Wardriving - Legal or not?
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by unclerob
but DUH?! thanks for calling us stupid anyways.
Although I love a good "lanning" (did you coin that term yourself), it's not the same as going over to your friends house.
Although the topic is actually WARDRIVING which would mean driving about (or travelling using some other means) and looking for an open hot spot and whether or not this practice is legal.
Here's the deal, if I were in my own home and my pc's wireless nic picked up on an unsecured access point that I could connect to and surf the net - then technically I haven't left my home and I have travelled to my friend's house & "Lanned" with him. The signals reached into my home and my computer was able to make use of them.
Some won't agree (hence this forum for discussion) but technically aren't the signals trespassing into your home from someone else's residence. I didn't go out my home and into someone else's home to steal them, they came to me.
Here's another technicality, computer networks are all technically permissions based. I can't access any network unless my pc is provided access to that network, either via login credentials (userid/password/domain or workgroup name) or via an open unsecured network that allows outside network access.
Plus I recently read a blurb that says that local government considers any unsecured wireless/radio signals that are accessible in a public place to be considered public signals and therefore you can't really call it trespassing.
Let's get even more technical, I'm sure there's a small miniscule clause in the ISP agreement that says you have to secure the internet connection that your purchasing from your ISP against any outside access which could possibly violate the user/ISP agreement. Technically the user with the unsecured wireless access point would be held accountable by his ISP for not having secured his internet connection because he's allowing others to use this service without paying for it.
Now that you've heard me rant a little bit,
you know it's not as simple as "DUH!" as you put it. That's smacks a little of being a derogative & insensitive type statement.
Here's my take.
Wardriving is probably legal since there aren't any concrete laws that forbid it's practice currently. Just because it's legal doesn't make it nice or ethical. But just because it's technically legal doesn't make it a good thing either. More like freeloading.
It's pretty hard to come up with an answer on something that's intangible like a wireless signal. If you attach the value of property ownership & $value to these signals, you also have to look at the otherside of the equation, if your property is invading someone else's home, shouldn't you be held accountable for allowing this signal to trespass someone's home because techically that's what it is - what if your signals cause interference with devices in that person's home (cordless phones, radios, satellites, microwaves, etc.) or maybe your signals futz up this person's existing wireless home network setup. Don't think it's a far stretch, read the owner's manuals for these devices and you'll find that the possibility of interference with other devices is an actual concern by the manufacturer themselves.
In the end you should be held liable for securing that signal so that it isn't made available for others to use if you intend for it to be private.
In conclusion,
DUH! - it's not that simple.
.... just my 0.02 cents cdn.
by chris029
by tadcook
When I am at home, my wireless laptop is configured so that it will only connect to my own router. I also have the router set up with WPA encryption, and MAC address filtering, so that only I can connect to it, and transmissions are encrypted. But when I go out and use wireless in public at a coffeehouse, I change the TCP/IP properties to allow assignment of my ip address via DHCP, and essentially open it up so I can connect to the outside world.
My neighborhood seems to have a lot of wireless routers, some of them obviously unconfigured. Often I will fire up the laptop at home without first reconfiguring TCP/IP properties, and I cannot count the number of times I've discovered later that I was accidentally hooked to someone else's LAN.
Is this illegal? I think not. Even if I do it intentionally. I say this because Wi-Fi devices are covered by Part 15 in the FCC rules.
Several important principles concerning Part 15:
1. Users have no reasonable expectation of privacy (unless they take extra steps to encrypt, of course).
2. Users must accept any interference from other users.
3. Unlicensed users operating under Part 15 may not cause interference to licensed users.
Who are licensed users on a license-free portion of the spectrum? Unlicensed users share about 40% of the channels with users licensed in the Amateur Radio Service. I am a ham, a licensed user. I have a legal right to operate there within the rules (which permit me to run literally thousands of times the power as Part 15 users) and to require that unlicensed users refrain from interfering with me.
Some parts of the VHF amateur radio spectrum are devoted to repeater stations. These are boxes sitting in a high place that relay signals from users over a wide area. Repeater owners have no exclusive use of the spectrum, but just like owners of Wi-Fi devices, they have methods to control access, similar to the encryption that unlicensed Wi-Fi users employ. If they don't use these methods, the repeater is "open" to use by other licensees, just as the unprotected Wi-Fi access point is open to other users. Most of them are open.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned in this discussion that is quite common on the 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi spectrum and is most definately illegal is the use of external antennas. Why? Because in order to meet type-acceptance requirements for Part 15 devices, they have to transmit below a certain signal strength, and they are type accepted only for the radiator (antenna) that they employ. Notice I said signal strength, independent of transmitter power. So it is not legal to attach your unlicensed router to your Pringles can antenna, even if your transmit power is below 100 mw.
So here is my take on all this:
-As a licensed user, I can use external gain antennas and run at power levels many, many times the power level that unlicensed users may operate.
-As a licensed user, I can require any unlicensed user to vacate the channel if it is interfering with my use.
-Just as a radio repeater owner who keeps his system open must expect that others may use his repeater, users of open wireless routers routers are in the same position.
But what about the ISP, you say? That is between the owner of the open router and his ISP. I have not contracted with his ISP. I have no business relationship with the ISP.
The unconfigured unprotected router is the result of the owner's actions, and the ISP can require the owner to protect access, or not. The unprotected router is free for my use, as long as I don't use it for anything illegal.
But anything I do illegally is independent of whether it goes through an unprotected router or not. There are no special laws needed to protect anyone, because malicious hacking into the open router owner's machine is illegal all by itself, just as vandalizing the open radio repeater is illegal.
So I don't lose any sleep at all over the fact that when I am driving around Seattle and need to check my Gmail account (which is handy for public Wi-Fi, because it uses SSL), I can always pull over near any apartment building and find all the free access I want, just as I can do inside or outside any King County Library or numerous coffeehouses or the open Wi-Fi access provided by the city along University Way.
73,
K7RA
by sconlin
This link is to the Michigan Legislature. The MCL, (Michgan Compiled Laws), is 750.219a. Please read it in its entirety, especially the last third. Might give some insight to the Michigan Law about connecting to a network without permission.
http://www.legislature.mi.gov/mileg.asp?page=getObject&objName=mcl-750-219a
Steve.
by lbelle
by beilstwh
by dominic_2002
by tadcook
I'm afraid you have been misinformed. I can transmit to their unsecured access point all I want.
When I am at home, my wireless laptop is configured so that it will only connect to my own router. I also have the router set up with WPA encryption, and MAC address filtering, so that only I can connect to it, and transmissions are encrypted. But when I go out and use wireless in public at a coffeehouse, I change the TCP/IP properties to allow assignment of my ip address via DHCP, and essentially open it up so I can connect to the outside world.
My neighborhood seems to have a lot of wireless routers, some of them obviously unconfigured. Often I will fire up the laptop at home without first reconfiguring TCP/IP properties, and I cannot count the number of times I've discovered later that I was accidentally hooked to someone else's LAN.
Is this illegal? I think not. Even if I do it intentionally. I say this because Wi-Fi devices are covered by Part 15 in the FCC rules.
Several important principles concerning Part 15:
1. Users have no reasonable expectation of privacy (unless they take extra steps to encrypt, of course).
2. Users must accept any interference from other users.
3. Unlicensed users operating under Part 15 may not cause interference to licensed users.
Who are licensed users on a license-free portion of the spectrum? Unlicensed users share about 40% of the channels with users licensed in the Amateur Radio Service. I am a ham, a licensed user. I have a legal right to operate there within the rules (which permit me to run literally thousands of times the power as Part 15 users) and to require that unlicensed users refrain from interfering with me.
Some parts of the VHF amateur radio spectrum are devoted to repeater stations. These are boxes sitting in a high place that relay signals from users over a wide area. Repeater owners have no exclusive use of the spectrum, but just like owners of Wi-Fi devices, they have methods to control access, similar to the encryption that unlicensed Wi-Fi users employ. If they don't use these methods, the repeater is "open" to use by other licensees, just as the unprotected Wi-Fi access point is open to other users. Most of them are open.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned in this discussion that is quite common on the 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi spectrum and is most definately illegal is the use of external antennas. Why? Because in order to meet type-acceptance requirements for Part 15 devices, they have to transmit below a certain signal strength, and they are type accepted only for the radiator (antenna) that they employ. Notice I said signal strength, independent of transmitter power. So it is not legal to attach your unlicensed router to your Pringles can antenna, even if your transmit power is below 100 mw.
