Discussion Locked

Ten words or less: "I don't use Linux because..."

0 helpful
717 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

717 replies

by jaqui

windows is the straw house built by the first little piggie
osx is the stick house by the second piggie.
linux is the brick house built by the third.

balmer is the wolf.

by apotheon

People who live in houses made of Windows shouldn't throw stones. I'm glad Linux was built from reinforced concrete.

by charliespencer

You must have posted this at least four times in this discussion alone. I don't run Linux and even I know it by now. I guess this discussion is so large that the newer participants are not reading the earlier postings.

You can lead a horse to water, but you can't make him drink when his head's up his @$$.

EDITED: On the other hand, the ability to run a Windows app under Linux is not a reason to switch OSs; it's just not a reason not to.

by apotheon

I'm getting tired of reading arguments that consist of something like "I tried Red Hat Linux 5 once and it was rilly hard!" The world has moved on. Get with the times. Your so-called experience is obsolete.

by hal 9000

I used Windows 3.11 For Work groups and it only took be half a day to setup the [b]Internet Connection[/b] but insist on comparing obsolete Nix installs to the newest Windows Install.

My attitude is leave them to their Win Boxes and let them all go the way of the Dodo when MS implodes there will be fewer IT workers on the scene and I'll have an easier life along with clients who have working systems that I can keep working.

Have you ever noticed that the same people who insist that change for the sake of change is unnecessary, don't mention this when the newest MS products hit the streets requiring a totally different way of doing the same thing and needs a new learning curve all over again.

Heaven help them if Billy Boy ever takes up his Unix option and uses a Windows newly developed Front End on a Unix Backend and allows it to actually work correctly with the set standards instead of the crap MS self imposed standard. :D

Col

by rkuhn040172

I would hardly consider the move from Win 98 to Win 2000 or Win 2000 to Win XP a "totally different way of doing the same thing" or "needs a new learning curve".

If that is your rationale, then Fedora 3 to Fedora 4 is a totally different way of doing the same thing or needs a new learning curve as well.

We all know that new OS's simply fix problems, introduce new features, and unfortunately mess around with our GUI for the sake of eye candy.

Linux is no better than Windows in that regard.

Both OS's simply get more bloated and have more feature creep from version to version. It is a shared problem with one or the other at times suffering more or less than the other.

As for Microsoft, don't hold your breath. If you are waiting for them to implode, whether that happens or not, it won't be anytime soon.

I'm putting my money where the most number of clients are. And those same clients are still working.

by apotheon

1. With the Debian software archives, I don't have to do exhaustive Google searches to find applications. Your implication that you have just as much software just as readily available for Windows doesn't hold water.

2. A great many of those 22,000 are worth having, and people use a heckuva lot of them. There are raytracers, video editing applications, network monitoring utilities, office productivity suites, integrated development environments, enterprise-class antivirus systems, GUI environments, games, (spoken/written) language learning tools, webservers, encryption schemes, mail clients and mail user agents, calendaring applications and servers, mail servers, proxy servers, hardware diagnostic utlities, web browsers, desktop publishing applications, music players, music servers, video players, image editing applications, IM clients, ripping/burning applications, videoconferencing applications, VoIP applications, VoIP PBX systems, firewall wizards, intrusion detection systems, packet sniffers, filesharing clients and servers, fax servers, Windows Remote Desktop clients as well as other remote management tools, network filesystem servers and clients (including Samba for SMB/CIFS compatibility), file browsers, automated backup systems of all descriptions, version control systems, distributed computing clients and servers (for things like SETI@Home), compression tools, postscript authoring/viewing/translation tools, PDF authoring/viewing/translation tools, encryption/decryption tools, text recognition tools, partition managers, disk imaging software, netboot and netinstall software, alarm clock programs, data recovery tools, forensic analysis tools, Palm sync applications, iPod tools, sound creation and editing software, tools for translating video into ASCII animation (yes, really), Flash authoring and viewing software, database management systems, CAD/CAM softare, DOS and Windows emulation software, virtual server software, game console emulators, and many more useful pieces of software.

by rkuhn040172

1. "exhaustive Google searches"

You know what each and every of the 22,000 software titles does, what it is for, what it's dependencies are, etc?

Or do you have to Google that? If you do know about all 22,000, here, let me drop a box of tooth picks and you count them for me.

I don't want just a repository of software. I want a list containing descriptions, rankings, user feedback, reviews, # of downloads, update info, who wrote it, history, etc.

Your list doesn't provide all of that. I don't blindly download, install and use software without some investigation including testing first.

So, I guess Googling is necessary after all.

2. Thanks for the vast wasted space of this. Was that a cut and paste?

However, most of the 22,000 titles would include software that 99% of the population will/would never use.

Just how many words are in the English language? How many do you use in a given day?

Just how many office apps do we need? How many variations of mail clients do we need?

Does standardization mean anything to you? And I'm not just talking about software standards and file formats.

I'm talking about end user training, whether or not the person or organization who wrote the software will be around 5 years from now, will they be supporting and updating the product 5 years from now, etc.

