Discussion Locked

Ten words or less: "I don't use Linux because..."

0 helpful
717 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

717 replies

by nigel

Windows sucks. I only use it for gaming. I call it my Wintendo. If you want to use a real operating system to do specific things use linux. No stupid wizards that dont work properly. No vague unknown error codes. No searching microshaft.com for hours searching for a resolution to a problem that is solved by "upgrading to our new and more expensive version".
windoze sucks
asp sucks
t-sql sucks
exchange sucks
wurd sucks
xbox sucks
If you want to learn real computing dont use windows garbage.

by rkuhn040172

Medications for people like you.

Sounds more like you just hate anything Microsoft and not hate any individual product.

Windows is used around the world by more people than anything else. How is that not "real"?

Wizards do help those who are less informed accomplish certain tasks and Linux uses them too.

Linux has its fair share of vague and unknown error codes.

I rarely search MS's website for answers. If I do, I typically find them pretty quickly.

If I don't, since it is the most used OS, there are millions of other websites that have the answers as quickly and as easy to find.

X-Box rules, by the way! :)

by jmgarvin

A) Windows is not used by more people than anything else. 50% of the server market is *nix and a GUESS at the desktop market is 85% - 90%, but with China going Linux, add 1.5 billion to the number of Linux users.

B) HA! Wizards that are made WELL can help people, but the borked up MS wizards are pointless. Why should I still have to configure stuff after the wizard?

C) Sure it does, but at least I can look into the code to see WHAT the programmer was trying to get at.

D) HA! Uh huh. I've got a bridge I want to sell you...

E) Unlike the plethora of forums, wikis, and LUGs that Linux has...jeez...

F) I have to admit, I like the Xbox 360. It looks great and does a good job. The controller is also surprisingly comfortable!

by charliespencer

Gods, I have finally seen the light! This is the answer I've been searching for. I love it when a poster states his position with well reasoned, technically informed statements, unlike the uninformed babblings of the other Linux advocates at TR. I'm going to work overtime this weekend to migrate everything I own or service to Linux thanks to nigel's undeniable assertions. I'm so grateful for this life-altering post.

by dawgit

sarcastic than :0 You of all people, had me worried. (like the sun was going to come up in the west tommorow)

by belkris

...I play online gaming occasionally (BF2) and the game is not available for Linux, although the server version runs on Linux.

Note however that this is the only thing stopping me from having only Linux at home, as all the other apps I use are web-enabled.

by rkuhn040172

I've been playing games with Punkbuster for years and nothing in Windows has ever broken it.

Why worry about a workaround?

by rkuhn040172

Applications do count.

Ok, not in a strictly OS debate, but two points.

One, applications do factor into the overall security picture as far as exposing a PC to threats.

Two, the Linux crowd loves to take shots at MS applications time and time again.

If, and I don't know this to be a fact, Linux or Windows programs are more vulnerable to attack than the other, I do think that has to be a part of the equation.

Who runs just an OS?

by rkuhn040172

Semantics.

A 3rd party app flaw is the flaw of the app until affects the OS.

Almost all software in Linux is 3rd party...nice hands cleaning.

by apotheon

Pick one:
Either a security issue with the IE Flash plugin is counted amongst Windows' flaws, or those third-party applications for Linux aren't counted amongst Linux's flaws. Up to you. This hypocritical "lookit all the purty flaws" crap you're peddling won't play in Peoria.

by apotheon

If you want to compare the security of the platform, you need to separate the relevant from the irrelevant.

Relevant:

1. the OS

2. applications whose vulnerabilities are due to OS functionality the applications use

3. applications that are integrated with the OS

Irrelevant:

1. applications that are not integrated with or necessary to the OS, and that do not have vulnerabilities related to their leveraging of OS functionality

[edit: weird typo]

by rkuhn040172

Only so if you count Linux's ability to shield the OS itself.

The apps come into play when a user's data gets corrupted.

An end user could care less if the OS survived if their data was lost. You continue to miss that point.

The OS is important, but my data is 10,000 times more important.

More and more Linux vulnerabilities are coming to light everyday that don't expose the OS but do expose the user side.

by jmgarvin

I think you are confusing the two.

SELinux REALLY protects the kernel. It is DAMN hard to get the kernel to do funny stuff with SELinux watching over everything....

As for arbitrary execution, if you setup your server properly (eg don't let untrustworthy apps run as root), then you are fine.

by apotheon

That was a nice attempt at a bait-and-switch, rickk. Too bad I didn't fall for it.

"Oh, lookit all these vulnerabilities for Linux!"

They're not Linux vulnerabilities, they're application vulnerabilities.

"Oh, well the OS doesn't matter!"

. . .

I pointed out the glaring flaw in your argument. You pretended that wasn't relevant. Okay. You go with that.

I wonder if you're as dishonest in other areas of your life as you are in these debates.

by iusethisaddresstocollectspam

... I have another cult to recruit for.

This isn't fair because I do have linux experience and respect for the movement - but seriously people - why does this happen everytime someone mentions the word Linux? Aren't there other causes to rally around?

by rkuhn040172

FUD and lies or opinion and right to believe?

Sure, there are some "facts" on both sides that are clearly FUD and lies.

But the vast majority of "facts" aren't so clear cut. We live, for the most part, in a gray world...nothing is black and white (at least not much anymore).

You like Linux, I like Windows. Get over it.