So here is my take on all this:
-As a licensed user, I can use external gain antennas and run at power levels many, many times the power level that unlicensed users may operate.
-As a licensed user, I can require any unlicensed user to vacate the channel if it is interfering with my use.
-Just as a radio repeater owner who keeps his system open must expect that others may use his repeater, users of open wireless routers routers are in the same position.
But what about the ISP, you say? That is between the owner of the open router and his ISP. I have not contracted with his ISP. I have no business relationship with the ISP.
The unconfigured unprotected router is the result of the owner's actions, and the ISP can require the owner to protect access, or not. The unprotected router is free for my use, as long as I don't use it for anything illegal.
But anything I do illegally is independent of whether it goes through an unprotected router or not. There are no special laws needed to protect anyone, because malicious hacking into the open router owner's machine is illegal all by itself, just as vandalizing the open radio repeater is illegal.
So I don't lose any sleep at all over the fact that when I am driving around Seattle and need to check my Gmail account (which is handy for public Wi-Fi, because it uses SSL), I can always pull over near any apartment building and find all the free access I want, just as I can do inside or outside any King County Library or numerous coffeehouses or the open Wi-Fi access provided by the city along University Way.
73,
K7RA
by jonathanpdx
So what if it was YOUR $100 and you needed it to buy food for your children? What if, instead of a hole in your pocket, it fell out when you removed your keys (or some other analogy - take your pick.) Would you be so smug about it then? I think not. It's always just "too bad" when it happens to someone else, but a major event when it affects us personally.
Just because everyone else is doing something wrong doesn't make it right.
And why refer to others who aren't as "fortunate" as you as "idiots"? Is that how you refer to others who aren't as "smart" or "clever" as you? Or who lose while you gain from their mistakes? If that's how you do business, I'm not sure I'd feel safe having you around any business with which I was associated.
As IT "Professionals," it is incumbent upon US to make sure we teach others to guard their resources and avoid making such mistakes.
by webwolf
by jamesrl
It has been proven to me over and over that some people well stretch ethical limits unless and until there is a law that clearly defines what is legal and what is not.
Until you have a law, some people will assume they have the moral right to do it.
James
by mwatch
I'm not quite sure how you could read all of the other posts and come to the conclusion it is legal?
At best there is a mish mash of different statutes depending on where you are. NONE have found a statute that would imply that if you are nice about it and only do it a little bit then wardriving is ok.
Yes compared to other injustices that pervade the world this is not a huge issue when done in a benign fashion.
You cannot dicard an ethical stance simply because it is smaller than other world issues. If you do you open the door to those that would want to judge the size of the apple bin before giving a green light to stealing one apple.
I completely disagree with the comment that ethics are tricky.
When a solid ethical stance is used, ethics are not at all tricky.
Try - It's not yours don't touch. Very simple and will serve you well all over the world in all sorts of situations.
The more complicated your ethical stance is the lower the probability is it will hold water over time. IE wardriving is ok if you only do it a little bit and don't have to hack a password and don't download porn and only do it from your own house using that nasty trespassing signal and the whole question is not very important in light of all the other garbage going on in the world?
by ittbowser
Ok, ethical, unethical, lawful or unlawful, there are going to be people that can argue for all sides.
All the analogies saying, ?if some one comes into ...? not the same that is physical trespass. While using the WiFi would not be physical trespass. There are laws that state trespassing (enter dictionary / court definition for trespassing) is illegal.
In one of the post above it was outlined how wardriving could be both lawful or unlawful depending on how the lawyers pleaded the case.
As for the "we should not take advantage of non tech savvy people...", ignorance is not an excuse! If you have a pool in your back yard, and a 5 year old falls in and drowns because you did not have a fence around it you are to blame. Even if you put up "No Trespassing" signs. "But" is not an excuse. Period. If your speeding down the road because you did not see the speed limit sigh that was smashed down and you get pulled over, you were still speeding. Therefore, if you are going to have a piece of equipment, whether it be a car, WiFi, or a pool, you need to know how to properly use it. Period!
Does that mean that if you find an open WiFi you should exploit it. NO! now that is malicious and as stated in the above law post that would be illegal.
jdclyde, I don't know why, if you have your own network, you would need to wardrive, but as for if it is ethical or unethical, I don't think you will get a definitive answer. But as to whether it is legal or illegal, that depends on how good your lawyer is!
Just my $ 0.02
(but hey what do I know? )
ITTBowser
by jimteach
You physically may not be entering their property but your packets are physically entering their physical router over their physical cannection.
Others have also said you are not stealing something, however you are stealing something, bandwidth and time. If you are downloading, uploading, etc. a page, a file, etc, and I want to use my bandwidth then you are using my bandwidth and wasting (stealing) my time. If I am a consultant making $300.00 an hour and it takes me a minute longer to do my job then you have just cost me $5.00. Or I am trying to do a purchase at a special price for a specific time, or I am trying to do a stock buy or sell and it takes longer than it should because you are using the line and I lose the sale, or it costs more to buy the stock or I don't get the best price, you have just stolen from me.
The consequence of you using the bandwidth which I paid for may cause me harm, then it is illegal. You are also responsible to pay damages.
Suppose I have a program running on my router that changes data in your packets, am I actually changing the data since you are not "physically not using my property"? Could you sue me for damages? What happens if you are doing your banking and I take your login ID and password and take money from your account, am I stealing? The logic others are using is if it is sent over the public airways it is open for anyone to use and since it came over the public airways to my private router to send your data can I claim it as a gift and use it as I see fit? (Like receiving an activated credit card in the mail. It is a gift that you can use.)
We talk about laws or the lack of a law to cover this. How minutia do the laws have to get before common sense takes over?
by unclerob
I'm not physically entering your property anymore than you are physically entering my property with your wireless signals. If you're not willing to entertain that you are trespassing when you broadcast your unsecured wireless signals on to my property with a signal strength strong enough to be detected by my computer's wireless nic and announce the presence of your wap to my computer equipment then I won't entertain that I am physically trespassing on to your property when I hitch the return ride back to your wireless access point and use your signal to surf the net. Some amount of responsibility needs to rest on the owner of the unsecured access point.
Now let's talk about your online banking scenario. In your example, if I'm using your wireless access point to surf the net and I'm doing my pc banking and you take/discover my login credentials for my online banking site and use them to take money from my account, you are stealing. Why? Well in your scenario it sounds like you've left your access point unsecured intentionally for the purpose of entrapment and running a program on your router to change the packets that I'm transmitting over so that you can change them & decipher them sounds a little devious, the term hacking comes to mind at this point.
The bank would probably not cover my losses because I was using an unsecured wireless internet connection to facilitate my pc banking. However the bank would probably have a few words with you (in court) because they tend to make a big deal of people who commit any type of theft from them & their systems. They have the money (pardon the pun) and the legal resources to make mince meat of anybody specifically those that would illegally use someone else's bank account.
Plus I don't think any credit cards are sent in the mail already activated, credit card companies require that you activate the cards from the home phone number on the original application. I don't think you'll be receiving any such gifts in the mail anytime soon.
I don't condone wardriving and I personally wouldn't surf the net on someone else's unsecured wireless access point - that's just me, I'm made that way but not everyone is and you shouldn't expect everyone to be that way either. Human nature dictates that alot of people will take advantage of other people. Unless there is a law that says that wardriving or surfing the net on someone else's unsecured wireless signals is illegal, people will continue to do it. It's not ethical, nice or the right thing to do, but alot of other things fall into that jurisdiction as well and continue to go on without too much stopping them.
just my 0.02 cents cdn,feel free to agree or disagree.
by liquidxit2
by tonythetiger
by daveo2000
Without getting into the argument about the car, we can use the analogy of the roads that cars use. There are public roads and there are toll roads. While many folks may not be familiar with the concept of free internet access, in NYC (and other places, I have no doubt) there are places called "Hot Spots" where WiFi is available for free. You don't have to ask anybody for permission, you don't have to buy an access card, you just hook up and go. You are still responsible not to break into anyone else's computer whilst using this network but you are free to roam (so to speak).