I don't put alot of faith in a person or organization that I've never heard of to use their software for anything mission critical.

by apotheon

"[i]You know what each and every of the 22,000 software titles does, what it is for, what it's dependencies are, etc?[/i]"
I don't have them all memorized, but finding out about any of them is a single command or a couple mouse-clicks away (depending on the interface you prefer for the package manager). For instance:

[b]$ apt-cache show aterm
Package: aterm
Priority: optional
Section: x11
Installed-Size: 228
Maintainer: G??ran Weinholt
Architecture: i386
Version: 1.0.0-2
Provides: x-terminal-emulator
Depends: libc6 (>= 2.3.5-1), libx11-6
Conflicts: suidmanager (<< 0.50)
Filename: pool/main/a/aterm/aterm_1.0.0-2_i386.deb
Size: 84430
MD5sum: 02b690718538090f58aadfc96ff499a8
Description: Afterstep XVT - a VT102 emulator for the X window system
Aterm is a colour vt102 terminal emulator, based on rxvt 2.4.8 with
some additions of fast transparency, intended as an xterm replacement
for users who do not require features such as Tektronix 4014
emulation and toolkit-style configurability. As a result, aterm uses
much less swap space -- a significant advantage on a machine serving
many X sessions. It was created with AfterStep Window Manager users
in mind, but is not tied to any libraries, and can be used anywhere.
Tag: interface::x11, made-of::lang:c, role::sw:utility, x11::terminal[/b]

"[i]Or do you have to Google that?[/i]"
I let computers do my grunt work for me, thank you. Of course, I use an operating system that is actually capable of doing that sort of grunt work for me, so I don't have to count toothpicks (or, in this case, search Google).

So . . . neither. I didn't have that information memorized, and I didn't have to search Google. In fact, you might notice that the description of the software package gives me an email address for direct contact of the package maintainer if I need help with something, it tells me the size of the package (in bytes), and it even gives me an MD5 checksum that is used when I do an install to ensure that the download isn't corrupted or compromised! Pretty nice. How did I ever live without this back when I was Windows-centric like you?

"[i]So, I guess Googling is necessary after all.[/i]"
Not really.

"[i]2. Thanks for the vast wasted space of this. Was that a cut and paste?[/i]"
Nope, that was off the top of my head. I'm an IT professional in the broadest sense of the term -- I do a little of everything. As a result, I tend to know quite a bit about a very wide range of subjects, including the sorts of software available. I just started thinking of types of software I know to exist and listed them, double-checking the Debian package archives to ensure that there were several available options for each type (when I wasn't already aware of several) before listing it so that I could be sure I wouldn't inadvertently lie. For the record, I didn't fail to find examples for a single software type that sprang to mind.

"[i]However, most of the 22,000 titles would include software that 99% of the population will/would never use.[/i]"
Of course. 99% of the population probably directly uses about two dozen software categories total -- all of which are well represented in the Debian archive. The comment to which I responded with the 22,000+ packages statistic related to the availability of applications, though, and as such my commentary was quite relevant, and made my point nicely.

"[i]Just how many words are in the English language? How many do you use in a given day?[/i]"
I don't happen to know how many there are, off the top of my head, but I use more of them in a given day than many native English speakers even know. So what?

"[i]Just how many office apps do we need? How many variations of mail clients do we need?[/i]"
We need enough so that everyone gets what they want. I use Mutt. I have a good friend that uses Pine. You'd probably prefer Thunderbird or Evolution, if you were gutsy enough to give Linux a serious workout for a few months rather than poking at it timidly and declaring it "too hard". You'd scream bloody murder if I made you use Mutt, though, and my Pine-using friend and I definitely disagree about whether Mutt or Pine is the better mail user agent. If we ended up with only three email clients or mail user agents available to us, though, you can bet money that at least one of Evolution, Mutt, Pine, and Thunderbird wouldn't make the cut -- in which case a lot of people would be quite upset.

Q: How many do we need?
A: Enough so everyone's happy with what they use.

"[i]I'm talking about end user training, whether or not the person or organization who wrote the software will be around 5 years from now, will they be supporting and updating the product 5 years from now, etc.[/i]"
So standardize your organization on one email client, and let me standardize mine on another. As for who's supporting a piece of software, you seem to suffer some misunderstanding of how things work in the open source software world: as long as it's still in demand, a piece of open source software is supported. It's really that simple. Many are even supported when they aren't in demand. Unlike with proprietary software, something doesn't stop getting supported when its vendor goes under or changes its business tactics. The software is open and free, which means that when one person drops the ball another has the option of picking it up -- and you might be surprised at the number of very competent people looking for a ball to pick up.

"[i]I don't put alot of faith in a person or organization that I've never heard of to use their software for anything mission critical.[/i]"
You clearly hear about people and organizations in a different manner than I do. I'm quite familiar with many of the organizations and individuals who develop and maintain the software I use. I've had personal conversations with open source software developers who work on software I use daily. I can't say the same thing about MS Office developers, and I sure as hell don't trust Sony's software. I think you're basing trust on the wrong criteria.

by apotheon

Have you looked into GIMPshop? It's a version of the GIMP that has been made to act like Photoshop for people afraid to try a new interface for the same tasks.

By the way, there are Flash authoring tools for Linux.

by Former member

Because her previous Email client app was a lashup of An older version of Netscape communicator and Corel Address Book, which was made for Widnows 3.1, but we had managed to keep it limping (until recently) in Win9x. It wasn't going to handle the move to XP, so we grabbed something new for her. Thunderbird seemed a good choice, free, Fairly friendly GUI...

Yes, the issue at hand was Change aversion, no doubt about that.

Of course some people proably read the part about my mom not talking to me, and thought I was lucky.

by hal 9000

Latest computer went there loaded with Nightmare 8 as well. :^0

While there is something to be said for your mother not talking to you for any period of time when this ends you'll find that you have a much bigger problem that if you had of been able to talk her through it along the way. My mother always seems to ring up and demand why it's no longer working? After I do something that she doesn't like and she still insists that [b]It's Stupid[/b] to click on the Start Button to shut down the computer.

She insists that she has to use Windows and has all the trouble in the world with it and when I leave my NB loaded with Debian she never has a problem with it and I constantly find her playing Solitaire on it while she will not open the Windows Box unless it's absolutely necessary.