What is FUD to you isn't FUD to everyone. What is lies to you isn't lies to everyone. Who elected you God? Why do you get to decide what is FUD and what isn't?

Everyone in this world has an opinion. Respect it.

We all come from various backgrounds and various experiences. Don't try to demean someone just because they may disagree with you.

You say Linux is more secure. I say I've had a great experience with Windows being secure.

Who cares?

People make their decisions based on what's right for them. Who the hell gave you the right to build your soapbox made of glass and then throw stones?

by charliespencer

" ... why does this happen everytime someone mentions the word Linux?"

When you figure out the answer to this one, please let me know. There are some people on both sides of the Linux / Windows debate who take an almost religious approach to the support of their favored OS. Within the Linux camp you'll find similar crusades over which distribution is better. I used to think the majority on each side realized there were legitimate advantages and disadvatages to both OS and application models. Unfortunately, that majority is either getting slimmer or has abandoned the defense of the middle ground and left the battlefield in disgust.

by x-marcap

MS has a major set of problem such as patches for one DB release breaking another release. Only one release level on a system.

Why shouldn't you be able to develop in one release, Run production in another release, and have an archive to test to see if new code fixed old problems.

by rkuhn040172

Why continue to bring up China?

Is it your mantra? Is that the replacement for "free as in beer"?

Most of China is poor and don't have computers. And even when they do, they are state controlled and can't even do with them what they want to do with them.

Try surfing the web there.

Wizards do fulfill the needs of the average home user.

99.9% of the population never looks at OS code whether they have access to it or not.

I'd bet there are more Windows websites than Linux, hands down.

BTW, again, the X-Box does rule. Many, many a nights drunk off my ass playing Madden.

by hal 9000

Till I knew what it was I was talking about. Have you been to China recently?

With your remarks I would guess not as they are sooooooooo far off the mark as to be way more than plain misleading they even go way beyond a [b]Downright LIE.[/b]

The only thing that you got right is the number of people there I had a friend attend a Medical Conference there about 1 month ago and he was to say the least impressed with the cities that he saw they make LA look like [b]Small Potatoes[/b] his words not mine. The Ultra Fast Train that he had a ride on between the major cities was impressive to him and he's used them all his comment on this one was [i]It makes the Bullet Train in Japan look Slow.[/i]

At an Intel Chanel Partners meeting 3 years ago we where all told about the openings in China that where available for us to make money on and since then it's only got easier to do business with them. I've been buying stuff from Private Companies in China for well over 15 years now and the only thing that has happened is that it's got easier to deal with them with far less Government Interference being placed in your way. China now is easier to deal with than Taiwan as the Government there actually helps you no end to move containers around and allow shipping with out all the [b]Red Tape[/b] that they used to have. I actually find it much easier to export from China than to Import into AU as the Government here places all kinds of restrictions on you and you just have to comply with them. I just wish that the AU Government made it as easy to do business on the Wharfs as the Chinese Government does.

Col

by rkuhn040172

And get back on your meds.

With your limited experience I'd say you don't have much room to talk either.

You're talking about 1 friend, shipping some things, and an Intel meeting...not exactly a broad based account.

No, I have never been to China. But my parents were there just 2 weeks ago. They spent 3 weeks in Vietnam and China.

That's about as much credibility as your friend, eh?

Once one leaves the major cities in China, in particular travelling west, the country is immensely poor and under-educated.

And I wouldn't exactly be putting a lot of faith in a country where the citizens don't even have the right to free speech.

Is China a growing, industrializing country. Sure. Are things changing quickly? Sure. But they have a long ways to go.

For the most part, China is going the way of Linux for financial and political reasons, not consumer choice.

by aaron a baker

Judging form what I'm reaing here, I'm glad I don't use XBox, if I did and something went wrong, "according to you", the problem would lie with me and not the unit or the programming inside. Yet All I'm doing is holding a controller, but the problem would somehow lie with me.
Glad I don't use XBox. ;)
Regards
Aaron

by jmgarvin

China is not some podunk little country, they are emerging in a SERIOUS way. Not only are they highly technical, but they have a strong drive to prove themselves to the world market.

I'm not going to argue about wizards as I have not the time nor the energy.

As for the "more Windows websites than Linux." I'm going to have to go with quality over quantity. I recently visited a "Windows IT" website. Their instructions on how to setup the Windows firewall was pointless. They had very little in the way of real technical content as it was mostly "ra-ra Vista!"

by mcmurray.mike

... I want to install the versions of apps that I want, not the distro.

I want PHP4.4 MySQL 5 and Apache 1.3 - why do I have to compile and install from source on Linux?
With Windows I download the package install it and it works.

by jmgarvin

Anyway, it isn't that damn hard to compile from source.

edit root's .bashrc (assuming you are using bash) and create a handy alias

alias srcmk='./configure && make && make install'

Jeez...

I still don't get why you would want to run old versions...it doesn't make sense....

by daveo2000

One of the things that MS has done rather effectively is to simplify/dumb down the interface to a complicated piece of equipment. That has accomplished a number of major things:

- it has gotten the computer into many households
- it has gotten major portions of computing out of the server room and onto desktops
- it has shifted the workforce around so that, in many companies, the typing pool of secretaries has nearly vanished
- it has gotten people connected that never would have been able to interact by any other medium.