So here is an interesting question: If your neighbor is operating a wireless router near a fully legal hot-spot and it looks, to connecting computers, just to be another hot-spot, who is at fault if a user connects? And what is the difference if the router owner operates this away from a legal hot-spot? It could be argued that the person operating the wireless router is responsible for locking down their system if the ISP stipulates that they do so to prevent accidental (or otherwise) access.
The whole music copying debate has so overly clouded what is, in fact, legal and what is not that people jump at the chance to call something illegal.
For those who have forgotten, to be guilty of breaking a law there must be motive, opportunity and intent (according to what I learned in my U.S. university). Then, once those are established you introduce the "reasonable person" evaluation of the facts. (Of course we could bring up Bush's "minority report" style methodologies to ask how much we, as a country, still support this premise...)
And, no, I am not trolling.
by beilstwh
"For those who have forgotten, to be guilty of breaking a law there must be motive, opportunity and intent "
Motive - Not having to pay for a service that someone else pays for and you are too cheap to pay the toll.
Opportunity - Some poor smuck sets up a AP for his use and a bunch of free loaders jump on the service.
INTENT - You intend to steal the service that you NEVER paid for.
I guess it's a crime.
by daveo2000
It isn't always that simple.
A group in my area put up a Hot-Spot in a park. They only advertise it inside the park. Does that mean that somebody that doesn't go in the park but connects in their house next to the park is stealing the service?
If I am accustomed to using hot-spots to connect and find that there is a new one in my area that wasn't advertised am I wrong for using it?
There is a very real argument that the provider of connectivity make sure that they are not violating any agreements.
by unclerob
If you own a wireless access point and don't enable wep or any other form of security to keep unwanted users out aren't you partially to blame in this scenario.
Here's my deal, I agree that it's not nice to war drive and freeload off of someone else's wireless connection. I don't think there are any concrete laws out there prohibiting this outright but legality aside, it's not ethical, nice or neighborly (if you're not wardriving and just piggybacking on your neighbor's wireless signals).
However, everyone (well alot of people in this discussion at any rate) is associating the value of physical property & ownership to the intangible wireless signals coming from the owner of the unsecured access point. If you grant that argument, you should view the flipside as well. If my neighbor's unsecured wireless access point is transmitting these signals and the signal strength is strong enough that it reaches my house and can enable my wireless nic to recognize the unsecured access point and offer for me to connect, aren't these signals in my area, on my property? Could it not be deemed that I can make use of these signals since they are travelling on to my property. People will argue that to make use of this signal means you are transmitting back to the access point and then trespassing on to his property & unlawfully using his equipment & internet connection. The original trespass wasn't made by you since it's the neighbor's wap which is the originator of the wireless signals so you can't complain if signals ride back to the wap and make use of the equipment and enable internet access.
Technically I would bet that the ISP that this person uses with his wireless equipment would take legal action against him instead of the wardriver in question. You enter into agreement with the ISP and a certain amount of responsibility rests with you to make sure that your connection isn't used/shared by others. That's why alot of ISP's won't offer support to a user who is trying to install a router in his home so that he can share his internet access to other pc's in the home. ISP's make money off off of each single user, they aren't making any more money if you split the connection between other user's in your home.
What if these uncontrolled, unsecured wireless signals from my neighbor's wap start interfering with other devices in my home (ie. cordless phone, radio, microwave, wireless nic, wireless access point, etc.) - it's not that far a stretch since the the manufacturer's of these access points indicate the possibility of these problems with the documentation that accompanies this equipment.
I think the responsibility should not just rest on the shoulders of those users that find an open unsecured access point and attempt to use it. Responsibility should also rest firmly on the shoulders of the owners of this equipment.
I personally wouldn't hitch a ride on someone else's unsecured wireless access point (I'd probably even offer to help secure an open access point) but that's just me - I'm neighborly that way but being a good neighbor isn't a requirement or the law, it's just a nice thing to do and not everyone is nice. So in the end people should secure their equipment and their property, if they don't, they shouldn't be that angry if someone takes advantage of their resources.
A sad fact of human nature is that some people will take advantage of other people and feel no remorse or shame in doing so either. Instead of complaining about other people wardriving (when technically there is no law against it that I know of) and freeloading off someone's wireless internet access, just do what you can to secure your equipment and if you can, help your neighbor secure his equipment if the need arises. We should probably lobby the manufacturer's of this equipment so that they do more to help the end consumer enable security on this equipment so that it becomes a non-issue as well. That's technically all that can be done unless a concrete wardriving law is enacted that makes this activity illegal and attaches suitable punishment as a deterrent against this type of activity.
This discussion still has quite a bit of steam left in it, I look forward to seeing more viewpoints on this issue. If wardriving isn't illegal, then it's technically legal (depending on your location and the local laws in place). I don't think jdclyde was asking for viewpoints on ethics and why people should do the right thing but he definitely got an earful from this forum.
just my 0.02 cents cdn....
by beilstwh
by rem
by csr-tech
First a few related points. (a) Rules of evidence for criminal law are more stringent than those for civil law. (b) Often things covered under criminal laws are also covered under civil laws. NB Be wary when confusing the above issues.
In most jurisdictions this matter is covered under both criminal and civil law as the unauthorised use of an item or service - in some countries it is also an offence under the communications laws as unathorised use.
In most cases theft requires the proof that the person took the item or service with the intent of not returning it or allowing the owner to have it back. unathorised use just requires evidence that you did use the item or service and a statement from the owner that they did not authorise its use by you at that time. This is unathorised use not theft - usually a misdemeanour not a felony.
regarding the Hot Spot confusion issue - the few hot spots that i have used have had a welcome page explaining that it is a free service and telling you who sponsors it, This comes up when you first connect to it - the two that I asked about this explained that it is both good advertising and was required by law. Thus when you connect if you do not get a hot spot welcome page it is clear it is not a hot spot. I do not know if this is law in every jurisdiction but it makes damn good advertising sense and very likely to be a similar welcome on connection at each. In either case it is the repsonsibility of the person charged with unlawful or unathorised use to prove that they did have authority to use it, failure to check and be sure of the connection makes you culpable.
by wojnar
If you agree that bandwidth is what you pay an ISP for, and that the usefulness of that bandwith is non-existant without a device which you need to have in place between you and its source, and when you connect to the vistim's router and transmit to their ISP that fraction of bandwidth holding your packet is not available for the rightful purchaser - then you have taken something that has a quantitative value without paying for it. Thats called STEALING.
STEALING IS NOT LEGAL in any state. Just as stealing water from a tap is illegal because what you are paying for is not the water but the processing, cleaning and delivery of the water. I don't know of anybody (except some CA folks who have oxygen bars in their neighborhood or people under physicians care) that PAY for air. Again, if you pay to have air delivered in a little tank and somebody takes that tank - its STEALING. If somebody takes something you don't own from your house, its not stealing. So I am sure my mom would have touched the air in your house since you don't own it. Too many people like to blame others for 'not securing their connections' instead of admitting that they stole something. What ever happened to personal integrity ??????
Can I then understand, based on your stated position, that if the connection is secured and you happen to figure out the needed codes it is not stealing since the owner of the router didn't make the passwords/encryption key hard enough ?
BTW it is also ilegal to place a firearm in an unsecured public area. Otherwise it is criminal negligence. Your analogy doesn't hold water.
by fvrba
Sorry about being 'clever'. Never intended it. My point ended with the sentence 'Personnally, I'm against using other people's assets without them knowing.' The last part was a parody. I waanted to lighten the topic a little with what I thought was so completely absurd that no one would actually think someone would take a motorhome to someone's home just to build a PICNIC TABLE!!! I was wrong again.
Two points seem to be coming out among the other comments. One, some people are also as absurd as I was (or thought I was) but I believe they are serious. e.g. 'your radio waves are invading my space, so I can use them however I want.' Two, some people want to feel justified in their actions or beliefs.
I think most of the comments I've read say something to the effect of Internet radio waves are just like any other EMR that they can intercept. Also they seem to feel they have the right to use them just like regular radio or TV and it's the same thing. It's not at all the same thing. Wardriving is seeking out open connections to use and you have to perform specific actions on a PC to make use of them. Some are probably saying they don't do anything, their computer automatically connects to open access points. They just start a browser and there it is. True but they've either preconfigured the PC for that or installed software to do it. Plus none of you who say you just use the waves by receiving them into your computer like a radio are being truthful. All of you send signals back to the access point. The Internet is a back and forth process. You are actively entering the other assets by electronic means.