Col

by Former member

But I haven't seen consistent application of the standard. Sure all (well, most anyway) of the debian derivatives use the same strategy, and all/most of the redhat derivatives are fairly similar. (I am guesing you are a Debian guy, as you seem fairly caustic in your views of the 'rpm crowd'. Well, so long as you stick with the officially approved packages anyhow.

by red_wolf9

If you do not play World of Warcraft ignore this entire reply (it won't make sense to you anyway)

You?re methodically stalking a Mage (in all purples), for that very moment he mistakenly pulls multiple adds. You can taste the victory, dagger's are poisoned, Preparation is not on cool off, you close in for the kill, you click Ambush, you prepare to bask in the glow of yet another one shot (I admit sometimes Backstab is need too) kill?

WHAT THE...?

Frame rates are suddenly garbage, you?re moving slower then a snail, your still in stealth !, the mage backs away from the adds (through you) and frost novas, locking you in place (with the adds). Your hard drive is grinding (like a 16 year old?s first try with a stick shift), you?re franticly mashing the vanish button, the mage blizzards... you die (he laughs and dances on your corpse). While running back, you cuss Blizzard, 15$ a month (per player) and they can't buy better servers!!!

You?re about to rez when WoW decides to minimize itself and you are prompted...

Windows has finishing installing new updates? Reboot now? Yes/Later

NOOOOoooo?
macro /target microsoft /rude

Anonymous member of The Crows on Stormreaver

by rkuhn040172

If you don't know how to avoid this, go back to a typewriter.

You act as if one can't turn off automatic updates. Any serious gamer does.

by apotheon

That's interesting. If a Linux user said that, you'd be all over him for being such an "elitist" who doesn't understand the needs of the "average user".

by jmgarvin

you'd say:
"Only the highly technical can even figure out what the updates are, much less turn them off."

by pkr9

Any serious gamer would by a piece of HW designed for games, wouldn't he/she ? Instead of buying a "one size - fits all" device.

by red_wolf9

I'm well aware the service can be turned off, but unlike most of you, I don't advise users to disable services. Why, because the average user should never be given that kind of advice. It only leads to them disabling other services like AV updates, which we all know they won?t turn back on.

The average desktop I come across has 8 or more icons down in the tray. Do you really think your average user is going to click on the little yellow shield and tell Windows to update? Sure they will, the same users has no idea what those icons even do... go ahead ask them. So preach on guys, encourage every gamer to disable any service that might hamper their game play. I guess that's why so many Microsoft updates silently re-enable Windows update.

Or Microsoft (and others) could work on intelligent background agents that don?t not consume 90% of the processor and send a system prompt (flagged high priority) that stomps all over running processes. Just a thought.

Apotheon has an interesting point, people that are smart enough to disable Windows update and smart enough to run it manually all the time, certainly have the mental capacity to use Linux. Therefore the only appropriate response to this forum topic should be? because I?m to lazy.

by charliespencer

" ... people that are smart enough to disable Windows update ... have the mental capacity to use Linux. Therefore the only appropriate response ... because I?m to lazy."

There's a difference between lazy and choosing to doing something other than learn an OS. There are other things in life besides computers. Spend a weekend working in the garden with me; the light will do your Vitamin D-deprived skin some good.

I've got your "lazy" right HERE.

by Former member

Okay, here's my choice:
I want Fedora's slick install front-end
Debian's more consistent install back-end
Knoppix's reliable plug-n-playfulness
and OpendBSD's security mindedness
With Microsoft's organized and more mature, GUI admin tools/control panel(I wanted to select this from a distro as well, but I couldn't think of a single one).

by ajole

but as far as your post goes, pretty true. The only thing, IMHO, keeping Linux from more use on the desktop is that Linux excludes the average Joe User from calling (or IMing) their friend and saying, I found this cool thing at the XYZ site, download it and install it! In Windows they can, in only a few clicks, be seeing what their friend is seeing. In Linux, they can't. They have to be "better" or more capable users, or they can't install it, or configure it, or for that matter even choose the correct file(s) to download for their distro!

by apotheon

The perception that you have to compile things from source to install software on Linux is persistent, but incorrect. I've compiled a grand total of two applications that I've used on my Linux systems over the years, and I'm an expert user. The common "Average Joe" needn't compile anything at all. There are point-and-click interfaces for installing software that don't even require you to open your browser. Can you imagine (to compare to the Windows world) being able to use something like the Add/Remove Programs dialog to install office suites, computer games, image editors, CAD/CAM software, integrated development environments, IM clients, media players, CD rippers/burners, VoIP software, and pretty much everything else under the sun without ever having to so much as press the eject button on your CD-ROM drive? I can, because I use Linux.

Why would I want to search Google for crappy free software when I can have high quality free software without ever having to open my browser?

by cbertram

It is a kubunto distro, and it works very well as a live CD. Then you don't have to install it on the HD. I like Knoppix and BeatrIX for old hardware, but run a dual boot xp/mepis 6 beta3 on my t41.

by apotheon

Kubuntu is a KDE-using variant of Ubuntu. Ubuntu is based on Debian.

MEPIS is based on Debian.

MEPIS is, in fact, an older distribution than Ubuntu (and the even younger Kubuntu). The only relationship between the two is that they are both Debian-based. MEPIS is [b]not[/b] "a kubunto[sic] distro" by any stretch!

That having been said . . .

MEPIS is excellent, as LiveCD distributions go. For those who find its default configuration to their taste, I definitely recommend it. Like many spin-off distributions, however, it's not really suited to having its configuration monkeyed with too much, so if you want something more customized for your particular tastes you might want to look into Debian itself.

by rkuhn040172

Linux may be a house of reinforced concrete.