Unfortunately, not being able to leave a good reputation untarnished, they have also:

- created some of the best platforms to create viruses so you need next to no technical training to create one
- moved most of the tuning elements so deep inside that you have to pay for specific training to figure out how to do it
- fostered a hostile and closed environment to software development worldwide
- been convicted of illegal monopolistic behavior

c'est la vie...

by pkr9

OK, then try to download a foreign language MS Officepackage on a US language Windows PC, and tell me how fine that works.

In windows you're locked to the language you selected in the first place. If you have a local language install and want a US install - reinstall all and loose all.

by nighthawk808

Just use Kpilot. There's a different package--I believe it's multisync but I can't be sure right now as I'm at work and stuck using a legacy OS--that will work if you're not a KDE user. Even if you use Gnome, Kpilot may work if you have the right libs installed.

Unfortunately, I haven't been able to figure out how to get it to transfer my pictures, as the media conduit seems to be different from everything else, but it does everything else (like app installs, etc.).

---Update---
Now that I'm sitting in front a non-brain-dead machine, I find that Gnome users would use a package called, duh, gnome-pilot.

I hate how OSS developers use such nonsensical names. Why can't they use normal names like "ctpazxx.ini" or "csrss.exe"? [I didn't make these up; they're two files in %SYSTEMROOT%\System32 ]

by hal 9000

I was loading XP Pro onto a White Box and got the [b]BSOD[/b] and on the reboot I got a message that read[b]Windows did a bad thing would you like to contact MS directly and find out what the problem was?[/b] :p

Something that I've never seen before in my life and I's still unsure of exactly how you where supposed to let it contact MS and report the problem whatever it was. It then rebooted all by itself and continued to load XP. I wasn't overly happy with this so I stopped the install wiped the drive and started the install all over again this time it went faultlessly. Another stupid Error Message to add to my list of things that are just crazy. :D

Col [:)

by nighthawk808

In the US, watching movies with Linux is already illegal. I'm a criminal because I use DeCSS to watch movies I legally own. And the MPAA wonders why I only have six movies in my collection, yet none on my HDD.

How is the greed and shortsightedness of movie studio executives and bought-off legislators Linux's fault?

I work at a help desk. I know all about the level of competence of the average user. And yet I still have a higher estimation of their abilities than you do. Not everyone is stupid, and even stupid people use Linux.

I'm not anti-MS, I'm pro-computer. M$ is bad for the computing world.

You don't know how to check dependencies? Fedora doesn't have a tool to do that for you? I don't know much about Red Hat because I dropped them like a hot potato after the way they handled splitting up Fedora and RHEL. In fact, the only RPM-based distro I know well is SuSE, and YaST is unbelieveably helpful (usually). I've also used many Debian-based distros, and they are justly legendary for their package managers.

And you do understand that a source RPM is something that you compile into a program, yet a typical RPM is something that has already been compiled and is ready to install, right? Sure, there are source RPM's too--they're intended for convenient access to the source and/or for advanced users to build for themselves. Just because they exist doesn't mean you have you have to use them, and it certainly isn't the case that they're the way most programs come. Fedora isn't Gentoo or LFS, and it's not supposed to be.

As for this quote: "I use fedora and i have some stupid problems occasionally". Isn't that a bit like saying "I drive a Yugo and I have problems getting it up to 120 MPH"? But seriously, how is that different from this quote: "I use Windows XP and I have some stupid problems occasionally." Are stupid problems somehow limited to the Linux world? I'd much rather have a stupid problem that crashes Konqueror than a stupid problem that turns my machine into a spambot.

Sound problem? None of the six different sound cards or integrated audio chips I've used in Linux have had a problem. Sound problems are so five years ago. Viva la ALSA!

Afraid of a shell? You can go months without ever having to drop to a command line if you don't want to.

As I've said before:
Thanks for your post, but come back when you've actually used Linux. If, as you claim, you aren't a novice Linux user, you'd know better. You haven't spewed out any tired old FUD we haven't all heard 42 times before.

by nighthawk808

Sorry. I was trying to catch up on my discussions and was posting in a bit of a hurry. I didn't realize it was you I was responding to. I'd have known better otherwise.

I hope you took it as a compliment that I thought of you as "one of the guys". You should.

by nighthawk808

The last I saw (about a month or two ago) it was officially being delayed in order to give it more time for testing. They're going to longer support cycles so they want to make sure they've got it right. Best of luck to them.

by aaron a baker

That all I remember is that I was supposed to make a diskette, that would eventually lead me into starting the install and then another diskette would be need etc. Then when I got to a certain point I would be able to put in the CD and carry on from there. This was in the day when they were giving them away 6 or 7 years ago.
So I have no doubt in my mind that they must have improved considerably but it left a bad taste in my mouth and I stand guilty of really not tying hard enough to give it another go. "Mea Culpa"
But I've got to tell you, with all the crap that Microsoft is pulling now, I'm thinking very hard of buying another Computer and trying again.
All I can really tell you is that it came in a red hat Box with Diskettes, two or three books, and a CD I think and that's about all I remember of it.
So you see, I really am a Linux novice, but one that is willing to learn and improve and as I suspect that XPPro will probably be my last MS System, it will be sooner than later.
The Bottom line is, This was a very long time ago and I was completely out of my depth, and boy, it showed. ;)
In many ways, I still am. :p
Regards
Aaron :)

by nighthawk808

... that's just off the top of Apotheon's head.