No matter how much you want to believe you're not using other people's assets, you are. You're sending signals to the access point and manipulating it to perform according to your wishes. As I said before, it's a question of perceived value. For most the Jaguar is too expensive to justify but the access point and electricity costs are next to nothing.
BTW, some of you mentioned trespassing. If you go down to the police station and honestly ask what constitutes trespassing, most will be in for a surprise.
by oregonnative
I tend to agree that open access is OK to use. Working in a downtown environment, there are lots of open connections to tap into. Almost all of them are local businesses providing a free service in order to promote goodwill for their business.
Why all this negative talk? Use what is offered courteously, of course, but with a clear conscience.
by csr-tech
by oregonnative
I think this is a great example of how IT guys (like me!) are always looking to guard the family jewels and NOT looking to add value to the world. Who cares? The Internet does not have the same expectation of privacy as does a house. If someone wants to park in front of my house to get a few free minutes of access, more power to them. If it inhibits my performance, I'll lock the door.
Also, I'm glad to be informed about how everyone else is a moron out there. Honestly, I didn't know.
by nwarfield
by tadcook
There are laws covering car theft.
There are laws covering malicious computer hacking.
But when I access an open Part 15 device, I am doing neither.
When I am at home, my wireless laptop is configured so that it will only connect to my own router. I also have the router set up with WPA encryption, and MAC address filtering, so that only I can connect to it, and transmissions are encrypted. But when I go out and use wireless in public at a coffeehouse, I change the TCP/IP properties to allow assignment of my ip address via DHCP, and essentially open it up so I can connect to the outside world.
My neighborhood seems to have a lot of wireless routers, some of them obviously unconfigured. Often I will fire up the laptop at home without first reconfiguring TCP/IP properties, and I cannot count the number of times I've discovered later that I was accidentally hooked to someone else's LAN.
Is this illegal? I think not. Even if I do it intentionally. I say this because Wi-Fi devices are covered by Part 15 in the FCC rules.
Several important principles concerning Part 15:
1. Users have no reasonable expectation of privacy (unless they take extra steps to encrypt, of course).
2. Users must accept any interference from other users.
3. Unlicensed users operating under Part 15 may not cause interference to licensed users.
Who are licensed users on a license-free portion of the spectrum? Unlicensed users share about 40% of the channels with users licensed in the Amateur Radio Service. I am a ham, a licensed user. I have a legal right to operate there within the rules (which permit me to run literally thousands of times the power as Part 15 users) and to require that unlicensed users refrain from interfering with me.
Some parts of the VHF amateur radio spectrum are devoted to repeater stations. These are boxes sitting in a high place that relay signals from users over a wide area. Repeater owners have no exclusive use of the spectrum, but just like owners of Wi-Fi devices, they have methods to control access, similar to the encryption that unlicensed Wi-Fi users employ. If they don't use these methods, the repeater is "open" to use by other licensees, just as the unprotected Wi-Fi access point is open to other users. Most of them are open.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned in this discussion that is quite common on the 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi spectrum and is most definately illegal is the use of external antennas. Why? Because in order to meet type-acceptance requirements for Part 15 devices, they have to transmit below a certain signal strength, and they are type accepted only for the radiator (antenna) that they employ. Notice I said signal strength, independent of transmitter power. So it is not legal to attach your unlicensed router to your Pringles can antenna, even if your transmit power is below 100 mw.
So here is my take on all this:
-As a licensed user, I can use external gain antennas and run at power levels many, many times the power level that unlicensed users may operate.
-As a licensed user, I can require any unlicensed user to vacate the channel if it is interfering with my use.
-Just as a radio repeater owner who keeps his system open must expect that others may use his repeater, users of open wireless routers routers are in the same position.
But what about the ISP, you say? That is between the owner of the open router and his ISP. I have not contracted with his ISP. I have no business relationship with the ISP.
The unconfigured unprotected router is the result of the owner's actions, and the ISP can require the owner to protect access, or not. The unprotected router is free for my use, as long as I don't use it for anything illegal.
But anything I do illegally is independent of whether it goes through an unprotected router or not. There are no special laws needed to protect anyone, because malicious hacking into the open router owner's machine is illegal all by itself, just as vandalizing the open radio repeater is illegal.
So I don't lose any sleep at all over the fact that when I am driving around Seattle and need to check my Gmail account (which is handy for public Wi-Fi, because it uses SSL), I can always pull over near any apartment building and find all the free access I want, just as I can do inside or outside any King County Library or numerous coffeehouses or the open Wi-Fi access provided by the city along University Way.
73,
K7RA
by info
by csr-tech
Legal or not, moral or not, as long as users leave their WAPs open with no security, people are gonna use them to connect to the internet.
It's not legal or moral to install malware on PCs either, but as long as users don't take reasonable steps to prevent it, it's gonna keep happening.
by tadcook
>if you dont pay for your bandwith - or use bandwith
>or other peoples connections without authorisation
>or payment - its stealing plain and simple - no grey
>areas there - you are just fishing for excuses by
>saying there isnt a specific law - you know its wrong
>so stop doing it and free loading on other people
You are misinformed. There is a specific law. It is Part 15 of 47 CFR (Code of Federal Regulations).
It is not "stealing".
When I am at home, my wireless laptop is configured so that it will only connect to my own router. I also have the router set up with WPA encryption, and MAC address filtering, so that only I can connect to it, and transmissions are encrypted. But when I go out and use wireless in public at a coffeehouse, I change the TCP/IP properties to allow assignment of my ip address via DHCP, and essentially open it up so I can connect to the outside world.
My neighborhood seems to have a lot of wireless routers, some of them obviously unconfigured. Often I will fire up the laptop at home without first reconfiguring TCP/IP properties, and I cannot count the number of times I've discovered later that I was accidentally hooked to someone else's LAN.
Is this illegal? I think not. Even if I do it intentionally. I say this because Wi-Fi devices are covered by Part 15 in the FCC rules.
Several important principles concerning Part 15:
1. Users have no reasonable expectation of privacy (unless they take extra steps to encrypt, of course).
2. Users must accept any interference from other users.
3. Unlicensed users operating under Part 15 may not cause interference to licensed users.
Who are licensed users on a license-free portion of the spectrum? Unlicensed users share about 40% of the channels with users licensed in the Amateur Radio Service. I am a ham, a licensed user. I have a legal right to operate there within the rules (which permit me to run literally thousands of times the power as Part 15 users) and to require that unlicensed users refrain from interfering with me.
Some parts of the VHF amateur radio spectrum are devoted to repeater stations. These are boxes sitting in a high place that relay signals from users over a wide area. Repeater owners have no exclusive use of the spectrum, but just like owners of Wi-Fi devices, they have methods to control access, similar to the encryption that unlicensed Wi-Fi users employ. If they don't use these methods, the repeater is "open" to use by other licensees, just as the unprotected Wi-Fi access point is open to other users. Most of them are open.
One thing I haven't seen mentioned in this discussion that is quite common on the 2.4 GHz Wi-Fi spectrum and is most definately illegal is the use of external antennas. Why? Because in order to meet type-acceptance requirements for Part 15 devices, they have to transmit below a certain signal strength, and they are type accepted only for the radiator (antenna) that they employ. Notice I said signal strength, independent of transmitter power. So it is not legal to attach your unlicensed router to your Pringles can antenna, even if your transmit power is below 100 mw.
So here is my take on all this:
-As a licensed user, I can use external gain antennas and run at power levels many, many times the power level that unlicensed users may operate.
-As a licensed user, I can require any unlicensed user to vacate the channel if it is interfering with my use.
-Just as a radio repeater owner who keeps his system open must expect that others may use his repeater, users of open wireless routers routers are in the same position.
But what about the ISP, you say? That is between the owner of the open router and his ISP. I have not contracted with his ISP. I have no business relationship with the ISP.
The unconfigured unprotected router is the result of the owner's actions, and the ISP can require the owner to protect access, or not. The unprotected router is free for my use, as long as I don't use it for anything illegal.
