owner has lost something (a needed connection) because the neighbor has appropriated that resource and denied its use to the rightful owner. Again, neither condition for rightful use is met.
What about this scenario: The subscriber has a maximum of one hundred concurrent connections to the Wi-Fi service. There are three people that need to connect, leaving ninety seven unused concurrent connections. The neighbor is using one of the concurrent connections illegitimately, but everyone with a just right to use it now can still connect.
Has the neighbor met either of the conditions for just use? Has he paid for it himself? Does he have permission to use it?
?But it?s only 1 % of the owner?s capacity, there is no great loss? some people will say. While it may not great loss, it is a loss nonetheless.
This issue does not need the toil of a board of ethicists to determine what is right and wrong. Maybe we all should re-read "ALL I REALLY NEED TO KNOW I LEARNED IN KINDERGARTEN" by Robert Fulghum. See his web site at http://www.robertfulghum.com/
by jdclyde
to see if any cases stick when not accompanied by illegal behavior.
Also, in the one example it is state and not federal handling on this, which means things could be different from state to state.
[b]
The Canadian link was a few years old. does anyone know if the theft of bandwidth charges stuck? Should be a matter of public records, right?
by hjleevta
Of course, it will vary by state - many areas of the law do. California and Oregon law both have specific provisions with small fines that do not require harm, loss, damage - whatever you wish to call it. The simple fact of accessing a network without authorization is enough.
I am unaware of anyone being charged or convicted of wireless network access without more serious crimes, but that makes sense. What DA wants to spend staff time on $250 petty fines?
There has been at least one conviction involving direct access that has been upheld at the appellete level (higher court refused to hear) and that crime did not result in any damage - only access. Public computer - private or off limits UNIX operating system.
I'll bet you'll see civil actions by private parties in states with laws such as California. There are enough nuts around to take you to small claims for the $250.
by jneumann
by zig zag
by unclerob
You know what they say about opinions (even legal ones), they're like a-holes, everyone has one.
And if they could fly, this place would be airport!
- 'nuff said on that one.
My point was actually to take into account the other side of the argument even though I'm of the opinion that you shouldn't steal, temporarily burrow, freeload, piggyback or whatever term you want to use when surfin' the net on someone else's dime.
Technically speaking I would say that those waves are trespassing on to his property and he is right about that, whether or not he could legally back that up is another thing entirely but he is right, those waves are floatin' about his area and are eminating from his neighbor's place.
If you're neighbor was shining a strong flashlight into your house from his place and that strong beam of light was coming through one of your windows on a constant basis and annoying you, I'm sure you could get someone (the police) to come over and have the neighbor turn off that flashlight.
Although not too likely, if enough people of the same opinion as this fellow got together, I'm sure they could raise some type of legal stink about this too.
And I hope I'm not right about my bit about radio waves causing some sort of condition or disease, the $hit will really hit the fan if that were ever to become true.
On a side note, this has got to be one of the liveliest TR discussions I've ever taken part in, I'm impressed, it still has some steam left in it to continue for quite some time. This is definitely a hot topic (about a "hot" spot).
.... cheers (& Merry Christmas)
by absolutely
by tadcook
The big change came with the Electronic Communications Privacy Act. Before that, since cordless phones were FCC Part 15 devices, the user had no reasonable expectation of privacy. Ignoring the laws of physics, Congress made listening in to cordless phones illegal just like listening to cellphones. Most of us radio hobbyists at the time felt that if a device wasn't encrypted, it should be legal to listen.
Something about Part 15 that hasn't been mentioned in this thread....users of Part 15 devices are by default expected to tolerate any interference, while at the same time they may not interfere with *licensed* services. It turns out that about 40% (I think?) of the 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi band is shared with both Amateur Radio and the military. I've never seen this done, but if I want to operate on 2.4 GHz at whatever power the ham license allows at that frequency, I can do it, and demand that all interfering Part 15 devices in my neighborhood be turned off.
I borrow unprotected access points all the time. Here in Seattle, if I am driving around with my laptop and need to access the net, the easiest way is to drive up to just about any apartment building, and fire up Netstumbler looking for unprotected access. It is getting more difficult though, as more people have become aware of the risks.
