My biggest client had a tape backup system when I took over doing their IT. I've never trusted these wretched things and I didn't trust this one. I made sure the backups were done and I regularly tested restoring various files. It worked, but I still didn't trust it.
So, without the client knowing, I implimented a secondary solution of my own: a cross-network backup to copy everything to a secured folder on a workstation with a bit of spare hard drive capacity, using a simple dos xcopy command and run as a sheduled event every night. I simply told the workstation's owner that I wanted it left on at night.
Last month the server data drive died.
The backup software (Novaback) took three hours rebuilding the tape index then announced that it was unable to locate the data on the tape.
With my line manager now close to tears, I let on about the second backup I'd been taking. It took an hour to restore it and the data lost was a mere two hours.
I wouldn't touch a tape backup again, given the choice. I've since built this client a backup server out of a redundant PII 400 machine with a nice new big hard drive. My dos routines take separate copies of all the data for Monday through Friday, and the pc is located in the building adjacent to the one containing the main server just in case of fire or burglary - truly off-site, and completely automatic. The whole backup solution cost less than one 40Gb backup tape. And, it works!