But anything I do illegally is independent of whether it goes through an unprotected router or not. There are no special laws needed to protect anyone, because malicious hacking into the open router owner's machine is illegal all by itself, just as vandalizing the open radio repeater is illegal.
So I don't lose any sleep at all over the fact that when I am driving around Seattle and need to check my Gmail account (which is handy for public Wi-Fi, because it uses SSL), I can always pull over near any apartment building and find all the free access I want, just as I can do inside or outside any King County Library or numerous coffeehouses or the open Wi-Fi access provided by the city along University Way.
73,
K7RA
by hjleevta
Don't know anything about the statute, but why isn't your action a violation of RCW 9A.52.120, Computer trespass in the second degree?
Don't get me wrong. I don't think the type of action you describe in the opening paragraphs of your post will not attract the attention of a prosecuting attorney, unless you happen to live in Florida.
by rpdnn
Rationalizations... being not the user or usee or the court deciding the issue.
Unprotected routers are free for your -practical- use, not your legal and/or ethical use, if the owner objects, or even if he doesn't, philosophically.
Unauthorized use does not carry honorable connotations... merely ones of convenience ...and sets precedents for extension to other unauthorized use... and abuse.
Some unauthorized use is 'condoned' due to perceptions of triviality... being unimportant to those who might prohibit it... but not necessarily to the owners so used.
Be courteous, go find a library/internet cafe.
so you cannot blame them when they buy the things or components for them. Most users would not know how to set anything on their system and it is all sold as plug and play/use. the few Wifi routers and access points that I have been involved in setting up have come with the default settings of everything wide open - I asked one of the manufacturer's techs about this and he said it was because they used to ship them secure and most buyers claimed that they could not get them to work - no security = no non-use complaints.
An unsecured wifi connection is about as equivalent to having your front door open and the wire screen on the latch - stupid but not unlawful and if anyone enters without your permission they are breaking the law.
Everything is sold as plug and play/use and on the basis that any moron can instal and use it - well they got that right as every moron is doing just that. When you buy a car that has security you can reasonably expect it to be operational when you purchase it, this is the standard concept. Most computers and computer gear is not sold with the security enabled, just look at MS Windows (any version). The blame lays with the manufacturers.
Re your arguement of the radio waves - care to apply that to cell phone frequencies etc? It does not wash.
The reality is that the Internet connection is a service, regardless of how it is accessed, that is paid for and the person paying for it has a right to use it without outside interference. connecting via an unsecure wifi point is the same as reaching in the window and plugging a cat5e cable from your computer into his switch - both are unauthorised use of the system and service. Please not I say unauthorised USE not theft as theft requires that you ohysically take something with the intent to permanently deny use of it to the rightful owner.
Wardriving is unlawful in nearly every jurisdication as it is unlawful use of a service - same as tricking the phones into giving a free call. However, the situation is muddled by people who wrongly think it is theft and by the people who provide Hot spot free use of their wifi to people.
by nwarfield
ethical and legal can and most of the time are two very different idealisms. It is against the law to drive above the speed limit, but is it un-ethical? Webster says:
1 :of or relating to ethics
2 : involving or expressing moral approval or disapproval
3 : conforming to accepted professional standards of conduct
4 of a drug : restricted to sale only on a doctor's prescription
Certainly it can be legal (if even marginally) and not ethical, especially as an IT person should know the value of the resource being used. I don't have any doubt of it being un-ethical...and I don't know of anyone that doesn't do things that are un-ethical from time to time...
by unclerob
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=82&threadID=185931&messageID=1909912
If not wardriving, even if I'm in my own home and I hitch a ride on the neighbor's unsecured wap, it would seem reading this Part 15 that it isn't illegal at all.
Hmmm.... Very interesting to say the least
As it applies only to that particular legislation and does not over rule the criminal laws which class this as unlawful use.
From the comments posted I assume that part 15 refers to communications legislation dealing wth the use of certain frequencies, as such it only has a bearing on the use of the frequency itself. Once you use that frequency to access the other person's Internet access you are then using their Internet access without their approval and in violation of the criminal laws of your jurisdiction - second action that is not covered by part 15.
Thus under part 15 connecting to the device is not an unlawful act but then using it to access the Internet would be. So making the link to the wifi device is not a crime but using it is.
OK people lets cut to the chase on this and ignore the ethical aspects (yes it is unethical too) and summarise the situation.
Wardriving when you use someone else's wifi Internet access to access the Internet you first connect to their wifi then access the Internet. The Internet is a service that is paid for - rates and charge methods vary but not relevant.
The first part of accessing the wifi device would appear to be lawful in some jurisdictions due to the US federal communications act, this may not be the same outside the USA, and a section being referred to as part 15. This only covers the connection to the wifi device as it relates to the frequency used to make that connection.
Once connected if you then start to access the other computers on that network or to access the Internet via that connection you are then in violation of the law in that you are making an unlawful use of the service or unlawful access to the system as you did not have permission to be their. You are now in the same position as someone who has hacked their way through the security and any other network and now dealing with the criminal legislation and any other laws regarding network access and use.
The above does NOT relate to Hot Spots where the owners have given approval to anyone to use their wifi and Internet access. However, the few of these that I have used have had a welcome page appear when I first access the connection and I would guess that most, if not all, do the same - thus it should be easy to tell if you are on a designated Hot Spot and have permission or not. The law places the onus on the person user to ensure that they have permission not upon the wifi owner.
This is the same as someone reaching into your window to plug their phone into an unused jack beside the window and making phone calls on your line. Or someone entering your hosue without permission when you have not locked the front door. Your lack of security has not made it lawful to access and use what is there.
Yes the owners should establish due security but most users are ahrd pushed turning a computer on - the switches rarely have large buttons with big green letters saying Turn On Here. Yes the manufacturers should ship the hardware with basic security turned on but they find that most purchasers can not then make the hardware work as they do not understand the security to set it up, thus they ship with nos ecurity to get more sales to the technically dyslexic.
by hjleevta
I have briefly read FCC Part 15 and have a few questions:
Interference would seem to mean interference in the operation of a device, as in interference in transmission or reception, not in the co-use, or use of another's equipment.
I couldn't see any reference to the right to privacy in the FCC regs. And even if I missed it, I would think the right to privacy covered would be one relating to broadcast, not the use of equipment.
I assume routers are Class B devices?
Do licensed users of other types of equipment share bandwidth with typical routers? I understand that there are any number of reserved bandwidths for various applications, but I'm not sure how they relate to each other in a technical sense. As an example, do ham operators broadcast in a range used by my router?
It seems likely that your license gives you the right to use your licensed equipment (ham radio for example) without any interference from my router, just as the local radio station has the right to operate without interference from either of us, or more properly from our equipment.
I seriously doubt your ham license gives you the right to utilize my router in any way without my permission. The regs seem to grant protection in use based on your position relative to others in the heirarchy of users, but always in the use of the licensee's equipment.
The little bit I found in case law talks about radio frequency interference. Do you really think you can define your use of my router as radio frequency interference?
More than 2 dozen states, including Washington and California, have laws on the unauthorized access of computer networks. California's specifically defines a penalty for intentional use that does no harm. I don't think FCC regs invalidate or supercede those laws - California's has been found constitutional in multiple cases (none involving the harmless use of someone's router.) We can only wait for the Florida case to move through the system.
I think that in California, the unauthorized use of an ISP is covered by the same statutes used to protect cable operators. The fact that you have no business relationship with the ISP is eactly the problem. They are providing service and you don't pay. How you access the ISP network isn't going to change your status under the law, other than create a situation no self respecting DA would want to touch I would think.
Does it make sense that how you obtain service (wireless vs. wired) you haven't paid for makes a legal difference?
by eric.olson
illegal? no ... unethical, maybe.
you could compare it to leaving the front door of your house open. just because its open, does not mean you're welcoming someone to come in and take your nice HDTV... although, leaving it open, entices someone to come in and take it.
same thing with wireless. someone is broadcasting a unsecure signal... is it subject to being hijacked, wargamed..., you bet.
its ultimately the responsibility of the owner of the WAP to secure it. just as its the responsibility of the home owner to lock their door when they leave / turn on their home alarm.
i do know where my grandparents live, about 50 people all have their linksys routers with the default name, probably the default password, and most of them have learned to change their channel because everyone was using the default and bumping eachother off. it wouldn't take much for someone to come in and turn the entire neighborhood into a huge mesh network, and give everyone wireless... lol
by smee63
by wroach4
by wroach4
Cox.net limits downloads to 2 gigabytes a month.
downloading off someones account is stealing their download time.
by rpdnn
Philosophically, you broke with common courtesy and see no harm... you entire reference point is indefensible philosophically/psychologically, but in reality, for practical quantification, there may be little effect, other than unauthorized use. That is the whole issue... unauthorzied use, no matter how unharmful or non-affecting. As absolute power corrupts absolutely, so unauthorized use leads to abuse, eventually... and you don't see the harm in your use.