Steel walls, concrete floors, shatter proof glass, etc. Quite sturdy.

But not very comfortable. It's cold, cramped, and feels more like a prison than a house.

Windows is warm, comfortable, and familar.

I'd rather be in your steel prison during a tornado but I'd rather be in my comfy house with the green grass and leather sofa when it's time to play.

by apotheon

You may find Windows more comfortable due to familiarity than Linux, but that's just you.

I'm thoroughly familiar with both Windows and Linux. I find that I'm more comfortable with a couch custom-designed for the shape of my but than one designed by molding it to Bill Gates' butt, though. I'm living in the lap of luxury here -- and I can clone more copies of my house for free any time I like if I want a summer home in the Hamptons, without having to pay the (real estate) developer beaucoup bucks.

by hal 9000

I prefer to spend my time configuring the unit properly so that I will not need to waste much more time latter down the track when the end user breaks it.

Be that a MS or Nix product the end result is always the same but I honestly pick up far more work because of Lazy IT Staff who install Windows and leave it set as an Out Of The Box installation and I then get paid quite a lot to clean it out and lock it down. But I know that I'll be back in 1 moth when the next round of MS Patches come out to do it all over again. Working with Windows is like hitting your head against a Brick Wall it only feels good when you STOP!

Col

by charliespencer

" ... I'll be back in 1 moth when the next round of MS Patches come out to do it all over again."

I've only had to roll back three patches in ten years of working with five desktop and three server versions of Windows; two I rolled back were optional hardware drivers. I don't roll out service packs until they've been out for a few months, preferring to let others be the guinea pigs. Are they what you mean?

by andy goss

M$ captured the desktop partly by accident - DOS and Windows 3.1 were so easy to copy from friends. The last M$ software I bought was Office 97, my son needed it for schoolwork, and it ended up on four PCs around the house. We all use Open Office these days, on Linux and Windows, and I don't think that kind of multiple use will be possible with "product activation". In maximising their returns, software vendors are making open source look attractive - it is cheaper, easier to install, and does the job as well or better. Why pay for an illegal pirated M$ Office when you can get a legal Open Office for nothing?

by a_fairb

My experience of fixing friend of friends PCs is that they tend to have pirate copies of office. Often taken from a corporate copy or a pre-install disk where product activation has been bypassed or pre-set. When I refuse to re-load pirate software and offer OO.org as an alternative I am looked at as if I had grown a second head and the user generally goes back down the pub for a pirate copy of MS office.

by jmgarvin

What can't you do with a Linux config file GUI that you can in Windows.

Hell, DNS is basically 2 clicks and you are setup. What the hell do you want?

by pkr9

Politeness forbid me to tell where...
OK - it just popped out while writing.

I'm so fed-up with these people trying to convince me that once you learned Windows and the OfficePackage, it's impossible to learn Linux, StarOffice, OpenOffice or whatever. If that's a problem, they should be prepared for some shocks later.

I have tricked people into believing that OpenOffice was the newest test version of MS Office by fiddling with icons.They claimed it was very good, and they just loved being able to open any kind of document no matter what kind of document you had open.

The general user have no reason to be familiar with the OS, it is a leftover from the PC pioneering days of the 80'es. No clerk in a bank, or airline check-in knows anything about the OS on the mainframe they use, they don't know what make and model, and they certainly don't know the name of the supplier's CEO, or cheif software architect. Who's boss of IBM or IBM SW? But they are experts in the application they use, and that's what matters.

by jmgarvin

Please prove your post.

Wait...lemme setup dhcp on my Fedora box...hold on...oh here we go:
# service dhcpd start
DONE!

Setting up DNS through webmin or the GUI tool is just as easy as editing the config file...It took me a long time to setup zones on Windows because I have to friggin' click everywhere. Plus I have to click and type multiple times for every new zone. Ya, that's efficient.

Installing an app in Linux:
# yum install abiword

Installing an app in Windows:
1) dig for CD
2) insert CD, wait for autoplay
3) autoplay fails and you have to manually click on the setup.exe
4) click next about 50 times
5) restart your machine
6) find out you need to download patches
7) install patches
8) restart

Ya, super efficent system there. Good call.

The security though obscurity argument is bunk so I'm not even going to address it. As for the rest of the mess of your post: IT IS EASIER TO MAINTAIN THAN WINDOWS.

Welcome to reality!

by rkuhn040172

1) Comparing a YUM install to a CD install isn't fair. How about a zdnet.com install or cnet.com install vs YUM. Can eliminate steps 1, 2, 3, and usually 5, 6, 7, 8.

3) Autoplay doesn't fail all that often and is usually the manufacturer of the CD's fault not Windows. Is the following too hard?:

[autorun]
open=setup.exe
icon= icon.ico

4) Most programs install with maybe 5-10 mouse clicks if you just choose the defaults.

5) Most programs don't require a reboot

6) Most programs downloaded on-line will already be fully patched. If you have a Linux program on a CD, it won't be fully patched either.

8) Most updates don't require a reboot.

by apotheon

Even when autoplay works (I give it about a 60% chance, in my experience), it takes as long to insert the CD and wait for the pretty little dialog to appear as it does to install the software on a Linux machine. People just seem incapable of grasping the fact that in a worst-case scenario (such as: you're a clueless newbie that knows nothing and has to use a GUI tool like Synaptic) installing a new program is as simple as clicking on its name in Add/Remove Programs (to relate it to a Windows example) -- except that, unlike Add/Remove Programs, Synaptic gives you access to 22,000 software packages, not just two built-in things and a list of things already installed.

by noyoki

That's not entirely true Palmetto. As I'm one of them.

The only thing that was keeping me on Windows is gaming.