When I first got a wireless laptop over a year and a half ago, I went up on my 2nd floor balcony and turned on Netstumbler, and here in the University District I could see 28 devices, mostly unprotected, including several wifi cafes.
At home I use a LinkSys router with SSID turned off, WPA instead of WEP encryption, MAC address filtering so even on the wired side of my LAN, it looks for the address of the machine attempting connection. I also have the router sitting in my basement, since I only use the wireless around the house. This keeps the RF cloud more confined to my property.
73, K7RA (another ham)
by tadcook
I knew I forgot something....
You know what is illegal with WiFi, and nobody talks about? Attaching external antennas. That is because when a device that intentionally radiates is certified for Part 15, it is certified only for the antenna that is on the device. So when you remove the antennas that came with your router and hook it to that pringles can, that is a violation. However, there is no such FCC rule that I can find that precludes you from connecting to an unprotected router.
by garyhussar
Documented means nothing. Precedence will be set when the first successful conviction takes place, then the writing will follow.
Don't look for loopholes. Do the right thing.
by techrepublic
No, I don't think so. In the first case you are modifying the cable
company's equipment. Stealing Satellite is using illegal
equipment to decode. In the case or hopping onto someone's
open wireless network, you are not modifying their system or
equipment and you are not using any illegal equipment or
software.
For a business, this is all moot, because any IT worth his salt is
going to protect the network.
BTW, many of the new routers have upgradable firmware which
can be replaced with custom versions. Many of these allow
simultaneous protected (WAP enterprise) and unprotected
connections. Here is one company:
http://www.sveasoft.com/
You could also put an unprotected wireless router on its own
subnet for clients.
by erich1010
The Jaguar analogy is bad because if I use the Jag, you can't at the same time. Even the garage example is bad because there is wear and tear on the tools and associated risk of damage to the property. The back yard example is bad because there is an actual trespassing issue. Though, that becomes less so for the front yard. Someone should reasonably expect to be able to walk up to my house without violating trespassing laws.
So, let's remove that stuff from the analogy and see if we can make it better. Let's take the garage example. If a garage door is closed. There is no issue. Going into the garage is illegal. What if the garage door is open. Perhaps it is raining, and I duck into someone's open garage for a second until the rain lightens, then continue on my way. As long as I don't touch anything in the garage, would that really be an unethical thing to do? I'm not sure if it would even be illegal, since the door was open. The only thing used in that case would be the roof, to keep the rain off. Was the roof used up any more by my use than if I wasn't there? No. Obviously, I've also temporarily used some space in the garage, but not enough to inconvenience the owner. (Another reason the RV in the driveway is a bad example) And if the owner noticed me there and told me to leave, I would have to leave, obviously. Staying overnight in the open garage every day would also be a different issue.
I see the wireless as similar. If I use someone's bandwidth because of a temporary need, and don't damage their system at all, then I don't see that as an ethical problem. It would be on par with ducking out of the rain or using someone's driveway to turn my car around. There are even businesses who intentionally leave wireless open to attract customers. This would similarly be analogous to extending their lobby. Many even advertise their products on a splash page before granting access.
Personally, I leave my wireless open. I don't mind the occasional user. If I notice my bandwidth slowing down because of too much outside use, I might lock it down or at least prioritize traffic. So far, it's not been an issue. I'm also considering a firewall to separate my wired computers from my wireless. But even that's not a major concern of mine because of location, and I have enough security built into my computers that I would most likely detect and block any maliciousness.
Eric
1. if you don't want to share your wifi AP don't it is simple to lock it down (though bad guys can still break in with time and work)
2. if you have a knowledge deficit you can find a simple set of instructions to tell you how to lock it down
3. if you don't care to do this simple thing then it is on YOUR head
4. if you don't know how to drive a car and you crash into someone it is still YOUR fault
take some personal responsibility and be graceful to others a few megs of downloads isn't going to kill anyone even if you used ALL of the bandwidth what is that worth... less then 2 dollars a day barely the level of petty theft for crips sake you are going to spend thousands to try and if convicted it will cost dozens of times the value of the product per day of incarceration give me a freekin break
by absolutely
But I do own my WiFi equipment, and deliberate use of my property without my permission is illegal in every case, including and not limited to my WiFi router. No new laws are necessary to establish that surreptitiously using a WiFi signal belonging to another person for their own private use is theft, only analysis of Internet Protocol as used by any router.