But in addition to all the things you can download, there are plenty of things that you don't have to. There are things that any standard distro with a typical install comes with OOTB that you have to find and/or buy to have available on the Windows platform. And if a certain app only does 99% of what you want, chances you can add it yourself since you have or can get the source code to give you that power. Try doing that with a binary, which is all that closed-source (read: most Windows) apps give you.

by rkuhn040172

99.9% of the world never looks at source code.

That is another old, worn out Linux argument.

Good for those that do, but please, such a small percentage of the population takes advantage of that "feature" that I would hardly call it an advantage.

by charliespencer

One of the oft-celebrated features of open source software is access to the source code. I wonder if that is over-emphasised in "The Great Debate (tm)". Sure, it's great to have the code if you are interested in changing the program and have the skills to do it; I'm not knocking that at all. I just wonder what percentage of open source users ever look at the code. An option that is ignored by the majority of the users isn't automatically unimportant, but it may not be a good selling point.

by nighthawk808

I've been looking for a project to teach myself PHP and/or Perl with. I've got one: I'll save us all a lot of trouble and write something that greps for phrases that contain "can't" "run" "games" "Linux" in proximity to one another and automatically creates and submits a post with the title "Yes, you can." and contains a link to www.transgaming.com. In tribute to my favorite autoresponding trollbot, I'll call it rickk++.

That would free up a lot more time for me to tend to my LART.

On second thought, maybe I should write it in C#. After all, if you're going to write a brain-dead application, you might as well use a brain-dead language.

by charliespencer

It's a shame I haven't done any programming in over a decade, and that was all FORTRAN and COBOL. If I had, I might have been able to understand your references to PERL, PHP, greps, LART, and C#. Oh well ...

:-)

by apotheon

Grab some simple webspider script written in Perl, target it at TR, add a one-liner regex-centric statement, and graft an API onto it for dealing with TR. Voila. You're in business.

The tough part would be getting the API specs.

by nighthawk808

if I wanted to slap together some random prewritten code, add some cruft on top of it, and then call it a program, I'd send my r?sum? to Microsoft. :)

by jmgarvin

Punkbuster has never worked quite right for me. I used to play Counter-Strike on my laptop and the Punkbuster updates wouldn't take unless I was admin and then only admin could run them until *I* made the app global...and even then sometimes PB would only run properly as admin...

There is a PB for Linux btw

by charliespencer

I've never read "Of Mice and Men", so I didn't get your reference. My leisure reading is almost completely sci-fi / fantasy.

"Rabbit food" is an old line in my family about getting a "bargain" on something you didn't need anyway.

by rkuhn040172

And a decent movie.

Written by John Steinbeck.

About two migrant workers in depression era. One, Lennie, is retarded and has a thing for rabbits.

Worth checking out.

by nighthawk808

I wish we had a million posters here as funny as you.

As for number 11: IBM sells AS/400's with SLES or RHEL preinstalled. I'd much rather have either of those than the OS/400 I have to deal with every day. There's nothing more enjoyable than typing WRKSYSVAL QTIME just to find out what time it is. The scary thing is that after a while, the TLA's start to make perfect sense.

by hal 9000

Came with 7 CD's and auto installed without a hitch even easier than an OEM install of Windows XP and they have got better since then.

I think I paid something like $39.00 AU for that copy of Red Hat and it had everything that I needed and then some unlike the Windows OEM XP Pro costing me $240.00 + and then Office XP Pro somewhere around the $450.00 AU mark for the Wholesale OEM's. Red Hat 9 certainly had a lot more and made it seem not worth the effort in paying for the OEM MS stuff and then having to install it. About the only difference that the end user will see is that they have to type in their Name and then a Password to get the OS to open. Then besides having the 4 available Desktops it looks just like a XP install with the Start Bar in the same place and the Menu system laid out like a Classic Windows View.

Col

by hal 9000

That 99.9% of the world doesn't bother with looking at the Source Code why is it then that you claim that this is a weakness with Open Source?

By being able to look at the Source Code that gives the [b]Script Kiddies[/b] an unfair advantage on how to break things while they seem to be doing a pretty fair job of it with Windows while being unable to actually look at the Source Code. :p

Col ]:)

by nighthawk808

If you're trying to find out what your page will look like in IE, test it in a standards-compliant browser, then stochastically cut and paste half-a-dozen snippets of your HTML into different locations. If you're using tables, don't forget to turn your monitor onto its side. And if you're coding specifically for IE users, cater to your audience's level by putting all your text in white and using a bright yellow (I recommend anythinig in the FF FF ** range) solid background. Those of us with 20/10 vision enjoy an occasional challenge. Alternatively, use an asymmetrical image approximately 50 pixels wide so it will tile at least 20 times at 1280x1024. Ensure that the predominant color of that image matches the color of your text.

Don't forget to change the text color of text, hyperlinks, and visited hyperlinks to all the same color. I love cluelessly guessing as to what is a link and what isn't.

Here's an extra special bonus tip for those of you who use FrontPage: make sure the target on your "Back" button is "javascript:history.go(-1)" so if I found your site through a search engine, I'll go right back to it instead of to your home page.

But wait, there's more: while you're misapplying JavaScript, have it disable my right-click context menu too. I didn't want to open that link in a new tab anyway. Besides, if I don't go to Edit/Preferences/Content and uncheck the "Enable JavaScript" box every once in a while, I'll forget where it's at.