I saw his post on Cedega months ago, and wanted to try it out.

The problem now is hardware failure (not from Linux, I fried my vid card or something). If I could get my spare computer running Linux, and get Cedega set up, I'd learn the new OS in a heartbeat, and jump ship from windows.

But I had issues setting up Cedega in kUbuntu (pre-failure, but I think it was a vid card issue) so I'm a bit afraid to just switch my main computer over until I know it does what I want it to...

It now sets up, but I still get an error... I'll futz with it this weekend when I have time to play with it and see what happens...

I just wanted to let you know that not every Windows home user is a happy user, and sometimes, (just sometimes!) we're even willing to try.

by charliespencer

Poor phrasing on my part, as usual. I probably should have said, " ... compatibility with an existing app BY ITSELF isn't going to motivate a home user to start learning a new OS."

by apotheon

I don't think anyone claimed it would. The point here is that someone complained about the inability to run a given app on Linux as a reason for not using it. Pointing out how untrue that assumption about compatibility is does not constitute an assumption that compatibility is a reason to switch OSes. It's just removing an obstacle. If, with all obstacles removed, you still want to stay with Windows, then do so.

Why do you keep reacting as though "metoo" compatibility is some kind of evangelical rallying cry? It's not. It's just debunking some myths.

For the most part, those of us (like me, jmgarvin, et cetera) who spend a fair bit of time telling people like rickk when they're wrong do so not to proselytize for Linux, but to counteract the FUD that is doing a disservice to people who are made afraid to try something new.

by charliespencer

You can upgrade a *nix OS without upgrading the GUI. Windows XP and 2K do have "Classic" mode, but it appears different from 9x.

With Windows, some of the bloatware is unremovable. Add / Remove Programs lists OE, Messenger, and some other options as removable, but all that gets removed is the shortcuts. The apps are still present and in some cases still start services. Some options don't even appear in Add / Remove without editing an .INI file. Try removing IE. *nix systems can be stripped down to the bare minimum if desired.

by hal 9000

How many of them moved from 98 to ME to Y2K to XP in that order?

From my experience [b]NONE![/b] All my customers stuck with 98 till the bitter end and even them where willing to pay for XP Pro Licenses and have 98 loaded. When Me Y2K and XP where being sold side by side with 98 what was constantly outselling the other 98! I was even loading 98 once support had officially stopped for it at the customers request.

They then went from 98 to XP Pro SP1 at the very least and this was a massive step to take but they where finally forced into it by MS total lack of support for software that they had been selling only 12 months previously. Now we have XP nearing the end if it's 5 year life cycle but as yet no replacement on the streets. The last version of Office was released in 2003 about 2 years after XP was released and just after 2003 ES was released.

What new product that is used by the masses has MS produced since 2003? What is the value of MS Shares right at the moment? If you feel so good about them rush out and buy all the MS Shares that you can afford as you are sure to make some easy money off them right?

How many times has Vista release data been put back? Will MS continue to support XP even though it's older than any other OS that they have ever had when Vista becomes available? I'm guessing not after all they have already supported it far longer than any previous OS they have ever built and currently we do not know when Vista will go into production. I'm sure that at the meeting that I go to next week the Sales People from MS will have all nice Screen Shots of Vista to show us but I'm equally sure that they will not have a working computer loaded with it there.

Lets face facts MS hasn't released any new OS since 2001 with the advent of XP and even then XP was consistently out sold by 98 as the people [b]Didn't want it.[/b] Can you see them accepting Vista with Open Arms and rushing out waiting for several days for it's release in shops where they can pay way too much for way too little like they did with 95?

The currently slated release is First Quarter 2007 so that will be Winter in the Northern Hemisphere I'm betting that most of the people will stay at home in bed and forget about the release of Vista.

But by all means ignore your Financial Adviser and invest all your retirement funds in Microsoft the shares are cheap right now and if you get in soon you may even get to see yourself loosing money as they drop further as MS has no prospect of releasing a new product in the foreseeable future that will grab the [b]Mass Market[/b] World Wide. Currently Europe is doing everything possible to prevent a MS Strangle hold in there China is doing exactly the same with it own home grown Linux to break China's dependence on the Redmond product as well as many of the Asian Countries are.

You're in the US so they will probably sell on for quite some time yet but in the long run they are doomed as they have just Plain & Simply upset way too many people who now want as little as anything possible to do with them. Even the Pirates in China are no longer interested in flogging their product surely that should tell you something.

Col

by hal 9000

I would tens to think that they are ll the same. As for needing only to roll back a couple of patches across all of the Windows Products you obviously never hit that Java one for 98 did you. :D

It only caused the death of all external Drives, and SCSI Connected Drives and Network connection.

Currently there are some Security Patches going around disabling Some USB Ports or devices and now they are starting to affect unimportant things like Printers which tend to hurt slightly.

I'll be attending a MS Meeting on the 22 ND all day and no doubt I'll be told all about how great Vista is be shown some pretty screen shots and then told that the release date is still in Limbo as there have been some unestimated problems with a 3rd party supper so the production date has been put back again. But I'll get to spend a few hours with Bill at the bar nd over a few drinks we'll both have a few laughs.

Col

by charliespencer

" ... you obviously never hit that Java one for 98 ... "

Right. We didn't have any 98 boxes so I didn't even see that one.

"there are some Security Patches going around disabling Some USB Ports or devices and now they are starting to affect unimportant things like Printers"

We don't have a lot of USB devices and all of our printers are networked, so I'm not seeing those either. I know we're working in two completely different environments; apparently they're more different than I thought.