Your questions:
If it not against the law, how can anyone claim it is unethical?
As most point out, law has little to do with ethics. The wifi access and wifi equipment is not yours, you did not pay for it, and did not have the common courtesy to ask to use it... (Yes it might be hard to find the wifi owner to do so.) ... but that is unethical. Although perhaps not to 'common' or 'practical' perception.
Based on what? Common courtesy would suggest you don't use other people's property without asking... just because the use is "intangible" doesn't make it better. Unauthorized use of other people's property is UNethical... and usually ILlegal... in just about all court cases. Many would push your argument further to claim that whatever property they did use suffered no damage, so where's the harm? Additional harm comes in this discussion... which is fostering a willingness to use others' property without permission... a 'societal' harm. Only the most kindly souls allow unauthorized use... most of the rest of us feel 'violated'... and that is a psychological harm. Just because the wifi owner was not sophisticated or caring enough to lock their system down... doesn't make unauthorized use 'right' or legal or justifiable or courteous. They may not care... but you don't know that.
The person that left their open access point is missing what at the end of the day?
Unbeknownst to them, they are missing the privacy of their possessions... and the right to give permission. They may not want to allow unauthorized use, no matter how trivial. It is their wifi property and their right of permission, trivial though that may be to others, like jdclyde.
They have been harmed in no way and nothing has been taken from them.
You indeed have violated someone else's property... you choose to consider it trivial. Point is... they may not... there's the harm. IF they had caught your use in the act... they may have panicked and done any number of things... harmful to you or themselves. And such discussions as this may lead to more widespread unauthorized wifi use... and temptation is always there to snoop and eventually abuse. [Edit... as someone else mentions, data/quota capacity has been taken... again trivial to you.]
A better solution might be a public wireless access system... free or not ...for all to use when needed, rather than 'using' other people/property.
Couldn't you have gone to an 'internet cafe' or a library?? Oh, that wasn't 'convenient' or timely... and those are excuses that more tangible thieves present, too.
But, this is mostly just... philosophical... by the way... would you conduct business, even just email, for your employer that way? Oh yeah, where do you park your car at night? I don't want to -walk- down to the convenience store.
by tadcook
Thanks for the response. That was very interesting reading those laws again:
------------------------------------
9A.52.110
(1) A person is guilty of computer trespass in the first degree if the person, without authorization, intentionally gains access to a computer system or electronic data base of another; and (a) The access is made with the intent to commit another crime; or (b) The violation involves a computer or data base maintained by a government agency. (2) Computer trespass in the first degree is a class C felony.
9A.52.120
(1) A person is guilty of computer trespass in the second degree if the person, without authorization, intentionally gains access to a computer system or electronic data base of another under circumstances not constituting the offense in the first degree. (2) Computer trespass in the second degree is a gross misdemeanor.
-----------------------
I would love to see this challenged in court, especially the IMHO overly-broad 2nd degree. I think the key here is that I am not doing anything with the person's computer, nor gaining access to a database. I wonder what kind of case they could make that an RF LAN is a "computer system"? Also, as long as there is no attempt to hack any computer on the network, and as long as the AP was unprotected, the fact that I can accidentally connect might protect me. Otherwise, in another ham radio example, some hams are into VHF packet radio. A packet radio controller is a networking device, sort of like an RF router is. Just like your LinkSys router, out of the box the commercial packet TNCs (Terminal Node Controllers) are set up with no protection, and digipeating turned on. It is hard to imagine any ham being charged under the RCW because he linked through a TNC to another station.
What I meant about 2nd degree being overly-broad is, in the 1st degree law they give some definition of what constitutes a crime. But second degree says it just covers *everything* not covered in the 1st degree statute!
by hjleevta
I think it will be difficult to get a real challenge in court in most states. Why go after most people encroaching on an open wireless link? Real waste of time for most DA types. And if they do go after you, you would need the ACLU or some other free attorney - the penalty wouldn't justify the attorney fees if you didn't plead it out.
As far as I can tell, Florida is a first in the nation case and I would be supprised if the guy doesn't plead out there. How do you justify thousands in attorney fees for a small fine, assuming the Florida prosecutor takes the felony off the table? Of course, the guy has to be a little dumb to sit in the same place for several hours after being noticed.
I agree Washington's law is very broad, but I think the "Computer system" definition isn't hard to meet. It may even be defined elsewhere in Washington law. Still, having no idea about any legislative background, the provison may have an entirely different meaning too. It just looks like a good fit.
California's law has a specific penalty provision for harmless use and it has been tested, though in a weird case - a guy using a public library computer to practice his UNIX skills hacked into the operating system on two or three computers and ran various resident UNIX system utilities. The worst thing he did was require that the library staff turn off one of the machines to reboot it. He was tried, convicted and the conviction was upheld by the state Court of Appeals. I think Oregon has a similar harmless use penalty. Makes it tough to argue you only borrowed a few radio waves.
All that said, I really don't think we will see much legal activity on this front, especially in the area of the harmless use you described. Why would any DA waste time going after you for parking outside some apartment building on the AVE for a few minutes? But please, move along and pick a different building if you catch some guy looking at you through the window.
by hjleevta
Maybe the best in the thread.
While I have fun with the technical aspects of this thread, I think your sentiments are exactly right. The use of someone else's wifi is just another tiny corner we cut. Too bad.
Thanks.
by donbolle
Whether or not someone is harmed by an action is irrelevant in a moral discussion. Harming somebody is both illegal and immoral every time. What has been done here is using something that does not belong to you without permission. To claim lack of harm makes it OK is just bullshit to draw attention away from the fact that you used something that belongs to someone else without compensation or permission. The fact that the law has not caught up with technology is irrelevant because what is illegal is what society has determined is unconscionable under any circumstances. That is pretty much always immoral.
Morality is a slippery slope, but I have found that if you have to think about whether something is right or not, or if you feel it necessary to justify the rightness of it, it probably isn't right or moral.
by dalekay
After reading a few replies on this subject, I know my fellow workers in IT are not to be trusted for the most part. Remind me not to ask for help from these kind folk who would leach off a site. In nature most parasites are harmful, not too different here. Not the first time I seen this discussed. Depends on who is doing the leaching is the response you get. Leach: hey it there so I use it. Host: I did not know or I feel so violated, how could they. Sickens me to think that my fellow professionals consider it ok for the most part to take advantage of this.
Sad to be considered a part of IT with this company found here.
by dalekay
After reading even more posts on this subject, I have determined that:
1. I don't want a great deal of these so called professionals working with me, in my place of business or associated.
2. To that end I am making a list and checking it twice. Santa won't stop in your area anymore as well as I will consider any resume from these bags of hot air to be filled in the circular bin.
3. The state of IT has fallen to the lowest in morals, which only proves these guys should not be trusted with others databases, company business and on.
4. I sincerely hope the small sample of IT professionals who think it right to steal get a visit from the legal types. i.e. homeland security as you should not be in the jobs you are in now.
by ddemattos
by techrepublic
If you tap into my wi-fi, I can still use it. If you tap into my phone,
then i can't use it.
Intercepting my calls or my network communications are illegal.
by fain
by csr-tech
by nwarfield
by oregonnative
Gosh, Ron. Talk about the pot calling the kettle black!
Personally, I listen to the arguments of calm, rational people first. Folks who resort to name-calling(like your last message) don't deserve an audience.
by fain
In your post, you said "Secondly, anyone who is hosting a open WAP knowingly or not does not have the right to get mad if they are being abused."
If it's OK to use the WAP, why call it "abuse"?
It's not stealing if the owner still retains access to the object in question.
I would consider if stealing if you made it so that only you could access the Internet through his router.