The use of another person's wireless connection is unlike the use of another Amateur Radio operator's frequency, in at least one way that understates the importance of stealing a wireless Internet connection. Every Internet "download" (or upload) involves some information transmitted both directions. The Internet does not "broadcast" every frequency like radio, and loading a web page is not a passive act of reception like tuning in a radio receiver to the frequency that is broadcasting what you want to hear. Instead, we send comparatively small packets requesting information from a specific Internet address, which is transmitted specifically to our own Internet address. Before the request, that information is just stored on a server, not being transmitted to [b]anybody[/b]. (To be exact, it is transmitted to every computer that sent a request for it, but [b]only[/b] on request.) In the case of a wireless connection, the requesting Internet Protocol address belongs to the wireless router, which must assign a local address (which won't be available at the destination site that sends the webpage to the wireless Internet thief) to each of its clients. Borrowing another person's wireless connection is an act of impersonation that requires use of the WiFi router's owner's address to receive your mail or other information you request via the Internet.
Amateur Radio experiences do not apply to
wireless Internet (without extensive modification) because of the lack of any information stored or processed on an amateur radio which somebody else might want to use to impersonate or defraud the user, and because reception of a radio wave can be anonymous with respect to the transmitter, but Internet traffic cannot. When somebody uses "your" Amateur Radio signal, you simply claim a new one, and the availability of such signal bandwidth was fundamental to the validity of the premises of Amateur Radio laws when those were developed [b]for that technology[/b]. The difference in technology requires premises that respect the rights of the owners of [b]equipment[/b], not of radio waves.
by mwatch
If you don't think it is illegal in FL you must think bandwidth is not property.
"(b) If the offense is committed for the purposes of devising or executing any
scheme or artifice to defraud or to obtain any property, then the offender is
guilty of a felony of the second degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082,
s. 775.083, or s. 775.084."
I'll guarantee the ISP thinks bandwidth is property, also bet that they would love to see wardrivers charged with a felony second degree. Do you want to be in front of the judge arguing that you didn't know it was property and by the way it wasn't locked up!
If I were your lawyer i'd be willing to argue that the legislature didn't intend the law to apply to wardrivers. It might be an interesting argument with the prosecutor and judge, kinda fun yah know. But then again I'll know for sure I'm going home that night.
A solid ETHICAL stance will protect you from misinterpretations of the law.
by csr-tech
It doesn't matter what you or I "think" is property. Also doesn't matter what the ISP "thinks" is property. What matters is what he state of Florida has defined as property:
"Property" means anything of value as defined in s. 812.011 [FN1PP] and includes, but is not limited to, financial instruments, information, including electronically produced data and computer software and programs in either machine-readable or human-readable form, and any other tangible or intangible item of value.
There is no definition for "Bandwidth" in this statue, but there are definitions for "access" and "computer network". There are also penalties for anyone who:
"Disrupts or denies or causes the denial of computer system services to an authorized user of such computer system services, which, in whole or part, is owned by, under contract to, or operated for, on behalf of, or in conjunction with another."
So that ought to help make it clear as mud.
by absolutely
by mvmughal
by mwatch
So you don't make the distinction, like many others, that "Open" is the key? Password protected/encrypted means stay out? Unprotected means free access?
You seem to be arguing that location is the only limit too use. That argument would allow you to do anything under the sun to break into a protected signal and use it in any way regardless of the impact on the WAP owner or ISP.
Does this apply to the interior of you car? Maybe what ever happens to bump into the antenna of your laptop as you walk in front of your neighbors PROPERTY?