When you're at the bar with Bill, please ask him if there was any technical reason he had to integrate the browser with the OS, or was it strictly a business move.

by hal 9000

The Bill that I'm talking about is Bill O'Shea the MS Head Tech here in AU who is a good little company boy some of the time anyway till he gets with me and a few drinks latter. Well enough said. :^0

I have a direct line to him now as I get some of the nasty ones to play with generally without a known solution so I get to fight my way through the problem and find a work around and then ring Bill up and tell him what's going wrong. The last time was with SP2 on a new P4 that was at best suspect from the maker but it had the MBR's destroyed when SP2 was applied and there was no reason according to MS why this was happening. It's a really nice feeling to apply something as big as SP2 and see everything go smoothly and then on the reboot be faced with a screen telling you there is no Boot Device Available/Found or whatever it said. Of course the C Drive was blank as the MBR's had been erased by installing SP2. Wasn't my idea of fun that one but it had to be fixed and I eventually traced it back to a Samsung DVD Player being the problem. Of course I had by that time disconnected the DVD Burner as being the possible culprit and didn't think about the Reader and even when I asked MS Technical Support about it they said it wouldn't affect the install. Apparently it did and when I disconnected it and reconnected the Burner it worked perfectly well at least until I reconnected the Reader and then everything went to Hell in a Hand basket again.

I think that part of the employment agreements at MS is that if you don't already have a Christian Name of William you have to change it by De pol to get employed at MS. :D

Col

by dawgit

"and she still insists that It's Stupid to click on the Start Button to shut down the computer."
You have to admit that your Mom has a good point there. And a sense of humour too. (got me to laughing anyway) -d

by dawgit

"And I am sure that if the proposed European patent law gets passes then seeing movies in linux will be officially illegal."
That is one of the most ka-ka based statement I've heard in a long time. Europe is the most Linux friedly place in the Universe. You don't realize just how many 'Holywood' movies and American TV shoes are Produced over here, and with Linux!

by Former member

Needed a security cam solution, a particular camera has alrady been selected, based on it's feature set (BTW, the cam was an embedded linux device). Opted to use motion (www.lavrsen.dk a pretty incredible creation actually). unfortuantely, there was no package for it at that time (I see there is now), so downloaded the sources. make failed, had to browse the source to find an out-of-date lib and rename references to the new lib name, then make. Didn't include an MPEG encoder, so had to grab and make Berkeley MPEG-1 Encoder (ran into a glitch on that too, but I can't find the notes on it now). CAM not supported by motion, so we change the cam itself to push (ftp) the images to an upload repository onthe motion server. Then use a third party graphic program to create the mask file for each of the cams to restrict motion sensing. Every couple weeks we get calls because the system isn't working (FTP goes nuts trying to handle the webcam connections). And have to restart the server.

We go and buy a $200 widnows program. Run setup.exe add the cam's create the masks directly on the active cam screens, and voila. Thing has been running for two years, and never had to touch it once.

(I do realize that this is a fairly unique situation. I also do use Linux for some things My NTP server, for instance. I find it easier to configure and manage Linux NTP over windows. But I thought this was a worthy anecdote to mention).

by apotheon

I should have said "elitest", not "elitist". I keep forgetting that you can't spell, even when you have the proper spelling for a term right in front of your face.

by apotheon

I like my Tropicana Pure Premium orange juice, fortified with calcium and Vitamin D. It doesn't harm my delicate skin like irradiating it with UV does.

by rkuhn040172

We aren't afraid of trying something new.

We just don't have time to mess around with another OS when the one we have works just fine.

If the "afraid of trying something new" were part of the deal, hell, why don't we all just take a week off work per OS and test them all out.

Surely there are at least 52 different OS's...I could go home and not have to work for a whole year.

After all, part of the Linux argument is customization and picking the one that works best for you.

Too bad it would take the rest of my freakin life to find the right one.

by charliespencer

Why go with an OS that doesn't support the hardware you purchased?

As you noted yourself, this isn't a typical installation. It would have been much easier if the hardware, software, and OS compatibility had been checked before purchasing.

by Former member

I am not following you. The camera was an embedded Linux System, with a feature set the end users desired. It was purchased as an observation cam prior to the wish to record, based on motion sensing. The first attempt at implementing motion sensing/recording was done using the previously mentioned package (a decent system, really. The author is to be commended for his fine work). The key point of interest is that the Linux solution was in fact more complicated. Yes, the system was not a planned system. No, the components were not checked for compatibility. But then, neither was the windows application.

by charliespencer

Apparently I'm having trouble remembering what said in a thread from one hour to the next. I confused some of the details in your camera post with different thread. I'll just sit quietly in the corner for a while...

by hal 9000

I bet you even get Holidays as well right? Unfortunately I don't never have well I did get 4 weeks off when my daughter was born but that was back in 1976 and the only things close to holidays since that time have been Hospital Stays and Court Appearances which took me away from work so they where considered a break from work.

As for getting out in the Sun and doing some gardening [b]No Thank You Very Much[/b] I've already had quite a few Skin Cancers surgically removed by a [b]Blackmailing Bastard of a Surgeon[/b] who stands over you with a sharp instrument and after the first cut suggests that the wants his business computers looked at and then starts shaking his hand making out that he's so worried about those [b]BLOODY Computers.[/b]

I've currently got it down to once a year seeing him at work though I go to this home on many more occasions than that and make threats of my own. But he defiantly know how to get you to do work that you really do not want to do and despite his little Foibles he's a really Great Surgeon who always good to know as he insists that he has to keep me alive so that he can call me at unreasonable hours to get advice on how to use the NB that I built him. The last phone call was that he couldn't get an Internet connection through the Dial Up Modem in the NB and he only had the RJ12 lead plugged into the RJ45 Socket. I wish they where all that easy to fix.