Post editied because I left one of my biggest pet peeves out.

by hal 9000

[i]I've been buying stuff from Private Companies in China for well over 15 years now[/i] That is part of a sentence that I used in the above post where exactly does it say anything about a Friend buying from China I thought I said it clearly enough [b]I've[/b] meaning me!

And Yes you are quite correct that further West you go in china [i]away from the sea ports[/i] the poorer things look until you get to the Tourist areas near the Great Wall of China then it's a [b]Tourist Mecca[/b] though probably not what you would want but I loved it the last time I was there a couple of years ago now.

You are however totally correct about the way that the Chinese Government works it's totally dictoral where it has the power but even now that is diminishing fast with all the International Trade.

You should visit Global Sources and register to get some of their Magazines sent to you free of charge you'll be really surprised what is available from them. I recently saw some Talon Brush Cutters in K Mart for about $178.00 AU and their cost FOB was $15.00 US straight from the factory in China.

They make everything from IC's to Heavy Earthmoving Equipment at prices that we can only dream of competing with. I personally buy a lot of Solar Power Generation hardware directly from China as well as some Computer Stuff and one of my suppliers I'm currently in discussions with to make some new computer devices to take advantage of some of the newer NB technology that isn't currently addressed by the rest of the industry anywhere World Wide. Now neither of us could hope to achieve this in our own countries at a price that would make it possible to sell this hardware.

You'll see exactly the same thing in the US just as you do in AU the further away from the Major Sea Ports that you move the poorer the people are. The fact that we both have Sea Ports available on both sides of our respective countries just makes it easier for the population to survive and live there but if we both only had one coast with Sea Ports we would see exactly the same thing in our respective countries.

Without the availability to generate [b]Export $[/b] there is very little demand to develop these areas particularly when you take into account the costs of moving the finished product to an export site.

Col

by rkuhn040172

Saying that having the source code open is a weakness to Linux.

I merely stated that having open code is not the huge strength that some make it out to be.

Others have said it, but not I.

I prefer to leave that portion of the debate to the same people who like to argue about religion...there is no right answer.

I prefer to reserve my comments to both the technical and real world areas.

Some Linux myths:

1) It's free...no, not in total costs allocated
2) It's open source...so, who ever looks at it
3) It's more secure...depends on too many other factors
4) It's user friendly...BS, not when the world is used to Windows already
5) It installs faster...marginally so, not a major concern
6) It's less bloated...and growing everyday

Just a few examples.

by daveo2000

I believe that one of the problems here is what you classify as what. Part of the FUD (Fear, Uncertainty, Doubt) spread is the Microsoft propaganda used in court rooms, advertisements and "press releases". One example is where they pointed to Open Source and classified it all as being unreliable and frought with bugs. Meanwhile, they continued to use the open source TCP/IP stack code as part of the Windows core through NT 5.

Maybe you don't hear or, more likely, don't feel a need to pay attention to their more deceitful digs at the Linux community but that doesn't make them (the statements) go away.

Both OS camps have their successes and failures. MS just has more salesmen out front and we all know how salesmen tend to bend the truth or outright lie to make their products look better or, failing that, make the competition look worse.

Yes, you are right. People should be able to choose for themselves and not be demeaned for their choice. But while everyone in the world has an opinion, we don't [b]have[/b] to respect those opinions, just allow the others to have them. Of course, once they express it in a public forum, they open themselves to having that opinion questioned.

And speaking of throwing stones, check out your own soap box. It has gotten pretty high. And many of the facts and fancies you have based it on are not so far from being made of glass as you would hope.

by rkuhn040172

You are mostly right, however, you act as if the Great Wall is far west.

Check a map man. The Great Wall is only about 2 hours drive from Beijing (at least a part of it).

I'm talking about western China...more towards Kazakhstan, Mongolia, India, Pakistan, Tibet.

It's some of the poorest places on the planet.

by daveo2000

and compose a well thought out reply instead of what comes off as knee-jerk cutsie, high-schoolish from-the-hip comebacks that seem to, more often than not, include references to drugs.

So far, HAL has presented commentary that shows him as a businessman that has had dealings in the business he is discussing. You are coming off as a high-school kids using his parents vacation as grounds to build up a business case.

Different league here. This isn't a school playground.

The one school analogy that would work well here is "do your homework [b]before[/b] you come to class... [b]please[/b]."

BTW, if you DO happen to be a high-school student, HAL would probably be a good source of info for one of your school projects, if you can stop insulting him long enough.

by rkuhn040172

According to them, in 2005 there were only 100 million Chinese using the web.

Grant it, that is web users, not computer users. But I think that gives some insight into the number of PC users.

100 million is a far cry from your quoted 1.5 billion. Nice try though.

Some facts:

There are 150 million Chinese below the international poverty line

100-150 million Chinese are living on part time jobs

Environmental damage is running rampant

They are considered lower middle income when it comes to income per capita

And perhaps their largest problem going massively under-reported is due to their one child policy.

In the years to come, with their rapidly aging population and a one child policy in place, their social infrastructure will be stressed tremendously with not enough young workers to support the aged population.

This factor is multiple fold worse than in other even western countries like the US and Europe.

by nighthawk808

You can use it when you want, where you want, how you want, whenever you want, and you can change it however you want. Congratulations on managing to make my point for me, even though you seem to have missed it completely.