If someone takes a shortcut through your yard, are they stealing your property? Someone hopping on your unencrypted wireless LAN is no different.
I think that if you're going to get after someone for using an unprotected wireless access point, you may have better luck pressing trespassing charges rather than theft since no property was actually stolen in the process.
It is my opinion that no charges at all should be made unless someone broke into a password protected network. If you don't place a password on your network, it is a free invite for anyone to join in.
Think of the precident that it would set if we could just throw people in jail for accessing wide open systems. Every web server owner on the Internet could use that new precident to throw anyone that ever accesses their server into prison! Isn't a password free web server just the same as a password free wireless access point?
by waynesreed
by ddemattos
"It's not stealing if the owner still retains access to the object in question."
Maybe it isn't stealing from the home owner who pays for the Internet service, but it certainly IS stealing from the Internet Service Provider.
by wojnar
There is a difference between saying "I don't care if anybody uses MY connection" and you assuming somebody ELSE doesn't care. How many users don't bother to read the information supplied with their router ?
In the U.S., if you unintentionally leave property somewhere and another person picks it up, they are required to return it when informed that you are the owner and you do not want them to keep it. (In fact, if you tip your waiter more than intended and want to get the money back, you are entitled to the return of the money. There are legal cases of this - look it up)
I agree with dalekay - I will be paying close attention to who I allow in my shop. Anyone who doesn't know what stealing is, will not be hired by or do work for my company. Let me give one last illustration of what is being discussed - If both you and your neighbor old wireless phone that uses the same frequency and you can connect to his base unit and makes calls through his phone service, is it stealing ? According to some folks, their answer is its not stealing if your neighbor doesn't know about it since he isn't being hurt by the activity. I know that this is not legal in Michigan since I was the victim of that exact scam. Its the same with any other communications device. Its WRONG, its IMMORAL, its UNETHICAL and it is ILLEGAL !
by blueknight
It's not the radio waves that's the problem, it's the MIS-USE of those waves. Radio, television, ham, and CB radio transmission all require a license to transmit the signal, therefore, your argument that they all be shut down is off base. All the aforementioned radio transmissions are one-way only -- you cannot use that same frequency and transmit back to the sending station. As another respondent pointed out, they are MEANT for you to receive.
The key phrase in this topic is UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS and every state has laws prohibiting UNAUTHORIZED ACCESS of another's computer network or system. If you transmitted something over a frequency used by someone's wireless network but in doing so you did not in any way access their network or computer then you have not committed a crime (unauthorized access). If, on the other hand, you did access someone else's network or computer without their express authorization, you have committed a crime. Just because you can receive a signal, does NOT entitle you to use it.
Every state uses very similar, if not identical, language in their statutes to define the crime though the title for the crime vary. For example, Iowa calls it computer theft, but the language is clear that unauthorized access is at the heart of it.
In the past year, we've had 10 cases of unauthorized access prosecuted in our county. My sister (Deputy DA in another county) has prosecuted nearly a dozen cases this year in juvenile court alone.
What bothers me about this discussion more than anything, is the number of individuals with no ethics or who lack a moral compass. It IS both unethical and illegal whether you think it is or not -- which is why many criminals get caught.
by unclerob
what's the name of that U.S. president of yours?
Sorry cheap shot (well maybe not too sorry, Iraq anyone?)
You've brought up an important point, the lack of ethics and how many people actually belong to the moral minority. But I don't think we need to put a label on anyone in this forum, from the majority of posts we're all discussing hypotheticals and why security isn't as a big a deal as it should be. Human nature dictates that most people will take advantage of one another if given the opportunity and I don't think that's going to change anytime soon. That may suck but that's life, and since that isn't going to change we should probably focus on security and preventing any type of theft and we should also focus on lobbying those in the positions of power to enact laws that offer harsher penalties against this type of theft so that people think twice before attempting wardriving and any related activities.
- just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree or disagree.
by jmgarvin
The broadband company will come after you. Qwest has started to default install security on their access points, but it still isn't great.
Also, Comcast in its ToS states that you cannot share outside of your house as it is considered theft.
by blueknight
I won't reiterate here except to say there have been a dozen or so prosecutions under PC 502 in our county and my sister has prosecuted a bunch in juvenile court in her county so far this year.
Just because you can't find stats, doesn't mean it's not prosecuted. I don't think the State AOC publishes stats down to the specific offense, just in general terms such as type of crime (eg misdemeanor property crimes etc.)
by blueknight
You gotta read past the definitions. It definitely IS illegal in Florida:
[pre]815.06. Offenses against computer users
(1) Whoever willfully, knowingly, and without authorization accesses or causes
to be accessed any computer, computer system, or computer network; or whoever
willfully, knowingly, and without authorization denies or causes the denial of
computer system services to an authorized user of such computer system
services, which, in whole or part, is owned by, under contract to, or operated
for, on behalf of, or in conjunction with another commits an offense against
computer users.
(2) (a) Except as provided in this subsection, an offense against computer
users is a felony of the third degree, punishable as provided in s. 775.082, s.
775.083, or s. 775.084.[/pre]
by csr-tech
by blueknight
You make a good point, but since he's the owner he doesn't count.
What the phrase "or causes to be accessed" really means is something like creating computer viruses and worms. The person who creates those "contaminants" doesn?t directly access the systems, but causes them to be accessed by the virus/worm etc. It could probably also be argued that installing a keylogger or keylogging software would be considered ?causing to be accessed.?
I live in a country town in Australia, It amazes me how many IT professionals (whether experts or not)have setup Wireless networks with no enforcement of security of any kind within their network!
Yet they utilise this equipment for ease of users, but yet cannot take the time to make it secure. They obviously cannot read, or be bothered with reading the instruction booklet that came with it. Most manufacturers supply some form of protection in the hardware and advise the owner about securing their system. They are told about the features they can use whether it be in the form of a firewall or another form of security!!
Here's a good example, a major bank in Australia has left access open for the internet on their Wireless network, they claim to have a very secure online banking system, So how can this be!! I'll let you decide, is it stupidity or just plain stupidity!!!
If people are so concerned about security why are they so lax about, why have any security at all. They are the ones who will end up paying for it!!!
So in my conclusion if people go out and setup all of this equipment and leave their network unsecure, they only have themselves to blame.
I live in a country town in Australia, It amazes me how many IT professionals (whether experts or not)have setup Wireless networks with no enforcement of security of any kind within their network!
Yet they utilise this equipment for ease of users, but yet cannot take the time to make it secure. They obviously cannot read, or be bothered with reading the instruction booklet that came with it. Most manufacturers supply some form of protection in the hardware and advise the owner about securing their system. They are told about the features they can use whether it be in the form of a firewall or another form of security!!
Here's a good example, a major bank in Australia has left access open for the internet on their Wireless network, they claim to have a very secure online banking system, So how can this be!! I'll let you decide, is it stupidity or just plain stupidity!!!
If people are so concerned about security why are they so lax about, why have any security at all. They are the ones who will end up paying for it!!!
So in my conclusion if people go out and setup all of this equipment and leave their network unsecure, they only have themselves to blame.
by dalekay
by oregonnative
I'll stand by what I say. If name calling is how you try to influence people, it tells me that you don't have the arguments to back up your position.
There may be 15 to 1 disagreement with me, but I guarantee you that that ratio is reversed when polling executive management. IT folks are involved in every process in every organization, but our ranks are filled with individuals who don't get the shot at management or don't have the influence they think they deserve. When you read all the rantings being posted in discussions like this one, is there any question at all why???
by oregonnative
I'll stand by what I say. If name calling is how you try to influence people, it tells me that you don't have the arguments to back up your position.
There may be 15 to 1 disagreement with me, but I guarantee you that that ratio is reversed when polling executive management. IT folks are involved in every process in every organization, but our ranks are filled with individuals who don't get the shot at management or don't have the influence they think they deserve. When you read all the rantings being posted in discussions like this one, is there any question at all why???
There are in fact a number of laws regarding Computer & IT security which protect consumers and organizations, in addition there are a number of laws already in force regarding Consumer & Organization privacy rights, including Intellectual Property.
To limit the context of this conversation to mere use of someone else's wireless connection as an "on ramp" to the internet is comparable to saying I simply used thier Cable TV connection to watch one or two programs. - Same concept, different provider, same legal precedent applies. One unfortuneate aspect of this issue is the lack of consumer education in this area, so most consumers are unaware that they can prosecute "wardrivers" or "hackers" or "users of opportunity" - call it what you like it is procescuteable.