Oh he's also the typical Appliance User as well if it aint on the desktop it don't exist so all the programs that he needs I have to place Shortcuts on the Desktop so he can use them. Then he keeps asking me why I sold him something so hard to work he like most appliance users expects it to work no matter what they do wrong. A perfect example was when they bought a new vacuum cleaner for home it came with a DVD Destruction Manual and he dropped it into the NB and wanted to know how to play it when he rang me 20 minutes latter without knowing if it was a Video CD/DVD or a written manual. He just expects it to work regardless.

Col

by hal 9000

I just wish I wasn't the one who had to show her how to use a Computer.

What gets me though is that she insists that she has to have Windows and then insists that when the computer gets changed she doesn't want massive changes made [Read that as a Different Version of Windows]so I'm stuck with 98SE on it and even then she complained bitterly when I changed it from 98 to 98SE and I really can not see any differences but she insists that there are and I'm just changing it for the sake of changing it.

But she had me totally stuffed when she hit me with the Why do you click on the start button to stop it? I really didn't have an answer for that one other than [b]It Just the Way That it Works[/b] and while she can accept that with here Video Player and DVD Player both have the same button to turn off and on none of them reads [b]Start[/b] when she doesn't have her glasses on. The TV is OK though as it says [b]Power[/b] so she can understand why it turns on and off but with Windows she is most insistent that it's crazy to need to click on the start button to close it down. And it's really hard to disagree with her on that one.

Col

by apotheon

You're not one of the people having a disservice done to them by others sowing FUD and being made afraid to try something new by the spreading of anti-anything-not-Microsoft BS. You are, in fact, one of the people spreading FUD. Go back, reread my previous post, and notice that I very firmly separated you from the "afraid" camp, and placed you in the "FUD" camp instead.

You can stop playing this solidarity game now.

by rkuhn040172

Or is Hal losing it?

His posts are getting harder and harder to read. He rambles on and on. I'm thinking he's drunk half of the time.

This dude has issues. I find myself having to read and re-read his posts over and over just to figure out what the heck he's trying to say.

by pkr9

I think Bill Gates created the 4-bit FAT table. This was obsolete almost instantly.

The rest is borrowed, bought, copied or outright stolen. Google for "Microsoft lawsuits lost".

by charliespencer

"Why do you keep reacting as though "metoo" compatibility is some kind of evangelical rallying cry? ... Those of us ... who spend a fair bit of time ... do so not to proselytize for Linux, but to counteract the FUD ..."

I'm reacting that way becease -sometimes- the "Yes, you can run Windows apps under Linux" message is phrased in a way implies that compatibility is the only requirement to be met before the user makes the switch. I looked back at this particular thread of the discussion and see that isn't the case. If I've stepped on any toes, I apologize. I'll quit beating this horse in this discussion, and be more restrained about climging back on it (badly mangled metaphor).

by charliespencer

While HAL's punctuation and sentence structure sometimes are a bit below standard, he's no worse than most of the key-manglers around here. I have to remind myself he's coming from a different background, both culturally and professionally. If his postings occasionally require a couple of readings to get his point, I usually find him to be worth the trouble.

by bigdave506

When I use Linux I am presented with a vast array of software, editors, window managers, clients for this, servers for that, libraries for something else.
I don't want any of this. I want an install that gives me a word processor with all the bells and whistles, a vanilla text file editor that lets me type, delete, cut & paste, find and replace. And maybe an IDE for development. I want them all to work together without me having to download, unpack and install another library with a host of dependencies. I don't want to choose from a big list of software that all seem to have similar but different functionality, and ultrakewl names.
Find me a distro that boots up into a GUI straight away and doesn't fill my disk with a thousand apps that I either don't need or don't know if I need or not. By all means put restrictions on the type of hardware I can use, but please, simplify my choices.

Sorry to sound like a sheep begging for a shepherd; I have worked in IT for nearly 20 years and just know that Windows mostly works. I think that if a Linux distro just looked pretty and worked without asking me to make another decision that appears to be purely arbitrary, I'd go back to it pretty quickly.

by charliespencer

" ... if a Linux distro just looked pretty and worked ... I'd go back to it pretty quickly."

"Go back" implies you used it in the past. Is the multitude of choices why you stopped, or was there some other reason?

by jmgarvin

Fedora Core 5: Boots into GUI by default. A desktop install is in the realm of 1gig, a huge (every package) install is in the realm of 6gig. Comes with Open Office 2.0 in the desktop install.

SuSe: Boots into GUI by default. A desktop install is in the realm of 1gig, a huge (every package) install is in the realm of 6gig. Comes with Open Office 2.0 in the desktop install.

There you go....

by pkr9

Please! - the world is too complicated - let me off. I can't make the descisions and choices, let someone else do it for me, and I don't care if they sc.... me while doing it. HELP !!

I don't know your background, except that you say that you are an IT consultant. I'm 59 with 35 years in IT, and can I tell you your'e in for some shocks later on.