Here are the first twelve lines of the Linux kernel's (now there's a redundancy) source code for handling big boo-boos:
/*
* linux/kernel/panic.c
*
* Copyright (C) 1991, 1992 Linus Torvalds
*/

/*
* This function is used through-out the kernel (including mm and fs)
* to indicate a major problem.
*/
#include
#include

Now, go and show me the first few lines of code that control Windows's BSOD. Go ahead; I'll be waiting right here.

What's that, you say? You can't? Why not? Are there things you can't modify in Windows that you can in Linux? Could that perhaps be because Windows isn't OSS? And obtaining the source code for Windows is--I'm not kidding--a felony unless you happen to be one of their "Valued Partners".

Would you like to add a fixed FIFO scheduling class to Windows? Sorry. You can't. It's not OSS.

I can do a better job managing IRQ's than Linus Torvalds.* So, let's see:
Opening up /usr/src/linux-2.6.16.13-4/kernel/irq/manage.c ...
Fiddling around a bit with the code...
Compiling...
Oh, look at that: a spiffy new IRQ handler.

Now that I've done that once, I'm feeling ambitious and I think I'll do the same thing in Windows. Oops, almost forgot--Windows isn't OSS, so I'm stuck with what they gave me.

OSS isn't just free as in beer, it's just as importantly free as in speech.

*I can't. This is just a hypothetical situation.

Post edited to correct glaring typo.

by rkuhn040172

Up to and including:

"*I can't. This is just a hypothetical situation."

Give a real world one...preferably one that the average user cares about.

You are still missing the point. I appreciate that you like to look at source code. Most users don't.

For those that don't, Windows is a viable choice. For those that do, Linux is the viable choice. It's that simple.

I don't spend time looking at OS code, therefore, from that one point of view, that one Linux strength means nothing to me.

by apotheon

The average user doesn't have to be aware of the direct benefits of using open source software to benefit from the indirect effects.

by x-marcap

When you changed the IRQs you had to reboot. If five cards wanted IRQ 3,5,7,and 11, you were SOL.

Plug and Play for Linux seems to handle better than MS from my experience. I usually make big systems, with multiple FC cards 2 Gig-E cards, and usually a kvm switch connection. RHEL Linux is far easier than 2k3 Enterprise Server...

by rkuhn040172

But I'm not in high school.

I'm 34 years old, been in IT for 7 years, business for 2-3, have multiple certs, bilingual and a degree. And that wasn't a parents "vacation".

They were there visiting my sister who has lived in China before, Vietnam for the last 6 months and before that France for 6 years.

I have travelled myself quite a bit so before you start calling Hal a businessman just because he buys stuff from somewhere, check your facts first. Do your homework.

Hard to swallow your own advice, huh?

by daveo2000

Personally, I find the first reading of HAL's posts a bit difficult too. I can't help it but I get distracted by misspelt words and run-on sentences no matter who writes them. (And HAL is by no means amongst the worst.)

However, there always seems to be more meat or good will in one of his paragraphs than in your collective rants in a given thread.

Why is that?

by daveo2000

By having access to the source you have access to compile time options so you can create a leaner binary with only the options that are important to execution on your platform.

MS has taken the one-size-fits-most path where everything gets compiled in and enabled or disabled by run-time configuration. Sure, you can do this with Linux as well but you can't recompile Windows leaving out certain features that you don't want... like the GUI.

It is very important when you need it but probably not of any importance at all to casual and cookie-cutter users.

There are other "non-code inspection" reasons as well but many are rather esoteric.

by charliespencer

Remember, I'm not opposed to Linux. At this point in time, the benefits of installing it don't outweigh the disadvantages for me personally and professionally. I'm about due to try it again, maybe in the fall, but for me it's strictly an academic exercise without application.

Edited for clarity.

by daveo2000

That seemed a good, well thought out post this time. Wonderful improvement. Too bad you didn't post like that at the start. Maybe next time?

I am curious though. Why would I have to swallow my own advice? I said that his presentation shows him as a businessman and you come off like a high-school kid. I neither said he [b]is[/b] a businessman nor that you [b]are[/b] a high-schooler. I don't know either of you and don't expect to, but the way he presents himself is far more professionally done than what you have done up to this last (meaningful) post.

by rkuhn040172

If such a small percentage of users actually take advantage of a "feature", is it really a "feature"?

To some, absolutely yes. To most, absolutely no.

Linux has a lot of better selling points to talk about than open source code. However, that one seems to get mentioned the most.

And the same could be said of most other software too. To pick on MS Office, do we really need a $300 office suite with features that 99% of the population doesn't even know exists?

Where I work, we are thinking about getting rid of MS Office for our remote construction sites and just giving them the Office readers.

Any data entry they do is in the form of a fax or a Palm handheld anyways.

But it's not just MS Office. Most all software is bloated beyond belief...closed source and open source...Microsoft or Linux.

by x-marcap

I bought SCO Xenix which cost about $4500.00 for a five user license. This is before windows 3.1. I had a gui based X on openserver 5 at the time of Windows 95. It was more stable, but it cost about 2500.00.

I now use 'iX based servers at home and work. I live in Xwindows not because I hate windows... Now wait, I hate windows. It is because I may have to reboot a server once every 6 months, wait I have one going on 3 years... It is because it only costs me $397.00 a seat license for XP. and I just love giving money to Gates...