In short if you can get prosecuted for "stealing Cable TV" by installing "black boxes" or "jumping someone elses cable signal" etc.. then you can be prosecuted for "jumping on" somonelese wireless connection.
Same offense - different provider. Both providers involve payment for services with the expectation of quality of service and warranties/gaurantees, not to mention the violation of a consumers privacy which can easily be crossed to stealing private information protected by law. When a "wardriver" or "wireless jumper" uses a consumers wireless connection for internet access without the consumers permission they are using a service the consumer pays for, without reasonable reimbursement for thier use of another consumers service connection. This sets precedent for loss on the consumers behalf. - A few points to think about the next time one finds themself pondering using someone else's wireless access to the internet.
by csr-tech
O.K. a bit more clarification on this topic. If you are in the IT industry you as an IT professional are presumed to have the knowledge in your area of expertise. So as such, you are presumed to have more technical and also knowledge of the legal aspects of your actions in your area of expertise than the consumer would. Therefore, it follows that the responsibility to act appropriately falls squarely on you in these situations and not on the consumer who may be uneducated in this area, or simply unaware that this vulnerability exists on thier device.
Anyway you look at this exploiting a security vulnerability (such as an open access point)without express consent of the owner of the device as a "method" to make the consumer aware of the vulnerability is not ethical as your "service" of "vulnerability scanning or penetration" was not at the request of the device owner or consumer. In short for you to provide a legal "service" for a consumer you must have the express consent of the consumer and they must be aware of the terms of the service bieng performed. To propose that finding an open access point and exploiting it constitutes a legitimate service would be in legal terms a "fraud".
Take some friendly advice from one who has worked in the IT/Computer security arena for over 18 years, the argument you propose is not a legitimate service for consumers and to propose that it is does a diservice to everyone involved. Your intentions may have been good, but the actions you have taken to complete your intentions were and are faulty. As the saying goes "the end does not justify the means".
May I suggest that if it is your true intent to educate consumers that you do something worthwhile to the industry and the consumer and provide a legitimate service which you provide to consunmers with thier knowledge and consent, and also provide yourself a modest income.
by santulli
by csr-tech
I have been reading a number of the replies on this thread, and some of them pertain to Radio waves bieng transmitted, under the supposition that they are "Public Access". While in the situation of a Radio Station broadcasting out this is true, however; one difference here is that the "wardriver" has no access to use the broadcast radio waves to utilize the bandwidth for access to the radio transmitters etc.. In short Radio is a one way medium, while Wireless access is two way communications. Now to cover another aspect of Radio - CB's, Amateur, Two way radios etc... While they are two way communications devices they do not provide a means to access a computer system or systems directly as do Wireless Access Devices. While you can join in on a "public conversation" on CB, Two Way and Amateur radio the owners of these devices fully understand they are publicy transmitting radio waves available to the public domain. Consumers and Businesses understand that these devices are for ease of use of thier IT devices without having to have Ethernet cables strung throughout the house. They are aware that the device does provide security and privacy measures, and although they may not be aware how to enable these measures, and therefore may leave thier access point open & vulnerable.
Failure of a consumer to enable the security & privacy features does not constitute an automatic licence for general public use of the device as part of the "public domain" for free access to the internet. The consumers access to the internet is under a paid service, which the "wardriver" then becomes a "stowaway" on using a connection paid for by someone else without thier express knowledge or consent, getting access for free at the cost of the device owner. - Now comparing this two CB, Two Way of Amateur Radio, while you can join in freely no one "on the air" or transmitting is paying for access to the radio signal as this is free to all. The only cost to consumers is the actual radio itself. If consumers had to pay for access to the radio signals transmitted when they talk (or broadcast) then "wardriving" on these radio waves would also be protected under law.
by rhalecki
I leave my Access points open. It doesn't bother me if my neighbor (or stranger, for that matter) uses it.
A co-worker of mine says I'm allowing others to free-load. (This, as she uses her employer-supplied computer to do her personal taxes!).
The point is, almost everyone "free-loads" in one way or another and thinks nothing of it. If it's my turn to be the "victim", so be it. As was mentioned before: nothing is actually taken. It's that some people are bothered that some people are "getting somethingfor free".
by toad464
by peveht
Just because something isn't illegal or immoral doesn't mean it's OK to do it. When you use or take something from someone, whether tangible or intangible, without their knowledge or permission it's WRONG!
Too many people these days have the misconception that just because no one got hurt or it didn't cost anything that it's OK. Somewhere, somehow it DID hurt someone or cost someone something. In the long run we all pay the price with the increased cost of goods or services and new laws or policies to prevent future violations.
There are many forms of violation. If you've ever been the victim of a robbery or burglary you know what I mean. The irresponsibility of a few end up hurting the rest of us. My hope is that someday those who don't see the harm they're doing will get their justice.
by oregonnative
I appreciate nwadmin's position, but often resources or services are intentionally left for others to use.
A great example of that are the City's public drinking fountains here in beautiful Portland, OR. Yes, it did cost someone (the City) something, but it's context implies that open usage is acceptable.
I think there is a hugely different context between jumping on an access point in a residential neighborhood and doing the same thing in a work environment. An open access point in a business community does not fundamentally differ with the public drinking fountain.
by wojnar
The primary difference between a city providing water fountains and access points being discovered is that the city is paid by its citizens to provide the water. The context is that the city is to provide certain public works. A business does NOT have a mandate or an obligation to provide anything to the general public. People keep forgetting that from a public works perspective, all necessary equipment is provide for the resource to be used. In a private business, if you are providing the equipment and tapping into a source of service without authorization, you are stealing.
Think of it this way - If you dig a hole in the sidewalk, tap into a watermain and run a pipe into your office so that your employees can get a free drink (which they are entitled to in a city park), Portland is NOT going to say 'Thanks for providing water to our citizens'. You will however hear from the city and/or the local public utilities commission about a court date.
If YOU provide the equipment needed to utilize a service, unless otherwise stated by the service owner/provider, you can not conclude the owner/provider wants you to have what they pay for.
If you think a business WANTS you to use their resources - try asking specifically if you are allowed to use it. If they say yes - go for it. If you don't ask or they say no, walk away. (if they say yes and they are not a Starbucks or a WiFi hotspot, you may want to apply for the CIO job when their network is conpromised and their current CIO gets fired!)
by deejay54
A vast majority of people out there that setup wireless access points are untechnical. Even though security options are explained in the setup manuals, they tend to ignore it. They just plug it in and fire it up. It works, their happy.
They have the option to secure it, but don't bother. If they realize the ramifications of not securing their wireless access point, it is probably only the knowledge that someone could (borrow) their internet access and not all the other bad things that we know could happen.
With that said, I think the Joe Public would care less, if they even knew that it was happening. Is it ethical? That is a good question. The only thing that I can see that your doing is stealing bandwidth. You are slowing down the owner of that network. You could be on shaky ground in that respect, but that is hardly damage done.
I personally have done it while traveling. However I reserve it to public libraries and hotel lobbies where it is expected that you would. Besides, I wouldn't want to have to explain myself to a police officer as to why I'm sitting in front of somebody's house in the dead of night working on a computer.
by dalekay
Certain parts of LA, if you are found parking doing that, you might be very lucky to the see the sun rise... Police or not in some cases.
But, I have seen this in my own area already. Even those with a little extra antenna. On the highways and roads. Even in front of my day job. For the most part, they are watched very carefully. Anybody want some License Plate numbers of these free loaders?
I think this thread is more a eye opener to me. I consider for the most part my fellow IT Pros to be more pro. I see it different now. Very few are. At least those that choose to post to this thread. No wonder the IT world is filled with chaos.
dale
by wojnar
by wojnar
If you are in a major US city and there is not a Starbucks within 25 feet of the private home or business that you are stealing from, alert the media! There could be a whole investigative report on how the poor citizens of that city are being cheated by not have a Starbucks every 50 feet ...
That is really the saddest part of all this - so many legal hotspots are available and advertised that there should be no reason an IT professional has to resort to stealing. Being lazy is no excuse for stealing a connection.
Sort by Trending