The notion that bandwidth is not property is plain silly. How much a month are you paying for your connection?
by mwatch
"Property" means anything of value as defined in s. 812.011 [FN1PP] and includes, but is not limited to, financial instruments, information, including electronically produced data and computer software and programs in either machine-readable or human-readable form, and any other tangible or intangible item of value.
Focus on "and any other tangible or intangible item of value".
Connections to the internet have value. A wide range of value slow=cheap faster=more.
Bandwidth is property, at least in FL, if you are citing FL law.
by barghesthowl
-While copyright law is a different subject for a different topic, I can and have explained to my 5-year-old the significant differences between copying and theft. It's not all that hard-"If I grab your apple out of your hand, you got nothing to eat, if I copy something, you've still got yours." It would be a lot harder to explain why some -do- consider copying theft! I'm trying here...
"Well, there's this thing called a "corporation". Yeah we'll get to that later, it's just a big business. And even though you're not taking anything away from anyone when you copy something, some people think that doing nearly anything without giving some of your money to these corporations is by default stealing from them. Nope, I don't believe it either."
As to the ISP's agreements-I can hardly understand those, and I'm relatively fluent in legalese. Once the ISP's start writing these agreements in terms that a 50-year-old, let alone 5-year-old, can understand, someone might care what they say. In the meantime, if they have a problem with it, they'll complain at me, and they'll then lose my business when I move to another provider if they're complaining over a minor issue.
Most people violate their ISP's terms of use all the time. Use PCAnywhere or its like? An SSH/FTP daemon for remote access? Running a server, against terms of use. Of course, that -isn't- what this is intended to prohibit, it's intended to prevent people running a high-traffic website or anything to that effect. That's why ISP's (wisely) do not complain about every minor infraction. So basically-if they don't and can't notice what you're doing, you sure must not be having a very detrimental effect on their network.
Another example-it was against Comcast's terms of service to connect more then one system to the network unless they set up the network! However, every time the connection needed to be serviced, the first question was "Do you use a router?" I always told them yes, and answered that my and my wife's machine were hooked up when they asked. They never said a word.
As to the religious arguments presented here? While I'm effectively atheist myself, I've always found myself liking the rather simpler Wiccan creed-"If it harm none, do what you will." Who does utilizing a non-scarce, currently unused resource harm?
by barghesthowl
This is an important concept, and it seems so many miss it.
If you're in my house without authorization, you are committing a physical trespass. You might be stealing something, you might be intending harm to me.
On the other hand, if you're on my unsecured wireless, you're doing something more like tuning into a radio station or CB conversation. The waves are right there in the air, available to anyone who cares to tune in, without committing any physical trespass at all.
If you want the conversation to be private, use an encrypted channel. If you want your wireless access to be private, use the security features included with the router. If you're too damn lazy to read the manual included with your router (or CB) and figure out what it does and how to make it do what you want, don't blame the person who tunes in.
Now, that being said-deliberately cracking a password to get in IS stepping over a clear "No Trespassing" sign. That's a different story.
by barghesthowl
Electricity is billed based on use. If you hook up to your neighbor's electric, you are going to drive up their bill.
Every ISP plan I've seen is billed based on a flat per-month rate. Use a little, use a lot, get the same bill at the end of the month. -IF- your neighbor's bill is not so, and is billed per (mega|giga)byte instead, your analogy is correct. But this doesn't happen.
If you are using such a large amount of bandwidth that your neighbor's connection performs badly, then you are taking away his right to enjoy the service he is paying for.
If all you're doing is web surfing and email, though, you're using very little. Your neighbor's performance does not suffer for it, his bill does not go up because of it.
The fireworks analogy presented a moment ago is the correct one. Yes, your neighbor paid for the fireworks, yes, you're enjoying them without paying. However, you are NOT detracting from your neighbor's enjoyment of what he paid for, and THAT is why it isn't wrong.
by barghesthowl
I can very well claim that making copies of something is not unethical, despite being illegal. On the other hand, slavery was an unethical practice, despite the fact that for quite some time it was perfectly legal.
The law (ideally, although not always realistically) should reflect ethics, it doesn't work the other way around.
by webwolf
by placidair
by placidair
Sort by Trending