The reason I don't use Linux is I have Solaris and HPUX instead at my house...

by ddavis2

I know that Linux can be frustrating. I have experienced it myself.

Sometimes, training and practice can make Linux a lot easier. As they say, "a little bit of training goes a long way".

I just authored a 16+ hour video series on Linux. It has a 200 page lab book to study on your own. It isn't theoretical but, instead, it is a video series where you are looking at the Linux server and watching me, the author, demonstrate how to perform different Linux tasks.

Take a look and see what you think. Here is the URL-

http://www.trainsignal.com/index.asp?b=1&a=11&PageAction=VIEWPROD&ProdID=46

by apotheon

Average end users reap the benefits of highly technical users having unfettered access to the source code.

by rkuhn040172

15 miles?...hmmm...and what exactly is the source of your information?

And what size qualifies as a "major" city?

I find your information very suspect. Prove me wrong.

by apotheon

The reason that importance seems overblown is that most of the time people don't bother to notice how things are interconnected and interdependent. The continued low (free) cost of open source software is dependent on its source code being free. The continued increased security of open source software is dependent on its source code being free. The relative immortality of open source software (which never vanishes just because some executive decides it's a good business strategy to make that happen) is dependent on its source code being free.

Pretty much every benefit of open source software is a direct result of the source code being free. That's why it keeps being brought up. Example:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5100-10877_11-6064734.html

by apotheon

Are you aware that 100 million is more than a third the total population of the United States, rickk?

Has it occurred to you that the 111 million Internet users in China are part of a growing trend that can very quickly overtake not only the number of Internet users in the US, but its total population?

If majority OS uptake in China is Linux, Microsoft is rapidly going to be sidelined as a bit-player in comparison. Denial is not a river in Egypt.

by rkuhn040172

I will grant you that the demographics are changing and changing rapidly.

However, here are some facts from InformationWeek and The Datbase that help explain why Microsoft (and many, many other companies both tech and non-tech) don't champion your cause...just yet.

1) Only about 15% of the world's population has access to the Internet
2) The US share of the world's Internet users, over 15 years old, is 22%.

Now, I'm focusing on the Internet for obvious reasons. A PC without a connection to the outside world is less attractive to a software company and other supporting roles as a PC that is.

Pretty compelling!

The US influence on marketing cannot be denied.

The US represents, what, maybe 5% of the world's population but we continue to consume the most resources, energy, products, services, etc than anyone else.

We are a goldmine to businesses.

Now, if Microsoft has a 90%-95% market share on the desktop (even if that is only in the US), where would you open shop? What skills would you obtain?

You are hanging onto the what if's, what might be's, the what could be's.

Companies do have to plan for that as well. But in the business world, China would be called a rising star. But the US is the cash cow.

China might have a growing influence in the future. But to pretend that they have as big an influence as some say now, is denying the facts.

I can continue to give you more facts but I don't think that is necessary at this point. The US is the world's cash cow as far as income per capita, discrentary spending, etc.

We have a nice mix of population, wealth, knowledge, culture, lifestyle, etc.

Now, where would you rather be selling PC's? In the US where the average PC cost maybe $800 and people don't bat an eye or in China where in the east people buy the $800 PC but in the west they're taking for free the hand cranking MIT piece of crap (joking)?

I will grant you that China will be a force to reckon with in the future. But to pretend that they are more than they are currently is simply denying the facts.

Now, I've mentioned selling PC's and Internet usage. Neither a core function of Microsoft as opposed to Dell, HP, Google, etc.

But the success of those markets is what drives Microsoft's success. They make the OS, the office suite, the browser, get advertising dollars, etc.

Companies invest the most time and energy in the cash cows (US, Canada, Europe, Asia...Japan, South Korea, etc), Australia...

Sure, they won't overlook the rising star but the emphasis is on the cash cow right now.

by charliespencer

I agree with everything you say, but that's a "big picture" view. I raise the question strictly as a response to nighthawk808's comment.

"And if a certain app only does 99% of what you want, chances you can add it yourself since you have or can get the source code to give you that power."

I wonder what percentage of OSS users lack the skills to change the code and therefore don't see having it as an advantage to them personally. Assuming OSS is adopted at an increasing rate outside the tech community, the number of users without programming skills will increase as a percentage of total users. These users will hopefully appreciate the open source model that makes their apps possible, but they may regard having the raw code on their individual machines as a waste of drive space. I would.

by rkuhn040172

I actually sort of agree with you for once.

But it applies not just to open source.

You could broaden that statement and it would still be true.

I hate it when I actually agree with you :)

by rkuhn040172

Once again, attacking me personally.

You don't even know me, yet you question my honesty? In other areas of my life?

Boy, you're slipping to new lows.

by nighthawk808

Linux will be bundling in their own browser (whose default start page is Linus Torvalds's personal website) and intertwine it so thoroughly with the rest of the system that it's impossible to uninstall. They'll also bundle in a media player, messaging client, and a gazillion other Linux-branded applications that are cheap knock-offs of whatever app is dominating that particular niche at that particular time. And, if you want to sell a computer without Linux preinstalled, Linus Torvalds will personally double the price (fortunately $0 x 2 = $0) or forbid you from installing it on any of the machines you sell. This is, of course, AFTER he has thrown a chair at you.