I have experience with SuSe, RedHat, Fedora, Knoppix, and all of these boots into a GUI, pick and chose you SW, and contrary to Windows you can select or deselect _everything_, and afterwards it's very easy to change selections. Admittedly you can end in dependency problems, this program needing that service, but you are clearly informed before removing them, and reinstalling those needed later on are straghtforward.
It is claimed that Windows installs easier than Linux. This is because almost ALL Windows installs are preloaded and tailored with the correct settings during manufacture.
Try installing Windows from a CD on an empty box, and you'll see a quite different situation. One I did couldn't find the network card, and suggested I found another driver on - the internet.

by dawgit

I was following a string about speed loading OSs, like it was important to be the fastest loader in the west. You are 100% correct in that with a plain white box, it don't happen. And with a MicroSoft XP, when starting out scratch, a connection 'Home' (MS via internet) is a must. I've had some machines take up to 8 hrs. to have completly 'up', and that with internet! For a 'normal' sys box (with XP) I always estimate at least 4 hours. I really had to laugh at some of the claims of 10-12 min. (sure, maybe to a bootable OS, but not a customer ready machine, on a bare box) And as for your net card problem, I've had that too. You must use another computer with internet access. There's no way around it with MS.

by apotheon

I don't think you stepped on anyone's toes, Palmetto. I was just pointing out that mentioning Windows software can be run on Linux isn't generally used as a tool for proselytizing, and wondering why you seemed to think it was.

by jjpalacios

things run more seamless in Windows and thats what end users want. Is not a Systems professional's issue, is a customer issue.

by peter

Compared to M$dros, linux is just so boring - it never falls over with those pretty blue screens giving you time to go and have a coffee.

Actually, the main reason I don't use linux is because I prefer Mac OS/X.

It is so sweet, though, to see people paying money to run the rubbish from M$ - and some even pretend to like it. Apple should never have licensed the GUI stuff to such an irresponsible outfit.

by aaron a baker

Having said that, I would add this, you have made a statement, now tell us WHY?
Why is Mac "That" Great?
I'll be interested in reading and learning.
Regards
Aaron

by dawgit

well, exactly what? At one time, maybe, for graphics, but Apple got left behind in the computing world. Their whole direction has changed from serious computing to the teenie mp3 cult. (that's not bad, but it's not helping in the working computing world)

by reeves007

I don't use Linux because...because I use OS X and it's under the hood. I cannot imagine going for less intuitive than Windows. Apple makes the best OS. With "Boot Camp" and an Intel Core Duo machine, you can pick your OS (Windows XP (aargh), Linux or OS X). I understand that most people use Windows because it is a defacto office OS. Were they given a choice, they would pick the best OS and it would have to be Tiger (OS X).

by jbeall

Although in my eternal optimism, I partitioned my hard drive so I can dual boot between winders and fedora. One glorious day, maybe I could get rid of the winders partition.

by cbetts99

I run Solaris!

NOTE- I rdp into a Windows Terminal Server to fill out my timecard (SAP runs on Solaris but I can't use it with Solaris . . . go figure). I really drives the boss nuts at work that I can do just about everything with Solaris (i.e. Watch DVDs, create MS Office documents, play media files). Then again, I have been a Solaris admin for ten years and even run it at home.

by apotheon

Of course, I have very good reasons for using Linux instead of Solaris, so I guess we're even.

by rlgoers

- Too much invested in Windows applications, including hundreds spent on Shareware. (okay, that's 11...)

Though, Vista may change my opinion. I'm getting tired of Big Brother getting more and more powerful. I don't need Bill Gates deciding what can and cannot be installed on my PC - and much worse - deleted from my system without my knowledge or consent. I'm hoping DRM is the death of Microsoft!

by honezk9

Bottom line is over 90% of computer users worldwide run the windows platform. This establishes a precident that succesfully groups people and their computer problems, when they arise. Linux user, not impervious to problems mind you, may be left in the dark to potential solutions, regardless of simplicity. As a systems administator I dont prefer Linux (regardless of how good you linux guru's say the security is) because of security. Being that it is open source, its vulnerabilities are out there for the world to see. The only reason a viable attack hasnt been made is due to the fact that you would only be targeting 3% of the populus. I dont know about you, but if Im going to spend my time to create a virus or the like, I would want it to hit as many people as possible, thus painting a huge target on the windows users back.

by jmgarvin

yadda yadda security through obscurity is bunk yadda yadda over 50% of the server market is *nix yadda yadda insert Window architecure flaws here yadda yadda.

If you read the thread you'll see point by point from apotheon, jdclyde, and I why your are full of it.

Is it just me or does this EXACT same post come up in every Linux thread?

by jmgarvin

Just because it is an APPLICATION that runs on Linux, does not mean it is Linux.

Jeez...what's up with this little nugget? Do you even try to keep up with that CERT and Sans are doing? Look at the top 20 list on Sans and tell me the Linux OS is still highly vulnerable.

by dawgit

... many thanks to jmgarvin on the little help there.
Those apps (many of which were on all the lists) were mostly 3rd party add-ons to an OS.
MicroSoft, however did have direct programs listed which are OS related, as opposed to very
few actual Linux bugs.
as said above by: jmgarvin, Do you really know how to use the vast field of information at CERT and others? What we don't need is the info available miss used and becoming more
mis-information.

by rlambert1

I pay a little over $16 per month (including taxes and fees)for broadband from Verizon. And, that's not an "introductory offer"

by beowulf_cam

Palmetto, you're never going to change the mind of jbush... Sounds like a committed Linux geek who will never admit any positives in Windows. You know, MS = EVIL, Linux = GOOD... :-) Both O/S have their own pros and cons. You pointed out the best reasons for maintaining Windows. Our company has a whole lot of money tied up in MS products -- it would take some major convincing to toss the investment.

Linux is still too geeky for the end user. Maybe eventually it will become a polished product. Our users require results now. You can't consider the cost of software and machines in a vacuum. You also have to consider the cost of downtime, training users and trying to make apps work that users want. We have a lot of third part software that is designed for Windows - Linux isn't an option at this time.

I installed Linux at home at got rid of it after a couple of months. Too much futzing around to get stuff to work. It just didn't seem that useful. Keep in mind, I use my machines for work NOT games.

by charliespencer

I'm only trying to point out to him that it doesn't matter if the software is free when I rarely install new software. Rabbit food could be free, but I don't want it if I have no interest in raising rabbits.