Clues here! Get your fresh hot clues here! Can I offer you one, sir?

by nighthawk808

And we may also have people out there who don't realize that I didn't make any of that up, I just changed the names to protect the guilty (and for comedic effect).

Maybe I should start putting disclaimers on posts like that one. Here's a first draft:

WARNING: The Surgeon General has declared this post unsafe for the humor-deficient and/or extremely gullible. Read at your own risk. The author disclaims all liability for aneurism, apoplexy, extreme bewilderment, or you looking like a fool after you took it seriously and responded with a semi-illiterate flame to said author. By reading the above post you have agreed to these terms. Have a good day.

by nighthawk808

Who is this Chad Perrin guy? Never heard of him. How do I know that he has clue one? Is he smarter than you? He writes a lot like you; maybe you guys should get together and have a beer sometime. You might have a few things in common. ;)

by apotheon

Very funny, nighthawk808. I suppose you've looked at my profile recently (and seen the name listed there).

by apotheon

I don't know you outside these little tea parties of ours, so if I'm curious about you outside them, I must question. On the other hand, it's pretty obvious that you're at least being dishonest with yourself, if not intentionally with the rest of us, within these debates -- so I don't have to question your honesty within the debates.

Was that bait-and-switch maneuver of yours intentionally deceitful, or are you just fooling yourself?

edit: . . . and if I've sunk to a new low, I'll take that as a compliment from someone who has been engaging in personal-life ad hominem fallacies against me for months.

by apotheon

I thought we were talking about desktop OS market share, not the best place to open a new drive-through Microsoft-mart.

by nighthawk808

I've known that for quite a while now. I discovered it by downloading some guide (I really can't remember which one). The name of it was something like "apotheon-linux.pdf", yet its author was Chad Perrin. I put 2 and 2 together and ended up with 4.00000001, which is close enough by IEEE 754's standards.

Every once in a while I think it's a good idea to make the connection between the two, so our new friends (hi guys!) or those who didn't know for some other reason can realize that you're not just someone who hangs around the discussions all day and has never done anything else with his life.

by nighthawk808

Didn't you bring up _Of Mice and Men_ earlier? Hal's posts are no more difficult to read than Faulkner, and a whole lot more coherent. He has his style, you have your style, I have my style, ad infinitum, and it's good that way.

by daveo2000

There are many users (don't know stats on that) that don't read source code but do interact in user groups. They make suggestions that somebody that does read source code likes.

The point you make is very worthy of note in the sense that the marketing is missing the point that it should deliver. Most users really won't want to "look" at the source and, in fact, won't have the source on their machines at all.

You don't actually need the full source on your disk. If you aren't making changes you will only need header files (.h). These allow other programs to see the functions that are in a compiled library (which other apps need) without needing access to the source of the actual functions. Windows liked this feature to so they came up with DLLs (dynamic link library) to mimick Unix .so files (shared object). I don't know if Win also mimicked .a files (archive) which are static link libraries.

How should the marketing be changed? Apotheon makes the points over and over but, in most cases, with too many words to catch the attention of the public you speak of. We could use a better catch phrase that speaks to the underlying benefits but geared more to sound bytes :) .

by daveo2000

Rickk,

If Apotheon was to ask if you were an alcoholic or afflicted by mental disease that required medication, would you take that as a personal attack against you?

That is the type of flippant, off-hand remark you regularly slip into your posts. Maybe you think they are funny but not everybody has your sense of humor.

Please lighten up. You do have things to add to the discussion but you seem to sour them with the attempted zingers.

by nighthawk808

The time is now 04:58:08. The OS is openSuSE 10.1. Package selection at install was custom, which means no server packages were installed. I'll have to install them, which is a one-time thing.

Start.
04:59:11 - Installing package dhcp-server. This consists of inserting CD 4 and clicking OK. YaST can do the rest on its own.
05:00:32 - Going for coffee. BRB.
05:07:13 - Back with coffee. Package installed. Starting configuration.
05:11:56 - Finished configuration. Starting testing.
05:15:52 - Finished testing. Works fine.
Stop.

And this is the first time I've ever configured a DHCP server from scratch.

Now, DNS server:
The time is 05:18:38.
Start.
05:19:19 - Installing bind package. Same as the other install: insert CD, click OK, receive banana.
05:21:14 - Package installed. Starting configuration.
05:23:52 - Finished configuration. Starting testing.
05:30:46 - Finished testing. Works fine.
Stop.

And, as above, this is the first time I've ever set up a DNS server from scratch.

"...none of consequence use [Linux]." Besides Google, many major (i.e., multi-national) banks, and a large percentage of investment firms. But what's a few hundred billion dollars of stock value among friends?

Have a good day, troll.

by nighthawk808

Just curious, because I've always heard people saying, "Assumption is the mother of all f***ups".

That should set you straight on what is and isn't a personal attack. That was a personal attack. And probably one of my funnier ones, too.

The patience Apotheon and the others have shown in restraining themselves from actual personal attacks on you is, to me, absolutely amazing. I almost envy them for their self-control. These guys make Job look like a two-year old on crack. I'm not sure you realize just how fortunate you've been.

by nighthawk808

Do you edit your pr0n or something? Do you make your own? Why would you even need to write to it in the first place if it's already there? I don't know about you, but I can't remember the last time I needed to write to my pr0n directory. That's why I gave it (and the rest of my files that I almost never access but don't want to delete) its own partition and called it /static .